Strasbourg, 7 December 2012
CEPEJ(2012)15
européAN COMMISSION FOR THE EFFICIENCY OF Justice (CEPEJ)
20th plenary meeting (6 – 7 December 2012)
Abridged report
A. FOREWORD
The European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ) held its 20th plenary meeting in Strasbourg on 6 – 7 December 2012. The meeting was chaired by Mr John STACEY (United Kingdom).
The agenda appears in Appendix.
B. LIST OF ITEMS DISCUSSED AND DECISIONS TAKEN BY THE CEPEJ
The CEPEJ:
1. Celebration of the 10th anniversary of the CEPEJ
§ warmly thanked the Deputy Secretary General of the Council of Europe, the President of the Ministers’ Delegates, the President of the European Court of Human Rights, the Commissioner for Human Rights, as well as the ambassadors and justice professionals who had kindly accepted to participate in its special session to mark its 10th anniversary;
§ entrusted its Bureau to duly take into account the discussions and proposals made during this session when drawing up the next activity programmes;
§ instructed the Secretariat to report publicly on these discussions, in particular through its web site;
2. Information by the President of the CEPEJ and the Secretariat
§ took note of the information given by its President, its members and its Secretariat who had participated in various fora where the work of the CEPEJ was presented and discussed; welcomed the active participation of CEPEJ in 2012 in 31 fora (in 20 states) dealing with issues of direct relevance to the functioning of justice;
3. Evaluating of the judicial systems
§ noted with great satisfactionthe excellent welcome by the Committee of Ministers of the Report, as well as the positive responses received as regards this Report in many member states, from policy makers, justice practitioners and the media;
§ invited its members to disseminate the Report to the competent authorities and judicial professionals of their country, in particular by facilitating its translation, where appropriate, and to forward as soon as possible to the Secretariat information on the way the Report is used by the state authorities and any press articles, written on a national level, that concern the Report;
§ instructed the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL to launch calls to external researchers for projects that might benefit from a CEPEJ label on the basis of a specific protocol and to manage this process, under the authority of the Bureau, while ensuring proper coordination with the other working groups;
§ entrusted the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL, where appropriate in cooperation with the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL, to further work on the role of the judicial systems in the current economic environment and to study “how to spend better” the budgetary means made available to the judicial systems;
§ decided to launch the next evaluation process in 2013 on the basis of data of the year 2012, with a view to publishing a new evaluation report during 2014;
§ adopted the revised version of the Evaluation Scheme (CEPEJ(2012)12) and its subsequent explanatory note (CEPEJ(2012)13), subject to possible changes to be proposed by the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL following the discussions during this meeting; the CEPEJ members will be invited to give their final approval through a written procedure before 1 May 2013;
agreed that the electronic Scheme should be opened for reply by national correspondents as from 15 May 2013 until 31 December 2013 and urged the national correspondents to comply with such a timeframe, in order for the data to be processed from January 2014;
instructed the Secretariat to bring the necessary improvements to the electronic version of the questionnaire and to organise appropriate modalities for the implementation of this new assessment cycle;
§ invited the Committee of Ministers to grant the CEPEJ appropriate means, in particular a permanent statistician, to enable this evaluation cycle to rely on proper expertise in matters of statistical data processing and analysis, and noted that such a scientific expertise could also guarantee statistical analysis within the framework of the SATURN Centre if this expertise was provided on a permanent basis;
§ agreed to pursue the cycle of peer evaluation visits on judicial statistics in 2013, took note of the interest expressed by Belgium, Estonia, Latvia,Lithuania and the United Kingdom and invited them to confirm this possibility to the Secretariat at the beginning of 2013;
§ confirmed its willingness to cooperate with OECD as regards the evaluation of the functioning of judicial systems;
§ instructed the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL, under the authority of the Bureau, to propose appropriate modalities for cooperation with non-member states of the Council of Europe;
4. Report for the European Commission on the impact of the functioning of judicial systems on the economy
§ took note of the report prepared by the experts appointed by the Bureau of the CEPEJ on “The functioning of judicial systems and the situation of the economy in the European Union member states” and entrusted the experts to further work on the executive summary of this report;
§ confirmed its willingness to further cooperate with the bodies of the European Union to evaluate the functioning of judicial systems, according to modalities to be clearly defined to ensure the proper implementation of the CEPEJ’s principles and methodology;
5. Report prepared by the CCBE on the role of lawyers in judicial proceedings
