Ministers’ deputies

Decisions adopted

Compilation 2010 – 2014

TABLE OF CONTENT

1.  List of meetings

2.  List of cases classified by country

3.  Table-index of cases and decisions adopted during meetings of the Committee of Ministers

4.  List of decisions adopted by the Committee of Ministers (same order as in the table)

In order to use this working document, please see the list of cases classified by country.

 Click on the desired case.

Once in the table-index, you have access to all the meetings during which the case you selected was subject to a decision of the Committee of Ministers.

So as to get  the decision adopted during a meeting, click on the case’s name in the corresponding line.  


1.  LIST OF MEETINGS

2010 

1078th meeting (DH), 4-6 March 2010

1086th meeting (DH), 2-4 June 2010

1092nd meeting (DH), 15-17 September 2010

1100th meeting (DH), 2-4 December 2010

2011 

1108th meeting (DH), 6-10 March 2011

1115th meeting (DH), 7-8 June 2011

1120th meeting (DH), 13-14 September 2011

1128th meeting (DH), 29 november -2 December 2011

2012 

1136th meeting (DH), 6-8 March 2012

1144th meeting (DH), 4-6 June 2012

1150th meeting (DH), 24-26 September 2012

1157th meeting (DH), 4-6 December 2012

2013 

1164th meeting (DH), 5-7 March 2013

1172nd meeting (DH), 4-6 June 2013

1179th meeting (DH), 24-26 September 2013

1186th meeting (DH), 3-5 December 2013

2014 

1193rd meeting (DH), 4-6 March 2014

1201st meeting (DH), 3-5 June 2014

1208th  meeting (DH), 23-25 September 2014

1214th meeting (DH), 2-4 December 2014


List of cases classified by country

*      Albania

*      Caka Berhani

*      Driza

*      Manushaqe Puto and others

*      Dybeku Grori

*      Xheraj

*      Armenia

*      Meltex Ltd

*      Minasyan and  Semerjyan

*      Azerbaijan

*      Fatullayev

*      Mahmudov and  Agazade

*      Mirsayev

*      Muradova

*      Namat Aliyev

*      Belgium

*      Dumont

*      M.S.

*      Belgium and Greece

*      M.S.S.

*      Bosnia and Herzegovina

*      Al Husin

*      Čolić and others

*      Karanović

*      Kudić

*      Maktouf and  Damjanović

*      Sejdic and  Finci

*      Suljagić

*      Bulgaria

*      Al-Nashif and others

*      Association for the European integration and Human Rights and Ekimdjiev

*      V. G. and others

*      Dimitrov and  Hamanov

*      Finger

*      Kitov

*      Djangozov

*      Kashavelov

*      Kehayov

*      Nachova and others

*      United Macedonian Organisation Illinden and others

*      Raza

*      Velikova

*      Croatia

Orsus and others

Skendzic and  Krznaric

*      Cyprus and Russian Federation

Rantsev

*      Czech Republic

*      D.H. and others

*      France

*      Bousarra

*      Gebremedhin

*      Georgia

*      Enukidze and  Girgvliani

*      FC Mrand ebi

*      Gharibashvili

*      Klaus and  Yuri Kiladze

*      Pandjikidze and others

*      Germany

*      M

*      Surmeli

*      Rumpf

*      Greece

*      Bekir-Ousta and others

*      Glykantzi

*      Konti-Arvaniti

*      Makaratzis

*      Michelioudakis

*      Diamontides No. 2

*      Nisiotis

*      Sampanis and others

*      Vassilios Athanasiou and others

*      Manios (Group)

*      Hungary

*      Horváth and  Kiss

*      Kalucza

*      R.R.

*      Tímár

*      Ireland

*      A., B. and  V.

