Chamber of Local Authorities

35th SESSION
CPL35(2018)PV01

MINUTES

Tuesday 6 November 2018

Chamber of Local Authorities

14.00 – 17.00, Hemicycle

1.

Opening of the 35th Session by a Vice-President of the Chamber

Breda PECAN, Vice-President of the Chamber, declared the 35th Session of the Chamber of Local Authorities open at 14.12.

2.

Election of the President of the Chamber

The Vice-president informed the Chamber that the Executive Secretary of the Chamber had received the name of only one candidate for the office of President of the Chamber, that of Xavier CADORET, France (SOC) and this candidature complied with rule 14.3 of the Rules and Procedures of the Congress.

Xavier CADORET addressed the Congress.

Following the vote, Ms PECAN announced the election of Xavier CADORET as President in accordance with Rule 15.3 of the Rules of Procedure:

For: 87

Against: 3

Abstentions: 2

Xavier CADORET, President of the Chamber, took the Chair at 14.17

3.

Adoption of the draft agenda of the Chamber

The draft agenda of the Chamber, contained in Document CPL35(2018)OJ, was adopted.



4.

Election of the 7 Vice-Presidents of the Chamber

The President informed the Chamber that the Executive Secretary of the Chamber received the names of seven candidates for the seven posts of Vice-President in accordance with Rule 14.4 of the Rules of Procedure.

The candidates were, in alphabetical order:

Michalis ANGELOPOULOS, Greece (EPP/CCE)

Liisa ANSALA, Finland (ILDG)

Gaye DOGANOGLU, Turkey ( EPP/CCE)

Clemens LAMMERSKITTEN, Germany (EPP)

Cristina MORENO MORENO, Spain, (SOC)

Barbara TOCE, Italy (SOC)

John WARMISHAM, United Kingdom (SOC)

The President invited the candidates to address the Chamber.

The candidates, except Cristina MORENO MORENO, addressed the Chamber.

The President reminded members of the rules relating to the election of Vice-Presidents.

Majlinda BUFI, Albania (SOC) and Wilma DELISSEN VAN TONGERLO, Netherlands (ILDG) were appointed as tellers by drawing of lots.

The President declared the vote open and invited the members of the Chamber to cast their ballot.

5.

Statement of the outgoing President of the Chamber

Anders KNAPE, the outgoing President, presented his statement contained in Document CPL35(2018)01.

Piero FASSINO Italy(SOC) intervened.

6.

Local democracy in Lithuania

The rapporteur, Sigurdur Bjorn BLONDAL, Iceland (R, ILDG), on behalf of the Monitoring Committee, presented Document [CPL35(2018)02].

The debate was opened.

Speakers: Kateryna MARCHENKO, Ukraine (SOC); Gintautas GEGUZINSKAS, Lithuania (EPP/CCE); Tomas MARTINAITIS, Lithuania (Youth Delegate); Brigitte VAN DEN BERG, Netherlands (ILDG) and Jakob WIENEN, Netherlands (EPP/CCE).

The rapporteur, Sigurdur Bjorn BLONDAL, replied to the debate.

The Chair of the Monitoring Committee, Leendert VERBEEK, Netherlands (SOC), replied to the debate.

The debate was closed.

The Chamber proceeded to vote on the draft recommendation contained in Document CPL35(2018)02.

The draft recommendation was adopted.

The President welcomed Darius URBONAS, Vice-Minister, Ministry of the Interior, Lithuania, and invited him to address the Chamber.

Darius URBONAS made a statement to the Congress and answered oral questions from the following members: Liisa ANSALA, Finland (ILDG) and Henrik HAMMAR, Sweden (EPP/CCE).

7.

Election of the 7 vice-presidents of the Chamber (continued)

The President declared the ballot for the election of vice-presidents closed.

8.

