|
MINISTERS’ DEPUTIES |
Notes on the Agenda |
CM/Notes/1569/H46-45 |
16 September 2026 |
|
1569th meeting,15-16 September 2026 (DH) Human rights
H46-45 Koval and Others group (Application No. 22429/05), Denysyuk and Others group (Application No. 22790/19) and Reznik (Application No. 31175/14) v. Ukraine Supervision of the execution of the European Court’s judgments Reference documents |
|
Application |
Case |
Judgment of |
Final on |
Indicator for the classification |
|
KOVAL AND OTHERS GROUP |
||||
|
22429/05 |
KOVAL AND OTHERS |
15/11/2012 |
15/02/2013 |
Complex problem |
|
4322/06 |
ZOSYMOV |
07/07/2016 |
07/10/2016 |
|
|
38262/10 |
SVIRGUNETS |
30/04/2020 |
30/04/2020 |
|
|
20/12/2022 |
20/12/2022 |
|||
|
47821/10 |
DUBOVYCH |
22/07/2021 |
22/07/2021 |
|
|
9166/14 |
GRATION TREYD, TOV |
22/02/2024 |
22/02/2024 |
|
|
55765/12 |
TREYD 2008, TOV |
15/04/2021 |
15/04/2021 |
|
|
2599/16 |
KORNIYETS AND OTHERS |
10/07/2025 |
10/10/2025 |
|
|
56181/15 |
NAYDYONOV AND VEDUTENKO |
23/10/2025 |
23/10/2025 |
|
|
42419/04 |
POGREBNYY AND OTHERS |
19/10/2023 |
19/10/2023 |
|
|
DENYSYUK AND OTHERS GROUP |
||||
|
22790/19 |
DENYSYUK AND OTHERS |
13/02/2025 |
13/05/2025 |
Complex Problem |
|
10415/16 |
MISHCHENKO |
09/10/2025 |
09/10/2025 |
|
|
26519/16 |
YAKYMCHUK |
11/09/2025 |
11/12/2025 |
|
|
36618/14 |
VYKHOR |
22/01/2026 |
22/01/2026 |
|
|
31175/14 |
REZNIK |
23/01/2025 |
23/04/2025 |
Complex Problem |
Case description
The Koval and Others group of cases[1] concerns various legislative and procedural issues relating to search, seizure and retention of property between 1999 and 2015 (violations of Article 8 and/or Article 1 of Protocol No. 1), and the lack of effective remedies in this respect (violations of Article 13).
The Reznik case concerns the lack of procedural safeguards for the protection of legal professional privilege in the context of search and seizure operation conducted in 2013, and the absence of an effective remedy in this respect (violations of Articles 8 and 13).
The Denysyuk and Others group of cases concerns various shortcomings relating to interception operations carried out or notified between 2008 and 2019, including due to the denial of access to the classified documents pertinent to such operations (violations of Article 8).
The Denysyuk and Others case also concerns the lack of safeguards for the protection of lawyer-client communications in the context of interception (violation of Article 8) and the authorities’ refusal to submit the documents requested by the Court (non-compliance with obligations under Article 38).
The Naydyonov and Vedutenko case concerns serious and flagrant deficiencies in the conduct of the criminal proceedings, instituted in 2014, concerning the fraudulent appropriation of vehicles owned by the applicants by private individuals and the disproportionate restriction on the disposal of the property designated as evidence in the criminal proceedings (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).
In addition, the Yakymchuk case concerns the irregularities in the reassignment of a criminal case to a judge who held special clearance to access secret documents (violation of Article 6).
Response to other violations found by the Court is supervised by the Committee in different groups of cases.[2]
Status of execution
At the previous examination of the Koval and Others group at its 1398th meeting (March 2021) (DH), the Committee noted with satisfaction the changes to the legislative framework introduced, notably by the 2012 Code of Criminal Procedure (CCP), governing searches, seizures, interception of communications, and establishing specific safeguards for searches on lawyers’ premises. In view of the progress achieved, the Committee closed two leading cases Volokhy (interception of correspondence) and Golovan (unlawful search conducted on a lawyer’s premises and the seizure of documents covered by lawyer-client privilege).[3] The Committee nevertheless expressed concern on the lack of effective remedies to challenge searches and interception of communications, notably for individuals without procedural standing in criminal proceedings. Since then, two new leading cases – Denysyuk and Others and Reznik – were added to the present group, both linked to the application of the legal framework introduced by the 2012 CCP.
The authorities submitted several action plans, most recently on 29 June 2026 (see DH-DD(2026)817), which are summarised as follows.
Individual measures
The just satisfaction has been paid in all cases,[4] where awarded, except for the Mishchenko case, where the applicant failed to provide his bank details.
