Strasbourg, 7 December 2016
CEPEJ(2016)21
europEAN COMMISSION FOR THE EFFICIENCY OF Justice (CEPEJ)
28th plenary meeting (6 – 7 December 2016)
Abridged report
A. FOREWORD
The European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ) held its 26th plenary meeting in Strasbourg on 6 - 7 December 2016. The meeting was chaired by Mr Georg STAWA (Austria), President of the CEPEJ.
The agenda appears in the Appendix.
B. LIST OF ITEMS DISCUSSED AND DECISIONS TAKEN BY THE CEPEJ
The CEPEJ:
§ thanked André POTOCKI, Judge at the European Court of Human Rights in respect of France, for having, at the opening the meeting:
- underlined the close links between the Court and the CEPEJ and the key role of the CEPEJ in facilitating the proper functioning of the Court's mechanisms by being a player as regards subsidiarity,
- recalled the essential work of the CEPEJ in the field of judicial time management and to promote the importance of court users in judicial policies,
- indicated that judges of the Court welcomed the recent evaluation reports on judicial systems as these were valuable tools for the Court's work,
- highlighted the need to improve the situation within judicial systems to ensure the right to an effective remedy as provided for by Article 13 of the European Convention on Human Rights and welcomed the forthcoming publication of the “Good practice guide to improve the functioning of justice”;
§ thanked the French Institut des Hautes Etudes sur la Justice and the Montreal Cyberjustice Laboratory (Canada) for the organisation of the "1st Cyberjustice Conference - Europe" in Strasbourg on 5 December 2016, highlighted the quality of the work and decided to take it into account in the context of its own work to enhance the efficiency and quality of justice through the use of information technology;
§ took note of the information provided by its President, its members and its Secretariat who had participated in various fora where the work of the CEPEJ had been presented and discussed and noted with satisfaction that this concerned 57 events (including cooperation activities) in 23 members States and 3 non-European states in 2016, contributing to the promotion of public policies aimed at ensuring the efficiency and quality of judicial systems;
§ took note of the information provided by Azerbaijan, Bulgaria, Estonia, France, Latvia, Malta, Netherlands, Serbia, Slovenia, Spain, "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia", Ukraine, United Kingdom, on recent developments in the judicial field and invited its members to forward to the Secretariat written information and useful references which could be included in the area "country profiles" of the CEPEJ web site;
§ welcomed the setting up by the Secretariat of the CEPEJ-STAT interactive database, an innovative tool which provides public decision-makers, justice professionals, researchers and, more broadly, the public with the possibility of obtaining valuable and comparable information easily on the functioning of judicial systems; invited its members to ensure a wide communication in their countries around this tool and instructed the Secretariat to promote it inside and outside the Council of Europe, including through video-conferences with member States ;
§ noted with great satisfaction the excellent reception by the Committee of Ministers of the report “European judicial systems – Edition 2016” and the thematic report on “the use of information technology in European courts”, as well as the positive responses received as regards this work in many member States, from policy makers, justice practitioners (see the specific on the tour de table) and the media (see the press review);
§ invited its members to disseminate the reports widely to the competent authorities and judicial professionals of their countries, in particular by facilitating their translation (at least the translation of the overview), where appropriate, and to forward as soon as possible to the Secretariat information on the way the reports are used by the state authorities and any press articles at national level concerning this work;
§ decided to launch the next evaluation process in 2017 on the basis of data of the year 2016, with a view to publishing the results in 2018;
§ adopted for this purpose the revised Evaluation Scheme (CEPEJ(2016)9), taking into account a positive indicative vote to include in the questionnaire a series of questions relating to the use of information technology in courts, and instructed the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL to adapt the explanatory note accordingly;
§ agreed that the electronic Scheme should be opened for reply by national correspondents as from 1 June 2017 until 31 December 2017 and urged the national correspondents to comply with such a timeframe, in order for the data to be processed from January 2018;
