Resolution CM/ResDH(2015)230
Execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
Vassilios Athanasiou and Others v. Greece and 205 cases of length of proceedings before administrative courts
(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 9 December 2015
at the 1243rd meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)
The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, which provides that the Committee supervises the execution of final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter “the Convention” and “the Court”),
Having regard to the final judgments transmitted by the Court to the Committee in these cases and to the violations established, and in particular to the indication made by the Court in the pilot judgment Vassilios Athanasiou and Others v. Greece to put in place effective domestic remedies in the area of excessive length of proceedings before administrative courts which comply with the requirements established in its case-law;
Recalling the respondent State’s obligation, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by all final judgments in cases to which it has been a party and that this obligation entails, over and above the payment of any sums awarded by the Court, the adoption by the authorities of the respondent State, where required:
- of individual measures to put an end to violations established and erase their consequences so as to achieve as far as possible restitutio in integrum; and
- of general measures preventing similar violations;
Having invited the government of the respondent State to inform the Committee of the measures taken to comply with the above-mentioned obligation;
Having examined the action report provided by the government indicating the measures adopted in order to give effect to the judgments, including the information provided regarding the individual measures and the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court (see document DH-DD(2015)1269);
Having satisfied itself that all the measures required by Article 46, paragraph 1, have been adopted,
DECLARES that it has exercised its functions under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention in these cases and
DECIDES to close the examination thereof.
Appendix
List of cases
|
Application No. |
Case |
Judgment of |
Final on |
|
50973/08 |
ATHANASIOU AND OTHERS |
21/12/2010 |
21/03/2011 |
|
70626/01 |
MANIOS |
11/03/2004 |
11/06/2004 |
|
19841/02 |
AGATHOS AND 49 OTHERS |
23/09/2004 |
02/02/05 |
|
13177/10 |
AGGELAKOPOULOS |
24/04/2014 |
24/04/2014 |
|
28760/04 |
AGGELAKOU-SVARNA |
14/12/2006 |
14/03/2007 |
|
43848/02 |
AGGELOPOULOS |
09/06/2005 |
09/09/2005 |
|
31873/08 |
ALEVIZOU-TERZAKI AND OTHERS |
07/02/2012 |
07/02/2012 |
|
23377/08 |
ALEXAKIS |
21/10/2010 |
21/10/2010 |
|
26682/05 |
ALEXIOU |
06/12/2007 |
06/03/2008 |
|
20204/09 |
ALUMINIA DE MACEDOINE ALMACO S.A. |
12/06/2012 |
12/06/2012 |
|
