1157th meeting (December 2012) / 1157e réunion (décembre 2012)

Ormancı group against Turkey / Groupe d’affaires Ormancı contre la Turquie

                       - 252 cases of length of judicial proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy /

                       - 252 affaires de durée de procédures judiciaires et d’absence de voie de recours effectif

Cases before administrative courts / Affaires devant les juridictions administratives

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations

43647/98

ORMANCI AND OTHERS

21/12/2004

21/03/2005

8030/07

AHMET İLHAN

20/10/2011

9574/03

AKAN

17/02/2009

17/05/2009

Art. 1 Prot. 1

34740/04+

AKAT AND KAYNAR

15/02/2011

15/05/2011

21868/02

ALICAN

26/01/2010

26/04/2010

75588/01

ALKIN

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

42921/02

ALTINDAĞ AND İPEK

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

69037/01

ARAÇ

21/09/2006

21/12/2006

1895/05

ARAS

17/02/2009

17/05/2009

22487/05

ATEŞSÖNMEZ

16/02/2010

16/05/2010

32837/02

AYAZ EMSAL AND OTHERS

02/06/2009

02/09/2009

8537/05

AYDIN

15/06/2010

15/09/2010

10467/02

AYIK

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

49548/99

BAŞ

24/06/2008

22/09/2009

24/09/2008

01/03/2010

47304/07

BERU

11/01/2011

11/04/2011

10655/07

BRAUN

21/02/2012

24869/05

BUHUR

20/07/2010

20/10/2010

29921/96

BÜKER

24/10/00

24/01/01

29600/02

ÇAKMAK

12/04/2007

12/07/2007

620/03

COŞKUN

21/04/2009

21/07/2009

23573/02

DANIŞ ABDULAZIZ

16/06/2009

16/09/2009

24647/04

DOĞAN YÜCEL

06/10/2009

06/01/2010

14310/05

DOĞRU AVŞAR

12/01/2010

12/04/2010

31132/96

DÖLENEKEN

06/12/2005

06/03/2006

36062/04

ERDAL ÇALIŞKAN

02/12/2008

02/03/2009

34490/03

ERDEM NUSRET

30/11/2010

29840/03

ERKAN HASAN

14/06/2007

14/09/2007

26576/02

GENÇ HASAN

31/07/2007

31/10/2007

32600/03

GÖKSEL TÜTÜN TICARET VE SANAYI A.Ş

22/09/2009

01/03/2010

6016/04

GÜRBÜZ MUSTAFA

05/01/2010

05/04/2010

42778/98

GÜVEN HATUN AND OTHERS

08/02/2005

08/05/2005

50906/99

GÜVEN MERYEM AND OTHERS

22/02/2005

22/05/2005

21175/06

HAKAN USLU

23/11/2010

23/02/2011

25580/03

HASEFE

08/01/2009

08/04/2009

23945/05

HATIPOĞLU

15/09/2009

15/12/2009

29965/05

KAN

08/02/2011

08/05/2011

49275/99

KARAKULLUKÇU

22/11/2005

22/02/2006

4520/02

KARTAL HAYRETTIN

20/10/2005

12/04/2006

68446/01

KEMAN

20/11/2007

20/02/2008

1855/02

KÖK

19/10/2006

19/01/2007

Art. 6§1 equality of arms / égalité des armes

10693/03

KORKUT

09/12/2008

05/06/2009

23453/04

KOŞAL

29/04/2008

29/09/2008

73283/01

KÖSEOĞLU

20/11/2007

02/06/2008

31301/05

KURTUCU AND OTHERS

13/07/2010

13/10/2010

7089/07

MECİT BOZKURT

20/10/2011

39327/02

METE

25/10/2005

25/01/2006

50948/99

MUSLUOĞLU AND OTHERS

14/06/2007

14/09/2007

18907/02

NARIN

15/12/2009

15/03/2010

76096/01

OLCAR