stressed that part of the Scheme would also be used within the framework of the cooperation with the European Commission (see below), which implied that, for this part of the Scheme, the national correspondents concerned were urged to respond by 1 October 2017;
§ decided that, in addition to the general report evaluating judicial systems based on key fact and figures, the thematic report for the 2016-2018 evaluation cycle would cover the court users and instructed the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL to prepare the draft reports on the basis of the information collected;
§ agreed that Morocco could be involved in this new evaluation cycle as an Observer to the CEPEJ;
§ welcomed the cooperation with the European Commission on the evaluation of judicial systems and noted that a new Study on judicial systems in the member states of the European Union was being prepared, based on the methodology developed by the CEPEJ, from the 2015 data, aimed at providing information allowing the European Commission to prepare its "EU Justice Scoreboard”; reiterated its full willingness to continue this cooperation in the coming years under the same modalities;
§ agreed that new peer evaluation visits on judicial statistics would take place to the Cyprus, Czech Republic and Georgia in 2017;
§ adopted the document “Measuring the quality of judicial services” (CEPEJ(2016)12) prepared by the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL from the preparatory work of Fabio BARTOLOMEO (CEPEJ member, Italy), which defines the CEPEJ indicators for measuring the quality of justice;
§ adopted the” Guidelines on how to drive changes towards cyberjustice” (CEPEJ(2016)13 prepared by the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL from the preparatory work of Harold EPINEUSE (scientific expert, France);
§ adopted the “Good practice guide to improve the functioning of justice” (CEPEJ(2016)14) prepared by the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL from the preparatory work of Francesco DE SANTIS (scientific expert, Italy), regarding structural measures taken by the member States in addition to the effective remedies required by ECHR Article 13;
§ adopted the updated version of the “Handbook on conducting satisfaction surveys for court users“ (CEPEJ(2016)15) prepared by the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL from the preparatory work of Jean-Paul JEAN and Hélène JORRY (scientific experts, France) and completed by Martial PASQUIER (scientific expert, Switzerland);
§ decided to forward these four documents to the Committee of Ministers in order that it may take note of them, as well as to the relevant Committees and bodies of the Council of Europe in order that they may make use of them when appropriate;
§ reiterated its invitation to the volunteer courts in the member States to indicate to the Secretariat their candidature for organising a coaching programme aimed at organising user satisfaction surveys based on the CEPEJ Handbook and invited its members to signal this opportunity widely to the courts in their countries;
§ adopted the “Implementation Guide: towards European timeframes for judicial proceedings” (CEPEJ(2016)5) prepared by the Steering Group of the SATURN Centre from a preparatory work of Marco FABRI (scientific expert, Italy), containing indicators for court case flow management;
§ took note of the other work carried out by the Steering group of the SATURN Centre according to its strategic action plan;
§ instructed its three working groupsto continue their consultation with a view to preparing a compilation of the definitions used in the work of the CEPEJ;
§ reiterated its invitation to the volunteer courts in the member States to indicate to the Secretariat their candidature for organising a coaching programme within the court aimed at implementing the SATURN tools for judicial time management based on the CEPEJ Guide and invited its members to signal this opportunity widely to the courts in their states;
§ welcomed the progress made in the on-going cooperation programmes, which allow the practical implementation of the methodology and tools of the CEPEJ and thus provide strong added value to the work of the Council of Europe in the beneficiary States and entities, in particular as regards the following programmes:
- Horizontal Facility for Western Balkans – Albania and Kosovo*[1] - Joint programme with the European Union,
- Programmatic Co-operation Framework for the countries of the Eastern partnership - Azerbaijan and Republic of Moldova - Joint programme with the European Union,
- Towards Strengthened Democratic Governance in the Southern Mediterranean – Tunisia, Jordan - Joint programme with the European Union
- Turkey - Developing mediation practices in civil disputes – Co-operation with the Swedish International Cooperation Development Agency (Sida),
- Programme to support the justice sector reform - improving the functioning of justice in Morocco using the tools of CEPEJ - Joint Programme with the European Union;
