Ministers’ Deputies
Annotated Agenda
CM/Del/OJ/DH(2010)1078 .. 22 December 2009
———————————————
1078th meeting (DH), 2-4 March 2010
Preliminary list of items for consideration
——————————————
In accordance with the decisions adopted at the Deputies' 1072nd meeting (December 2009):
Delegations wishing to provide information concerning the items appearing on the preliminary agenda for the 1078th meeting are invited to make such information available to the Secretariat before 8 January 2010.
Any information transmitted after this date will not be reflected in the notes on the annotated agenda of the present meeting.
Section 2 will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 1 February 2010.
Sections 4.1 and 4.3 will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 5 February 2010.
The order of business will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 16 February 2010.
Sections 4.2, 5, 6, 1 and General Questions will be placed on the Committee of Ministers’ Internet site on 23 February 2010.
Please note that in order to shorten this document, the lists for certain groups of cases appear in separate Appendices, which are available from links from the electronic version of this document.
CONTENTS
SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED
SECTION 6 - CASES PRESENTED WITH A VIEW TO THE PREPARATION OF A DRAFT FINAL RESOLUTION
Additional documents
Addendum Preparation of the next DH meeting (1086th meeting, June 2010)
Item a.
Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business
Action
The Deputies are invited to adopt the annotated agenda and the Order of Business.
Item b.
State of ratification by member states of the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceedings of the European Court of human rights, the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe and Protocols No 6, No. 12, No. 13, No. 14 and 14 bis to the Convention for the protection of human rights and fundamental freedoms
Action
The Deputies are invited to provide information on the state of signature and ratification of these texts. Tables showing the current state of signature and ratification appear in Addendum General Questions.
Item c.
Preparation of the next meeting (1086th meeting, June 2010)
See Addendum Preparation of the next meeting
Action
The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary draft Agenda of their 1086th meeting (June 2010), as it appears in Addendum Preparation of the next meeting, together with the time-table for the preparation of the meeting.
Action
The Deputies are invited to adopt the resolutions putting and end to the examination of the following cases as they appear in Section 1.
SUB-SECTION 1.1 – LEADING CASES
No new case
SUB-SECTION 1.2 – CASES CONCERNING PROBLEMS ALREADY SOLVED
No new case
SUB-SECTION 1.3 – CASES NOT INVOLVING GENERAL OR INDIVIDUAL MEASURES
No new case
SUB-SECTION 1.4 – FRIENDLY SETTLEMENTS AND PROBLEMS OF A GENERAL CHARACTER
No new case
This section lists the new judgments rendered by the European Court of Human Rights, (for further details, see the texts of the judgments on http://www.echr.coe.int).
Action
The Deputies are invited to take note of the introductory information concerning these cases. The respondent states will provide action plan / action report for their execution in due course.
In cases in which the measures have already been taken in response to earlier judgments raising similar issues or in cases in which the European Court has ordered specific measures, this will be indicated.
However, in all cases circulation of the text of the judgment to the competent authorities is required and delegations are invited to provide written confirmation of this.
Payment of just satisfaction
In all new cases in which states are obliged to pay a sum, whether granted by the Court or agreed to in friendly settlement, the authorities of the state concerned are invited to provide written confirmation of payment to the Secretariat.
The cases for which the final character of the judgment has not yet been confirmed by the Court appear on a grey background.
The Deputies decided in particular to resume consideration of these items at their 1086th meeting (June 2010) (DH), in the light of information to be provided on the payment of the just satisfaction, if necessary.
- 3 cases against Albania
25336/04 Grori, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
32907/07 Gjyli, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- Case concerns the failure to enforce a final judicial decision concerning the right to compensation in respect of properties nationalised under the communist regime
35720/04+ Vrioni and others, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009[1]
- 1 case against Austria
20082/02 Zehentner, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- 1 case against Belgium
1062/07 Stagno, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 20 cases against Bulgaria
33738/02 Nenov, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
23530/02 Iordanov Iordan and others, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
68334/01 Agromodel OOD, judgment of 24/09/2009, final on 24/12/2009
- Case concerning the lack of sufficient guarantees in the framework of a law authorising recourse to secret surveillance measures
21480/03 Yordanov Georgi, judgment of 24/09/2009, final on 24/12/2009
- 2 cases concerning the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence
15035/03 Popov Konstantin, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
33726/03 Tsonev Tsonyo, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
- Case concerning the impossibility to appeal against a criminal conviction for a minor disturbance of public order
8682/02 Stanchev, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
- Case concerning the violation of the right to freedom of movement due to lengthy and disproportionate prohibition on leaving Bulgaria for non-payment of tax debt
50/02 Ignatov, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
*22627/03 Zaharievi, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 10/12/2005
- 6 cases concerning the violation of the applicants' right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions due to the annulment of their title to property acquired under the communist regime
76963/01 Gyuleva and others, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
31836/04 Kirova and others, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
27636/04 Panayotova, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
29722/04 Peshevi, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
27213/04 Tsonkovi, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
19162/03 Yurukova and Samundzhi, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
- Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments
1152/03 Yanakiev Dimitar, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
- Case concerning the length of detention on remand
3475/03 Titovi, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
- 3 cases of length of civil proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
20568/02 Marinova and Radeva, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
7148/04 Ruga, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
19256/03 Stefanova Donka, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
- 3 cases against Croatia
46423/06 Beganović, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
55759/07 Maresti, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
- Case of length of civil proceedings – inadequate compensation awarded by domestic courts and lack of an effective remedy
33867/06 Vujčić, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 1 case against Cyprus
- Case of length of civil proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
30282/06 Christodoulou, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- 1 case against Denmark
- Case of length of civil proceedings
44034/07 Nielsen, judgment of 02/04/2009, final on 02/07/2009
- 1 case against Estonia
41653/05 Kochetkov, judgment of 02/04/2009, final on 02/07/2009
- 5 cases against Finland
13566/06 Pietiläinen, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 18/11/2009
- Case concerning the lack of a fair trial as the applicant had not been given the opportunity to question a prosecution witness, who was minor
30542/04 D., judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 3 cases of length of judicial proceedings
24732/06 Aiminen, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
7790/05 Knaster, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
38158/07 Oy Hopotihoi Suomen Lelukamarit Toy & Hobby Ltd and Matti Kangasluoma, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- 6 cases against France
39364/05 Khider, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
12268/03 Hachette Filipacchi (“Ici Paris”), judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 23/10/2009
1946/06 Bowler International Unit, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 23/10/2009
- Case concerning the retroactive application of new legislation to pending judicial proceedings
*30345/05 Joubert, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 10/12/2005
- Case concerning the disproportionate penalty imposed on the applicant for failure to declare a sum of money to the customs authorities
39973/03 Moon, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
- Case of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative courts
40589/07 Sartory, judgment of 24/09/2009, final on 24/12/2009
- 2 cases against Georgia
- Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments
16277/07 Kvitsiani, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
40022/05 Kobelyan, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 2 cases against Germany
8453/04 Bayer, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- Case concerning the length of judicial proceedings
1126/05 D.E., judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 15 cases against Greece
24981/07 Vafiadis, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
- Case mainly concerning the failure to implement final judicial decisions
32838/07 Clinique psychiatrique “Athina” Vrilisson Sarl and Clinique Lyrakou SA, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
46368/06 Zeïbek, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
36963/06 Zouboulidis No. 2, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
48906/06 Varnima Corporation International S.A., judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
514/07 Christodoulou, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
46929/06 Elyasin, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 8 cases concerning the length of judicial proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy
- Cases before administrative authorities and courts
15545/07 Examiliotis No. 4, judgment of 11/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
38463/07 Kontogouris, judgment of 30/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
46064/07 Papathanasis, judgment of 30/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- Cases before criminal courts
43407/06 Chuwunonso, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
39870/06 Ekonomi, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 02/10/2009
33863/07 Elezi and others, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
50914/06 Roïdakis No. 2, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
2002/07 Sarantidou, judgment of 02/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 7 cases against Hungary
37214/05 Bárkányi, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
- 2 cases concerning the violation of the right to a fair trial (convictions upheld in camera in the absence of applicants and their lawyers in appeal proceedings)
26958/05 Sándor Lajos Kiss, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
37376/05 Talabér, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 4 cases of length of judicial proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
- Proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations
19689/05 Jánosi, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
*25073/05 Schwartz, judgment of 03/11/2009, final on 1/12/2009
*5766/05 Schwartz and others, judgment of 03/11/2009, final on 1/12/2009
- Criminal proceedings
*45392/05 Neu, judgment of 03/11/2009, final on 1/12/2009
- 9 cases against Italy
- Case concerning the danger that the applicant might be subject to torture or to degrading or inhuman treatment in his country of origin (Tunisia) if the deportation order against him were to be enforced
12584/08 Sellem, judgment of 05/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
22635/03 Sulejmanovic, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 2 cases concerning the special prison regime provided by Article 41bis of the Prison Administration Act (Article 8)
24423/03 Annunziata, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
24425/03 Piacenti, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 3 cases mainly concerning unfair proceedings due to retrospective legislation reducing compensation for expropriation and insufficient compensation in this respect
71399/01 Bortesi and others, judgment of 10/06/2008, final on 10/09/2008, revised on 08/12/2009
38596/02 Mandola, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
29290/02 Vessichelli, judgment of 09/06/2009, final on 09/09/2009
- Case concerning de facto expropriation on account of the authorities' refusal to allow the applicant to build on his land on the basis of administrative decisions which had expired more than 20 years before
7977/03 Rossitto, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- Case concerning bankruptcy proceedings (Articles 8 and 13)
33873/04 Scannella Giuseppe and others, judgment of 09/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 3 cases against Latvia
65014/01 Pacula, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
798/05 Miroļubovs and others, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
- Case mainly concerning poor detention conditions
62609/00 Nikitenko, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- 5 cases against Lithuania
27576/05 Aleksa, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
26892/05 Igarienė and Petrauskienė, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
- 3 cases of length of civil proceedings
17997/04 Naugžemys, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
12278/03 Padalevičius, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
22906/04 Vorona and Voronov, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 1 case against Luxembourg
- Case concerning the violation of the right of access to court due to dismissal of a cassation appeal on overly formalistic grounds
*18522/06 Dattel No. 2, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 10/12/2005
- 2 cases against Malta
17056/06 Micallef, judgment of 15/10/2009 – Grand Chamber
47045/06 Amato Gauci, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
- 4 cases against Moldova
- Case concerning ill-treatment under police custody and the lack of effective investigation in this respect (Articles 3 and 13)
7045/08 Gurgurov, judgment of 16/06/2009, final on 16/09/2009, rectified on 17/06/2009
- Case concerning the quashing of final domestic decisions by extending the time-limit for lodging requests for revision
39815/07 Baroul-Partner-A, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
13936/02 Manole and others, judgment of 17/09/2009, final on 17/12/2009
- Case of length of civil proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
27516/04 Panzari, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 1 case against Monaco
43376/06 Prencipe, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- 1 case against Montenegro and Serbia[2]
11890/05 Bijelić, judgment of 28/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 34 cases against Poland
47709/99 Rachwalski and Ferenc, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
38273/02 Stochlak, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning deficiencies in the legal aid system
41373/04 Arciński, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
29761/03 Białas Janusz, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
3818/04 Seliwiak, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
- Case concerning freedom of expression
20436/02 Wojtas-Kaleta, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
22279/04 Plechanov, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
6669/03 Giermek and others, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
21700/02 Polańscy, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 3 cases concerning the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence
26744/02 Kisilewski, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
12772/06 Kotowski, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
*42785/06 Pasternak, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- 11 cases mainly concerning the length of detention on remand
39842/05 Dyller, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
31116/03 Feliński, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
7883/07 Figas, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
6093/04 Jamroży, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
8713/03 Janus, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
50020/06 Kacprzyk, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
23755/03 Maciejewski, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
11253/07 Maruszak, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
8403/02 Mgłosik, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
43610/06 Wiśniewski, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
29940/06 Woźniak, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- Case of length of criminal proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
473/07 Wroński, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
- 6 cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative bodies and courts
12605/03 Kania Leon and Agnieszka, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
33429/07 Korcz, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
28604/03 Lorenc, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
20982/07 Prądzyńska-Pozdniakow, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
20166/07 Suchecki No. 1, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
33744/06 Tymieniecki, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 4 cases concerning the length of proceedings before civil and labour courts and the lack of an effective remedy
5943/07 Gordon-Krajcer, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
13933/04 Kęsiccy, judgment of 16/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
42778/07 Przybyła, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
28309/06+ Waltoś and Pawlicz, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 37 cases against Romania
75109/01+ Burzo, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
- 2 cases concerning poor detention conditions
12535/04 Artimenco, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
12934/02 Stoicescu Marian, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- Case concerning ill treatment during the detention
34022/05 Radu Alexandru Marius, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
34197/02 Luka, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
23782/06+ Constantin and Stoian, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 2 cases concerning the violation of the right of access to a court due to excessive court fees required
10097/05 Brezeanu, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
17034/03 Constantin Daniel Lionel, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
8727/03 Popescu Stanca, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- Case concerning the annulment of final court decisions relating to property ownership
38969/02 S.C. Concordia Internaţional S.R.L., judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning the annulment of final court decisions
4321/01 Colceru, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- 13 cases mainly concerning the failure to restore or compensate for nationalised property sold by the state to third parties
8266/05 Becskei, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
11474/04 Cernitu, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
13248/05+ Chamber of Commerce, Industry and Agriculture of Timişoara No. 1, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
23520/05+ Chamber of Commerce, Industry and Agriculture of Timişoara No. 2, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
28976/03 Constantinescu Paula, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
17979/05 Dumitras, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
39761/03 Rasidescu, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
16272/03 Simionescu-Râmniceanu, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
43953/02 Simionescu-Râmniceanu No. 2, judgment of 22/07/2009, final on 22/10/2009
34741/07 Ştefănescu and others, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
42194/05 Tamir and others, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
23692/02 Tănăsescu, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
31566/03 Turus, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009, rectified on 15/09/2009
- 8 cases mainly concerning the failure to enforce final judicial decisions ordering restitution of or compensation in respect of property nationalised or lost during the communist period
28998/04 Cârstea, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
6098/05 Ciornei, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
34247/06 David, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
31139/03 Naghi, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
21318/02 Popa Aurel, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
20589/04 Popescu Octavian, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
2916/04 Priotese, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
30453/04 Roman, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 2 cases concerning late enforcement of, or failure to enforce final judicial decisions by public institutions
27444/03 Babei and Clucerescu, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
37805/05 Costăchescu, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 2 cases concerning the continued impossibility to dispose of properties and to receive rent for their use resulting from the application of the emergency rent provisions
28106/03 Brumărescu No. 2, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
*28777/03 Schmidt, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 10/12/2005
- Case of length of civil proceedings
31253/03 Balea, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- 59 cases against the Russian Federation
- 23 cases concerning security forces in the Chechen Republic
32297/05 Alaudinova, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
27001/06 Amanat Ilyasova and others, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
15569/06 Asadulayeva and others, judgment of 17/09/2009, final on 17/12/2009
15441/05+ Basayeva and others, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
36156/04 Bitiyeva and others, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
16629/05 Dokayev and others, judgment of 09/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
3179/05 Gakiyev and Gakiyeva, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
15439/05 Gaziyeva and others, judgment of 09/04/2009, rectified on 04/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
4571/04 Israilova and others, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
*29851/05 Karimov and others, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
28148/03 Khachukayev, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
33264/04 Khalitova and others, judgment of 11/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
28159/03 Khasuyeva, judgment of 11/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
13862/05 Khumaydov and Khumaydov, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
2393/05 Magomadova, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
27244/03 Malsagova and others, judgment of 09/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
*24297/05 Mutsayeva, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
13737/03 Nenkayev and others, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
15440/05 Pukhikova, judgment of 02/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
12457/05 Rezvanov and Rezvanova, judgment of 24/09/2009, final on 24/12/2009
21810/03 Taysumov and others, judgment of 14/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
12417/05 Turluyeva and Khamidova, judgment of 14/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
*5428/05 Yusupova and others, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- 5 cases mainly concerning poor detention conditions
13659/06 Ananyin, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
36932/02 Bakhmutskiy, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
24325/03 Generalov, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
2052/08 Kokoshkina, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
34393/03 Pitalev, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
- 4 cases mainly concerning ill-treatment inflicted on the applicants while in custody and the lack of an effective investigation
19223/04 Fedorov Vladimir, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
2807/04 Gladyshev, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
30049/02 Kornev Yevgeniy, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
66688/01 Toporkov, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
7025/04 Pishchalnikov, judgment of 24/09/2009, final on 24/12/2009
17183/05 Yevdomikov, judgment of 17/09/2009, final on 17/12/2009
- 7 cases mainly concerning unlawful detention, excessive length and insufficient grounds
10638/08 Alekhin, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
2737/04 Avdeyev and Veryayev, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
41169/02 Kononovich, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
20571/04 Lamazhyk, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
3194/08 Medvedev Segey, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