*      Italy

*      Ben Khemays

*      Trabelsi

*      Centro Europa 7 S.R.L. and  Di Stefano

*      Cirillo

*      Cand eroni

*      Luordo

*      Mostacciuolo

*      Gaglione and others

*      Hirsi Jamaa and others

*      M.V. and others

*      Saadi

*      Sneersome and  Kampanella

*      Sulejmanovic

*      Torreggiani and others

*      Lithuania

*      L.

*      Paksas

*      Malta

*      M.D. and others

*      Norway

*      Lindheim and others

*      Poland

*      Dzwonkowski

*      Fuchs

*      Grzelak

*      Horych

*      Hutten-Czapska

*      Kaprykowski

*      Kudla

*      Podbielski

*      Orchowski

*      Trzaska

*      Tysiac

*      R.R.

*      Portugal

*      Oliveira Modesto

*      Republic of Moldova

*      Becciev

*      Ciorap 

*      Corsacov

*      Eremia

*      Olaru and others

*      Paladi

*      Taraburca

*      Republic of Moldova and  Russian Federation

*      Ilaşcu and others

*      Ivantoc and others

*      Romania

*      Anghelescu Barbu No. 1

*      Association « 21 December 1989 »

*      Bragadireanu

*      Georgel and Georgeta Stoicescu

*      Moldovan

*      Nicolau

*      Stoianova and Nedelcu

*      Predica

*      Sacaleanu

*      Strain

*      Țicu

*      Gheorghe Predescu

*      Maria Atanasiu

*      Russian Federation

*      Alekseyev

*      Alim

*      Ananyev and others

*      Burdov No. 2

*      Catan and others

*      Garabayev

*      Gladysheva

*      Kalashnikov

*      Kamaliyevy

*      Khanamirova

*      Khashiyev and  Akayeva

*      Kiyutin

*      Liu (Group)

*      Mikheyev

*      Ryabykh

*      Serbia

*      EVT Company

*      Grudić

*      Zorica Jovanović

*      Slovak Republic

*      Jakub

*      Labsi

*      Slovenia

*      Kurić and others

*      Spain

*      Del Río Prada

*      Martinez Martinez

*      The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia

*      Association of citizens Radko & Paunkovski

*      El-Masri

*      Turkey

*      Ahmand  Yildirim

*      Chypre

*      Varnava

*      Demirel

*      Incal

*      Gözel and  Özer

*      Ürper

*      Ormanci

*      Ümmühan Kaplan

*      Oya Ataman

*      Hulki Güneş

*      Kakoulli

*      Loizidou

*      Ülke

*      Xenides-Arestis

*      Ukraine

*      Gongadze

*      Kharchenko

*      Naumenko Svand lana

*      Merit

*      Nevmerzhitsky

*      Yakovenko

*      Melnik

*      Logvinenko

*      Isayev

*      Kaverzin

*      Afanasyev

*      Lutsenko

*      Oleksandr Volkov

*      Tymoshenko

*      Vasiliy Ivashchenko

*      Naydyon

*      Vyerentsov

*      Zhovner

*      Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov

*      United-Kingdom

*      Al-Jedda

*      Al-Saadoon and  Mufdhi

*      Al-Skeini and others

*      McKerr

*      Hirst No. 2

*      Othman (Abu Qatada)

*      S. and  Marper



2.  TABLE-INDEX OF CASES AND DECISIONS ADOPTED DURING MEETINGS OF THE CM

Year

Meeting

Case

State

Judgment Final on

Violation

Action requested

2011

1108

(6-10 March 2011)

CAKA BERHANI (GROUP)

ALBANIA

08/03/2010

04/10/2010

Unfairness of criminal proceedings due in particular to the failure to secure the appearance of certain witnesses at the applicants’ trial and the first instance; to a court's failure to have due regard to the testimony of four witnesses given in the applicant's favour (in Caka case) and to the failure to secure convincing evidence domestic judgments justifying the applicant's conviction (in Berhani case) (violations of Article 6§1 taken alone or in conjunction with Article 6§3 (d)).