§ thanked the Croatian authorities for the cooperation developed in the framework of the Programme funded by the EEA/Norway Grants entitled "Improvement of the way cases are handled by the judicial system by applying tried and tested methodologies developed by the CEPEJ", which came successfully to an end on 30 June 2016;
§ agreed to develop specific cooperation for assessing the functioning of the judicial systems in Latvia and Slovakia, as well as a specific cooperation for the development of mediation in Bulgaria, and possibly with Ukraine for court management;
§ thanked the European Union, the EEA/Norway Grants and Sida for their confidence in the CEPEJ’s specific expertise in supporting the reforms of judicial systems towards greater efficiency and quality through the practical implementation of the CEPEJ’s own methodology and tools, and reiterated its willingness to cooperate with its member States and other partner States and entities to support the development of the public service of justice in Europe and beyond;
§ recalled that the implementation of these numerous programmes by the CEPEJ requires the availability of members and experts of the CEPEJ and called upon its members and experts to inform the Secretariat of their willingness to participate in such programmes;
§ thanked the Supreme Court of Murcia (Spain) for presenting the project "Judicial Excellency and 2015-2020 strategic programme" as a good practice aimed at improving the efficiency and quality of the public service of justice, deserving of being shared with a wider public at European level and beyond;
§ instructed the Secretariatto develop, in particular in electronic form, the CEPEJ Innovation Centre as a virtual place bringing together good practices as regards court organisation and to implement activities of research of good practices at the European level;
§ welcomed the 2016 Report by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe on the "State of democracy, human rights and the rule of law – a security imperative for Europe"; noted with satisfaction that the Secretary General had requested the relevant bodies to "develop the methodology and establish a regular in-house evaluation mechanism on the independence and impartiality of the judiciaries of the Council of Europe member states”, reiterated its readiness to be involved in the implementation of the Council of Europe Plan of Action on strengthening judicial independence and impartiality;
§ took note of the information provided on the activities of the Consultative Council of European Judges (CCJE), the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (CCPE), and as regards cooperation with the European Court of Human Rights;
§ took note of the information provided by the representatives of Slovakia and Malta, speaking on behalf of the outgoing and incoming presidencies of the European Union, on the recent and planned developments within the Union in the field of justice;
§ thanked the authorities of Serbia for having organised the main event of the 2016 European Day of Justice in Belgrade, as well as the judicial authorities in 19 member States which organised specific events within the framework of this Day; invited its members to promote initiatives for the 2017 edition and candidatures for organising the main event;
§ invited its members to promote candidacies for the next edition of the “Crystal Scales of Justice” in 2017;
§ took noteof the information provided by its Observers, and in particular the OECD, the European Union of Rechtspfleger (EUR) which introduced its White Paper, the International Union of bailiffs and judicial officers (UIHJ), the European Association of Judges (EAJ), the European Judicial Training Network (EJTN), thanked them for their concrete contribution to the CEPEJ’s activities and invitedthem to contribute further to the implementation of its Activity Programme;
§ entrusted its members and the Secretariat to update the composition of the CEPEJ Network of pilot courts and thanked the pilot court of Arnhem for its invitation to organise the 2017 plenary meeting of the Network in the Netherlands;
§ recalled the invitation for its member States to appoint substitute? members to the CEPEJ;
§ invited the member States, through the CEPEJ members to propose to the Secretariat by 15 January 2017 qualified experts to participate in the CPEJ Working Group on mediation (CEPEJ-GT-MED) and entrusted its Bureau to appoint members of this group, taking into account these proposals;
§ encouraged its members to join the CEPEJ on Facebook;
§ re-elected for a two year period Georg STAWA (Austria) as President of the CEPEJ, Ramin GURBANOV (Azerbaijan) as Vice-President of the CEPEJ, Ivana BORZOVA (Czech Republic) and Noel RUBOTHAM (Ireland) as members of the Bureau;
§ took note of the draft calendar for the CEPEJ meetings in 2017, including the plenary meetings which may take place on 29 - 30 June and 7 - 8 December.