In several cases related to unlawful searches and seizures, the interference stopped when the search ended[5] or with the return of the seized property.[6] In addition:[7]
- In Zosymov,verification is underway to establish the location of the seized property; proceedings under Article 1176 of the Civil Code could be instituted to obtain compensation for any damage.
- In Pogrebnyy and Others, the authorities reported that Mr Pogrebnyy has a right to obtain duplicates of his driving licence and diplomas, seized by the police and missing since 2011.
- In Naydyonov and Vedutenko, the principal criminal proceedings concerning unlawful appropriation of vehicles remain pending before the first-instance court while the pre-trial investigation into certain aspects of the appropriation of vehicles continues.[8]
- In Denysyuk and Others, the criminal proceedings remain pending against the applicants Denysyuk and Berezkin, the criminal proceedings against the applicant Beylin were terminated. The applicant Kulchytskyy, a lawyer representing other applicants, did not face independent criminal charges and the non-pecuniary damage sustained was addressed by the Court’s finding of a violation.
- In Mishchenko, the interference stopped when the respective covert investigative measures ended. In addition, the classified rulings authorising the covert recording of the telephone conversations were withheld from the domestic courts and subsequently destroyed on the expiry of the statutory storage period.
- In Yakymchuk, following the Court’s judgment, the proceedings against the applicant, which the Court found to have been unfair, were reopened and remain pending.
- In Vykhor, the criminal proceedings against the applicant, which the Court found to have been excessively lengthy, remain pending.
- In Koval and Others, the investigation into the applicants’ complaints of ill-treatment was reopened following the Court’s judgment in 2012 and terminated in 2013, it was reopened again in 2026 and remains pending.
- In Korniyets and Others, the investigation into the ill-treatment allegations of the applicant Zhabo were reopened following the Court’s judgment in 2025.
- In Koval and Others, Svirgunets and Yakymchuk, where violations of Articles 5 and 6 were found, the relevant detention or criminal proceedings had ended prior to the Court’s judgments.
General measures:
The authorities reiterated a number of legislative changes introduced by the CCP and the Law on Bar and Practice of Law in 2012, which were already described in detail and analysed in the previous notes.[9]
a. Searches, seizures and retention of property (the Koval and Others group)
Law No. 2137-IX, enacted on 22 March 2022, amended the 2012 CCP by adding computer systems to the list of objects temporary seizure of which shall be carried out only if they are specifically indicated in the court order. It prohibited their temporary seizure unless certain conditions were met. In addition, the Supreme Court and lower courts have developed a practice addressing the lawfulness of searches and as to compensation for property disposed of, lost or damaged after being seized and on the return of the temporarily seized property, including personal identification documents. As regards statistical data, in 2025, out of 103 372 requests for search warrants examined by investigating judges, 89 737 requests were granted and 7 257 rejected.[10]
b. Covert audio and video monitoring and interception of telephone communications (the Denysyuk and Others group)
The 2012 Instruction on the Organisation of Covert Investigative (Operative) Measures (CIOMs) and the Use of their Results in Criminal Proceedings covers the procedure of declassification of material collected. Notably, once CIOMs are completed, the prosecutor may submit a request to declassify collected material to an expert commission of an authority that classified it, which takes the decision on the declassification. The authorities provided judicial practice related to the declassification of the material and admissibility of evidence obtained as a result of CIOMs. According to the statistics, in 2025, investigative judges approved 144 146 requests for CIOMs out of 158 642 requests examined;[11] prosecutors authorised 11 257 CIOMs. Declassification of the material collected was requested by prosecutors in 46 750 cases.[12]
c. Lawyers’ procedural guarantees (the Reznik and Denysyuk and Others cases)
The Rule of Law Roadmap, approved by the Cabinet of Ministers in May 2025, envisages the improvement of the regulatory framework on the legal profession and its alignment with the European standards. On 9 March 2026, Ukraine signed the Council of Europe Convention for the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer which establishes legal safeguards to ensure the effective functioning of the profession. Also, the Committee for the Protection of Lawyers’ Rights of the Ukrainian National Bar Association (NBA Committee) is monitoring administrative and judicial practices concerning privileged information. In 2025 the Bar Association received 636 reports about search and detention of lawyers; among these 60 reports were carried out without notifying the relevant Bar Councils.[13]
d. Replacement of a judge without a special security clearance (the Yakymchukcase)
A new version of the Regulation on the Automated Court Document Management System, approved by the Council of Judges on 11 November 2024 (the Regulation), governs the repeated automated allocation of cases to judges. In 2025, 35 criminal offences under Article 376-1 of the Criminal Code (unlawful interference with the operation of automated systems) were recorded.[14]
e. Observance of Article 38
The authorities submitted that the compliance with Article 38 will be ensured through the implementation of the general measures arising from the Denysyuk and Others case.
