Français | Word

Ministers’ Deputies

Annotated Agenda

CM/Del/OJ/OT(2002)819-Add 4 – Volume 1 (restricted) 26 November 2002

———————————————

819th (DH) Meeting 3 and 5 December 2002

Section 4

Cases raising special questions (individual measures, measures not yet defined or special problems)

——————————————

Action

Section 4

The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of the cases listed below, on the basis of the Rules concerning the application of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention.

SECTION 4.2

INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

EGMEZ AGAINST CYPRUS

Judgment of 21/12/00

Item H46-975

TRADUCTION

Mr Tekin Akillioglu, representing Mr Egmez, 0090 312 417 35 52 Ankara Turkey

Mr P.-H. IMBERT

Director

Council of Europe

67075 Strasbourg France

fax 0033 3 88 41 27 93

Ankara, 13.9.2002

Dear Sir,

I have the honour to inform you that, on the Committee of Ministers Internet page summarising follow-up to judgments, my client read the following passage concerning him:

" H46‑591 30873 Egmez, judgment of 21/12/00

The case mainly concerns the inhuman treatment inflicted upon the applicant by state officials during his arrest before being admitted to hospital in Larnaca (violation of Article 3) and the absence of an effective remedy in this respect (violation of Article 13).

Individual measures: The applicant's lawyer sent a letter to the Secretariat on 19 April 2001 raising several questions about the need to adopt individual measures in this case. In May 2001 the Secretariat forwarded a copy of the letter to the Cypriot authorities. The latter confirmed that they were presently examining the measures that might need to be taken in respect of this case and indicated that the Secretariat would be kept informed in writing of any development in this field.

On 1 December 1995, the Attorney General filed a nolle prosequi in the applicant's case with the Nicosia District Court, in accordance with Article 113.2 of the Constitution. The applicant was released on the same day. On 4 December 1995, the Nicosia District Court discharged the applicant.

General measures: As in the Denizci & Others case, also examined under section 4.2, the Cypriot authorities have indicated:

a. that the judgment was disseminated to all institutions concerned (judicial and also police force/security forces, Attorney General's Office, Ombudsman, Cyprus Bar Association). The Ministry of Justice and Ministry of Interior have requested that appropriate instructions be prepared and distributed to all State officials in order to avoid any future case of ill‑treatment. Instructions prepared by the Attorney General have also been distributed to all authorities concerned. The judgment, which has been published, has also received extensive media coverage in the country. The Cypriot authorities will transmit to the Secretariat, in written form, exact details of the above‑mentioned information.

b. Furthermore, sections 242‑243 of the Criminal Code and related parts of the code of criminal procedure had already been amended taking into account the findings of the European Court of Human Rights. However, further legislative measures are envisaged. In this respect, the Attorney General's Office, in co‑operation with the Justice Department, is drafting a bill in order to avoid in the future the type of violation found in this case. The Secretariat has requested to be informed of any development in this field.

‑ The Committee has requested, apart from the information already requested in the Denizci & Others case also applicable to this case, whether, as far as the violation of Article 13 is concerned and in the light of §§ 71 and 99 of the Court's judgment, the Cypriot authorities envisage the adoption of specific measures in order to guarantee that similar violations do not recur.

At the time of issuing the present notes, no information, in written form, had been received.

1.         In view of the assertion that “the authorities were presently examining the [individual] measures that might need to be taken in respect of this case”, my client would like to know what “developments” there eventually were and the reason for the authorities’ silence. 

2.         In the above communiqué the emphasis is rather on measures relating to the future, whereas my client would like a clear, detailed answer as regards proceedings against the police officers guilty of the torture (the so-called “inhuman treatment”).

3.         The fact that my client was unable to name the culprits is not a valid excuse: the Court, upholding the Commission’s findings, accepted that it was for the Government to act on the complaint the applicant made through the Ombudsman, particularly as the record of the witnesses’ testimony unequivocally gives the names of all the police officers implicated in the case.  The Chief Prosecutor is giving the officers a pat on the back by using his aberrant constitutional powers not to prosecute them.

4.         As far as action in this case is concerned, the demands made by the Directorate of Human Rights would seem to be frustrated by Article 113.2 of the Cypriot Constitution, which vests an absolute discretion in the Chief Prosecutor not to institute proceedings.

5.         In short, my client believes that the police officers responsible are being protected by the Chief Prosecutor, who seems to regard my client’s discharge and release as sufficient compensation in themselves.

6.         My client would point out that paragraphs 72, 99 and 100  of the judgment (quoted below) make clear the obligation under Article 13 to institute criminal proceedings: 1. In the light of all the above, the Court considers that, because of the special obligation that the Convention creates for domestic authorities in the case of arguable Article 3 claims, the applicant, by lodging a complaint with the Ombudsman, discharged his duty under Article 35 § 1 of the Convention to afford the State concerned an opportunity to put matters right through its own legal system before having to answer before an international body for their acts. The only way of putting matters right in the circumstances of the case was the institution of criminal proceedings against the officers involved and, given section 6 § 9 of the Laws on the Ombudsman, a complaint to the Ombudsman should have normally brought about this result.

…

2. The Commission considered that, in accordance with the case‑law, an action for damages would not have afforded the applicant an effective remedy. Moreover, the Government had not invoked any precedent of a successful private prosecution against police officers charged with torture and inhuman treatment. In any event, in the applicant's case there was tolerance of such treatment at the highest administrative level. As a result, only an inquiry that had the backing of the chief prosecuting authority of the Republic would have had reasonable prospects of success. However, the Attorney‑General did not institute criminal proceedings against any of the police officers involved in the applicant's case. Therefore, the Commission found a breach of Article 13 of the Convention.

3. The Court recalls that its finding that the applicant exhausted domestic remedies was based on the following considerations: the applicant, by complaining to the Ombudsman, had given the authorities the opportunity to put matters right by ordering an investigation capable of leading to the identification and punishment of the officers involved; this was the only remedy that was appropriate for the kind of violation complained of; however, the Attorney‑General, who is the official in charge of bringing criminal proceedings, did not take any steps in this direction. The Court, having accepted the above, considers that there was a breach of Article 13 of the Convention.

In conclusion, my client requests:

- the Committee of Ministers to issue a recommendation reminding the Government of its duty to comply with Article 13 of the Convention, not only in future but, above all, in so far as my client is concerned;

- the Director of Human Rights to circulate this request to all the Ministers’ Deputies.

Yours sincerely,

Tekin Akillioglu

Representing Mr Egmez

TRADUCTION

Mr P.-H. IMBERT

Director

Council of Europe

Strasbourg

12.3.2002

Dear Sir,

My client has asked me to convey to you his concern about the Government’s silence about prosecution of the police officers guilty of the torture and ill-treatment established in the Commission report, which findings the Court upheld.  Those presumed responsible have now been identified with sufficient certainty to enable the prosecutor, Mr Markides, to use his discretion under the Cypriot constitution.  As we said before the Court, the prosecutor unfortunately did not see his way to using his powers to start an investigation of the torturers.  He simply accused my client of not reporting them and not making a complaint, etc.  In my client’s view, it is now for the Government to establish proof and to demonstrate compliance with the Court’s judgment by starting proceedings against the police officers in question, who are still serving. 

My client would sue for damages in any such proceedings.

Please convey this request to the Committee of Ministers.

Yours sincerely,

Tekin Akillioglu

Representing Mr Egmez

PERMANENT REPRESENTATION

OF THE

REPUBLIC OF CYPRUS

TO THE COUNCIL OF EUROPE

Tel. 03 88 24 98 70 Fax 03 88 36 90 56 20, Avenue de la Paix 67000 Strasbourg e‑mail [email protected]

Strasbourg, 4 October 2002

Dear Mrs Dinsdale,

Re: Egmez and Denizci & Others v. Cyprus

With reference to the above‑mentioned cases and your letter dated the 4th of September 2002, HD/sm, please find attached herewith additional information concerning the execution of the said judgments of the European Court of Human Rights.

The information appended hereto addresses to a great extent the requested information of the 798th DH meeting (11‑12 June 2002). I would, therefore, kindly request you to convey the contents of the present letter to the attention of the Committee of Ministers at the next Human Rights meeting (7 to 10 October 2002).

On this occasion, I would like to reiterate my Government's commitment and determination in executing the said judgments, in full, at the earliest possible.

Yours faithfully,

j

Nicholas EMILIOU (Dr)

Permanent Representative

Mrs Jane DINSDALE

Directorate General of Human Rights ‑ DG II

Directorate I

Council of Europe

67075 Strasbourg Cedex

cc: Mr. Simon PALMER

        Secretariat of the Committee of Ministers

        Council of Europe

        67075 Strasbourg Cedex

INFORMATION REQUESTED BY RELEVANT INFORMAL

NOTE OF THE SECRETARIAT CONCERNING

EXAMINATION 13Y THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

OF THE ENFORCEMENT OF THE COURT'S

JUDGMENTS IN THE CASES OF DENIZCI AND EGMEZ

A) 1. A situation like the one which arose in the Egmez Case, is no longer a obstacle to the initiation of a criminal investigation by the Attorney‑General. That is, after the Court's Judgment. a situation, like the one in the. Egmez Case, whereby an individual, though alleging to have been subjected to acts of ill‑treatment by the police constituting criminal offences under domestic legislation (and a violation of Article 3 of the Convention), nevertheless does not address a written complaint to the Attorney General and/or is not willing or likely at the outset to co‑operate 'in a criminal investigation that may be ordered by the Attorney‑General, or in any ensuing criminal proceedings, is no longer an obstacle to the initiation and completion of a criminal investigation into the allegations by order of the Attorney‑General. This is so, since following the Court's Judgment, which resulted in the relevant decision of the Committee of Ministers of 22.3.2001 concerning the delegation to the Attorney‑General of the Committee's power of appointment of independent criminal investigators (details of which have already been submitted), the Attorney‑General of the Republic, can appoint despite a situation as above, independent criminal investigators to carry out a criminal investigation concerning the allegations, that is, he can so appoint, irrespective of the fact that the complainant has not addressed to him any written complaint, and the allegations have reached him through other sources of information. The same applies, irrespective of the fact, that the complainant does not appear at the outset to he willing or likely to cooperate, or retracts from his allegations, or cannot be traced, considering that such factors as these, are no longer taken into account as constituting obstacles to the initiation and completion of a criminal investigation by the Attorney‑General.

2. The investigation referred to in para.23 of the Court's Judgment in the Case of Deniczi (see Ministers' Deputies Annotated Draft Agenda of 23 October 2001). that is, concerning the death of liker Tufansoy, which included a Coroner's inquest in 1995 concluding that the killing was committed by unknown persons, is still open. In other words. the file of the above criminal investigation (as to which the Court saw no element which would allow it to conclude that this was inadequate contrary to Article 2), is still open, and will remain so until the perpetrators of the murder are identified and brought before the Court.

B) 1. By virtue of the Police (Disciplinary) Regulations 1989, a member of the police commits a disciplinary offence, if he carries out an arrest illegally or thoughtlessly, or without reasonable or sufficient cause, or if he exerts any force which is not absolutely necessary, on any person in custody, or on any person with whom he comes into contact in the execution of his duties, or if he behaves with cruelty to any person. A police member who is proved to have committed such a disciplinary offence, is subject to dismissal, or compulsory resignation, or demotion, or to retention, interruption or postponement of yearly salary increments, or to disciplinary transfer, or to strict reprimand, or reprimand. The disciplinary sanction to be imposed, depends on the particular circumstances of each case.

2. Under Article 11 of the Constitution, which is the Article safeguarding the right to liberty and security of person, every person arrested must be allowed at the time of his arrest, to have the services of a lawyer (para.4), and must be brought before a Judge within 24 hours, if not released earlier on (para.5).

3. The judgments were not only disseminated to the authorities concerned, but also to bodies and institutions pursuing human rights issues (Ombudsman. National Institution for the Protection of Human Rights, Human

Rights Committee of the House of Representatives), and to the legal community (the Cyprus Bar association). Although not published in the official language, extracts from the judgments, concerning the findings of violation were reiterated in the daily pres and from radio and television stations, and were brought to the notice of the public at large.

Extract from the Records of the Meeting of the Committee of Ministers Dated 22/3/2001

Delegation of powers of the Committee of Ministers to the Attorney General of the Republic,
under the Delegation of the Exercise of Powers Derived from Law, Law 23 of 1962

No.of Decision

53.406

(No. of Note 46/2001),

19. Regarding its Decisions with no. 44.874 and 48.448 dated 3.10.1996 and 7.101998, respectively, the Committee of Ministers:

a)    Was informed, concerning the letter sent by the Attorney General of the Republic, to the Secretary of the Committee of Ministers, dated 14.3.2001 and under reference no. A.G. 32/1987/6 and 74/1936/4, for delegating to the Attorney‑General, the power of the Committee of Ministers to appoint criminal investigators under section 4(2) of the Criminal Procedure Law.

b)    Decided after taking into account the above letter, to authorize the Attorney‑General of the Republic, in accordance with the Delegation of the Exercise of Powers Derived from Law, Law 23 of 1962, to appoint criminal investigators, in instances in which, there come to his knowledge in any manner whatsoever:

(i) allegations against a member of the Police as to the commission of any criminal offence,

(ii) allegations as to the commission by any person, other than by members of constituted bodies, of a criminal offence of an economic nature, punishable with a term of imprisonment exceeding one year, without the existing til now limitation, which is hereby abolished, as to it being necessary to submit a written complaint to the Attorney‑General of the Republic.

___________

_____________

To the Attorney‑General of the Republic,

The above Decision is transmitted to you for information and for any action concerning your Service.

(Chrysostomos Sofianos)

Secretary of the Committee of Ministers.

4.4.2001.

Cc.       ‑ Undersecretary to the President.

‑ Director General Ministry of Justice and Public Order.

O.G.Suppl. III (I)

No. 3493, 27.4.2001

Number 169

23 of 1962.

R.A.A. 16912001

THE DELEGATION OF THE EXERCISE OF POWERS DERIVED

FROM LAW, LAW OF 1962

Notification under section 3(1)

it is notified, that as from the date of the Decision of the Council of Ministers, which is set out in the Fifth Column of the Table, the Committee of Ministers in exercise of the powers with which it is vested by sub‑section (1) of section 3 of the Delegation of the Exercise of Powers Derived from Law, Law of 1962, has delegated to the person exercising the function set out in the Fourth Column of the Table, subject to any terms, exceptions or reservations as may be specified respectively in the Third Column, the exercise of the powers set out in the Second Column, which the Committee of Ministers is empowered to exercise under the provisions which are set out in the First Column of the Table.

The Table set out in the notification under no. R.A.A. 249/87 (as subsequently amended) is modified accordingly.

Table.

R.A.A_ 249/87

             62/88

             80/89

             27/90

             40/91

             277/91

             753/92

             87/93

             112/93

             I2/93

             156/93

             196/93

             209/93

             227/93

             28/5

             308/95

             325/96

             383/96

             141/97

             218/97

             396/97

             301/98

             218/99

             318/99

             397/00.

SECTION 4.2

INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

METROPOLITAN CHURCH OF BESSARABIA AND OTHERS AGAINST MOLDOVA

Judgment of 13/12/01 – Final on 27/03/02

Item H46-1025

Appendix I

Traduction

Unofficial translation

Decision of the Government of the Republic of Moldova

on buildings and premises used for worship

No. 740 of 11.06.2002

Official Gazette of the Republic of Moldova, No. 78-81/838 of 20.06.2002

            For the purpose of determining the ownership of buildings and premises used for worship, and of registering the title to such property in accordance with the Religious Observance Act (Law No. 979 of 24 March 1992), the Land Registry Act (Law No. 1549-XIII of 25 February 1999) the Act governing State regulation of the real property regime, the land registry and real property monitoring (Law No. 1247-XII of 22 December 1992), the Monuments Conservation Act (Law No. 1530-XII of 22 June 1993), and the State Programme instituting the land registry, approved by Decision of the Government of the Republic of Moldova No. 1030 of 12 October 1998, the Government of the Republic of Moldova

DECIDES as follows:

1. Within 30 days after the date of the applications lodged by the representatives of religious denominations, the mayors of municipalities, towns and villages shall set up committees composed of suitably qualified individuals, chaired by the mayors and assisted, should the need arise, by specialists in this field at the invitation of the central government authorities, to determine the ownership of the buildings and premises used for worship and to assess the area of the land pertaining to them.

2. The State Agency for real property transactions and land registration shall:

- ensure, pursuant to the applications lodged, the registration of the buildings and premises used for worship and of the land pertaining to them;

- in conjunction with the appropriate departments of the local authorities, issue to the parishes and religious communities, at their request, deeds authenticating their title as landowners in accordance with the current legislation.

3. Parishes or religious communities operating in buildings used for worship which are classified as State-protected monuments (specified in the appendix hereto), shall in all cases complete the requisite formalities with the Ministry of Culture for non-paying use of these buildings in accordance with the current legislation.

Signed by:

Prime Minister

of the Republic of Moldova                                           Mr Vasile TARLEV

Countersigned by:

Minister of Justice                                                         Mr Ion MOREI

Minister of Culture                                                         Mr Ion PACURARU

Chisinau, 11 June 2002

No. 740

THE RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF THE MOLDOVAN LAW

ON RELIGIOUS DENOMINATIONS

(Non-official translation)

Article 9  Freedom of organisation and functioning of religious denominations

Religious denominations are free to organise themselves and can function freely within the provisions of the current law.

Religious denominations organise themselves according to their own rules, in accordance with their doctrines, canons and traditions.

Religious denominations are forbidden to establish by their Statutes, or to carry out activities, which undermine the independence, sovereignty, integrity and security of the Republic of Moldova and public order, or are linked to political activities, or to establish articles or carry out other activities which undermine the Constitution of the Republic of Moldova, this law and existing legislation (introduced by Law No. 1220-XV of 12 July 2002).

Article 14  Approval of Statutes

In order to organise or operate, each religious denomination files with the State body for religious denominations a declaration with an appendix of the Statutes (the rules) of organisation and operation, which provide information on its structure and administration and on its fundamental principles of belief.

The specific declaration in the first paragraph of the present article is filed with the State Authority for religious denominations, which in the 30 days following the deposition, will enter the religious denomination in the Register of Religious Denominations.

The manner of keeping the Register of Religious Denominations is established by the State Authority for religious denominations.  In the case of non-observation of the provisions laid down in the third paragraph of Article 9 of the current law, on application by the State body for religious denominations, recognition could be declared void through judicial proceedings with the prohibition of the religious denomination to operate for one year.

The religious denomination will not be able to resume its activities until it complies with the final court decision and on condition that it satisfies the provisions of the first and second paragraphs of the current article (introduced by Law No 1220-XV of 12 July 2002).

Article 49  Judicial Protection

Any action that undermines the rights granted by the present law and exercised within the limits established by the law may be challenged through judicial proceedings.

Persons who are deemed guilty of non-compliance of the present law are sued according to the manner established by the current legislation (introduced by Law No. 263-XIV of 24 December 1998).

Article 52 International Treaties

If the international treaty to which the Republic of Moldova is a party, establishes other norms than those provided for in the present law, the provisions of the international treaty will be applicable (introduced by Law No. 1220-XV of 12 July 2002).

PROVISIONS OF DOMESTIC LAW ALLOWING THE REOPENING OF PROCEEDINGS FOLLOWING THE EUROPEAN COURT'S JUDGMENTS

(Non-official translation)

Article 325 of the Code of Civil Procedure (extract)

Grounds for revision of final decisions

The judicial decisions which have become final after their examination in appeal proceedings or without being challenged by an appeal, as well as the decisions on the merits delivered in cassation proceedings, can be reviewed if:

(…)

12. there has been a final decision by the European Court of Human Rights in which the Republic of Moldova is party (sub-paragraph introduced in July 2002).