APPENDIX I
AGENDA
André POTOCKI, Judge at the European Court of Human Rights in respect of France, former Vice-President of the CEPEJ
Rapporteur: Jean-Paul JEAN (France), Chair of the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL
i. Training session on the use of the dynamic database CEPEJ-STAT
ii. Impact of the reports and the CEPEJ-STAT data base resulting from the 2014-2016 evaluation cycle
iii. Implementation of the 2016 - 2018 evaluation cycle
a. amendment of the evaluation scheme
b. selection of the issue to be addressed within the framework of the 2018 thematic report
c. calendar
iv. Co-operation with the European Union within the framework of the “Justice Scoreboard”
v. Implementation of the pilot peer evaluation co-operation process
Rapporteur: François PAYCHĖRE (Switzerland), Chair of the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL
i. Discussion, with a view to their adoption, of the draft indicators for measuring the quality of justice
ii. Discussion, with a view to their adoption, of the draft Guidelines on how to drive changes towards cyberjustice
iii. Discussion, with a view to its adoption, of the draft Good practice guide adopted by some Council of Europe member states to improve the functioning of justice
iv. Update of the Handbook on conducting satisfaction surveys for court users (CEPEJ(2010)1)
Rapporteur: Jacques BÜHLER (Switzerland), Chair of the Steering group of the SATURN Centre
i. Discussion, with a view to their adoption, of the draft Implementation Guide: towards European timeframes for judicial proceedings
ii. Plenary meeting of the network of Pilot courts, Strasbourg, 21 September 2016
iii. Other work of the CEPEJ-SATURN, including the current work on common definitions
i. State of affairs on some programmes
- Horizontal Facility for South-eastern Europe – Albania and Kosovo[2] - Joint programme with the European Union
- Programmatic Co-operation Framework for the countries of the Eastern partnership - Azerbaijan and Republic of Moldova - Joint programme with the European Union
- Cooperation Programme between Croatia and the CEPEJ funded by Norway Grants:"Improvement of the way cases are handled by the judicial system by applying tried and tested methodologies developed by the CEPEJ"
ii. Other on-going and future programmes
- Towards Strengthened Democratic Governance in the Southern Mediterranean – Tunisia, Jordan, Palestine - Joint programme with the European Union
- Turkey - Developing mediation practices in civil disputes – Co-operation with the Swedish International Cooperation Development Agency (Sida)
- Programme to support the justice sector reform - improving the functioning of justice in Morocco using the tools of CEPEJ - Joint programme with the European Union
- Assessment of the functioning of the judicial system in Latvia
- Assessment of the functioning of the judicial system in Slovakia
The CEPEJ members are invited to examine the progress in the co-operation programmes (see the document mentioned below). The CEPEJ members acting as experts involved in these programmes, as well as the Secretariat, are prepared to answer any questions that may be put to them during the meeting.
i. Consultative Council of European Judges (CCJE)
ii. Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (CCPE)
iii. European Committee on Legal Co-operation (CDCJ)
iv. Steering Committee on Crime Problems (CDPC)
Rapporteurs: Ladislav DUDITS (Slovakia) and Francesco DEPASQUALE (Malta) on behalf of the outgoing and incoming presidency of the European Union
· Introduction to the White paper of the European Union of Rechtspfleger (EUR) for a Greffier / Rechtspfleger for Europe
i. Updating of the Network of pilot courts
ii. Deputy members of the CEPEJ
iii. CEPEJ experts involved in cooperation programmes
iv. CEPEJ-GT-MED (Working group on mediation)
APPENDIX II
List of participants / Liste des participants
CEPEJ MEMBERS / MEMBRES DE LA CEPEJ
7 December /décembre 2016