7739/06 Sorokin, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
16854/03 Tsarkov, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
76836/01 Kimlya and others, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
35989/02 Novikov, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
*67336/01 Danilenkov and others, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- 2 cases mainly concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments
23554/03 Makarova, judgment of 01/10/2009, final on 01/01/2010
756/05+ Markovtsi and Selivanov, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 23/10/2009
- Case mainly concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments
Housing disputes (judges)
5950/04 Blinov and Blinova, judgment of 30/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 6 cases mainly concerning quashing of final judgments through the supervisory review procedure (civil aspects)
42234/04 Borodkin, judgment of 17/09/2009, final on 17/12/2009
30709/03 Klimenko and Ostapenko, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 23/10/2009
27114/04 Khotuleva, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 06/11/2009
3447/05+ Molodyka and others, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 23/10/2009
32865/06+ Senchenko and others and 35 other “Yakut pensioners” cases, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
*8269/02 Sutyazhnik, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- Case concerning the violation of the right to a fair trial, the applicant’s case not having been determined by a tribunal established by law
6945/04 Ilatovskiy, judgment of 09/07/2009, final on 09/10/2009
- Case concerning the unfairness of certain criminal proceedings due to the courts’ failure to appoint a lawyer for the applicant
14934/03 Potapov, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- 4 cases of length of civil proceedings
39898/03 Kharitonov, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
4487/04 Orlova Svetlana, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
42046/06 Zaytsev and others, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
32380/06 Zharkova, judgment of 17/09/2009, final on 17/12/2009
- 4 cases against Serbia
- 2 cases concerning freedom of expression
*32550/05 Bodrožić, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 10/12/2009
*38435/05 Bodrožić and Vujin, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- Case concerning failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic decisions
Socially-owned companies
16909/06+ Grišević and others, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
- Case of length of judicial proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
Family-related proceedings
45251/07 M.V., judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- 7 cases against the Slovak Republic
30754/04 Dvořáček and Dvořáčková, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
8227/04 E.S. and others, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
32881/04 K.H. and others, judgment of 28/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
54252/07+ Lawyers Partners, a.s., judgment of 16/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 2 cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations
42561/04 Ďurech and others, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
19304/04 Gajdoš, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
- Case of length of criminal proceedings
19011/05 Tomčáni, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 2 cases against Slovenia
*21055/03 Gaspari, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 10/12/2009
- Case of length of judicial proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
33946/03 Lesjak, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
- 1 case against Switzerland
13444/04 Glor, judgment of 30/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 4 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
27865/02 Bočvarska, judgment of 17/09/2009, final on 17/12/2009
- 3 cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before labour or civil courts and lack of an effective domestic remedy
39538/03 Blage Ilievski, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
37812/04 Josifov, judgment of 25/06/2009, final on 25/09/2009
35640/04 Veljanoska, judgment of 23/07/2009, final on 23/10/2009
- 95 cases against Turkey
30471/08 Abdolkhani and Karimnia, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
6291/05 Yananer, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
- 2 cases concerning the actions of the Turkish security forces
Cases concerning the inhuman and degrading treatment of the applicants and /or the absence of effective investigations
35160/05 Yavuz Ali, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
41253/04 Yerdenli, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 4 cases mainly concerning the lack of effective investigation in respect of the actions of the Turkish security forces following ill-treatment of the applicants
16234/04 Erdoğan Füsun and others, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
7880/02 Gül Ümit, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
40160/05 Kömürcü Müdet No. 2, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
31300/05 Terzi and Erkmen, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- Case concerning the lack of effective investigation of the circumstances surrounding deaths occurring during military service
75535/01 Bayram Esat, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- Case concerning the excessive use of force in quelling a prison riot and lack of an effective investigation
5981/03 Keser and Kömürcü, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
- Case mainly concerning the excessive use of force to break up unlawful but peaceful demonstrations
43279/04 Ersoy, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- 3 cases mainly concerning the independence and impartiality of state security courts
43422/02 Bilgin and Bulga, judgment of 16/06/2009, final on 16/09/2009
8126/02 Giç, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
32489/03 Polat Hasan, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning freedom of expression – defamation proceedings
17089/03 Sorguç, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
22766/04 Kara, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
- Case concerning the right to freedom of association(disciplinary sanction imposed for participating in a protest meeting organised by the trade union)
30946/04 Kaya and Seyhan, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
- Case concerning the right to freedom of association (criminal conviction for participating in a strike)
22943/04 Özcan, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
- Case concerning the right to freedom of association of civil servants and their right to participate in a strike
68959/01 Ererji Yapı-Yol Sen, judgment of 21/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
4914/03 Turnalı, judgment of 07/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
12769/02 Osmanağaoğlu, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
- Case concerning the failure to communicate the public prosecutor's opinion before the Court of Cassation and / or the lack of oral hearing
27803/02 Arga, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- 5 cases mainly concerning the violation of the equality of arms due to the failure to communicate the written opinion of the Public Prosecutor before the Supreme Military Administrative Court
44292/04 Cihangül, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
8543/05 Dikel, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
43696/04 Erdoğan Okan, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
2843/05 Okur Tevfik, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
38287/04+ Tamay and others, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 2 cases concerning the violation of the equality of arms due to the failure to communicate classified documents in the case file
43554/04 İlter, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
38011/05 Merdan, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 11 cases mainly concerning the unfairness of criminal proceedings due to the lack of the assistance of counsel during detention in custody
24739/04 Arslan Ahmet, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
1915/03 Arzu, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
8180/04 Baran İhsan No. 1, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
6318/02 Bayan Zeki, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
2910/04 Çelebi and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
6094/03 Elçiçek and others, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
74307/01 Gök and Güler, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
12550/03 Işık Çimen, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
22922/03 Kaya Halil, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
71864/01 Tağaç and others, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
10324/05 Özcan İzzet, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- Case concerning the failure to bring the applicants before the trial court
25381/02 Demir Seyithan, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- 2 cases concerning the unfairness of criminal proceedings on account of the lack of oral hearing
37215/04 Aldemir, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
40886/02 Günseli Kaya No. 2, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
30326/03 Erkuş, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- Case concerning the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence
22190/05 Kapçak, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- 18 cases mainly concerning interference in property rights and/or respect for home (properties in the northern part of Cyprus)
16094/90 Andreou Papi, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16085/90 Christodoulidou, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16259/90 Diogenous and Tseriotis, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
19900/92 Epiphaniou and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
37395/97 Hadjiprocopiou and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
39970/98 Hadjithomas and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
35214/97 Hapeshis and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
35214/97 Hapeshis and Hapeshi-Michaelidou, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
43685/98 Iordanis Iordanou, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
21887/93 Josephides, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16682/90 Loizou and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
29092/95 Ramon, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
46159/99 Rock Ruby Hotels Ltd, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16160/90 Saveriades, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
47884/99 Skyropiia Yialis Ltd, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16082/90 Strati, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16078/90 Vrahimi, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
16654/90 Zavou and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning the inability of foreigners to inherit property in Turkey due to alleged failure to satisfy the reciprocity requirement
31206/02 Fokas, judgment of 29/09/2009, final on 29/12/2009
- 2 cases concerning the lack of compensation for the loss of title to property on account of its designation as public forest
24620/04 Çetiner and Yücetürk, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
10250/02 Taş Ali, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning the lack of compensation following annulment of title to a plot of land in the framework of the Coastal Law regime
43498/04 Fatihoğlu and Ugutmen, judgment of 28/04/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- 2 cases mainly concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments
6982/04 Akdüz and others, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
41246/98 Ünal Akpinar İnşaat İmalat Sanayi Ve Ticaret S.A. and Akpinar Yapi Sanaysi S.A., judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 06/11/2009
- Case concerning delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest
41479/05 Üçpınar, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
18623/03 Demirel Cahit, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
- 8 cases mainly concerning the length of detention on remand and/or of criminal proceedings
6178/04 Akyaz, judgment of 07/07/2009, final on 07/10/2009
7987/07 Atsız and others, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
37291/04 Fırat, judgment of 30/06/2009, final on 30/09/2009
32008/05 Karagöz Etem, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
7605/05 Mücek, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
43824/07 Özdemir Veli, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
24801/05 Ünay, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
7945/05 Uyanık and Kabadayı, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
39515/03 Okçu, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009, revised on 24/08/2009
- 9 cases mainly concerning the length of judicial proceedings and the lack of an effective remedy
- Cases before criminal courts
23945/05 Hatipoğlu, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
45873/05 Pehlivanoğlu, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
- Cases before civil courts
34656/03 Barker, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
21086/04 Daneshpayeh, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
4818/03+ Erhun, judgment of 16/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
4889/05+ Karataş and Yıldız and others, judgment of 16/07/2009, final on 16/10/2009
5298/06 Saruhan and Çelik, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
8476/05 Seval Tekstil Sanayi ve Mümessillik Dış Ticaret Ltd Şti, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
27597/06 Sürgit, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning the continued detention of the applicant for several days after his release had been ordered
34806/03 Talay, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- 2 cases concerning detention in police custody
17727/02 Dün, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
39686/02 Oral and Atabay, judgment of 23/06/2009, final on 23/09/2009
- 3 cases of length of criminal proceedings before state security courts
30944/04 Kara Güli, judgment of 15/09/2009, final on 15/12/2009
15179/02 Koç and Yürek, judgment of 21/07/2009, final on 21/10/2009
13467/05 Singar, judgment of 22/09/2009, final on 22/12/2009
- 15 cases against Ukraine
- Case concerning ill treatment inflicted on the applicant while in custody and /or the lack of an effective investigation
12174/03 Drozd, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
- 6 cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments
48771/06 Prokopyeva, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
9480/06 Semenovych, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
27589/05 Shventkovskiy, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
39760/05 Solonskiy, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
41313/06+ Sorokina and Goncharenko, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
33959/05 Tereshchenko, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
- 6 cases of length of civil proceedings
10426/02 Koziy, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
9025/03 Pilipey, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
4430/04 Sebova, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
3638/04 Shastkiv and Valitska, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
1409/03 Smirnov, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
29025/05 Yakubovych, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
- 2 cases of length of criminal proceedings
39447/03 Gavrylyak, judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 06/11/2009
13404/02 Yefanov and others, judgment of 30/07/2009, final on 30/10/2009
Action
The Deputies are invited to supervise the payment of just satisfaction in the following cases pending before the Committee of Ministers for execution supervision. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in principle at their next Human Rights meeting.
Supervision of payment is dealt with through separate tables distributed each month. An updated version will be distributed just before each meeting.
The Deputies decided to resume consideration of these items at their 1086th meeting (June 2010) (DH), in the light of information to be provided on the payment of the just satisfaction, if necessary.
SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTIONS
(INDIVIDUAL MEASURES, MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS)
(See Addendum 4 for part or all these cases)
Action
The Deputies are invited to supervise the progress made in the adoption of the implementing measures in the following cases raising several problems.
SUB-SECTION 4.1 – SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUAL MEASURES ONLY[3]
- 1 case against Bosnia and Herzegovina
7435/04 Milisavljević, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
- 2 cases against Bulgaria
30985/96 Hassan and Tchaouch, judgment of 26/10/00 - Grand Chamber
39023/97 Supreme Holy Council of the Muslim community, judgment of 16/12/2004, final on 16/03/2005
- 8 cases against Croatia
- Case of length of enforcement proceedings
49916/07 Medić, judgment of 26/03/2009, final on 26/06/2009
- 7 cases of length of civil proceedings
29159/03 Poje, judgment of 09/03/2006, final on 09/06/2006
32264/03 Butković, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 24/08/2007, rectified on 05/09/2007
8854/04 Krnić, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
26455/04 Plazonić, judgment of 06/03/2008, final on 06/06/2008
21591/06 Pleteš, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 29/09/2008
43709/02 Raguž, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
5129/03 Sukobljević, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
- 3 cases against Greece
28606/05 Kabili, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 31/10/2008
9029/05 Kampanellis, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 21/09/2007
68138/01 Zazanis and others, judgment of 18/11/2004, final on 30/03/2005
- 3 cases against Hungary
30789/05 Rózsa, judgment of 28/04/2009, final on 28/07/2009
31475/05 Kenedi, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 26/08/2009
37374/05 Társaság a Szabadságjogokért, judgment of 14/04/2009, final on 14/07/2009
- 3 cases against Italy
10249/03 Scoppola, judgment of 17/09/2009 – Grand Chamber
- 2 cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments ordering the demolition of buildings
77606/01 Paudicio, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
6870/03 Vitiello, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007
- 1 case against Norway
31283/04 Orr, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 01/12/2008
- 4 cases against Poland
34049/96 Zwierzyński, judgment of 19/06/2001, final on 19/09/2001 and of 02/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002 (Article 41), revised on 06/03/2007, final on 24/09/2007
8677/03 P.P., judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 08/04/2008
- 2 cases concerning the violation of the right of access to a court due to domestic courts' refusal to exempt applicants from substantial court fees
20482/03 Cibicki, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
32971/03 Palewski, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
- 8 cases against Romania
75101/01 Grecu, judgment of 30/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
6817/02 Iordache, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
- Case concerning the annulment of final civil court decisions
2367/04 Georgescu Daniel and Niculina, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
- 5 cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions relating to property ownership
31678/96 Gheorghiu T. and D.I., judgment of 17/12/02, final on 21/05/03
28400/04 Fischer, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
6248/03 Popea, judgment of 05/10/2006, final on 05/01/2007
10230/05 Sersescu, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
40670/98 Todorescu, judgment of 30/09/03, final on 30/12/03
- 1 case against the Russian Federation
42086/05 Liu and Liu, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 02/06/2008
- 11 cases against Serbia
39177/05 V.A.M., judgment of 13/03/2007, final on 13/06/2007
- 10 cases of excessive length of judicial proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
- Family-related proceedings
3150/05 Jevremović, judgment of 17/07/07, final on 17/10/07
- Commercial proceedings
28443/05 Samardžić and AD Plastika, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007
- Civil proceedings
38350/04 Popović, judgment of 20/11/2007, final on 20/02/2008
9906/04 Čeh, judgment of 01/07//2008, final on 01/10/2008
- Labour proceedings
41513/05 Mikuljanac, Mališić and Šafar, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 09/01/2008
17271/04 Cvetković, judgment of 10/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
33029/05 Dorić, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
2637/05 Jovićević, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
29907/05 Stanković, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 06/04/2009
26642/05 Stevanović, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 09/01/2008
- 2 cases against the Slovak Republic
8607/02 Cabala, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
7205/02 Stanková, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 31/03/2008
- 1 case against Spain
1483/02 Panella Puig, judgment of 25/04/2006, final on 25/07/2006
- 2 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
14438/03 Nesevski, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
- Case of length of civil proceedings
24660/03 Bogdanska Duma, judgment of 07/05/2009, final on 07/08/2009
- 230 cases against Turkey
- 2 cases mainly concerning the unfairness of criminal proceedings brought against the applicants due to the lack of assistance by counsel during their trials
42104/02 Kahraman Kemal and Kahraman Ali, judgment of 26/04/2007, final on 26/07/2007
32432/96 Tunç Talat, judgment of 27/03/2007, final on 27/06/2007
11449/02 Tavlı, judgment of 09/11/2006, final on 09/02/2007, rectified on 25/01/2007
60856/00 Eren Mürsel, judgment of 07/02/2006, final on 03/07/2006
- Case of length of criminal proceedings before state security courts
31540/02 Atıcı No. 2, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
- 4 cases of length of criminal proceedings in particular before martial law courts
15259/02 Ertürk Hasan, judgment of 12/04/2005, final on 12/07/2005
287/03 Çengelli and Eryılmaz, judgment of 10/06/2008, final on 10/09/2008
9984/03 Kanbur No. 2, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
36150/02 Kaya Mehmet, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006
Cases raising the issue of restitutio in integrum for the applicants:
reopening of the domestic proceedings not allowed by Turkish law:
- 209 cases concerning the independence and impartiality of state security courts
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Gençel group)
39465/98 Parsıl, judgment of 26/04/2005, final on 26/07/2005
- 8 cases concerning ill-treatment suffered by the applicants and the lack of independence and impartiality of state security courts
52941/99 Gültekin and others, judgment of 31/05/2005, final on 31/08/2005, rectified on 06/12/2005
27526/95 Günaydın Vedat and Şahin, judgment of 13/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
48063/99 Aslan Orhan, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006
42579/98 Demir Murat, judgment of 02/03/2006, final on 02/06/2006
43925/98 Karakaş and Yeşilırmak Yılmaz, judgment of 28/06/2005, final on 28/09/2005
39813/98 Önder Soner, judgment of 12/07/2005, final on 12/10/2005
40986/98 Soner and others, judgment of 27/04/2006, final on 27/07/2006
42594/98 Uçkan, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 22/09/2006
32984/96 Alfatli and others (applicant Mahmut Memduh Uyan), judgment of 30/10/03, final on 24/03/04
- Case concerning the independence and impartiality of the General Staff Military Court
60999/00 Satık No. 2, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
1767/03+ Dağdelen and others, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
SUB-SECTION 4.2 – INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS
- 1 case against Albania
19206/05 Dauti, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
- 6 cases against Armenia
31237/03 Kirakosyan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
22390/05 Mkhitaryan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
41698/04 Tadevosyan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
32283/04 Meltex Ltd and Mesrop Movsesyan, judgment of 17/06/2008, final on 17/09/2008
38978/03 Sharukhanyan, judgment of 27/05/2008, final on 27/08/2008
21638/03 Paykar Yev Haghtanak Ltd, judgment of 20/12/2007, final on 02/06/2008
- 3 cases against Azerbaijan
22684/05 Muradova, judgment of 02/04/2009, final on 02/07/2009
35877/04 Mahmudov and Agazade, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 18/03/2009
21674/05 Rahimova, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
- 4 cases against Austria
49686/99 Gütl, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
28648/03 Lang, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 19/06/2009
42967/98 Löffelmann, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
- Case concerning the lack of oral hearing
30003/02 Stojakovic, judgment of 09/11/2006, final on 09/02/2007
- 7 cases against Belgium
29787/03+ Riad and Idiab, judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 24/04/2008
44256/06 Cakir Turan, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
13178/03 Mubilanzila Mayeka and Kaniki Mitunga, judgment of 12/10/2006, final on 12/01/2007
45413/07 Anakomba Yula, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
49230/07 L’Erablière A.S.B.L., judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
48386/99 Cottin, judgment of 02/06/2005, final on 02/09/2005
22945/07 Houtman and Meeus, judgment of 17/03/2009, final on 17/06/2009