20/11/2007

20/02/2008

9508/06+

ÖNER ÖZER AND OTHERS

11/01/2011

50913/99

ÖZEL MEHMET AND OTHERS

26/04/2005

26/07/2005

50733/99

ÖZKAN NURI

09/11/2004

30/03/2005

17533/04

ÖZOĞUZ

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

45873/05

PEHLIVANOĞLU

21/07/2009

21/10/2009

41665/02

RODOPLU

23/01/2007

23/04/2007

4038/06

SADIK BILGIN

23/11/2010

11/04/2011

75834/01

ŞENOL ULUSLARARASI NAKLIYAT, İHRACAT VE TICARET LIMITED ŞIRKETI

20/05/2008

20/08/2008

8095/02

TAN RABIA AND OTHERS

31/01/2008

30/04/2008

30001/03

TARIMCI

14/10/2008

14/01/2009

5287/06

TEKNOTES MÜHENDISLIK İNŞAAT TAAHHÜT TIC. VE SAN. A.Ş.

12/10/2010

21/02/2011

23086/07

TERZI

25/01/2011

25/04/2011

41421/05

TUR-KO TURIZM YATIRIM VE TICARET A.Ş.

06/10/2009

01/03/2010

42091/02

YENGIN

20/02/2007

20/05/2007

62838/00

YIĞIT İSMAIL

25/10/2005

12/04/2006

17839/07

ZAMAN

25/01/2011

25/04/2011

42952/04

ZEYTINLI

26/01/2010

26/04/2010

Art. 1 Prot. 1


Cases before civil courts / Affaires devant les juridictions civiles

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations


34588/03

AÇIKGÖZ MUSTAFA

09/12/2008

05/06/2009

26998/04

AFSAR

15/11/2011

4212/02

AKINCIBAŞI

29/11/2007

29/02/2008

19509/07

AKSEKI

06/03/2012

14037/04+

AKSOY AND OTHERS

18/11/2008

18/02/2009

26211/06

AKSOY SELMA

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

28668/03

AKYOL ZÖHRE

04/11/2008

05/06/2009

37899/04

ANAT AND OTHERS

26/04/2011

28/11/2011

37927/04

ARSLAN VEDAT

18/01/2011

15814/04

AYRAL

14/06/2007

14/09/2007

28353/02

AZIZ AYDIN ARSLAN

02/12/2008

02/03/2009

39616/06

BABADAĞ

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

74463/01

BAHÇEYAKA

13/07/2006

13/10/2006

41902/04

BAKIRCI AND OTHERS

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

9522/03

BALTUTAN AND ANO İNŞAAT VE TICARET TTD. ŞTI

06/10/2009

06/01/2010

34656/03

BARKER

22/09/2009

22/12/2009

18535/05

BARLAS TÖRÜN

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

42422/04+

BAŞARAN AND OTHERS

16/06/2009

16/09/2009

19441/04

BIÇER AND OTHERS

20/07/2010

20/10/2010

24280/09

BUYUKKOL

04/10/2011

61/04

ÇAYĞAN

27/01/2009

27/04/2009

60176/00

ÇOLAK EBRU AND ÇOLAK TAYFUN ENGIN

30/05/2006

30/08/2006

Art. 8

21086/04

DANESHPAYEH

16/07/2009

16/10/2009

31345/05

DEMIRTÜRK

19/01/2010

19/04/2010

44031/04+

DOKDEMIR AND OTHERS

16/12/2008

06/07/2009

25759/07

DÜNDAR KAMER

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

23221/07

ERSEVEN

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

31792/06

EVCIMEN SEBAHATTIN

23/02/2010

23/05/2010

17993/09

GANIMET TASKIN

04/10/2011

18704/04

GEZER

06/10/2009

06/01/2010

Art. 1 Prot. 1

40853/05

GÜNGÖR MUSTAFA

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

52517/99

GÜNTER

22/02/2005

22/05/2005

34294/04

GÜRKAN (YAVAŞ)