EUROPEAN COMMISSION FOR THE EFFICIENCY OF JUSTICE
COMMISSION EUROPEENNE POUR L’EFFICACITE DE LA JUSTICE
(CEPEJ)
28thplenary meeting / 28ème réunion plénière
Strasbourg, 6 December /décembre - 7 December/décembre 2016
Room / Salle 9
Palais de l’Europe
List of participants / Liste des participants
CEPEJ MEMBERS / MEMBRES DE LA CEPEJ
ALBANIA/ALBANIE
Entela DOBI, Judicial Inspector, Ministry of Justice,TIRANA
ANDORRA/ANDORRE
ARMENIA/ARMENIE
Vigen KOCHARYAN, Vice-ministre de la Justice, Ministère de la Justice, EREVAN : Apologised / excusé
AUSTRIA/AUTRICHE
Georg STAWA, Head of Department “III 8 - Objectives and Effects, Consulting and Information Management", Federal Ministry of Justice, VIENNA, (President of the CEPEJ /Président de la CEPEJ)
AZERBAIJAN/AZERBAÏDJAN
Ramin GURBANOV, Judge, Baku City Yasamal District Court, Co-ordinator of Judicial Modernisation Project, BAKU
BELGIUM/BELGIQUE
Dietger GEERAERT, Attaché, Service Public Fédéral, Justice, BRUXELLES, Apologised / Excusé
BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA/BOSNIE-HERZÉGOVINE
Dragomir VUKOJE, Judge of the Appellate Division of the Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina, SARAJEVO
Rusmir ŠABETA, responsable du Departement d'administration judiciaire du Secrétariat du Conseil supérieur de la magistrature de Bosnie-Herzègovine, SARAJEVO
BULGARIA/BULGARIE
Ekaterina TODOROVA, Senior Expert, International Legal Co-operation and European Affairs Directorate, Ministry of Justice, SOFIA
CROATIA/CROATIE
Ivan CRNČEC, assistant Minister, International Co-operation Directorate, Ministry of justice, ZAGREB
CYPRUS / CHYPRE
Costas PAMBALLIS, Judge at the Supreme Court, NICOSIA
CZECH REPUBLIC/REPUBLIQUE TCHEQUE
Ivana BORZOVÁ, Head of Department of Civil Supervision, Ministry of Justice , PRAGUE
DENMARK/DANEMARK
Marianne GRAM NYBROE, International Coordinator, Department of Training, Danish Court Administration, COPENHAGEN
ESTONIA/ESTONIE
Kaidi LIPPUS, Head of divisjon, Courts divison, Judicial Administration Policy Department, Ministry of Justice, TALLINN
FINLAND/FINLANDE
Kari Samuli KIESILĀINEN, Head of Department, Directorate General, Ministry of Justice, HELSINKI
FRANCE
Laetitia BRUNIN, Adjointe à la sous-directrice de la statistique et des études, Secrétariat général, Ministère de la justice, PARIS
GEORGIA/GÉORGIE
Nino BAKAKURI, Judge, Supreme Court, TBILISSI
GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE
Matthias HEGER, Chef du Service de Procédure civile internationale, Ministère fédéral de la justice, BERLIN
Jörg ALLMENDINGER, Ministerialrat, Leiter des Referats V 2, EJN-contact point for Baden-Württemberg, Department for European Law and International Law, Ministry of Justice and for European Affairs of Baden-Württemberg, STUTTGART
GREECE/GRÈCE
Michael PIKRAMENOS, Councilor of State, and As. Professor of Law School at University of Thessaloniki, ATHENS
HUNGARY/HONGRIE
Gábor SZÉPLAKI-NAGY,Procureur, Chef d’unité, Parquet Général, Ministère de la justice, BUDAPEST
ICELAND/ISLANDE
Arnfrídur EINARSDOTTIR, Judge at the District Court of Reykjavik, District Court of Reykjavik, REYKJAVÍK
IRELAND/IRLANDE
Noel RUBOTHAM, Head of Reform and Development, Courts Service, DUBLIN
Nicola KELLY, Courts Policy Division, Department of Justice and Equality, DUBLIN: Apologised / Excusée
ITALY/ITALIE
Fabio BARTOLOMEO, Directeur général des statistiques, Ministère de la Justice, ROME
LATVIA/LETTONIE
Aija BRANTA, Judge, Supreme Court, RIGA
LITHUANIA/LITUANIE
Laima GARNELIENE, Judge, Criminal Cases Division, Lithuanian Court of Appeal, VILNIUS
LUXEMBOURG
Robert BIEVER, Procureur Général d’Etat honoraire, Ministère de la justice, LUXEMBOURG-KIRCHENBERG
MALTA/MALTE
Francesco DEPASQUALE, Magistrate, Magistrates' Chambers, The Law Courts, VALETTA
Joanne BATTISTINO, Research and Special Projects Officer, Office of the Director General, Strategy & Support, Ministry For Justice, Culture and Local Government, VALLETTA