§ warmly thanked the CCBE, the Université Libre of Brussels and the scientific expert Isabelle ANDOULSI for the report on “The role of lawyers in judicial proceedings in Europe” and instructed the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL and the Secretariat to organise its publication on the CEPEJ’s web site as a public working document;
6. CEPEJ cooperation programmes
§ welcomed the on-going Joint Programmes with the European Union carried out by the CEPEJ for evaluating and supporting the reform of the judicial systems in Morocco and Tunisia, and possibly soon in Jordan, on the basis of the CEPEJ tools and methodology; in this framework, welcomed the active participation of the delegations from Morocco and Tunisia in its work and expressed the wish to find by the beginning of the year 2013 an agreement with the authorities on concrete activities to be implemented within the Moroccan and Tunisian courts to improve the efficiency and quality of their operation;
§ welcomed the report prepared by the experts of the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL on "the efficiency of justice"within the Joint Programme with theEuropean Union forthe Eastern Partnership countries(Armenia, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Moldova, Ukraine), based on the report "European judicial systems - Edition 2012", and highlighted the excellent synergies developed between its intergovernmental work andthe direct andin-depth use of this work to support judicial reforms in several member states;
7. Quality of justice
§ took note of the on-going work of the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL as regards the organisation of judicial maps, the role of judicial experts and the organisation of court premises; instructed the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL and the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL to work together on the definition of indicators for the quality of justice;
§ reiterated its invitation to the volunteer courts in the member states to indicate to the Secretariat their candidature for organising a coaching programme aimed at organising user satisfaction surveys based on the CEPEJ Handbook and invited its members to inform widely the courts in their states of this opportunity;
8. Judicial time management
§ took note of the work carried out by the Steering group of the SATURN Centre, in particular in order to facilitate the concrete use of the Guidelines on judicial time management, and instructed it to pursue its work according to its strategic action plan; encouraged in particular the member states to indicate to the Secretariat elements regarding best practices of judicial time management to complement and update the existing documents;
§ approved the revised version of the report on “Length of court proceedings in the member states of the Council of Europe based on the case law of the European Court of Human Rights” prepared by the scientific experts Françoise CALVEZ and Nicolas RÉGIS (CEPEJ(2012)16) and decided to publish it in the Series of the “CEPEJ Studies”;
§ reiterated its invitation to the volunteer courts in the member states to indicate to the Secretariat their candidature for organising within the court a coaching programme aimed at implementing the SATURN tools for judicial time management based on the CEPEJ Guide and invited its members to inform widely the courts in their states of this opportunity;
9. CEPEJ Network of Pilot Courts
§ warmly thanked the authorities of Malta for having invited the Network of pilot courts to meet in Gozo on 27 September and welcomed the efficient contribution of the pilot courts to the implementation of the CEPEJ activity programme, in particular on lengths of proceedings and on the quality of justice;
10. Targeted cooperation with the member states
§ invited the member states which would like to benefit from the cooperation of the CEPEJ to forward their proposals to the Secretariat, so that they can be considered by the Bureau, subject to the available budget;
11. Other cooperation with the European Union
§ took note of the information given by the representatives Cyprus and Ireland, speaking on behalf of the outgoing and incoming presidencies of the European Union, on the recent and foreseen developments within the Union in the field of justice;
§ thanked the Lithuanian authorities for having organised the 2012 main event of the European Day of Justice in Vilnius around the issue of judicial mediation, including an interesting film festival on mediation, as well as the judicial authorities in 13 member states which organised specific events within the framework of this Day;
§ welcomed the success of the European Prize: "the Crystal Scales of Justice" and congratulated the winner: the Regional Court of Antwerp (Belgium), for its initiative for the follow-up of judicial expertises, as well as the three institutions which were granted a special mention by the jury: the Regional Court of Tarascon (France) for “The co-hearing of the judge in family affairs – Auditor of children”; the Supreme Court of Slovenia for the “Judicial data warehouse and performance dashboards” and the General Secretariat of justice administration (Spain) for the project “Lexnet”;
invited its members to promote candidacies for the next edition of the "Crystal Scales of Justice";
12. Gender issues within CEPEJ activity
§ took note of the oral report by its special rapporteur for gender issues in the activities of the CEPEJ, Gábor SZÉPLAKI-NAGY (Hungary), and entrusted its Bureau and working groups to remain particularly attentive to this issue in the implementation of the activity programme;
13. Election of the Bureau
§ re-elected for a two year period John STACEY (United Kingdom) as President of the CEPEJ, Georg STAWA (Austria) as Vice-President of the CEPEJ, and Irakli ADEISHVILI (Georgia) and Audun BERG (Norway), as members of the Bureau.