In addition, the authorities reported various capacity building activities for law-enforcement officers, prosecutors and judges concerning investigative measures, including CIOMs.
Analysis of the Secretariat
Individual measures
No further individual measures are required in five cases, where the violations had ended prior to the Court’s judgments and/or the just satisfaction was paid (Dubovych, Treyd 2008, TOV, Gration Treyd, TOV, Svirgunets, Pogrebnyy and Others). The Committee might wish to close the supervision in these cases, without prejudice to its evaluation of the general measures.
The individual measures were partly resolved in Zosymov and Korniyets and Others when the searches ended and, in Naydyonov and Vedutenko, where the interference with the right to dispose of vehicles stopped with the lifting of the obligation to ensure their safekeeping.
The Committee might wish to call upon the authorities to ensure swift and Convention-compliant conclusion of the pending investigations into the applicants’ ill-treatment allegations in Koval and Others and Korniyets and Others and to expedite the criminal proceedings in Naydyonov and Vedutenko.
As regards Zosymov, during the last examination the Committee already noted with regret the absence of information as to the fate of the applicant’s property.[15] The authorities should be called upon to complete the verification regarding the seized property without further delay and, if the property in question has not been returned to the applicant, to provide information on whether the applicant has claimed compensation.
No individual measures are necessary in the leading Reznik case where the seized data-storage devices were returned, and the applicant made no claims that any privileged material was extracted from them.[16]
In Denysyuk and Others, the authorities could be invited to clarify whether any further measures are possible in respect of all four applicants to remedy the violations found by the Court on account of their inability to seek redress for alleged breaches of their Article 8 rights, owing to the denial of access to the documents, including judicial decisions authorising covert investigative measures in question.
The Committee could invite the authorities to report on the outcome of the reopened domestic proceedings and clarify the fate of covert audio-recording performed by I.P.[17] in Yakymchuk, as well as to clarify the measures taken to expedite the criminal proceedings and the fate of material obtained by way of covert investigative measures in Vykhor.
General measures
a. Searches, seizures and retention of property
It is positive that Law No. 2137-IX introduced additional safeguards against unlawful or arbitrary seizure of computer systems. As regards the inability to obtain judicial review of searches, including for individuals without procedural standing in criminal proceedings, it is recalled that this shortcoming was consistently criticised by the Court[18] and already noted with concern by the Committee.[19] No legislative measures have been taken to address this lacuna, while the number of requests for search warrants appears to be growing,[20] as does the rate of granting them by investigating judges.[21] The authorities might be urged to make it possible for the person affected, including a third party, to seek judicial review of a search warrant, whether issued by a judge prior to the search or approved ex post facto.[22]
The case-law of the Supreme Court, while positive, mostly concerns the admissibility of the evidence collected as a result of searches and does not permit to analyse whether the decisions by investigative judges authorising searches (both prior and ex post facto) are properly justified. The authorities should be invited to ensure that such decisions are duly reasoned[23] and to provide judicial practice in this respect. The limited[24] examples of court decisions provided confirm the possibility to obtain compensation for property disposed of, lost or damaged and to challenge the retention of temporarily seized property before the courts. This positive trend in the judicial practice should be maintained, to further develop into a
well-established judicial practice.
b. Covert audio and video monitoring and interception of telephone communications
The Court found that the authorisation of secret surveillance measures lacked proper judicial scrutiny either due to the domestic courts’ failure to ensure the necessity and proportionality assessment[25] or the applicants’ lack of access to the classified documents.[26] The authorities clarified certain aspects of the declassification procedure and the use of the collected material as evidence. However, the statistical data on declassification do not show the proportion of decisions ordering CIOMs which remain classified and it is not clear how the balancing exercise between the competing interests at stake is conducted before such decisions are taken. Furthermore, information is needed on the measures to ensure proper reasoning of judicial decisions authorising CIOMs. These measures are also important in view of a significant number of granted requests for CIOMs by investigative judges.[27] The legislative amendments appear necessary to address the absence of the procedure for identifying and handling accidentally intercepted privileged communications between lawyers and clients and of an independent supervisory authority overseeing interception of private communications as well as the lack of an effective possibility to obtain post factum judicial review of the lawfulness of, and justification for CIOMs, as well as redress.[28] The Committee might therefore wish to invite the authorities to promptly adopt legislative amendments, institutional and practical measures addressing all lacunae and shortcomings identified in these judgments.