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA/REPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA
Ruxanda REVENCU, Chef Adjoint de la Direction Générale Agent Gouvernemental, Chef de la Direction représentation devant la Cour Européenne des Droits de l’Homme du Ministère de la Justice, CHISINAU : Apologised / Excusée
MONACO
Sébastien BIANCHERI, Premier juge au tribunal de première instance, MONACO
MONTENEGRO
Tijana BADNJAR, Legal Advisor, Department for Judiciary Directorate for Civil Legislation Ministry of Justice, PODGORICA
NETHERLANDS/PAYS‑BAS
Frans VAN DER DOELEN, Programme Manager of the Department of the Justice System, Ministry of Justice, THE HAGUE
Eliane EIJNWACHTER, Ministry of Justice, THE HAGUE
NORWAY/NORVÈGE
Audun BERG, Senior Advisor, The National Courts Administration, OSLO, Apologised / Excusé
Sophie Elisa POPPE, Senior Adviser, Civil Affairs Department, Ministry of Justice and Public Security, OSLO
POLAND/POLOGNE
Michał DĄBROWSKI, Judge, main expert in the Department of Courts, Organisation and Judicial Analyses, WARSAW
PORTUGAL
João ARSENIO DE OLIVEIRA, Head of Department International Affairs Department, Directorate General for Justice Policy, Ministry of Justice, LISBON, Apologised / Excusé
Sara NUNES DE ALMEIDA, Head of unit, Civil Justice, Citizenship and International Litigation Unit, Directorate General for Justice Policy, International Affairs Department, Ministry of Justice, LISBON
ROMANIA/ROUMANIE
Violeta BELEGANTE, Conseiller juridique, Chef du service du droit privé, Direction de l'Elaboration des actes normatifs, des études et de la documentation, Ministère de la Justice, BUCAREST
THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION/FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE
Alexandra KRIVOSHEEVA, deputy head of the Notariat Division of the Department of Legal Assistance and Cooperation with the Judiciary of the Ministry of Justice, MOSCOW: Apologised / Excusée
Alexey TROFIMENKOV, Third Secretary, Legal Department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, MOSCOW
Anton MARKOVSKIY– Deputy to the Permanent Representative of the Russian Federation to the Council of Europe, STRASBOURG, FRANCE
SERBIA/SERBIE
Ivana NINČIĆ, National Correspondent to the CEPEJ, Ministry of Justice, BELGRADE
SLOVAK REPUBLIC/RÉPUBLIQUE SLOVAQUE
Ladislav DUDITS, Judge, Kosice Regional Court, KOSICE
SLOVENIA /SLOVENIE
Tina BRECELJ, State Secretary, Ministry of Justice, LJUBLJANA
SPAIN/ESPAGNE
Juan Fernando ARMENGOT IBORRA, Advisor, Directorate General for international Legal Co-operation and Relations with Religious Affairs, Ministry of Justice, MADRID
SWEDEN/SUÈDE
Jenny LINDESTAM, Legal Advisor, Legal departement, The Swedish National Courts Administration, JÖNKÔPING, Apologised / Excusée
SWITZERLAND/SUISSE
Jacques BÜHLER, Secrétaire Général suppléant, Tribunal fédéral suisse, LAUSANNE
"THE FORMER YOUGOSLAV REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA"/"L'EX-RÉPUBLIQUE YOUGOSLAVE DE MACÉDOINE"
Nikola PROKOPENKO, Head of Department of Courts, Public Prosecutors and other Judicial institutions, Ministry of Justice, SKOPJE
TURKEY/TURQUIE
Ibrahim ÇETIN, Judge, Head of department, Directorate General for Strategy Development, Ministry of Justice, ANKARA
Sumru OKAYER, Rapporteur Judge, Directorate of Strategy Development, Ministry of Justice, ANKARA
UKRAINE
Polina KAZAKEVYCH, Head of International Department of the High Qualification Commission of Judges of Ukraine, KYIV
UNITED KINGDOM/ROYAUME‑UNI
Robert WRIGHT, Civil Litigation Funding and Costs, Access to Justice, Ministry of Justice, LONDON
***
***
Jean-Paul JEAN, Président de chambre, Directeur du service de documentation, des études et du rapport, Chef du service des relations internationales, Cour de cassation, PARIS, FRANCE (Chair of the GT-EVAL / Président du GT-EVAL)
François PAYCHÈRE, Magistrat titulaire de la Cour des Comptes de la République et du Canton de Genève, GENEVE, SUISSE (Chair of the GT-QUAL / Président du GT-QUAL)