APPENDIX I
AGENDA
6 December 2012 - Celebration of the 10th anniversary of the CEPEJ
“The CEPEJ: 10 years of concrete action for improving
the efficiency and quality of the functioning of courts, for the sake of users”
Chairperson: Mr John STACEY, President of the CEPEJ
9.00 |
Opening of the meeting § Gabriella BATTAINI-DRAGONI, Deputy Secretary General of the Council of Europe § Ambassador Josep DALLERÈS, Permanent Representative of Andorra, Chairperson of the Deputies § Dean SPIELMANN, President of the European Court of Human Rights § Nils MUIŽNIEKS, Commissioner for Human Rights § John STACEY, President of the CEPEJ |
9.30 |
10 years of concrete tools aimed at policy makers and justice professionals § The CEPEJ evaluation cycles of European judicial systems: a tool of public policy for orienting reforms of the judicial system Jean-Paul JEAN, Avocat Général, Court of Cassation and associated Professor at the University of Poitiers, France, Chairman of the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL § Tour de table: how has the CEPEJ Report “European judicial system – Edition 2012” been received and used in the member States? All delegations are invited to inform the CEPEJ of actions taken in their countries to disseminate the CEPEJ’s Report and, where appropriate, of the use made of the Report by political and judicial authorities. Discussion |
10.30 – 11.00 |
Break |
11.00 |
§ The CEPEJ court coaching programme on SATURN tools for improving judicial time management: establishing a comprehensive court project Bettina COEN, Judge at the Court of Fribourg, Germany § How can a court clerk use the CEPEJ tools on judicial time management? Jean-Jacques KUSTER, European Union of Rechtspfleger and court clerks (EUR) Discussion § The CEPEJ Handbook for conducting satisfaction surveys aimed at court users: a tool for improving the perception of the users’ trust in their judicial system Carmen DANTIS, Prosecutor at the Court of Vrancea, Romania Discussion § The CEPEJ Guidelines for a better implementation of the existing Council of Europe's Recommendation on enforcement: a key working tool for bailiffs Mathieu CHARDON, Bailiff, Versailles, France, First Secretary of the International Union of Judicial Officers (UIHJ) Discussion |
12.30 |
Lunch Break |
14.00 |
Innovative practices contribute to improving the efficiency and quality of the service delivered to court users |
§ Follow-up of judicial expertises - Regional Court of Antwerp, Belgium, Winner of the “2012 Crystal Scales of Justice Prize”, by Greet NUYENS, Vice-President, First Instance Court of Antwerp, Belgium and Isabelle BRESSELEERS, Judge, First Instance Court of Antwerp, Belgium Discussion § The co-hearing of the family judge and auditor of children, Regional Court of Tarascon, France, Special Mention of the “2012 Crystal Scales of Justice Prize”, by Marc JUSTON, President of the regional Court of Tarascon, France Discussion § Lexnet, General Secretariat of justice administration, Spain, Special Mention of the “2012 Crystal Scales of Justice Prize”, by Gemma del REY ALMANSA, Coordinator in the Unit of Support of the Spanish Secretary General for Justice Administration. Discussion § Judicial data warehouse and performance dashboards, Supreme Court of Slovenia, Special Mention of the “2012 Crystal Scales of Justice Prize”, by Gregor STROJIN, Head of Public Affairs Office, Supreme Court of Slovenia Discussion |
|
16.00 – 16.30 |
Break |
16.30 |
A long way to the efficiency and quality of justice |