Local democracy in Slovenia

The rapporteur, Gaye DOGANOGLU, Turkey (EPP/CCE), on behalf of the Monitoring Committee, presented Document [CPL35(2018)03].

The debate was opened.

Speakers: Bernardka KRNC, Slovenia (ILDG); Zdenek BROZ, Czech Republic (ECR); Rosaleen O'GRADY, Ireland (ILDG); and Samantha BERGA, Latvia (Youth Delegate).

The rapporteur, Gaye DOGANOGLU, replied to the debate.

The debate was closed.

The Chamber proceeded to vote on the draft recommendation contained in Document CPL35(2018)03.

The draft recommendation was adopted.

9.

Information report on the municipal elections in the Netherlands (21 March 2018)

The rapporteur, Stewart DICKSON, United Kingdom (R, ILDG), on behalf of the Monitoring Committee on the Information report on the municipal elections in Netherlands on 21 March 2017, presented Document [CPL35(2018)04].

The debate was opened.

Speakers: Rafet VERGILI, Turkey (ECR); Peter JOHN, United Kingdom (SOC); Larissa KENNEDY, United Kingdom (Youth Delegate) and Lucia KROON, Netherlands (EPP/CCE).

The rapporteur, Stewart DICKSON, replied to the debate.

The debate was closed.

10.

Result of the ballot for the election of the Vice-Presidents of the Chamber

The President informed the Chamber of the result of the ballot for the election of the seven vice-presidents.

Members voting:                    123

Blank or spoilt ballots:            7

Valid votes cast:                    116

The President declared that seven Members had duly been elected as Vice-Presidents, and listed them in the following order according to the number of votes that each had received, which determined their precedence:

-                  Barbara TOCE, Italy (SOC)

-                  Liisa ANSALA, Finland (ILDG)

-                  John WARMISHAM, United Kingdom (SOC)

-                  Michalis ANGELOPOULOS, Greece (EPP/CCE)

-                  Clemens LAMMERSKITTEN, Germany (EPP/CCE)

-                  Cristina MORENO MORENO, Spain, (SOC)

-                  Gaye DOGANOGLU, Turkey ( EPP/CCE)

The President congratulated the seven vice-presidents.


11.

Mayors under pressure

The President welcomed the following speakers and invited them to make a statement:

Jean-Yves CAMUS, Special Advisor to the Delegate General for International Relations, City of Paris, France;

Andrzej PORAWSKI, Executive Director, Association of Polish Cities, Poland; and

Nebojsa ZELENOVIĆ, Mayor of Šabac, Serbia.

The debate was opened.

Speakers: Heather MCVEY, United Kingdom (SOC); Zoran PERISIC, Serbia (PPE/CCE); Andreas GALSTER, Germany (EPP/CCE); Bartlomiej SORDYL, Germany (Youth Delegate); Gheorghe RAILEANU, Moldova (EPP/CCE); Sasa PAUNOVIC, Serbia (SOC) and Emin YERITSYAN, Armenia (EPP/CCE).

The debate was closed.

12.

Close by the President of the Chamber

The President thanked the members of the Chamber for their participation. The 36th Session of the Chamber would take place during the 36th Session of the Congress between 2 and 4 April 2019.

The President declared the 35th Session of the Chamber closed at 17.15


LISTE DE PRESENCE

Session de la chambre des pouvoirs locaux

06/11/2018 AFTERNOON / APRES-MIDI

        Mr / M. Akos Istvan ACSAY

HUNGARY / HONGRIE

        Mr / M. Michail ANGELOPOULOS

GREECE / GRÈCE

        Mrs / Mme Krasimira ANASTASOVA replacing Galina STOYANOVA

BULGARIA / BULGARIE

        Mrs / Mme Liisa ANSALA

FINLAND / FINLANDE

        Mrs / Mme Alenka ANTOSOVA

CZECH REPUBLIC / RÉPUBLIQUE TCHÈQUE

        Ms / Mlle Tatiana BADAN

REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA / REPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA

        Mr / M. Yucel BARAKAZI

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mr / M. David BARO RIBA

ANDORRA / ANDORRE

        Mr / M. Jean-Paul BASTIN

BELGIUM / BELGIQUE

        Mr / M. Oleg BEKMEMETEV

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mr / M. Vsevolod BELIKOV

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mr / M. Jean-Marie BELLIARD

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mrs / Mme Henrietta BERO

HUNGARY / HONGRIE

        Mr / M. Robert BIEDRON

POLAND / POLOGNE

                Mr / M. Alessandro BINDI

SAN MARINO / SAINT MARIN

        Mr / M. Sigurdur Bjorn BLONDAL

ICELAND / ISLANDE

        Mr / M. Zdenek BROZ

CZECH REPUBLIC / RÉPUBLIQUE TCHÈQUE

        Mrs / Mme Majlinda BUFI

ALBANIA / ALBANIE

        Mr / M. Xavier CADORET

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mrs / Mme Marta CAMPANARI-TALABER

HUNGARY / HONGRIE

        Mr / M. Pedro CEGONHO

PORTUGAL / PORTUGAL

        Mrs / Mme Yasemen CELIK

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mrs / Mme Christine CHEVALLEY

SWITZERLAND / SUISSE

        Mr / M. Constantin COJOCARI

REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA / REPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA

        Mr / M. Marc COOLS

BELGIUM / BELGIQUE

        Mr / M. John CROWE

IRELAND / IRLANDE

        Mrs / Mme Violeta CRUDU

REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA / REPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA

        Mr / M. Walery CZARNECKI

POLAND / POLOGNE

        Mrs / Mme Constance DE PELICHY

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mrs / Mme Wilma DELISSEN VAN TONGERLO

