Decisions adopted by the Committee of Ministers

Compilation 2014 – 2018

ÊLink to the compilation 2010-2014

Select a State

u Albania

Flag of Albania.svg

u Germany

Flag of Germany.svg

u Poland

Flag of Poland.svg

u Andorra

Drapeau d'Andorre

u Greece

Flag of Greece.svg

u Portugal

Portugal

u Armenia

Flag of Armenia.svg

u Hungary

Flag of Hungary.svg

u Republic of Moldova

Flag of Moldova.svg

u Austria

Drapeau de l'Autriche

u Iceland

Drapeau de l'Islande

u Romania

Flag of Romania.svg

u Azerbaijan

Flag of Azerbaijan.svg

u Ireland

Flag of Ireland.svg

u Russian Federation

u Belgium

Flag of Belgium.svg

u Italy

Flag of Italy.svg

u San Marino

Drapeau de Saint-Marin

u Bosnia and Herzegovina

Flag of Bosnia and Herzegovina.svg

u Latvia

Drapeau de la Lettonie

u Serbia

Flag of Serbia.svg

u Bulgaria

Bulgarie

u Liechtenstein

Drapeau du Liechtenstein

u Slovak Republic

Flag of Slovakia.svg

u Croatia

Flag of Croatia.svg

u Lithuania

Flag of Lithuania.svg

u Slovenia

Flag of Slovenia.svg

u Cyprus

Flag of Cyprus.svg

u Luxembourg

Drapeau du Luxembourg

u Spain

Drapeau de l'Espagne

u Czech Republic

Flag of the Czech Republic.svg

u Malta

Flag of Malta.svg

u Sweden

Drapeau de la Suède

u Denmark

Drapeau du Danemark

u Monaco

Drapeau de Monaco

u Switzerland

Flag of Switzerland.svg

u Estonia

Drapeau de l'Estonie

u Montenegro

Drapeau du Monténégro

u Turkey

Flag of Turkey.svg

u Finland

Drapeau de la Finlande

u Netherlands

Flag of the Netherlands.svg

u Ukraine

Flag of Ukraine.svg

u France

France

u North Macedonia

Flag of Macedonia.svg

u United Kingdom

Flag of the United Kingdom.svg

u Georgia

Flag of Georgia.svg

u Norway

Flag of Norway.svg

u


Notice

This document is produced under the sole responsibility of the Department for the Execution of Judgments of the European Court of Human Rights. It is not binding for the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe and is provided for information purposes only.

The term “Roma and Travellers” is used at the Council of Europe to encompass the wide diversity of the groups covered by the work of the Council of Europe in this field: on the one hand a) Roma, Sinti/Manush, Calé, Kaale, Romanichals, Boyash/Rudari; b) Balkan Egyptians (Egyptians and Ashkali); c) Eastern groups (Dom, Lom and Abdal); and, on the other hand, groups such as Travellers, Yenish, and the populations designated under the administrative term “Gens du voyage”, as well as persons who identify themselves as Gypsies.

All reference to Kosovo, whether to the territory, institutions or population, in this text shall be understood in full compliance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 and without prejudice to the status of Kosovo.


LIST OF HUMAN RIGHTS MEETINGS

2014 

1193rd meeting (HR), 4-6 March 2014

1201st meeting (HR), 3-5 June 2014

1208th meeting (HR), 23-25 September 2014

1214th meeting (HR), 2-4 December 2014

2015 

1222nd meeting (HR), 10-12 March 2015

1230th meeting (HR), 9-11 June 2015

1236th meeting (HR), 22-24 September 2015

1243rd meeting (HR), 8-10 December 2015

2016 

1250th meeting (HR), 8-10 March 2016

1259th meeting (HR), 7-8 June 2016

1265th meeting (HR), 20-21 September 2016

1273rd meeting (HR), 6-8 December 2016

2017 

1280th meeting (HR), 7-9 March 2017

1288th meeting (HR), 6-7 June 2017

1294th meeting (HR), 19-21 September 2017

1302nd meeting (HR), 5-7 December 2017

2018

1310th meeting (HR), 13-15 March 2018

1318th meeting (HR), 5-7 June 2018

1324th meeting (HR), 18-20 September 2018

1331st meeting (HR), 4-6 December 2018

2019

1340th meeting (HR), 12-14 March 2019

1348th meeting (HR), 4-6 June 2019

1355th meeting (HR), 23-25 September 2019

1362nd meeting (HR), 3-5 December 2019


List of cases classified by State


Flag of Albania.svg

Albania

Caka Berhani (Group)

Driza (Group)

Dybeku (Group)

Grori

Luli and Others

Manushaqe Puto and Others

Flag of Armenia.svg

Armenia

Ashot Harutyunyan

Chiragov and Others

Virabyan (Group)

Flag of Azerbaijan.svg

Azerbaijan

Fatullayev

Gafgaz Mammadov (Group)

Humbatov (Group)

Ilgar Mammadov

Insanov (Group)

Mahmudov and Agazade (Group)

Mammadov (Jalaloglu) (Group)

Mikayil Mammadov (Group)

Mirzayev (Group)

Muradova (Group)

Namat Aliyev (Group)

Sargsyan

Tarverdiyev (Group)

Flag of Belgium.svg

Belgium

Dumont (Group)

L.B. (Group)

M.S.

Trabelsi

Vasilescu

Flag of Belgium.svg Flag of Greece.svg

Belgium

and

Greece

M.S.S.

Flag of Bosnia and Herzegovina.svg

Bosnia and Herzegovina

Al Husin

Colić and Others

Ðokić

Kunić and Others (Group)

Mago and Others

Maktouf and Damjanović

Sejdic and Finci (Group)

Bulgarie

Bulgaria

Al-Nashif and Others (Group)

Association for European integration and Human Rights and Ekimdzhiev (Group)

C.G. and Others (Group)

Dimitrov and Hamanov

Djangozov (Group)

Finger

International Bank of Commerce
and Development AD and Others

Kehayov (Group)

Kitov (Group)

Kolevi (Group)

Nachova and Others (Group)

Neshkov and Others

Nencheva and Others

United Macedonian Organisation Illinden and Others (Group)

Stanev (Group)

S.Z. (Group)

Velikova (Group)

Yordanova and Others

Flag of Croatia.svg

Croatia

Ajdarić

Šečić

Skendzic and Krznaric (Group)

Statileo

Flag of Cyprus.svg

Cyprus

M.A. (Group)

Onoufriou

Flag of Cyprus.svg 

Cyprus

&

Russian Federation

Rantsev

Flag of the Czech Republic.svg

Czech Republic

D.H. and Others

France

France

I.M.