§ The initial ambitions of the CEPEJ and the current achievements Eberhard DESCH, Head of Division of International Law, Federal Ministry of Justice, Berlin, former President of the CEPEJ § Efficiency and quality of justice are still to be improved: new challenges for the CEPEJ in the coming years. Round Table chaired by André POTOCKI, Judge at the European Court of Human Rights, former Vice-President of the CEPEJ with the participation of: · Eberhard DESCH, President of the CDCJ · Paul MAFFEI, Vice-President of the CCJE · João Manuel DA SILVA MIGUEL, President of the CCPE · Georg STAWA (Austria), Vice-President of the CEPEJ |
|
17.30 |
Cocktail offered by the Council of Europe |
7 December 2012 – Continuation of the plenary meeting
Rapporteur: Frans VAN DER DOELEN (Netherlands), Member of the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL
i. Debriefing on the process implemented since 2002
ii. Continuation of the process
a. amendement of the Evaluation Scheme
b. complementary studies
c. launching of the 2012 - 20104 cycle
d. towards a permanent Observatory of justice in Europe
iii. Implementation of the pilot peer evaluation co-operation process
iv. Specific co-operation with non-CoE member states
§ Co-operation with OECD
§ Other co-operation
Rapporteur: Georg STAWA (Austria), Vice-President of the CEPEJ
Rapporteur: Georg STAWA (Austria), Vice-President of the CEPEJ
i. Co-operation programmes with Morocco, Tunisia and Jordan
Rapporteurs: Jacques BÜHLER (Switzerland) and Secretariat
ii. Efficiency of justice in the countries of the Eastern Partnership
Rapporteur: Georg STAWA (Austria), Vice-President of the CEPEJ
Rapporteur: Fabio BARTOLOMEO (Italy), Member of the CEPEJ-GT-QUAL
Rapporteur: Jacques BÜHLER (Switzerland), Chair of the Steering group
i. Updating of the report on lengths of proceedings in the ECHR case law
ii. Draft comments on the SATURN Guidelines of CEPEJ on judicial time management
Rapporteur: John STACEY, President of the CEPEJ
Members of the CEPEJ are requested to prepare for the meeting, if need be, proposals of concrete activities in the light of the specific needs of their state in 2013.
Rapporteur: Gábor SZÉPLAKI-NAGY (Hungary)
APPENDIX II
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS
SPECIAL SESSION - 10th ANNIVERSARY / SESSION SPECIALE - 10EME ANNIVERSAIRE
SPEAKERS / INTERVENANTS
(by order of presentation / Par ordre de présentation)
Gabriella BATTAINI-DRAGONI, Deputy Secretary General of the Council of Europe / Secrétaire Générale adjointe du Conseil de l’Europe
Ambassador Josep DALLERÈS, Permanent Representative of Andorra to the Council of Europe, Chairperson of the Deputies / Président des Délégués des Ministres, Représentant Permanent de l’Andorre auprès du Conseil de l’Europe
Dean SPIELMANN, President of the European Court of Human Rights / Président de la Cour Européenne des Droits de l’Homme
Nils MUIŽNIEKS, Commissioner for Human Rights of the Council of Europe / Commissaire aux Droits de l’Homme
John STACEY, President of the CEPEJ / Président de la CEPEJ
Jean-Paul JEAN, Avocat Général, Court of Cassation and associated Professor at the University of Poitiers, France, Chairman of the CEPEJ-GT-EVAL / Avocat Général, Cour de Cassation et Professeur associé à l’Université de Poitiers, France, Président du CEPEJ-GT-EVAL
Bettina COEN, Judge at the Court of Fribourg, Germany / Juge du tribunal de district de Fribourg, Allemagne
Jean-Jacques KUSTER, European Union of Rechtspfleger and court clerks (EUR), Instance Court of Strasbourg, France / Union européenne des greffiers de justice (EUR), Tribunal d’Instance de Strasbourg, France
Carmen DANTIS, Prosecutor at the Court of Vrancea, Romania / Procureur au Tribunal de Vrancea, Roumanie
Mathieu CHARDON, Bailiff, Versailles, France, First Secretary of the International Union of Judicial Officers (UIHJ) / Huissier de justice, Versailles, France, Premier Secrétaire de l’Union Internationale des Huissiers de Justice (UIHJ)