c. Lawyers’ procedural guarantees
The Committee might welcome the authorities’ commitment to improving the framework governing the legal profession.[29] In view of the Court’s findings, it is essential that the legal framework clarifies legitimate exceptions to the professional secrecy of a lawyer and provides for safeguards against the disclosure of privileged electronic communications to the investigation.[30]
An effective remedy should be introduced to challenge actions of law-enforcement officers in the course of search and seizures,[31] along with a mechanism allowing lawyers to verify the veracity of alleged interception of lawyer-client communications and the lawfulness of these actions[32] as well as the expeditious review by an independent authority of disputes between Bar Association representatives and law-enforcement officers as regards possible seizure of privileged documents.[33] Several examples of well-reasoned court decisions ensuring the protection of lawyer-client privilege, in particular, by limiting the scope of search warrants, were provided. At the same time, the statistics suggest that law-enforcement bodies do not always comply with the legislation in place.[34] The Committee might wish to call upon the authorities to continue providing judicial practice on the protection of lawyer-client privilege, also in the light of the abovementioned findings of the Court, and to pursue further capacity-building targeting the law-enforcement officers, prosecutors, judges and lawyers.
d. Other violations
The authorities should clarify how the provisions of the Regulation, which appears to be quite general, are applied in the specific context of the replacement of a judge without a special security clearance by a judge who holds the respective clearance. The Committee might also wish to invite the authorities to provide information on measures to address deficiencies in the investigation of fraudulent appropriation of property (Naydyonov and Vedutenko).
e. Observance of Article 38
The obligation under Article 38 of the Convention implies putting in place any such procedures as would be necessary for unhindered communication and exchange of documents with the Court, notably those which the Court specifically requests.[35] Emphasising the importance of cooperation by the governments in Convention proceedings, the Committee might wish to call on the authorities to ensure unhindered communication and exchange of documents with the Court and to make a clear commitment in this respect.
|
Financing assured: YES |
[1] An additional judgment in the case of Levchenko v. Ukraine (No. 58785/15) is due to be classified at the present 1569th meeting.
[2] Notably, Afanasyev / Kaverzin groups (ill-treatment by the police), Ignatov / Korneykova group (non-Convention-compliant detention practices), Merit / Svetlana Naumenko groups (excessive length of proceedings and the lack of effective remedies).
[3] Violations established in both cases stemmed from the 1960 Code of Criminal Procedure.
[4] In the Svirgunets case, the Court awarded the pecuniary damage given that it was impossible to return the property to the applicant.
[5] Koval and Others, Dubovych and Reznik.
[6]Treyd 2008, TOV, Gration Treyd, TOV and Reznik.
[7] For a full overview of individual measures see the memorandum H/Exec(2026)7.
[8] In their Rule 9 communications the applicants mostly expressed concern about the delays in the criminal proceedings (see
DH-DD(2026)445, DH-DD(2026)645, DH-DD(2026)646, DH-DD(2026)923 and DH-DD(2026)1004 as well as DH-DD(2026)508,
DH-DD(2026)774 and DH-DD(2026)1057 for the authorities’ replies).
[10] In 2024, out of 93 524 requests for search warrants 78 314 requests were granted and 7 239 rejected.
[11] In 2024, investigative judges approved 138 150 requests for CIOMs out of 151 416 requests examined.
[12] In 2024, prosecutors authorised 11 276 CIOMs and requested decisions on declassification of materials in 45 124 cases.
[13] In 2024, the Bar Association received 416 such reports, 39 of which were carried out without notifying Bar Councils.
[14] In 2024, 42 such criminal offences were reported.
[15] Computer equipment, data storage devices and other possessions.
[16] Reznik, §§ 26 and 76.
[17] Yakymchuk, §§ 82-85.
[18] For example, the 2016 Zosymov judgment (§§ 61-63) and the 2025 Korniyets and Others judgment (§§ 81-82).
[20] Notably, 103 372 requests in 2025 compared to 93 524 in 2024.
[21] From 83.74% in 2024 to 86.81% in 2025.
[22] Korniyets and Others, §§ 67-74 and 81; Dubovych, § 32; Zosymov, §§ 61 and 94.
[23] Korniyets and Others, § 71; Reznik, § 73.
[24] Three court decisions about return of temporarily seized property and three examples regarding compensation were provided.
[25] Vykhor, §§ 22 and 23.
[26] Denysyuk and Others, §§ 97-100.
[27] As demonstrated by statistical data, in 2025, 90.87% requests were granted.
[28] Denysyuk and Others, §§ 110-113, 132 and 135; Vykhor, § 24; Volokhy, §§ 59-61.
[29] Evidenced by the signed Convention for the Protection of the Profession of Lawyer and the inclusion to the Rule of Law Roadmap.
[30] Reznik, §§ 67-77.
[31] Specifically in the context of breaches of the lawyer-client privilege (Reznik, §§ 82-91).
[32] Denysyuk and Others, §§ 149 and 150.
[33] Reznik, § 75.
[34] Demonstrated by 60 reports about search/detention of lawyers without notifying Bar Councils in 2025 and 39 such reports in 2024.
[35] Denysyuk and Others, § 158.