Resolution CM/ResDH(2016)332
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
196 cases against Turkey (see list appended)
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 9 November 2016
at the 1270th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established;
Recalling that the violations of the Convention found by the Court in these cases primarily concern the right to liberty and security within the context of detention on remand; other violations concern:
- the continued detention of the applicant following a release order issued (violation of Article 5 § 1) in the case of Tandoğan (9244/02) (this issue was examined under the Hamşioğlu group of cases (see Final Resolution CM/ResDH(2014)123);
- the excessive length of criminal proceedings (violations of article 6 § 1) in 110 cases and the lack of an effective remedy in this respect (violations of article 13) in 20 cases (these issues were examined under the Ormancıand Others group of cases (see Final Resolution CM/ResDH(2014)298);
- the lack of independence and impartiality of the State security courts (violations of Article 6) in the cases of Demirel (39324/98), Sevgin and Ince (46262/99), Temel and Taşkin (40159/98) (this issue was examined under the Gençel and Çıraklar groups of cases (see Final Resolutions CM/ResDH(2013)256 and ResDH(99)555) respectively);
- the violation of the right to adversarial proceedings and equality of arms, on account of the authorities’ failure to communicate to the applicants the prosecutors’ opinion before the Court of Cassation (violation of Article 6 § 1) (this issue was examined under the Göç group of cases (see Final Resolution CM/ResDH(2011)307));
- the absence of legal assistance in police custody (violations of Article 6 § 3(c)) in the cases of Dil (2611/09), Doğan and Kalın (1651/05), Feti Ateş and Others (28827/04) (this issue is being examined under the Salduz (36391/02) group of cases);
- the violation of the applicant’s right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty (violation of Art 6 § 2) in the case of Urfi Cetinkaya (19866/04) (this issue is being examined under the Dicle and Sadak case (48621/07));
- the violation of the applicant’s right to respect for his private life on account of unjustified interference by the prison authorities with his correspondence (violation of Article 8) in Fethullah Akpulat (22077/03) (this issue is being examined under the Tamer group (6289/02));
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the action report provided by the government indicating the measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments including the information provided regarding the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2016)1176);