- 1 case against Bosnia and Herzegovina
22893/05 Rodić and 3 others, judgment of 27/05/2008, final on 01/12/2008
- 24 cases against Bulgaria
50963/99 Al-Nashif and others, judgment of 20/06/02, final on 20/09/02
65028/01 Bashir and others, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
1365/07 C.G. and others, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
54323/00 Hasan, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
61259/00 Musa and others, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 09/07/2007
391/03 Işyar, judgment of 20/11/2008, final on 20/02/2009
44009/02 Ivanov Evgeni, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008
73481/01 Bochev, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009
15158/02 Kirilov, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008
52435/99 Ivanova, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
- 2 cases concerning infringements of the freedom of assembly of organisations which aim to achieve “the recognition of the Macedonian minority in Bulgaria” and of their members
44079/98 United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden and Ivanov, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
46336/99 Ivanov and others, judgment of 24/11/2005, final on 24/02/2006
412/03+ Holy synod of the Bulgarian Orthodox Church (Metropolitan Inokentiy) and others, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
15197/02 Petrov, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008
- 2 cases mainly concerning the interception of the applicants’ telephone conversations
62540/00 Association for European Integration and Human Rights and Ekimdzhiev, judgment of 28/06/2007, final on 30/01/2008
5182/02 Kirov, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008
50899/99 Yordanov Krasimir, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
9808/02 Stoichkov, judgment of 24/03/2005, final on 24/06/2005
66455/01 Bulinwar OOD and Hrusanov, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
17868/07 Mihaylov Kostadin, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
- 2 cases concerning the violation of the right of access to a court due to excessive amount of court fees imposed in civil proceedings for damages
68490/01 Stankov, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007
20594/02 Tzvyatkov, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008
3991/03 "Bulves" Ad, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009
75022/01 Popov Petyo, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009
- 11 cases against Croatia
46598/06 Tomašić Branko and others, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
11223/04 X., judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
35030/04 Karadžić, judgment of 15/12/2005, final on 15/03/2006
- 4 cases concerning poor detention conditions and lack of an effective remedy
73786/01 Cenbauer, judgment of 09/03/2006; final on 13/09/2006
33138/06 Pilčić, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 17/04/2008
29660/03 Štitić, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 31/03/2008
20877/04 Testa, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 30/01/2008
28261/06 Ćosić, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
43595/06 Bačić, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
24661/02 Buj, judgment of 01/06/2006, final on 01/09/2006
25774/05 Bistrović, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 31/08/2007
- 4 cases against Cyprus
4268/04 Panovits, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009
39058/05 Kyriakides, judgment of 16/10/2008, final on 16/01/2009
39627/05 Taliadorou and Stylianou, judgment of 16/10/2008, final on 16/01/2009
31811/04 Michael Theodossiou LtD, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
- 7 cases against the Czech Republic
995/06 Andĕlová, judgment of 286/02/2008, final on 29/09/2008
7550/04 Reslová, judgment of 18/07/2006, final on 18/10/2006
1633/05 Koudelka, judgment of 20/07/2006, final on 20/09/2006
26141/03 Fiala, judgment of 18/07/2006, final on 11/12/2006
26634/03 Kříž, judgment of 09/01/2007, final on 09/04/2007
27726/03 Mezl, judgment of 09/01/2007, final on 09/04/2007
14044/05 Zavřel, judgment of 18/01/2007, final on 18/04/2007
- 1 case against Denmark
247/07 Christensen, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009
- 2 cases against Estonia
- 2 cases of length of civil proceedings and lack of an effective remedy
11548/04 Saarekallas Oü, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 08/02/2008
43276/06 Missenjov, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
- 6 cases against Finland
22635/04 Vilén, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
21022/04 Natunen, judgment of 31/03/2009, final on 30/06/2009
22508/02 F. and M., judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007
- 2 cases concerning the search and seizure of privileged material and the length of judicial proceedings
50882/99 Sallinen Petri and others, judgment of 27/09/2005, final on 27/12/2005
19348/04 Sorvisto, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
10163/02 Johansson, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
- 1 case against France and Romania
6152/02 Dinu, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 06/04/2009
- 7 cases against France
5608/05 Renolde, judgment of 16/10/2008, final on 16/01/2009
70204/01 Frérot, judgment of 12/06/2007, final on 12/09/2007
9375/02 Saoud, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 09/01/2008
36497/05+ Ligue du monde islamique and Organisation islamique mondiale du secours, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
24488/04 Guillard, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
- 2 cases concerning the equality of arms in criminal proceedings (extension of the time-limit in which the prosecutor could make an appeal, without a possibility for the applicant to lodge a cross-appeal)
63879/00 Ben Naceur, judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 03/01/2007
1092/04 Gacon, judgment of 22/05/2008, final on 22/08/2008
- 15 cases against Georgia
23204/07 Ghavtadze, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
9870/07 Poghossian, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
1704/06 Ramishvili and Kokhreidze, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
522/04 Aliev, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
- 3 cases concerning the lack of effective investigation into the applicants’ allegations of ill-treatment
73241/01 Davtyan, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 27/10/2006
68622/01 Danelia, judgment of 17/10/2006, final on 17/01/2007
11830/03 Gharibashvili, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
37048/04 Nikolaishvili Giorgi, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
30779/04 Patsuria, judgment of 06/11/2007, final on 06/02/2008[4]
7932/03 Jgarkava, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
9103/04 The Georgian Labour Party, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
28537/02 “Iza” Ltd and Makrakhidze, judgment of 27/09/2005, final on 27/12/2005
2507/03 “Amat-G“ Ltd and Mebaghishvili, judgment of 27/09/2005, final on 15/02/2006
69852/01 Kidzinidzé, judgment of 29/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
41957/04 Kharitonashvili, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2009
- 1 case against Germany
45749/06+ Kaemena and Thöneböhn, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009
- 236 cases against Greece
27695/03 Serifis, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
39780/06 Kotsaftis, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008
- 2 cases concerning the poor detention conditions (detention on remand)
32927/03 Kaja, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 27/10/2006
30303/07 Siasios and others, judgment of 04/06/2009, final on 04/09/2009
43529/07 Nerattini, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 18/03/2009
35522/04 Stavropoulos Vassilios, judgment of 27/09/2007, final on 27/12/2007
11801/04 Tsalkitzis, judgment of 16/11/2006, final on 26/03/2007
42778/05+ Giosakis No 1, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
36205/06 Giosakis No 2, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
1234/05 Reklos and Davourlis, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
32186/02 Agga No. 3, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006
33331/02 Agga No. 4, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006
- 3 cases concerning the dissolution and refusal to register associations established by persons belonging to the Muslim minority of Western Thrace (Greece)
35151/05 Bekir-Ousta and others, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
34144/05 Emin and others, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 01/12/2008
26698/05 Tourkiki Enosi Xanthis and others, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 29/09/2008
- 3 cases mainly concerning freedom of expression
19331/05 Katrami, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 06/03/2008
28504/05 Kanellopoulou, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 31/03/2008
24444/07 Kydonis, judgment of 02/04/2009, final on 02/07/2009
44858/04 Markoulaki No. 1, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
2898/03 N.T. Giannousis and Kliafas Brothers S.A., judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 23/05/2007
46372/99 Papastavrou and others, judgments of 10/04/03, final on 10/07/03 and of 18/11/04, final on 18/02/05
66742/01 Katsoulis and others, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004 and of 24/11/2005, final on 24/02/2006
Interim Resolution ResDH(2006)27
6789/06 Fakiridou and Schina, judgment of 14/11/2008, final on 14/02/2009
43588/06 Vontas and others, judgment of 05/02/2009, final on 06/07/2009
66725/01 Fotopoulou, judgment of 18/11/2004, final on 18/02/2005
52903/99 Dactylidi, judgment of 27/03/03, final on 09/07/03
- 203 cases of length of judicial proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Manios group)
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2007)74
- 7 cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before the Court of Audit
73840/01 Papazoglou and others, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 13/02/04
66296/01 Belaousof and others, judgment of 27/05/2004, final on 10/11/2004
44132/06 Examiliotis No. 3, judgment of 04/12/2008, final on 06/07/2009
12767/02 Hourmidis, judgment of 19/05/2004, final on 19/08/2004
66808/01 Lazarou, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004
62771/00 Litoselitis, judgment of 05/02/2004, final on 05/05/2004
11536/05 Papadopoulos Georgios, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
- 2 cases against Hungary
12188/06 Csánics, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
33629/06 Vajnai, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
- 3 cases against Iceland
39731/98 Sigurđsson, judgment of 10/04/03, final on 10/07/03
31930/04 Eggertsdottir, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 05/10/2007
42628/04 Westlund Súsanna Rós, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 07/07/2008
- 115 cases against Italy
- 9 cases concerning the danger that the applicants might be subjected to torture or to degrading or inhuman treatment in their country of origin (Tunisia) if the deportation orders against them were to be enforced
37201/06 Saadi, judgment of 28/02/2008 – Grand Chamber
2638/07 Abdelhedi, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
38128/06 Ben Salah, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
46792/06 Bouyahia, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
44006/06 C.B.Z., judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
11549/05 Darraji, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
16201/07 Hamraoui, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
37257/06 O., judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
37336/06 Soltana, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
36822/02 Bracci, judgment of 13/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
62094/00 Majadallah, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 26/03/2007
33932/06 Todorova, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
29768/05 Errico, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
75909/01 Sud Fondi Srl and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
- 3 cases concerning the special prison regime provided by Article 41bis of the Prison Administration Act (Article 8)
28320/02 Guidi, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
22728/03 De Pace, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
24424/03 Zara, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 06/07/2009
- 11 cases concerning the special prison regime provided by Article 41bis of the Prison Administration Act (Articles 6§1 and 13)
41576/98 Ganci, judgment of 30/10/03, final on 30/01/04
56317/00 Argenti, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
35795/02 Asciutto, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 07/07/2008
60915/00 Bifulco, judgment of 08/02/2005, final on 08/05/2005, Interim Resolution ResDH(2005)56
74912/01 Enea, judgment of 17/09/2009 – Grand Chamber
53723/00 Gallico, judgment of 28/06/2005, final on 28/09/2005
25498/94 Messina Antonio No. 2, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178
33695/96 Musumeci Carmelo, judgment of 11/01/2005, final on 06/06/2005
60395/00 Papalia, judgment of 04/12/2007, final on 04/03/2008
42285/98 Salvatore, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006
8316/02 Viola, judgment of 29/06/2006, final on 29/09/2006
- 2 cases concerning the lack of a public hearing in proceedings for the application of preventive measures
399/02 Bocellari and Rizza, judgment of 13/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
1905/05 Perre and others, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
- 85 cases concerning constructive expropriation
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2007)3
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Belvedere Alberghiera S.R.L. group)
- 1 case against Lithuania
16013/02 Četvertakas and others, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
- 9 cases against Malta
- Case concerning freedom of expression
7333/06 Lombardo and others, judgment of 24/04/2007, final on 24/07/2007
17209/02 Adami Zarb, judgment of 20/06/2006, final on 20/09/2006
77562/01 San Leonard Band Club, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004
35349/05 Fleri Soler and Camilleri, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 26/12/2006 and of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008 (Article 41)
31122/05 Ghigo, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 26/12/2006 and of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008 (Article 41)
17647/04 Edwards, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007 and of 17/07/2008, final on 06/04/2009 (Article 41)
- 3 cases of length of civil proceedings
34539/02 Debono, judgment of 07/02/2006, final on 07/05/2006
15091/06 Bezzina Wettinger and others, judgment of 08/04/2008, final on 08/07/2008
35829/03 Central Mediterranean Development Corporation Limited, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007
- 51 cases against Moldova
- 2 cases concerning the violation of the right to a fair hearing due to inadequate notification proceedure
61821/00 Ziliberberg, judgment of 01/02/2005, final on 01/05/2005
7413/05 Russu, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009
14385/04 Oferta Plus SRL, judgments of 19/12/2006, final on 23/05/2007 and of 12/02/2008 (Article 41), final on 07/07/2008
476/07+ Olaru and others, judgment of 28/07/2009, final on 28/10/2009
- 47 cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Luntre group)
- 2 cases against Norway
21132/05 Tv Vest As and Rogaland Pensjonistparti, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009
15472/02 Folgerø and others, judgment of 29/06/2007 – Grand Chamber
- 65 cases against Poland
11562/05 Byrzykowski, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006
15562/02 Lewandowski and Lewandowska, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
19616/04 Pieniak, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
23052/05 Kaprykowski, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
28300/06 Musiał Sławomir, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
44369/02 Wenerski, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
5410/03 Tysiąc, judgment of 20/03/2007, final on 24/09/2007
28586/03 Czarnowski, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009, rectified on 04/06/2009
- 37 cases mainly concerning the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence
31583/96 Klamecki No. 2, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03
43120/05 Andrulewicz, judgment of 03/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007
31038/06 Andrysiak, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008
20138/03 Bobel, judgment of 22/01/2008, final on 22/04/2008
26846/05 Ćwiertniak, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
20841/02 Drozdowski, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006
35833/03 Dzitkowski, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
55470/00 Ferla, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008
36161/05 Jakubiak, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
20251/04 Janulis, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 04/02/2009
72976/01 Jasiński, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 06/03/2008
8363/04 Kliza, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
44521/04 Kołodziński, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
10816/02 Kozimor, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
12269/02 Kozłowski Eryk, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 04/02/2009
49128/06 Krawiecki, judgment of 09/06/2009, final on 09/09/2009
51895/99 Kwiek, judgment of 30/05/2006, final on 30/08/2006
21890/03 Lewak, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 31/03/2008
73988/01 Łuczko, judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 03/01/2007
14450/02 Maksym, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
37641/97 Matwiejczuk, judgment of 02/12/03, final on 02/03/04
42083/98 Mianowski, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04
43837/06 Misiak, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 03/09/2008
62323/00 Najdecki, judgment of 06/02/2007, final on 06/05/2007
6390/03 Nowicki, judgment of 27/02/2007, final on 27/05/2007
8260/04 Ochlik, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
64284/01 Oleksy, judgment of 28/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
10381/04 Owsik, judgment of 16/10/2007, final on 16/01/2008
24322/02 Panusz, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
39840/05 Pawlak, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
92/03 Pisk-Piskowski, judgment of 14/06/2005, final on 14/09/2005
29366/03 Stępniak, judgment of 29/01/2008, final on 29/04/2008
64283/01 Tomczyk Prokopyszyn, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006
38007/02 Warsiński, judgment of 04/12/2007, final on 04/03/2008
63905/00 Wasilewski, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006
39519/05 Zborowski No. 3, judgment of 22/04/2008, final on 22/07/2008, rectified on 06/05/2008
45133/06 Zborowski, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
53025/99 Frankowicz, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
1543/06 Bączkowski and others, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 24/09/2007
52479/99 Rybacki, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
4317/04 Kaźmierczack, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
5422/04 Wojciechowski, judgment of 09/12/2008, final on 05/06/2009
35014/97 Hutten-Czapska, judgment of 19/06/2006 - Grand Chamber; (Article 41) judgment of 28/04/2008 - Grand Chamber – Friendly settlement
22860/02 Woś, judgment of 08/06/2006, final on 08/09/2006
- 5 cases concerning the unfairness of lustration proceedings
38184/03 Matyjek, judgment of 24/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007
68761/01 Bobek, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007
34030/07 Jałowiecki, judgment of 17/02/2009, final on 17/05/2009
37469/05 Luboch, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
38886/05 Rasmussen, judgment of 28/04/2009, final on 28/07/2009
9444/00 Kania, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/08/2007
23779/02 Kozłowski, judgment of 23/01/2007, final on 23/04/2007
- 6 cases concerning the lack of access to a court to challenge refusals to grant legal aid
12825/02 Tabor, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006
15670/02 Biziuk, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
64916/01 Bobrowski, judgment of 17/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
13526/07 Orzechowski Mirosłav, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
76396/01 Zagawa, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
14464/03 Zaniewski, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
- 53 cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative bodies and courts
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Fuchs group)
- 44 cases against Portugal
31276/05 Women On Waves and others, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
- 3 cases concerning freedom of expression
11182/03+ Colaço Mestre and SIC - Sociedade Independente de Communicação, S.A., judgment of 26/04/2007, final on 26/07/2007
20620/04 Azevedo, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
17107/05 Campos Dâmaso, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
- 15 cases concerning inadequate compensation for land expropriated under the agrarian reform of 1975
30533/03 Carvalho Acabado, judgment of 18/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
10172/04 Campos Costa and others, judgment of 30/10/2007, final on 30/01/2008
24668/05 Companhia Agrícola Cortes e Valbom S.A., judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 30/12/2008
21513/05 Companhia Agrícola da Barrosinha S.A., judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
21240/02+ Companhia Agrícola de Penha Garcia, S.A. and 16 other cases “Agrarian reform”, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
44311/04+ Costa Capucho and 23 other cases “Agrarian reform”, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
30844/05 De Avellar Cordeiro Zagallo, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
25025/05 De Sousa Carvalho Seabra, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 16/03/2009
41453/02 Herdade da Comporta - Actividades Agro Silvícola e Turísticas, S.A., judgment of 10/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008
31720/05 Kindler de Barahona, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2009
44386/05 Melo e Faro Maldonado Passanha and others, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
35254/05 Simões Alves Noronha, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
31677/04 Sociedade Agrícola Herdade da Palma S.A., judgment of 10/07/2007, final on 12/11/2007
17199/05+ Sociedade Agrícola da Herdade das Várzeas, Lda and 22 other cases “Agrarian reform”, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 23/12/2008
30808/05 Vasconcelos Do Couto and 23 other cases “Agrarian reform”, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
- 25 cases of length of judicial proceedings
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2007)108
a. Cases before civil courts
34422/97 Oliveira Modesto and others, judgment of 08/06/00, final on 08/09/00
54926/00 Costa Ribeiro, judgment of 30/04/03, final on 30/07/03
53997/00 Dias Da Silva and Gomes Ribeiro Martins, judgment of 27/03/03, final on 27/06/03
53534/99 Esteves, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03
56345/00 Ferreira Alves No. 2, judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04
53937/00 Ferreira Alves, Limited, judgment of 27/02/03, final on 27/05/03
49671/99 Ferreira da Nave, judgment of 07/11/02, final on 07/02/03
56110/00 Frotal-Aluguer de Equipamentos S.A., judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04
58617/00 Garcia da Silva, judgment of 29/04/2004, final on 29/07/2004
49279/99 Koncept-Conselho em Comunicação e Sensibilização de Públicos, Lda, judgment of 31/10/02, final on 31/01/03
52412/99 Marques Nunes, judgment of 20/02/03, final on 20/05/03
54566/00 Moreira and Ferreirinha, Lda and others, judgment of 26/06/03, final on 26/09/03
55081/00 Neves Ferreira Sande e Castro and others, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04
57323/00 Pena, judgment of 18/12/03, final on 18/03/04
48187/99 Rosa Marques and others, judgment of 25/07/02, final on 25/10/02
59017/00 Soares Fernandes, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004
44298/98 Tourtier, judgment of 14/02/02, final on 14/05/02
b. Cases before administrative courts
52662/99 Jorge Nina Jorge and others, judgment of 19/02/04, final on 19/05/04
55340/00 Sociedade Agrícola do Peral and other, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03
c. Cases before criminal courts
48956/99 Gil Leal Pereira, judgment of 31/10/02, final on 31/01/03
14886/03 Monteiro da Cruz, judgment of 17/01/2006, final on 17/04/2006
50775/99 Sousa Marinho and Marinho Meireles Pinto, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03
52657/99 Textile Traders, Limited, judgment of 27/02/03, final on 27/05/03
d. Case before family courts
51806/99 Figueiredo Simoes, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03
e. Case before labour courts
53795/00 Farinha Martins, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 10/10/03
- 242 cases against Romania
63258/00 Gagiu, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
5325/03 Voiculescu, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
42716/02 Toma, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
- 13 cases mainly concerning ill-treatment by the police and lack of an effective investigation
46430/99 Anghelescu Barbu No. 1, judgment of 05/10/2004, final on 05/01/2005
42066/98 Bursuc, judgment of 12/10/2004, final on 12/01/2005
48254/99 Cobzaru, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
6773/02 Damian-Burueană and Damian, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 26/08/2009
49234/99 Dumitru Popescu No.1, judgment of 26/04/2007, final on 26/07/2007