Greet NUYENS, Vice-President, First Instance Court of Antwerp, Belgium / Vice-Présidente, Tribunal de Première Instance d’Anvers, Belgique
Isabelle BRESSELEERS, Judge, First Instance Court of Antwerp, Belgium / Juge, Tribunal de Première Instance d’Anvers, Belgique
Marc JUSTON, President of the regional Court of Tarascon, France / Président du Tribunal de Grande Instance de Tarascon, France
Gemma DEL REY ALMANSA, Coordinator in the Unit of Support of the Spanish Secretary General for Justice Administration, Madrid, Spain / Coordinatrice à l’Unité de soutien, Secrétariat Général de l’Administration de la Justice, Madrid, Espagne
Gregor STROJIN, Head of Public Affairs Office, Supreme Court of Slovenia / Chef du Bureau des relations publiques, Cour Suprême de Slovénie
Eberhard DESCH, Head of Division of International Law, Federal Ministry of Justice, Berlin, former President of the CEPEJ / Chef de la Division du droit international, Ministère fédéral de la justice, Président du CDCJ Berlin, ancien Président de la CEPEJ
André POTOCKI, Judge at the European Court of Human Rights, former Vice-President of the CEPEJ / Juge à la Cour Européenne des Droits de l’Homme, ancien Vice-président de la CEPEJ
Paul MAFFEI, Counselor at the Court of Cassation, Brussels, Belgium, Vice-President of the CCJE / Conseiller à la Cour de Cassation, Bruxelles, Belgique , Vice-Président du CCJE
João DA SILVA MIGUEL, Member of EUROJUST for Portugal, President of the CCPE / Membre d’EUROJUST au titre du Portugal, Président du CCPE
SECRETARIAT OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE / SECRETARIAT DU CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE
Hanne JUNCHER, Head of Justice and Legal Co-operation Department / Chef du service de la coopération judiciaire et juridique
Andrew DRZEMCZEWSKI, Chef du Département des questions juridiques & des droits de l'Homme, Assemblée parlementaire du Conseil de l’Europe
***
Plenary Meeting - List of Participants /
Réunion plénière - Liste des participants
CEPEJ MEMBERS / MEMBRES DE LA CEPEJ
ALBANIA/ALBANIE : Apologised / Excusée
ANDORRA/ANDORRE
Carme OBIOLS, Secrétaire Générale, Conseil supérieur de la Justice, ANDORRE LA VIEILLE
ARMENIA/ARMENIE
Armen SANOYAN, Head of International Treaties Expertise Division, Department of International Legal Affairs of the Administration, Ministry of Justice, YEREVAN
AUSTRIA/AUTRICHE
Georg STAWA, Head of Department Pr 8, Projects, Strategy and Innovation, Federal Ministry of Justice, VIENNA (Vice-President of the CEPEJ / Vice-Président de la CEPEJ)
AZERBAIJAN/AZERBAÏDJAN
Ramin GURBANOV, Chief of reforms division, General department of organisation and supervision,
Co-ordinator of Judicial Modernisation Project, Ministry of Justice, BAKU
Nail HUSEYNQULIYEV, Consultant in the Judicial Modernization Project, Ministry of Justice, BAKU,
BELGIUM/BELGIQUE
Dietger GEERAERT, Attaché Service Juridique, Direction Générale de l'Organisation Judiciaire, Service public fédéral Justice, BRUXELLES
BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA/BOSNIE-HERZÉGOVINE
Zlatko Kulenovic,Republic of Srpska Supreme Court, BANJA LUKA
Rusmir Šabeta, Head of the Judicial Administration Department, The Secretariat of the High Judicial and Prosecutorial, Council of Bosnia and Herzegovina, SARAJEVO
CYPRUS/CHYPRE
Effie PAPADOPOULOU, Judge at the Supreme Court, NICOSIA
CZECH REPUBLIC/REPUBLIQUE TCHEQUE
Ivana BORZOVÁ, Head of Department of Civil Supervision, Ministry of Justice, PRAGUE
DENMARK/DANEMARK
Klaus RUGAARD, Head of Finance and Analysis Department, Danish Court Administration, COPENHAGEN
ESTONIA/ESTONIE
Mai SELKE, Advisor, Ministry of Justice, TALLINN
FINLAND/FINLANDE
Kari Samuli KIESILĀINEN, Head of Department, Directorate General, Ministry of Justice, HELSINKI
FRANCE