Having noted that the applications in these cases were lodged with the Court between 16 December 1996 and 5 July 2012 and that none of the applicants are currently being detained on remand;
Having satisfied itself that all the measures required by Article 46, paragraph 1, have been adopted,
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix: List of the cases
|
Application |
Case |
Judgment of |
Final on |
|
39324/98 |
DEMIREL |
28/01/2003 |
28/04/2003 |
|
10512/02 |
ABDULLAH YILMAZ |
22/07/2008 |
22/10/2008 |
|
19332/04 |
ABAY |
01/12/2009 |
01/03/2010 |
|
17681/04 |
ABDO |
26/01/2010 |
26/04/2010 |
|
28069/07 |
ABDULKERIM KAYA |
05/01/2010 |
05/04/2010 |
|
31595/07 |
ABDULSİTAR AKGÜL |
25/06/2013 |
25/09/2013 |
|
15234/05 |
AÇAN AND OTHERS |
13/05/2014 |
13/05/2014 |
|
61442/00+ |
ACUNBAY |
31/05/2005 |
31/08/2005 |
|
38372/06+ |
ADIYAMAN AND ERMAN |
26/10/2010 |
26/01/2011 |
|
77331/01 |
AĞDAŞ ÇETIN |
19/09/2006 |
19/12/2006 |
|
23480/06 |
AKALIN |
23/11/2010 |
23/02/2011 |
|
8076/08 |
AKAN AND ÇELİK |
25/11/2014 |
25/11/2014 |
|
35561/06 |
AKPOLAT |
08/01/2009 |
08/04/2009 |
|
6178/04 |
AKYAZ |
07/07/2009 |
07/10/2009 |
|
23438/02 |
AKYOL |
20/09/2007 |
20/12/2007 |
|
483/02 |
ALGUR AND OTHERS |
20/11/2007 |
20/02/2008 |
|
24597/08 |
ALİ RIZA KAPLAN |
13/11/2014 |
13/02/2015 |
|
34396/05+ |
ALP AND OTHERS |
07/12/2010 |
07/03/2011 |
|
73038/01 |
ALTIN HIYASETTIN |
24/05/2005 |
24/08/2005 |
|
31610/08 |
ALTINOK |
29/11/2011 |
29/02/2012 |
|
44319/04 |
ARAZ |
20/05/2010 |
20/08/2010 |
|
33746/02 |
ARI AND ŞEN |
02/10/2007 |
02/01/2008 |
|
7933/05 |
ATEŞ MIZRAP |
26/01/2010 |
26/04/2010 |
|
7987/07 |
ATSIZ AND OTHERS |
23/06/2009 |
23/09/2009 |
|
30441/08+ |
AYDOGAN AND OTHERS |
08/02/2011 |
08/05/2011 |
|
43550/04 |
AYGÜL |
16/06/2009 |
16/09/2009 |
|
29287/02 |
AYHAN AND OTHERS |
14/10/2008 |
14/01/2009 |
|
20259/06 |
AYTIMUR |
20/05/2010 |
20/08/2010 |
|
43256/04 |
BAĞRIYANIK |
05/06/2007 |
05/09/2007 |
|
35257/04 |
BAHÇELI |
06/10/2009 |
06/01/2010 |
|
495/02 |
BALTACI |
18/07/2006 |
18/10/2006 |
|
26170/03 |
BARIŞ |
31/03/2009 |
30/06/2009 |
|
74337/01 |
BAŞTIMAR AND OTHERS |
05/12/2006 |
05/03/2007 |
|
26896/02 |
BAYAM |
31/07/2007 |
31/10/2007 |
|
28053/10 |
BİLAL DOĞAN |
27/11/2012 |
27/02/2013 |
|
8610/02 |
BILGIN ÖZDEN |
14/06/2007 |
14/09/2007 |
|
26891/02 |
BOYRAZ |
20/05/2008 |
20/08/2008 |
|
18623/03 |
CAHIT DEMIREL |
07/07/2009 |
07/10/2009 |
|
16777/06+ |
CAN AND GÜMÜŞ |
31/03/2009 |
30/06/2009 |
|
7940/05 |
ÇARKÇI |
26/06/2007 |
10/12/2007 |
|
26808/08 |
CATAL |
17/04/2012 |
17/07/2012 |
|
37912/04 |
ÇAYAN BILGIN |
08/12/2009 |
08/03/2010 |
|
45490/05 |
CELIK AND ABATAY |
29/11/2011 |
29/02/2012 |
|
6670/10 |