23/02/2010

23/05/2010

4753/07

KAPUSIZ

07/12/2010

07/03/2011

9437/04

KARADUMAN HAMIYE AND OTHERS

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

31953/05

KARATAS

26/10/2010

11/04/2011

33106/04

KAYGISIZ

24/11/2009

24/02/2010

26136/95

M.Ö

19/05/2005

19/08/2005

38424/97

MOLIN İNŞAAT

11/01/2005

06/06/2005

61914/00

NALBANT

10/08/2006

10/11/2006

38668/07

ÖZKOKU

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

74039/01

ÖZTUNÇ

27/03/2007

27/06/2007

54673/00

ÖZTÜRK LATIF FUAT AND OTHERS

02/02/2006

02/05/2006

15966/06

POYRAZ

07/12/2010

07/03/2011

40848/04

RAHMETULLAH BINGOL

21/12/2010

21/03/2011

42710/04

SAÇLI AND OTHERS

03/02/2009

03/05/2009

40200/04

SARI

30/09/2008

30/12/2008

13767/04

SARI AND OTHERS

29/07/2008

26/01/2009

5298/06

SARUHAN AND ÇELIK

22/09/2009

22/12/2009

26518/95

SEKIN MAHMUT AND OTHERS

22/01/04

22/04/04

9577/03

ŞEN SIRACATTIN

21/12/2006

21/03/2007

17883/04

ŞENER PINAR

18/11/2008

18/02/2009

34986/05+

SENYÜREK AND ŞAHIN AND 17 OTHER APPLICATIONS

21/09/2010

21/12/2010

14015/05

ŞEREFLI AND OTHERS NO. 2

30/03/2010

04/10/2010

38521/02

ŞIŞIKOĞLU

14/06/2007

14/09/2007

1058/06

SUNA

09/11/2010

11/04/2011

27597/06

SÜRGIT

22/09/2009

22/12/2009

17940/03

SÜRMELIOĞLU

19/02/2008

07/07/2008

15614/02

TAMAR MEHMET

18/07/2006

18/10/2006

9915/03

TARAKCI

14/06/2007

14/09/2007

33379/02

TOSUN EZEL

10/01/2006

10/04/2006

17408/04

TUNCA

31/01/2008

30/04/2008

58922/00

TÜRKOĞLU

08/08/2006

08/11/2006

12974/03

TÜRKÜLER AND OTHERS

03/05/2007

03/08/2007

48264/99

ÜNAL VEHBI

09/11/2006

09/02/2007

29459/05

YALÇIN VELI

02/03/2010

19/04/2011

02/06/2010

19/07/2011

Art. 6§1 non-communication of the written opinion of the general prosecutor / noncommunication de l’avis du procureur général