M.A. (Group)

Mennesson (Group)

M.K.

Flag of Georgia.svg

Georgia

Aliev

Identoba and Others (Group)

Merabishvili

Gharibashvili (Group)

Flag of Germany.svg

Germany

M. (Group)

Flag of Greece.svg

Greece

Beka Koulocheri (Group)

Bekir-Ousta and Others (Group)

Chowdury and Others

Diamontides No.2 (Group)

Glykantzi

Konti-Arvaniti (Group)

Manios (Group)

Makaratzis (Group)

Martzaklis and Others (Group)

Michelioudakis

M.S.S. (Group)

Nisiotis (Group)

Rahimi (Group)

Sakir

Sampani and Others (Group)

S.D. (Group)

Siasios and Others (Group)

Vallianatos and Others

Vassilios Athanasiou and Others

Flag of Hungary.svg

Hungary

Baka

Gazsó (Group)

Gubacsi (Group)

Horváth and Kiss

István Gábor Kovács (Group)

Kalucza

László Magyar (Group)

R.R.

Szabó and Vissy

Tímár (Group)

Tonello

Varga and Others

Flag of Ireland.svg

Ireland

A., B. and C.

McFarlane (Group)

O’Keeffe

Flag of Italy.svg

Italy

Abenavoli (Group)

Agrati and Others (Group)

Centro Europa 7 S.R.L. and Di Stefano

Ceteroni (Group)

Costa and Pavan

Di Sarno and Others

Hirsi Jamaa and Others

Gaglione and Others

Khlaifia and Others

Ledonne No. 1 (Group)

Luordo (Group)

M.C. and Others

Mostacciuolo Giuseppe No.1 (Group)

Olivieri and Others

Oliari and Others

Sharifi and Others

Sneersome and Kampanella

Sulejmanovic

Talpis

Torreggiani and Others

Flag of Lithuania.svg

Lithuania

Abu Zubaydah

L.

Matiošaitis and Others

Paksas

Vasiliauskas

Flag of Malta.svg

Malta

Apap Bologna (Group)

Suso Musa (Group)

Flag of Macedonia.svg

North Macedonia

Association of Citizens “Radko” and Paunkovski

El-Masri

Hajrulahu

Ivanovski

Orthodox Ohrid Archdiocese (Group)

Flag of Norway.svg

Norway

Lindheim and Others

Flag of the Netherlands.svg

The Netherlands

Jaloud

Flag of Poland.svg

Poland

Al-Nashiri (Group)

Bąk (Group)

Dzwonkowski (Group)

Fuchs (Group)

Grabowski

Grzelak

Horych (Group)

Kaprykowski (Group)

Kędzior

Kudla (Group)

Majewski (Group)

P. and S.

Podbielski (Group)

R.R.

Rutkowski and Others

Tysiac

Portugal

Portugal

Oliveira Modesto and Others (Group)

Vicente Cardoso (Group)

Flag of Moldova.svg

Republic of Moldova

Becciev (Group)

Boicenco (Group)

Brega (Group)

Ciorap (Group)

Corsacov (Group)

Eremia (Group)

Genderdoc-M

Guţu

I.D. (Group)

Levinta

Luntre and Others (Group)

Muşuc (Group)

Paladi (Group)

Sarban (Group)

Taraburca (Group)

Timus and Taurus

Flag of Moldova.svg 

Republic of Moldova

&

Russian Federation

Ilaşcu and Others

Ivantoc and Others

Flag of Romania.svg

Romania

Al Nashiri

Anghelescu Barbu No.1 (Group)

Association « 21 December 1989 » (Group)

Bălsan

Bragadireanu (Group)

Bucur and Toma

Centre for legal resources on behalf of Valentin Câmpeanu

Cristian Teodorescu

Gheorghe Predescu

Maria Atanasiu

Moldovanand Others (Group)

N.

Nicolau (Group)

Parascineti

Predică (Group)

Rezmiveş and Others

Sacaleanu (Group)

S.C. Polyinvest S.R.L. and Others

Soare and Others (Group)

Strain and Others (Group)

Stoianova and Nedelcu (Group)

Țicu (Group)

Zlatin and Others

Russian Federation

Alekseyev

Alim

Bayev and Others

Buntov

Catan and Others

Finogenov and Others

Garabayev (Group)

Georgia

Gerasimov and Others

Jehovah’s Witnesses of Moscow and Others

Khashiyev and Akayeva (Group)

Kim (Group)

Klyakhin (Group)

Krupko and Others

Kudeshkina

Lashmankin and Others

Liu No. 2 (Group)

Mikheyev (Group)

Navalnyy and Ofitserov

Oao Neftyanaya Kompaniya Yukos

Roman Zakharov

Svinarenko and Slyadnev (Group)

Y.U.

Flag of Serbia.svg

Serbia

EVT Company (Group)

Grudić

Milanović

Zorica Jovanović

Flag of Serbia.svg  Flag of Slovenia.svg

Serbia

and

Slovenia

Alisić and Others

Flag of Slovakia.svg

Slovak Republic

Labsi

Flag of Slovenia.svg

Slovenia

Mandić and Jović (Group)

Flag of Switzerland.svg

Switzerland

Al-Dulimi and Montana Management Inc.

Tarakhel

Flag of Turkey.svg

Turkey

Ahmet Yildirim

Altuğ Taner Akçam (Group)

Ataykaya

Batı and Others (Group)

Cyprus

Dink

Erdoğan and Others (Group)

Ergin (No. 6)

Incal (Group)

Gözel and Özer (Group)

Gülay Çetin

Kasa (Group)

Nedim Şener (Group)

Opuz

Oya Ataman (Group)

Oyal (Group)

Özmen (Group)

Sinan Işik

Söyler (Group)

Ürper and Others (Group)

Varnava and Others

Xenides-Arestis (Group)

Flag of Ukraine.svg

Ukraine

Afanasyev (Group)

Agrokompleks

Belousov

Burmych and Others

Chanyev

East/West Alliance Limited

Fedorchenko and Lozenko (Group)

Gongadze

Ignatov (Group)

Isayev (Group)

Karabet and Others (Group)

Kaverzin

Kebe and Others

Kharchenko

Khaylo (Group)

Korneykova

Logvinenko (Group)

Melnik (Group)

Naydyon (Group)

Nevmerzhitsky (Group)

Oleksandr Volkov

Salov (Group)

Tymoshenko

Vasiliy Ivashchenko

Vyerentsov (Group)

Yakovenko (Group)

Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov

Zhovner (Group)

Flag of the United Kingdom.svg

United Kingdom

Al-Skeini and Others

Aswat

McKerr (Group)

Hirst No. 2 (Group)


TABLE-INDEX OF DECISIONS ADOPTED BY THE CM DURING ITS MEETINGS

‡Meetings where this logo is used are meetings where consideration of the concerned case was postponed, or the time-table for its examination adopted/modified.