25844/04 |
ANASTASIADIS AND OTHERS |
24/04/2008 |
24/07/2008 |
|
25833/04 |
ANASTASOPOULOS AND OTHERS |
24/04/2008 |
24/07/2008 |
|
10803/04 |
ANDONIADIS |
06/07/2006 |
06/10/2006 |
|
33523/02 |
ANDREADAKI AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
21824/02 |
ANDRIANESIS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
06/07/2005 |
|
389/03 |
ANDRIOTIS AND ANDRIOTIS |
25/01/2007 |
25/04/2007 |
|
22510/09 |
ANOGIANAKIS |
12/06/2012 |
12/06/2012 |
|
34206/02 |
APOSTOLAKI |
17/03/2005 |
17/06/2005 |
|
10468/04 |
ARGYROU AND OTHERS |
15/01/2009 |
15/04/2009 |
|
27278/03 |
ARVANITAKI-ROBOTI AND OTHERS |
15/02/2008 |
Grand Chamber |
|
22395/10+ |
ASIMAKOPOULOS |
16/10/2014 |
16/10/2014 |
|
24133/05 |
ASSOCIATION “E. APOSTOLOPOULOS AND K. LYMPEROPOULOS” |
24/04/2008 |
24/07/2008 |
|
16282/08 |
ATHANASIADIS |
22/04/2010 |
22/07/2010 |
|
34339/02 |
ATHANASIADIS AND OTHERS |
28/04/2005 |
30/11/2005 |
|
15938/06 |
AVDELIDIS AND OTHERS |
10/04/2008 |
29/09/2008 |
|
25852/04 |
AVOUTZIS AND OTHERS |
24/04/2008 |
24/07/2008 |
|
26084/04 |
AVRAMIDIS AND OTHERS |
24/04/2008 |
24/07/2008 |
|
45830/08+ |
BAKIRTZIDIS AND OTHERS |
11/07/2013 |
11/07/2013 |
|
24454/07 |
BEKAS |
12/03/2009 |
12/06/2009 |
|
28264/07 |
BEKIARI AND OTHERS |
02/04/2009 |
02/07/2009 |
|
28073/09 |
CANGELARIS |
03/05/2012 |
03/05/2012 |
|
21276/03 |
CHARALAMBOS KARAGIANNIS |
09/06/2005 |
09/09/2005 |
|
32279/02 |
CHARALAMBOS KATSAROS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
38302/02 |
CHARMANTAS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
33997/06 |
CHATZINIKOLAOU |
21/02/2008 |
21/05/2008 |
|
10953/05 |
CHRYSOCHOOU |
03/05/2007 |
03/08/2007 |
|
497/07 |
DALI |
06/11/2008 |
06/02/2009 |
|
13320/03 |
DAMILAKOS |
30/03/2006 |
30/06/2006 |
|
43394/06 |
DAVARIS |
16/04/2009 |
16/07/2009 |
|
28749/04 |
DIAKOUMAKOS |
30/11/2006 |
28/02/2007 |
|
13332/03 |
EKDOSEIS N. PAPANIKOLAOU A.E. |
04/05/2006 |
04/08/2006 |
|
28819/04 |
ELMALIOTIS AND KONSTANTINIDIS |
25/01/2007 |
25/04/2007 |
|
41558/04 |
ERGO ABEKTE |
27/09/2007 |
27/12/2007 |
|
20885/10 |
EVROMART A.E. |
22/01/2013 |
22/01/2013 |
|
15545/07 |
EXAMILIOTIS No. 4 |
11/06/2009 |
06/11/2009 |
|
27353/09 |
FERGADIOTI-RIZAKI |
18/04/2013 |
18/07/2013 |
|
31071/05 |
FILIOTI |
11/10/2007 |
11/01/2008 |
|
1001/09 |
FIX |
12/07/2011 |
28/11/2011 |
|
40049/08 |
FOUNTIS AND OTHERS |
03/02/2001 |
03/02/2001 |
|
18830/03 |
FRAGGALEXI |
09/06/2005 |
09/09/2005 |
|
46312/09 |
FRANGOS |
10/05/2011 |
10/05/2011 |
|
27153/08 |
FTYLAKIS AND OTHERS |
03/02/2001 |
03/02/2001 |
|
8725/08 |
GALANIS |
01/04/2010 |
01/07/2010 |
|
36251/03 |
GALATALIS |
13/07/2006 |
13/10/2006 |
|
38720/05 |
GALIATSOU-KOUTSIKOU AND OTHERS |
24/04/2008 |
24/07/2008 |
|
5077/03 |
GAVALAS |
04/08/2005 |
04/11/2005 |
|
40032/08 |
GEORGIADIS |
10/10/2013 |
10/10/2013 |
|
10691/04 |
GEORGIOU |
01/06/2006 |
01/09/2006 |
|
25324/03 |
GEORGOPOULOS AND OTHERS |
