DH-SYSC-II(2019)OJ1

15/01/2019

STEERING COMMITTEE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
(CDDH)

________

COMMITTEE OF EXPERTS ON THE SYSTEM OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
(DH-SYSC)

_________

DRAFTING GROUP ON THE PLACE OF THE
EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE
EUROPEAN AND INTERNATIONAL LEGAL ORDER

(DH-SYSC-II)

_________

5th meeting

DRAFT AGENDA

Tuesday 5 (9:30) – Friday 8 February 2019 (End of the meeting: 13:00)

Strasbourg, Agora building, room G02

The agenda and the documents of the meeting are available on the website

www.coe.int/cddh

E-mail: [email protected]


Reference documents concerning all items on the agenda

DH-SYSC(2018)01

Extract of the terms of reference given by the Committee of Ministers to the CDDH regarding the work of the DH-SYSC during the 2018–2019 biennium and relevant extracts of the CDDH meeting reports

DH-SYSC-II(2017)002

Context of the work of the DH-SYSC-II on the future Report of the CDDH

CDDH(2018)R90

Report of the 90th CDDH meeting (27–30 November 2018)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)R4

Report of the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting (25–28 September 2018)

CDDH(2018)R89

Report of the 89th CDDH meeting (19–22 June 2018)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)R3

Report of the 3rd DH-SYSC-II meeting (3–5 April 2018)

CDDH(2017)R88

Report of the 88th CDDH meeting (5–7 December 2017)

DH-SYSC(2017)R4

Report of the 4th DH-SYSC meeting (9–10 November 2017)

DH-SYSC-II(2017)R2

Report of the 2nd DH-SYSC-II meeting (20–22 September 2017)

CDDH(2017)R87

Report of the 87th CDDH meeting (6–9 June 2017)

DH-SYSC(2017)R3

Report of the 3rd DH-SYSC meeting (10–12 May 2017)

DH-SYSC-II(2017)R1

Report of the 1st DH-SYSC-II meeting (30–31 March 2017)

CDDH(2015)R84 Addendum I

CDDH report on the longer-term future of the system of the European Convention on Human Rights

Copenhagen Declaration

CDDH(2015)004

Brussels Declaration

CDDH(2012)007

Brighton Declaration

CDDH(2011)010

Izmir Declaration

CDDH(2010)001

Interlaken Declaration

DH-SYSC(2016)009

Decisions adopted at the 1252nd meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies on the CDDH Report on the longer-term future of the system of the European Convention on Human Rights
(30 March 2016)

CM/Res(2011)24

Committee of Ministers’ Resolution CM/Res(2011)24 on intergovernmental committees and subordinate bodies, their terms of reference and working methods

DH-SYSC-II(2018)23

Chapter of Theme 1, subtheme i) (Methodology of interpretation by the European Court of Human Rights and its approach to international law), as provisionally adopted at the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting in September 2018

DH-SYSC-II(2018)25

Chapter of Theme 1, subtheme iii) (Interaction between the resolutions of the Security Council and the European Convention on Human Rights), as provisionally adopted at the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting in September 2018

ITEM 1: OPENING OF THE MEETING, ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA AND OF THE ORDER OF BUSINESS

DH-SYSC-II(2019)OJ1

Draft agenda

DH-SYSC-II(2019)OT1

Draft order of business

ITEM 2: DISCUSSION ON, AND ADOPTION OF THE DRAFT CHAPTERS OF THEME 1 –

CHALLENGE OF THE INTERACTION BETWEEN THE CONVENTION AND OTHER BRANCHES OF INTERNATIONAL LAW, INCLUDING INTERNATIONAL CUSTOMARY LAW

Item 2.1: Subtheme ii) – State responsibility and extraterritorial application of the ECHR

DH-SYSC-II(2018)24

Revised draft chapter of Theme 1, subtheme ii) (State responsibility and extraterritorial application of the European Convention on Human Rights), as amended following the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2019)28

Comments on the revised draft chapter of Theme 1, subtheme ii) (State responsibility and extraterritorial application of the European Convention on Human Rights), in view of the 5th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2018)16

Draft chapter of Theme 1, subtheme ii) (State responsibility and extraterritorial application of the European Convention on Human Rights), as submitted by co-Rapporteurs Prof. Alexei Ispolinov and Mr Chanaka Wickremasinghe in view of the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2018)18rev