25266/05

YARDIMCI

05/01/2010

28/06/2010

8472/07

YAVUZDOĞAN

31/01/2012

43709/98

YAZICIOĞLU

02/10/2007

02/01/2008

16456/03+

YILDIRIM AND OTHERS

18/03/2008

29/09/2008

6749/03

YILDIZ AND OTHERS

24/07/2007

24/10/2007

48057/99

YORGIYADIS

19/10/2004

30/03/2005

15725/07

YUMUSAK AND YILDIRIM

22/11/2011

22/02/2012

Cases before labour courts / Affaires devant les juridictions du travail

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations

34395/04

AKKAYA

02/03/2010

02/06/2010

28578/05

BILGEÇ

15/12/2009

15/03/2010

43945/04

BOSTAN

23/03/2010

23/06/2010

18308/02

DIKICI

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

54672/00

ERTÜRK HÜSEYIN

22/09/2005

22/12/2005

1395/03

GULDANE ACAR AND OTHERS

22/11/2011

22/02/2012

Art. 1 Prot. 1

10818/06

GÜRBÜZ NAIM

12/10/2010

12/01/2011

17604/04

KARADAVUT

29/01/2008

07/07/2008

22956/04

KARYAĞDI

08/01/2008

08/04/2008

7190/05

ŞAHIN ŞEVKI

09/12/2008

09/03/2009

40750/04

ŞIRIN

25/11/2008

25/02/2009


Cases before criminal courts / Affaires devant les juridictions pénales

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations


29059/02

AĞRAKÇE

04/11/2008

04/02/2009

58539/00

AKAY

24/10/2006

24/01/2007

20583/02

AKKURT ŞAKIR

29/11/2007

29/02/2008

6016/03

ALPTEKIN

16/06/2009

16/09/2009

14071/04

ARIKAN

01/12/2009

01/03/2010

3884/04

ASLANTÜRK

19/01/2010

19/04/2010

39977/98

ATKIN MEHMET

21/02/2006

21/05/2006

19878/03

BAŞARAN

22/07/2008

22/10/2008

75942/01

BAYHAN

26/06/2007

26/09/2007

25099/04

BOZOOĞLU

06/10/2009

06/01/2010

Art. 6§1 absence of hearing / défaut d’audience

17860/07

CETINKAYA No. 2

25/01/2011

25/04/2011

74939/01

DAĞ

08/08/2006

08/11/2006

12248/03

DEDEMAN

16/12/2008

16/03/2009

16444/07

DEDEOGLU

25/01/2011

25/04/2011

50165/99

DOĞAN ALI RIZA

22/12/2005

22/03/2006

17914/09

DOLUTAS

17/01/2012

53546/99

DÖNER HASAN

20/11/2007

20/02/2008

27719/02

ERDEN

20/11/2007

20/02/2008

71342/01

ERIN

10/08/2006

10/11/2006

28268/02

ERIŞ

08/01/2008

08/04/2008

10477/02

ERTEN

17/07/2008

17/10/2008

74522/01

ESEN ALI

24/07/2007

24/10/2007

5400/02

ESER

25/10/2005

25/01/2006

24468/03

GÜLBAHAR AND TUT

24/02/2009

24/05/2009

Art. 6§3c lack of legal assistance during custody / défaut d’assistance d’un avocat pendant la garde à vue;

Art. 5§3 length of detention on remand

20872/02

GÜNSELI AND YAYIK

21/02/2008

21/05/2008

20578/05

HASKO

17/01/2012

17/04/2012

29871/96

İLETMIŞ

06/12/2005

06/03/2006

Art. 8 prohibition of leaving the country / interdiction de quitter le territoire

6045/04

İMREN

16/06/2009

16/09/2009

30316/02

İZMIRLI

26/06/2007

26/09/2007

33634/04

KADIROĞLU

02/12/2008

02/03/2009

39783/06

KARABULUT

30/11/2010

74798/01

KARAKAŞ AND BAYIR

11/04/2006

11/07/2006

23574/04

KARTAL

13/10/2009

13/01/2010

22929/04

KAYA İSMAIL

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

14294/04

KIPRITCI

03/06/2008

03/09/2008

36686/07

KOÇ MEHMET

17/02/2009

06/07/2009

23085/04

KORKMAZ YALÇIN

25/11/2008

26/08/2009

23139/07

MEHMET NURİ ÇAÇAN

24/04/2012

16155/04

NIZAMETTIN GEZER

06/03/2012

33620/02

ORUÇ

21/12/2006

21/03/2007

36526/04

ÖZCAN

03/02/2009

03/05/2009

2209/03

ÖZCAN

13/12/2007

13/03/2008

21773/02

ŞAHIN FEDAI

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

34400/02

ŞAHIN VOLCAN

20/05/2008

20/08/2008

Art. 6§1 non-communication of the written opinion of the general prosecutor / noncommunication de l’avis du procureur général

3372/05

SAMSA

01/07/2008

01/10/2008

43379/02

SELEK

12/12/2006

12/03/2007

21167/06

ŞENAY YILDIZ

20/10/2011

31932/03

UĞUZ

13/12/2007

13/03/2008

1206/03

UYSAL AND OSAL

13/12/2007

13/03/2008

35150/06

VARDAR

26/10/2010

11/04/2011

9613/03

VURANKAYA

10/05/2007

10/08/2007

36110/97

YALMAN AND OTHERS

03/06/2004

03/09/2004

32907/03

YILDIZ

10/04/2007

10/07/2007

45652/04

YILDIZ EMIL

23/02/2010

23/05/2010

51423/99

YILMAZ KAHRAMAN AND OTHERS

24/04/2008

24/07/2008

Cases before commercial and consumers’ courts / Affaires devant les juridictions commerciales et sur les droits des consommateurs

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations

41123/04

BAKIRCIOGLU AND OTHERS

20/05/2010

20/08/2010

11181/04

ÇAĞLAR

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

4818/03+

ERHUN

16/06/2009

06/11/2009

19173/03

EVRIM İNŞAAT A.Ş.