ÇELİK ÖZGÜR |
17/0232015 |
17/0232015 |
|
41746/04 |
ÇEVEN |
24/11/2009 |
24/02/2010 |
|
8140/08 |
CEVIZ |
17/07/2012 |
17/10/2012 |
|
14899/03 |
ÇIÇEKLER |
22/12/2005 |
22/03/2006 |
|
16963/07 |
ÇIĞDEM |
21/04/2009 |
21/07/2009 |
|
45977/99 |
ÇOBANOĞLU AND BUDAK |
30/01/2007 |
30/04/2007 |
|
42138/07+ |
DEMIR AND İPEK |
26/01/2010 |
26/04/2010 |
|
77845/01 |
DERECI |
24/05/2005 |
24/08/2005 |
|
2611/09 |
DİL |
24/09/2013 |
24/09/2013 |
|
66066/09 |
DİNÇ AND ÇAKIR |
09/07/2013 |
09/10/2013 |
|
28551/06 |
DINÇ ERHAN |
20/05/2010 |
20/08/2010 |
|
61443/00 |
DINLER |
31/05/2005 |
31/08/2005 |
|
1651/05 |
DOGAN AND KALIN |
21/12/2010 |
21/03/2011 |
|
54625/09 |
DURMUŞ AND TANŞANCIK |
31/07/2012 |
31/07/2012 |
|
17765/02 |
DURSUN |
03/05/2007 |
03/08/2007 |
|
57963/00 |
DUYUM |
27/03/2007 |
09/07/2007 |
|
47280/09 |
EKİCİ |
05/03/2013 |
05/03/2013 |
|
18992/03 |
ELĞAY |
20/01/2009 |
20/04/2009 |
|
6194/04 |
ENGIN |
13/10/2009 |
13/01/2010 |
|
41810/06+ |
ERCAN KARTAL |
29/03/2011 |
29/03/2011 |
|
73359/10 |
ERGEZEN |
08/04/2014 |
08/07/2014 |
|
13176/05 |
ERKAN İNAN |
23/02/2010 |
23/05/2010 |
|
32008/05 |
ETEM KARAGÖZ |
15/09/2009 |
15/12/2009 |
|
42956/09 |
EVLİYAOĞLU |
05/03/2013 |
05/03/2013 |
|
22077/03 |
FETHULLAH AKPULAT |
15/02/2011 |
15/05/2011 |
|
34759/04+ |
FETI ATES AND OTHERS |
21/12/2010 |
21/03/2011 |
|
28827/04 |
FETI ATEŞ |
10/06/2008 |
10/09/2008 |
|
28074/08 |
FİLİZ |
04/03/2014 |
04/06/2014 |
|
37291/04 |
FIRAT |
30/06/2009 |
30/09/2009 |
|
21292/07 |
GAMZE ULUDAĞ |
10/12/2013 |
10/03/2014 |
|
22478/06+ |
GEDIK |
20/05/2010 |
20/08/2010 |
|
71517/01 |
GEZICI AND İPEK |
10/11/2005 |
10/02/2006 |
|
51839/99 |
GÖKÇE AND DEMIREL |
22/06/2006 |
22/09/2006 |
|
6257/02 |
GÜZEL (ZEYBEK) |
20/11/2007 |
20/02/2008 |
|
28485/03 |
HABIP ÇIFTÇI |
23/09/2008 |
23/12/2008 |
|
18378/02 |
HANBAYAT |
17/07/2007 |
17/10/2007 |
|
58398/00 |
HASAN CEYLAN |
23/05/2006 |
23/08/2006 |
|
44027/09 |
HASDEMIR |
22/05/2012 |
22/05/2012 |
|
43918/08 |
HATICE DUMAN |
22/05/2012 |
22/05/2012 |
|
15048/09 |
HEBAT ASLAN AND FİRAS ASLAN |
28/10/2014 |
28/01/2015 |
|
19637/05+ |
İNAN AND OTHERS |
13/10/2009 |
13/01/2010 |
|
58231/09 |
İSMAİL YILMAZ |
24/09/2013 |
24/09/2013 |
|
32420/03 |
KAÇAR MURAT |
03/05/2007 |
03/08/2007 |
|
43648/05 |
KAÇMAZ |
02/02/2010 |
02/05/2010 |
|
16779/02 |
KALAY |
22/09/2005 |
22/12/2005 |
|
43654/05 |
KALAYLI |
11/10/2011 |
11/01/2011 |
|
24917/04 |
KAMA |
10/06/2008 |
10/09/2008 |
|
20648/02 |
KAMIL ÖCALAN |
12/12/2006 |
12/03/2007 |
|
7328/03 |
KAPAR |
03/05/2007 |
03/08/2007 |
|
5701/02 |
KARAGÖZ GÖNÜL |
20/10/2005 |
20/01/2006 |
|
76991/01 |
KARAKAŞ |
13/06/2006 |
13/09/2006 |
|
11468/02 |
KARATAY AND OTHERS |
15/02/2007 |
15/05/2007 |
|
40994/98 |