25230/03 Georgescu, judgment of 13/05/2008, final on 13/08/2008
64536/01 Iambor No.1, judgment of 24/06/2008, final on 24/09/2008
14526/03 Lupaşcu, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 04/02/2009
43247/02 Melinte, judgment of 09/11/2006, final on 09/02/2007
10778/02 Niţă, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 06/04/2009
71090/01 Olteanu, judgment of 14/04/2009, final on 14/07/2009
58478/00 Rupa No. 1, judgment of 16/02/2008, final on 16/03/2009
42722/02 Stoica, judgment of 04/03/2008, final on 04/06/2008
- 5 cases mainly concerning poor detention conditions
22088/04 Bragadireanu, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 06/03/2008
6586/03 Brânduşe, judgment of 07/04/2009, final on 07/07/2009
25763/03 Măciucă, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 26/08/2009
4792/03 Petrea, judgment of 29/04/2008, final on 01/12/2008
5269/02 Tănase, judgment of 12/05/2009, final on 12/08/2009
41124/02 Filip, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2007
28341/95 Rotaru, judgment of 04/05/00 - Grand Chamber
Interim Resolution ResDH(2005)57
70786/01 Rosengren, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
1434/02+ Lupaş and others, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2007
31679/96 Ignaccolo-Zenide, judgment of 25/01/00
4023/04 Amănălăchioai, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 26/08/2009
37284/02 Lafargue, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006
- 1 case against Romania and 1 case against Hungary and Romania
71099/01 Monory, judgment of 05/04/2005, final on 05/07/2005
7198/04 Iosub Caras, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 11/12/2006
73957/01 Varga, judgment of 01/04/2008, final on 01/07/2008
78060/01 Petrina, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
7901/02 Hagiescu and others, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009
42790/02 Deak, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 06/04/2009
60868/00 Vasilescu Grigore, judgment of 08/06/2006, final on 08/09/2006
17309/02 Grozescu, judgment of 27/09/2007, final on 27/12/2007
75951/01 Viaşu, judgment of 09/12/2008, final on 09/03/2009
1477/02 SC Pilot Services S.A. Constanţa, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 03/09/2008 and of 22/09/2009, possibly final on 22/12/2009
6079/02 Prodanof and others No. 2, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
26985/03 Burghelea, judgment of 27/01/2009, final on 27/04/2009
21911/03 Tudor Tudor, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
23066/02 Faimblat, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
36478/02 Jones, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
- 2 cases concerning the failure to observe the principle of legal certainty as final judgments resolving the applicants’ cases were not taken into account
4351/02 Amurăriţei, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 23/12/2008
9164/02 Ichim, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
- 121 cases concerning the failure to restore or compensate for nationalised property sold by the state to third parties
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Străin group)
Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay
by the administration in enforcing final judicial decisions:
- 54 cases concerning the failure to enforce final judicial decisions ordering the restitution of or compensation in respect of property nationalised or lost during the communist period
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Popescu Sabin group)
- 10 cases mainly concerning late enforcement of final judicial decisions ordering the applicants' reinstatement in their posts in public bodies and payment of salary arrears for the period they were unemployed
23878/02 Strungariu, judgment of 29/09/2005, final on 29/12/2005
35935/02 Cone, judgment of 24/06/2008, final on 24/09/2008
6098/03 Durdan, judgment of 26/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007
23657/03 Miclici, judgment of 20/12/2007, final on 20/03/2008
5060/02 Mihaescu, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 26/03/2007
20763/03 Niţescu Vasile, judgment of 21/04/2009, final on 21/07/2009
32019/03 Ocneanu, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
9555/03 Ştefanescu, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
24464/03 Şurtea, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on
29762/02 Teodorescu, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
- 12 cases concerning late enforcement of, or failure to enforce final judicial decisions by public institutions
73970/01 Sacaleanu, judgment of 06/09/2005, final on 06/12/2005
37380/03 Balcan, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
25765/04 Delca, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 06/07/2009
13386/02 Moldoveanu, judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
26004/03 Niţescu, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 24/06/2009
1486/02 Orha, judgments of 12/10/2006, final on 12/01/2007 and of 04/11/2008 - Friendly settlement
24714/03 Paicu, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
5050/02 Pântea Elisabeta, judgment of 15/06/2006, final on 15/09/2006
34860/02 Piştireanu, judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 30/12/2008
29268/03 S.C. Ghepardul S.R.L., judgment of 14/04/2009, final on 14/07/2009
28333/02 SC Ruxandra Trading SRL, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007 and of 02/12/2008, final on 02/03/2009
40263/05 Străchinaru, judgment of 21/02/2008, final on 21/05/2008
- 136 cases against the Russian Federation
46468/06 Aleksanyan, judgment of 22/12/2008, final on 05/06/2009
15339/02+ Budayeva and others, judgment of 20/03/2008, final on 29/09/2008
25385/04 Medova, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
14139/03 Bolat, judgment of 05/10/2006, final on 05/01/2007
- 8 cases concerning extradition
38411/02 Garabayev, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 30/01/2008
42443/02 Eminbeyli, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2009
2947/06 Ismoilov and others, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 01/12/2008
13476/04 Khudyakova, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
42502/06 Muminov, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
656/06 Nasrulloyev, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
8320/04 Ryabikin, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008
16074/07 Shchebet, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008
- 12 cases mainly concerning ill-treatment inflicted on the applicants while in custody and the lack of an effective investigation
77617/01 Mikheyev, judgment of 26/01/2006, final on 26/04/2006
5742/02 Akulinin and Babich, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 02/01/2009
36220/02 Barabanshchikov, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 26/01/2009
1748/02 Belousov, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
3811/02 Denisenko and Bogdanchikov, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
78145/01 Kovalev, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
839/02 Maslova and Nalbandov, judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
9297/02 Nadrosov, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 26/01/2009
36410/02 Nikitin Oleg, judgment of 09/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
30033/05 Polonskiy, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
64398/01 Samoylov, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
65859/01 Sheydayev, judgment of 07/12/2006, final on 23/05/2007
- 47 cases concerning unlawful detention, excessive length and insufficient grounds
(see Appendix for the list of cases in the Klyakhin group)
7188/03 Chember, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
- 39 cases concerning poor conditions of detention, amounting to degrading treatment
47095/99 Kalashnikov, judgment of 15/07/02, final 15/10/02, Interim Resolution ResDH(2003)123
1750/03 Andreyevskiy, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 06/07/2009
22107/03 Antropov, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
67253/01 Babushkin, judgment of 18/10/2007, final on 18/01/2008
37810/03 Bagel, judgment of 15/11/2007, final on 15/02/2008
28617/03 Belashev, judgment of 04/12/2008, final on 04/05/2009
106/02 Benediktov, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 24/09/2007
68337/01 Buzychkin, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
39420/03 Bychkov, judgment of 05/03/2009, final on 05/06/2009
66802/01 Dorokhov, judgment of 14/02/2008, final on 14/05/2008
205/02 Frolov Andrey, judgment of 29/03/2007, final on 24/09/2007
52058/99 Gorodnitchev, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
22/03 Grigoryevskikh, judgment of 09/04/2009, final on 09/07/2009
30983/02 Grishin, judgment of 15/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
36941/02 Gubkin, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 23/07/2009
24650/02 Guliyev, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008
34000/02 Ivanov Igor, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 30/01/2008
37213/02 Kantyrev, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on /01/2008
25948/05 Knyazev, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
67086/01 Korobov and others, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
62208/00 Labzov, judgment of 16/06/05, final on 16/09/05
25664/05 Lind, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 02/06/2008
6270/06 Lyubimenko, judgment of 19/03/2009, final on 19/06/2009
15217/07 Makarov Aleksandr, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 14/09/2009
6954/02 Maltabar and Maltabar, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 29/04/2009
14850/03 Matyush, judgment of 09/12/2008, final on 09/03/2009
63378/00 Mayzit, judgment of 20/01/05, final on 06/07/05
52697/99 Mikadze, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007
22625/02 Mironov, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 08/02/2008
11982/02 Novinskiy, judgment of 10/02/2009, final on 10/05/2009
66460/01 Novoselov, judgment of 02/06/05, final on 02/09/05
1606/02 Popov and Vorobyev, judgment of 23/04/2009, final on 23/07/2009
3522/04 Salmanov, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 31/10/2008
15591/03 Seleznev, judgment of 26/06/2008, final on 01/12/2008
23691/06 Shteyn (Stein), judgment of 18/06/2009, final on 18/09/2009
42239/02 Starokadomskiy, judgment of 31/07/2008, final on 31/10/2008
3130/03 Sudarkov, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
63955/00 Sukhovoy, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
36898/03 Trepashkin, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007
6293/04 Mirilashvili, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 05/06/2009
42454/02 Menchinskaya, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
184/02 Kuznetsov and others, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 11/04/2007
10519/03 Barankevich, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
72881/01 Moscow Branch of the Salvation Army, judgment of 05/10/2006, final on 05/01/2007
18147/02 Church of Scientology Moscow, judgment of 05/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007
30160/04 Dzhavadov, judgment of 27/09/2007, final on 27/12/2007
35082/04 Makhmudov, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
- 8 cases concerning freedom of expression
72683/01 Chemodurov, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007
25968/02 Dyuldin and Kislov, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007
37406/03 Dyundin, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
14888/03 Godlevskiy, judgment of 23/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
73219/01 Filatenko, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 06/03/2008
29372/02 Karman, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2007
12365/03 Krasulya, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 22/05/2007
34736/03 Obukhova, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
55066/00+ Russian Conservative Party of Entrepreneurs and others, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 11/04/2007
17864/04+ Krasnov and Skuratov, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 31/03/2008
10877/04 Kuznetsov Sergei, judgment of 23/10/2008, final on 23/01/2009
32147/04 Kuimov, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
1509/02 Tatishvili, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 09/07/2007
1758/02 Kazakov, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 05/06/2009
3891/03 Samokhvalov, judgment of 12/02/2009, final on 12/05/2009
14810/02 Ryakib Biryukov, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
- 2 cases concerning violations of the right to home due to industrial pollution
55723/00 Fadeyeva, judgment of 09/06/2005, final on 30/11/2005
53157/99+ Ledyayeva, Dobrokhotova, Zolotareva and Romashina, judgment of 26/10/2006, final on 26/03/2007
- 3 cases concerning the search carried out in the home of the applicants in the framework of criminal proceedings opened against their clients and the illegal seizure and retention of property
71362/01 Smirnov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007
18274/04 Borzhonov, judgment of 22/01/2009, final on 22/04/2009
19856/04 Kolesnichenko, judgment of 09/04/2009, final on 09/07/2009
- 6 cases concerning quashing of final judgments through the supervisory review procedure (criminal proceedings)
65582/01 Radchikov, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
54882/00 Chervonenko, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 06/07/2009
15336/02 Chistyakov Eduard, judgment of 09/04/2009, final on 09/07/2009
75469/01 Kiselev, judgment of 29/01/2009, final on 06/07/2009
63997/00 Fedorov, judgment of 26/02/2009, final on 26/05/2009
8927/02 Sharomov, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
- 37 cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in enforcing judgments relating to the social benefits of former Chernobyl workers
Resolution ResDH(2004)85, Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)43
33264/02 Levin, judgment of 02/02/05, final on 02/05/06
34439/04 Agaponova and others, judgment of 07/02/2008, final on 07/05/2008
75025/01+ Aleksentseva and others, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 17/04/2008
966/03 Almayeva, judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 25/01/2008
35774/04 Arulepp, judgment of 06/11/2008, final on 06/02/2009
32786/04 Bakharev and others, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
21932/03 Bakharev, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007
37930/02 Bazhenov, judgment of 20/10/05, final on 20/01/06
34679/03 Belotserkovets, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
24620/02 Belyayev, judgment of 25/01/2007, final on 25/04/2007
72558/01 Blagovestnyy, judgment of 04/07/2006, final on 04/10/2006
1719/02 Butsev, judgment of 22/09/05, final on 15/02/06
40642/02 Denisenkov, judgment of 22/09/05, final on 15/02/06
34431/04 Denisova, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
28488/04 Dokolin, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
41842/04 Fitisov, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 08/02/2008
38719/03 Glushakova, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
38305/02 Gorokhov and Rusyayev, judgment of 17/03/05, final on 12/10/05
63995/00 Kukalo, judgment of 03/11/2005, final on 03/02/2006
11319/04 Kukalo No. 2, judgment of 24/07/2008, final on 24/10/2008
43209/04 Ledovkin, judgment of 21/02/2008, final on 21/05/2008
35893/04 Levin Viktor, judgment of 25/09/2008, final on 25/12/2008
43282/02 Naydenkov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 24/09/2007
37927/02 Nikolayev, judgment of 02/03/06, final on 02/06/06
19589/02 Parkhomov, judgment of 20/10/05, final on 20/01/06
15890/04 Petrov Viktor, judgment of 24/07/2008, final on 24/10/2008
36939/02 Podyapolskiy, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008
38720/03 Popov Aleksandr, judgment of 05/04/2007, final on 05/07/2007
26307/02 Shirykalova, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
32786/03 Silchenko, judgment of 28/09/2006, final on 28/12/2006
24664/02 Siverin, judgment of 04/12/2008, final on 04/03/2009
33660/04 Smelov, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 02/01/2009
37647/04 Smorodinova, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 17/04/2008
34938/04 Suslin, judgment of 23/10/2008, final on 23/01/2009
39013/05 Svitich, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007
40543/04 Voronin, judgment of 04/12/2008, final on 04/03/2009
38845/04 Zubarev, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 02/01/2009
- 1 case against San Marino
40786/98 Beneficio Cappella Paolini, judgment of 13/07/2004, final on 13/10/2004 and of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007 - Friendly settlement
- 4 cases against Spain
36777/03 Iribarren Pinillos, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
37496/04 Iguall Coll, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
423/03 Díaz Ochoa, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 22/09/2006
41745/02 Lacárcel Menéndez, judgment of 15/06/2006, final on 11/12/2006
- 1 case against Sweden
62332/00 Segersted-Wiberg and others, judgment of 06/06/2006, final on 06/09/2006
- 2 cases against Switzerland
29002/06 Schlumpf, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
32772/02 Verein gegen Tierfabriken Schweiz (VgT) No. 2, judgment of 30/06/2009 – Grand Chamber
- 4 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"
74651/01 Association of citizens “Radko” and Paunkovski, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
27736/03 Petkoski and others, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 05/06/2009
10649/03 Fetaovski, judgment of 19/06/2008, final on 19/09/2008
- Case of length of criminal proceedings
26541/02 Nankov, judgment of 29/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
- 237 cases against Turkey
38595/97 Kakoulli, judgment of 22/11/2005, final on 22/02/2006
28290/95 Güngör, judgment of 22/03/2005, final on 22/06/2005
70337/01 Güveç, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
- 43 cases concerning the lack of effective investigations in respect of the actions of the Turkish security forces
a) following ill-treatment of the applicants and / or
33097/96+ Batı and others, judgment of 03/06/2004, final on 03/09/2004
1249/03 Atalay, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
26893/02 Ataş and Seven, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 16/03/2009
71912/01+ Böke and Kandemir, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009, rectified on 18/08/2009
30461/02 Çağlayan, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 21/01/2009
28433/02 Çamdereli, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
39324/02 Çelik No. 1, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
25172/02 Çamçi and others, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 24/05/2009
72194/01 Doğan Nurgül, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
10301/03 Getiren, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
5264/03 Gülbahar and others, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 21/01/2009
40803/02 Karabulut Mustafa, judgment of 20/11/2007, final on 20/02/2008
30009/03 Karademir Osman, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
8810/03 Karaduman and others, judgment of 17/06/2008, final on 17/09/2008
29766/03 Karatepe and Ulaş, judgment of 17/06/2008, final on 17/09/2008
5387/02 Kelekçier, judgment of 28/04/2009, final on 28/07/2009
32577/02 Kur Orhan, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 29/09/2008
52067/99 Okkalı, judgment of 17/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
74306/01 Öktem, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 26/03/2007
45906/99 Özcan Zeynep, judgment of 20/02/2007, final on 20/05/2007
13903/02 Özgür and Çamlı, judgment of 04/12/2007, final on 04/03/2008
53147/99 Şahin Zülcihan and others, judgment of 03/02/2005, final on 03/05/2005
15828/03 Salmanoğlu and Polattaş, judgment of 17/03/2009, final on 17/06/2009
68881/01 Şimşek Hüseyin, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008
43918/98 Sunal, judgment of 25/01/2005, final on 25/04/2005
19028/02 Tamer Fazıl Ahmet and others, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007
8534/02 Tekin and others, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008, rectified on 30/09/2008
11381/02 Tonka and others, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
33086/04 Türkan, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
43124/98 Türkmen, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
15750/02 Uyan No. 2, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 21/01/2009
32446/96 Yaman Abdülsamet, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005
34738/04 Yeşil and Sevim, judgment of 05/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007, rectified on 14/11/2007
19374/03 Yilmaz and others, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
17721/02 Yılmaz Hürriyet, judgment of 05/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007
b) following the death of the applicants’ relatives
34592/97 Ağdaş, judgment of 27/07/2004, final on 27/10/2004
51967/99 Aksakal Teren, judgment of 11/09/2007, final on 06/07/2009
19180/03 Çetin Nafiye and others, judgment of 07/04/2009, final on 07/07/2009
34491/97 Demir Ceyhan and others, judgment of 11/01/2005, final on 11/04/2005
42942/02 Duran Ali and Ayşe, judgment of 08/04/2008, final on 08/07/2008
40262/98 H.Y. and Hü.Y., judgment of 06/10/2005, final on 06/01/2006
35072/97+ Şimşek and others, judgment of 26/07/2005, final on 26/10/2005
33750/03 Yeter, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
48939/99 Ôneryıldız, judgment of 30/11/2004 - Grand Chamber
- 4 cases concerning non-enforcement of court decisions in cases concerning environmental protection
46117/99 Taşkın and others, judgment of 10/11/2004, final on 30/03/2005, rectified on 01/02/2005
46771/99 Öçkan and others, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 13/09/2006
17381/02 Lemke, judgment of 05/06/2007, final on 05/09/2007
36220/97 Okyay Ahmet and others, judgment of 12/07/2005, final on 12/10/2005 - Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2007)4
1448/04 Zengin Hasan and Eylem, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 09/01/2008
- 3 cases concerning the independence and impartiality of military disciplinary courts
39429/98 Bayrak, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 24/09/2007
30200/02 İrkin, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 23/12/2008
27341/02 Veyisoğlu, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 26/09/2007
- 6 cases mainly concerning freedom of expression – military conviction for incitement to abstain from compulsory military service
47533/99 Ergin No. 6, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 04/08/2006
37033/03 Doğan Ahmet, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 06/07/2009
4211/02 Erükcü, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009
56827/00 Düzgören, judgment of 09/11/2006, final on 09/02/2007
65344/01 Onaran, judgment of 05/06/2007, final on 05/09/2007
70335/01 Yurdatapan, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 08/04/2008
56566/00 Kaplan Yaşar, judgment of 24/01/2006, final on 24/04/2006
28582/02 Asan, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
75510/01 Artun and Güvener, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 26/09/2007, rectified on 12/11/2007
38406/97 Albayrak, judgment of 31/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
34797/03 Ulusoy and others, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 24/09/2007
- 4 cases concerning freedom of expression – broadcasting legislation
64178/00+ Özgür Radyo-Ses Radyo Televizyon Yayın Yapım Ve Tanıtım A.Ş. No. 1, judgment of 30/03/2006, final on 30/06/2006, rectified on 05/12/2008
6587/03 Nur Radyo Ve Televizyon Yayıncılığı A.Ş., judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008, rectified on 03/03/2008
11369/03 Özgür Radyo-Ses Radyo Televizyon Yayın Yapım Ve Tanıtım A.Ş. No. 2, judgment of 04/12/2007, final on 02/06/2008, rectified on 05/12/2008
10129/04 Özgür Radyo – Ses Radyo-Televizyon Yayın Yapım Ve Tanıtım A.Ş., judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
19353/03 Saygılı and others, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 08/04/2008
35839/97 Pakdemirli, judgment of 22/02/2005, final on 22/05/2005
- 3 cases concerning freedom of expression – civil defamation proceedings
48176/99 Turhan, judgment of 19/05/2005, final on 19/08/2005, rectified on 30/03/2006
39656/03 Erdoğan Ayhan, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
17095/03 Öztürk Cihan, judgment of 09/06/2009, final on 09/09/2009
36458/02 Temel Irfan and others, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009
6615/03 Karaçay, judgment of 27/03/2007, final on 27/06/2007
23018/04+ Urcan and others, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
12863/02 Işıldak, judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 30/12/2008
37483/02 Erdagöz Güzel, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
8932/03 Paşaoğlu, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
- Case of length of detention on remand of minors
20817/04 Nart, judgment of 06/05/2008, final on 06/08/2008
35832/97 IPSD and others, judgment of 25/10/2005, final on 25/01/2006
23815/04 Uslu No. 2, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009, rectified on 15/07/2009
16330/02 Gülmez, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 29/09/2008
35686/02 Ünel, judgment of 27/05/2008, final on 27/08/2008
- 2 cases concerning the unfairness of certain judicial proceedings in which the request for annulment of an administrative act was denied and the administration refused to submit a classified file
70516/01 Dağtekin and others, judgment of 13/12/2007, final on 13/03/2008, rectified on 21/05/2008
31881/02 Gencer, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
- 7 cases concerning the failure to communicate the public prosecutor’s opinion before the Council of State
33446/02 Meral, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
19728/02 Akgül, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
9907/02 Araç, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 23/12/2008.