Article 369/2 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (extract)

Grounds for an application for annulment

The final judgments in criminal cases can be challenged through application for annulment in the following cases:

(…)

1.i) if an international judicial body has found by its decision a violation of human rights and fundamental freedoms, which can be remedied by a new trial (sub-paragraph introduced by the Law No.1090-XIV of 23.06.2000)

SECTION 4.2

INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

QUINN AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

Application No. 23496 (Interim Resolutions DH(98)214 and ResDH(2002)85)

MURRAY KEVIN AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

Application No 22384 (Interim Resolutions DH(98)156 and ResDH(2002)85)

MAGEE AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

Judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00 (Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)85)

MURRAY JOHN AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

Judgment of 08/02/96 (Interim Resolutions DH(2000)26 and ResDH(2002)85)

AVERILL AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

Judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00 (Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)85)

Items H32-2800, H32-2801, H46-2802, H54-2803 and H46-2804

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

________

INTERIM resolution DH (2000) 26

CONCERNING THE JUDGMENT OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
OF 8 FEBRUARY 1996
IN THE CASE OF JOHN MURRAY AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 14 February 2000
at the 695th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 54 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter referred to as “the Convention”),

            Having regard to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in the John Murray case delivered on 8 February 1996 and transmitted the same day to the Committee of Ministers;

            Recalling that the case originated in an application (No. 18731/91) against the United Kingdom, lodged with the European Commission of Human Rights on 16 August 1991 under Article 25 of the Convention by Mr John Murray, a British national, and that the Commission declared admissible the complaints that the provision of the Criminal Evidence Order 1988 which permits inferences to be drawn by a tribunal from the failure of the accused to answer police questions or to give evidence and their use in determining his guilt had constituted a violation of his right to a fair trial and of the presumption of innocence; that denying the applicant access to a solicitor during the first forty-eight hours of police custody amounted to a violation of Article 6, paragraph 3.c, of the Convention; and, that the practice in Northern Ireland not to allow access to a lawyer, unlike the practice in England and Wales, was discriminatory;

            Recalling that the case was brought before the Court by the Commission on 9 September 1994 and by the Government of the respondent State on 11 October 1994;

            Whereas in its judgment of 8 February 1996 the Court:

- held, by fourteen votes to five, that there had been no violation of Article 6, paragraphs 1 and 2, of the Convention arising out of the drawing of adverse inferences on account of the applicant's silence;

- held, by twelve votes to seven, that there had been a violation of Article 6, paragraph 1, in conjunction with Article 6, paragraph 3.c, of the Convention as regards the applicant's lack of access to a lawyer during the first forty-eight hours of his police detention;

- held, unanimously, that it was not necessary to examine the applicant's complaint of a violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 6;

- held, unanimously, that, as regards pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage, the finding of a violation of Article 6, paragraph 1, in conjunction with paragraph 3.c, constituted, in itself, sufficient just satisfaction for the purposes of Article 50 of the Convention;

- held, unanimously, that the Government of the respondent State was to pay, within three months, for costs and expenses 15 000 pounds sterling less 37 968.60 French francs to be converted into pounds sterling at the rate of exchange applicable on the date of delivery of the present judgment and that simple interest at an annual rate of 8% should be payable from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement;

            - dismissed, unanimously, the remainder of the claim for just satisfaction;

            Having regard to the Rules adopted by the Committee of Ministers concerning the application of Article 54 of the Convention;

            Having invited the Government of the respondent State to inform it of the measures which had been taken in consequence of the judgment of 8 February 1996, having regard to the United Kingdom’s obligation under Article 53 of the Convention to abide by it;

            Considering that High Contracting Parties are required to take the necessary measures to conform herewith, notably by preventing new violations of the Convention similar to those found in the Court's judgments;

            Whereas the Government of the respondent State provided the Committee of Ministers with information about the measures taken so far to this effect (this information appears in the Appendix to this resolution);

            Having satisfied itself that on 30 April 1996, within the time-limit set, the Government of the respondent State paid the applicant the sum provided for in the judgment of 8 February 1996,

            Declares, after having taken note of the information supplied by the Government of the United Kingdom, that it has provisionally exercised its functions under Article 54 of the Convention in this case;

            Decides to resume consideration of this case, as far as general measures are concerned, when the Act on "Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence" enters into force or, at the latest, at one of its meetings in September 2000.

Appendix to Interim Resolution DH (2000) 26

Information provided by the Government of the United Kingdom
during the examination of the John Murray case

by the Committee of Ministers

The Government of the United Kingdom expresses its regret concerning the time it has taken to identify the necessary measures to implement this case.  It points out that the important problems caused by the developments of the situation in Northern Ireland since the adoption of the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights have made it difficult to find a permanent solution taking into account all the pertinent elements (including the protection of lawyers having access to persons arrested in connection with terrorist activities).

The government has, nonetheless, identified and taken a number of important steps to prevent a repetition of the circumstances that arose in the case of John Murray.  The judgment in this case concerned the interaction of two pieces of legislation and careful consideration was necessary before determining the most appropriate way to respond to the Court's ruling.  The Government consulted on a number of options for change and, on 1 December 1998, announced an interim administrative solution pending the introduction and implementation of legislation.

Guidance was issued in December 1998 to prosecutors and the police both in England and Wales and in Northern Ireland.  This guidance seeks to ensure that the usual practice will be for suspects to have access to legal advice before being interviewed at a police station.  Where access to legal advice is denied, the police are encouraged to put questions from which inferences might be drawn again, after the suspect has been given the opportunity to obtain such advice.  Additionally, prosecutors have been advised not to seek reliance on inferences drawn from silence before access to legal advice was granted.  Where the court, of its own volition, indicates an intention to draw such inferences, prosecutors are advised to draw its attention to the judgment of the European Court in this case.

In December 1998, the government introduced legislation which included an amendment to the relevant law so as to prohibit the drawing of inferences from silence when a suspect is being questioned at a police station or other authorised place of detention, when he or she has been denied access to legal advice.  The Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 received royal assent in July 1999.  Before the relevant provision of this Act (Section 58) can be implemented in England and Wales, it will be necessary to make certain amendments to the Code of Practice Covering the detention, treatment and questioning of persons by police officers which is issued under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984.  In particular, these amendments will relate to the terms in which suspects are cautioned or warned about the consequences of a failure or refusal to answer questions. 

Amendments to the Code involve extensive public consultation and the changes proposed must be debated in both  Houses of Parliament.  A review of the Codes of Practice has begun and the aim is to bring in a revised Code C by summer 2000, which will enable the implementation of Section 58 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999.

Similar legislation for Northern Ireland (the Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1999) was made in October 1999.  Before the relevant provision of this Order (Article 36) can be implemented, the Codes of Practice under the Police and Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1989 will need to be amended.

The further information about the necessary legislative changes should be available towards the end of the year 2000. The Government therefore suggests the postponement of the Committee of Ministers' examination of the case until December 2000.

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)85

Quinn against the United Kingdom, Interim Resolution DH(1998)214

Murray Kevin against the United Kingdom, Interim Resolution DH(1998)156

Magee against the United Kingdom, judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 6 June 2000, final on 6 September 2000

Murray John against the United Kingdom, judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 8 February 1996, Interim Resolution DH(2000)26

Averill against the United Kingdom, judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 6 June 2000, final on 6 September 2000

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 11 June 2002
at the 798th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, as amended by Protocol No. 11 (hereinafter referred to as “the Convention”),

Having regard to its decisions of 11 June 1998[1] and 10 July 1998[2] under former Article 32 of the Convention in the Murray Kevin and Quinn cases respectively and to the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights of 8 February 1996, in the Murray John case[3], and 6 June 2000 (final on 6 September 2000) in the Averill and Magee cases, all of them concerning the right to silence, the right not to incriminate oneself and the denial of access to legal advice during the first 48 hours of detention (24 hours in the Averill case), combined with the provisions in national law whereby the choice of the accused to remain silent could result in the court or jury drawing unfavourable conclusions (violations of Article 6, paragraph 3.c alone or combined with Article 6, paragraph 1);

Recalling Interim Resolution DH(2000)26 of 14 February 2000 in which the Committee of Ministers decided to resume consideration of the Murray John case, as far as general measures are concerned, when the amendments to the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 and the Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1999 entered into force or, at the latest, at one of its meetings in 2000;

Having regularly invited the Government of the United Kingdom in 2000, 2001 and 2002, to inform it of any progress in the adoption of the measures envisaged by the United Kingdom authorities, as summarised in Interim Resolution DH(2000)26;

Regretting that, more than two years after the adoption of Interim Resolution DH(2000)26, the amendments to the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999, in particular the new Section 58, and the Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1999 have still not entered into force;

Strongly encourages the United Kingdom authorities to take all the necessary measures to ensure the rapid entry into force of the amendments to the “Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 and the Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1999, so as effectively to prevent new violations of the Convention similar to those found in these cases,

Decides to resume consideration of the matter once the legislation in question has entered into force or, at the latest, at its 819th meeting (December 2002).

SECTION 4.2

INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

JORDAN AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

McKERR AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

KELLY AND OTHERS AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

SHANAGHAN AGAINST THE UNITED KINGDOM

Judgments of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01

Items H46-906 to H46-909

Introduction

1.         The Court emphasises that it is not its function "to specify in any detail which procedures the authorities should adopt in providing for the proper examination of the circumstances of a killing by State agents" (Jordan, paragraph 143, McKerr paragraph 159, Kelly an Others, paragraph 136, and Shanaghan, paragraph 123). The Government takes the findings of the Court very seriously and is determined to comply fully with the judgments. As a result, there was established a group of officials, under the chairmanship of an official from the Northern Ireland Office and including representation from all the relevant Government departments and other authorities. This paper considers the various shortcomings identified by the Court in the four cases, and sets out how the Government proposes to responds to them; certain measures had already been taken prior to the judgments and a number of further measures have been taken as a direct consequence of the judgment. Set out below are the Government’s comments on each of the shortcomings identified in paragraph 142 of Jordan, paragraph 157 of McKerr, paragraph 136 of Kelly and Others and paragraph 122 of Shanaghan.

2.          Since the events in question in the four judgments, the United Kingdom has enacted the Human Rights Act 1998 (Annex A). The Act, which in terms of the United Kingdom's constitutional position constitutes a major development in the procedures for the protection of human rights, provides for the Convention to be relied upon in the courts of the United Kingdom. In particular, under section 6(1) of that Act, it is unlawful for a public authority to act in a way which is incompatible with a right set out in the Convention. The Director of Public Prosecutions,. the Chief Constable, all coroners, as well as Ministers of the Crown, are "public authorities" within the meaning of the Act and are thus bound to act compatibly with Convention rights. A copy of the judgments in these cases has been sent to the DPP, the Chief Constable and all coroners in Northern Ireland. They are thus aware of the Court's judgments on the requirements of Article 2.

3.          In addition, following a recommendation of the Patten Report on policing for Northern Ireland, a lawyer with specific expertise in the field of human rights was appointed to the staff of the Police Service of Northern Ireland in October 200 1. The Police Service and the Police Ombudsman are both aware of the need to respect human rights and the Convention in particular, and to provide appropriate training for their staff.

Lack of independence of the police officers investigating the incident from those implicated in the incident

4.          Since November 2000, there is an independent Police Ombudsman in Northern Ireland. She has a staff of over one hundred including a team of independent investigators. The legal texts setting out the manner of appointment and powers of the Ombudsman, together with a paper giving further details, are at Annex B. It is to be noted in particular:

a) Where there is a "serious complaint" (defined in section 50(1) of the Police (NI) Act 1998 as including any case where the complaint relates to the death or serious injury of any person), the Ombudsman is obliged by section 54(2) to investigate it J in accordance with section 56, ie by appointing one of her officers to investigate it; and

b) where the Ombudsman determines that a criminal offence may have been committed by a police officer, the Ombudsman is required by section 58(2) of the 1998 Act to send a report to the Director of Public Prosecutions together with any appropriate recommendations.

5.          In relation to cases not covered by the Police Ombudsman's jurisdiction, the Chief Constable of the Police Service of Northern Ireland is very conscious of the need to ensure that, in appropriate cases, an incident involving the security forces is investigated by persons who are independent of those implicated in the incident. For example, in a recent case where it was alleged that the security forces were implicated in a murder, be requested that the incident be investigated by a police force from England. In the light of the judgments, the Chief Constable will be mindful of the need to make use of this Power in appropriate cases.

6.          It is also to be noted that under section 11 (1) of the Coroners Act (Northern Ireland) Act 1959 (copy attached at Annex C) the Coroner receives the evidence of investigations conducted by a police constable. The Police Ombudsman has likewise made a working arrangement to pass to coroners any information obtained by her investigators.

Defects in the police investigations

7.          The Government, having considered the matter carefully, has concluded that, in view of the passage of time since the incidents in question in the four judgments, it would not be feasible to re‑open the police investigations in those cases. Nevertheless, the Coroner for Belfast has stated his intention of holding an inquest into the death of Mr Jordan and there are ongoing legal proceedings in which the family of Mr McKerr are seeking to compel the Government to provide an investigation into his death.

8.          The Chief Constable remains very mindful of the need to ensure that all allegations of crime, but particularly of serious crime such as unlawful killings, are investigated expeditiously and thoroughly.

9.          It is also to be noted that both the Police Service of Northern Ireland and the Police Ombudsman now have family liaison officers, whose duty is to keep in contact with a victim's family during the course of an investigation.

Lack of public scrutiny and information to the victims families of the reasons for the decision of the Director of Public Prosecutions not to prosecute any soldier

10.        The Director of Public Prosecutions recognised the need to evolve his policy on giving reasons to take account of the judgments of the ECHR. He has issued a statement setting out his policy and a copy of that statement is attached at Annex D.

The DPP has not given his staff any explicit directions following the judgments in these cases. The Director already has in place instructions that require him to be notified of any cases of particular difficulty or sensitivity. In practice,. it would be inconceivable for any case arising from a death allegedly caused by an agent of the state not to be drawn to his attention.

12.        Just as prosecutions in any such case would be handled personally by the Director of Deputy Director, any decision as to the giving of reasons in the event of non prosecution would also be considered at that level.

13.        The decision whether or not to give reasons for non prosecution in any given case involves the balancing of differing factors which are mainly public interest considerations. The balancing of public interest considerations is set out at length in the Court of Appeal decision R v Adams (copy attached at Annex E). It is possible, for example, that in giving reasons for a decision not to prosecute information would be made public which could cause a serious risk to an individual's safety and may raise Article 2 issues itself.

14.        It is important, therefore, that the Director continues to take a case by case approach to the giving of reasons. This emphasis on the particular circumstances of each case accords entirely with the jurisprudence of the European court, exemplified in the Jordan decision itself. A blanket requirement that he gives reasons in all cases could give rise to unfairness. The statement explaining his change of policy, therefore, is specifically worded to ensure that the Director retains the right to consider the circumstances of each case individually and reach decisions on a case by case basis, having weighed all material considerations.

15.        The Director is a public authority within the meaning of the Human Rights Act 1998 and must act accordingly. His obligations as a public authority are guided and shaped by the jurisprudence of the European Court, including the decisions in Jordan and the related cases. The Director acknowledges this, while simultaneously observing that he retains the discretion which is necessary to permit a fully informed case by case approach to be taken. His decisions maybe subjected to judicial scrutiny by judicial review proceedings at the suit of a dissatisfied interested party.

The inquest procedure did not allow any verdict or findings which might play an effective role in securing a prosecution in respect of any criminal offence which may have been disclosed.

16.        The inquest provides a public forum for the investigation of a death. The inquest is heard in a courtroom open to the public. It is the practice of coroners to sit with a jury in inquests into the deaths of persons alleged to have been killed by the security forces (although this is not a statutory obligation).

17.        The family of the deceased are fully involved participants in the inquest. The family are provided with disclosure of all statements sent to the coroner where death resulted from actions of a police officer acting in the course of his duty (see paragraph 24). A scheme to provide for legal representation. at exceptional inquests isin place (see paragraph 21 for more details).

18.        The coroner is required, as a public authority for the purposes of section 6(1) of the Human Rights Act 1998, to ensure that the scope of the inquest is appropriately wide. A person suspected of involvement in the death can be compelled to attend the inquest. The family may cross‑examine any witness. (A witness is not obliged to answer a question tending to incriminate him).

19.        Under Article 6 of the Prosecution of Offences (Northern Ireland) Order 1972 (Annex F), the Coroner is, as the Court noted, required to send to the Director of Public Prosecutions a written report where the circumstances of any death appears to disclose that a criminal offence may have been committed. The report will include all the evidence before the Coroner together with a full record of the proceedings. Upon receipt of such a report, the Director of Public Prosecutions for Northern Ireland considers the evidence then available to him to determine whether to prosecute. Such a report will either result in a prosecution or in the Director applying his new policy on the giving of reasons.

20.        The result is that the judgments of the Court, as applied through the Human Rights Act, will allow procedures to play an effective role in securing a prosecution in respect of any criminal offence which may have been disclosed. Consequently, provision for allowing verdicts of say unlawful killing in inquests is not considered necessary. It would also be problematic in an inquest held with a jury because the risk of intimidation of jurors remains very significant.

The scope of examination of the inquest was too restricted

21.        It is the duty of the coroner to decide on the scope of the inquest. The coroner is a 94 public authority" for the purposes of section 6(1) of the Human Rights Act 1998, and it is thus unlawful for him to act in a manner incompatible with the Convention rights. Accordingly, if an issue were raised at the inquest which, under Article 2 of the Convention ought to be the subject of investigation (such as an allegation of collusion by the security forces, as in paragraph 122 of the Shanaghan judgment), it is the duty of the coroner to act in a manner compatible with Article 2 and in particular to ensure that the scope of the inquest were appropriately wide. The result is that the judgments of the Court, as applied through the Human Rights Act, will allow inquest procedures which can play a role in securing a prosecution for any criminal offences which may have been revealed.

22.        As indicated above, copies of the four judgments have been. circulated to all coroners in Northern Ireland (see the letter at Annex G). The Northern Ireland Court Service is working with the Judicial Studies Board in Northern Ireland on arranging a training event, probably in early 2003, on the implications of the judgments. In particular, at that training event, training will be given about the issues which emerged

from these judgments, including the scope of inquests and the need for promptness.

The persons who shot the deceased could not be required to attend the inquest as witnesses

23.        The Lord Chancellor has brought forward an amendment to the Coroners (Practice and Procedure) Rules (Northern Ireland) 1963 so that in future a witness suspected of involvement in a death can be compelled to attend the inquest. A copy of the 1963 Rules and the amending Rules are at Annex H.

Non‑disclosure of witness statements prior to the appearance of a witness at the inquest prejudiced the ability of the families to prepare for and to participate in the inquest and contributed to long adjournments in the proceedings

24.        A Home Office Circular in April 1999 dealing with deaths in police custody has been implemented by the Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary (now the Police Service of Northern Ireland) by Force Order (see Annex 1). As a result of the implementation of this circular, the Chief Constable normally will disclose to interested persons, including the family of the deceased, the statements sent to the Coroner where death occurred in police custody or where it resulted in the actions of a police officer acting in the course of his duty.

25.        In the cases of McClory and Thompson (copies attached at Annex J) the courts in Northern Ireland have enforced the Chief Constable's duty of disclosure.

The absence of legal aid for the representation of the victim's family

26.        A scheme has been established by the Lord Chancellor to provide for legal representation at certain exceptional inquests in Northern Ireland. This legal aid scheme applies where the applicant has a sufficiently close relationship to the deceased to warrant the funding of representation. In deciding whether to grant legal aid under this scheme, the Lord Chancellor will be obliged, by virtue of the Human Rights Act, to act in a manner compatible with the Convention. Further details of the new scheme and how it has operated are given at Annex K.

The Public Interest Immunity certificate in McKerr had the effect of preventing the inquest examining matters relevant to the outstanding issues in the case

27.        The doctrine of public interest immunity operates to protect documents and/or information from disclosure in legal proceedings where such disclosure would be contrary to the public interest. In Rowe and Davis the European Court of Human Rights accepted that, in certain circumstances, the use of public interest inununity certificates is justified, even in criminal cases (see paragraph 61 of the judgment).

28.        Since the domestic proceedings in McKerr there have been two significant developments in the law and practice in relation to public interest immunity. Firstly as stated in the paper prepared on behalf of the Attorney General in 1996:

"the major change in the law has been the case of R v Chief Constable of West Midlands, ex parte Wiley in 1994. Lord Woolf made it clear that a minister could discharge his responsibility regarding material which is subject to PII by making his own judgment on whether the overall public interest favoured its disclosure. If he thought that it did, he could make disclosure without asserting PIL If he thought that it did not, or if he was in doubt, he should put the matter to the court."

A copy of the decision of the House of Lords in Wiley is attached at Annex L.

29.        Secondly, following the publication of the Report by Lord Justice Scott the Attorney General carried out a public consultation in relation to the use of public interest immunity certificates and in December 1996 announced to Parliament changes in the Government's practice in relation to public interest immunity. The major change was that the Government would no longer apply the division of claims into class and contents claims but would in future focus on the damage caused by disclosure. A copy of the Attorney General's statement and the paper is attached at Annex M.

30.        Although the paper and the statements confined themselves to England and Wales, Ministers in the Northern Ireland Office had already applied the Wiley approach and the new approach in the paper was quickly adopted in Northern Ireland. The decision of the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland in McCorley v the Governor of Her Majesty's Prison, Maghaberry illustrates the current law and practice in relation to public interest immunity in Northern Ireland. A copy of that decision is enclosed at Annex N.

The inquest proceedings did not commence promptly and were not pursued with reasonable expedition

32.         As already indicated, coroners are now required to act in a manner compatible with Article 2 of the Convention to ensure that inquest proceedings are commenced promptly and pursued with reasonable expedition.

33.        An additional full‑time Deputy Coroner has been appointed for Belfast to expedite business, so that there are now one full‑time coroner, one full‑time deputy coroner and one part‑time deputy coroner. The Northern Ireland Court Service is providing additional administrative support to part‑time coroners. The coroners in Belfast have an administrative support team of five staff and a computer system to facilitate their work. The coroners also have a dedicated legal resource and in more difficult cases counsel is instructed. For example in the Jordan inquest, the coroner is assisted by a solicitor, junior and senior counsel.

34.        The Northern Ireland Court Service is in consultation with the coroners with the purpose of improving the availability of statistics and information on outstanding inquests.

35.        Separately, officials of the Northern Ireland Court Service are aware of the need to minimise any delay in hearing inquests and, in this regard, they are in contact with individual coroners.

SECTION 4.3.