09/02/2010

09/05/2010

28388/03

GÜNGIL

10/03/2009

10/06/2009

33158/03

KADRIYE SÜLÜN

06/02/2007

09/07/2007

29064/06

KARANFILLI

30/11/2010

12/07/2011

74495/01

KAT İNŞAAT TICARET KOLLEKTIF ŞIRKETI

24/07/2007

24/10/2007

43874/06

KULMAC

04/10/2011

8476/05

SEVAL TEKSTIL SANAYI VE MÜMESSILLIK DIŞ TICARET LTD ŞTI

22/09/2009

22/12/2009

38891/03

TÜKETICI BILINCINI GELIŞTIRME DERNEĞI

27/02/2007

27/05/2007

17756/06

UYAR

23/02/2010

23/05/2010


Cases before land registry courts / Affaires devant les juridictions cadastrales

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations

3738/04

AKTAR

02/02/2010

02/05/2010

43033/02

ARIKAN AND OTHERS

02/06/2009

02/09/2009

20605/03

BALIKÇI KEMAL

07/10/2008

07/01/2009

19895/03+

BALIKÇI MAHMUT AND ZÜLFÜ

21/10/2008

21/01/2009

43948/02

BILGIÇ DÖNDÜ

02/03/2010

02/06/2010

31504/02

ÇETINKAYA SELAHATTIN AND OTHERS

20/10/2009

01/03/2010

76091/01

DOĞAN NAIME AND OTHERS

17/07/2007

17/10/2007

6990/04

EKDAL AND OTHERS

25/01/2011

25/04/2011

22492/02

ERGÜL AND OTHERS

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

60579/00

GÖK AYŞE AND OTHERS

08/04/2008

29/09/2008

6219/04

GOKÇEK AND OTHERS

26/01/2010

21/02/2011

37252/05

KALGI

20/10/2009

01/03/2010

41613/05

MAVITAN

18/01/2011

20/06/2011

2249/03

MERTER AND OTHERS

23/03/2010

23/06/2010

51963/99

NAMLI AND OTHERS

05/12/2006

23/05/2007

41192/04

NANE AND OTHERS

24/11/2009

10/05/2010

10182/04

OZAKINCI

05/04/2011

11841/02

ÖZDEN

03/05/2007

03/08/2007

31487/02

ÖZDEN NO. 2

03/05/2007

03/08/2007

28925/03

ÖZGEN AND OTHERS

08/04/2008

08/07/2008

9939/02

PEKINEL

18/03/2008

18/06/2008

7436/02

ŞENCAN

13/12/2007

02/06/2008

7755/05

SERÇINOĞLU

20/10/2009

20/01/2010

1533/03

ŞEREFLI AND OTHERS

20/01/2009

20/04/2009

37532/02

SOYLU AND OTHERS

06/04/2010

06/07/2010

64725/01

SÜMER MESRURE

08/04/2008

08/07/2008

64236/01

TALIPOĞLU MEHMET ALI

24/07/2007

24/10/2007

4530/06

ULGEN

06/03/2012

8782/02

UGUR ALI KEMAL AND OTHERS

03/03/2009

14/09/2009

57407/00

UYSAL VELI

04/03/2008

04/06/2008

Case before military courts / Affaires devant les tribunaux militaires

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations

32254/05

ADIYAMAN ORHAN

06/04/2010

06/07/2010

21377/04

ER

27/10/2009

27/01/2010

5173/05

KARAKAYA ELIF

27/10/2009

27/01/2010

37626/02

ÖZEL AND OTHERS

31/01/2008

07/07/2008

Art. 6§1 lack of independence and impartiality of the General Staff Court / défaut d’indépendance et d’impartialité du tribunal de l’état-major

Cases before different kinds of courts / Affaires devant de multiples juridictions

Application/

Requête

Case / Affaire

Judgment of / arrêt du

Final on / définitif le

Other violations/

Autres violations

9209/04+

TAYLAN AND OTHERS

14/09/2010

21/02/2011