2841/05+ Ekmekçi and others, judgment of 26/05/2009, final on 26/08/2009
38012/03 Hasırcı, judgment of 24/03/2009, final on 06/07/2009
41296/04+ Karaduman and Tandoğan, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 03/09/2008
37829/05 Yılmaz Melek Sima, judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 06/04/2009
44088/04 Menemen Minibüsçüler Odası, judgment of 09/12/2008, final on 09/03/2009
33663/02 Mörel, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
40998/98 Islamic Republic Of Iran Shipping Lines, judgment of 13/12/2007, final on 13/03/2008
- 139 cases of length of judicial proceedings
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Ormancı group)
- 393 cases against Ukraine
- 4 cases mainly concerning the failure to conduct an effective investigation into the death of the applicants
32478/02 Shevchenko, judgment of 04/04/2006, final on 04/07/2006
29971/04 Kats and others, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 18/03/2009, rectified on 06/05/2009
39964/02 Khaylo, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009
249/03 Muravskaya, judgment of 13/11/2008, final on 13/02/2009
72286/01 Melnik, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006
40269/02 Koretskyy and others, judgment of 03/04/2008, final on 03/07/2008
- 8 cases concerning the inhuman and degrading treatment of the applicants and / or the absence of an effective remedy whereby complaint might be made and lack of procedural safeguards in police custody
38722/02 Afanasyev, judgment of 05/04/2005, final on 05/07/2005
17323/04 Ismailov, judgment of 27/11/2008, final on 27/02/2009
16437/04 Kobets, judgment of 14/02/2008, final on 14/05/2008
75520/01 Kozinets, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 06/03/2008, rectified on 27/02/2008
34331/03 Spinov, judgment of 27/11/2008, final on 06/07/2009
39188/04 Suptel, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
19312/06 Vergelskyy, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
32092/02 Yaremenko, judgment of 12/06/2008, final on 12/09/2008
- 8 cases concerning the poor detention conditions of the applicants
39042/97 Kuznetsov, judgment of 29/04/03
41220/98 Aliev, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03
40679/98 Dankevich, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03
41707/98 Khokhlich, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03
18660/03 Malenko, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
39483/98 Nazarenko, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03
38812/97 Poltoratskiy, judgment of 29/04/03
15825/06 Yakovenko, judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 25/01/2008
- 14 cases mainly concerning inhuman and/or degrading treatment in detention resulting from overcrowding, unsatisfactory hygiene and sanitation conditions or inadequate medical care, as well as lack of an effective remedy
54825/00 Nevmerzhitsky, judgment of 05/04/2005, final on 12/10/2005
16505/02 Doronin, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
72277/01 Dvoynykh, judgment of 12/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
28827/02 Isayev, judgment of 28/05/2009, final on 28/08/2009
65550/01 Koval, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
16447/04 Kucherenko Nikolay, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
2570/04 Kucheruk, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
75522/01 Mikhaniv, judgment of 06/11/2008, final on 6/04/2009
34211/04 Miroshnichenko Roman, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
40774/02+ Solovey and Zozulya, judgment of 27/11/2008, final on 27/02/2009
35231/02 Svershov, judgment of 27/11/2008, final on 27/02/2009
39458/02 Tkachev, judgment of 13/12/2007, final on 13/03/2008
30628/02 Ukhan, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 18/03/2009
17283/02 Yeloyev, judgment of 06/11/2008, final on 06/02/2009
34056/02 Gongadze, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2008)35, Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)74
- 3 cases concerning extradition
2440/07 Soldatenko, judgment of 23/10/2008, final on 23/01/2009
48068/06 Novik, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 18/03/2009
2929/05 Svetlorusov, judgment of 12/03/2009, final on 12/06/2009
3236/03 Ponomaryov, judgment of 03/04/2008, final on 29/09/2008
16404/03 Shabelnik, judgment of 19/02/2009, final on 19/05/2009
30663/04 Lutsenko, judgment of 18/12/2008, final on 18/03/2009
7577/02 Bochan, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007
37878/02 Tserkva Sela Sosulivka, judgment of 28/02/2008, final on 28/05/2008
77703/01 Svyato-Mykhaylivska Parafiya, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
- 346 cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments
CM/Inf/DH(2007)30-rev (English only) and CM/Inf/DH(2007)33
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2008)1, Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)159
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Zhovner group)
47148/99 Novoseletskiy, judgment of 22/02/2005, final on 22/05/2005
- 11 cases against the United Kingdom
30562/04+ S. and Marper, judgment of 04/12/2008 – Grand Chamber
3455/05 A. and others, judgment of 19/02/2009 – Grand Chamber
74025/01 Hirst No. 2, judgment of 06/10/2005 - Grand Chamber
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)160
- 6 cases concerning the action of the security forces in the United Kingdom
28883/95 McKerr, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01
37715/97 Shanaghan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01
24746/94 Hugh Jordan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01
30054/96 Kelly and others, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01
43290/98 McShane, judgment of 28/05/02, final on 28/08/02
29178/95 Finucane, judgment of 01/07/03, final on 01/10/03
Interim Resolutions ResDH(2005)20, CM/ResDH(2007)73 and CM/ResDH(2009)44
CM/Inf/DH(2006)4-rev2, CM/Inf/DH(2006)4-addrev3 and CM/Inf/DH(2008)2-rev
58243/00 Liberty and others, judgment of 01/07/2008, final on 01/10/2008
3383/06 Bullen and Soneji, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009, rectified on 27/01/2009
SUB-SECTION 4.3 – SPECIAL PROBLEMS
- 1 case against Italy
246/07 Ben Khemais, judgment of 08/07/2009, final on 06/07/2009
- 355 cases against the Russian Federation
33509/04 Burdov No. 2, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 04/05/2009
CM/Inf/DH(2006)19-rev2, CM/Inf/DH(2006)19-rev3, CM/Inf/DH(2006)45,
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)43
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)158
- 209 cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Timofeyev group)
CM/Inf/DH(2006)19-rev2, CM/Inf/DH(2006)19-rev3, CM/Inf/DH(2006)45,
Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)43, Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2009)158
- 55 cases mainly concerning the quashing of final judgments through the supervisory review procedure (civil aspects)
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Ryabykh group)
- 90 cases concerning security forces in the Chechen Republic
CM/Inf/DH(2006)32-rev2, CM/Inf/DH(2008)33, CM/Inf/DH(2008)33-add CM/Inf/DH(2009)32
(See Appendix for the list of cases in the Khashiyev and Akayeva group)
- 275 cases against Turkey
25781/94 Cyprus against Turkey, judgment of 10/05/01 – Grand Chamber
CM/Inf/DH(2008)6, CM/Inf/DH(2007)10/1-rev, CM/Inf/DH(2007)10/3-rev, CM/Inf/DH(2008)6/5, CM/Inf/DH(2009)39
Interim Resolutions ResDH(2005)44 and CM/ResDH(2007)25
16064/90+ Varnava and others, judgment of 18/09/2009 – Grand Chamber
46347/99 Xenides-Arestis, judgments of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006 and of 07/12/2006, final on 23/05/2007
CM/Inf/DH(2007)19, Interim Resolution CM/ResDH(2008)99, DD(2009)540
39437/98 Ülke, judgment of 24/01/2006, final on 24/04/2006
Interim Resolutions CM/ResDH(2007)109 and CM/ResDH(2009)45, DD(2009)556
28490/95 Hulki Güneş, judgment of 19/06/03, final on 19/09/03
Interim Resolutions ResDH(2005)113, CM/ResDH(2007)26 and CM/ResDH(2007)150
72000/01 Göçmen, judgment of 17/10/2006, final on 17/01/2007
46661/99 Söylemez, judgment of 21/09/2006, final on 21/12/2006
25060/02+ Erdal Aslan, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 02/03/2009
- 198 cases concerning the actions of the Turkish security forces
(Interim Resolutions ResDH(2005)43 and CM/ResDH(2008)69)
- 69 Friendly settlements and striking-out concerning actions of the Turkish security forces and involving undertakings by the Turkish government
SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED
(See Addendum 5 for part or all these cases)
Action
The Deputies are invited to supervise progress in the adoption of general measures aiming at preventing further similar violations to those found by the Court in the following cases.
SUB-SECTION 5.1 – LEGISLATIVE AND/OR REGULATORY CHANGES
- 2 cases against the Netherlands
50210/99 Doerga, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004
64752/01 Voskuil, judgment of 22/11/2007, final on 22/02/2008
- 1 case against Portugal
64330/01 Antunes Rocha, judgment of 31/05/2005, final on 12/10/2005
- 4 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia"
- 4 cases concerning lack of effective investigation of allegations of ill-treatment by the police
69908/01 Jasar, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
13252/02 Dželadinov, judgment of 10/04/2008, final on 10/07/2008
69875/01 Sulejmanov, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
13191/02 Trajkoski, judgment of 07/02/2008, final on 07/07/2008
- 4 cases against Turkey
- 4 cases concerning the violation of the equality of arms due to the failure to communicate classified documents in the case file
59741/00 Aksoy (Eroğlu), judgment of 31/10/2006, final on 31/01/2007
59739/00 Güner Çorum, judgment of 31/10/2006, final on 31/01/2007
60366/00 Kahraman, judgment of 31/10/2006, final on 31/01/2007
3055/04 Topal, judgment of 21/04/2009, final on 21/07/2009
SUB-SECTION 5.2 – CHANGES OF COURTS’ CASE-LAW OR OF ADMINISTRATIVE PRACTICE
No new case
SUB-SECTION 5.3 – PUBLICATION / DISSEMINATION
The Deputies decided to resume consideration of these items at their 1086th meeting (June 2010) (DH), in the light of information to be provided on general measures, namely publication and dissemination of the European Court's judgments.
Section 5.3a
Cases in which supervision of measures concerning publications and disseminations has been taking place for less than a year
- 2 cases against Bulgaria
66535/01 Kroushev, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 03/10/2008
68294/01 Kandzhov, judgment of 06/11/2008, final on 06/02/2009
- 2 cases against Denmark
- 2 cases of length of criminal proceedings
32848/06 Moesgaard Petersen, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009
36244/06 Hasslund, judgment of 11/12/2008, final on 11/03/2009
- 2 cases against Greece
25145/05 Vasilakis, judgment of 17/01/2008, final on 17/04/2008
- Case concerning freedom of expression
15909/06 I Avgi Publishing and Press Agency S.A. and Karis, judgment of 05/06/2008, final on 05/09/2008
- 1 case against Italy
- Case concerning the lack of access to a court, the applicants being unable to bring proceedings for libel against members of the parliament enjoying parliamentary privilege
46967/07 C.G.I.L. and Cofferati, judgment of 24/02/2009, final on 06/07/2009
- 1 case against Moldova
7170/02 Grădinar, judgment of 08/04/2008, final on 08/07/2008
- 1 case against Poland
- Case concerning freedom of expression
57659/00 Kita, judgment of 08/07/2008, final on 08/10/2008
- 4 cases against Romania
15741/03 Visan, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
36900/03 Toşcuţă and others, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
- 2 cases concerning the impossibility to obtain possession of a land or equivalent compensation, due to the existence of a second property title delivered to third persons under Law No. 18/1991
20294/02 Drăculet, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 31/03/2008 and of 05/02/2009, final on 05/05/2009
31005/03 Ioan, judgment of 01/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
- 8 cases against Turkey
6489/03 Karaman, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
25471/02 Gemici, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 02/03/2009
1606/03 Salihoğlu, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 21/01/2009
22427/04 Canlı Cematettin, judgment of 18/11/2008, final on 18/02/2009
- 3 cases concerning the annulment of titles of property belonging to minority religious foundations, more than thirty years after lawful acquisition
37639/03+ Bozcaada Kimisis Teodoku Rum Ortodoks Kilisesi Vakfı, judgment of 03/03/2009, final on 03/06/2009, rectified on 02/10/2009
1480/03 Samatya Surp Kevork Ermeni Kilisesi, Mektebi Ve Mezarlığı Vakfı Yönetim Kurulu, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 16/03/2009
36165/02 Yekidule Surp Pırgiç Ermeni Hastanesi Vakfı, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 16/03/2009
- Case concerning ill-treatment as a result of disproportionate security measures during the medical examination of detainees
7496/03 Uyan Filiz, judgment of 08/01/09, final on 08/04/09.
Section 5.3b
Cases in which supervision of measures concerning publications and disseminations has been taking place for more than a year
- 1 case against Andorra
69498/01 Pla and Puncernau, judgment of 13/07/2004, final on 15/12/2004 and of 10/10/2004 (Article 41) - Friendly settlement
- 8 cases against Bulgaria
56272/00 Kayadjieva, judgment of 28/09/2006, final on 28/12/2006
31365/96 Varbanov, judgment of 05/10/00
39269/98 Kepenerov, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 03/12/03
40061/98 M.S., judgment of 04/07/02 - Friendly settlement
68079/01 Nikolov Nikola, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
44624/98 Prikyan and Angelova, judgment of 16/02/2006, final on 16/05/2006
40476/98 Yanakiev, judgment of 10/08/2006, final on 10/11/2006
39272/98 M.C., judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04
- 1 case against Italy
- Case concerning the lack of access to a court, the applicants being unable to bring proceedings for libel against members of the parliament enjoying parliamentary privilege
10180/04 Patrono, Cascini and Stefanelli, judgment of 20/04/2006, final on 20/07/2006
- 3 cases against Latvia
30273/03 Perry, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
61005/00 Kornakovs, judgment of 15/06/2006, final on 15/09/2006
66820/01 Svipsta, judgment of 09/03/2006; final on 09/06/2006
- 3 cases against Poland
6925/02 Szymoński, judgment of 10/10/2006, final on 10/01/2007
46917/99 Stankiewicz, judgment of 06/04/2006, final on 06/07/2006
51728/99 Rosenzweig and Bonded Warehouses Ltd., judgment of 28/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005
- 2 cases against Romania
77193/01+ Dragotoniu and Militaru-Pidhorni, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 24/08/2007
35097/02 Bozgan, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
- 7 cases against Turkey
1855/02 Kök, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 19/01/2007
34494/97 H.M., judgment of 08/08/2006, final on 08/11/2006
70845/01 Kılıç Taner, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
58771/00 Amato, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007
49548/99 Baş, judgment of 24/06/2008, final on 24/09/2008 and of 22/09/2009, possibly final on 22/12/2009
- Case concerning the right to a fair hearing (re-examination without valid reason of issues which had already been the subject of a final decision)
10332/02+ Gög, Kolsuzoğlu and Agbayır, judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 24/04/2008
- Case concerning the annulment of titles of property belonging to minority religious foundations, more than thirty years after lawful acquisition
34478/97 Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi, judgment of 09/01/2007, final on 09/04/2007, rectified on 22/05/2007
SUB-SECTION 5.4 – OTHER MEASURES
No new case
SECTION 6 - CASES PRESENTED WITH A VIEW TO THE PREPARATION OF A DRAFT FINAL RESOLUTION
(See Addendum 6 for part or all these cases)
Action
At the time of issuing the present annotated Agenda, the information available on the measures taken in these cases seemed to allow the preparation of draft resolutions putting an end to their examination by the Committee of Ministers.
As regards the cases appearing in Section 6.1, the Deputies are invited to examine the new information available with a view to evaluating whether a draft final resolution can be prepared. As regards cases listed in Section 6.2, the Deputies are invited to note that the elaboration of a draft final resolution, in co-operation with the delegation of the respondent state, is under way. In both cases, the Deputies are invited to postpone consideration of these cases to their next meeting.