SPECIAL PROBLEMS

SCOZZARI AND GIUNTA AGAINST ITALY

Judgment of 13/07/2000 – Grand Chamber

(Interim Resolutions ResDH(2001)65 and ResDH(2001)151, CM/Inf(2001)12) et CM/Inf(2002)20

item H46-1071

see below:

Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)65

Interim Resolution ResDH(2000)151

753bis meeting – 29 May 2001

Appendix 2

(Item H46-1)

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)65
concerning the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights
of 13 July 2000 (Grand Chamber)
in the case of Scozzari and Giunta against Italy

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 29 May 2001
at the 753bis meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, as amended by Protocol No. 11 (hereinafter referred to as “the Convention”) and having regard to the Rules concerning the application of this Article,

Having regard to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in the Scozzari and Giunta case delivered and transmitted to the Committee of Ministers on 13 July 2000, in which the Court notably found two violations of Article 8 of the Convention on account, on the one hand, of the delays in organising contact visits and the limited number of such visits between the first applicant and her children, after they had been taken into public care and, on the other hand, of the placement, uninterrupted to date, of the children in a community (“Il Forteto”) among whose managers are persons convicted for ill-treatment and sexual abuse of handicapped persons placed in the community;

Having regard to the obligation of every State, under Article 46, paragraph 1, of the Convention, to abide by the judgments of the Court, in particular - as the Court also underlined in the said judgment - by putting an end to the violations found and to redress as far as possible their effects;

Having regularly examined the case since September 2000 and having invited the Government of Italy to inform it of the measures taken in consequence of the judgment, while stressing and underlining the urgency attaching to the matter;

Noting that the question of alternative placements has not been addressed by the Italian authorities and that, consequently, Ms Scozzari’s children continue to be placed in the “Forteto” community;

Noting with the greatest interest that, following Ms Scozzari’s taking up residence in Belgium, the Belgian Government has approached the Italian authorities in order to examine the possibilities of organising, by judicial means, the placement of the children in Belgium, near the mother’s place of residence, under the guardianship of the competent youth court;

Finding that such a proposal could provide the basis for a solution respecting the Court’s judgment,

Encourages, considering the urgency of the situation, the Belgian and Italian authorities to implement without delay the proposal so as to put an end to the violations found,

Decides to resume consideration of this case, if need be, at each of its meetings.

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)151

concerning the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights
of 13 July 2000 (Grand Chamber)
in the case of Scozzari and Giunta against Italy

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 3 October 2001

at the 764th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, under the terms of Article 46, paragraph 2, of the European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter referred to as “the Convention”) and having regard to the Rules concerning the application of this Article,

Having regard to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 13 July 2000 in the Scozzari and Giunta case, in which the Court notably found two violations of Article 8 of the Convention on account, first, of the delays in organising contact visits and the limited number of such visits between the first applicant and her children, after they had been taken into public care and, secondly, of the placement, uninterrupted to date, of the children in the community Il Forteto in the circumstances described in paragraphs 201 to 216 of the judgment, namely :

-             the failure of the authorities to provide full and pertinent explanations on the reasons justifying the sending of the children in this community in spite of the elements which made understandable, from an objective standpoint, the first applicant’s concerns, namely the fact that certain “Forteto” leaders with serious previous convictions for ill-treatment and sexual abuse of handicapped people placed in the community could still play an active role in bringing up the children ;

-             the fact that the implementation of the Youth Court’s decisions had been deflected from their intended purpose of allowing visits between the mother and the children to take place as a result of the attitude of the social services and of some of the leaders of Il Forteto - including one of the convicted men - who had delayed or hindered the implementation of such decisions and exercised a mounting influence on the children aimed at distancing them from their mother;

-             the doubt about who really has effective care of the children ;

-             the failure of the relevant authorities, in particular the judiciary, to increase their level of supervision;

-             the absence of any time limit on the care order;

Having furthermore regard to Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)65 adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 29 May 2001, in which the Committee, considering the urgency of the situation, encouraged the Italian and Belgian authorities to implement without delay a proposal submitted by the latter regarding an alternative placement of the children in Belgium where the mother currently lives;

Noting with interest, in this respect, that the Belgian authorities have supplemented their earlier proposal so as to organise, after adequate preparation in Italy, contacts between Ms Scozzari and her children in Belgium under the supervision and with the assistance of the competent Belgian authorities;

Having carefully examined the information so far provided by the Italian authorities on the measures taken, since September 2000, to implement the Court’s judgment and noting that, after the three preliminary meetings between the mother and her children which took place in March-April 2001, the Florence Youth Court in July 2001 notably authorised further contacts, on a monthly basis, in the presence of persons nominated by the social services from among those never previously involved in the procedure, and confirmed the placement of the children into public care in the Forteto community for an additional period of three years, which could be shortened under specific conditions;

Regretting that, more than one year after the European Court’s judgment, the latter has still not been fully executed; in fact, several problems at the basis of the Court’s finding of a violation in respect of the placement in the Forteto community have not been remedied;

Noting that the Italian authorities, on account of the above-mentioned shortcomings, have undertaken to give full effect to the Court’s judgment without delay;

Invites the Italian authorities rapidly to take concrete and effective measures in order to prevent that the children be irreversibly separated from their mother and to ensure that their placement respect the superior interests of the children and the mother’s rights, as defined by the Court in its judgment;

Encourages the Italian authorities in particular to reinforce their contacts with the Belgian authorities with a view to organising meetings very quickly between mother and children at a neutral location, pursuant to the decision of the Florence Youth Court,

Decides to resume consideration of this case, if need be, at each of its meetings.

SECTION 4.3.

SPECIAL PROBLEMS

- 2150 cases concerning the length of judicial proceedings

(see also for more detailed information, CM/Inf(98)29, CM/Inf(98)40, CM/Inf(99)37, CM/Inf(2000)40, CM/Inf(2000)40-Add and CM/Inf(2001)37 ; Interim Resolutions DH(97)336, DH(99)436, DH(99)437 and ResDH(2000)135)[4]

                   - Civil Courts

H32-1072     26017          A. and B.T., Interim Resolution DH(96)479

H32-1073     40581          A. and M.B., Interim Resolution DH(99)564

H32-1074     35284          A. L.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)565

H32-1075     31643          A., G., C. and M.B., Interim Resolution DH(97)611

H32-1076     36653          A., M., R. and R.Z., Interim Resolution DH(99)133

H32-1077     27194          A.A. and L.M., Interim Resolution DH(97)22

H32-1078     24166          A.A. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)471

H32-1079     26021          A.A. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)478

H32-1080     29135          A.A. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)365

H32-1081     35296          A.A. IV,Interim Resolution DH(98)391

H32-1082     26829          A.A.Q. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)615

H32-1083     26846          A.B. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)616

H32-1084     37874+        A.B., E.F. and C.C., Interim Resolution DH(98)392

H32-1085     30097          A.C. and C.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)444

H32-1086     26036          A.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)480

H32-1087     23588          A.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)559

H32-1088     27985          A.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)159

H32-1089     38148          A.C. VI, Interim Resolution DH(99)272

H46-461       44481          A.C. VII, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1090     26418          A.F. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)521

H32-1091     35334          A.F. V, Interim Resolution DH(98)393

H32-1092     18067          A.G. I

H32-1093     36627          A.G. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)134

H32-1094     39129          A.G. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)474

H32-1095     26413          A.I. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)522

H32-1096     35304          A.I. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)394

H32-1097     31640          A.M. A., Interim Resolution DH(97)612

H32-1100     29668          A.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)424

H32-1098     31352          A.M. L., Interim Resolution DH(97)613

H32-1099     26424          A.M. R., Interim Resolution DH(96)523

H32-1101     38488          A.P. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)370

H46-1102     35265          A.P. II, judgment of 28/07/99

H32-1103     16480          A.R.

H32-1104     24022          A.S., A.T. and M.S., Interim Resolution DH(95)262

H32-1105     25999          A.T. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)481

H32-1106     27165          A.T. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)23

H32-1107     24023          A.V., Interim Resolution DH(95)263

H46-1108     40947          Abbate (Giuseppe), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1109     28730          Abrami, Interim Resolution DH(97)246

H32-1110     26842          Adamo (Antonia), Interim Resolution DH(96)617

H46-1111     40944          Adamo (Nino Andrea), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-462       46515          Adriani, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1112     39882          Adrignola A., G., and P., Interim Resolution DH(99)566

H32-1113     34854          Agnello, Interim Resolution DH(98)395

H46-1114     40963          Aiello, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1115     49316          Albertosi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1116     29158          Albertosi, Interim Resolution DH(97)298

H32-1117     38519          Albini, Interim Resolution DH(99)371

H32-1118     40617          Alborghetti and Brivio S., E., M.C., and R., Interim Resolution DH(99)567

H46-1119     45078          Aldo Tripodi, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-1120     24033          Alessandrini, Interim Resolution DH(95)264

H46-1121     49371          Alfonsetti, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1122     44383          Alicino, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1123     34838          Allegranzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)329

H46-1124     51651          Allegri, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1125     19752          Aloe

H46-463       46964          Alpites S.P.A., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1126     45084          Altamura, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-1127     34234          Altieri and Cifani, Interim Resolution DH(98)225

H32-1128     27459          Aluffi, Interim Resolution DH(97)169

H46-1129     49353          Am. M. and S.I., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1130     37132          Amato, Interim Resolution DH(99)234

H32-1131     27495          Ambiveri and Arnoldi, Interim Resolution DH(97)91

H32-1132     26039          American Eagle S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)482

H32-1133     27982          Amighetti and Jolly Moto S.N.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)156

H46-194       52979          An.M., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1134     29155          Andreoletti, Interim Resolution DH(97)299

H32-1135     31635          Anfosso, Interim Resolution DH(97)614

H32-1136     34841          Angeli, Interim Resolution DH(98)330

H32-1137     24162          Angelone and Celeste, Interim Resolution DH(96)472

H46-464       47785          Angemi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1138     40604          Annibale, Interim Resolution DH(99)568

H32-1139     28592          Annunziata, Interim Resolution DH(99)51

H32-1140     26444          Antognelli, Interim Resolution DH(96)524

H46-1141     46993          Antonini C and A, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1142     26836          Antonini V. and I., Interim Resolution DH(96)618

H32-1143     24796          Antoniotti, Interim Resolution DH(96)38

H32-1144     27452          Aprile, Interim Resolution DH(97)51

H46-1145     45881          AR.GE.A S.n.c. en liquidation, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-465       48412          Ar.M., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1146     24163          Archimede, Interim Resolution DH(96)224

H46-466       46958          Ardemagni and Ripa, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1147     44628          Aresu, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1148     46987          Arienzo, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1149     29720          Arlistico, Interim Resolution DH(97)547

H46-1150     38098          Arnò, judgment of 09/11/99

H46-195       51671          Arrigoni, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1151     20046          Arruzzolo

H32-1152     38138          Artefice, Interim Resolution DH(99)273

H32-1153     30099          Artuso Maria Nicoletta, Interim Resolution DH(97)445

H32-467       39900          Artuso Paolo

H32-1154     28383          Ass. Consumatori San Gregorio, Interim Resolution DH(98)161

H46-196       56084          At.M., judgment of 07/05/02, final on 07/08/02

H46-1155     44456          Atzori, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1156     38520          Ausiello Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(99)372

H32-1157     30094          Ausilio, Interim Resolution DH(97)446

H32-468       39137          Avallone

H32-1158     28729          Avellani, Interim Resolution DH(97)247

H32-1159     25287          Azzarà, Interim Resolution DH(96)483

H32-1160     29129          B.A. S., Interim Resolution DH(97)300

H32-1161     26849          B.M., Interim Resolution DH(96)619

H32-1162     35940          B.Z., Interim Resolution DH(99)52

H32-1163     39119          Baffoni, Interim Resolution DH(99)476

H32-1164     28727          Baglietto, Interim Resolution DH(97)248

H32-1165     40587          Bagnarelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)570

H46-1166     44433          Bagnetti and Bellini, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-197       51678          Baioni and Badini, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1167     26410          Bakovic, Interim Resolution DH(96)525

H32-1168     37135          Balderi, Interim Resolution DH(99)135

H46-1169     49362          Baldi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1170     47001          Baldini, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1171     34852          Balzani, Interim Resolution DH(98)331

H32-1172     27964          Baracchini, Interim Resolution DH(97)142

H32-1173     38101          Baranelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)274

H32-1174     35294          Barbagiovanni Gasparo, Interim Resolution DH(98)396

H32-1175     39117          Barbarino I, Interim Resolution DH(99)477

H32-1176     39142          Barbarino II, Interim Resolution DH(99)478

H46-1177     38109          Bargagli, judgment of 09/11/99

H46-1178     49377          Barnaba, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-198       52987          Barone Antonio and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1179     49369          Baroni and Michinelli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1180     34268          Barraco, Interim Resolution DH(98)226

H32-1181     38507          Bartolini I, Interim Resolution DH(99)373

H32-1182     39895          Bartolini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)571

H46-1183     44458          Bartolini III, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1184     29662          Bartolucci, Interim Resolution DH(97)526

H32-1185     35342          Basile Bernardo Domenico, Interim Resolution DH(98)397

H32-1186     34863          Basile and Perazza, Interim Resolution DH(98)317

H32-1187     26011          Basile Rocco Antonio and Nicolò, Interim Resolution DH(96)484

H46-1188     40928          Battistelli, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1189     34260          Baudone, Interim Resolution DH(98)227

H32-1190     35921          Bazzea, Interim Resolution DH(99)53

H46-1191     49315          Bazzoni, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1192     39128          Bedin, Interim Resolution DH(99)479

H46-469       44511          Bellagamba, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1193     27969          Belletti, Interim Resolution DH(97)146

H32-1194     27476          Bellio, Interim Resolution DH(97)170

H46-470       40977          Beltramo, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-471       44431          Beluzzi and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1195     51661          Beluzzi and Mangili, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-199       52974          Beneventano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1196     30593          Berardini Angelo I, Interim Resolution DH(97)527

H32-1197     35286          Berardini Angelo II, Interim Resolution DH(99)54

H32-1198     26826          Bergonzini, Interim Resolution DH(96)620

H46-1199     44435          Berlani, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1200     34869          Bernardi, Interim Resolution DH(98)398

H32-1201     34261          Bernardoni, Interim Resolution DH(98)399

H46-1202     46995          Berto, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-200       51667          Bertot, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-472       39883          Bertozzi, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/04/00

H32-1203     38493          Bertuccelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)374

H46-1204     44388          Besati, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1205     51695          Bettella, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-473       44442          Bevilacqua, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1206     29652          Bianchi Armando, Interim Resolution DH(97)425

H32-1207     26817          Bianchi Ines, Interim Resolution DH(96)621

H32-1208     26027          Biasci, Interim Resolution DH(97)52

H46-474       36811          Bielectric S.R.L., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1209     33802          Bimbi, Interim Resolution DH(98)162

H46-1210     40937          Binelis and Nanni, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1211     49358          Bini, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1212     34266          Bisaro, Interim Resolution DH(98)228

H32-1213     26845          Bizzotto, Interim Resolution DH(97)92

H46-475       44437          Bocca, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1214     38482          Boccabella and Torlone, Interim Resolution DH(99)375

H32-1215     22944          Boccardi and Comune, Interim Resolution DH(96)225

H32-1216     35308          Bogliolo Giacomo I, Interim Resolution DH(98)400

H32-1217     35309          Bogliolo Giacomo II, Interim Resolution DH(98)401

H32-1218     35311          Bogliolo Giacomo III, Interim Resolution DH(98)402

H32-1219     27181          Bogliolo Mario, Interim Resolution DH(97)93

H32-1220     37175          Bolignari, Interim Resolution DH(99)136

H32-476       39121          Bolla

H46-1221     49313          Bonacci and others, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1222     25257          Bonaccorso, Interim Resolution DH(96)163

H32-1223     34247          Bonanno, Interim Resolution DH(98)229

H46-477       44457          Bonelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1224     38133          Bonetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)275

H32-1225     19838          Bonfanti I

H32-1226     19839          Bonfanti II

H32-1227     19840          Bonfanti III

H32-1228     19841          Bonfanti IV

H32-1229     19842          Bonfanti V

H32-1230     19843          Bonfanti VI

H32-1231     19837          Bonfanti VII, Interim Resolution DH(96)226

H32-1232     29150          Bonforte, Interim Resolution DH(97)301

H32-1233     26840          Bongianni R. and F. M., Interim Resolution DH(96)622

H32-1234     38516          Bongiovanni, Interim Resolution DH(99)376

H46-1235     45059          Bono, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-1236     39902          Bonomi A. and S., Interim Resolution DH(99)572

H32-1237     38114          Bonvicini, Interim Resolution DH(99)276

H32-1238     31347          Bordogna, Interim Resolution DH(97)615

H32-1239     33782          Borracci, Interim Resolution DH(98)163

H32-1240     37148          Borromeo, Interim Resolution DH(99)137

H32-1241     31358          Borselli, Interim Resolution DH(97)616

H32-1242     24816          Boscaro, Interim Resolution DH(96)40

H46-1243     36608          Bosio and Moretti, judgment of 06/09/99

H32-1244     30108          Botta II, Interim Resolution DH(97)447

H32-1245     27979          Botti, Interim Resolution DH(97)154

H32-1246     21075          Bottiglieri

H32-1247     29650          Bramante, Interim Resolution DH(97)426

H32-1248     40620          Bricalli, Interim Resolution DH(99)573

H46-1249     51660          Brivio, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1250     29139          Broccia, Interim Resolution DH(97)302

H32-1251     27952          Bruno Emanuele, Interim Resolution DH(97)175

H46-201       52914          Bruno Paolo, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-478       44436          Buffalo s.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1252     33790          Buldini Kotecha, Interim Resolution DH(98)164

H32-1253     32284          Buompastore, Interim Resolution DH(98)22

H32-1254     34872          Buonfino, Interim Resolution DH(98)332

H46-1255     48419          Buonocore, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-479       46534          Burghesu, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1256     39879          Burigat, Interim Resolution DH(99)574

H46-1257     51682          Butta, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1258     34857          C. C., Interim Resolution DH(98)403

H32-1259     27988          C. D.C. (Di Cara), Interim Resolution DH(97)178

H32-1260     33131          C. D.L., Interim Resolution DH(98)101

H32-1261     39898          C., G., and N.A., and T.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)575

H46-1262     49302          C.A.I.F., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1263     38146          C.B. and F.E.V., Interim Resolution DH(99)277

H32-1264     38099          C.B.S., Interim Resolution DH(99)278

H32-1265     35912          C.C. and 5 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)55

H32-1266     31330          C.I.P.D.I. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)617

H46-480       46980          C.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1267     34243          C.L.P.C., Interim Resolution DH(98)230

H32-1268     30587          C.M. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)528

H32-1269     35944          C.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)56

H32-1270     30582          C.M.R. L.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)529

H32-1271     31641          C.R.A.D.C.C. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)618

H32-1272     35340          Cacace, Interim Resolution DH(98)404

H32-1273     37151          Caccamo, Interim Resolution DH(99)138

H32-1274     39875          Caccialupi Olivieri Parteguelfa and Ciarrocchi, Interim Resolution DH(99)576

H32-1275     26443          Cacciola, Interim Resolution DH(96)647

H32-1276     31334          Cairo, Interim Resolution DH(97)619

H32-1277     34829          Calandra, Interim Resolution DH(98)318

H32-481       35292          Calandrella F., P. and 2 others

H32-1278     38129          Calanna, Interim Resolution DH(99)279

H32-1279     19830          Calaudi

H46-1280     46541          Calbini, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1281     40588          Calderone R., A.M., A.M., and E., Interim Resolution DH(99)577

H32-1282     35941          Caldora, Interim Resolution DH(99)57

H32-1283     35305          Calipso Montana s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(98)406

H32-1284     27473          Calistri, Interim Resolution DH(97)180

H32-1285     26430          Callegari, Interim Resolution DH(96)527

H46-1286     36624          Calor Sud, judgment of 26/10/99

H46-202       56092          Calvagni and Formiconi, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1287     51649          Camici, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1288     23203          Camodeca, Interim Resolution DH(96)227

H46-1289     48423          Campana, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1290     27472          Campoli, Interim Resolution DH(97)53

H32-1291     37140          Canali, Interim Resolution DH(99)139

H46-1292     51680          Canapicchi, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1293     34855          Canocchi, Interim Resolution DH(98)319

H46-1294     40959          Cantacessi, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1295     47004          Cantu, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1296     27959          Capezzali, Interim Resolution DH(97)139

H46-1297     41802          Capoccia Agnese, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-482       39881          Capodanno, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/04/00

H32-1298     38137          Caporaso Adamo, Interim Resolution DH(99)280

H46-1299     40951          Cappellaro, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-203       51696          Cappelletti and Dell’Agnese, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1300     39161          Capriotti, Interim Resolution DH(99)481

H32-1301     30583          Capulli, Interim Resolution DH(97)530

H46-1302     45074          Caputo, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1303     44382          Caracciolo, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1304     33152          Carbonaro, Interim Resolution DH(98)102

H32-1305     25265          Carbone Alessandro, Interim Resolution DH(96)211

H32-1306     38523          Carbone Benito, Interim Resolution DH(99)377

H46-1307     51702          Carbone, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-484       46526          Carboni, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1308     39165          Carcani and Monterosso, Interim Resolution DH(99)482

H32-1309     29153          Carcassi I, Interim Resolution DH(97)303

H32-1310     31339          Carcassi II, Interim Resolution DH(97)620

H32-1311     25230          Cariola E. and M.R., Interim Resolution DH(96)228

H32-1312     27179          Carlino, Interim Resolution DH(97)24

H32-1313     35297          Carloni Natale, Interim Resolution DH(98)407

H32-1314     27978          Carloni Paolo, Interim Resolution DH(97)153

H32-1315     37147          Carnevali, Interim Resolution DH(99)140

H32-1316     39159          Carozza, Interim Resolution DH(99)483

H46-1317     44516          Carrone, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1318     35301          Carrubba, Interim Resolution DH(98)408

H46-1319     44399          Cartoleria Poddighe S.N.C., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-485       45859          Caruso Giuseppina, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1320     26035          Caruso Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(96)486

H32-1321     26406          Caruso, Giardiello and Caruso, Interim Resolution DH(96)528