Year

Meeting

Case

State

Violation

Action requested

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

CAKA

(Group)

ALBANIA

Unfair criminal proceedings

To urge the authorities to submit, without further delay, information on the situation of the detained applicants and on the measures of a general nature.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

CAKA

(Group)

ALBANIA

Unfair criminal proceedings

To assess the information provided by the Albanian authorities and to identify the outstanding questions.

To examine the proposal to adopt a final resolution in two cases.

Final resolution CM/ResDH(2016)272 adopted in four cases.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

CAKA

(Group)

ALBANIA

Unfair criminal proceedings

To examine the final draft resolution with a view to closing the examination of this group.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1186th meeting and assessment of the progress achieved in the implementation of the pilot judgment.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1193rd meeting and assessment of the progress achieved in the implementation of the action plan presented by the authorities at the last examination of the case.

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1201st meeting and assessment of the progress achieved in the implementation of the action plan.

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of Articles 6 § 1, 1, of Protocol No. 1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and Others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1230th meeting and to assess the progress achieved in the implementation of the action plan.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of Articles 6 § 1, 1, of Protocol No. 1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and Others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1243rd meeting and to assess the progress achieved in the implementation of the action plan.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation for property nationalised under the communist regime.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify outstanding questions.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

DRIZA (Group)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation for property nationalised under the communist regime.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1294th meeting.

To consider the proposal to close the cases in which the individual measures have been resolved.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

DYBEKU

GRORI

ALBANIA

Ill-treatment suffered by the applicants as a result of a lack of adequate medical care whilst in detention (violation of Article 3).

The Grori case also concerns the unlawfulness of the applicant’s detention from 15/05/2002 until 29/12/2003 which was founded on international law instruments not yet in force in respect of Albania (violation of Article 5§1) and the unjustified delay in complying with the European Court's interim measure to transfer the applicant to a civilian hospital (violation of Article 34).

Action report submitted on 25/06/2014. Assessment of the information provided.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

DYBEKU

GRORI

ALBANIA

Unlawful detention and poor conditions of detention; failure to comply with interim measures indicated by the Court.

To examine the proposal to adopt a final resolution.

Final resolution CM/ResDH(2016)273 adopted.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

LULI AND OTHERS

(Group)

ALBANIA

Excessive length of civil proceedings and absence of a remedy in that respect.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions.

Closure of Marini case (3738/02).

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

LULI AND OTHERS

(Group)

ALBANIA

Excessive length of civil proceedings and absence of a remedy in that respect.

To assess the action report submitted on 15/10/2018.

2016

‡

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

CHIRAGOV AND OTHERS

ARMENIA

Impossibility for persons displaced during the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to gain access to their homes and properties in the region; lack of effective remedies (continuing violations of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, Articles 8 and 13). Article 41 judgment awaited.

After consultation of the delegation, consideration of this case was postponed.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

CHIRAGOV AND OTHERS

ARMENIA

Impossibility for persons displaced during the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to gain access to their homes and properties in the region; lack of effective remedies.

To examine the follow-up given or envisaged to the judgment.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

HARUTYUNYAN ASHOT

(Group)

ARMENIA

Placing and keeping the applicants in a metal cage during court hearings despite the lack of any real security risk, and denial of adequate medical assistance in a detention facility (Article 3).

To examine the authorities’ action plan as well as the possibility of closing the Committee’s supervision of the violation concerning placing and keeping the applicants in metal cages.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

HARUTYUNYAN ASHOT

(Group)

ARMENIA

Inadequate medical care in detention.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting.

2019

1340

(12-14 March 2019)

HARUTYUNYAN ASHOT

(Group)

ARMENIA

Inadequate medical care in detention.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1302nd meeting. To consider the proposal to close one repetitive case in which the individual measures have been resolved.

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

VIRABYAN

ARMENIA

Ill-treatment of the applicant in police custody and failure to carry out an effective investigation, including into allegations that the ill-treatment was politically motivated (violation of Article 3 alone, and of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 3 procedural limb); violation of the presumption of innocence (Article 6(2)).

To assess the updated action plan and to request for further information, in particular on the re-opened investigations and legislative amendments under consideration.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

VIRABYAN

ARMENIA

Ill-treatment and torture in police custody and ineffective investigations, including into allegations that the ill-treatment was politically motivated. Violation of the presumption of innocence and the rights to effective legal assistance and access to court.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1230th meeting.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

VIRABYAN

ARMENIA

Ill-treatment and torture in police custody and ineffective investigations, including into allegations that the ill-treatment was politically motivated. Violation of the presumption of innocence and the rights to effective legal assistance and access to court.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1273rd meeting.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

GAFGAZ MAMMADOV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Dispersals and arrests of demonstrators.

To examine the individual and general measures required.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

GAFGAZ MAMMADOV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Dispersals and arrests of demonstrators.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1288th meeting.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

GAFGAZ MAMMADOV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Dispersals and arrests of demonstrators.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1302nd meeting.

2014

1214

(2-4 December 2014)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Imprisonment for reasons other than those permitted by Article 5 namely, to punish the applicant for having criticised the government (Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5).

First examination, in particular of the issue of individual measures and general measures concerning Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5 § 1

2015

1222

(11-12 March 2015)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Imprisonment for reasons other than those permitted by Article 5 namely, to punish the applicant for having criticised the government (Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5).

Examination of the urgent individual measures.

Adoption of an interim resolution

CM/ResDH(2015)43

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Imprisonment for reasons other than those permitted by Article 5 namely, to punish the applicant for having criticised the government (Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5).

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1222nd meeting.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Imprisonment for reasons other than those permitted by Article 5 namely, to punish the applicant for having criticised the government (Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1230th meeting.

Adoption of an interim resolution

CM/ResDH(2015)156

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention for reasons other than those permitted by Article 5, namely to punish the applicant for having criticised the government (Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5).

To follow up the interim resolution adopted at the 1236th meeting.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention for reasons other than those permitted by Article 5, namely to punish the applicant for having criticised the government (Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1243rd meeting.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicant for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting.