Section 6.1
Cases in which the new information available since the last examination appears to allow the preparation of a draft final resolution
- 2 cases against France
62740/00 Matheus, judgment of 31/03/2005, final on 01/07/2005
17070/05 Farhi, judgment of 16/01/2007, final on 23/05/2007
- 1 case against Greece
45769/06 Kokkinis, judgment of 06/11/2008, final on 06/02/2009
- 6 cases against Romania
- 2 cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions concerning tax exemptions
25632/02 Stere and others, judgment of 23/02/2006, final on 23/05/2006
21351/03 Stîngaciu and Tudor, judgment of 03/08/2006, final on 03/11/2006
35671/97 Lindner and Hammermayer, judgment of 06/04/2006 - Grand Chamber - Friendly settlement
31549/96 Popovici and Dumitrescu, judgment of 06/04/2006 - Grand Chamber - Friendly settlement
30324/96 Smoleanu, judgment of 06/04/2006 - Grand Chamber - Friendly settlement
- Case concerning the annulment of final court decisions relating to property ownership
7893/02 Ghibuşi, judgment of 23/06/2005, final on 12/10/2005
Section 6.2
Cases waiting for the presentation of a draft final resolution
- 43 cases against Austria
42780/98 I.H., judgment of 20/04/2006, final on 20/07/2006
45289/99 Brunnthaler, judgment of 29/06/2006, final on 29/09/2006
69162/01 Geyer, judgment of 07/07/2005, final on 07/10/2005
45203/99 Birnleitner, judgment of 24/02/2005, final on 24/05/2005
29477/95 Eisenstecken, judgment of 03/10/00
24430/94 Lanz, judgment of 31/01/02, final on 31/04/02
26113/95 Wirtschafts-Trend Zeitschriften Verlagsgesellchaft m.b.H., Interim Resolution DH(98)378
32899/96 Buchberger, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02
60553/00 Malek, judgment of 12/06/03, final on 12/09/03
43454/98 Bakker, judgment of 10/04/03, final on 10/07/03
40016/98 Karner, judgment of 24/07/03, final on 24/10/03
54698/00 Kaya, judgment of 08/06/2006, final on 08/09/2006
54645/00 Osinger, judgment of 24/03/2005, final on 24/06/2005
12555/03 Müller, judgment of 05/10/2006, final on 05/01/2007
76900/01 Öllinger, judgment of 29/06/2006, final on 29/09/2006
55193/00 Schelling, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
35354/04 Abrahamian, judgment of 10/04/2008, final on 10/07/2008
7912/05 Bösch, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007
1032/04 Emer-Reissig, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/08/2007
76293/01 Brugger, judgment of 26/01/2006, final on 26/04/2006
10523/02 Coorplan-Jenni GmbH and Hascic, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 11/12/2006
62539/00 Jurisic and Collegium Mehrerau, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 11/12/2006
2881/04 Prischl, judgment of 26/04/2007, final on 26/07/2007
17912/05 Bösch, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007
7401/04 Hofbauer No. 2, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/08/2007
2293/03 Wieser, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 22/05/2007
45983/99 Kaplan, judgment of 18/01/2007, final on 18/04/2007
12643/02 Moser, judgment of 21/09/2006, final on 21/12/2006
36812/97+ Sylvester, judgment of 24/04/03, final on 24/07/03
- Cases concerning freedom of expression
46389/99 Albert-Engelmann-Gesellschaft mbH, judgment of 19/01/2006, final on 19/04/2006
26606/04 Falter Zeitschriften GmbH, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 22/05/2007
30547/03 Ferihumer, judgment of 01/02/2007, final on 01/05/2007
60899/00 Kobenter and Standard Verlags GmbH, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
9605/03 Krone Verlag GmbH and Co KG No.5, judgment of 14/11/2008, final on 14/02/2009
5266/03 Nikowitz and Verlagsgruppe News GesmbH, judgment of 22/02/2007, final on 22/05/2007
35841/02 Österreichischer Rundfunk, judgment of 07/12/2006, final on 07/03/2007
13071/03 Standard Verlags GmbH, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
19710/02 Standard Verlags GmbH and Krawagna-Pfeifer, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
76918/01 Verlagsgruppe News GmbH, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2006
10520/02 Verlagsgruppe News GmbH No.2, judgment of 14/12/2006, final on 14/03/2006
58547/00 Wirtschafts-Trend Zeitschriften-Verlags GmbH No. 2, judgment of 27/10/2005, final on 27/01/2006
66298/01+ Wirtschafts-Trend Zeitschriften-Verlags GmbH No. 3, judgment of 13/12/2005, final on 13/03/2006
- Case of length of proceedings before disciplinary authorities and court
513/05 Schmidt, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
- 33 cases against Belgium
17849/91 S.A. Pressos Compania Naviera and others, judgment of 20/11/95, Interim Resolution DH(99)724
47650/99 Silvester’s Horeca Service, judgment of 04/03/2004, final on 04/06/2004
33400/96 Ernst and others, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03
51564/99 Čonka, judgment of 05/02/02, final on 05/05/02, Interim Resolution ResDH(2006)25
37370/97 Stratégies and Communications and Dumoulin, judgment of 15/07/02, final on 15/10/02
26103/95 Van Geyseghem, judgment of 21/01/99 – Grand Chamber
34989/97 Goedhart, judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01
36449/97+ Stroek L. and C., judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01
51338/99 Pronk, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004
46848/99 Stift, judgment of 24/02/2005, final on 24/05/2005
- Cases of length of civil proceedings
49794/99 Oval S.P.R.L., judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
50615/99 Boca, judgment of 15/12/02, final on 15/02/03
51083/99 Bouzalmad, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004
50855/99 Dautel, judgment of 30/01/2003, final on 30/04/2003
49797/99 De Plaen, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
49522/99 Dooms and others, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
52303/99 GB-Unic No. 1, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004
52304/99 GB-Unic No. 2, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004
52229/99 Gillet, judgment of 24/04/03, final on 24/04/03
50624/99 Gökce and others, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03
50566/99 Kenes, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
49546/99 Lefebvre, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
50857/99 Lenaerts, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004
49518/99 Nelissenne, judgment of 23/10/03, final on 23/01/04
50853/99 Olbregts, judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04
49332/99 Oren and Shoshan, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
50172/99 Randaxhe, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
49495/99 S.A. Sitram, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03
50859/99 Willekens, judgment of 24/04/03, final on 24/07/03
52231/99 Roobaert, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004
52230/99 Rouard, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004
- Case of length of a pre-trial investigation and of lack of an effective remedy
27072/05 Garsoux and Massenet, judgment of 13/05/2008, final on 13/08/2008
- Case concerning the unfairness of certain criminal proceedings (no individual examination of the existence of aggravating circumstances)
12949/05 Delespesse, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
- 1 case against Bosnia and Herzegovina
27966/06 Šobota-Gajić, judgment of 06/11/2007, final on 06/02/2008
- 9 cases against Bulgaria
43578/98 I.D., judgment of 28/04/2005, final on 28/07/2005
42346/98 G.B., judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004
40653/98 Iorgov, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 07/07/2004
62544/00 Vasilev Petar, judgment of 21/12/2006, final on 21/03/2007
57855/00 Ganchev, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
54172/00 Atanasov, judgment of 10/01/2008, final on 10/04/2008
51796/99 Spasov, judgment of 16/11/2006, final on 16/02/2007
53746/00 Ivanov Ivan, judgment of 10/01/2008 – Friendly settlement
58925/00 Totchev, judgment of 30/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
- 9 cases against Croatia
71615/01 Mežnarić No. 1, judgment of 15/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005
503/05 Kovač, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007
32457/05 Gashi, judgment of 13/12/2007, final on 13/03/2008 and of 09/10/2008, final on 09/01/2009
34499/06 Perić, judgment of 27/03/2008, final on 27/06/2008
- Cases of length of civil proceedings
29182/03 Kozlica, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
18421/05 Lesnina d.d., judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 31/03/2008
17117/06 Nikolac, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
9204/04 Nogolica No. 3, judgment of 07/12/2006, final on 07/03/2007
32668/02 Uljar and others, judgment of 08/03/2007, final on 08/06/2007
- 4 cases against Cyprus
44730/98 Serghides and Christoforou, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03 and of 10/06/2003, final on 24/09/2003
21906/04 Kafkaris, judgment of 12/02/2008 – Grand Chamber
23890/02 Phinikaridou, judgment of 20/12/2007, final on 20/03/2008
28025/03 Kolona, judgment of 27/09/2007, final on 27/12/2007 and of 02/10/2008 - Friendly settlement
- 17 cases against the Czech Republic
75615/01 Štefanec, judgment of 18/07/2006, final on 18/10/2006
33071/96 Malhous, judgment of 12/07/01 - Grand Chamber
1414/03 Mareš, judgment of 26/10/2006, final on 26/01/2007
64935/01 Chmelíř, judgment of 07/07/2005, final on 12/10/2005
5935/02 Heglas, judgment of 01/03/2007, final on 09/07/2007
48548/99 Zich and others, judgments of 18/07/2006, final on 18/10/2006 and of 21/12/2006 - Friendly settlement (Article 41)
20728/05 Vokoun, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 03/10/2008
35450/04 Melich and Beck, judgment of 24/07/2008, final on 24/10/2008
- Cases concerning the right of access to the Constitutional Court
4401/03 Geco, a.s., judgment of 21/09/2006, final on 21/12/2006
55179/00 Glaser, judgment of 14/02/2008, final on 14/05/2008
- Cases concerning the right of access to the Constitutional Court due to its excessively formalistic interpretation of the admissibility rules
10254/03 Drahorád and Drahorádová, judgment of 20/03/2008, final on 20/06/2008
17999/03 Mourek, judgment of 03/04/2008, final on 03/07/2008
31806/02 Hoření, judgment of 06/03/2008, final on 29/09/2008
18806/02 Ješina, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007
- Cases concerning the right of access to the Constitutional Court due to its excessively formalistic interpretation of the admissibility rules
40593/05 Regálová, judgment of 03/07/2008, final on 03/10/2008
27088/05 Rechtová, judgment of 26/06/2008, final on 26/09/2008
- Case concerning the right of access to the Constitutional Court due to its excessively formalistic interpretation of the admissibility rules
24021/03 Faltejsek, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 15/08/2008
- 4 cases against Denmark
52792/99 Vasileva, judgment of 25/09/03, final on 25/12/03
56811/00 Amrollahi, judgment of 11/07/02, final on 11/10/02
25907/02 Topp, judgment of 29/11/2005 - Friendly settlement
5989/03 Iversen, judgment of 28/09/2006, final on 28/12/2006
- 4 cases against Estonia
11423/03 Pello, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 10/12/2007
2192/03 Harkmann, judgment of 11/07/2006, final on 11/10/2006
14659/04+ Dorozhko and Pozharskiy, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
38241/04 Bergmann, judgment of 29/05/2008, final on 29/08/2008
- 14 cases against Finland
46602/99 A.H., judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/8/2007
41673/98 Bruncrona, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005 and of 25/04/2006, final on 25/07/2006
14151/02 W., judgment of 24/04/2007, final on 24/07/2007
18358/02 Muttilainen, judgment of 22/05/2007, final on 22/08/2007
70216/01 Laaksonnen, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
45830/99 Nuutinen Juha, judgment of 24/04/2007, final on 24/07/2007
20511/03 I., judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
2872/02 K.U., judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 02/03/2009
40199/02 Kallio, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
32993/02 Lehtinen Hannu, judgment of 22/07/2008, final on 22/10/2008
18620/03 Juppala, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 02/03/2009
53678/00 Karhuvaara and Iltalehti, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005
56767/00 Selistö, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005
- Case concerning the unfairness of insurance proceedings due to impossibility of commenting on medical opinions included in the case file
28301/03 S.H., judgment of 29/07/2008, final on 29/10/2008
- 91 cases against France
17997/02 Le Stum, judgment of 04/10/2007, final on 04/01/2008
73947/01 Zervudacki, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 27/10/2006
23054/03 S.U., judgment of 10/10/2006, final on 10/01/2007
348/03 Ong, judgment of 14/11/2006, final on 14/02/2007
11810/03 Maurice, judgment of 06/10/2005 and of 21/06/2006 - Friendly settlement - Grand Chamber
7217/05 E.T., judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 03/01/2007
24846/94 Zielinski and Pradal and Gonzalez and others, judgment of 28/10/99 - Grand Chamber
59584/00 Rivas, judgment of 01/04/2004, final on 01/07/2004
25444/94 Pelissier and Sassi, judgment of 25/03/99
67263/01 Mouisel, judgment of 14/11/02, final on 21/05/03
31677/96 Watson John, Interim Resolution DH(2000)20
65436/01 Henaf, judgment of 27/11/03, final on 27/02/04
71846/01 Rachdad, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 13/02/04
46044/99 Lallement, judgment of 11/04/02, final on 11/07/02 and of 12/06/03, final on 12/09/03
64927/01 Palau-Martinez, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04
40892/98 Koua Poirrez, judgment of 30/09/03, final on 30/12/03
68255/01+ Crochard and 6 others, judgment of 03/02/2004, final on 14/06/2004
66224/01 Gosselin, judgment of 13/09/2005, final on 13/12/2005
25971/94 Proma di Franco Gianotti, Interim Resolution DH(99)566
59480/00 Harizi, judgment of 29/03/2005, final on 29/06/2005
53946/00 Vaney, judgment of 30/11/2004, final on 28/02/2005
41522/98 Gaultier, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006
70160/01 Aon Conseil and Courtage S.A. and others, judgment of 25/01/2007, final on 25/04/2007
73893/01 Besseau, judgment of 07/03/2006, final on 07/06/2006
58148/00 Editions Plon, judgment of 18/05/2004, final on 18/08/2004
57516/00 Société de Gestion du Port de Campoloro et société fermière de Campoloro, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 06/12/2006
12316/04 Asnar, judgment of 18/10/2007, final on 18/01/2008
5356/04 Mazelié, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 23/10/2006
7508/02 L.L., judgment of 10/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
65411/01 Sacilor-Lormines, judgment of 09/11/2006, final on 09/02/2007
12332/03 Castelot, judgment of 24/04/2008 – Friendly settlement
68673/01 Mathieu, judgment of 27/10/2005, final on 27/01/2006
1914/02 Dupuis and others, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007
38287/02 Van Glabeke, judgment of 07/03/2006, final on 07/06/2006
75699/01 Vaturi, judgment of 13/04/2006, final on 13/07/2006
17902/02 Zentar, judgment of 13/04/2006, final on 13/07/2006
62236/00 Guilloury, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 22/09/2006
75833/01 Schemkamper, judgment of 18/10/2005, final on 18/01/2006
38208/03+ Seris, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 10/08/2007
21324/02 Plasse-Bauer, judgment of 28/02/2006, final on 28/05/2006
50278/99 Aoulmi, judgment of 17/01/2006, final on 17/04/2006
52206/99 Mokrani, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03
59423/00 SARL Aborcas, judgment of 30/05/2006, final on 30/08/2006
34043/02 Mattei, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
73529/01 Miraux, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 12/02/2007
16022/02 Roux, judgment of 25/04/2006, final on 25/07/2006
19421/04 Faure, judgment of 15/01/2009, final on 15/04/2009
70456/01 Sayoud, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
49580/99 Santoni, judgment of 29/07/2003, final on 29/10/2003, revised on 01/06/2004, final on 01/09/2004
77773/01 Flandin, judgment of 28/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
59842/00 Vetter, judgment of 31/05/2005, final on 31/08/2005
71611/01 Wisse, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006
61104/00 Quillevere, judgment of 27/10/2005 - Friendly settlement
- Cases concerning freedom of expression
54968/00 Paturel, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006
71343/01 Brasilier, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006
35916/04 Chalabi, judgment of 18/09/2008, final on 18/12/2008
22567/03 Desjardin, judgment of 22/11/2007, final on 22/02/2008
64016/00 Giniewski, judgment of 31/01/2006, final on 01/05/2006
- Cases concerning the Government Commissioner's presence at the deliberations of the trial bench in proceedings before administrative courts
13324/04 Association Avenir d’Alet, judgment of 14/02/2008, final on 06/04/2009
5107/04 Djaoui, judgment of 04/10/2007, final on 04/01/2008
7091/04 Pieri, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007
18130/05 Bochet, judgment of 10/04/2008, final on 29/09/2008
77240/01 CED Viandes and others, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 27/10/2006
- Case concerning the right of access to the Court of cassation
44404/02 Cour, judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 03/01/2007
- Cases concerning the equality of arms (failure to disclose the report of the conseiller rapporteur to the applicants who were not represented by counsel)
42122/04 A.X.A., judgment of 24/07/2008, final on 24/10/2008
44562/04 Fonfrede, judgment of 16/10/2008, final on 16/01/2009
36109/03 Leroy, judgment of 02/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
- Cases concerning the equality of arms (failure to disclose the report of the conseiller rapporteur to the applicants who were represented by counsel)
12876/04 S.C. Plélo-Cadiou, judgment of 22/11/2007, final on 02/06/2008
19/05 Laudette, judgment of 11/06/2009, final on 11/09/2009
53892/00 Lilly France, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 14/01/04
77655/01 Relais du Min S.ar.l., judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006
3211/05 Vuillemin, judgment of 19/09/2006, final on 19/12/2006
- Cases concerning the unfairness and the length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before financial courts
58675/00 Martinie, judgment of 12/04/2006 - Grand Chamber
53929/00 Richard-Dubarry, judgment of 01/06/2004, final on 01/09/2004
49699/99+ Siffre, Ecoffet and Bernardini, judgment of 12/12/2006, final on 12/03/2007, rectified on 27/03/2007
- 2 cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before military pensions tribunals of incapacity
46096/99 Mocie, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03
76977/01 Desserprit, judgment of 28/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
- Cases of length of civil proceedings
53118/99 Boiseau, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02
53425/99 Dumas, judgment of 23/09/03, final on 24/03/04
35589/97 Kanoun, judgment of 03/10/00, final on 03/01/01
41943/98 L.L., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02
41476/98 Laine, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02
33424/96 Nouhaud and others, judgment of 09/07/02, final on 09/10/02
- Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations or the determination of criminal charges before administrative courts
44451/98 A.A.U., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01
37876/02 Clément, judgment of 06/06/2006, final on 06/09/2006
32157/06 Gunes, judgment of 20/11/2008, final on 20/02/2009
- Case of length of criminal proceedings
56651/00 Destrehem, judgment of 18/05/2004, final on 18/08/2004
- Cases of length of criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages
42272/98 Potier, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006
52621/99 Schwarkmann, judgment of 08/02/2005, final on 08/05/2005
- Case of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before labour courts
27314/02 Vallar, judgment of 04/10/2007, final on 04/01/2008
- Case of length of detention on remand
21148/02 Garriguenc, judgment of 10/07/2008, final on 10/10/2008
- 20 cases against Germany
8722/02 Becker, judgment of 14/12/2006 - Friendly settlement
59008/00 Siebert, judgment of 23/03/2006 - Friendly settlement
65745/01 Dzelili, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
30943/96 Sahin, judgment of 08/07/03 - Grand Chamber
44672/98 Herz, judgment of 12/06/03, final on 03/12/03
31871/96 Sommerfeld, judgment of 08/07/03 - Grand Chamber
37568/97 Böhmer, judgment of 03/10/02, final on 21/05/03
35968/97 Van Kuck, judgment of 12/06/03, final on 12/09/03
11057/02 Haase, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004
57249/00 Herbolzheimer, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03
64387/01 Uhl, judgment of 10/02/2005, final on 10/05/2005
58453/00 Niedzwiecki, judgment of 17/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
59140/00 Okpisz, judgment of 25/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006, rectified on 14/11/2005
38033/02 Stork, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006