KATAR AND OTHERS |
18/04/2006 |
18/07/2006 |
|
7263/04 |
KESIKKULAK |
08/01/2009 |
08/04/2009 |
|
61440/00 |
KIMRAN |
05/04/2005 |
05/07/2005 |
|
34683/07+ |
KINAY İSMAIL AND KINAY ŞEYHMUS |
02/02/2010 |
02/05/2010 |
|
30689/05 |
KIRLANGIÇ |
25/09/2012 |
25/12/2012 |
|
10262/04 |
KÖKLÜ |
14/10/2008 |
14/01/2009 |
|
74321/01 |
KOŞTI AND OTHERS |
03/05/2007 |
03/08/2007 |
|
56493/07 |
KÜRÜM |
26/01/2010 |
26/04/2010 |
|
41433/06+ |
KUTLAR AND OCAKLI |
01/02/2011 |
01/05/2011 |
|
17403/10 |
KUZU AND ABAY |
08/10/2013 |
08/10/2013 |
|
70026/10 |
LEVENT BEKTAŞ |
16/06/2015 |
19/10/2015 |
|
33104/04 |
MUSTAFA TOSUN |
18/11/2008 |
18/02/2009 |
|
6840/08 |
MAHMUT OZ |
03/07/2012 |
03/10/2012 |
|
33631/04 |
MAHMUT YAMAN |
20/01/2009 |
20/04/2009 |
|
42296/07 |
MEHMET ALI ÇELIK |
27/01/2009 |
27/04/2009 |
|
58405/10 |
MEHMET ALİ POLAT |
21/01/2014 |
21/01/2014 |
|
9603/07+ |
MEHMET GARIP ÖZER AND OTHERS |
05/01/2010 |
05/04/2010 |
|
61908/00 |
MEHMET GÜNEŞ |
21/09/2006 |
21/12/2006 |
|
54614/07 |
MEHMET MANSUR DEMİR |
24/07/2012 |
24/07/2012 |
|
4018/07+ |
MEHMET ÖZCAN AND OTHERS |
26/10/2010 |
11/04/2011 |
|
48545/99 |
MEHMET ŞAH ÇELIK |
24/07/2007 |
24/10/2007 |
|
47043/99 |
MEHMET YAVUZ |
24/07/2007 |
24/10/2007 |
|
7605/05 |
MÜCEK |
16/07/2009 |
16/10/2009 |
|
2623/04 |
MÜDET KÖMÜRCÜ |
23/09/2008 |
23/12/2008 |
|
5346/03 |
MÜNIRE DEMIREL |
20/05/2008 |
20/08/2008 |
|
47359/09 |
MURAT AKTAŞ |
24/09/2013 |
24/09/2013 |
|
60225/11 |
MURAT ÖZDEMİR |
15/04/2014 |
15/07/2014 |
|
35065/97 |
N.M. |
25/10/2005 |
25/01/2006 |
|
69812/11 |
NAMAZ AND ŞENOĞLU |
11/06/2012 |
11/06/2012 |
|
2694/06 |
NİHAT ATEŞ |
22/10/2013 |
22/10/2013 |
|
59860/10 |
ÖNER AKTAŞ |
29/10/2013 |
29/01/2014 |
|
9462/05+ |
ORMAN AND OTHERS |
07/12/2010 |
07/03/2011 |
|
61441/00 |
ÖZDEMIR SADEGÜL |
02/08/2005 |
02/11/2005 |
|
23601/10 |
OZKAN TURGUT |
22/05/2012 |
22/08/2012 |
|
13017/02 |
PAKKAN |
31/10/2006 |
31/01/2007 |
|
4233/03 |
PEHLIVAN |
09/12/2008 |
09/03/2009 |
|
61446/00 |
POLAT ALI HIDIR |
05/04/2005 |
05/07/2005 |
|
40593/04 |
POLAT CENGIZ |
11/12/2007 |
11/03/2008 |
|
9572/05 |
RAHMAN |
15/02/2011 |
15/05/2011 |
|
30911/04 |
REMZI AYDIN |
20/02/2007 |
20/05/2007 |
|
24267/07 |
RİFAT DEMİR |
04/06/2013 |
04/09/2013 |
|
28489/04 |
RÜZGAR HASAN |
27/05/2008 |
27/08/2008 |
|
44324/09 |
SABAHATTİN ALKAN |
22/10/2013 |
22/10/2013 |
|
4220/02+ |
SADIKOĞULLARI AND ERDEM |
21/10/2008 |
21/01/2009 |
|
45465/04 |
SAĞNAT |
13/10/2009 |
13/01/2010 |
|
29361/07 |
ŞAHAP DOĞAN |
27/05/2010 |
27/08/2010 |
|
28807/05 |
SAHIN ZEKI |
22/02/2011 |
22/05/2011 |
|
1947/09 |
SARAR |
27/03/2012 |
27/03/2012 |
|
1966/07+ |
ŞAYIK AND OTHERS |
08/12/2009 |
08/03/2010 |
|
9961/08 |
ŞEKERCİ |
01/07/2014 |
01/07/2014 |
|
46262/99 |