H32-1322     27182          Casanica, Interim Resolution DH(97)167

H32-1323     27470          Casavola, Interim Resolution DH(97)54

H32-1324     31335          Casilli, Interim Resolution DH(97)621

H32-1325     35332          Casini, Interim Resolution DH(98)409

H32-1326     37313          Cassa Edile della Provincia di Ascoli Piceno, Interim Resolution DH(99)578

H32-1327     37137          Cassandra Luigi II, Interim Resolution DH(99)207

H46-1328     40961          Cassetta, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1329     51679          Cassin, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1330     40962          Castelli Elia, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1331     35333          Castelli Massimiliano, Interim Resolution DH(98)410

H32-1332     34233          Castellucci Galtrucco, Interim Resolution DH(98)237

H46-1333     44448          Castrogiovanni, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1334     34843          Casula, Interim Resolution DH(98)411

H46-1335     46510          Catalano, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-1336     45075          Catania and Zuppelli, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 06/04/01

H32-1337     29161          Cavadini, Interim Resolution DH(97)304

H46-486       45861          Cavallaro, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1338     26860          Cavallin, Interim Resolution DH(96)623

H32-1339     38487          Cavallini and Gualersi, Interim Resolution DH(99)378

H32-1340     25215          Caviglia, Interim Resolution DH(96)164

H46-204       52915          Cazzato, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-820       25249          Cazzorla and Gigante

H32-1341     34272          Cecchi, Interim Resolution DH(98)231

H46-1342     40936          Cecere (Maria Rosaria), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1343     27479          Cecere Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(97)55

H32-1344     29138          Ceglia, Interim Resolution DH(97)305

H32-1345     37154          Celebre, Interim Resolution DH(99)141

H32-1346     29136          Celi (Lelio), Interim Resolution DH(97)306

H32-1347     29647          Celi (Leonida), Interim Resolution DH(97)427

H46-1348     44429          Centi I, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1349     44432          Centi II, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1350     39150          Centi, Interim Resolution DH(99)484

H46-1351     44377          Centineo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1352     27196          Centore, Interim Resolution DH(97)25

H32-1353     20554          Ceravolo

H46-487       36620          Ceriello, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H32-1354     34830          Cerquandi, Interim Resolution DH(98)333

H46-488       46537          Cerulli and Zadra, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1355     38504          Ceruti, Interim Resolution DH(99)379

H46-1356     48418          Cesaro, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H54-1357     22461+        Ceteroni, judgment of 15/11/96

H32-1358     35938          Chiapetto Vincenzo II, Interim Resolution DH(99)142

H46-489       45869          Chiappetta, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1359     13569          Chiarelli

H32-1360     40582          Chinnici I, Interim Resolution DH(99)579

H46-1361     49374          Chinnici II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1362     26023          CI.ME.B. S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)487

H46-1363     46989          Ciabocco, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-205       52970          Ciancetta and Mancini, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1364     27469          Cianci G. and A., Interim Resolution DH(97)56

H32-1365     35928          Cibin, Interim Resolution DH(99)58

H32-1366     22527          Cicely and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)27

H32-1367     35303          Cicerone E., S., S. and D., Interim Resolution DH(98)453

H32-1368     29654          Cicino, Interim Resolution DH(97)467

H32-1369     39168          Cilea, Interim Resolution DH(99)485

H32-1370     31333          Ciliberti, Interim Resolution DH(97)622

H32-1371     31336          Cimenti, Interim Resolution DH(97)624

H32-1372     26862          Cimini, Interim Resolution DH(96)624

H32-1373     35914          Cimino Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(99)59

H32-1374     33792          Cims Iole, Interim Resolution DH(98)165

H32-1375     31346          Cims Marco, Interim Resolution DH(97)625

H32-1376     35902          Cipolletti, Interim Resolution DH(99)60

H46-490       46959          Circo and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1377     36603          Cirillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)143

H32-1378     29648          Cirino, Interim Resolution DH(97)428

H46-1379     40955          Cittadini and Ruffini, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-491       44504          Citterio and Angiolillo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1380     46999          Ciuffetelli, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1381     27474          Ciuffetelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)94

H46-492       47779          Ciuffetti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1382     25341          Civelek, Interim Resolution DH(99)580

H32-1383     37187          Clucher, Interim Resolution DH(99)144

H46-1384     43434          Cobianchi I, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-1385     45852          Cobianchi II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1386     31344          Coccia, Interim Resolution DH(97)626

H32-1387     37167          Coduto Fernando I, Interim Resolution DH(99)145

H32-1388     37181          CodutoFernando II, Interim Resolution DH(99)146

H32-1389     38509          Cogo, Interim Resolution DH(99)380

H32-1390     40590          Colangelo, Interim Resolution DH(99)581

H46-206       56095          Colasanti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1391     35925          Colautti, Interim Resolution DH(99)61

H32-1392     26024          Comentale, Interim Resolution DH(96)488

H32-1393     20010          Condoluci and Napoli

H32-1394     29669          Condoluci, Interim Resolution DH(97)429

H46-1395     44460          Condominio Citta di Prato, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1396     34842          Condominio Rosa Dei Venti, Interim Resolution DH(98)334

H32-1397     12168          Condominio via Flaminia. 141

H46-1398     49375          Consalvo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-493       46532          Conte Gaspare and others, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-1399     32765          Conte Nunzio II, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-1400     34239          Conte Riccardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)232

H32-1401     40589          Conti Elia, Interim Resolution DH(99)582

H46-494       47774          Conti Giuliana, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1402     39160          Copropriété X., Interim Resolution DH(99)486

H32-1403     38128          Coralluzzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)281

H46-1404     48416          Corcelli, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-495       44385          Cornaglia, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-496       46527          Corsi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1405     39140          Corso and Facchetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)525

H32-1406     27201          Cortellessa, Interim Resolution DH(97)26

H46-497       35616          Coscia, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H32-1407     27199          Cosma Bonifacio, Interim Resolution DH(97)27

H46-1408     45884          Cossu, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-498       46538          Costantini Francesco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-499       44500          Cova, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1409     27164          Covi and Anzelini, Interim Resolution DH(97)28

H32-1410     19827          Crea

H46-207       56085          Cristina, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1411     49309          Crotti, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1412     24027          Crovato, Interim Resolution DH(95)275

H32-1413     20332          Crupi and others

H32-1414     40583          Cucinotta Orazio, Interim Resolution DH(99)583

H32-1415     38105          Cucinotta Tullio, Interim Resolution DH(99)282

H46-500       45880          Cultraro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1416     28384          Cunsolo, Interim Resolution DH(98)166

H32-1417     34827          Curatola, Interim Resolution DH(98)335

H32-1418     26855          Curatolo and Marucchelli, Interim Resolution DH(96)625

H32-1419     38524          Curia, Interim Resolution DH(99)381

H32-1420     25240          Curio, Interim Resolution DH(96)473

H32-1421     25226          D. and P.D.R. and L.M., Interim Resolution DH(96)167

H32-1422     34859          D. S., Interim Resolution DH(98)337

H32-1423     40576          D., F., and F.M. and M.V., Interim Resolution DH(99)584

H32-1424     27178          D.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)57

H46-501       46536          D.C. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-1425     46507          D.G., judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-1426     44533          D.I., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1427     26026          D.M. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)489

H32-1428     26448          D.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)529

H32-1429     16300          D.S. and O.P., Interim Resolution DH(96)112

H46-208       52925          D’Alfonso, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-826       44513          D’Ammassa and Frezza, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-502       45872          D’Annibale, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-503       40216          D’Arrigo and Garrozzo, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-1430     27200          D'Agata, Interim Resolution DH(97)29

H32-1431     20207          D'Agostino and Pugliese

H32-1432     38485          Dalla Pozza I, Interim Resolution DH(99)382

H32-1433     40597          Dalla Pozza II, Interim Resolution DH(99)585

H32-1434     29127          Dall'Acqua, Interim Resolution DH(97)307

H32-1435     27968          Dambra, Interim Resolution DH(97)145

H46-209       52921          Damiano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1436     49307          D'Amore, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1437     40603          Dan, Interim Resolution DH(99)586

H32-1438     29163          Danesi, Interim Resolution DH(97)308

H32-1439     36651          Danieli, Interim Resolution DH(99)235

H46-1440     45890          D'Antoni, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1441     51662          D'Apice, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1442     17482          D'Aquino and Petrizzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)28

H46-1443     49318          D'Arrigo, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1444     39147          Datti A. and F., and Bezzi, Interim Resolution DH(99)487

H32-1445     38139          De Agazio Fortunato III, Interim Resolution DH(99)283

H32-1446     37157          De Agazio Giancarlo, Interim Resolution DH(99)147

H32-1447     30102          De Camillis Emidio, Interim Resolution DH(98)168

H32-1448     23603          De Camillis Giovanni, Interim Resolution DH(97)95

H32-504       40566          De Cicco Concetta

H32-1449     33797          De Cicco Nicola, Interim Resolution DH(98)167

H32-1450     37134          De Cristofaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)148

H46-1451     51683          De Guz, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1452     40974          De Lisi, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00

H32-505       40580          De Lorenzi

H32-1453     26843          De Luca Gianni, Interim Resolution DH(96)661

H32-1454     22741          De Luca Vincenzo, Interim Resolution DH(96)34

H32-1455     24805          De Mita, Interim Resolution DH(96)45

H32-1456     26010          De Mori, Interim Resolution DH(96)491

H32-1457     36625          De Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(99)149

H46-827       49372          De Pilla, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-210       52920          De Rosa la Francesco, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1458     19559          De Santis Armando

H46-1459     49366          De Santis Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on, 25/01/02

H46-1460     49367          De Santis Guiseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-211       52923          De Santis III, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1461     44455          De Simine, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1462     35287          De Simon and Incontrera, Interim Resolution DH(98)412

H32-1463     35300          De Simone and 6 others, Interim Resolution DH(98)454

H46-506       42520          De Simone Pasquale, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1464     35949          De Simone, Interim Resolution DH(99)62

H32-1465     40567          Decaro G., A., M., and F., Interim Resolution DH(99)589

                                      final on 01/01/2003[5]

H46-212       52968          Del Bono and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1466     36640          Del Mistro, Interim Resolution DH(99)150

H32-1467     24644          Del Prete, Interim Resolution DH(96)229

H32-1468     35933          Del Sole, Interim Resolution DH(99)63

H32-1469     37183          Del Vecchio Michele, Interim Resolution DH(99)201

H32-1470     26015          Delfino, Interim Resolution DH(96)490

H46-213       56106          Dell’Aquila, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1471     32299          Della Corte, Interim Resolution DH(98)169

H46-1472     44408+        Delmonte and Badano, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1473     38469          Deschamps, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-1474     40965          Di Annunzio, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H32-1475     27974          Di Bella and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)150

H32-1476     24853          Di Blasio A. and L., Interim Resolution DH(97)96

H32-1477     38497          Di Caro, Interim Resolution DH(99)590

H32-1478     29143          Di Ciccio, Interim Resolution DH(97)470

H32-1479     37314          Di Cicco, Di Giammatteo and Fantini, Interim Resolution DH(99)644

H32-1480     34251          Di Domenico, Interim Resolution DH(98)234

H32-1481     29666          Di Donfrancesco, Interim Resolution DH(97)430

H32-1482     34851          Di Fabio I, Interim Resolution DH(98)338

H46-1483     49355          Di Fabio II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-507       39138          Di Fant I

H32-508       39139          Di Fant II

H32-1484     35910          Di Florio, Interim Resolution DH(99)64

H46-1485     44495          Di Francesco, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1486     39130          Di Gianfilippo, Interim Resolution DH(99)490

H32-1487     36629          Di Giovanni II, Interim Resolution DH(99)151

H46-828       44446          Di Girolamo and 6 others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1488     36645          Di Girolamo, Interim Resolution DH(99)152

H32-1489     25242          Di Gregorio, Interim Resolution DH(97)97

H46-1490     34256          Di Mauro, judgment of 28/07/99

H46-509       46976          Di Motoli and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-214       52978          Di Niso, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1491     35285          Di Prisco and Cappon, Interim Resolution DH(98)455

H46-1492     40970          Di Rosa, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1493     35923+        Di Salvo and Formica, Interim Resolution DH(99)65

H46-1494     45898          Di Teodoro and others, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1495     33153          Di Trapani and Crescimanno, Interim Resolution DH(98)123

H46-215       41740          Diebold, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H32-1496     26411          Diglio, Interim Resolution DH(96)530

H32-1497     34840          Dionisi, Interim Resolution DH(98)339

H32-1498     33160          Domenico and Giusa, Interim Resolution DH(98)103

H32-1499     34848          Donati, Interim Resolution DH(98)340

H32-1500     32285          Donato, Interim Resolution DH(98)23

H32-1501     29665          Donfrancesco M. and A., Interim Resolution DH(97)431

H46-1502     40925          D'Onofrio (Francesco), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-510       46520          Dorigo Franco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1503     34870          D'Orsi, Interim Resolution DH(98)336

H32-1504     29159          Dotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)370

H32-1505     38513          Dulcamara and Del Vecchio, Interim Resolution DH(99)383

H32-1506     40579          E.A., Interim Resolution DH(99)591

H32-1507     38107          E.B., E.B. and M.B., Interim Resolution DH(99)284

H32-1508     27186          E.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)30

H32-1509     38484          E.D.C., Interim Resolution DH(99)384

H32-1510     19824          E.D.G., Interim Resolution DH(97)58

H32-1511     24817          E.F. and M.C.P., Interim Resolution DH(96)46

H46-511       44480          E.G., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1512     48422          E.I., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1513     24801          E.M. and A.P., Interim Resolution DH(96)47

H46-216       44519          E.M. II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1514     23600          E.M., R.V. and A.S.S.

H32-1515     23623          E.P. I

H32-1516     26043          E.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)492

H46-1517     40953          Ediltes S.n.c., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1518     24036          Elettrodiffusion S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)35

H32-1519     27477          Elia, Interim Resolution DH(97)59

H32-512       39906          Emmebiemme S.r.l.

H46-1520     40976          Ercolino and Ambrosino, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1521     40926          F. I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1522     40971          F. II, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1523     30577          F., A.M., M.G. and P.P. S., Interim Resolution DH(97)531

H46-514       46524+        F., T. and E., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1524     27457          F.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)98

H32-1525     27458          F.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)99

H46-1526     44523          F.C. and F.G., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1527     35337          F.C. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)413

H46-1528     51653          F.CA., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1529     26409          F.D.A. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)531

H32-1530     37143          F.D.L., Interim Resolution DH(99)153

H32-1531     38505          F.D.S., Interim Resolution DH(99)385

H32-1532     39869          F.D'A III, Interim Resolution DH(99)593

H32-1533     39870          F.D'A IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)594

H32-1534     39874          F.E., Interim Resolution DH(99)595

H32-1535     26029          F.L., Interim Resolution DH(96)493

H46-515       46533          F.L.S., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1536     26421          F.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)532

H32-1537     26422          F.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)533

H32-1538     38134          F.P.R., Interim Resolution DH(99)431

H32-1539     30597          F.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)532

H46-1540     44471          F.S. II, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-516       39164          F.S.p.A. II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-517       46971          F.T., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1541     34249          F.V., Interim Resolution DH(98)235

H32-1542     38499          Fabbiano, Interim Resolution DH(99)386

H32-518       26012          Facciolini

H32-1543     38136          Facciolini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)285

H32-1544     29040          Faieta, Interim Resolution DH(98)25

H46-519       46968          Falconi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1545     38474          Faldetta, Interim Resolution DH(99)387

H32-1546     36635          Falleni A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(99)154

H46-217       52972          Falzarano Carmine, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1547     25264          Famas S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)171

H32-1548     35319          Fanni Bruno, Interim Resolution DH(98)414

H32-1549     36638          Fanni Susanna, Interim Resolution DH(99)155

H46-520       47781          Farinosi and Barattelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1550     39157          Fattore A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(99)491

H32-1551     40596          Fazioli, Interim Resolution DH(99)596

H32-1552     20042          Fedele

H46-1553     45892          Feffin, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1554     35935          Feliciano, Interim Resolution DH(99)66

H32-1555     27957          Feminella, Interim Resolution DH(97)137

H32-1556     39126          Feneziani, Interim Resolution DH(99)492

H46-1557     51675          Ferfolja, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-218       52916          Ferrara Vincenza, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1558     44405          Ferraresi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1559     25216          Ferrari Stefano, Interim Resolution DH(96)172

H32-1560     27456          Ferraro Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(97)60

H32-1561     39156          Ferrazzini, Interim Resolution DH(99)493

H46-521       45870          Ferrazzo and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1562     27197          Ferretti Amleto, Interim Resolution DH(97)31

H32-1563     26835          Ferretti Guido, Interim Resolution DH(96)626

H32-1564     39880          Ferron, Interim Resolution DH(99)597

H32-1565     33803          Ficara Carmela, Interim Resolution DH(98)170

H46-1566     45062          Ficara Domenico, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H46-522       45868          Filippello Giorgio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1567     38475          Filippello, Interim Resolution DH(99)598

H32-1568     34868          Filocamo and Dominijanni, Interim Resolution DH(98)341

H32-1569     32296          Filosa II, Interim Resolution DH(98)26

H46-1570     49317          Filosa, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1571     27464          Finvilden S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)61

H32-1572     30100          Fiorentino, Interim Resolution DH(97)448

H46-1573     44393          Fiorenza, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1574     36611          Fioretto and De Luca, Interim Resolution DH(99)156

H32-1575     26832          Firme zia Lilla, Interim Resolution DH(96)627

H32-1576     38121          Florio and Butera, Interim Resolution DH(99)286

H32-523       38145          Focardi and Conti

H32-1577     24050          Foggetti and Quaini, Interim Resolution DH(95)280

H46-1578     44424          Follo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1579     36616          Fondificio A.C.F., Interim Resolution DH(99)157

H32-1580     39166          Fontana and Sartorio, Interim Resolution DH(99)495

H32-1581     29653          Foresta, Interim Resolution DH(97)432

H32-1582     27448+        Formica, Interim Resolution DH(97)62

H32-1583     26830          Formichetti, Interim Resolution DH(97)100

H32-1584     22975          Fornara and others

H32-1585     26420          Forni, Albanese, Centro Orafo Mantovano, Interim Resolution DH(96)534

H46-1586     45079          Fortunati, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1587     46996          Fracchia, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-524       46965          Franceschetti and Odorico, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1588     26022          Franceschi, Interim Resolution DH(96)494

H46-1589     46529          Franchina, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-1590     49373          Franco, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-525       38118          Fraschetti

H32-1591     29124          Frediani, Interim Resolution DH(97)309

H32-1592     27192          Furnari A., G., G. and F., Interim Resolution DH(97)32

H32-1593     26415          Fusco G., F. and P., Interim Resolution DH(96)556

H32-1595     36655          G. D'A., Interim Resolution DH(99)159

H32-1596     16014          G. and A.P.