Adoption of an interim resolution

CM/ResDH(2016)144

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicant for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To assess the current situation.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicant for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To assess the current situation.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To assess the current situation.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1280th meeting.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

(two decisions at this meeting)

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1288th meeting.

2017

1298

(25 October 2017)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To examine, with a view to its adoption, the interim resolution giving formal notice to Azerbaijan of the Committee’s intention to bring before the Court the question whether Azerbaijan has failed to fulfill its obligation under Article 46 § 1 of the Convention.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

Follow up of the Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2017)379.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

The case is on the Order of Business in accordance with Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2016)144.

No decision.

2019

1340

(12-14 March 2019)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

It is not proposed to debate these cases or to adopt a decision unless there is a request to this end or an evolution of the situation.

No decision.

2019

1344

(24

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

Individual situation of the applicant.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

ILGAR MAMMADOV

AZERBAIJAN

Arrest and pre-trial detention to punish the applicants for having criticised the government, in breach of Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5.

To examine the Court’s judgment (Article 46 § 4) if available. To examine the issues raised by the other cases of the group.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

INSANOV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of Article 3 due to inhuman and degrading detention conditions; Violations of Article 6 in criminal and civil proceedings.

To assess the action plan and to request outstanding information, in particular, under the individual measures.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

INSANOV

AZERBAIJAN

Inhuman and degrading detention conditions (Article 3); unfairness of both the criminal proceedings against the applicant and the civil proceedings concerning his conditions of detention (Article 6).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1236th meeting.

2019

1340

(12-14 March 2019)

INSANOV

AZERBAIJAN

Inhuman and degrading detention conditions (Article 3); unfairness of both the criminal proceedings against the applicant and the civil proceedings concerning his conditions of detention (Article 6).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting.

2014

1188

Ordinary Meeting

(15 January 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision taken at the 1186th meeting.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1188th meeting.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1193th meeting.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1201st  meeting.

Adoption of an Interim Resolution

CM/ResDH(2014)183

2014

1214

(2-4 December 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATTULAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the interim resolution adopted at the 1208th meeting.

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATTULAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1214th meeting.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATTULAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1230th meeting.

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATTULAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1236th meeting.

Adoption of an interim resolution CM/ResDH(2015)156.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATTULAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

To follow up the interim resolution adopted at the 1243rd meeting.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

FATTULAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting.

Adoption of an interim resolution

CM/ResDH(2016)145

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of the right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of the law on defamation.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1273rd meeting.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of the right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of the law on defamation.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1280th meeting.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Violation of the right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of the law on defamation.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1294th meeting.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

MIRZAYEV (Group)

HUMBATOV (Group)

TARVERDIYEV (Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Non-enforcement of final domestic judgements.

To assess the developments since the last examination of the groups in 2012 and to identify the remaining outstanding issues. To consider the proposal to close the repetitive cases in which the individual measures have been resolved.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

MURADOVA

(Group)

MAMMADOV (JALALOGLU)

(Group)

MIKAYIL MAMMADOV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Excessive use of force by the security forces and lack of effective investigations.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding issues.

2018

1310

(13-15 March 2018)

MURADOVA

(Group)

MAMMADOV (JALALOGLU)

(Group)

MIKAYIL MAMMADOV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Excessive use of force by the security forces and lack of effective investigations.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1294th meeting.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1186th meeting.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1193rd  meeting.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1201st meeting.

2015

1222

(11-12 March 2015)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1208th meeting.

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1222nd meeting.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1230th meeting.

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1236th meeting.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 and 2010 parliamentary elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

To follow the decision adopted at the 1243rd meeting.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 and 2010 parliamentary elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1265th meeting.

2018

1310

(13-15 March 2018)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 and 2010 parliamentary elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1280th meeting.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(Group)

AZERBAIJAN

Various irregularities in the context of the 2005 and 2010 parliamentary elections and lack of safeguards against arbitrariness.

To assess the developments since the last examination of the group in 2018.

2016

‡

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

SARGSYAN

AZERBAIJAN

Impossibility for persons displaced during the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to gain access to their homes and properties in the region; lack of effective remedies (continuing violations of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, Articles 8 and 13). Article 41 judgment awaited.

After consultation of the delegation, consideration of this case was postponed.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

SARGSYAN

AZERBAIJAN

Impossibility for persons displaced during the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict to gain access to their homes and properties in the region; lack of effective remedies.

To examine the follow-up given or envisaged to the judgment.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

BELL

BELGIUM

Excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings

To assess the action plan submitted on 19/10/2018 and to identify outstanding questions.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

DUMONT

BELGIUM

Excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings (Article 6 § 1) and, in several cases, lack of an effective remedy (Article 13).

To call for an update of the information on individual and general measures, no follow-up having been given to date, to the decision adopted by the Committee in September 2013.

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

DUMONT

BELGIUM

Excessive length of civil and criminal proceedings (Article 6 § 1) and, in several cases, lack of an effective remedy (Article 13).

To assess the progress achieved and the outstanding questions in this group of cases. To examine the proposal to conclude the Committee’s supervision of 17 cases concerned by the positive developments in the area of length of judicial proceedings and domestic remedies.

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

L.B.

(Group)

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning the care of persons with mental health problems like the applicants, who are kept in a prison environment due to, in particular, the lack of capacity to receive them in the external psychiatric system (Articles 3 and 5).

Assessment of the progress achieved and identification of the outstanding questions for the individual and general measures in this group of cases.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

L.B.

(Group)

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning the care of persons with mental health problems like the applicants, who are kept in a prison environment due to, in particular, the lack of capacity to receive them in the external psychiatric system (Articles 3 and 5).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1230th meeting.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

L.B.

(Group)

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning the care of persons with mental health problems detained in prison.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting and the pilot judgment W.D.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

L.B.

(Group)

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning the care of persons with mental health problems detained in prison.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1280th meeting.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

L.B.

(Group)

W.D.

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning the care of persons with mental health problems detained in prison.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1302nd meeting.

To consider the proposal to close nine cases in which the individual measures have been taken.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

M.S.

BELGIUM

Applicant’s forced return to Iraq, following unlawful periods of detention

Assessment of the progress made in respect of the individual and general measures.

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition of the applicant to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence (Article 3). Non-respect of interim measure indicated by the Court (Article 34).