54810/00 Jalloh, judgment of 11/07/2006 - Grand Chamber
55809/00 Berger, judgment of 14/06/2007 - Friendly settlement
71440/01 Freitag, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007
- Cases of length of civil proceedings
66491/01 Grässer, judgment of 05/10/2006, final on 26/03/2007
58364/00 Lück, judgment of 15/05/2008, final on 15/08/2008 – Striking-out
27250/02 Nold, judgment of 29/06/2006, final on 11/12/2006
- 28 cases against Greece
9747/04 Gorou No. 4, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 23/05/2007
43837/02 Castren-Niniou, judgment of 09/06/2005, final on 09/09/2005
75898/01 Ioannidou-Mouzaka, judgment of 29/09/2005, final on 29/12/2005
32259/02 Iera Moni Profitou Iliou Thiras, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006
73717/01 Alija, judgment of 07/04/2005, final on 07/07/2005
75483/01 Dimitrellos, judgment of 07/04/2005, final on 07/07/2005
43622/98 Malama, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 05/09/01 and judgment of 18/04/02 (Article 41), final on 18/07/02
47020/99 Kolokithas, judgment of 07/06/01 - Friendly settlement
47760/99 Koskinas, judgment of 20/06/02, final on 20/09/02
48679/99 AEPI S.A., judgment of 11/04/02, final on 11/07/02
66294/01 Boulougouras, judgment of 27/05/2004, final on 27/08/2004
66810/01 Kliafas and others, judgment of 08/07/2004, final on 08/10/2004
16945/02 Agatianos, judgment of 04/08/2005, final on 04/11/2005
52464/99 Papadopoulos Georgios, judgment of 06/02/03, final on 21/05/03
2507/02 Kurti, judgment of 29/09/2005, final on 29/12/2005
38460/97 Platakou, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 06/09/01
67629/01 Assymomitis, judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005
39295/02 Mouzoukis, judgment of 13/04/2006, final on 13/07/2006
74989/01 Ouranio Toxo and others, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006
65545/01 Rizos and Daskas, judgment of 27/05/2004, final on 27/08/2004
33554/03 Lykourezos, judgment of 15/06/2006, final on 15/09/2006
10162/02 Eko-Elda Avee, judgment of 09/03/2006; final on 09/06/2006
7629/05 Roïdakis, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 21/09/2007
35533/04 Mamidakis, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 11/04/2007
21091/04 Papa, judgment of 06/07/2006, final on 06/10/2006
28340/02 Examiliotis No. 2, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 23/10/2006
- Case concerning right of access to criminal court (time-limit to lodge an appeal on point of law) and length of criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages
21845/03 Gorou No. 3, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 23/10/2006
- Case mainly concerning the length of criminal proceedings
14189/05 Karanakis, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007
- 10 cases against Hungary
53129/99 Imre, judgment of 02/12/03, final on 02/03/04
57967/00 Kmetty, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04
30103/02 Maglódi, judgment of 09/11/2004, final on 09/02/2005
32768/03 Csáky, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006
41463/02 Földes and Földesné Hajlik, judgment of 31/10/2006, final on 26/03/2007
47940/99 Balogh, judgment of 20/07/2004, final on 20/10/2004
25691/04 Bukta and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007, rectified on 25/09/2007
26137/04 Barta, judgment of 10/04/2007, final on 10/07/2007
9174/02 Korbely, judgment of 19/09/2008 – Grand Chamber
37509/06 Bessenyei, judgment of 21/10/2008, final on 21/01/2009
- 1 case against Iceland
60669/00 Ásmundsson Kjartan, judgment of 12/10/2004, final on 30/03/2005
- 45 cases against Italy
35972/97 Grande Oriente d'Italia di Palazzo Giustiniani, judgment of 02/08/01, final on 12/12/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2004)71
52763/99 Covezzi and Morselli, judgment of 09/05/03, final on 24/09/03
31127/96 E.P. No. 3, judgment of 06/11/99, révisé le 03/05/2001 (Article 41)
22716/93 P.G. II, Interim Resolutions DH(97)18 and ResDH(2002)58
56271/00 Sardinas Albo, judgment of 17/02/2005, final on 17/05/2005
67972/01 Somogyi, judgment of 18/05/2004, final on 10/11/2004
31227/96 Ambruosi, judgment of 19/10/00, final on 19/01/01
14025/88 Zubani, arrêts des 07/08/96 and 16/06/99
40877/98 Cordova Agostino No. 1, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03
45649/99 Cordova Agostino No. 2, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03
43269/98 Leoni, judgment of 26/10/00, final on 04/04/01
30127/96 Sciortino, judgment of 18/10/01, final on 27/03/02
43522/98 Grava, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 10/10/03
73936/01 De Jorio, judgment of 03/06/2004, final on 10/11/2004
23924/94 C.A.R. srl, Interim Resolution DH(98)154
55634/00 Cianetti, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 10/11/2004
51739/99 Nordica Leasing S.p.a., judgment of 14/10/2004, final on 14/01/2005
26426/95 S.B.F. S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(97)599
35227/97 Frascino, judgment of 11/12/03, final on 11/03/04
42191/02 R.R., judgment of 09/06/2005, final on 12/04/2006
25639/94 F.L., judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02
36681/97 Santoro, judgment of 01/07/2004, final on 01/10/2004
42644/02 Picaro, judgment of 09/06/2005, final on 30/11/2005
23053/02 Ielo, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 12/04/2006
30961/03 Sannino, judgment of 27/04/2006, final on 13/09/2006
44330/98 Principe and others, judgment of 19/12/00 - Friendly settlement
- Case concerning in absentia proceedings
12151/86 F.C.B., judgment of 28/08/91, Resolution DH(93)6 and Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)30
- Case concerning the failure to give speedy decisions concerning the lawfulness of the applicant's detention on remand
15349/06 Rizzotto, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
- Case concerning bankruptcy proceedings (Articles 8 and 13)
28466/03 Citarella, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
4910/04 La Fazia, judgment of 16/10/2007, final on 16/01/2008
11/04 Votto, judgment of 16/10/2007, final on 16/01/2008
38823/04 Di Crosta, judgment of 13/11/2007, final on 13/02/2008
26735/05 Cifra, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
33226/05 D’Apolito, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
40807/05 Fabiano, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
40824/05 Furno, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
11000/05 Massimo Maria Assunta, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
40261/05 Moroni, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
38264/05 Puzella and Cosentino, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
40664/05 Valentini, judgment of 10/03/2009, final on 10/06/2009
4733/04 Votto Renato, judgment of 23/10/2007, final on 23/01/2008
- Case concerning freedom of expression
42211/07 Riolo, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
- 3 cases concerning unfair proceedings due to retrospective legislation reducing compensation for expropriation and insufficient compensation in this respect
37637/05 Sarnelli, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
65687/01 Matteoni and others, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 01/12/2008
15581/05 Pierotti, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
- 7 cases against Latvia
57829/00 Vides Aizsardzības Klubs, judgment of 27/05/2004, final on 27/08/2004
73443/01+ Freimanis and Līdums, judgment of 09/02/2006, final on 09/05/2006
76843/01 Nazarenko, judgment of 01/02/2007, final on 01/05/2007
3992/02 Vogins, judgment of 01/02/2007, final on 01/05/2007
16657/03 A/s Diena and Ozoliņš, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007
65022/01 Zaicevs, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007
- Case concerning the length of detention on remand
14755/03 Ž., judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 24/04/2008
- 21 cases against Lithuania
53254/99 Karalevičius, judgment of 07/04/2005, final on 07/07/2005
41510/98 Jasiūnienė, judgment of 06/03/03, final on 06/06/03
66004/01+ Vaivada, judgment of 16/11/2006, final on 26/03/2007
30165/02 Jurevičius, judgment of 14/11/2006, final on 14/02/2007
4902/02 Čiapas, judgment of 16/11/2006, final on 16/02/2007
5457/03 Jucys, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 08/04/2008
55480/00+ Sidabras and Džiautas, judgment of 27/07/2004, final on 27/10/2004
70665/01 Rainys and Gasparavičius, judgment of 07/04/2005, final on 07/07/2005
37259/04 Švenčionienė, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
14414/03 Jucius and Juciuvienė, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
10425/03 Gulijev, judgment of 16/12/2008, final on 16/03/2009
72596/01 Balsytė-Lideikienė, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 04/02/2009
36919/02 Armonienė, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
23373/03 Biriuk, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
871/02 Savenkovas, judgment of 18/11/2008, final on 18/02/2009
70659/01+ Juozaitienė and Bikulčius, judgment of 24/04/2008, final on 24/07/2008
- Case concerning the violation of the right to a fair hearing on account on criminal conviction following active incitement by state agents
10071/04 Malininas, judgment of 01/07/2008, final on 01/10/2008
- Case concerning the violation of the right to a fair hearing on account on criminal conviction for corruption following active incitement by state agents
74420/01 Ramanauskas, judgment of 05/02/2008 – Grand Chamber
- Cases of length of criminal proceedings
37415/02 Simonavičius, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006
418/04 Gečas, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007
302/05 Norkūnas, judgment of 20/01/2009, final on 20/04/2009
- 6 cases against Luxembourg
51773/99 Schaal, judgment of 18/02/03, final on 18/05/03
13130/02 Dattel and others, judgment of 04/08/2005, final on 04/11/2005
38432/97 Thoma, judgment of 29/03/01, final on 29/06/01
44978/98 Berlin, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03
51772/99 Roemen and autre, judgment of 25/02/03, final on 25/05/03
15048/03 Mathony, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
- 6 cases against Moldova
32268/02 Malahov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007
36455/02 Gurov, judgment of 11/07/2006, final on 11/10/2006
45701/99 Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia and others, judgment of 13/12/01, final on 27/03/02 - Interim Resolution ResDH(2006)12
952/03 Biserica Adevărat Ortodoxă din Moldova and others, judgment of 27/02/2007, final on 29/05/2007
- Cases concerning the quashing of final judgments
74154/01 Braga, judgment of 14/11/2006, final on 14/02/2007
30303/03 Nistas Gmbh, judgment of 12/12/2006, final on 12/03/2007
- 22 cases against the Netherlands
10807/04 Veraart, judgment of 30/11/2006, final on 28/02/2007
48086/99 Beumer, judgment of 29/07/03, final on 29/10/03
51392/99 Göçer, judgment of 03/10/02, final on 21/05/03
25149/03 Van Houten, judgment of 29/09/2005, final on 29/12/2005 - Striking-out
37328/97 A.B., judgment of 29/01/02, final on 29/04/02
34549/97 Meulendijks, judgment of 14/05/02, final on 14/08/02
26668/95 Visser, judgment of 14/02/02
35731/97 Venema, judgment of 17/12/02, final on 17/03/03
44760/98 Del Latte, judgment of 09/11/2004, final on 09/02/2005
45582/99 Lebbink, judgment of 01/06/2004, final on 01/09/2004
50435/99 Rodriguez Da Silva and Hoogkamer, judgment of 31/01/2006, final on 03/07/2006
2345/02 Said, judgment of 05/07/2005, final on 05/10/2005
5379/02 Nakach, judgment of 30/06/2005, final on 30/09/2005
62015/00 Schenkel, judgment of 27/10/2005, final on 27/01/2006
46300/99 Marpa Zeeland B.V. and Metal Welding B.V., judgment of 09/11/2004, final on 09/02/2005
54789/00 Bocos-Cuesta, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
50252/99 Sezen, judgment of 31/01/2006, final on 03/07/2006
25525/03 El Majjaoui & Stichting Touba Mosquee, judgment of 20/12/2007 - Striking-out
1948/04 Salah Sheekh, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 23/05/2007
38258/03 Van Vondel, judgment of 25/10/2007, final on 25/01/2008
52391/99 Ramsahai and others, judgment of 15//05/2007 - Grand Chamber
60665/00 Tuquabo-Tekle and others, judgment of 01/12/2005, final on 01/03/2006
- 2 cases against Norway
30287/96 Hammern, judgment of 11/02/03, final on 11/05/03
12148/03 Sanchez Cardenas, judgment of 04/10/2007, final on 04/01/2008
- 42 cases against Poland
39199/98 Podbielski and PPU Polpure, judgment of 26/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005
48542/99 Zawadka, judgment of 23/06/2005, final on12/10/2005
26229/95 Gawęda, judgment of 14/03/02
45214/99 Sildedzis, judgment of 24/05/2005, final on 24/08/2005
39598/98 Hulewicz, judgment of 23/02/2006, final on 23/05/2006
34090/96 W.B., judgment of 10/01/2006, final on 10/04/2006
28249/95 Kreuz, judgment of 19/06/01
26624/95 Worwa, judgment of 27/11/2003, final on 14/06/2004
34091/96 M.B., judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004
26760/95 Werner, judgment of 15/11/01
29692/96+ R.D., judgment of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02
29537/95+ Radaj, judgment of 28/11/02, final on 28/02/03
35489/97 Sałapa, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03
38670/97 Dewicka, judgment of 04/04/00, final on 04/07/00
24244/94 Migoń, judgment of 25/06/02, final on 25/09/02
26761/95 Płoski, judgment of 12/11/02, final on 12/02/03
68880/01 Schirmer, judgment of 21/09/2004, final on 21/12/2004
30865/96 Jasiński, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006
33866/96 Bogulak, judgment of 13/06/2006, final on 13/09/2006
73547/01 Jedamski and Jedamska, judgment of 26/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005
71731/01 Kniat, judgment of 26/07/2005, final on 26/10/2005
48140/99 Teltronic-Catv, judgment of 10/01/2006, final on 10/04/2006
38064/97 Turczanik, judgment of 05/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005
28358/95 Baranowski, judgment of 28/03/00
39510/98 A.S., judgment of 20/06/2006, final on 23/10/2006
41187/02 Szwagrun-Baurycza, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007
49913/99 Zielonka, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006
38797/03 Ambruszkiewicz, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 23/10/2006
43425/98 Skałka, judgment of 27/05/03, final on 27/08/03, rectified on 16/09/03
43797/98 Malisiewicz-Gąsior, judgment of 06/04/2006, final on 06/07/2006
63131/00 Gębura, judgment of 06/03/2007, final on 06/06/2007
54723/00 Brudnicka and others, judgment of 03/03/2005, final on 03/06/2005
42049/98 Związek Nauczycielstwa Polskiego, judgment of 21/10/2004, final on 02/02/2005
37522/02 Zmarzlak, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 15/04/2008
39742/05 Baranowski Piotr, judgment of 02/10/2007, final on 02/01/2008
- Cases concerning freedom of expression
18235/02 Dąbrowski, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
51744/99 Kwiecień, judgment of 09/01/2007, final on 09/04/2007
- Case concerning the lack of access to court on account of excessive court fees
73002/01 Kijewska, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
- Case concerning restrictions on the right of access to a court due to refusal to exempt the applicants from substantial court fees
38399/03 Polejowski, judgment of 04/03/2008, final on 04/06/2008
- Cases of length of civil proceedings
45288/99 Ciągadlak, judgment of 01/07/03, final on 01/10/03
71891/01 Hałka and others, judgment of 02/07/02, final on 02/10/02
31382/96 Kurzac, judgment of 22/02/01, final on 22/05/01
- 11 cases against Portugal
69338/01 Calheiros Lopes and others, judgment of 07/06/2005, final on 07/09/2005
29813/96+ Almeida Garret, Mascarenhas Falcão and others, judgment of 11/01/00 and judgment of 10/04/01
15777/89 Matos and Silva and 2 others, judgment of 16/09/96
53468/99 Mora Do Vale and others, judgment of 29/07/2004, final on 29/10/2004 and of 18/04/2006, final on 18/07/2006
61009/00 Geraldes Barba, judgment of 04/11/2004, final on 04/02/2005
38830/97 Czekalla, judgment of 10/10/02, final on 10/01/03
29288/02 Roseiro Bento, judgment of 18/04/2006, final on 18/07/2006
9388/02 Cruz da Silva Coelho, judgment of 13/12/2005, Friendly settlement
75088/01 Urbino Rodrigues, judgment of 29/11/2005, final on 01/03/2006
25053/05 Ferreira Alves No.3, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 21/09/2007
7623/04 Antunes and Pires, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 21/09/2007
- 37 cases against Romania
41134/98 Glod, judgment of 16/09/03, final on 16/12/03
42930/98 Crişan, judgment of 27/05/03, final on 27/08/03
38565/97 Cotleţ, judgment of 03/06/03, final on 03/09/03
58472/00 Dima, judgment of 16/11/2006, final on 26/03/2007
53037/99 Ionescu Virgil, judgment of 28/06/2005, final on 28/09/2005
57808/00 Albina, judgment of 28/04/2005, final on 28/07/2005
19997/02 Boldea, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
28871/95 Constantinescu, judgment of 27/06/00
53897/00 Dănilă, judgment of 08/03/2007, final on 08/06/2007
41250/02 Mircea, judgment of 29/03/2007, final on 29/06/2007
28114/95 Dalban, judgment of 28/09/99 - Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution ResDH(2005)2
33348/96 Cumpănă and Mazăre, judgment of 17/12/2004 - Grand Chamber
46572/99 Sabou and Pîrcălab, judgment of 28/09/2004, final on 28/12/2004
77364/01 Ilişescu and Chiforec, judgment of 01/12/2005, final on 01/03/2006
- Cases concerning the absence of an oral hearing on appeal in criminal proceedings
30699/02 Marin, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
42512/02 Mihaiu, judgment of 4/11/2008, final on 4/02/2009
- Cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions relating to property ownership
33627/96 Bărăgan, judgment of 01/10/02, rectified on 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03
12050/02 Bartos, judgment of 20/07/2006, final on 20/10/2006
42872/02 Cornif, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 11/04/2007
30502/03 Puşcaş, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 11/01/2008
28104/03 Raicu, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 19/01/2006
19982/04 Savu, judgment of 04/11/2008, final on 04/02/2009
32927/96 Segal, judgment of 17/12/02, final on 17/03/03 and of 27/07/2004, final on 27/10/2004
24466/03 Urbanovici, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 23/12/2008
49781/99 Florică, judgment of 25/01/2005 - Friendly settlement
- Cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions
35077/02 Licu, judgment of 04/03/2008, final on 04/06/2008
1526/02+ Igna and Igna (Valea), judgment of 14/02/2008, final on 14/05/2008
37442/03 SC Parmalat Spa and SC Parmalat Romania SA, judgment of 21/02/2008, final on 21/05/2008
15872/03 SC Editura Orizonturi SRL, judgment of 13/05/2008, final on 13/08/2008
20366/04 Sfrijan, judgment of 22/11/2007, final on 22/02/2008
38840/03 Rada, judgment of 08/11/2007, final on 08/02/2008
- Case concerning the annulment of final court decisions concerning tax exemptions
26511/04 Pop Valer, judgment of 13/12/2007, final on 13/03/2008
- Case concerning the lack of access to a court to claim restitution of a nationalised building
65402/01 Radu Cornelia Eufrosina, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007
- Cases concerning the violation of the right of access to a court due to excessive court fees
30200/03 Larco and others, judgment of 11/10/2007, final on 31/03/2008
38151/05 Rusen, judgment of 08/01/2009, final on 08/04/2009
- Case concerning the failure by a domestic court to address the applicant’s submissions and arguments when imposing a criminal fine in defamation proceedings
34434/02 Folea, judgment of 14/10/2008, final on 14/01/2009
- Case concerning the failure by domestic courts to address the applicants’ submissions and arguments when imposing the payment of moral damages
21468/03 Rache and Ozon, judgment of 31/03/2009, final on 30/06/2009
- 6 cases against the Russian Federation
74826/01 Shofman, judgment of 24/11/2005, final on 24/02/2006
68443/01 Baklanov, judgment of 09/06/2005, final on 30/11/2005
58254/00 Frizen, judgment of 24/03/2005, final on 30/11/2005
58255/00 Prokopovich, judgment of 18/11/2004, final on 18/02/2005
30138/02 Nurmagomedov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 07/09/2007
73043/01 Arshinchikova, judgment of 29/03/2007, final on 29/06/2007
- 27 cases against the Slovak Republic
49418/99 Hrico, judgment of 20/07/2004, final on 20/10/2004
47227/99 Baková, judgment of 12/11/02, final on 12/02/03
24530/94 Vodeničarov, judgment of 21/12/00
29032/95 Feldek, judgment of 12/07/01, final on 12/10/01
32686/96 Marônek, judgment of 19/04/01, final on 19/07/01
42472/98 Tkáčik, judgment of 14/10/03, final on 24/03/04
39753/98 König, judgment of 20/01/04, final on 20/04/04
32106/96 Komanický, judgment of 04/06/02, final on 04/09/02
41784/98 A.B., judgment of 04/03/03, final on 04/06/03
39359/98 Pavletić, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 10/11/2004
53371/99 Čanády, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 30/03/2005
50213/99 Tám, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 10/11/2004
69146/01 Babylonová, judgment of 20/06/2006, final on 20/09/2006
57678/00 Bíro, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006
54797/00 H.F., judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006