H46-1594     44510          G. and C.C., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H32-1597     31355          G. and I.B., Interim Resolution DH(97)628

H46-1598     46997          G. Giappichelli Editore S.r.l., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1599     31356          G. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)627

H32-1600     33161          G., R. and V. V., Interim Resolution DH(98)104

H32-1601     35945          G.A. and 7 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)67

H32-1602     19496          G.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)110

H46-526       44397          G.B. IV, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1603     33134+        G.B., A.C. and L.V., Interim Resolution DH(98)105

H32-1604     33136          G.B.C., Interim Resolution DH(98)106

H32-1605     32290          G.C. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)342

H46-1606     44441          G.C. VII, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1607     36605          G.C.VI, Interim Resolution DH(99)158

H32-1608     34236          G.D. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)236

H46-1609     44522          G.F. and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1610     31645          G.F. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)629

H32-1611     27960          G.F.I, Interim Resolution DH(97)140

H32-1612     30598          G.G. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)533

H32-1613     29660          G.G.II, Interim Resolution DH(97)433

H32-1614     26016          G.I., Interim Resolution DH(96)495

H32-1615     24315          G.L. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)173

H32-1616     30585          G.L. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)534

H46-1617     51666          G.L., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1618     40614          G.L.S., Interim Resolution DH(99)599

H32-1619     25247          G.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)174

H32-1620     27183          G.M. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)33

H32-1621     31351          G.M. VI, Interim Resolution DH(97)630

H32-1622     35330          G.M. VII, Interim Resolution DH(98)415

H46-527       37131          G.M.N., judgment of 02/11/99, final on 02/11/99

H32-1623     25266          G.M.N., Interim Resolution DH(96)175

H32-528       38503          G.P. and 25 others

H32-1624     31357          G.P. and F.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)631

H32-1625     33794          G.P. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)171

H32-1626     38123          G.P.F. and M.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)289

H32-1627     27954          G.P.M., Interim Resolution DH(97)135

H32-1628     32287          G.R. and P.M., Interim Resolution DH(98)41

H32-1629     23300          G.R. and S.D., Interim Resolution DH(97)535

H32-1630     23480          G.R. II

H46-529       46543          G.S. and L.M., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1631     26447          G.S. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)535

H32-1632     27180          G.S. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)34

H32-1633     29658          G.S. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)434

H32-1634     32281          G.S. VI, Interim Resolution DH(98)172

H32-1635     35312          G.S. VII, Interim Resolution DH(99)600

H32-1636     29670          G.V. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)435

H32-1637     32279          G.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)27

H32-1638     35341          G.V. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)416

H32-1639     38506          G.V. IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)389

H46-530       47786          G.V. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-829       44421          Galasso, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1640     35315          Galazzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)417

H46-1641     39871          Galgani and De Matteis I, judgment of 28/09/00

H46-1642     44497          Galgani and de Matteis II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-531       46963          Galiè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1643     26848          Galletti, Interim Resolution DH(96)628

H46-1644     46990          Gallo Carmelo, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1645     37163          Gambardella, Interim Resolution DH(99)160

H32-1646     33800          Gambini and Macchia, Interim Resolution DH(98)173

H32-1647     26828          Garavaglia, Interim Resolution DH(97)63

H32-1648     27956+        Garberi P. E. and M., Interim Resolution DH(97)632

H32-1649     30091          Garufi, Interim Resolution DH(97)420

H46-1650     51648          Gaspari, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1651     25225          Gasparoli, Interim Resolution DH(96)176

H32-1652     31646          Gasperoni, Interim Resolution DH(97)633

H32-1653     33140          Gatta, Interim Resolution DH(98)107

H32-1654     34242          Gatti, Interim Resolution DH(98)418

H46-1655     49304          Gatto, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1656     45873          Gaudino, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1657     36636          Gavoncini Lenci A. and A. and Scanu, Interim Resolution DH(99)161

H46-219       52984          Ge.Im.A.S.a.s., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1658     36614          Gennari, Interim Resolution DH(99)162

H46-220       56099          Genovesi, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1659     23422          Gentile Italo, Interim Resolution DH(96)536

H32-1660     19870          Gerace

H32-1661     40602          Geva S.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(99)601

H32-1662     36623          Ghedina, Interim Resolution DH(99)163

H46-1663     38116          Ghilino, judgment of 02/11/99

H32-1664     30590          Ghirardi, Interim Resolution DH(97)536

H32-1665     26019          Ghiron, Interim Resolution DH(96)496

H32-1666     35266          Giacomon, Interim Resolution DH(99)68

H32-1667     28733          Giambrone, Interim Resolution DH(97)249

H32-1668     35908          Giampietri, Interim Resolution DH(99)69

H46-1669     40942          Gianetti and De Lisi, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-532       46528          Giannalia, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-533       47773          Gianni, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1670     25245          Giardinieri, Interim Resolution DH(96)177

H46-1671     45888          Giarratana, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1672     45109          Gibertini, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-1673     33789          Gigante E. and N., Interim Resolution DH(98)192

H32-1674     35916          Gilio Benito, Interim Resolution DH(99)70

H46-1675     53361          Giomi, judgment of 05/10/00, final on 05/01/01

H32-1676     24322          Giorgi Alberti, Interim Resolution DH(95)417

H46-1677     40930          Giorgio, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1678     22572          Giovanelli and Vicentini

H46-1679     46531          Giovannangeli, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1680     21340          Giovannetti

H32-1681     18924          Giovannetti Graziani

H32-1682     32283          Giraldi Francesco, Interim Resolution DH(98)28

H32-1683     32294          Giraldi Germana, Interim Resolution DH(98)29

H32-1684     29141          Giraldi I, Interim Resolution DH(97)310

H46-534       45860          Giuseppe Nicola and Luciano Caruso, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1685     27475          Giusti I, Interim Resolution DH(97)64

H32-1686     32297          Giusti II, Interim Resolution DH(98)30

H32-1687     26838          Giusto, Interim Resolution DH(96)629

H46-1688     40941          Glebe Visconti, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1689     24542          Godet, Interim Resolution DH(96)230

H32-1690     33791          Golia Angelo, Interim Resolution DH(98)174

H32-1691     23431          Gracci, Interim Resolution DH(96)231

H32-1692     38486          Graizzaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)390

H32-1693     30092          Granatelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)449

H32-1694     21671          Granatiero Rosa and Raffaella

H32-1695     27963          Grande and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)181

H46-1696     45110          Grappio, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1697     44430          Grassi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1698     45886          Gratteri, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1699     27467          Gravagno Francesca, Interim Resolution DH(97)65

H46-1700     44512          Greco, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1701     39151          Greppi, Interim Resolution DH(99)496

H32-1702     26408          Grignano, Interim Resolution DH(96)649

H32-1703     35907          Grilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)71

H46-1704     49308          Grimaldi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1705     26020          Grio, Interim Resolution DH(96)497

H32-1706     38511          Gris, Interim Resolution DH(99)391

H46-1707     49303          Grisi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1708     27986          Gualtieri, Interim Resolution DH(97)160

H46-1709     49321          Guarnieri, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1710     24782          Gubitosi, Interim Resolution DH(96)51

H46-1711     52975          Gucci, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02, arrêt révisé le 01/10/2002,

H46-221       44413          Guerrera Angelo Giuseppe, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-1712     44403          Guerrera I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1713     44423          Guerrera II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1714     33144          Guetti G, G. and G., Interim Resolution DH(98)108

H46-1715     45896          Guidi, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1716     31639          Gurciullo and Cappello, Interim Resolution DH(97)634

H46-1717     44502          Gusso and Grasso, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1718     30109          Hay, Interim Resolution DH(97)450

H32-1719     22974          I. S. and M.A.T. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)178

H32-1720     29157          I. S. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)311

H32-1721     34839          I. S. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)343

H46-1722     40957          I., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-535       40968          I.F., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-222       51708          I.M., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-223       52957          I.P.A. S.r.l., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-536       44418          I.P.E.A. S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-537       39116          I.R., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H32-1723     36606          I.S. and M.A.T. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)165

H32-1724     35336          I.S. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)419

H32-1725     37158          I.S. V, Interim Resolution DH(99)164

H32-1726     29126          Iaconetta, Interim Resolution DH(97)312

H46-1727     44530          Iacovelli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1728     40973          Iadanza, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1729     45885          Iannelli, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1730     49359          Iannetti, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1731     30580          Ianni Domenico I, Interim Resolution DH(97)537

H32-1732     35295          Ianni Domenico II, Interim Resolution DH(98)420

H46-1733     46986          Ianni III, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-538       44447          Ianniti and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1734     44514          Iezzi and Cerritelli, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1735     45876          Il Messaggero S.a.s. I, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-539       46516          Il Messaggero S.a.s. II, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-540       46517          Il Messaggero S.a.s. III, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-541       46518          Il Messaggero S.a.s. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-542       46519          Il Messaggero S.a.s. V, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-830       44501          Il Messaggero S.A.S. VI, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1736     39154          Il quadrifoglio" calzature-pelletteria di Maria Enrica Colombo S.a.s.,

H46-543       47777          Ilardi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-544       44508          Immobiliare Il Messaggero del geometra Antonio Iorillo, judgment of 25/10/01,

                                      final on 25/01/02

H32-1737     34270          Immobiliare Li.ma. s.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(98)238

H32-1738     26853          Immobiliare San Teodoro s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)631

H32-1739     34861          Imparato Francesco, Interim Resolution DH(98)344

H32-1740     29156          Inches, Interim Resolution DH(97)313

H32-1741     28728          Inteco S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)250

H32-1742     33786          Iorillo Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(98)175

H46-1743     45875          Iorillo Debora, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-224       56088          IT.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-225       44396          Ital Union Servizi S.a.s. n° 1, judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[6]

H46-226       44913          Ital Union Servizi S.a.s. n° 2, judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[7]

H46-227       44914          Ital Union Servizi S.a.s. n° 3, judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[8]

H46-545       39894          Italiano, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-546       46530          Iulio, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1744     35291          L. P., Ga. C. and Gi. C., Interim Resolution DH(98)421

H46-547       40924          L. S.r.l., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1745     44515          L., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1746     26018          L.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)498

H32-1747     26040          L.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)650

H32-1748     24024          L.D.C., Interim Resolution DH(95)284

H32-1749     35922          L.D.T., Interim Resolution DH(99)72

H32-1750     27973          L.F. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)149

H32-1751     30088          L.F. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)451

H32-1752     36646          L.G. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)166

H32-1753     40575          L.G. IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)602

H46-1754     39487          L.G.S. S.p.a. II, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-1755     40980          L.G.S. S.p.a., judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H32-1756     31354          L.L., C.S. and S.M., Interim Resolution DH(97)635

H32-1757     24825          L.M. V, Interim Resolution DH(96)474

H32-1758     32276          L.M. VI, Interim Resolution DH(98)31

H32-1759     36633          L.M.L., Interim Resolution DH(99)167

H32-1760     30576          L.P. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)538

H32-1761     36631          L.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)168

H32-1762     31329          L.R. B., Interim Resolution DH(97)636

H32-1763     27958          L.S. and T.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)138

H46-228       52986          L.S., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1764     26423          L.U., Interim Resolution DH(96)537

H32-1765     18664          La Ferrara and others

H32-1766     34853          La Gorga, Interim Resolution DH(98)422

H32-1767     33788          La Mantia, Interim Resolution DH(98)176

H32-1768     34845          La Monica, Interim Resolution DH(98)345

H32-1769     13570          La Porta

H32-1770     39152          La Rosa, Interim Resolution DH(99)498

H32-1771     38100          La Torre, Interim Resolution DH(99)290

H32-1772     28731          Labate A., G., S. and B., Interim Resolution DH(97)251

H46-1773     44520          Lagana, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1774     33158          Laino, judgment of 18/02/99

H46-548       46542          Lanino, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1775     19832          Lanzo

H32-1776     35919          Larotonda I, Interim Resolution DH(99)73

H32-1777     35920          Larotonda II, Interim Resolution DH(99)392

H32-1778     39866          Lasagna and Milandri I, Interim Resolution DH(99)603

H32-1779     39867          Lasagna and Milandri II, Interim Resolution DH(99)604

H32-1780     25237          Latella, Interim Resolution DH(96)232

H32-1781     26038          Laterza, Interim Resolution DH(96)499

H32-549       31341          Lazzari and Scagnoli

H32-1782     39144          Lazzari M. and C. and F., Interim Resolution DH(99)499

H32-1783     26844          Lazzarini, Interim Resolution DH(96)632

H32-1784     28726          Lealini, Interim Resolution DH(97)252

H32-1785     23604          Legge Massimo and Liberato, Interim Resolution DH(97)101

H32-1786     28721          Lelli G., L. and L., Interim Resolution DH(97)555

H32-1787     39158          Lenza, Di Stefano and Mancini, Interim Resolution DH(99)500

H32-1788     37171          Leo, Interim Resolution DH(99)169

H32-1789     39897          Leone Prefabbricati S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)605

H32-1790     27188          Lepore Armando I, Interim Resolution DH(97)35

H32-1791     27993          Lepore Armando II, Interim Resolution DH(97)161

H32-1792     29128          Li Donni, Interim Resolution DH(97)314

H46-1793     44394          Liberatore, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1794     35331          Liberi, Interim Resolution DH(98)423

H46-1795     40950          Liddo and Batteta, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1796     49376          Lilla Santilli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1797     31327          Lilloni, Interim Resolution DH(97)638

H32-1798     34835          Limardi, Interim Resolution DH(98)346

H32-1799     35930          Lipari, Interim Resolution DH(99)74

H46-1800     45055          Lippera Zaniboni, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-1801     38122          Lispi, Interim Resolution DH(99)291

H32-1802     29167          Litardi, Interim Resolution DH(97)315

H32-1803     34860          Liut, Interim Resolution DH(98)347

H46-550       45853          Lo Cicero, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-551       40571          Lo Sardo

H32-1804     35915          Lodi and Delmonte, Interim Resolution DH(99)75

H32-1805     25239          Lombardi Satriani I, Interim Resolution DH(96)180

H32-1806     26008          Lombardi Satriani II, Interim Resolution DH(96)500

H32-1807     34831          Lombardi Satriani III, Interim Resolution DH(98)320

H32-1808     35273          Lombardi Satriani IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)424

H46-229       52958          Lombardo la Francesco, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-552       46523          Lonardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-230       51668          Lopriore, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1809     38132          Losardo, Interim Resolution DH(99)292

H32-1810     33842          Lucarini Maria Clementina II, Interim Resolution DH(99)393

H46-553       46962          Lucas International S.R.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-231       52919          Luciani, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1811     27865          Lunari, Interim Resolution DH(97)253

H32-1812     39122          Lupi Giovanni II, Interim Resolution DH(99)501

H32-1813     25244          Luzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)181

H32-1814     38126          M. and G.P., Interim Resolution DH(99)502

H32-1815     33133          M. G., Interim Resolution DH(98)110

H46-1816     40940          M. I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1817     40931          M. II, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-554       44406          M. S.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1818     33154          M., G.F. and A.T., Interim Resolution DH(98)109

H32-1819     27953          M.A.D.F., Interim Resolution DH(97)134

H46-1820     45893          M.A.I.E. S.n.c., judgment of 07/11/00, final on 06/04/01

H32-1822     26000          M.C. C., Interim Resolution DH(96)651

H32-1823     24797          M.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)53

H32-1824     39135          M.C. IX, Interim Resolution DH(99)503

H32-1825     26833          M.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(96)662

H32-1826     34263          M.C. VI, Interim Resolution DH(98)239

H32-1827     37141          M.C. VII, Interim Resolution DH(99)170

H46-1821     38478          M.C. VIII, judgment of 09/11/99

H32-1828     18253          M.C., A.C., A.N.C., G.S. and E.S.

H32-1829     25228          M.D.M., Interim Resolution DH(96)182

H32-1830     34873          M.F. C., Interim Resolution DH(98)348

H32-1831     38525          M.G. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)394

H46-1832     49305          M.I. and E.I., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1833     31647          M.L. D.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)639

H32-1834     25231          M.L. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)183

H32-1835     31353          M.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)640

H46-1836     46985          M.Q., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1837     35943          M.R. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)100

H32-1838     38496          M.R.G. and E.F., Interim Resolution DH(99)395

H32-1839     26006          M.R.V., Interim Resolution DH(96)501

H32-1840     35934          M.S. and F.B., Interim Resolution DH(99)76

H32-1841     40578          M.S.A., Interim Resolution DH(99)607

H32-1842     27168          M.T. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)36

H32-1843     34252          M.T.P., Interim Resolution DH(98)240

H32-1844     32302          M.V., Interim Resolution DH(98)32

H32-1845     37133          M.V.F. and M.O.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)171

H32-1846     27169          M.Z., Interim Resolution DH(97)77

H32-1847     26028          Ma. C., Interim Resolution DH(96)652

H32-1848     25214          MA.RI.OR. S.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(96)184

H32-1849     37159          Maccà Amelia I, Interim Resolution DH(99)172

H32-1850     38110          Maccà Amelia II, Interim Resolution DH(99)293

H46-1851     44464          Maccari Ada, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1852     39877          Macelloni, Interim Resolution DH(99)608

H32-1853     29663          Maffeo and Papa, Interim Resolution DH(97)548

H32-1854     27965          Maggi and Arcangeloni, Interim Resolution DH(97)143

H32-1855     39896          Maggioni and Rota, Interim Resolution DH(99)609

H32-1856     25263          Maggiore, Interim Resolution DH(96)185

H32-1857     35903          Magnano and Anselmo, Interim Resolution DH(99)77

H32-1858     35932          Magnante Trecco, Interim Resolution DH(99)78

H32-1859     34280          Magnaterra, Interim Resolution DH(98)241

H32-1860     27184          Magni, Interim Resolution DH(97)37

H32-1861     26007          Magno Di Gaspare, Interim Resolution DH(96)502

H32-1862     26859          Magri, Interim Resolution DH(96)633

H32-1863     34275+        Maiorano G, C., and M. and Serafini, Interim Resolution DH(98)242

H32-1864     24822          Majani S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)113

H32-1865     25221          Maldini and Garulli G. B. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)233

H46-555       46961          Maletti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1866     21076          Malvaso Maria Concetta and Carmela

H32-1867     20012          Malvaso Rocco

H32-1868     24332          Manca (Antonio Gavina), Interim Resolution DH(95)425

H46-1869     40938          Manca (Renata and Maria), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1870     31636          Manca Marisa, Interim Resolution DH(97)641

H46-1871     46994          Mancinelli, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1872     34248          Mandelli, Interim Resolution DH(98)243

H32-1873     38104          Manieri, Interim Resolution DH(99)294

H46-232       51706          Mannari, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1874     34241          Manni Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(98)244

H32-1875     29132          Manni, Interim Resolution DH(97)371

H32-1876     31350          Manotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)642

H32-1877     35314          Mansueto, Interim Resolution DH(98)425

H46-1878     44498          Mantini II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-821       28725          Manzi A., B. and L.

H32-1879     29154          Manzinali, Interim Resolution DH(97)316

H46-1880     49370          Marcantoni, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1881     28734          Marcellino, Interim Resolution DH(97)256

H32-1882     32278          Marcello, Interim Resolution DH(98)33

H32-1883     33142          Marchese Carlo, Interim Resolution DH(98)111

H32-1884     26403          Marchetti Alessandro I, Interim Resolution DH(96)653

H32-1885     25882          Marchetti Alessandro II, Interim Resolution DH(97)102

H46-556       44443          Marchi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-557       46957          Marcolongo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1886     37156          Marè, Interim Resolution DH(99)208

H46-558       44517          Mari and Mangini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1887     45063          Mari I, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H46-1888     49365          Mari II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1889     38481          Marinelli and C.S.n.c. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)610

H32-1890     38514          Marinelli and C.S.n.c. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)611

H32-1891     38515          Marinelli and C.S.n.c. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)612

H32-1892     35335          Marinelli Guiseppe, Interim Resolution DH(98)426

H46-1893     49364          Marinelli Lucia, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1894     33781          Marino Liliana, Interim Resolution DH(98)177

H32-1895     26005          Marino Ruggiero, Interim Resolution DH(96)503

H32-1896     37139          Marletta, Interim Resolution DH(99)173

H32-1897     25250          Marolda, Interim Resolution DH(96)186

H32-1898     29656          Martelli and Straccia, Interim Resolution DH(97)436

H46-1899     47784          Martinetti and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1900     32298          Martino, Interim Resolution DH(98)34

H46-559       44422          Marzinotto, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1901     44496          Masala, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1902     40972          Masi, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1903     37185          Massa, Interim Resolution DH(99)174

H46-560       46966          Massaro, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-561       46979          Mastrantonio Francesca, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1904     34849          Mastrocinque Giovanni, Interim Resolution DH(98)321

H46-233       47479          Mastromauro S.R.L., judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H32-1905     27453          Matarrese and Di Masi, Interim Resolution DH(97)66

H32-1906     39141          Matera, Interim Resolution DH(99)504

H46-234       52973          Mattaliano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1907     35931          Matteoni O. F. A. and R., Interim Resolution DH(99)79

H46-562       44420          Mauri, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1908     44391          Mauti, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1909     27187          Mazzà Giuseppe and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)38

H32-1910     26044          Mazzacuva, Interim Resolution DH(96)504

H32-1911     34828          Mazzella, Interim Resolution DH(98)322

H32-1912     33779          Mazzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)178

H32-1913     31328          Mazziotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)643

H46-1914     51655          Mazzoleni and others, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1915     29142          Mazzoli and 8 others, Interim Resolution DH(97)317

H32-1916     26417          Mazzone, Interim Resolution DH(96)538

H32-1917     26254          Medzihradszky, Interim Resolution DH(98)112

H32-1918     24798          Meistro and Santin, Interim Resolution DH(96)475

H46-1919     44438          Mel Sud S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1920     35917          Melchionna, Interim Resolution DH(99)80

H32-1921     26857          Meloni S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)634

H32-1922     24789          Meluso Angelo I, Interim Resolution DH(96)66

H32-1923     26416          Meluso Angelo II, Interim Resolution DH(96)539

H32-1924     38471          Meluso Angelo III, Interim Resolution DH(99)396

H32-1925     38472          Meluso Angelo IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)397

H32-1926     35288          Mengano and Morini, Interim Resolution DH(98)427

H32-1927     34269          Mercandino, Interim Resolution DH(98)245

H32-1928     30578          Merlanti, Interim Resolution DH(97)539

H32-1929     26419          Merra, Interim Resolution DH(96)540

H46-235       56101          Mesiti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1930     37168          Messina I, Interim Resolution DH(99)175

H32-1931     40574          Messina II, Interim Resolution DH(99)613

H32-1932     29146          Mezzatesta, Interim Resolution DH(97)318

H46-1933     49311          Mezzena, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1934     51654          Mezzetta, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1935     33796          Micanzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)179

H32-1936     38130          Michieli and Gentilini, Interim Resolution DH(99)295

H32-1937     34847          Milani, Interim Resolution DH(98)428

H32-1938     33798          Milano, Interim Resolution DH(98)180

H32-1939     35906          Milazzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)81

H46-1940     48403          Minici, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1941     32280          Minnai, Interim Resolution DH(98)35

H32-1942     33163          Minniti and Lucianò, Interim Resolution DH(98)113

H32-1943     25218          Minotti, Interim Resolution DH(96)187

H46-1944     45098          Miola, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1945     46540          MMB S.N.C. and Beloli, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1946     36612          Mobilio, Interim Resolution DH(99)176

H32-1947     36609          Molari, Interim Resolution DH(99)177

H46-1948     48417          Mole, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1949     51652          Molek, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1950     51650          Molinaris, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1951     34250          Monaco Maria, Interim Resolution DH(98)246

H32-1952     35909          Monorchio, Interim Resolution DH(99)82

H32-1953     39885          Montanari, Interim Resolution DH(99)614

H32-1954     32282          Monti, Interim Resolution DH(98)247

H32-1955     38492          Monticelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)398

H46-1956     49354          Morelli and Levantesi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-563       46973          Morelli and Nerattini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1957     39120          Morelli F. and G., Interim Resolution DH(99)505

H46-1958     45066          Morena, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H46-1959     48413          Morese II, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1960     40932          Morese, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1961     45067          Moretti, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-1962     26428          Moroni, Interim Resolution DH(96)542

H32-1963     37138          Morra, Interim Resolution DH(99)178

H32-1964     34267          Morticella, Interim Resolution DH(98)248

H32-1965     39143          Moscarelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)506