2011

1115

(7-8 June 2011)

CAKA

(GROUP)

ALBANIA

08/03/2010

See above

2011

1128

(29 nov.-2dév. 2011)

 CAKA

(GROUP)

ALBANIA

08/03/2010

See above

2012

1150

(24-26 September 2012)

CAKA

(GROUP)

ALBANIA

08/03/2010

See above

Follow-up in particular of the requests for the reopening of the impugned national proceedings, in accordance with the decision adopted at the 1128th meeting

2013

1164

(5-7 March 2013)

CAKA

(GROUP)

ALBANIA

08/03/2010

See above

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1150th meeting, in particular of the requests for the reopening of the impugned national proceedings and the reasons why some of the applicants who have obtained a reopening - are still detained.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

CAKA

(GROUP)

ALBANIA

08/03/2010

See above

To urge the authorities to submit, without further delay, information on the situation of the detained applicants and on the measures of a general nature.

2010

1086

(2 June 2010)

DRIZA (+ 4 cases)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

2010

1100

(2 December 2010)

DRIZA (+ 5 cases)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

2011

1108

(6-10 March 2011)

DRIZA (GROUP)

(+ 5 autres cases)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

2011

1115

(7-8 June 2011)

DRIZA (GROUP)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

2011

1120

(13-14 September 2011)

DRIZA (GROUP)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

2012

1144

(4-6 June 2012)

DRIZA (GROUP)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

Assessment of the state of execution of this Group of cases and of the strategy envisaged by the authorities for the future – follow-up of the mission in Tirana end of March.

2012

1150

(24-26 September 2012)

DRIZA (GROUP)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1144th DH meeting, inviting the authorities in particular to provide the Committee, in good time for the September meeting, with information on the results achieved following the steps taken with a view to establishing a list of final decisions granting restitution or compensation for property nationalised under the communist regime

2012

1157

(4-6 December 2012)

DRIZA (GROUP)

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic decisions concerning the right of the applicants to compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) as a consequence of the nationalization of property under the communist regime

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1150th DH meeting, inviting the authorities in particular to update the Committee on the next set of measures that will be taken with a view to the execution of the final judicial decisions already identified; and to indicate when they will be in a position to draw up a definitive list of the final administrative decisions to be executed.

2013

1164

(5-7 March 2013)

DRIZA (GROUP)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

17/12/2012

These cases concern the non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13). The European Court in the pilot judgement Manushaqe Puto and others fixed a deadline of 18 months for the authorities to set up an effective compensation mechanism.

Follow-up of the decision adopted at the 1157th meeting, asking the authorities to make rapidly concrete progress and in particular:

- to establish the final list of all judicial and administrative decisions to be executed

- finalise the land value map,

- and then, on the basis of these elements, calculate the cost of the execution of the decisions, in order to be able to define the resources needed, adopt the final execution mechanism, and execute - of their own motion - the decisions at issue.

2013

1172

(4-6 June 2013)

DRIZA (GROUP)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

17/12/2012

These cases concern the non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13). The European Court in the pilot judgement Manushaqe Puto and others fixed a deadline of 18 months for the authorities to set up an effective compensation mechanism.

Assessment of the status of execution of this Group of cases and of the appropriate response to be given in the absence of significant progress, despite repeated calls from the Committee (on the basis of a draft interim resolution).

2013

1186

(3-5 December 2013)

DRIZA (GROUP)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

17/12/2012

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

Express serious concern with the lack of adequate progress in setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism, despite the Committee’s repeated requests, the last being made in the Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2013)115, and despite the approaching deadline set by the Court for the implementation of the Manushaqe Puto judgment.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

DRIZA (GROUP)

MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

17/12/2012

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1186th meeting and assessment of the progress achieved in the implementation of the pilot judgment.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

DRIZA (GROUP) MANUSHAQE PUTO AND OTHERS

ALBANIA

17/12/2012

02/06/2008

Non-enforcement of final domestic court and administrative decisions relating to the applicants’ right to restitution or compensation (whether pecuniary or in kind) for property nationalised under the communist regime (violation of articles 6§1, 1, Protocol No.1 and 13).