65575/01 Hornáček, judgment of 06/12/05, final on 06/03/06
64001/00 Mikulová, judgment of 06/12/05, final on 06/03/06
69208/01 Šmál, judgment of 07/11/2006, final on 07/02/2007
17684/02 Rosival and others, judgment of 23/09/2008 – Friendly settlement
54334/00 Lexa, judgment of 23/09/2008, final on 23/12/2008
57239/00 Kanala, judgment of 10/07/2007, final on 30/01/2008 and of 14/10/2008, final on 06/04/2009
48666/99 Kučera, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007
14893/02 Haris, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007
- Case concerning freedom of expression
72208/01 Klein, judgment of 31/10/2006, final on 31/01/2007
- Cases of length of criminal proceedings
74827/01 Pavlík, judgment of 30/01/2007, final on 30/04/2007
43377/98 Žiačik, judgment of 07/01/03, final on 07/04/03
5868/02 Z., judgment of 13/05/2008, final on 13/08/2008
- 3 cases against Slovenia
28400/95 Majarič, judgment of 08/02/00
- Cases of length of certain proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations mainly before administrative courts and authorities
14852/03 Gluhar, judgment of 21/12/2006, final on 21/03/2007
47825/99 Krisper, judgment of 23/03/2006, final on 23/06/2006
- 3 cases against Spain
58438/00 Martínez Sala and others, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005
69966/01 Dacosta Silva, judgment of 02/11/2006, final on 02/02/2007
66990/01 Soto Sanchez, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04
- 6 cases against Sweden
47473/99 Hellborg, judgment of 28/02/2006, final on 28/05/2006
53507/99 Swedish transport workers union, judgment of 18/07/2006, final on 18/10/2006 - Striking-out
35179/97 Allard, judgment of 24/06/03, final on 24/09/03
13284/04 Bader and others, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006
44298/02 Synnelius and Edsbergs Taxi AB, judgment of 30/06/2009 - Friendly settlement
- Case of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before the administrative courts
6301/05 The Estate of Nitschke, judgment of 27/09/2007, final on 27/12/2007
- 12 cases against Switzerland
43874/98 Linnekogel, judgment of 01/03/2005, final on 01/06/2005
27798/95 Amann, judgment of 16/02/00 - Grand Chamber
33499/96 Ziegler, judgment of 21/02/02, final on 21/05/02
31827/96 J.B., judgment of 03/05/01, final on 03/08/01
55894/00 Fuchser, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006
53146/99 Hurter, judgment of 15/12/2005, final on 20/02/2006
77551/01 Dammann, judgment of 25/04/2006, final on 25/07/2006
55705/00 McHugo, judgment of 21/09/2006, final on 21/12/2006
41773/98 Scavuzzo-Hager and others, judgment of 07/02/2006, final on 07/05/2006
61697/00 Meloni, judgment of 10/04/2008, final on 10/07/2008
35865/04 Foglia, judgment of 13/12/2007, final on 13/03/2008
58757/00 Jäggi, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006
- 3 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
41195/02 Nikolov, judgment of 20/12/2007, final on 20/03/2008
- Cases of length of proceedings before administrative bodies and courts
13898/02 Dumanovski, judgment of 08/12/2005, final on 03/07/2006
66907/01 Docevski, judgment of 01/03/2007, final on 01/06/2007
- 113 cases against Turkey
68514/01 Yılmaz and Kılıç, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
34503/97 Demir and Baykara, judgment of 12/11/2008 – Grand Chamber
15394/02 Ilıcak, judgment of 05/04/2007, final on 24/09/2007, rectified on 14/12/2007
24245/03 D. and others, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 23/10/2006
61353/00 Tunceli Kültür ve Dayanışma Derneği, judgment of 10/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
50959/99 Odabaşı and Koçak, judgment of 21/02/2006, final on 03/07/2006
46257/99 İzmir Savaş Karşıtları Derneği and others, judgment of 02/03/2006, final on 02/06/2006
42572/98 İmret, judgment of 10/01/2006, final on 10/04/2006
40035/98 Jabari, judgment of 11/07/00, final on 11/10/00
25144/94 Sadak Selim and others, judgment of 11/06/02, final on 06/11/02
32580/96 Koç Ahmet, judgment of 22/06/2004, final on 22/09/2004
18954/91 Zana, judgment of 25/11/97
13062/03 Kuzu, judgment of 17/01/2006, final on 17/04/2006
74405/01 Tütüncü and others, judgment of 18/10/2005, final on 18/01/2006
75569/01 Çetinkaya, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006
51290/99 Demokratik Kitle Partisi and Elçi, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007
71907/01 Kavakçı, judgment of 05/04/2007, final on 05/07/2007
8691/02 Sılay, judgment of 05/04/2007, final on 05/07/2007
51358/99 Paşa and Erkan Erol, judgment of 12/12/06, final on 23/05/07
50147/99+ Yedikule Surp Pırgiç Ermeni Hastanesi Vakfı, judgment of 26/06/2007 – Friendly settlement
24632/02 Ünsal, judgment of 20/02/2007, final on 20/05/2007
36370/02 Piroğlu and Karakaya, judgment of 18/03/2008, final on 18/06/2008
38187/97 Adalı, judgment of 31/03/2005, final on 12/10/2005
47297/99 Bülbül, judgment of 22/05/2007, final on 22/08/2007
- Case concerning the failure to protect the right to life during military service and/or the lack of an effective investigation in this respect
48913/99 Yürekli, judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 17/10/2008
- Cases concerning freedom of expression
40287/98 Alınak, judgment of 29/03/2005, final on 29/06/2005
63739/00 Aydın Abdullah No. 2, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006
50692/99 Aydın Tatlav, judgment of 02/05/2006, final on 02/08/2006
68234/01 Başkaya Fikret, judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 03/01/2007
71355/01 Deniz, judgment of 27/06/06, final on 27/09/06
66400/01 Tapkan and others, judgment of 20/09/2007, final on 20/12/2007
77650/01 Taş Erdal, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
58459/00+ Yeşilgöz and Firik, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006
- Case concerning dissolution of political parties
28602/95 Tüm Haber Sen and Çınar, judgment of 21/02/2006, final on 21/05/2006
- Case concerning the right to free election
26733/02 Sobacı, judgment of 29/11/2007, final on 29/02/2008
- Cases concerning the independence and impartiality of state security courts
41316/98 Atça and others, judgment of 06/02/03, final on 06/05/03
59659/00 Özdemir Tekin, judgment of 06/02/03, final on 06/05/03
- Cases concerning the unfairness of criminal proceedings on account of the lack of oral hearing
75836/01 Arslan Adem, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007
29765/02+ Barışık and Alp, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
34506/03 Bolluk, judgment of 02/10/2007, final on 02/01/2008
28888/02 Dağlı, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
27225/02 Erseven and others, judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 24/04/2008, rectified on 26/06/2008
6291/02 Gençer Yusuf and others, judgment of 21/12/2006, final on 21/03/2007
74341/01 Karahnoğlu Mehmet, judgment of 03/10/2006, final on 12/02/2007
11424/03 Karakaya, judgment of 24/01/2008, final on 24/04/2008
40885/02 Kaya Günseli, judgment of 07/10/2008, final on 7/1/2009
1383/02 Kaya Mevlüt, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
36594/04 Köseoğlu, judgment of 10/06/2008, final on 10/09/2008
29782/02 Önen Evrenos, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
19497/02 Orhan Erkan, judgment of 01/03/2007, final on 01/06/2007
39856/02 Oyman, judgment of 20/02/2007, final on 09/07/2007
27158/02 Sümer, judgment of 06/02/2007, final on 06/05/2007
38414/02 Taner, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
74242/01 Tanyar and Küçükergin, judgment of 05/12/2006, final on 05/03/2007
11529/02 Turan Hüseyin, judgment of 04/03/2008, final on 04/06/2008
45/04 Uğurlu, judgment of 17/06/2008, final on 17/09/2008
6281/02 Varsak, judgment of 15/02/2007, final on 15/05/2007
21502/04 Yalvaç, judgment of 10/06/2008, final on 10/09/2008
16741/04 Yılmaz Nurhan No. 2, judgment of 08/04/2008, final on 08/07/2008
21164/03 Yılmaz Nurhan, judgment of 11/12/2007, final on 11/03/2008
- Cases mainly concerning the lack of an oral hearing and the failure to communicate the public prosecutor’s opinion before the Court of Cassation and / or the lack of oral hearing in compensation proceedings
502/03 Apaydın, judgment of 12/02/2008, final on 12/05/2008
67136/01 Arslan Abdülkerim, judgment of 20/09/2007, final on 31/03/2008
42208/02+ Ayçoban and others, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006
4236/03 Balaban, judgment of 24/06/2008, final on 24/09/2008
21843/02 Demirci, judgment of 03/06/2008, final on 03/09/2008
10365/03 Demirel Hünkar, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
19646/03 Deniz Faruk, judgment of 12/02/2008, final on 12/05/2008
32456/96 Dindar, judgment of 20/12/2005, final on 20/03/2006
4119/02 Doğan Halis No. 3, judgment of 10/10/2006, final on 10/01/2007
75946/01 Doğan Halis, judgment of 07/02/2006, final on 07/05/2006
36590/97 Göç Mehmet, judgment of 11/07/02 – Grand Chamber
9323/03 Göktaş Ali, judgment of 12/02/2008, final on 12/05/2008
66446/01 Göktas, judgment of 29/11/2007, final on 29/02/2008
77109/01 Hocaoğulları, judgment of 07/03/2006, final on 07/06/2006
62226/00 Işik Mehmet Fehmi, judgment of 21/02/2006, final on 21/05/2006
70084/01+ Kabasakal and Atar, judgment of 19/09/2006, final on 19/12/2006
19462/04 Karakoç Şahin, judgment of 29/04/2008, final on 29/07/2008
9007/03 Kaya Öner, judgment of 10/04/2007, final on 10/07/2007
6247/03 Kaymaz, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 26/09/2007
17174/03 Keş, judgment of 02/12/2008, final on 02/03/2009
25949/03+ Kılıç and Korkut, judgment of 12/02/2008, final on 12/05/2008
1375/03 Kızıl and others, judgment of 08/04/2008, final on 08/07/2008
23720/02+ Koçak and others, judgment of 21/12/2006, final on 21/03/2007
77432/01 Kömürcü, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 22/09/2006
38282/02 Maçin No. 2, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007
9709/03 Marti, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007
7404/03 Ölmez Cemal, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
19578/02 Özata Zahide Songül, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 15/02/2006
9149/03 Özmen and others, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
37562/02 Sağir, judgment of 19/10/2006, final on 19/01/2007
28137/02 Şahin Çağdaş, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006, rectified on 21/08/2006
16593/03+ Söğüt, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 31/08/2007
29848/02 Taş Erdal No. 5, judgment of 20/09/2007, final on 20/12/2007
13021/02 Taş Erdal No.2, judgment of 20/09/2007, final on 20/12/2007
16139/03 Tekelioğlu, judgment of 27/05/2008, final on 27/08/2008
4124/02 Tosun, judgment of 28/02/2006, final on 28/05/2006
21085/02 Turğay, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 12/07/2007
15071/03 Uçma, judgment of 04/03/2008, final on 04/06/2008
12458/03 Ünlü Suat, judgment of 15/01/2008, final on 07/07/2008
8628/03 Yalçın, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 03/08/2007
9043/03 Yayan, judgment of 27/11/2007, final on 27/02/2008
14802/03 Yeniay, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 26/09/2007
42086/02 Yurtsever Mesut, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007
31385/02 Zûlfi Tan Mehmet, judgment of 04/12/2007, final on 04/03/2008
- Case of length of detention on remand of minors
21768/02 Selçuk Vehbi, judgment of 10/01/2006, final on 10/04/2006
- Case concerning detention in custody
7860/02 Eren Mehmet Sıddık and others, judgment of 31/03/2009, final on 30/06/2009, rectified on 24/11/2009
- Cases of length of criminal proceedings in particular before martial law courts
74507/01 Aslan Mahmut, judgment of 02/10/2007, final on 02/01/2008
583/03 Demirören, judgment of 02/06/2009, final on 02/09/2009
- Case concerning the lack of effective investigation on the circumstances surrounding deaths occurring during military service
34813/02 Aydın Ömer, judgment of 25/11/2008, final on 25/02/2009
- Case concerning delays by the administration in paying compensation for unlawful detention and the applicable rate of default interes
51965/99 Yakışır, judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 30/12/2008
- Cases concerning delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest
473/03 Gür and Yıldız, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
3820/03 Tınarlıoğlu, judgment of 31/03/2009, final on 30/06/2009
- Case of length of criminal proceedings before state security courts
34740/03 Bozlak and others, judgment of 13/01/2009, final on 13/04/2009
- 10 cases against Ukraine
61406/00 Gurepka, judgment of 06/09/2005, final on 06/12/2005
13156/02 Ponomarenko, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 14/09/2007
15123/03 Volovik, judgment of 06/12/2007, final on 31/03/2008, rectified on 03/03/2008
- 7 cases concerning the quashing of the final judgments through the supervisory review procedure (protest)
61333/00 Tregubenko, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 30/03/2005
62608/00 Agrotehservis, judgment of 05/07/2005, final on 30/11/2005
74104/01 Ivanova, judgment of 13/09/2005, final on 13/12/2005
27640/02 Maznyak, judgment of 31/01/2008, final on 30/04/2008
77317/01 Poltorachenko, judgment of 18/01/2005, final on 18/04/2005, rectified on 26/01/2005
6965/02 Savinskiy, judgment of 28/02/2006, final on 28/05/2006
53500/99 Zherdin, judgment of 21/02/2006, final on 21/05/2006
- 104 cases against the United Kingdom
1271/05 Gault, judgment of 20/11/2007, final on 20/02/2008
13229/03 Saadi, judgment of 29/01/2008 – Grand Chamber
28212/95 Benjamin and Wilson, judgment of 26/09/02, final on 26/12/02
27229/95 Keenan, judgment of 03/04/01
36256/97 Thompson, judgment of 15/06/2004, final on 15/09/2004
41534/98 Bell, judgment of 16/01/2007, final on 16/04/2007
57067/00 Grieves, judgment of 16/12/03 - Grand Chamber
34155/96 G.W., judgment of 15/06/2004, final on 15/09/2004
35574/97 Le Petit, judgment of 15/06/2004, final on 15/09/2004
60860/00 Tsfayo, judgment of 14/11/2006, final on 14/02/2007, rectified on 10/07/2007
14858/03 C., judgment of 10/05/2007 - Friendly settlement
56745/00 Black, judgment of 16/01/2007, final on 16/04/2007
68890/01 Blake, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 26/12/2006
68416/01 Steel and Morris, judgment of 15/02/2005, final on 15/05/2005
12350/04 Wainwright, judgment of 26/09/2006, final on 26/12/2006
36536/02 B. and L., judgment of 13/09/2005, final on 13/12/2005
25594/94 Hashman and Harrup, judgment of 25/11/99 - Grand Chamber
Interim Resolution ResDH(2005)59
42317/98 Hooper, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005
30034/04 Elahi, judgment of 20/06/2006, final on 20/09/2006
49771/99 Stephen Jordan No. 2, judgment of 10/12/02, final on 10/03/03
29392/95 Z. and others, judgment of 10/05/01 - Grand Chamber
38719/97 D.P. and J.C, judgment of 10/10/02, final on 10/01/03
33218/96 E. and others, judgment of 26/11/02, final on 10/01/03
32570/03 Grant, judgment of 23/05/2006, final on 23/08/2006
59512/00 Blackstock, judgment of 21/06/2005, final on 21/09/2005
53741/00 Crowther, judgment of 01/02/2005, final on 06/07/2005
61827/00 Glass, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004
22520/93 Johnson Stanley, judgment of 24/10/97
517/02 Kolanis, judgment of 21/06/2005, final on 21/09/2005
33394/96 Price, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 10/10/01
60958/00 S.C., judgment of 15/06/2004, final on 10/11/2004
23414/02 Wood Clayton, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005
45825/99+ Miller, Morrisson and Gillespie, judgment of 26/10/2004, final on 26/01/2005
39846/98 Brennan, judgment of 16/10/01, final on 16/01/02
48015/99 Easterbrook, judgment of 12/06/03, final on 12/09/03
39393/98 M.G., judgment of 24/09/02, final on 24/12/02
36533/97 Atlan A. and T., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01
45276/99 Hilal, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01
28901/95 Rowe and Davis, judgment of 16/02/00
35718/97 Condron, judgment of 02/05/00, final on 02/08/00
33274/96 Foxley, judgment of 20/06/00, final on 20/09/00
39360/98 S.B.C., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01
32340/96 Curley, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00
37471/97 Faulkner William, judgment of 04/06/02, final on 04/09/02
44652/98 Beckles, judgment of 08/10/02, final on 08/01/03
35765/97 A.D.T., judgment of 31/07/00, final on 31/10/00
48539/99 Allan, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03
38784/97 Morris, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02
37555/97 O'Hara, judgment of 16/10/01, final on 16/01/02
53236/99 Waite, judgment of 10/12/02, final on 10/03/03
56547/00 P., C., and S., judgment of 16/07/02, final on 16/10/02
40787/98 Hirst, judgment of 24/07/01, final on 24/10/01
57836/00 Mellors, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03
21413/02 Kansal, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 10/11/2004
39665/98+ Ezeh and Connors, judgment of 09/10/03 - Grand Chamber
25680/94 I., judgment of 11/07/02 - Grand Chamber
28957/95 Goodwin Christine, judgment of 11/07/02 - Grand Chamber
44647/98 Peck, judgment of 28/01/03, final on 28/04/03
47441/99 Wood Mark, judgment of 15/03/2005 - Friendly settlement
35605/97 Kingsley, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber
40029/02 Wingrave, judgment of 29/11/2005 - Friendly settlement
50272/99 Hutchison Reid, judgment of 20/02/03, final on 20/05/03
60148/00 Singh and others, judgment of 08/06/2006 - Friendly settlement
47676/99+ Beet and others, judgment of 01/03/2005, final on 06/07/2005
29798/96+ Lloyd and others, judgment of 01/03/2005, final on 06/07/2005
30308/96 Faulkner Ian, judgment of 30/11/99 - Friendly settlement
8866/04 Hussain, judgment of 07/03/2006, final on 07/06/2006
46387/99+ Whitfield and others, judgment of 12/04/2005, final on 12/07/2005
60682/00 Young, judgment of 16/01/2007, final on 16/04/2007
62617/00 Copland, judgment of 03/04/2007, final on 03/07/2007
39482/98 Dowsett, judgment of 24/06/03, final on 24/09/03
39647/98+ Edwards and Lewis, judgment of 27/10/2004 - Grand Chamber
30668/96 Wilson and the National Union of Journalists, Palmer, Wyeth and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport workers, Doolan and others, judgment of 02/07/02, final on 02/10/02
55434/00 Boyle, judgment of 08/01/2008, final on 08/04/2008
23496/94 Quinn, Interim Resolution DH(98)214
22384/93 Murray Kevin, Interim Resolution DH(98)156
28135/95 Magee, judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00
18731/91 Murray John, judgment of 08/02/96, Interim Resolution DH(2000)26
36408/97 Averill, judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00
Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)85
25904/07 N.A., judgment of 17/07/2008, final on 06/08/2008
42341/04 Bhandari, judgment of 02/10/2007, final on 31/03/2008
44362/04 Dickson, judgment of 04/12/2007 – Grand Chamber
11002/05 Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen (aslef), judgment of 27/02/2007, final on 27/05/2007
38000/05 R.K. and A.K., judgment of 30/09/2008, final on 30/12/2008
10578/05+ Hunt and Miller, judgment of 23/06/2009 – Friendly settlement
- Cases concerning the lack of proper review of the lawfulness of the applicants' continued detention
46295/99 Stafford, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber
19365/02 Hill, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004
75362/01 Von Bülow, judgment of 07/10/03, final on 07/01/04
67385/01 Wynne No. 2, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04
- Case concerning the lack of independence and impartiality of a court-martial
40426/98 Martin, judgment of 24/10/2006, final on 24/01/2007
- Case of length of civil proceedings
74976/01 Eastaway, judgment of 20/07/2004, final on 20/10/2004
- Cases of length of criminal proceedings
515/02 Henworth, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 02/02/2005
13881/02 King, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005
14399/02 Massey, judgment of 16/11/2004, final on 16/02/2005, rectified on 29/04/2005
- Cases concerning interference in private life due to covert police surveillance
47114/99 Taylor-Sabori, judgment of 22/10/02, final on 22/01/03
1303/02 Lewis, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04
- Cases concerning discrimination between widows and widowers on grounds of gender regarding social security benefits
27961/02 Booth, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
42711/02 Mitchard, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
28045/02 Murray Robert, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
74961/01 Nelson, judgment of 01/04/2008, final on 01/07/2008
28071/02 Shireby, judgment of 09/12/2008, final on 09/03/2009
42709/02 Turner, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
25379/02 Twizell, judgment of 20/05/2008, final on 20/08/2008
28095/02 Twomey, judgment of 03/02/2009, final on 03/05/2009
[1] This application was lodged against Italy and Albania but the European Court found no violation in respect of Italy.
[2] The European Court found no violation in respect of Serbia.
[3] Inclusion of cases in this Section does not exclude the possibility that general measures may be examined at subsequent meetings.
[4] The Secretariat proposes to postpone this case to the 1086th meeting (June 2010)