Jean-Paul SUDRE,Inspecteur général adjoint des services judiciaires, Ministère de la Justice et des Libertés, PARIS
GEORGIA/GÉORGIE
Irakli ADEISHVILI, Judge, Chamber of Civil Cases, Tbilisi Appeals Court, TBILISI, Apologised / Excusé
GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE
Matthias HEGER, Chef du Service de Procédure civile internationale, Ministère fédéral de la Justice, BERLIN
Anna-Lena LUX, Judge, Referentin für Europa- und Wissenschaftsrecht, Federal Ministry of Justice Baden-Württemberg, STUTTGART
GREECE/GRÈCE
Michalis PIKRAMMENOS, Ministry of Justice, Counselor of the State, ATHENS
HUNGARY/HONGRIE
Gábor SZÉPLAKI-NAGY, Procureur, Chef d’unité, Parquet Général, BUDAPEST
ICELAND/ISLANDE
Arnfriđur EINARSDÓTTIR, Judge, District Court of Reykjanes, HAFNARFIRDI
IRELAND/IRLANDE
Noel RUBOTHAM, Head of Reform and Development, Courts Service, DUBLIN
Caroline MURPHY, Courts Policy Division, Department of Justice and Equality, DUBLIN
ITALY/ITALIE
Fabio BARTOLOMEO, Directeur général des statistiques, Ministère de la Justice, ROME
LATVIA/LETTONIE
Aija BRANTA, Judge of the Constitutional Court, RIGA
LIECHSTENSTEIN : Apologised / Excusé
LITHUANIA/LITUANIE
Laima GARNELIENE, Head of Criminal Cases Division, Lithuanian Court of Appeal, VILNIUS
LUXEMBOURG
Laurent THYES, Attaché de Gouvernement, Ministère de la justice, LUXEMBOURG-KIRCHBERG
MALTA/MALTE
Francesco DEPASQUALE, Magistrate, Court of Justice, Ministry of Justice and Home Affairs, VALLETTA
REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA / REPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA
Lilia GRIMALSCHI, Head of the Government Agent Division, Ministry of Justice, Substitute Member of CEPEJ, CHISINAU
MONACO
Stéphanie VIKSTRÖM, Premier juge au Tribunal de première instance. Tribunal de première instance, Palais de Justice, MONACO
MONTENEGRO/MONTÉNÉGRO
Tijana BADNJAR, Department for International Co-operation and European Integration, Ministry of Justice and Human Rights of Montenegro, PODGORICA
NETHERLANDS/PAYS‑BAS
Frans VAN DER DOELEN, Programme Manager of the Department of the Justice System, Ministry of Justice, THE HAGUE
NORWAY/NORVÈGE
Audun BERG, Senior adviser, The National Courts Administration, TRONDHEIM, Apologised / Excusé
Ingvild GRINDELAND ANDERSEN, Senior Adviser,International Secretariat, Department of legal affairs, the National Courts Administration, TRONDHEIM
POLAND/POLOGNE
Jakub MICHALSKI, Assistant to Mr. Grzegorz Wałejko, Undersecretary of State, National Correspondent, Ministry of Justice, WARSAW
PORTUGAL
João ARSÉNIO DE OLIVEIRA, Head of Department, International Affairs Department, Directorate General for Justice Policy, Ministry of Justice, LISBON
ROMANIA/ROUMANIE
Violeta BELEGANTE, Conseiller juridique, Chef du service du droit privé, Direction de l'Elaboration des actes normatifs, des études et de la documentation, Ministère de la Justice, BUCAREST
THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION/FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE
Pavel SMIRNOV, Adviser, Office of the Representative of the Russian Federation at European Court of Human Right, MOSCOW
Alexander PARSHIN, Deputy of the Director General, Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, MOSCOW,
Elena TRUFANOVA, Senior Consultant, International Legal Cooperation Division. Judicial Department, Supreme Court of the Russian Federation, MOSCOW
Konstantin KOSORUKOV, Deputy for Legal Affairs to the Permanent Representative of the Russian Federation at the Council of Europe, STRASBOURG, FRANCE,
SAN MARINO/SAINT MARIN : Apologised / Excusé
SERBIA/SERBIE
Snežana ĐURDEVIĆ, Ministry of Justice and Public Administration, BELGRADE
SLOVAK REPUBLIC/RÉPUBLIQUE SLOVAQUE
Ladislav DUDITS, Judge, Kosice Regional Court, KOSICE
SLOVENIA /SLOVENIE
Marko SORLI, Vice President of the Supreme Court, LJUBLJANA