08/12/2005 |
08/03/2006 |
|
30460/06+ |
GEROMANOLIS AND OTHERS |
16/10/2008 |
16/01/2009 |
|
15689/03 |
GIAKOUMELI AND OTHERS |
08/12/2005 |
08/03/2006 |
|
70314/01 |
GIALAMAS |
21/10/2004 |
21/01/2005 |
|
72285/01 |
GIAMAS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
29829/05 |
GIANNETAKI E. & S. METAFORIKI LTD AND GIANNETAKIS |
06/12/2007 |
06/03/2008 |
|
33339/02 |
GIKA AND 9 OTHERS |
17/03/2005 |
17/06/2005 |
|
394/03 |
GIKA AND 5 OTHERS |
30/06/2005 |
30/09/2005 |
|
14173/03 |
GILI AND OTHERS |
08/12/2005 |
08/03/2006 |
|
58572/10 |
GLETSOS |
06/02/2014 |
06/02/2014 |
|
65048/09+ |
GOROS AND OTHERS |
21/05/2015 |
21/05/2015 |
|
62459/09 |
GOUDOUMAS |
02/05/2013 |
02/05/2013 |
|
33367/10 |
GOULIOTI-GIANNOUDI AND OTHERS |
09/01/2014 |
09/01/2014 |
|
72983/01 |
GOUTSIA AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
10525/09 |
GRYPAIOS AND OTHERS |
07/02/2012 |
07/02/2012 |
|
72030/01 |
HADJIDJANIS |
28/04/2005 |
28/07/2005 |
|
40298/08 |
ILIOPOULOS AND OTHERS |
03/02/2001 |
03/02/2001 |
|
29980/08 |
INTERSALONIKA A.E.G.A.Z. |
10/05/2011 |
10/05/2011 |
|
5072/03 |
IOANNIDIS |
04/08/2005 |
04/11/2005 |
|
45823/08 |
IOANNIS ANASTASIADIS AND OTHERS |
18/04/2013 |
18/07/2013 |
|
1953/10 |
IOANNOU AND OTHERS |
12/06/2012 |
12/06/2012 |
|
5973/03 |
KABETSIS |
21/04/2005 |
21/07/2005 |
|
64867/09 |
KAGGOS |
19/07/2011 |
19/07/2011 |
|
38311/02 |
KAKAMOUKAS AND OTHERS |
15/02/2008 |
Grand Chamber |
|
67591/01 |
KALKANIS |
08/07/2004 |
08/10/2004 |
|
33173/02 |
KALLIRI-GIANNIKOPOULOU AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
5179/09 |
KALLITSIS |
13/01/2011 |
13/01/2011 |
|
38688/02 |
KALLITSIS No. 2 |
17/02/2005 |
06/07/2005 |
|
58433/09 |
KARADANIS |
05/04/2011 |
05/04/2011 |
|
6480/06 |
KARAHALIOS No. 7 |
06/12/2007 |
06/03/2008 |
|
7865/06 |
KARAHALIOS No. 8 |
06/12/2007 |
06/03/2008 |
|
41714/08 |
KARDARAS AND OTHERS |
03/02/2001 |
03/02/2001 |
|
6706/02 |
KARELLIS |
02/12/2004 |
02/03/2005 |
|
37420/02 |
KAROBEÏS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
17461/08 |
KAROKIS |
07/01/2010 |
07/04/2010 |
|
21279/03 |
KASKANIOTIS AND OTHERS |
09/06/2005 |
09/09/2005 |
|
35202/10 |
KATSIGIANNIS AND OTHERS |
09/01/2014 |
09/01/2014 |
|
27620/08 |
KLITHROPIIA IPIROU EVVA HELLAS A.E. |
13/01/2011 |
13/04/2011 |
|
46059/09 |
KOKKINATOS |
05/04/2011 |
05/04/2011 |
|
5957/03 |
KOLLIAS |
21/04/2005 |
21/07/2005 |
|
10304/03 |
KOLLOKAS |
30/03/2006 |
30/06/2006 |
|
56814/08 |
KON/NOS CHITZOS SOLINOURGIA ABEE |
19/04/2011 |
19/04/2011 |
|
35812/07 |
KONDYLI AND OTHERS |
02/04/2009 |
02/07/2009 |
|
29529/07 |
KONSTANTINIDOU AND OTHERS UTRES |
02/04/2009 |
02/07/2009 |
|
15001/06 |
KONSTANTINOS LADAS |
21/02/2008 |
07/07/2008 |
|
38463/07 |
KONTOGOURIS |
30/04/2009 |
06/11/2009 |
|
9957/08 |
KOROSIDOU |
10/02/2011 |
10/05/2011 |
|
31259/04 |
KORTESSI |
13/07/2006 |
11/12/2006 |
|
33819/02 |
KOSTI-SPANOPOULOU |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