H46-236       52926          Mostacciuolo, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1966     36641          Mostosi, Interim Resolution DH(99)179

H32-1967     36656          Motta Umberto S.R.L., Interim Resolution DH(99)180

H32-1968     35293          Mucciola and Bottino, Interim Resolution DH(98)429

H32-1969     37153          Mugnaini Brandani, Interim Resolution DH(99)236

H46-564       44490          Murgia, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1970     46514          Murru I, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-1971     45091          Murru II, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-1972     45095          Murru III, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-1973     44386          Murru IV, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-237       56089          Murru V, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1974     34846          Musci, Interim Resolution DH(98)323

H32-1975     26002          Muso Aurelio I, Interim Resolution DH(96)505

H32-1976     30087          Muso Rosina, Interim Resolution DH(97)452

H46-1977     44507          Musti and Iarossi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1978     39868          N.M. and A.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)615

H32-1979     35329          N.Z., Interim Resolution DH(98)430

H32-1980     20043          Napoli and Mammoliti

H32-1981     27970          Nardelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)147

H46-1982     40949          Nardone (Ennio and Antonella), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1983     29661          Nardone Angelo I, Interim Resolution DH(97)438

H32-1984     37173          Nardone Angelo II, Interim Resolution DH(99)181

H32-1985     29667          Nardone Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(97)437

H32-1986     27972          Naselli, Interim Resolution DH(97)148

H32-1987     39878          Nasto, Interim Resolution DH(99)616

H32-565       39872          Nata

H32-1988     38147          Nati II, Interim Resolution DH(99)296

H32-1989     33780          Nati, Interim Resolution DH(98)181

H32-1990     34277          Nazzaro, Interim Resolution DH(98)249

H32-1991     38500          Nembrini Gonzaga, Interim Resolution DH(99)399

H46-566       46522          Nolla, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1992     38124          Novello, Interim Resolution DH(99)297

H46-1993     45072          Novotny, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-1994     29646          O. S.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(97)439

H32-1995     38108          O.B. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)298

H46-1996     44506          O.B. II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1997     29657          O.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)440

H46-1998     51698          O.M., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1999     26837          O.O., Interim Resolution DH(96)635

H46-567       44494          O.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-2000     49320          Onori, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-2001     38473          Orelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)400

H32-2002     27463          Orlando and Fiorentino, Interim Resolution DH(97)67

H32-2003     35905          Orlando, Interim Resolution DH(99)101

H32-2004     36622          Orlandoni and Lapis, Interim Resolution DH(99)182

H32-2005     25232          Ottelli, Interim Resolution DH(96)476

H32-2006     26861          Ozimo and Lamanna, Interim Resolution DH(96)636

H46-2007     51692          P. and M.O., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2008     34858          P. T. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)349

H32-2009     39864          P., M.R. and C.E., Interim Resolution DH(99)618

H32-2010     37144          P.A. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)209

H32-2011     37145          P.A. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)183

H32-2012     37146          P.A. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)184

H32-2013     26441          P.B. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)543

H46-568       44468          P.B. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2014     27161          P.C. and F.Z., Interim Resolution DH(97)40

H32-2015     27976          P.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)151

H32-2016     39162          P.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)507

H32-2017     38140          P.D.B, Interim Resolution DH(99)299

H46-2018     47000          P.I., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2019     14140          P.P. I

H32-2020     27460          P.P.II, Interim Resolution DH(97)68

H32-2021     25258          P.U. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)188

H32-2022     25259          P.U. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)189

H32-2023     25260          P.U. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)190

H32-2024     40568          Padalino R., C., and M.R., Interim Resolution DH(99)619

H46-569       40570          Padalino V. and G., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-2025     35994          Paderni I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 29/06/00

H32-2026     24334          Pala, Interim Resolution DH(95)428

H32-2027     36637          Paladini, Interim Resolution DH(99)185

H32-2028     28723          Pallotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)255

H32-2029     38127          Palmisano, Interim Resolution DH(99)312

H46-2030     49310          Palumbo, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-2031     40565          Panarari and Turani, Interim Resolution DH(99)620

H32-2032     30579          Panella Bruno I, Interim Resolution DH(97)540

H32-2033     31349          Panella Bruno II, Interim Resolution DH(97)644

H32-571       21707          Panissa, D., G. and A. Vittonetto

H32-2034     35302          Panozzo, Interim Resolution DH(98)431

H32-2035     32295          Pansa, Interim Resolution DH(98)36

H46-2036     46991          Paolelli I, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2037     44463          Paolelli II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2038     26033          Paolillo and Morini, Interim Resolution DH(96)506

H32-2039     40573          Paradiso Giorgio, Interim Resolution DH(99)621

H32-2040     24331          Parisi, Interim Resolution DH(95)429

H32-2041     25219          Parodi, Interim Resolution DH(96)191

H32-2042     40585          Pasinetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)622

H32-2043     34274          Pasquali Zanotti, Interim Resolution DH(98)258

H46-2044     45101          Pasquetti, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-2045     28056          Pasquino, Interim Resolution DH(97)645

H32-2046     27160          Passarella, Interim Resolution DH(97)41

H32-2047     38096          Passerini I, Interim Resolution DH(99)300

H32-2048     38097          Passerini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)301

H32-2049     39125          Pasta, Interim Resolution DH(99)508

H46-2050     51657          Pastrello, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2051     30095          Patelli and Pesenti, Interim Resolution DH(97)666

H32-2052     29169          Patrizi I, Interim Resolution DH(97)326

H32-2053     34833          Patteri, Interim Resolution DH(98)432

H46-2054     49396          Peda, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-2055     51700          Pelagagge, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-238       56098          Pelagatti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2056     35338          Pellegrini Odilia, Interim Resolution DH(98)433

H32-2057     38489          Pepe, Interim Resolution DH(99)401

H32-2058     29664          Pepiciello, Interim Resolution DH(97)441

H32-2059     31337          Peresson, Interim Resolution DH(97)646

H46-2060     51699          Perico, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-572       39155          Perilli and Gigotti Micheli

H32-2061     24047          Perini, Interim Resolution DH(95)293

H46-2062     45894          Pernici and D'Ercole, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2063     25267          Perrone, Interim Resolution DH(96)192

H32-2064     29160          Pesaresi and 8 others, Interim Resolution DH(97)319

H32-2065     33147          Pesarin, Interim Resolution DH(98)114

H46-2066     40923          Petix, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2067     25246          Petromilli, Interim Resolution DH(96)193

H32-2068     29137          Pettinelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)320

H46-574       44380          Pettirossi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2069     25248          Pezzati, Interim Resolution DH(96)194

H32-2070     30592          Pezzilli, Interim Resolution DH(97)541

H32-2071     34278          Pezzini, Interim Resolution DH(98)250

H32-2072     31644          Pia, Interim Resolution DH(97)647

H32-2073     29162          Piazzalunga II, Interim Resolution DH(97)321

H46-2074     51697          Piccinin, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2075     26031          Piccinini I, Interim Resolution DH(96)654

H32-2076     33167          Piccininno, Interim Resolution DH(98)182

H46-2077     45878          Piccirillo Angela, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-2078     47003          Piccoli, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2079     29655          Piccolo, Interim Resolution DH(97)442

H32-2080     35942          Picconi and Puggioni, Interim Resolution DH(98)434

H32-2081     31642          Pierfederici, Interim Resolution DH(97)648

H32-2082     29140          Pierucci, Interim Resolution DH(98)115

H32-2083     34862          Pioli, Interim Resolution DH(98)350

H32-576       39899          Pirilli

H32-2084     35283          Piscopo and 5 others, Interim Resolution DH(98)435

H46-2085     45874          Pittoni, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-2086     51665          Plebani, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2087     26445          Poddighe and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)544

H32-2088     35901          Poli, Interim Resolution DH(99)83

H46-239       52976          Policriti and Gioffré, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2089     34834          Polidoro, Interim Resolution DH(98)351

H32-2090     35317          Poligamma s.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(98)436

H32-2091     24794          Polperio and 7 others I, Interim Resolution DH(96)71

H32-2092     24795          Polperio and 7 others II, Interim Resolution DH(96)72

H46-2093     44499          Pomante Pappalepore, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2094     37164          Poppi, Interim Resolution DH(99)237

H46-2095     44454          Porcelli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2096     30584          Porfilio, Interim Resolution DH(97)542

H46-2097     40967          Privitera, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-578       46967          Procaccianti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-579       46969          Procopio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2098     27955          Proietti Valeri, Interim Resolution DH(97)136

H32-2099     37593          Provide S.r.l. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)624

H32-2100     40621          Provide s.r.l. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)625

H46-2101     49312          Provide S.R.L., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-2102     13545          Provinzano

H32-2103     20235          Pucchielli

H32-2104     20208          Pucci

H32-2105     35911          Pucci and Veschi, Interim Resolution DH(99)84

H32-2106     27447          Puglia, Interim Resolution DH(97)69

H32-2107     25254          Pugliani and Cianca, Interim Resolution DH(96)195

H46-240       41803          Pupillo, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00; revised judgment on just

                                      satisfaction of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02

H32-2108     39893          Quattrone Francesco, Interim Resolution DH(99)626

H46-580       44412          Quattrone Pasquale, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-2109     40927          R. I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2110     40964          R. II, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-2111     26440          R.D., Interim Resolution DH(96)545

H46-241       52971          R.L., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2112     33156          R.L.P., Interim Resolution DH(98)183

H32-2113     30090          R.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)453

H46-2114     44526          R.P. and others, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2115     24807          R.P. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)73

H32-2116     36626          R.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)210

H32-2117     34245          R.R., Interim Resolution DH(98)251

H32-2118     36602          R.S.p.A., Interim Resolution DH(99)186

H32-2119     26425          R.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)546

H46-2120     44381          Raffa, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2121     26046          Raffi Giuliano I, Interim Resolution DH(96)507

H32-2122     26841          Raffi Giuliano II, Interim Resolution DH(96)637

H46-242       52962          Raffio, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-825       44524          Ragas, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2123     35939          Ragnolini, Interim Resolution DH(99)85

H32-2124     27171          Ragusi, Bordandini, Pattuelli and Vidimian, Interim Resolution DH(97)42

H46-581       38498          Rando, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H32-2125     27162          Ranucci, Interim Resolution DH(97)103

H46-243       52913          Rapisarda, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2126     19222          Rapotez

H32-2127     38495          Ravanelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)510

H46-2128     46984          Ravignani, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2129     35289          Redaelli Tecna S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(98)437

H32-2130     26014          Reinaudo, Interim Resolution DH(96)509

H32-2131     26847          Reni, Interim Resolution DH(96)638

H32-2132     36652          Reniero, Interim Resolution DH(99)238

                                      Interim Resolution DH(99)497

H32-2133     26001          Ricchiuto, Interim Resolution DH(96)510

H32-2134     38483          Ricci Maria Annina, Interim Resolution DH(99)402

H32-2135     35327          Ricci Riccardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)438

H46-2136     46988          Ricci Silvia, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2137     26030          Riccioni, Interim Resolution DH(96)511

H32-2138     36617          Rico Giovanni I, Interim Resolution DH(99)187

H32-2139     36618          Rico Giovanni II, Interim Resolution DH(99)188

H32-2140     17049          Righetti

H46-583       44465          Rigutto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2141     25256          Ristoro G., A. and A, Interim Resolution DH(96)196

H46-2142     49357          Rizio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2143     26404          Rizza, Interim Resolution DH(96)547

H46-244       44409          Rizzo Giuseppe, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, rectifié le 09/07/02

H32-2144     27983          Rizzo M. R. and G. and De Martino, Interim Resolution DH(97)157

H32-2145     38477          Rizzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)403

H32-2146     39892          Roberto R., M-L., C., and F., and Tudisco, Interim Resolution DH(99)627

H46-2147     51659          Roccatagliata, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2148     31345          Rocchi Almerico, Interim Resolution DH(97)649

H46-245       51664          Rodolfi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-2149     45887          Roma, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2150     26437          Romagnoli, Interim Resolution DH(96)548

H32-2151     33510          Romaniello G and A, Interim Resolution DH(98)266

H32-2152     30089          Romaniello, Interim Resolution DH(97)454

H46-246       52969          Romano Almanio Antonio, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-584       43098          Romano, judgment of 28/09/00

H32-2153     38106          Romei, Interim Resolution DH(99)302

H32-2154     40572          Rondinone, Interim Resolution DH(99)628

H46-2155     44531          Rongoni, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-2156     40948          Ronzulli, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2157     49361          Rosa Antonio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2158     36643          Rosa Elisabetta, Interim Resolution DH(99)189

H32-2159     34874          Roselli Italo I, Interim Resolution DH(98)439

H32-585       35328          Roselli Italo II

H46-2160     38480          Roselli Italo III, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-586       44479          Rosetti e Ciucci and C., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-587       44527          Rossana Ferrari, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2161     40598          Rossi Eufrasia, Interim Resolution DH(99)629

H32-2162     27971          Rossi Franca, Interim Resolution DH(97)171

H46-247       51710          Rossi Gianbattista, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-248       52988          Rossi Maria Giovanna, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2163     34238          Rossi Romano, Interim Resolution DH(98)252

H46-588       44472          Rossi Valeria, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-249       51704          Rota Giacomo and Gianfranco, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-250       51705          Rota Roberto and Giuseppe, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2164     25236          Rotella and Zuccalà, Interim Resolution DH(96)197

H46-2165     46513          Rotiroti, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-2166     27977          Ruggeri, Interim Resolution DH(97)152

H32-2167     27478          Rullo Tassone, Interim Resolution DH(97)70

H32-2168     33143          S. C. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)116

H32-2169     27962          S. D.P., Interim Resolution DH(97)141

H46-2170     40934          S., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2171     40184          S.A.GE.MA S.n.c. II, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-2172     24042          S.B., Interim Resolution DH(95)298

H32-2173     26042          S.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)78

H32-2174     26405          S.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)549

H32-2175     26407          S.D., Interim Resolution DH(96)550

H32-2176     39118          S.G., Interim Resolution DH(99)526

H32-2177     39148          S.I.E.L.P.A. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)511

H32-2178     34864          S.I.P.I. S.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(98)324

H32-2179     38508          S.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)404

H32-2180     26414          S.P. and S.V., Interim Resolution DH(96)551

H46-2181     45061          S.S., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2182     24324          Sabia, Interim Resolution DH(95)441

H46-589       44461          Sacchi Roberto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2183     25107          Sacchi, Interim Resolution DH(96)115

H32-2184     37169          Salamanca, Interim Resolution DH(99)190

H46-251       30423          Salini Costruttori Spa, Interim Resolution DH(99)673

H32-2185     38111          Salomone, Interim Resolution DH(99)303

H32-2186     36642          Saltari, Interim Resolution DH(99)240

H32-2187     30104          Salvatore I, Interim Resolution DH(97)455

H32-2188     30105          Salvatore II, Interim Resolution DH(97)456

H32-2189     30106          Salvatore III, Interim Resolution DH(97)457

H32-2190     30110          Salvatore IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)458

H32-2191     30111          Salvatore V, Interim Resolution DH(97)459

H32-2192     30112          Salvatore VI, Interim Resolution DH(97)460

H46-2193     40943          Salvatori and Gardin, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2194     49360          Salvi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H46-2195     44404          Salzano, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 04/04/01

H32-2196     31340          Sambati, Interim Resolution DH(97)650

H32-2197     27174          Samir, Interim Resolution DH(97)43

H46-822       38135          Sanna, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H32-2198     35929          Santarcangelo, Interim Resolution DH(99)86

H32-2199     30588          Santella, Interim Resolution DH(97)543

H46-2200     45895          Santini, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2201     26034          Santonocito and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)512

H46-590       44466          Santoro Valerio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-591       47780          Santorum, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2202     32288          Sapuppo, Interim Resolution DH(98)37

H32-2203     35326          Sardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)441

H32-2204     40569          Sarti, Interim Resolution DH(99)630

H46-2205     45069          Sartori, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-2206     30591          Sasso, Interim Resolution DH(97)544

H32-2207     38490          Saullo, Interim Resolution DH(99)405

H46-2208     49368          Savanna and La Selva, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2209     33166          Savini and Malaspina, Interim Resolution DH(98)117

H46-592       45854          Savino, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-252       52977          Savona II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2210     38479          Savona, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-593       44419          Sbrojavacca Pietrobon, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2211     34237          Scagliola, Interim Resolution DH(98)253

H32-2212     24021          Scala, Interim Resolution DH(95)299

H46-594       36621          Scalvini, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H46-2213     44489          Scannella Giuseppe, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2214     33793          Scannella, Interim Resolution DH(98)184

H32-2215     35904          Scappaticci A.F. and A, and Ruzza, Interim Resolution DH(99)87

H46-2216     40929          Scarano, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2217     30096          Scerra, Interim Resolution DH(97)461

H32-2218     24780          Schiavone, Interim Resolution DH(96)76

H46-2219     40623          Sciarrotta and Guarino, judgment of 05/04/00

H46-253       52918          Scinto, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2220     32286          Scipioni, Mancini C.M., B.and D., Interim Resolution DH(98)38

H32-2221     24814          Scognamiglio II, Interim Resolution DH(96)116

H32-2222     38470          Scoppio, Interim Resolution DH(99)406

H32-2223     14578          Scotti II

H32-2224     26834          Scuderi Graziella, Interim Resolution DH(96)639

H46-254       52983          Seccia, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2225     44467          Seminara, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2226     38119          Serino Luigi, Interim Resolution DH(99)304

H46-2227     49306          Servillo and D'Ambrosio, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-2228     44402          Servodidio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-255       52959          Sessa, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2229     33151          Sestito, Sestito and Zaccone, Interim Resolution DH(98)118

H32-2230     37155          Severino, Interim Resolution DH(99)191

H32-2231     33787          Sferlazza, Interim Resolution DH(98)185

H32-2232     33148          Sgrò, Interim Resolution DH(98)119

H32-2233     27984          Sgroi, Interim Resolution DH(97)158

H46-2234     40945          Siega and 7 others, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2235     40577          Siena I, Interim Resolution DH(99)631

H46-2236     48415          Siena II, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2237     26432          Siface, Interim Resolution DH(96)552

H32-2238     26825          Silvan S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)640

H46-2239     44400          Silvestri, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-2240     27176          Simonetti (N.S.), Interim Resolution DH(97)39

H32-2241     30581          Simoni, Interim Resolution DH(97)545

H32-2242     26854          Simotti A, O. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)641

H32-2243     26402          Siniscalchi and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)553

H46-2244     44493          Siper S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2245     36604          Sirol Soc. Coop. a.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)192

H46-256       52989          Sirufo, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2246     25243          SO.CO.AB.S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)291

H46-257       56093          Società Croce Gialla Romana S.a.s., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2247     35271          Società Sant'Andrea S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(98)442

H32-2248     32289          Société Générale de Sucreries, Interim Resolution DH(98)39

H32-2249     34240          Somigli, Interim Resolution DH(98)254

H46-595       44491          Sonego, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2250     33146          Sonego, Interim Resolution DH(98)120

H32-2251     39901          Sonzogno, Interim Resolution DH(99)632

H32-2252     34832          Sorace Carmelo, Interim Resolution DH(98)443

H32-2253     26004          Sorace Giuseppe I, Interim Resolution DH(96)513

H32-2254     38494          Sorace Giuseppe II, Interim Resolution DH(99)407

H32-2255     27468          Sorbo, Interim Resolution DH(97)168

H46-258       51670          Sordelli and C. S.n.c., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2256     25235          Sorrenti Alessandro II, Interim Resolution DH(96)198

H46-596       44470          Spada, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2257     35299          Spadon, Interim Resolution DH(98)444

H32-2258     27195          Spadoni Giacomo, Interim Resolution DH(97)44

H32-2259     38125          Spadoni Maurizio, Interim Resolution DH(99)305

H32-2260     39132          Spampani, Interim Resolution DH(99)512

H46-259       51711          Spanu, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-2261     46512          Sparano, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-2262     34232          Sparti, Interim Resolution DH(98)267

H46-2263     44487          Spera II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2264     26839          Spiccia, Interim Resolution DH(96)642

H32-2265     36613          Spinato, Interim Resolution DH(99)193

H46-260       56105          Spinelli, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2266     29651          Spinosi, Interim Resolution DH(97)443

H32-2267     40618          Spitale, Interim Resolution DH(99)633

H32-2268     39873          Sportelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)634

H46-261       56094          Sposito, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-597       39705          Spurio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-2269     37142          Squeo, Interim Resolution DH(99)194

H46-2270     44503          Squillante Gennaro, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2271     39136          Squillante Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(99)513

H46-262       52990          Stabile, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2272     30586          Stacchiotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)651

H32-598       39865          Staffolani

H32-2273     35282          Statile, Interim Resolution DH(98)445

H46-2274     44518          Stefanini, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-263       49314          Steiner and Hassid Steiner, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002

H32-2275     25229          Sterchele C. and C., Interim Resolution DH(96)199

H46-2276     47002          Storti, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2277     21507          Stringini, Interim Resolution DH(97)104

H32-2278     25252          Strongoli I, Interim Resolution DH(96)200

H32-2279     25253          Strongoli II, Interim Resolution DH(96)201

H46-2280     45056          Studio Tecnico AMU S.A.S., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2281     27173          Sud Ovest S.A.S., Interim Resolution DH(97)45

H32-2282     24039          T. s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(95)302

H32-2283     37165          T.A.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)88

H32-2284     24040          T.M. and M.G.C., Interim Resolution DH(95)303

H32-2285     38521          T.M.A.2 S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)408