SCIENTIFIC EXPERT / EXPERT SCIENTIFIQUE
Marco FABRI, Director, Research Institute on Judicial Systems, National Research Council (IRSIG-CNR), BOLOGNA, ITALY
OBSERVER STATES TO THE CEPEJ / ÉTATS OBSERVATEURSAUPRES DE LA CEPEJ
ISRAEL / ISRAËL
Gali AVIV, Director of the Israeli Courts Research Division, The Supreme Court of Israel, JERUSALEM
Shanee BENKIN, Researcher, Israeli Courts Research Division, The Supreme Court of Israel, JERUSALEM
JAPAN / JAPON
Shun KITAGAWA, Consul, Consulate-General of Japan, STRASBOURG, FRANCE
MOROCCO / MAROC
Abderrafi EROUIHANE, Directeur des études de la coopération et de la modernisation, Ministère de la justice et des libertés, RABAT
Abdelkader LOTFI, Président du tribunal de première instance de Marrakech, MARRAKECH
TUNISIA / TUNISIE
Raja BOUSSEMA, chargée de la coopération internationale, Asie, Amérique, Union Européenne et Conseil de l’Europe, Cabinet du ministère de la justice, chargée de mission Coopération, TUNIS
Radhia BEN AISSA, Vice-présidente, tribunal de première instance de Zaghouan, ZAGHOUAN
OBSERVERS / OBSERVATEURS
HAGUE CONFERENCE ON PRIVATE INTERNATIONAL LAW/ / CONFERENCE DE LA HAYE DE DROIT INTERNATIONAL PRIVE : Apologised / Excusée
WORLD BANK / BANQUE MONDIALE
Georgia HARLEY, Public Sector Specialist, Governance Global Practice, WASHINGTON, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT (OECD) / ORGANISATION POUR LA COOPERATION ET LE DEVELOPPEMENT ECONOMIQUE (OCDE)
Tatyana TEPLOVA,2 rue André Pascal, 75775 PARIS, FRANCE
COUNCIL OF THE BARS AND LAW SOCIETIES OF THE EUROPEAN UNION / CONSEIL DES BARREAUX EUROPÉENS (CCBE)
Michel BENICHOU, President, BRUXELLES, BELGIQUE
Simone CUOMO, Senior Legal Advisor, BRUSSELS, BELGIUM
EUROPEAN UNION OF RECHTSPFLEGER AND COURT CLERKS / UNION EUROPÉENNE DES GREFFIERS DE JUSTICE (EUR)
Angélique FEHER, Greffier, Tribunal de Grande Instance, CHARLEVILLE-MEZIERES, FRANCE
Jean-Jacques KUSTER, Président de l’EUR, Greffier en Chef, Tribunal d’Instance, STRASBOURG, FRANCE
Vivien WHYTE, Représentant de l'EUR, Directeur stagiaire des services de greffe judiciaires, Ecole Nationale des Greffes, DIJON, FRANCE
INTERNATIONAL UNION OF BAILIFFS / UNION INTERNATIONALE DES HUISSIERS DE JUSTICE ET OFFICIERS JUDICIAIRES (UIHJ)
Sue COLLINS, Vice-présidente de l’UIHJ, PARIS, FRANCE
Mathieu CHARDON, Huissier de justice, Secrétaire Général de l’UIHJ, PARIS, FRANCE
MAGISTRATS EUROPÉENS POUR LA DÉMOCRATIE ET LES LIBERTÉS (MEDEL)
ASSOCIATION OF EUROPEAN ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGES (AEAJ) / FÉDÉRATION EUROPÉENNE DES JUGES ADMINISTRATIFS (FEJA)
Pierre VINCENT, Président maintenu en activité près le tribunal administratif, Cour d’Appel administrative de Nancy, NANCY, FRANCE
EUROPEAN ASSOCIATION OF JUDGES / Association européenne des MAGISTRATS (EAJ)
Virginie DUVAL, Présidente de l’Union Syndicale des magistrats, PARIS, FRANCE
Gerhard REISSNER, Vice-President of the Austrian Association of Judges, President of the District Court of Floridsdorf, VIENNA, AUSTRIA
EUROPEAN JUDICIAL TRAINING NETWORK (EJTN) / RESEAU EUROPEEN DE FORMATION JUDICIAIRE(REFJ)
Wojciech POSTULSKI, Secrétaire Général, BRUXELLES, BELGIQUE
EUROPEAN NETWORK OF COUNCILS FOR THE JUDICIARY (ENCJ) / RESEAU EUROPEEN DES CONSEILS DE LA JUSTICE (RECJ)
Monique VAN DER GOES, Director of the ENCJ Office, BRUSSELS, BELGIUM
COUNCIL OF THE NOTARIAT OF THE EUROPEAN UNION (CNUE) /CONSEIL DES NOTARIATS DE L’UNION EUROPEENNE (CNUE)
Geertjan SARNEEL, Meijling & Sarneel Notarissen en Adviseurs, BRUXELLES, BELGIQUE
EUROPEAN EXPERTISE AND EUROPEAN INSTITUTE (EEEI) / INSTITUT EUROPEEN DE L’EXPERTISE ET DE L’EXPERT (EEEI) : Apologised / Excusé
***
EUROPEAN UNION / UNION EUROPÉENNE
european CommisSion / Commission européenne
Ingo WEUSTENFELD, Policy officer, Directorate General Justice and Consumers, Unit 03 - General justice policies and judicial systems, BRUSSELS, BELGIUM
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION / CONSEIL DE L’UNION EUROPEENNE