33191/02 |
KOTSANAS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
5967/03 |
KOUFOGIANNIS |
21/04/2005 |
21/07/2005 |
|
24089/08 |
KOUKOURIS |
16/09/2010 |
16/12/2010 |
|
72289/01 |
KOUREMENOS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
34362/02 |
KOUTROUBAS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
73669/01 |
KOZYRIS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
51382/08 |
KYRIAZIS AND OTHERS |
16/09/2010 |
16/12/2010 |
|
72211/01 |
LAGOUVARDOU-PAPATHEODOROU AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
65430/01 |
LALOUSI-KOTSOVOS |
19/05/2004 |
19/08/2004 |
|
42150/06 |
LAMBADARIDOU |
05/06/2008 |
01/12/2008 |
|
31282/04 |
LAZARIDI |
13/07/2006 |
11/12/2006 |
|
17930/05 |
LEONIDOPOULOS |
31/05/2007 |
12/11/2007 |
|
26279/06 |
LOUKAS |
29/05/2008 |
29/08/2008 |
|
19731/02 |
LOUMIDIS |
04/08/2005 |
04/11/2005 |
|
16106/03 |
MAKEDONOPOULOS |
19/05/2005 |
19/08/2005 |
|
43841/02 |
MAKRIS |
07/04/2005 |
07/07/2005 |
|
25536/04 |
MANTZILA |
04/05/2006 |
04/08/2006 |
|
16630/07 |
MANTZOS AND OTHERS |
02/04/2009 |
02/07/2009 |
|
54837/08 |
MATOU AND OTHERS |
22/07/2010 |
22/10/2010 |
|
18838/10 |
MENTAKOS |
10/04/2014 |
10/04/2014 |
|
21091/07 |
MICHAÏLIDOU AND OTHERS |
12/03/2009 |
12/06/2009 |
|
34358/02 |
MIKROS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
13558/10 |
MINATSIS |
28/05/2014 |
28/05/2014 |
|
16109/03 |
MOÏSIDIS |
19/05/2005 |
19/08/2005 |
|
22029/03 |
NAFPLIOTIS |
02/06/2005 |
02/09/2005 |
|
6711/02 |
NASTOS |
15/07/2004 |
10/11/2004 |
|
50759/10 |
NIAROS |
24/04/2014 |
24/04/2014 |
|
31273/04 |
NIKAS AND NIKA |
13/07/2006 |
11/12/2006 |
|
26907/07 |
NIKITAKI AND OTHERS |
12/03/2009 |
12/06/2009 |
|
21978/03 |
NIKOLOPOULOS |
02/06/2005 |
02/09/2005 |
|
32168/03 |
NIKOPOULOU |
29/09/2005 |
29/12/2005 |
|
36525/05 |
ODEON CINEPLEX A.E. |
18/10/2007 |
18/01/2008 |
|
42589/02 |
OIKONOMIDIS |
17/02/2005 |
17/05/2005 |
|
8694/02 |
PALASKA |
19/05/2004 |
10/11//2004 |
|
3542/09 |
PANILAS AND OTHERS |
10/05/2011 |
10/05/2011 |
|
18700/05 |
PAPADOGEORGOS |
03/05/2007 |
03/08/2007 |
|
53311/08 |
PAPADOPOULOU |
16/09/2010 |
16/12/2010 |
|
33808/02 |
PAPAMICHAÏL AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
39170/06 |
PAPASTEFANOU |
20/03/2008 |
20/06/2008 |
|
2189/05 |
PAPASTERIADES |
31/05/2007 |
31/08/2007 |
|
46064/07 |
PAPATHANASIS |
30/04/2009 |
06/11/2009 |
|
18602/03 |
PATELAKI-SKAMAGGA AND OTHERS |
30/06/2005 |
30/09/2005 |
|
28617/10 |
PATRIKIOS |
13/11/2014 |
13/11/2014 |
|
18582/03 |
PATSOURAKI AND OTHERS |
30/06/2005 |
30/09/2005 |
|
5038/03 |
PLASTARIAS |
21/04/2005 |
21/07/2005 |
|
23032/05 |
POLYCHRONAKOS |
11/10/2007 |
11/01/2008 |
|
35178/05 |
POULITSIDI |
11/10/2007 |
11/01/2008 |
|
624/05 |
PSARAKIS |
26/04/2007 |
26/07/2007 |
|
33518/02 |
REFENE-MICHALOPOULOU AND OTHERS |
17/03/2005 |
17/06/2005 |
|
14165/03 |
RENIERI AND OTHERS |
08/12/2005 |
08/03/2006 |