To assess the action plan submitted on 20 October 2015.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition, in 2013, of the applicant from Belgium to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence (Article 3). Failure to respect the Court’s interim measure indicating that Belgium should not extradite the applicant while the case was still pending (Article 34).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1243rd meeting.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition, in 2013, of the applicant from Belgium to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence (Article 3). Failure to respect the Court’s interim measure indicating that Belgium should not extradite the applicant while the case was still pending (Article 34).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition in 2013 of the applicant from Belgium to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence; failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition in 2013 of the applicant from Belgium to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence; failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To assess the revised action plan provided in response to the decision adopted at the 1265th meeting.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition in 2013 of the applicant from Belgium to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence; failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1288th meeting.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

TRABELSI

BELGIUM

Extradition in 2013 of the applicant from Belgium to the United States, where he risks an irreducible life sentence; failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To assess the action report submitted on 30/10/2018 and to consider the proposal to close the case.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

VASILESCU

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning prison overcrowding and conditions of detention.

To assess the action plan submitted by the authorities on 07/07/2016.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

VASILESCU

BELGIUM

Structural problem concerning prison overcrowding and conditions of detention.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1265th meeting.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

M.S.S.

BELGIUM& GREECE

Expulsion of an asylum seeker from Belgium to Greece

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1186th meeting

2014

1214

(2-4 December 2014)

M.S.S.

BELGIUM& GREECE

Expulsion of an asylum seeker from Belgium to Greece

Belgium: assessment of the information provided on the last point under examination (effective remedy);

Adoption of a Final Resolution

Greece: assessment of the general measures regarding living conditions of asylum seekers (including unaccompanied minors) and identification of outstanding issues

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

AL HUSIN

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Potential violation of Article 3 of the Convention in the event of the applicant’s deportation to Syria

Proposal to transfer this case under the standard procedure.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

ČOLIĆ AND OTHERS

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Non-enforcement of final domestic court decisions ordering payment of war damages.

To assess the information provided in the action report of 03/01/2017 and to examine the proposal to transfer the group to the standard procedure.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

ÐOKIĆ

MAGO AND OTHERS

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Inability for members of the former Yugoslav People’s Army (“YPA”) to repossess their pre-war apartments in the aftermath of the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina.

To assess the information provided by the authorities of Bosnia and Herzegovina and to identify the outstanding questions.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

ÐOKIĆ

MAGO AND OTHERS

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Inability for members of the former Yugoslav People's Army (“YPA”) to repossess their pre-war apartments in the aftermath of the war in Bosnia and Herzegovina.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1265th meeting.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

KUNIĆ AND OTHERS

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Non-enforcement of final judgments ordering the payment of work-related benefits.

To assess the action plan submitted on 04/10/2018 and to identify outstanding questions.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

MAKTOUF AND DAMJANOVĆ

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

War crimes cases: retroactive application of new criminal law with more severe sanctions.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1186th meeting.

To consider the proposal to adopt a final resolution.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Violation of right to free elections and discrimination against minorities

Follow-up of the Interim resolution adopted at the 1186th meeting.

2014

1214

(2-4 December 2014)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Violation of right to free elections and discrimination against minorities

To encourage the authorities and political leaders of Bosnia and Herzegovina to intensify their efforts, following the recent elections, with a view to reaching a consensus on the Constitutional amendments.

2015

1230

(3-5 June 2015)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Violation of right to free elections and discrimination against minorities

To assess the state of play of the execution process after the elections held in October 2014.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Ethnic-based discrimination on account of the ineligibility of persons not affiliated with one of the "constituent peoples" (Bosnians, Croats or Serbs) to stand for election to the House of Peoples (the upper chamber of Parliament) and the Presidency.

To assess the updated action plan provided by the authorities on 20/10/2016.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Ethnic-based discrimination on account of the ineligibility of persons not affiliated with one of the "constituent peoples" (Bosnians, Croats or Serbs) to stand for election to the House of Peoples and the Presidency.

To follow up decision adopted at the 1273rd meeting.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Ethnic-based discrimination on account of the ineligibility of persons not affiliated with one of the "constituent peoples" (Bosnians, Croats or Serbs) to stand for election to the House of Peoples and the Presidency.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1288th meeting.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

SEJDIĆ AND FINCI

(Group)

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Ethnic-based discrimination on account of the ineligibility of persons not affiliated with one of the "constituent peoples" (Bosnians, Croats or Serbs) to stand for election to the House of Peoples and the Presidency.

To assess the situation in light of the planned exchange of views with the Minister.

2015

1222

(11-12 March 2015)

AL-NASHIF AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Lack of adequate protection against arbitrariness in proceedings concerning expulsion measures on national security grounds due to the lack of judicial review of these measures.

Adoption of a final resolution in the cases of Al-Nashif and Others, Hasan, Bashirand Others and Musa and Others and assessment of the individual measures in the Baltaji case.

CM/ResDH(2015)44

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

ASSOCIATION FOR EUROPEAN INTEGRATION AND HUMAN RIGHTS AND EKIMDZHIEV

(Group)

BULGARIA

Lack of sufficient guarantees against the risk of abuse in the operation of the secret surveillance system.

To assess the progress achieved since the last examination and to identify the outstanding questions.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

ASSOCIATION FOR EUROPEAN INTEGRATION AND HUMAN RIGHTS AND EKIMDZHIEV

(Group)

BULGARIA

Lack of sufficient guarantees against the risk of abuse in the operation of the secret surveillance system.

To assess the recent developments and to identify possible outstanding questions.

2015

1222

(11-12 March 2015)

C.G. AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Shortcomings found in the judicial review set up in 2003 in the area of expulsion based on national security grounds.

Assessment of the progress achieved and identification of the outstanding questions in this group.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

C.G. AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Shortcomings in the judicial review mechanism set up in 2003 in the field of expulsion based on national security grounds.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify outstanding questions.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

C.G. AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Shortcomings in the judicial review mechanism set up in 2003 in the field of expulsion based on national security grounds.

To assess the progress achieved and the outstanding questions. To examine the draft final resolutions with a view to closing several cases.

2019

1340

(12-14 March 2019)

C.G. AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Shortcomings in the judicial review mechanism set up in 2003 in the field of expulsion based on national security grounds.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions and the measures necessary to avoid delay in the execution process.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

KEHAYOV

(Group)

NESHKOV AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Excessive length of judicial proceedings, pilot judgments, deadline expired in August 2012.

To assess the progress achieved in the outstanding questions.

To examine the proposal of the authorities to conclude the Committee’s supervision of the pilot judgments Finger and Dimitrov and Hamanov and 54 cases of the Kitov and Djangozov groups, as well as of their action plan for the outstanding questions.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

KEHAYOV

(Group)

NESHKOV AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Structural problem highlighted by the European Court in the Neshkov and Others pilot judgment concerning conditions of detention in investigative detention facilities and prisons (overcrowding, poor sanitary and material conditions) and lack of an effective remedy in this respect.