The Court, in the pilot judgment Manushaqe Puto and others, requested the setting-up of an effective compensation mechanism before 17 June 2014.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1193rd meeting and assessment of the progress achieved in the implementation of the action plan presented by the authorities at the last examination of the case.

2013

1164

(5-7 March 2013)

DYBEKU

GRORI

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

07/10/2009

These cases concern the ill‑treatment suffered by the applicants as a result of a lack of adequate medical treatment whilst in detention (violation of Article 3).

The case of Grori also concerns the unlawfulness of the applicant’s detention from 15/05/2002 until 29/12/2003 which was founded on international law instruments not yet in force in respect of Albania (violation of Article 5§1) and the unjustified delay in complying with the European Court's interim measure to transfer the applicant to a civilian hospital (violation of Article 34).

Action plan submitted in November 2011. Delay in the submission of the necessary additional information to allow examination of the status of execution of the cases by the Committee.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

DYBEKU

GRORI

ALBANIA

02/06/2008

07/10/2009

Ill-treatment suffered by the applicants as a result of a lack of adequate medical care whilst in detention (violation of Article 3).

The Grori case also concerns the unlawfulness of the applicant’s detention from 15/05/2002 until 29/12/2003 which was founded on international law instruments not yet in force in respect of Albania (violation of Article 5§1) and the unjustified delay in complying with the European Court's interim measure to transfer the applicant to a civilian hospital (violation of Article 34).

Action report submitted on 25/06/2014. Assessment of the information provided.

2010

1100

(2 December 2010)

XHERAJ

ALBANIA

01/12/2008

Violation of the applicant's right to a fair trial and infringement of the principle of legal certainty due to the quashing of a final judgment acquitting him of murder (violation of Article 6§1).

2011

1108

(6-10 March 2011)

XHERAJ

ALBANIA

01/12/2008

Violation of the applicant's right to a fair trial and infringement of the principle of legal certainty due to the quashing of a final judgment acquitting him of murder (violation of Article 6§1).

2011

1128

(29 nov.-2dév. 2011)

XHERAJ

ALBANIA

01/12/2008

Violation of the applicant's right to a fair trial and infringement of the principle of legal certainty due to the quashing of a final judgment acquitting him of murder (violation of Article 6§1).

2010

1078

(4 March 2010)

MELTEX LTD AND   MESROP MOVSESYAN

ARMENIA

17/09/2008

Violation of the applicant company’s freedom of expression on account of the refusal, by the National Television and Radio Commission (NTRC), on seven occasions in 2002 and 2003, to deliver to the applicant a broadcasting license (violation of Article 10).

2010

1092

(15 September 2010)

MELTEX LTD AND  MESROP MOVSESYAN

ARMENIA

17/09/2008

Violation of the applicant company’s freedom of expression on account of the refusal, by the National Television and Radio Commission (NTRC), on seven occasions in 2002 and 2003, to deliver to the applicant a broadcasting license (violation of Article 10).

2013

1172

(4-6 June 2013)

MINASYAN AND  SEMERJYAN

(GROUP)

ARMENIA

23/09/2009

Violations of the applicants' right to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions due to the expropriation of their flats or the deprivation of their right to use of flats under conditions that are not prescribed by law (Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

Take note of the action report provided by the Armenian authorities for the execution of this Group of cases and instruct the Secretariat to present a detailed assessment of the said action report at the latest at the December 2013 DH meeting.

2013

1186

(3-5 December 2013)

MINASYAN AND  SEMERJYAN

(GROUP)

ARMENIA

23/09/2009

Violations of the applicants' right to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions due to the expropriation of their flats or the deprivation of their right to use of flats under conditions that are not prescribed by law (Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

Follow-up to the decision taken at the 1172nd meeting.