SEVGIN AND INCE |
20/09/2005 |
20/12/2005 |
|
7540/07+ |
SEVIM AND OTHERS |
05/01/2010 |
05/04/2010 |
|
4020/07+ |
ŞINEĞU AND OTHERS |
13/10/2009 |
13/01/2010 |
|
27561/02 |
SOLMAZ |
16/01/2007 |
16/04/2007 |
|
34623/03 |
SOLMAZ CAHIT |
14/06/2007 |
14/09/2007 |
|
74657/01 |
SOYLU |
18/12/2007 |
02/06/2008 |
|
19985/04 |
STOICA |
29/11/2011 |
29/02/2012 |
|
48846/07+ |
SUDAN AND OTHERS |
05/04/2011 |
05/04/2011 |
|
38283/04 |
SÜLEYMANOĞLU |
29/01/2013 |
29/04/2013 |
|
1508/08 |
SUUT AYDIN |
24/09/2013 |
24/09/2013 |
|
25324/02 |
TACIROĞLU |
02/02/2006 |
02/05/2006 |
|
1636/02 |
TAMAMBOĞA AND GÜL |
29/11/2007 |
29/02/2008 |
|
28150/03 |
TAMCAN |
12/06/2007 |
12/09/2007 |
|
235/02 |
TAMER AND OTHERS |
22/06/2006 |
11/12/2006 |
|
9244/02 |
TANDOĞAN |
20/09/2007 |
20/12/2007 |
|
18711/02 |
TARAK. |
08/04/2008 |
28/09/2008 |
|
21179/02 |
TAŞ SABRI |
20/09/2005 25/04/2006 |
20/12/2005 25/07/2006 |
|
23623/10 |
TASCI AND DEMIR |
03/05/2012 |
03/08/2012 |
|
33153/04 |
TEKIN |
17/01/2012 |
17/01/2012 |
|
42554/98+ |
TEKIN AND BALTAŞ |
07/02/2006 |
07/05/2006 |
|
40159/98 |
TEMEL AND TAŞKIN |
30/06/2005 |
30/09/2005 |
|
16185/06 |
TOKMAK |
16/02/2010 |
16/05/2010 |
|
13244/02 |
TÖRE No. 2 |
11/07/2006 |
11/10/2006 |
|
11855/04 |
TÜM OKAN |
17/06/2008 |
17/09/2008 |
|
2422/06+ |
TUNCE AND OTHERS |
13/10/2009 |
13/01/2010 |
|
11798/03 |
TUTAR İSKENDER |
10/10/2006 |
10/01/2007 |
|
1968/07+ |
UGUR ŞEYHMUS AND OTHERS |
19/10/2010 |
11/04/2011 |
|
49651/06 |
UGUR |
24/01/2012 |
24/04/2012 |
|
29545/06+ |
ULU AND OTHERS |
07/12/2010 |
07/03/2011 |
|
10317/03 |
ÜMIT IŞIK |
16/03/2010 |
16/06/2010 |
|
24801/05 |
ÜNAY |
22/09/2009 |
22/12/2009 |
|
19866/04 |
ÜRFİ ÇETİNKAYA |
23/07/2013 |
09/12/2013 |
|
40555/04 |
ÜTEBAY. |
17/07/2008 |
17/10/2008 |
|
7945/05 |
UYANIK AND KABADAYI |
22/09/2009 |
22/12/2009 |
|
18078/02 |
VAYIÇ |
20/06/2006 |
20/09/2006 |
|
43824/07 |
VELI ÖZDEMIR |
23/06/2009 |
23/09/2009 |
|
23639/10 |
YAKAR |
22/05/2012 |
22/08/2012 |
|
11339/03 |
YAKIŞAN |
06/03/2007 |
06/06/2007 |
|
15041/03 |
YALÇIN |
19/02/2008 |
19/05/2008 |
|
2723/07 |
YALÇIN ABDULLAH |
21/04/2009 |
21/07/2009 |
|
53214/09 |
YAŞAR ERİŞ |
28/05/2012 |
28/05/2012 |
|
62581/12 |
YAYĞIN |
03/02/2015 |
03/02/2015 |
|
21521/06+ |
YER AND GUNGOR |
07/12/2010 |
07/03/2011 |
|
41481/05 |
YEŞILMEN AND OTHERS |
16/02/2010 |
16/05/2010 |
|
15649/05 |
YEŞILYURT |
23/02/2010 |
23/05/2010 |
|
20827/08 |
YIĞITDOĞAN |
16/03/2010 |
16/06/2010 |
|
46048/06 |
YILDIZ ERCÜMENT |
10/06/2008 |
10/09/2008 |
|
23706/07+ |
YOLDAS AND OTHERS |
15/03/2011 |
15/03/2011 |
|
31152/04 |
YÜCEL No. 2 |
08/04/2008 |
08/07/2008 |
|
12439/03 |
YURT |
20/02/2007 |
20/05/2007 |
|
1515/04 |
ZEHI DOĞAN |
02/02/2010 |
02/05/2010 |