The deadline set by the Court for introducing effective preventive and compensatory remedies expires on 01/12/2016.

To assess the measures taken and/or envisaged, in accordance with the revised action plan submitted on 06/07/2015 and to underline the importance of introducing effective domestic remedies by the deadline set in the Neshkov and Others pilot judgment

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

KEHAYOV

(Group)

NESHKOV AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Conditions of detention in remand facilities and prisons and lack of an effective remedy.

To assess the progress achieved after the legislative reform adopted on 25/01/2017 which introduced the effective domestic remedies required by the Neshkov pilot judgment and to identify outstanding questions.

2018

1310

(13-15 March 2018)

KEHAYOV

(Group)

NESHKOV AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Conditions of detention in remand facilities and prisons and lack of an effective remedy.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify outstanding questions. To examine the draft final resolution with the view to closing 19 cases in which the individual measures have been resolved.

2015

1236

(22-24 September 2015)

DJANGOZOV

(Group)

KITOV

(Group)

DIMITROV and HAMANOV

FINGER

BULGARIA

Poor conditions of detention in prisons and investigative detention facilities and lack of effective remedies for this.

Structural problem highlighted by the European Court in the Neshkov and Others pilot. The deadline set by the Court for introducing effective preventive and compensatory remedies expires on 01/12/2016.

To assess the measures taken and/or envisaged, in accordance with the revised action plan submitted on 04/01/2016 and to underline the importance of introducing effective domestic remedies by the deadline set in the Neshkov and Others pilot judgment.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

DJANGOZOV

(Group)

KITOV

(Group)

BULGARIA

Excessive length of criminal and civil proceedings; lack of effective remedies.

To examine the draft final resolutions with a view to closing the majority of the cases. To examine a proposal to transfer to the standard procedure the cases which remain under supervision.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

INTERNATIONAL BANK FOR COMMERCE AND DEVELOPMENT AD AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Unfairness of the proceedings concerning the withdrawal of a bank licence and the bank’s insolvency.

To assess the current legal framework and to identify the outstanding questions.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

NACHOVA AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Excessive use of firearms by police officers during arrests; ineffective investigations.

To identify the outstanding questions in the Nachova case.

To examine the proposal to adopt a final resolution in the other cases.

Final resolution CM/ResDH(2016)274 adopted.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

NENCHEVA AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Lack of prompt and sufficient measures to prevent deaths of children placed in public care; lack of prompt and effective investigation into these deaths.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

NENCHEVA AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Lack of prompt and sufficient measures to prevent deaths of children placed in public care; lack of prompt and effective investigation into these deaths.

To assess the updated action report submitted on 10/10/2018.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Infringement of the freedom of association of an organisation which aims to achieve "the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria" - refusals to register their association in 1998-99 and 2002-04, based on considerations of national security (alleged separatist ideas) when the applicants had not hinted at any intention to use violence or other undemocratic means to achieve their aims, as well as on the constitutional prohibition for associations to pursue political goals (violation of Art. 11).

Follow-up to the decision to review the question of a possible transfer to enhanced procedure.

2014

1214

(2-4 December 2014)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals of the courts, in 1998-99 and 2002-04, to register an association aiming at achieving "the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria", refusals based, on the one hand, on considerations of national security, protection of public order and the rights of others (alleged separatist ideas) and, on the other hand, on the constitutional prohibition for associations to pursue political goals (violations of Art. 11).

Assessment of the additional measures taken by the Bulgarian authorities since December 2013 and proposal to transfer to the enhanced procedure.

2016

‡

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals of the courts, in 1998-99 and 2002-04, to register an association aiming at achieving "the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria", refusals based, on the one hand, on considerations of national security, protection of public order and the rights of others (alleged separatist ideas) and, on the other hand, on the constitutional prohibition for associations to pursue political goals (Article 11).

Consideration of this group of cases was postponed to 1265th meeting.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals of the courts to register an association aiming at achieving “the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria”.

To assess the latest refusals to register the applicant association and one similar organization, as well as the additional measures currently implemented by the authorities.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals of the courts to register an association aiming at achieving “the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria”.

To assess the legislative reform adopted by the authorities and to identify the outstanding questions.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals by the courts to register an association aiming at achieving "the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria".

To assess the information provided in response to the decision adopted at the 1273rd meeting and to identify the outstanding questions.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals by the courts to register an association aiming at achieving "the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria".

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1288th meeting and to identify the outstanding questions.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

UNITED MACEDONIAN ORGANISATION ILINDEN AND OTHERS

(Group)

BULGARIA

Unjustified refusals by the courts to register an association aiming at achieving "the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria".

To assess the information submitted on 16/10/2018 and to identify the outstanding questions.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

STANEV

BULGARIA

Illegal placement in social care homes of persons suffering from mental disorders, lack of judicial review and lack of possibility to request compensation. Impossibility to submit directly before a court a request for revocation of the partial guardianship. Poor living conditions in social care homes and lack of effective remedy in this respect.

To assess the measures adopted or envisaged presented in the revised action plan of 07/04/2016 and to identify the outstanding questions.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

STANEV

BULGARIA

Unlawfulness of the placement in social care homes of persons with mental disorders: lack of judicial review and poor living conditions; impossibility for partially incapacitated persons to request the restoration of their legal capacity.

To assess the information provided in response to the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting and to identify the outstanding questions.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

S.Z.

(Group)

BULGARIA

Ineffective investigations into rape, sequestration and incitement to prostitution committed by private individuals.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions. To examine the proposal to transfer the Kolevi case to the enhanced procedure.

2018

1310

(13-15 March 2018)

S.Z.

(Group)

KOLEVI

BULGARIA

Ineffective investigations into rape, sequestration and incitement to prostitution committed by private individuals. Lack of guarantees for the independence of criminal investigations against the Chief Prosecutor.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify outstanding questions. To examine the draft final resolution with the view to closing one case in which the individual measures have been resolved.

2019

1340

(12-14 March 2019)

S.Z.