2010

1100

(2 December 2010)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

04/10/2010

Breaches of the applicants' right to freedom of expression on account of his sentencing to imprisonment after the publication by him, inter alia, of two articles in the newspaper Realny Azerbaijan (violations of Article 10).

2011

1108

(6-10 March 2011)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

4/10/2010

Breaches of the applicants' right to freedom of expression on account of his sentencing to imprisonment after the publication by him, inter alia, of two articles in the newspaper Realny Azerbaijan (violations of Article 10).

2010

1078

(4 March 2010)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

2011

1115

(7-8 June 2011)

MAHMUDOV AND AGAZADE

(GROUP)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

04/10/2010

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

2011

1128

(29 nov.-2dév. 2011)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

2012

1136

(6-8 March 2012)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Taking stock of the general measures envisaged and to highlight the necessity to take further measures

2012

1144

(4-6 June 2012)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Assessment of the state of progress in taking general measures following the questions raised by the Committee at its 1136th meeting

2012

1150

(24-26 September 2012)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Assessment of the state of progress in taking general measures following the decision adopted at the 1144th meeting

2012

1157

(4-6 December 2012)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Assessment of the state of progress in taking general measures (in particular with respect to the cooperation with the Venice Commission regarding the elaboration of the Law on defamation) following the decision adopted at the 1150th meeting

2013

1172

(4-6 June 2013)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Take stock of the state of progress regarding the preparation of the law on defamation

2013

1179

(24-26 September 2013)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Examination of a draft interim resolution given the absence of any information provided in response to the decision adopted at the 1172nd meeting.

2013

1186

(3-5 December 2013)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Follow-up to the decision taken at the 1179th meeting.

2014

1188

Réunion ordinaire

(15 january 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violations of the right to freedom of expression of the applicants, journalists, in particular due to their being sentenced to imprisonment for publications made.

Follow-up to the decision taken at the 1186th meeting.

2014

1193

(4-6 March 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1188th meeting.

2014

1201

(3-5 June 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1193th meeting.

2014

1208

(23-25 September 2014)

MAHMUDOV AND  AGAZADE

(GROUP)

FATULLAYEV

AZERBAIJAN

18/03/2009

Violation of right to freedom of expression, arbitrary application of law.

Follow-up to the decision adopted at the 1201st  meeting.

Adoption of an Interim resolution

CM/ResDH(2014)183

2011

1108

(6-10 March 2011)

MIRZAYEV

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

03/03/2010

Non-enforcement of final judicial decisions ordering the eviction of internally displaced persons (IDP) who were unlawfully occupying the applicants’ apartments

2012

1144

(4-6 June 2012)

MIRZAYEV

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

03/03/2010

Non-enforcement of final judicial decisions ordering the eviction of internally displaced persons (IDP) who were unlawfully occupying the applicants’ apartments

Taking stock of the individual and general measures taken so far

2010

1086

(2 June 2010)

MURADOVA

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

02/07/2009

Excessive use of force by the police against the applicants (two of them journalists) during demonstrations and lack of an effective investigation in this respect (violations of Article 3 on substantive and procedural limb). Violation of Article 10 due to excessive use of force imposed on the applicant journalist (Najafli case).

2013

1172

(4-6 June 2013)

MURADOVA

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN

02/07/2009

Excessive use of force by the police against the applicants (two of them journalists) during demonstrations and lack of an effective investigation in this respect (violations of Article 3 on substantive and procedural limb). Violation of Article 10 due to excessive use of force imposed on the applicant journalist (Najafli case).

Assessment of the status of execution of this Group of cases on the basis also of the recent action plans submitted.

2013

1179

(24-26 September 2013)

NAMAT ALIYEV

(GROUP)

AZERBAIJAN