EUROPEAN UNION AGENCY FOR FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS / AGENCE DE L’UNION EUROPEENNE POUR LES DROITS FONDAMENTAUX : Apologised / Excusée
COMMITTEE ON CIVIL LIBERTIES, JUSTICE AND HOME AFFAIRS (LIBE) / COMMISSION DES LIBERTES CIVILES, DE LA JUSTICE ET DES AFFAIRES INTERIEURES DU PARLEMENT EUROPEEN (LIBE)
***
COUNCIL OF EUROPE / CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE
EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS (ECHR) / COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME (CEDH)
Paola TONARELLI-LACORE, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights / Greffe de la Cour européenne des droits de l’Homme, STRASBOURG, FRANCE
CONSULTATIVE COUNCIL OF EUROPEAN JUDGES / CONSEIL CONSULTATIF DE JUGES EUROPEENS (CCJE)
Nina BETETTO, Judge, Vice-President of the Supreme Court, LJUBLJANA, SLOVENIA
CONSULTATIVE COUNCIL OF EUROPEAN PROSECUTORS / Conseil consultatif de procureurs européens (CCPE)
Cédric VISART de BOCARME, Président du CCPE, Directeur du service d’appui commun auprès du Collège des procureurs généraux et du Collège du ministère public, BRUXELLES, BELGIQUE
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR CRIME PROBLEMS / COMITE EUROPEEN POUR LES PROBLÈMES CRIMINELS (CDPC)
***
SECRETARIAT
DGI – Human Rights and Rule of Law – Division for the Independence and Efficiency of Justice /
DGI - Droits de l’Homme et Etat de droit – Division pour l’indépendance et l’efficacité de la justice
Fax: +33 3 88 41 37 43
E-mail: [email protected]
Hanne JUNCHER, Head of the Justice and Legal Co-operation Department / Service de la coopération judiciaire et juridique
Stéphane LEYENBERGER, Secretary of the CEPEJ / Secrétaire de la CEPEJ
Clementina BARBARO, Administrator / Administratrice
Lidija NAUMOVSKA, Statistician Administrator /Administratrice statisticienne
Yannick MENECEUR, Special Advisor to the Secretariat of the CEPEJ / Conseiller spécial auprès du Secrétariat de la CEPEJ
Christel SCHURRER, Administrator / Administratrice
Félicie DIARD-DETOEUF, Principal Administrative Assistant / Assistante administrative principale
Solène VISART DE BOCARME, Principal Administrative assistant / Assistante administrative principale
Annette SATTEL, Administration and Networks / Administration et Réseaux
Elisabeth HEURTEBISE, Assistant / Assistante
Emily WALKER, Assistant / Assistante
Blerina BULICA, Trainee / Stagiaire
CEPEJ Co-operation programmes / Programmes de coopération de la CEPEJ
Muriel ISELI, Jordan, Tunisia / Jordanie, Tunisie
Leonid ANTOHI, Azaerbaijan, République de Moldova / Azerbaïdjan, République de Moldova
Micol EMINENTE, Morocco / Maroc
Clémence BOUQUEMONT, CEPEJ Co-operation Unit /Unité de coopération de CEPEJ |
Suzana FRASHERI, Albania / Albanie
Stéphanie BUREL, Albania, Kosovo* / Albanie, Kosovo*
Paul MEYER, Croatia, Turkey / Croatie, Turquie
Njomza CARKAXHIU-NUSHI, Kosovo*
Gentjana TELO, Albania / Albanie
Hamza KARMOUN, Morocco / Maroc
INTERPRETERS / INTERPRÈTES
Chloé CHENETIER
Nicolas GUITTONNEAU
Pascale MICHLIN
Kolia ILIN
Alexei MILKO
* All reference to Kosovo, whether the territory, institutions or population, in this text shall be understood in full compliance with United Nations Security Council Resolution 1244 and without prejudice to the status of Kosovo /
* Toute référence au Kosovo dans ce texte, qu'il s'agisse du territoire, des institutions ou la population, doit se comprendre en pleine conformité avec la Résolution 1244 du Conseil de sécurité des Nations Unies et sans préjudice du statut du Kosovo
[1] * All references to Kosovo, whether the territory, institutions or population, in this text shall be understood in full compliance with United Nation's Security Council Resolution 1244 and without prejudice to the status of Kosovo.
[2] All references to Kosovo, whether the territory, institutions or population, in this text shall be understood in full compliance with United Nation's Security Council Resolution 1244 and without prejudice to the status of Kosovo.