SPAIN/ESPAGNE
Maria Jesús FRAILE MARTIN Adviser, Directorate General International Legal Cooperation and Religious Affairs, Ministry of Justice, MADRID
SWEDEN/SUÈDE
Eva FERNQVIST, Legal advisor, Legal Department, Swedish National Courts Administration, JÖNKÖPING
SWITZERLAND/SUISSE
Jacques BÜHLER, Secrétaire Général suppléant, Tribunal fédéral suisse, LAUSANNE (Chair of the Steering Group of the SATURN Centre/ Président du Groupe de Pilotage du Centre SATURN)
"THE FORMER YOUGOSLAV REPUBLIC OF MACEDONIA"/"L'EX-RÉPUBLIQUE YOUGOSLAVE DE MACÉDOINE"
Nikola PROKOPENKO,Head of Department of Courts, Public Prosecutors and other Judicial institutions, Ministry of Justice, SKOPJE
TURKEY/TURQUIE
Ismail AKSEL, Judge, Department for Strategy and Development, Ministry of Justice, ANKARA
Engin DURNAGÔL, Judge, High Council of Judges and Prosecutors, Deputy Secretary General, ANKARA
Inan KABILAY, ANKARA
UNITED KINGDOM/ROYAUME‑UNI
John STACEY, Government Advisor for Efficiency and Quality of Justice, President of the CEPEJ, (President of the CEPEJ / Président de la CEPEJ)
Rory MUNRO, Civil Justice Reform Programme Manager “Access to Justice”, Justice Policy Group, Civil Justice Reform, Ministry of Justice, LONDON
***
President of the Working Group on Evaluation of Judicial Systems
CEPEJ-GT-EVAL/
Président du Groupe de travail sur l’évaluation des systèmes judiciaires
CEPEJ-GT-EVAL
Jean-Paul JEAN, Avocat général près la Cour de Cassation, Professeur associé à l’Université de Poitiers, PARIS, FRANCE (Chair of the GT-EVAL / Président du GT-EVAL)
***
BUREAU OF THE LISBON NETWORK / BUREAU DU RESEAU DE LISBONNE
Shota RUKHADZE, Deputy Chairman, The High School of Justice, TBILISI, GEORGIA
***
OBSERVER STATES / ÉTATS OBSERVATEURS
CANADA : Apologised / Excusé
JAPAN /JAPON : Apologised /Excusé
MERICA / ETATS-UNIS D’AMERIQUE
ISRAEL / ISRAËL
Keren WEINSHALL-MARGEL, Director, Israeli Courts Research Division (ICRD), The Supreme Court of Israel, JERUSALEM
Ifat TARABOULOS, Researcher, Israeli Courts Research Division, The Supreme Court of Israel , JERUSALEM
***
INVITED STATES / PAYS INVITES
MOROCCO /MAROC
Najia RAHALI, Directrice des études, de la coopération et de la modernisation, Ministre de la Justice, RABAT
Abdallah BOUJIDA, Président du tribunal de première instance (pôle civil), CASABLANCA, MAROC
Abdelaziz ISSERSSIF, Président du tribunal de première instance, SIDI KACEM, MAROC
Abdelmati EL KADDOURI, Président du Tribunal administratif, AGADIR, MAROC
TUNISIA / TUNISIE
Ridha BEN MAHMOUD, Chef de Cabinet, Ministère de la Justice, Apologised / Excusé
Ridha BEN AMOR, Inspecteur Général Adjoint, Inspection Générale, Ministère de la Justice
Soufiane SLITI, Substitut du procureur de la République, Tribunal de première instance de Tunis
***
OBSERVERS / OBSERVATEURS
COUNCIL OF THE BARS AND LAW SOCIETIES OF THE EUROPEAN UNION / CONSEIL DES BARREAUX EUROPÉENS (CCBE)
Simone CUOMO (Mr), Senior Legal Advisor, Council of Bars and Law Societies of Europe (European lawyers promoting law and justice) BRUSSELS, BELGIUM
Jana WURSTOVA, International Department, Czech Bar Association, PRAGUE, Czech Republic
EUROPEAN UNION OF RECHTSPFLEGER AND COURT CLERKS / UNION EUROPÉENNE DES GREFFIERS DE JUSTICE (EUR)
Thomas KAPPL, President of EUR, MUNICH, ALLEMAGNE, Apologised / Excusé
Jean-Jacques KUSTER, Greffier en Chef, Tribunal d’Instance, STRASBOURG, FRANCE
Vivien WHYTE, Greffier au Tribunal de Grande Instance de Strasbourg, STRASBOURG, FRANCE
INTERNATIONAL UNION OF BAILIFFS / UNION INTERNATIONALE DES HUISSIERS DE JUSTICE ET OFFICIERS JUDICIAIRES (UIHJ)
Leo NETTEN, Président de l’UIHJ, MONFORT L’AMAURY, FRANCE
Mathieu CHARDON, Huissier de justice, Premier secrétaire de l’UIHJ, VERSAILLES, FRANCE
EUROPEAN FEDERATION OF ADMINISTRATIVE JUDGES / FÉDÉRATION EUROPÉENNE DES JUGES ADMINISTRATIFS