H32-2286     35937          T.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)89

H32-2287     24803          T.S.I. s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)77

H32-2288     23566          T.-S.I., Interim Resolution DH(97)297

H32-2289     35298          Taddei, Interim Resolution DH(99)90

H46-599       44417          Tagliabue, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2290     33661          Tagliavini, Interim Resolution DH(98)446

H32-2291     36610          Talarico, Interim Resolution DH(99)239

H32-600       38102          Talenti

H46-2292     51656          Targi and Bianchi, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-2293     40933          Tarsia, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2294     33165          Tartaglia I, Interim Resolution DH(98)121

H46-2295     48402          Tartaglia II, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-601       44486          Tebaldi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2296     13692          Tedesco I

H32-2297     13693          Tedesco II

H32-2298     40593          Tedesco Mario Felice, Interim Resolution DH(99)636

H46-602       44425          Tedesco Michele, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-2299     46508          Teofili, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-2300     35913          Tesolin S.and F., Interim Resolution DH(99)91

H32-2301     30589          Tessadri, Interim Resolution DH(97)546

H46-264       51673          Tiozzo Peschiero L. and L., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2302     26436          Todesco Aldo, Interim Resolution DH(96)554

H32-2303     38468          Tommaselli C., A., M. V. and G., Interim Resolution DH(99)409

H46-2304     45862          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. I, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2305     45863          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2309     45864          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. III, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2310     45865          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. IV, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2306     45866          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. V, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2307     45867          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. VI, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-603       46539          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.P.A. VII, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-2308     56100          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. VIII, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2311     39123          Torregiani, Interim Resolution DH(99)514

H54-2312     26433          Torri, judgment of 01/07/97

H32-2313     39903          Torzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)637

H32-2314     39167          Tosone, Interim Resolution DH(99)515

H46-2315     45104          Trapani Francesco II, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-2316     34265          Trapani, Interim Resolution DH(98)255

H46-2317     44439          Traspadini, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2318     34856          Tripodi (Giacinto), Interim Resolution DH(98)352

H46-2319     40946          Tripodi (Giuseppe), judgment of 25/01/00 23/10/01, final on 25/04/00 23/01/02

H32-2320     27177          Tripodo M, C. and G. and Leonardo, Interim Resolution DH(97)46

H32-2321     34230          Trippa, Interim Resolution DH(98)256

H32-2322     38491          Triuzzi, Interim Resolution DH(99)410

H32-2323     34844          Trivellini, Interim Resolution DH(98)353

H32-2324     27961          Troccolo and Carrassi L. and C., Interim Resolution DH(97)172

H46-2325     44478          Troiani I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2326     31637          Troncato, Interim Resolution DH(98)40

H32-2327     38510          Tulli, Interim Resolution DH(99)411

H46-2328     45879          Turchini, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2329     36632          Turetta, Interim Resolution DH(99)195

H32-2330     35267          Tuso, Interim Resolution DH(98)447

H32-2331     26013          Uricchio, Interim Resolution DH(96)514

H32-2332     27198          V. and R.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)47

H32-2333     29168          V. L.S., Interim Resolution DH(97)322

H32-2334     36628          V.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)196

H32-2335     36634          V.D.P., Interim Resolution DH(99)197

H32-2336     31342          V.L., Interim Resolution DH(97)652

H32-2337     25234          V.M. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)202

H32-2338     29130          V.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)323

H32-2339     30216          V.N., Interim Resolution DH(97)653

H32-2340     33155          V.P. and F.P., Interim Resolution DH(98)122

H32-2341     26401          V.R. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)655

H32-2342     30103          V.R. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)462

H46-265       52967          Vaccarella, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2343     30101          Vaccari, Interim Resolution DH(97)463

H46-2344     46977          Vaccarisi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2345     23147          Vaggelli-Lupi, Interim Resolution DH(96)245

H46-2346     44459          Vairano, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-2347     49356          Valenti, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2348     24793          Valentini, Interim Resolution DH(96)79

H46-2349     44398          Valentino, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2350     38467          Valeri and Valeri and Rosa, Interim Resolution DH(99)412

H32-2351     37180          Valerio, Interim Resolution DH(99)198

H32-2352     34836          Valesani, Interim Resolution DH(98)354

H32-2353     27980          Valsecchi, Interim Resolution DH(97)155

H46-2354     44384          Valvo and Branca, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2355     27455          Vannucchi, Interim Resolution DH(97)71

H46-266       51707          Vanzetti, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2356     40584          Vardaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)638

H32-2357     25251          Varvaro, Interim Resolution DH(96)477

H32-2358     36607          Vasto, Interim Resolution DH(99)241

H32-2359     37172          Vattano, Interim Resolution DH(99)199

H46-267       56086          Vazzana, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-605       44488          Vecchi and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-606       44528          Vecchini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2360     34253          Vedovato, Interim Resolution DH(98)257

H46-268       52960          Ventrone, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-269       56096          Venturin, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-607       44534          Venturini Alberto I, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-2361     44535          Venturini III, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2362     33801          Verdelli, Interim Resolution DH(98)186

H32-2363     27166          Verini I, Interim Resolution DH(97)105

H32-608       40586          Verini II

H46-2364     46982          Verini III, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2365     46983          Verini IV, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2366     46992          Verini V, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2367     16087          Vernillo

H32-2368     35948          Verza, Interim Resolution DH(99)92

H32-2369     25222          Vesentini, Interim Resolution DH(96)203

H46-270       52965          Vetrone, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2370     18011          Vicari G., R., and V.

H32-2371     36654          Vicari I, Interim Resolution DH(99)200

H46-609       40599          Vicari II, judgment of 15/02/00

H32-2372     19835          Villani I

H46-2373     51663          Villanova, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2374     35306          Vincenti Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(98)448

H46-2375     40935          Vinci, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2376     38501          Viola, Interim Resolution DH(99)413

H46-610       44395          Visentin, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-611       37166          Vitale and others, judgment of 02/11/99

H32-2377     29144          Vitali I, Interim Resolution DH(97)324

H32-2378     34875          Vitone, Interim Resolution DH(98)235

H32-2379     29164          Vivian, Interim Resolution DH(97)325

H46-2380     45064          Von Berger Icilio and Luciano, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2381     26850          Von Berger Icilio I, Interim Resolution DH(96)644

H32-2382     26851          Von Berger Icilio II, Interim Resolution DH(96)645

H32-2383     26852          Von Berger Icilio III, Interim Resolution DH(96)646

H32-2384     35926          Von Berger Luciano I, Interim Resolution DH(99)93

H32-2385     35927          Von Berger Luciano II, Interim Resolution DH(99)94

H32-2386     27471          W.B., Interim Resolution DH(97)72

H46-612       44445          W.I.E. S.n.c., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-2387     45060          X200 S.R.L., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2388     39127          Zagato, Interim Resolution DH(99)516

H46-613       44462          Zanasi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2389     23587          Zanelli

H32-2390     40606          Zanon and Lazzaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)640

H32-2391     27185          Zappavigna and Andriano, Interim Resolution DH(97)48

H32-2392     27966          Zarzana, Interim Resolution DH(97)144

H32-2393     34257          Zavatta I, Interim Resolution DH(98)259

H32-2394     34259          Zavatta II, Interim Resolution DH(98)355

H32-2395     27175          Zilaghe and Dettori, Interim Resolution DH(97)49

H46-614       37079          Zironi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-2396     27451          Zoccali, Interim Resolution DH(97)73

H32-2397     39133          Zoccola, Interim Resolution DH(99)517

H46-271       52963          Zotti and Ferrara I, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-272       52964          Zotti and Ferrara II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-273       52966          Zotti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2398     45087          Zurzolo, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

                                      - Execution proceedings

H46-2399     40958          A.V. and A.B., judgment of  05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H32-2400     34273          De Luca Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(98)233

H54-2402     15797          Di Pede, judgment of 26/09/96

H32-2401     35290          Finocchiaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)494

H46-2404     40969          Muso Aurelio II, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-2405     40981          Muso Aurelio III, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H54-2403     24295          Zappia, judgment of 26/09/96

                                      - Administrative Courts

H46-615       41809          A.B. V, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-274       56226          Abate and Ferdinandi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2406     29171          Abbate (Giovanni), Interim Resolution DH(97)367

H54-2407     25587          Abenavoli, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-834       41806          Alesiani and 510 others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2408     26863          Almanno, Interim Resolution DH(96)611

H46-833       41805          Arivella, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2409     25579          B.Q., Interim Resolution DH(96)213

H32-2410     26864          Bacci Roberto Maria, Interim Resolution DH(96)612

H32-2411     25585          Bagnoli and Mazzone G., A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)214

H32-2412     34878          Barcellona, Interim Resolution DH(99)202

H32-2413     35343          Bertozzi, Vorrasi, Ciarmoli and Forgione, Interim Resolution DH(99)642

H32-832       27189          Bevilacqua

H46-616       34437          Caliendo, judgment of 14/03/00, final on 14/03/00

H46-617       41817          Caliri, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-2414     19977          Carriero, Interim Resolution DH(96)26

H32-2415     31628          Catania, Interim Resolution DH(99)414

H32-2416     25576          Cavaliero s.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(96)215

H32-2417     34882          Cecamore, Interim Resolution DH(99)203

H46-2418     44332          Cecchini, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-275       56222          Centis, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2419     29170          Cerruto, Interim Resolution DH(97)368

H32-2420     29125          Chierici B. and E., Interim Resolution DH(97)331

H46-835       41804          Ciotta, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-276       56206          Colonnello and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-2421     41811          Comitini, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-277       56208          Conte and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-278       56202          Cornia, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2422     27494          Corona Vincenzo, Interim Resolution DH(97)020

H32-2423     25577          Cosma, Interim Resolution DH(96)216

H32-2424     25588          D.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)217

H46-279       56224          D’Amore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2425     27996+        D'Amico and Altobelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)130

H46-280       56217          De Cesaris, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H54-2426     25574          De Santa, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-2427     20359          Della Sala Raffaele, Interim Resolution DH(96)614

H46-281       56205          Dente, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2428     14147+        Di Bonaventura

H46-282       56225          Di Pede II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-283       56221          Donato, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-837       44525          Ferrari Marcella II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-838       44379          Finessi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-284       56212          Folletti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2429     30600          G. D.P., Interim Resolution DH(97)525

H32-2430     25584          G.L.C., Interim Resolution DH(96)218

H32-2431     31622          G.O. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)654

H46-836       35956          Galatà and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-285       44342          Gattuso, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002

H46-286       56203          Ginocchio, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2432     25580          Giorgini, Interim Resolution DH(96)219

H54-2433     25586          Lapalorcia, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-2434     25581          Latini, Interim Resolution DH(96)220

H46-287       44334          Lattanzi and Cascia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-288       56204          Limatola, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-289       56207          Lugnan in Basile, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2435     15080          Magnaghi, Interim Resolution DH(96)379

H32-2436     27994+        Manzini and Benet, Interim Resolution DH(97)129

H46-839       44343          Massimo Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-842       44352          Massimo Giuseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-291       56220          Mastropasqua, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2437     38149          Mazzone G. and E. (I), Interim Resolution DH(99)306

H32-2438     38150          Mazzone G. and E. (II), Interim Resolution DH(99)307

H46-2439     33804          Mennitto, judgment of 05/10/00

H32-2440     25589          Mentastro, Interim Resolution DH(96)221

H46-2441     44338          Miele, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-619       41815          Monti Enrico, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-2442     17814          Mori Puddu, Interim Resolution DH(97)177

H46-620       41810          Mosca, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-2443     38526          Murgo M, O, and S. and Giannone, Interim Resolution DH(99)415

H32-2444     30322          Nani, Interim Resolution DH(98)193

H46-290       56211          Napolitano Giuseppe, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H54-2445     25839          Nicodemo, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-2446     44335          O., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2447     18908          P.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)111

H32-2448     35950+        Paglietti and 126 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)99

H46-622       41816          Paradiso Antonio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-831       15800+        Perego and Romanet

H46-292       56213          Piacenti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-293       56223          Polcari, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2449     34880          Polto Miranda, Interim Resolution DH(99)204

H46-294       56219          Presel, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-623       31631          Procaccini, judgment of 30/03/00, final on 30/03/00

H32-2450     27999+        Recinelli and Corona, Interim Resolution DH(97)132

H32-2451     27493          Recinelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)21

H32-2452     27997          Ridolfi, Interim Resolution DH(97)131

H46-840       44345          Rinaudo and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-295       56214          Ripoli I, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-296       56215          Ripoli II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2453     26865+        Rubbo and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)613

H32-2454     34881          Ruocco, Interim Resolution DH(99)643

H32-2455     25582          Sansoni, Interim Resolution DH(96)222

H32-2456     31625          Santoro Claudio, Interim Resolution DH(97)655

H46-297       56201          Sardo Salvatore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2457     29672          Scopelliti II, Interim Resolution DH(97)469

H32-2458     27484+        Serino and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)133

H32-2459     25450          Spera Michele, Interim Resolution DH(97)372

H46-298       56218          Stabile Michele, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2460     34283          Stampacchia, Interim Resolution DH(98)272

H32-2461     25583          Stracuzzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)241

H32-2462     25578          Turrina and Scattolini, Interim Resolution DH(96)223

H32-2463     31620          U. P., Interim Resolution DH(97)656

H32-2464     38152          Ullo, Interim Resolution DH(99)308

H46-299       44333          V.P. and F.D.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-841       44346          Venturini Alberto II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2465     29301          Vitali II, Interim Resolution DH(97)332

H32-2466     29302          Vitali III, Interim Resolution DH(97)333

H32-2467     39170          Zappalà, Interim Resolution DH(99)523

H46-624       41814          Zeoli and 34 others, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 05/10/00

                                      - Labour Courts

H46-2468     44390          A.V. II, judgment of 06/11/01, final on 06/02/02

H32-2469     27991+        Accuosto and Saviello, Interim Resolution DH(97)166

H46-311       51031          Aceto and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2470     38141          Altieri, Interim Resolution DH(99)313

H46-2471     48421          Altomonte, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2472     36648          Ambrosino Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(99)211

H32-2473     33145          Antonini Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(98)124

H32-2474     28771          Apicella, Interim Resolution DH(97)290

H54-2475     32375          Aprile De Puoti, judgment of 09/11/99

H46-312       51089          Armellino la Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-313       51093          Armellino Lucia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2476     44469          Ascolinio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2477     27462          Bagli and Musumeci, Interim Resolution DH(97)79

H32-2478     39891          Balbi, Interim Resolution DH(99)645

H32-2479     40605          Barone Maria, Interim Resolution DH(99)646

H32-2480     34271          Belloni, Interim Resolution DH(98)260

H46-314       52824          Belviso and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2481     38115          Ben Charfeddine, Interim Resolution DH(99)314

H32-2482     28769          Benedetto, Interim Resolution DH(97)257

H46-315       56091          Bernardini, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-316       56103          Bevilacqua Giovanni, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-317       52804          Bianco Pellegrino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-318       52816          Biondi and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-319       51030          Biondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2483     35918          Buffa, Interim Resolution DH(99)95

H32-2484     29645          C.A., Interim Resolution DH(97)418

H46-2486     45883          C.a.r.l. en Liquidation II, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2485     45882          C.a.r.l.en Liquidation I, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2487     26439          Cagnetta, Interim Resolution DH(96)559

H32-2488     28747          Cairella, Interim Resolution DH(97)258

H46-320       51150          Calabrese, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2489     48408          Calo, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2490     40595          Camerino, Interim Resolution DH(99)648

H32-2491     39169          Capoluongo Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(99)649

H32-2492     40619          Capoluongo M.R.V., Interim Resolution DH(99)650

H32-2493     28745          Caporaso Carmela, Interim Resolution DH(97)259

H32-2494     38142          Capozzi Di Stefano, Interim Resolution DH(99)316

H32-642       36615          Cappello

H32-2495     38120          Cappelloni, Interim Resolution DH(99)315

H46-2496     49319          Capri, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-643       38095          Cardillo

H46-321       51134          Cardo Cristina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-322       51146          Cardo Elisa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2497     48414          Carlucci, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-323       51127          Carolla, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2498     40612          Caruso Angelina, Interim Resolution DH(99)652

H32-2499     35339          Cascone and Marrazzo, Interim Resolution DH(98)449

H32-2500     37136          Cassandra Luigi I, Interim Resolution DH(99)213

H32-2501     40600          Celentano, Interim Resolution DH(99)653

H46-324       52835          Cerbo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2502     29131          Cherubini, Interim Resolution DH(97)369

H46-2503     56102          Ciampaglia, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-325       52801          Ciarmoli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-644       46521          Ciccardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-2504     31343          Cimadoro, Interim Resolution DH(97)623

H46-326       52815          Cimmino and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-327       51112          Circelli Maria Antonia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2505     28741          Circelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)260

H46-328       52807          Ciullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2506     28739          Cocchiaro, Interim Resolution DH(97)261

H46-646       44532          Colacrai, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-329       52821          Colangelo Domenico, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-330       51116          Colella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2507     26827          Conti Filippo, Interim Resolution DH(96)663

H32-2508     39888          Coppola, Interim Resolution DH(99)651

H32-2509     38502          Corrarello I, Interim Resolution DH(99)416

H32-2510     39149          Corrarello II, Interim Resolution DH(99)518

H32-2511     39146          Correnti, Interim Resolution DH(99)519

H46-331       51147          Crisci, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-332       51164          Crovella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-333       56104          Cullari, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-334       51149          Cuozzo Giovanna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-335       51154          Cuozzo la Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2512     28766+        Cusano and La Salvia, Interim Resolution DH(97)262

H32-2513     37186          Cutillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)214

H46-336       51163          D’Angelo Michele, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2514     33141          De Candia, Interim Resolution DH(98)125

H46-337       51125          De Filippo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2515     28763          De Luca Maria, Interim Resolution DH(97)264

H46-338       51098          De Rosa Giovanna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-339       51141          De Rosa Maria, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2516     34254          De Sando, Interim Resolution DH(98)261

H46-340       51137          Del Grosso Nicola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2517     28767          Del Pozzo, Interim Resolution DH(97)265

H46-341       51160          Del Re, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-342       51027          Del Vecchio Anna Rita, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-343       51155          Della Ratta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2518     28736          Delle Donne, Interim Resolution DH(97)266

H46-344       51129          Di Dio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-656       46975          Di Gabriele, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2519     38112          Di Gilio, Voto, Peduto and Notari, Interim Resolution DH(99)318

H46-345       51131          Di Maria, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-347       52846          Di Meo Antonio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-346       52813          Di Meo and Masotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-348       51099          Di Meo Franca, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-349       51092          Di Mezza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2520     43011          Di Niro, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-2521     23243          Di Paola, Interim Resolution DH(96)242

H46-350       51157          Di Resta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2522     40616          Di Santo, Interim Resolution DH(99)654

H46-2523     44414          Di Sisto, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-351       51143          Donato Pepe, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2524     28743          D'Onofrio (Gelsomina), Interim Resolution DH(97)263

H32-2525     39153          Dottorini, Interim Resolution DH(99)520

H46-2526     48404          Dragonetti, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2527     32292          E.Z., Interim Resolution DH(98)42

H46-2528     48420          Efisio Pisano, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2529     37184          Esposito (Loredana), Interim Resolution DH(99)215

H46-352       51119          Esposito Lucia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-659       46978          F.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2530     35269          F.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)450

H32-2531     33157          Falbo, Interim Resolution DH(98)126

H32-2532     27990          Falco, Interim Resolution DH(97)165

H46-353       51145          Falluto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-354       51121          Falzarano Pasquale, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2533     51156          Fasulo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, rectifié le 12/09/2002

H46-355       51091          Ferrara Clementina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/2002

H46-356       51128          Ferrara Serafina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2534     25220          Ferrari Giampiero, Interim Resolution DH(96)212

H54-2535     33440          Ferrari Marcella I, judgment of 28/07/99

H46-357       51144          Fiorenza Carmine, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-358       51142          Formato, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2536     40613          Formichella, Interim Resolution DH(99)655

H46-2537     45897          Forte, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-662       45855          Fr.C., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-359       52843          Franco and Basile, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2538     36619          Franklin, Interim Resolution DH(99)216

H46-360       52924          Frattini and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2539     33150          G. D. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)451

H32-2540     24826          G.B. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)59

H32-2541     39163          G.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)521

H32-2542     24779          G.B.S., Interim Resolution DH(96)60

H32-2543     30093          G.D.Z., Interim Resolution DH(97)552

H32-2544     28744          Gagliarde, Interim Resolution DH(97)267

H46-361       51161          Gagliardi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-362       51103          Gattone and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-363       51135          Gaudino Palma, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2545     37176+        Gazzo, Rossini, Poli, Dal Forno and Ferro, Interim Resolution DH(99)217

H46-364       47186          Gentile Agostino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-666       37170          Giampietro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2546     28749          Giannini, Interim Resolution DH(97)268

H46-365       52830          Giannotta and Iannella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2547     39905          Gilio Antonia, Interim Resolution DH(99)656

H46-366       51148          Gisondi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2548     48407          Giuseppina Romano, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2549     34850          Grassi, Interim Resolution DH(98)356

H46-367       51159          Grasso Alfonsina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2550     26807          Grosso, Interim Resolution DH(96)243

H46-670       39124          Guagenti, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-368       51094          Iacobucci and Lavorgna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2551     38144          Iammarino, Interim Resolution DH(99)319

H46-369       51153          Iannotta Antonietta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2552     24806          Iaria, Interim Resolution DH(96)61

H46-370       51102          Iesce and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2553     39890          Iescone, Interim Resolution DH(99)657