(Group)

KOLEVI

BULGARIA

Systemic problem of ineffective criminal investigations in Bulgaria with regard to shortcomings which affect investigations concerning both private individuals and law enforcement agents and lack of guarantees for the independence of criminal investigations against the Chief Prosecutor.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions and the measures necessary to avoid delay in the execution process.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

VELIKOVA

(Group)

BULGARIA

Excessive use of force by members of the law enforcement agencies; ineffective investigations.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding issues.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

VELIKOVA

(Group)

BULGARIA

Excessive use of force by law enforcement agents; ineffective investigations.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding issues; to transfer the cases of Gutsanovi, Govedarski, Slavov and Others and Stoyanov and Others to the standard procedure on the basis of the important progress achieved with general measures.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

YORDANOVA AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Planned expulsion of persons of Roma[1] origin from an unlawful settlement in Sofia, where most of them had lived for decades with the authorities’ acquiescence, on the basis of legislation not requiring any proportionality review of the expulsion orders (potential violation of Article 8 if the removal order is implemented).

To assess the measures taken so far and to identify the outstanding questions.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

YORDANOVA AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Eviction of persons of Roma origin on the basis of a legislation not requiring an adequate examination of the proportionality of the measure.

To assess the measures taken so far and to identify the outstanding questions.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

YORDANOVA AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Eviction of persons of Roma origin on the basis of a legislation not requiring an adequate examination of the proportionality of the measure.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

YORDANOVA AND OTHERS

BULGARIA

Eviction of persons of Roma origin on the basis of a legislation not requiring an adequate examination of the proportionality of the measure.

To assess the progress achieved in the preparation of the legislative reform required and to identify the outstanding questions.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

AJDARIĆ

CROATIA

Unfair criminal trial (violation of Article 6 § 1).

To adopt a final resolution.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

ŠEČIĆ

CROATIA

Failure to carry out an effective investigation into a racist attack on a person of Roma origin.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify the outstanding questions.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

SKENDŽIĆ AND KRZNARIĆ

(Group)

CROATIA

Lack of an effective and independent investigation into crimes committed during the Croatian Homeland War (1991-1995) (violations of Article 2 in procedural limb).

-----

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

SKENDŽIĆ AND KRZNARIĆ

(Group)

CROATIA

Lack of an effective and independent investigation into crimes committed during the Croatian Homeland War (1991-1995) (violations of Article 2 in procedural limb).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1208th meeting.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

SKENDŽIĆ AND KRZNARIĆ

(Group)

CROATIA

Lack of an effective and independent investigation into crimes committed during the Croatian Homeland War (1991-1995).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

SKENDŽIĆ AND KRZNARIĆ

(Group)

CROATIA

Lack of an effective and independent investigation into crimes committed during the Croatian Homeland War (1991-1995).

To assess the effectiveness of the measures taken.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

STATILEO

(Group)

CROATIA

Statutory limitations on use of property by landlords, including through the rent control scheme for flats subject to protected leases.

To assess the information provided by the Croatian authorities and to identify the outstanding issues.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

STATILEO

(Group)

CROATIA

Statutory limitations on use of property by landlords, including through the rent control scheme for flats subject to protected leases.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1265th meeting.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

STATILEO

(Group)

CROATIA

Statutory limitations on use of property by landlords, including through the rent control scheme for flats subject to protected leases.

To follow up the decision adopted at 1280th meeting.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

STATILEO

(Group)

CROATIA

Statutory limitations on use of property by landlords, including through the rent control scheme for flats subject to protected leases.

To assess the revised action plan submitted on 04/10/2018 and to identify outstanding questions.

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

M.A.

(Group)

CYPRUS

Unlawful detention of asylum seekers and lack of effective remedies to challenge the lawfulness of detention and /or deportation (Articles 5 § 1 and 5 § 4, Article 13 in conjunction with Articles 2 and 3).

To assess the action plan submitted on 07/12/2015.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

M.A.

(Group)

CYPRUS

Lack of effective remedy with automatic suspensive effect in deportation proceedings and absence of speedy review of lawfulness of detention.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting and to assess the action plans of 01/07/2016 and 23/03/2017.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

M.A.

(Group)

CYPRUS

Lack of effective remedy with automatic suspensive effect in deportation proceedings and absence of speedy review of lawfulness of detention.

To assess the revised action plan submitted on 04/10/2018 and to identify outstanding questions.

To consider the proposal to close 4 cases, in which the individual measures have been taken.

2018

1310

(13-15 March 2018)

ONOUFRIOU

CYPRUS

Degrading treatment in solitary confinement, limitation of visitation rights, monitoring of correspondence and lack of an effective remedy in these respects.

To assess the progress achieved and to identify outstanding questions. To examine the proposal to transfer the case to the enhanced procedure.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

RANTSEV

CYPRUS

&

THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION

Ineffective investigation into the death of a possible victim of human trafficking.

To assess the information submitted and to examine the proposal to adopt a final resolution.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

D.H. AND OTHERS

CZECH REPUBLIC

Discrimination in the enjoyment of the applicants’ right to education due to their assignment to special schools (schools for children with special needs including those suffering from a mental or social handicap) between 1996 and 1999, on account of their Roma origin (violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 2 of Protocol No. 1).

Follow-up to the decision of 1186th meeting and assessment of the updated action plan to be submitted.

2015

1222

(11-12 March 2015)

D.H. AND OTHERS

CZECH REPUBLIC

Discrimination in the enjoyment of the applicants’ right to education due to their assignment to special schools (schools for children with special needs including those suffering from a mental or social handicap) between 1996 and 1999, on account of their Roma origin (violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 2 of Protocol No. 1).

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1201st meeting (updated action plan to be submitted by 10 February 2015 at the latest).

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

D.H. AND OTHERS

CZECH REPUBLIC

Discrimination in the enjoyment of the applicants’ right to education due to their assignment to special schools (schools for children with special needs including those suffering from a mental or social handicap) between 1996 and 1999, on account of their Roma origin (violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 2 of Protocol No. 1).

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1222nd meeting; to examine the general measures.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

D.H. AND OTHERS

CZECH REPUBLIC

Discrimination in the enjoyment of the applicants’ right to education due to their assignment to special schools between 1996 and 1999, on account of their Roma origin.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting and to assess the action plan of 10/02/2017.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

D.H. AND OTHERS

CZECH REPUBLIC

Discrimination in the enjoyment of the applicants’ right to education due to their assignment to special schools between 1996 and 1999, on account of their Roma origin.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1288th meeting (examination of the general measures).

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

I.M.

FRANCE

Lack of an effective remedy to challenge a removal measure.

To assess the action report submitted by the authorities on 15/09/2016.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

M.A.

(Group)

FRANCE

Expulsion to Algeria with a real and serious risk of ill-treatment and failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To examine only the urgent individual measures.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

M.A.