|
64756/01 |
SADIK AMET AND OTHERS |
03/02/2005 |
03/05/2005 |
|
51408/07 |
SAKKATOS AND OTHERS |
25/11/2010 |
25/11/2010 |
|
48007/09 |
SEÏTANIDIS AND AKTINAKIS |
10/04/2014 |
10/04/2014 |
|
37428/02 |
SELIANITIS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
38330/05 |
SEREMENTIS |
27/03/2008 |
27/06/2008 |
|
32025/06 |
SIAFAKA |
31/07/2008 |
31/10/2008 |
|
23929/08 |
SIAKAPETI AND OTHERS |
13/01/2011 |
13/01/2011 |
|
28743/04 |
SILLAÏDIS |
30/11/2006 |
28/02/2007 |
|
64846/09 |
SITOSILO VOLOU A.E. |
12/06/2012 |
12/06/2012 |
|
5081/03 |
SPYROPOULOS |
04/08/2005 |
04/11/2005 |
|
27806/02 |
STAMATIOS KARAGIANNIS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
41582/08 |
STAMATIS |
13/01/2011 |
13/01/2011 |
|
14127/03 |
STAMOS |
19/05/2005 |
19/08/2005 |
|
34366/02 |
STATHOUDAKI AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
23410/09 |
STELIOS SCHINAS-SPILIOS KAISARIS KOINOPRAXIA |
04/10/2011 |
04/10/2011 |
|
36169/10 |
TASIOULI |
09/01/2014 |
09/01/2014 |
|
42108/02 |
TAVLIKOU-VOSYNIOTI |
09/06/2005 |
09/09/2005 |
|
5453/06 |
TECHTRON E.P.E. |
06/03/2008 |
06/06/2008 |
|
16696/02 |
THEODOROPOULOS AND OTHERS |
15/07/2004 |
15/10/2004 |
|
37429/02 |
THEODOROS ANAGNOSTOPOULOS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
23009/05 |
THOMAS MAKRIS |
21/06/2007 |
12/11/2007 |
|
26021/10 |
TRIANTAFYLLOU |
14/11/2013 |
14/11/2013 |
|
6667/09 |
TSALAPATAS AND OTHERS |
18/10/2011 |
18/10/2011 |
|
9673/03 |
TSAMOU |
21/04/2005 |
21/07/2005 |
|
42320/02 |
TSANTIRIS |
01/12/2005 |
01/03/2006 |
|
5085/03 |
TSARAS |
04/08/2005 |
04/11/2005 |
|
28770/04 |
TSEKOURIDOU |
25/01/2007 |
09/07/2007 |
|
44685/07 |
TSELIKA-SKOURTI |
28/05/2009 |
28/08/2009 |
|
18607/05 |
TSERONIS |
07/02/2008 |
07/05/2008 |
|
13464/04 |
TSIOTRAS |
01/06/2006 |
01/09/2006 |
|
19521/06 |
TYPOPOIITIRIA THIVAS A.E. |
11/12/2008 |
11/03/2009 |
|
17965/03 |
TZAGGARAKI AND OTHERS |
26/01/2006 |
26/04/2006 |
|
66608/09 |
TZIOVARA AND GEMELIARI |
11/04/2013 |
11/04/2013 |
|
72270/01 |
VASILAKI AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
19431/02 |
VAYOPOULOU |
15/07/2004 |
15/10/2004 |
|
17114/07 |
VEGLERIS AND BRATSAS |
02/04/2009 |
02/07/2009 |
|
72267/01 |
VELI-MAKRI AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
65501/01 |
VERGOS |
24/06/2004 |
24/09/2004 |
|
37992/08+ |
VEZYRGIANNIS |
03/07/2012 |
03/07/2012 |
|
27802/02 |
VLASOPOULOS AND OTHERS |
10/02/2005 |
10/05/2005 |
|
28803/07 |
VLASTOS |
16/04/2009 |
16/07/2009 |
|
5076/03 |
VOZINOS |
04/08/2005 |
04/11/2005 |
|
40317/08 |
VRACHLIOTIS AND OTHERS |
03/02/2001 |
03/02/2001 |
|
57628/09 |
X-CODE LYSEIS PLIROFORIKIS A.E. |
14/03/2013 |
14/03/2013 |
|
25998/10 |
XYPOLITAKOS |
05/12/2013 |
05/12/2013 |
|
45481/09 |
ZANNI |
17/04/2012 |
17/04/2012 |
|
32247/10 |
ZIOUTA |
19/06/2014 |
19/06/2014 |
|
77658/01 |
ZISIS |
19/07/2007 |
19/10/2007 |
|
24898/06 |
ZOURDOS AND OTHERS |
05/06/2008 |
01/12/2008 |