H32-2554     39145          Incarbone, Interim Resolution DH(99)522

H32-2555     27981          Iudica, Interim Resolution DH(97)162

H46-371       51120          Izzo Antonio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2556     39889          Izzo Domenico, Interim Resolution DH(99)658

H46-372       51170          Izzo Giovanni, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2557     24694          L.C. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)517

H32-2558     26442          La Bella, Interim Resolution DH(96)560

H46-373       51021          La Torella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-374       52802          Lagozzino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2559     28737          Lamberti, Interim Resolution DH(97)269

H32-2560     36639          Lapolla, Interim Resolution DH(99)218

H46-375       52812          Lavorgna and Iorio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2561     38103          Lentini, Interim Resolution DH(99)320

H32-2562     38512          Leonessa, Interim Resolution DH(99)417

H32-2563     37182          Leonetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)219

H32-2564     40592          Liberato, Interim Resolution DH(99)659

H32-2565     32291          Lilli, Interim Resolution DH(98)43

H46-376       51140          Lombardi Emma, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-377       51100          Lombardi Gaetana, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2566     26009          Lombardo Sestilio, Interim Resolution DH(96)518

H32-2567     28762+        Longo, D'Occhio and Bruno, Interim Resolution DH(97)270

H46-2568     48405          Lucio Mario Catillo, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2569     27446          M. D.C. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)81

H46-378       52822          Macolino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2570     29166          Maiale, Interim Resolution DH(97)330

H46-379       52819          Mancino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2571     36644          Maniglio, Interim Resolution DH(99)220

H32-2572     35936          Marasco, Interim Resolution DH(99)321

H32-2573     35947          Marchese Giuseppina, Interim Resolution DH(99)96

H32-2574     27202+        Marino Ettore and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)82

H46-380       51169          Marotta Alberto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-381       51138          Marotta Arturo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-682       37160          Marsicovetere

H32-2575     38117          Marsili, Interim Resolution DH(99)322

H46-382       51168          Martino Alfonso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2576     29123          Mascia, Interim Resolution DH(97)553

H32-2577     28750          Massimo, Interim Resolution DH(97)271

H32-2578     40608          Mastrantone, Interim Resolution DH(99)660

H46-383       52827          Mastrocinque Mafalda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2579     29649          Mastronunzio, Interim Resolution DH(97)419

H46-384       51167          Matera Tommasina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2580     42993          Mattiello, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H46-385       51101          Maturo and Vegliante, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2581     28758          Maturo, Interim Resolution DH(97)272

H46-2582     49322          Mazzacchera, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-386       52845          Mazzarelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2583     28760          Mazzilli, Interim Resolution DH(97)273

H46-387       51130          Mazzone and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-388       51158          Meccariello, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2584     30098          Mecozzi, Interim Resolution DH(97)421

H46-389       51118          Melillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-390       51677          Meneghini, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2585     28752          Mennillo, Interim Resolution DH(97)274

H46-391       52818          Meola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2586     40594          Mideo, Interim Resolution DH(99)661

H32-2587     33164          Minieri, Interim Resolution DH(98)357

H46-392       51133          Moffa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-393       52840          Mongillo Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2588     39887          Montano, Interim Resolution DH(99)662

H32-2589     38518          Morzillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)418

H32-2590     30596          Mostacciulo, Interim Resolution DH(97)549

H32-2591     32301          Mostacciuolo, Interim Resolution DH(98)44

H32-2592     26003          Napoli Elio, Interim Resolution DH(96)664

H32-2593     31348          Napoli, Interim Resolution DH(98)55

H46-2594     44415          Napolitano, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-394       44428          Nardone Antonio, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2595     51123          Natalina de Rosa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-395       51136          Nazzaro, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-396       52832          Nero and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2596     21438          Nicoletti, Interim Resolution DH(96)111

H32-2597     27191          O.F.T., Interim Resolution DH(97)83

H46-397       51029          Ocone, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2598     39886          Olgato, Interim Resolution DH(99)663

H32-2599     38522          Orsillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)419

H46-2600     40966          P., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-2601     27193          P.V.G., Interim Resolution DH(97)84

H46-398       51105          Pacifico, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-399       51114          Paduano, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2602     28756          Pagnano, Interim Resolution DH(97)275

H46-400       52829          Pallotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2603     28732          Palma, Interim Resolution DH(97)276

H46-401       51023          Palmieri Maddalena, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-402       51022          Palmieri Mario la Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-403       52841          Panza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2604     29152          Paolini, Interim Resolution DH(97)327

H32-2605     36650          Papa Saletta, Interim Resolution DH(99)222

H32-2606     36630          Pappalardo, Interim Resolution DH(99)223

H32-2607     38143          Paradiso Marilena, Interim Resolution DH(99)323

H32-2608     40611          Parente, Interim Resolution DH(99)664

H46-405       52842          Pascale Elda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-404       52837          Pascale and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-406       52826          Pascale Maria Annunziata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2609     28740          Pasquariello, Interim Resolution DH(97)277

H46-2610     44444          Pastore, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2611     32277          Patrizi II, Interim Resolution DH(98)045

H46-407       51111          Patuto Salvatore, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-408       51113          Pelosi Concetta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-409       51162          Pengue, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-410       52808          Perna Giuseppina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2612     26856          Persia, Interim Resolution DH(96)665

H32-2613     40610          Pesce Agnese, Interim Resolution DH(99)665

H32-2614     37174          Pesce Giuseppa, Interim Resolution DH(99)224

H46-411       52828          Petrillo and Petrucci, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-412       51025          Petrillo Gino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2615     36649          Petrillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)225

H32-2616     34262          Petrone, Interim Resolution DH(98)262

H46-2617     44529          Pezzuto, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2618     35946          Piazza, Interim Resolution DH(99)097

H46-2619     46509          Picconi, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H32-2620     34837          Piconi, Interim Resolution DH(98)326

H32-2621     28761          Piesco, Interim Resolution DH(97)278

H46-413       51139          Pilla Addolorata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2622     28759          Pilla Michele, Interim Resolution DH(97)279

H46-414       51024          Porto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2623     34279          Pristerà, Interim Resolution DH(98)263

H32-2624     40622          Proietti Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(99)666

H32-2625     32293          Prologo, Interim Resolution DH(98)46

H46-415       52825          Pucella and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2626     17292          R.d.R.

H32-2627     26045          R.M. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)519

H32-2628     26429          R.S. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)562

H46-416       51126          Raccio Emilia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2629     28722          Radicioni, Interim Resolution DH(97)280

H32-2630     40615          Ranaldo Pellegrino, Interim Resolution DH(99)667

H32-2631     33149          Regino, Interim Resolution DH(98)187

H46-2632     48409          Reino, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-417       51109          Restuccio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-418       51095          Riccardi Lucia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-419       52820          Riccardi Vicenzina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-420       51096          Riccio and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-421       51108          Rinaldi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2633     28753          Rinaldi, Interim Resolution DH(97)281

H46-695       46974          Risola, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-422       52823          Romano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-423       52844          Romano Rosa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2634     38113          Rotondi II, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H46-424       51151          Ruggiero, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2635     17336          Rulli

H32-2636     37162          S.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(99)226

H32-2637     34246          Sabio, Interim Resolution DH(98)264

H32-2638     40609          Saccone, Interim Resolution DH(99)668

H46-425       52833          Santagata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-426       51165          Santina Pelosi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2639     28751          Sanzari, Interim Resolution DH(97)282

H32-2640     38131          Sarli, Interim Resolution DH(99)324

H32-2641     28754          Sauchella, Interim Resolution DH(97)283

H32-2642     29165          Savoia II, Interim Resolution DH(97)328

H46-427       51090          Scaccianemici, judgment of 28/02/02, final on28/05/02

H32-2643     30107          Scagnoli, Interim Resolution DH(97)550

H46-2644     44389          Scarfone, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-428       52982          Sciacchitano and Lo Sciuto, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2645     31638          Sciarra, Interim Resolution DH(97)657

H46-429       40151          Sciarrotta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H32-2646     24784          Scognamiglio I, Interim Resolution DH(96)117

H32-2647     34255          Sellan, Interim Resolution DH(98)265

H32-2648     28746          Serena and De Filippo, Interim Resolution DH(97)284

H46-430       52917          Serino Antonella, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2649     28738          Simeone, Interim Resolution DH(97)285

H46-431       52831          Simone and Pontillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2650     27454          Società Italiana Cauzioni S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(97)85

H32-2651     30595          Soriano, Interim Resolution DH(97)551

H46-432       51115          Spagnoletti, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2652     40607          Sperandeo, Interim Resolution DH(99)669

H32-2653     34865+        Spiezio and Di Furia, Interim Resolution DH(98)358

H46-2654     48406          Stefanucci, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2655     33162          Stile, Interim Resolution DH(98)127

H46-433       52839          Tanzillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2656     51122          Tarantino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2657     40591          Tascione, Interim Resolution DH(99)670

H46-434       52836          Tazza and Zullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-435       52810          Tazza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2658     28748          Tedesco Luigi, Interim Resolution DH(97)286

H32-2659     33799          Tesauro, Interim Resolution DH(98)188

H32-2660     39876          Tola, Interim Resolution DH(99)671

H46-436       52922          Tommaso, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2661     48410          Tozzi, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-437       51152          Tretola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-702       46960          Trimboli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-438       52809          Truocchio Edmondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-439       51166          Truocchio Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-440       51124          Tudisco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2662     45108          Tullio D'Angelo, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-441       51097          Uccellini and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-442       52817          Urbano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-443       51026          Uzzo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2663     27466          V.B. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)086

H32-2664     34871          Venzo, Interim Resolution DH(98)359

H32-2665     39907          Verde, Interim Resolution DH(99)672

H32-2666     33785          Vespucci, Interim Resolution DH(98)189

H32-2667     28755          Vigliotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)287

H46-444       52811          Villari, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-843       44416          Viola, arrêts du 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02 and of 07/11/02, final on 07/02/03[9]

H32-2668     28757          Viscio, Interim Resolution DH(97)288

H32-2669     33783          Visco and Montuoro I, Interim Resolution DH(98)190

H32-2670     33784          Visco and Montuoro II, Interim Resolution DH(98)191

H46-445       52847          Viscuso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2671     27167          Vitale Rosa, Interim Resolution DH(97)87

H46-446       51028          Vitelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2672     27989          Volpe, Interim Resolution DH(97)164

H32-2673     17765          Zaffarana, Interim Resolution DH(96)244

H32-2674     36647          Zampetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)227

H46-447       51132          Zeolla, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2675     38517          Zito, Interim Resolution DH(99)420

H46-448       52814          Zoccolillo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2676     28735          Zollo, Interim Resolution DH(97)289

H32-2677     27987          Zuccardi Merli, Interim Resolution DH(97)163

H32-2678     29134          Zullino, Interim Resolution DH(97)329

H46-449       52800          Zuotto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

                                      - Criminal proceedings

H32-2679     21807+        A. and A.F. and A.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)176

H32-2680     27141          A.A.Q. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)128

H32-2681     21068          A.M. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)366

H32-2682     23356          A.R. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)47

H32-2683     21873          Achilli, Interim Resolution DH(98)91

H46-2684     35207          Aggiato, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2685     33454          Albé, Interim Resolution DH(99)421

H32-2686     22873          Arconte I, Interim Resolution DH(98)48

H32-2687     31230          Arconte II, Interim Resolution DH(99)102

H46-2688     44970          Arganese, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2689     20854          Arichetta, Interim Resolution DH(97)108

H32-2690     24920          Ballestra, Interim Resolution DH(98)268

H32-2691     27584          Bertelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)325

H32-2692     24909          Bonomo, Interim Resolution DH(99)228

H32-2693     25541          Bortolussi, Interim Resolution DH(97)554

H32-2694     27540          Brincat Joseph II, Interim Resolution DH(99)103

H46-2695     44976          C.P., judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2696     39997          Cancellieri, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2697     16752+        Capoccia Vittorio

H46-708       38878          Ciacci, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2698     27240          Cilione, Interim Resolution DH(99)326

H32-2699     33950          Cola, Interim Resolution DH(99)422

H32-2700     24854          Coser Lauro, Interim Resolution DH(97)292

H46-2701     39714          Davinelli, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2702     33969          De Blasiis, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 06/04/00

H32-2703     23968          De Santis Roberto, Interim Resolution DH(98)269

H46-709       42351          Del Giudice, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-2704     41513          Di Donato and 3 others, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2705     29077          E.M. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)229

H32-2706     16549          Emmanuele V. and G.

H46-2707     40457          F.C., judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2708     35000          F.F., Interim Resolution DH(99)423

H46-710       45267          F.R. and 3 others, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H32-2709     31009          Fabrizi, Interim Resolution DH(99)327

H46-2710     34203          Ferrarin, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 06/09/01

H32-2711     28166          Forte II, Interim Resolution DH(98)49

H32-2712     28591          Frisaldi, Interim Resolution DH(98)270

H32-2713     17043          G. and A.G. and M.C.

H46-711       41603          G.B.Z., L.Z. and S.Z., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 15/02/00

H32-2714     28664          G.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(98)456

H32-2715     28666          G.N. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)50

H32-2716     22120          G.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)465

H32-2717     33605          G.P. V, Interim Resolution DH(99)424

H32-2718     35554          G.S. VIII, Interim Resolution DH(99)425

H46-2719     37752          Gelli, judgment of 19/10/99, final on 01/02/00

H32-2720     28594          Ghignoni, Interim Resolution DH(99)104

H46-712       41094          Giannangeli, judgment of 05/07/01, final on 05/10/01

H32-2721     18138          Giner, Interim Resolution DH(95)444

H32-2722     36057          Giunchiglia, Interim Resolution DH(99)426

H46-2723     41275          Guarino Carmela, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-713       32646          Guerresi, judgment of 24/04/01, final on 24/04/01

H46-2724     40458          Ialongo, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2725     40662          Iarrobino and De Nisco, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2726     45260          Icolaro, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2727     28963          Isnardi II, Interim Resolution DH(97)659

H32-2728     23570          L.C. and P.A., Interim Resolution DH(97)464

H32-2729     22870          L.G. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)294

H32-2730     33377          L.Z., Interim Resolution DH(99)328

H46-2731     35742          Ledonne I, judgment of 12/05/99, final on 12/08/99

H46-2732     38414          Ledonne II, judgment of 12/05/99, final on 12/08/99

H32-2733     20543          Lupo, Interim Resolution DH(96)107

H32-2734     29508          M.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)329

H32-2735     22901          M.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)466

H32-2736     24904          Maggiani, Interim Resolution DH(97)660

H46-2737     41206          Mangascia, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-2738     37702          Marchetti Alessandro III, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-714       41893          Martinez, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-2739     43635          Matera Domenico, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-725       23969          Mattoccia, judgment of 25/07/00

H46-2740     43350          Maurano, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2741     23306          Milioni Guerriero and Mansueti, Interim Resolution DH(97)661

H32-2742     30605          Mongiardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)457

H32-2743     28167          Moni Mario, Interim Resolution DH(98)51

H32-2744     32045          Morelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)105

H32-2745     28903          Motalli, Interim Resolution DH(97)280

H46-2746     47681          Motta Luciana, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 06/09/01

H32-2747     25124+        Nativi, Loriga+, Interim Resolution DH(97)662

H46-715       44943          Orlandi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2748     18755          P.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)109

H46-2749     45269          P.G.F., judgment of 05/07/01, final on 05/10/01

H46-2750     37507          Palmigiano Natale, judgment of 11/01/00, final on 11/04/00

H46-716       29898          Patanè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-717       30132          Pepe Umberto, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-718       36733          Perilli

H32-719       24170          Pesce Mario

H32-2751     23310          Poidimani, Interim Resolution DH(97)173

H32-2752     35007          Profeta, Interim Resolution DH(99)428

H32-2753     29881          Puccio, Interim Resolution DH(98)458

H32-2754     29530          Rossi Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(98)459

H46-2755     40693          Rotellini and Barnabei, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2756     45480          S.G., S.M. and P.C., judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2757     36719          Saccomanno, judgment of 12/05/99, final on 12/08/99

H32-2758     21567          Salerno, Interim Resolution DH(97)174

H46-2759     43536          Schiappacasse, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2760     32728          Spissu, Interim Resolution DH(99)330

H46-2761     34081          Starace, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-2762     33749          Suraci A. and A., Interim Resolution DH(99)331

H46-2763     45264          Tommaso Palumbo, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-720       26806          U.O. I

H32-721       26781          U.O. II

H32-722       26782          U.O. III

H32-2764     33691          V.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)332

H32-2765     28839          Viezzer, Interim Resolution DH(98)271

H46-724       43199          Visintin, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2766     29510          Vocca, Interim Resolution DH(98)460

H32-2767     31461          Zaia, Interim Resolution DH(2000)21

                   - Criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages

H46-726       45856          Bacigalupi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-727       45857          Comella and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-450       46970          Contardi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-728       45858          Tesconi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

SECTION 4.3.

SPECIAL PROBLEMS

LOIZIDOU AGAINST TURKEY
Judgments of 18/12/1996 (merits) and 28/07/1998 (just satisfaction)

(Interim Resolutions DH(99)680, DH(2000)105 and ResDH(2001)80)

Item H54-2769

see below:

Interim Resolution DH(99)680

Interim Resolution DH(2000)105

Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)80

APPENDIX 11

(item H54-1)

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

________

INTERIM resolution DH (99) 680

CONCERNING THE JUDGMENT OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
OF 28 JULY 1998

IN THE CASE OF LOIZIDOU AGAINST TURKEY

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 6 October 1999
at the 682^nd meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers,

Having regard to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights of 28 July 1998 which ordered Turkey to pay to the applicant before 28 October 1998 specific sums for damages suffered and for costs and expenses ;

Considering that this judgment has been transmitted to the Committee of Ministers for supervision of its execution in accordance with Article 54 of the Convention;

Having regard to the fact that Turkey’s compliance with this judgment has been examined by the Committee of Ministers’ Deputies in subsequent meetings since September 1998;

Considering that the Government of Turkey has indicated that the sums awarded by the European Court could only be paid to the applicant in the context of a global settlement of all property cases in Cyprus and concluding that the conditions of payment envisaged by the Government of Turkey cannot be considered to be in conformity with the obligations flowing from the Court’s judgment ;

Deploring the fact that Turkey has not yet complied with the judgment by paying to the applicant the sums awarded by the Court,

Stressing the obligation undertaken by all contracting States to abide by the judgments of the Court, in accordance with Article 53 of the European Convention on Human Rights;

Strongly urges Turkey to review its position and to pay the just satisfaction awarded in this case in accordance with the conditions set out by the European Court of Human Rights so as to ensure that Turkey, as a High Contracting Party, meets its obligations under the Convention.

Appendix 19

Section 4.3

Item H54-545

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

Interim Resolution DH (2000) 105

concerning the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights
of 28 July 1998
in the case of Loizidou against Turkey

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 24 July 2000
at the 716th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, acting under the terms of Article 54 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (hereinafter referred to as “the Convention”),

Deeply deploring the fact that, to date, Turkey has still not complied with its obligations under the judgment delivered by the European Court of Human Rights on 28 July 1998 in the case of Loizidou against Turkey;

Recalling its Interim Resolution DH (99) 680 of 6 October 1999, in which, inter alia, the Committee of Ministers strongly urged Turkey to pay the just satisfaction awarded in this case so as to ensure that Turkey, as a High Contracting Party, meets its obligations under the Convention;

Recalling that, subsequently, the Chairman of the Committee of Ministers wrote to his Turkish counterpart recalling that, as for all Contracting Parties, Turkey’s obligation to abide by judgments of the Court is unconditional;

Stressing that Turkey has had ample time to fulfil in good faith in the present case its obligations,

Emphasises that the failure on the part of a High Contracting Party to comply with a judgment of the Court is unprecedented;

Declares that the refusal of Turkey to execute the judgment of the Court demonstrates a manifest disregard for its international obligations, both as a High Contracting Party to the Convention and as a member State of the Council of Europe;

In view of the gravity of the matter, strongly insists that Turkey comply fully and without any further delay with the European Court of Human Rights’ judgment of 28 July 1998.

Appendix 18

Section 4.3

(item H54-759)

COUNCIL OF EUROPE
COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS

Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)80

concerning the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights
of 28 July 1998
in the case of Loizidou against Turkey

(Adopted by the Committee of Ministers on 26 June 2001
at the 757^th meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies)

The Committee of Ministers, acting under the terms of former Article 54 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention” below),

Having regard to the judgment of the European Court of Human Rights (“the Court” below) of 28 July 1998 which ordered Turkey to pay to the applicant before 28 October 1998 specific sums for damages and for costs and expenses;

Recalling its Interim Resolution DH (2000) 105, in which it declared that the refusal of Turkey to execute the judgment of the Court demonstrated a manifest disregard for Turkey’s international obligations, both as a High Contracting Party to the Convention and as a member State of the Council of Europe, and strongly insisted that, in view of the gravity of the matter, Turkey comply fully and without any further delay with this judgment;

Very deeply deploring the fact that, to date, Turkey has still not complied with its obligations under this judgment;

Stressing that every member State of the Council of Europe must accept the principles of the rule of law and of the enjoyment by all persons within its jurisdiction of human rights and fundamental freedoms;

Stressing that acceptance of the Convention, including the compulsory jurisdiction of the Court and the binding nature of its judgments, has become a requirement for membership of the Organisation;

Stressing that the Convention is a system for the collective enforcement of the rights protected therein,

Declares the Committee’s resolve to ensure, with all means available to the Organisation, Turkey’s compliance with its obligations under this judgment,

Calls upon the authorities of the member States to take such action as they deem appropriate to this end.