(Group)

FRANCE

Expulsion to Algeria with a real and serious risk of ill-treatment and failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To assess the new information submitted on 09/11/2018.

2019

1340

(12-14 March 2019)

M.A.

(Group)

FRANCE

Expulsion to Algeria with a real and serious risk of ill-treatment and failure to comply with the Court’s interim measure.

To examine the urgent individual measures (M.A.) and to examine the information submitted (including general measures) in the first two action plans of 02/01/2019.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

MENNESSON

(Group)

FRANCE

Refusal to grant legal recognition in France to parent-child relationships legally established in the United States between children born as a result of surrogacy agreements and the French couples who made the agreements.

To assess the action reports submitted and to consider adopting a final resolution in these cases.

2015

1243

(8-9 December 2015)

M.K.

FRANCE

Violation of the right to respect for private life; collection and retention of fingerprints (Article 8).

To assess the action plan and to request information concerning general measures.

2016

1265

(20-21 September 2016)

ALIEV

GEORGIA

Poor conditions of detention.

To assess the action plan submitted by the authorities.

2017

1288

(6-7 June 2017)

ALIEV

GEORGIA

Poor conditions of detention.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1265th meeting.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

GHARIBASHVILI

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of effective investigations into allegations of violations of the right to life or ill-treatment; excessive use of force by the police in the course of arrest and/or in custody.

Assessment of the measures taken and identification of the outstanding issues.

2015

1222

(11-12 March 2015)

GHARIBASHVILI

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of effective investigations into allegations of violations of the right to life or ill-treatment; excessive use of force by the police in the course of arrest and/or in custody.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1208th meeting.

2016

1259

(7-8 June 2016)

GHARIBASHVILI

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of effective investigations into allegations of violations of the right to life or ill-treatment; excessive use of force by the police in the course of arrest and/or in custody.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1222nd meeting.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

GHARIBASHVILI

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of effective investigations into allegations of violations of the right to life or ill-treatment; excessive use of force by the police in the course of arrest and/or in custody.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1259th meeting.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

GHARIBASHVILI

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of effective investigations into allegations of ill-treatment or violations of the right to life; excessive use of force by the police in the course of arrest and/or while detaining suspects.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1273rd meeting.

2016

1273

(6-8 December 2016)

IDENTOBA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of protection against homophobic attacks during a demonstration.

To assess the action plan submitted by the authorities on 26/04/2016. To examine the proposal to transfer the cases of 97 Members of the Gldani congregation of the Jehovah’s witnesses and four others as well as Begheluri and others under the enhanced procedure.

2018

1318

(5-7 June 2018)

IDENTOBA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of protection against homophobic attacks during a demonstration.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1273rd meeting.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

MERABISHVILI

GEORGIA

Failure of the domestic courts to give sufficiently reasoned decisions for the continued pre-trial detention of the applicant, a former Prime Minister and Minister of the Interior, and use of the pre-trial detention during this period by the Chief Public Prosecutor for the illegitimate purpose of pressurising the applicant into providing information on matters unrelated to the criminal case against him (violations of Article 5 § 3 and Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5 § 1)

To assess the action plans submitted on 04/06/2018 and 26/10/2018.

2019

1348

(4-6 June 2019)

MERABISHVILI

GEORGIA

Failure of the domestic courts to give sufficiently reasoned decisions for the continued pre-trial detention of the applicant, a former Prime Minister and Minister of the Interior, and use of the pre-trial detention during this period by the Chief Public Prosecutor for the illegitimate purpose of pressurising the applicant into providing information on matters unrelated to the criminal case against him (violations of Article 5 § 3 and Article 18 taken in conjunction with Article 5 § 1)

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1331st meeting.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

TSINTSABADZE

(Group)

GEORGIA

Lack of effective investigations into allegations of ill-treatment or violations of the right to life; excessive use of force by the police in the course of arrest and/or while detaining suspects.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1294th meeting.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

M.

(Group)

GERMANY

Unlawful extension or imposition of “preventive detention” on the basis of retroactive legislative changes

In the light of the measures taken, proposal to transfer the Group to standard procedure.

2014

1214

(2-4 December 2014)

BEKA-KOULOCHERI

(Group)

GREECE

Non-compliance by the administration with domestic court decisions and lack of an effective remedy.

To take stock of individual and general measures in light of recent developments in the Court’s case law and at a domestic level

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

BEKA-KOULOCHERI

(Group)

GREECE

Non-compliance by the authorities with domestic court decisions and lack of an effective remedy.

To follow the developments in the implementation of individual measures and, as regards general measures, to follow the implementation of measures concerning compliance with judgments ordering lift of expropriation and modification of district boundary plan.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

BEKA-KOULOCHERI

(Group)

GREECE

Non-compliance by the authorities with domestic court decisions and lack of an effective remedy.

To assess the information provided in response to the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting; to consider closing 11 cases of the group.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

BEKA-KOULOCHERI

(Group)

GREECE

Non-compliance by the authorities with domestic court decisions and lack of an effective remedy.

To assess the information provided on 08/10/2018 and to identify outstanding questions.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

BEKIR-OUSTA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GREECE

Violation of the right to freedom of association (Article 11)

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1201th meeting.

Adoption of an interim resolution

CM/ResDH(2014)84

2016

1250

(8-10 March 2016)

BEKIR-OUSTA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GREECE

Refusal of domestic courts to register the applicants’ associations (Article 11).

To follow up to the Interim Resolution adopted at the 1201st meeting.

2017

1280

(7-9 March 2017)

BEKIR-OUSTA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GREECE

Refusal of domestic courts to register the applicants’ associations.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1250th meeting.

2017

1294

(19-21 September 2017)

BEKIR-OUSTA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GREECE

Refusal of domestic courts to register the applicants’ associations.

To follow-up the decision adopted at the 1280th meeting.

2017

1302

(5-7 December 2017)

BEKIR-OUSTA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GREECE

Refusal of domestic courts to register the applicants’ associations.

To follow up the decision adopted at the 1294th meeting.

2018

1331

(4-6 December 2018)

BEKIR-OUSTA AND OTHERS

(Group)

GREECE

Refusal of domestic courts to register the applicants’ associations.

To assess the information provided on 09/10/2018 and to identify outstanding questions.

2018

1324

(18-20 September 2018)

CHOWDURY AND OTHERS

GREECE

Inadequate response to human-trafficking through exploitation of the vulnerability of unauthorised migrant workers.

To assess the action plan submitted on 06/06/2018 and to identify the outstanding questions.

2015

1236

(22-24