Pierre VINCENT, Cour Administrative d’Appel de Nancy, NANCY, FRANCE
MAGISTRATS EUROPÉENS POUR LES DÉMOCRATIES ET LES LIBERTÉS (MEDEL)
Eric ALT, Vice-Président de MEDEL, Conseiller référendaire, Cour de Cassation, PARIS, FRANCE
EUROPEAN NETWORK OF COUNCILS FOR THE JUDICIARY (ENCJ) / RESEAU EUROPEEN DES CONSEILS DE LA JUSTICE (RECJ)
Geert VERVAEKE, Membre du Conseil supérieur de la magistrature, BRUXELLES, BELGIQUE
Ria MORTIER, Membre du Bureau du Conseil supérieur de la magistrature, BRUXELLES, BELGIQUE
COUNCIL OF THE NOTARIATS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION / CONSEIL DES NOTARIATS DE L’UNION EUROPEENNE
Susanne KRAEMER, Legal Adviser at the CNUE, BRUSSELS, BELGIUM
WORLDBANK / BANQUE MONDIALE
Daría GOLDSTEIN, Senior Counsel, the Legal Department, WASHINGTON, D.C, USA
***
EUROPEAN UNION / UNION EUROPÉENNE
european CommisSion / Commission européenne
Aristotelis GAVRILIADIS, Directorate General JUST/A/1, Civil Justice , BRUSSELS
EUROPEAN UNION AGENCY FOR FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS / AGENCE DE L’UNION EUROPEENNE POUR LES DROITS FONDAMENTAUX : Apologised / Excusée
***
COUNCIL OF EUROPE / CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE
EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS (ECHR) / COUR EUROPÉENNE DES DROITS DE L’HOMME (CEDH)
Paola TONARELLI-LACORE, Registry of the European Court of Human Rights/Greffe de la Cour Européenne des Droits de l’Homme
PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLY OF THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE / ASSEMBLÉE PARLEMENTAIRE DU CONSEIL DE L’EUROPE
Tamas GAUDY NAGY, Member of the Committee on Legal Affairs and Human Rights (Hungary), Representative of the Parliamentary Assembly to the CEPEJ
CONSULTATIVE COUNCIL OF EUROPEAN JUDGES / CONSEIL CONSULTATIF DE JUGES EUROPEENS (CCJE)
Paul MAFFEI, Conseiller à la Cour de Cassation, BRUXELLES, Belgique, Vice-Président du CCJE
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE ON LEGAL CO-OPERATION / COMITE EUROPÉEN DE COOPÉRATION JURIDIQUE (CDCJ)
Eberhard DESCH, Head of Division of International Law, Federal Ministry of Justice, BERLIN, GERMANY, Chair of the CDCJ
CONSULTATIVE COUNCIL OF EUROPEAN PROSECUTORS / Conseil consultatif de procureurs européens(CCPE)
João DA SILVA MIGUEL, Member of EUROJUST in respect of Portugal, THE HAGUE, President of the CCPE
EUROPEAN COMMITTEE FOR CRIME PROBLEMS / COMITE EUROPEEN POUR LES PROBLÈMES CRIMINELS (CDPC) : Apologised / Excusé
STEERING COMMITTEE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS / COMITE DIRECTEUR POUR LES DROITS DE L’HOMME (CDDH) : Apologised / Excusé
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) / ORGANISATION POUR LA COOPERATION ET LE DEVELOPPEMENT ECONOMIQUES (OCDE)
Natalia NOLANFLECHA, Policy Analyst, Directorate of Public Governance Territorial Development, Reform of the Public Sector Division
***
SECRETARIAT
DGI – Human Rights and Rule of Law – Division for the Independence and Efficiency of Justice /
DGI - Droits de l’Homme et Etat de droit – Division pour l’indépendance et l’efficacité de la justice
Stéphane LEYENBERGER, Secretary of the CEPEJ / Secrétaire de la CEPEJ
Muriel DECOT, Co-Secretary of the CEPEJ / Co-secrétaire de la CEPEJ
Artashes MELIKYAN, Administrator / Administrateur
Hasan HENDEK, Special Advisor to the Secretariat of the CEPEJ / Conseiller spécial auprès du Secrétariat de la CEPEJ
Maria ORESHKINA, Principal Administrative assistant / Assistante administrative principale
Jean-Pierre GEILLER, Documentation
Annette SATTEL, Communication
Elisabeth HEURTEBISE, Assistant/Assistante
Trainees / Stagiaires
Camille BONNIN
Interpreters / Interprètes
Nicolas GUITTONNEAU
Bettina LUDEWIG
Alexei MILKO
Leonid VEKCHINE