Comments on the draft chapters of Theme 1, in view of the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2018)08rev

Comments on the draft chapter of Theme 1, subthemes ii) and iii), in view of the 3rd DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2018)21

Contribution of the Registry of the European Court of Human Rights

DH-SYSC-II(2018)12

Notes of the presentation on Theme 1, sub-theme ii) (State responsibility and extraterritorial application of the European Convention on Human Rights) submitted by Professor R. Lawson, University of Leiden (Netherlands)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)04

Contribution for the preparation of the draft chapter of Theme 1, subtheme ii) (State responsibility and extraterritorial application of the European Convention on Human Rights) by the Contributor, Mr M. Zwanenburg

DH-SYSC-II(2018)06

External voluntary contributions on Theme 1, subthemes ii) and iii) from two Italian universities

Item 2.2: Subtheme iv) – Interaction between international humanitarian law and the ECHR

DH-SYSC-II(2018)15

Draft chapter of Theme 1, subtheme iv) (Interaction between international humanitarian law and the European Convention on Human Rights)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)18rev (see above)

Comments on the draft chapters of Theme 1, in view of the 4th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2018)13

(available in French only)

Notes of the presentation on Theme 1, sub-theme iv) (Interaction between international humanitarian law and the European Convention on Human Rights) made by Professor S. Touzé, Paris II Panthéon-Assas University (France)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)10

(available in French only)

Contribution for the preparation of the draft chapter of Theme 1, subtheme iv) (Interaction between international humanitarian law and the European Convention on Human Rights) by the Contributor, Professor A. Kovler

DH-SYSC-II(2018)11

External voluntary contribution on Theme 1, subtheme iv) (Interaction between international humanitarian law and the European Convention on Human Rights) by Professor Dr. I. Viarengo, and Dr. F. Favuzza, University of Milan (Italy)

ITEM 3: DISCUSSION ON, AND ADOPTION OF THE DRAFT CHAPTER OF THEME 2 –

CHALLENGE OF THE INTERACTION BETWEEN THE CONVENTION AND OTHER INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS INSTRUMENTS TO WHICH THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE MEMBER STATES ARE PARTIES

DH-SYSC-II(2019)29

Revised draft chapter of Theme 2 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and other international human rights instruments to which the Council of Europe Member States are parties), in the light of the experts’ written comments, in view of the 5th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2018)26

Draft chapter of Theme 2 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and other international human rights instruments to which the Council of Europe Member States are parties)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)27

Comments on the draft chapter of Theme 2 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and other international human rights instruments to which the Council of Europe Member States are parties), in view of the 5th DH-SYSC-II meeting

DH-SYSC-II(2019)30

External voluntary contribution for the preparation of the draft chapter of Theme 2 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and other international human rights instruments to which the Council of Europe Member States are parties), submitted by Prof. M. Pedrazzi and Dr. F. Favuzza,

University of Milan (Italy)

DH-SYSC-II(2018)22

Notes on the draft chapter of Theme 2 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and other international human rights instruments to which the Council of Europe member States are parties) submitted by the Rapporteur, Ms Sofia Kastranta, in view of the 4th meeting of the DH-SYSC-II

DH-SYSC-II(2018)20

Notes of the presentation on Theme 2 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and other international human rights instruments to which the Council of Europe member States are parties) submitted by Professor P. Pazartzis, University of Athens (Greece)

ITEM 4: DISCUSSION ON THEME 3 –

CHALLENGE OF THE INTERACTION BETWEEN THE CONVENTION AND THE LEGAL ORDER OF THE EU AND OTHER REGIONAL ORGANISATIONS

DH-SYSC-II(2019)32

Outline of the draft chapter of Theme 3 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and the legal order of the EU and other regional organisations) submitted by the Rapporteur, Ms Kristīne Līcis, in view of the 5th meeting of the DH-SYSC-II

DH-SYSC-II(2019)33

Notes of the presentation on Theme 3 (Challenge of the interaction between the Convention and the legal order of the EU and other regional organisations) submitted by the ad hoc expert

ITEM 5: ORGANISATION OF FUTURE WORK

DH-SYSC-II(2019)31

Revised Planning of the work of the DH-SYSC-II,
in view of the 5th DH-SYSC-II meeting

ITEM 6: ADOPTION OF THE MEETING REPORT

*           *           *