NETHERLANDS / PAYS-BAS

        Mrs / Mme Martine DIESCHBURG-NICKELS

LUXEMBOURG / LUXEMBOURG

        Mrs / Mme Nijole DIRGINCIENE

LITHUANIA / LITUANIE

        Mr / M. Nevzat DOGAN

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mrs / Mme Gaye DOGANOGLU

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mrs / Mme Veronica DONTU

ROMANIA / ROUMANIE

        Mrs / Mme Jelena DRENJANIN

SWEDEN / SUÈDE

        Mr / M. Semir EFENDIC

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA / BOSNIE-HERZÉGOVINE

        Mr / M. Emile EICHER

LUXEMBOURG / LUXEMBOURG

        Mr / M. Piero FASSINO

ITALY / ITALIE

        Mr / M. Mario FAVA

MALTA / MALTE

        Mr / M. Robert FEJSTAMER

SERBIA / SERBIE

        Mrs / Mme Maria Elisabete FERREIRA CORREIA DE MATOS

PORTUGAL / PORTUGAL

        Mr / M. Andreas GALSTER

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mr / M. Mario GAUCI

MALTA / MALTE

        Mr / M. Gintautas GEGUZINSKAS

LITHUANIA / LITUANIE

        Mrs / Mme Krasimira GERMANOVA

BULGARIA / BULGARIE

        Mrs / Mme Linda GILLHAM

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mrs / Mme Belinda GOTTARDI

ITALY / ITALIE

        Mr / M. Franz Xaver GRUBER

AUSTRIA / AUTRICHE

        Mr / M. Michel GUEGAN

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mr / M. Halldor HALLDORSSON

ICELAND / ISLANDE

        Mr / M. Henrik HAMMAR

SWEDEN / SUÈDE

        Mr / M. Ivan HANZEK

CROATIA / CROATIE

        Mr / M. José Francisco HILA VARGAS

SPAIN / ESPAGNE

        Mr / M. Beat HIRS

SWITZERLAND / SUISSE

        Mrs / Mme Marianne HOLLINGER

SWITZERLAND / SUISSE

        Mrs / Mme Christiane HORSCH

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mr / M. Basilio HORTA

PORTUGAL / PORTUGAL

        Ms / Mlle Mary Hanna HOURIGAN

IRELAND / IRLANDE

        Mr / M. Vardan HOVHANNISYAN

ARMENIA / ARMÉNIE

        Mrs / Mme Silvia HUBER

AUSTRIA / AUTRICHE

        Mr / M. Humbat HUSEYNOV

AZERBAIJAN / AZERBAÏDJAN

        Mrs / Mme Samira HUSEYNOVA

AZERBAIJAN / AZERBAÏDJAN

        Mr / M. Gyorgy ILLES

HUNGARY / HONGRIE

        Mrs / Mme Saara ILVESSALO

FINLAND / FINLANDE

        Mrs / Mme Anna Gunnhildur INGVARSDOTTIR

ICELAND / ISLANDE

        Mr / M. Krzysztof IWANIUK

POLAND / POLOGNE

        Mr / M. Peter JOHN

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mrs / Mme Antonija JOZIC

CROATIA / CROATIE

        Mrs / Mme Pascale JURDANT-PFEIFFER

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mr / M. Resat KASAP

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mr / M. Ott KASURI

ESTONIA / ESTONIE

        Mrs / Mme Nino KAVTARADZE

GEORGIA / GÉORGIE

        Mr / M. Jean-Pierre KLEIN

LUXEMBOURG / LUXEMBOURG

        Mr / M. Anders KNAPE

SWEDEN / SUÈDE

        Mrs / Mme Alena KNOBOVA

CZECH REPUBLIC / RÉPUBLIQUE TCHÈQUE

        Mrs / Mme Sabine KOBER

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mr / M. Mehmet KOCATEPE

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mr / M. Marios KOUKLIS

CYPRUS / CHYPRE

        Mrs / Mme Bernardka KRNC

SLOVENIA / SLOVÉNIE

        Mrs / Mme Lucia KROON

NETHERLANDS / PAYS-BAS

        Ms / Mlle Joanne Louise LABAN

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mr / M. Clemens LAMMERSKITTEN

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mr / M. Imanol LANDA JAUREGI

SPAIN / ESPAGNE

        Mr / M. Svein LARSEN

NORWAY / NORVÈGE

        Mr / M. Andrew LEADBETTER

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mr / M. Francis LEC

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mrs / Mme Zalina LIANOVA

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mrs / Mme Kateryna MARCHENKO

UKRAINE / UKRAINE

        Mr / M. Luc MARTENS

BELGIUM / BELGIQUE

        Mr / M. Krysztof MATYJASZCZYK

POLAND / POLOGNE

        Mr / M. Sergii MAZUR

UKRAINE / UKRAINE

        Mrs / Mme Heather MCVEY

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mr / M. Ilsur METSHIN

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mr / M. Dilyan MLAZEV

BULGARIA / BULGARIE

        Mr / M. Darko MRVALJEVIC replacing Snezana MATIJEVIC

MONTENEGRO / MONTENEGRO

        Mr / M. Stanislav MOSHAROV

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mrs / Mme Gabriele NEFF

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mrs / Mme Minja OBRADOVIC

SERBIA / SERBIE

        Mr / M. Donath OEHRI

LIECHTENSTEIN / LIECHTENSTEIN

        Mrs / Mme Rosaleen O'GRADY

IRELAND / IRLANDE

        Mrs / Mme Zehra OZYOL

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mr / M. Sasa PAUNOVIC

SERBIA / SERBIE

        Mrs / Mme Breda PECAN

SLOVENIA / SLOVÉNIE

        Mr / M. Jozsef PFEFFER

HUNGARY / HONGRIE

        Mr / M. Vladimir PREBILIC

SLOVENIA / SLOVÉNIE

        Mr / M. Volodymyr PROKOPIV

UKRAINE / UKRAINE

        Mr / M. Andreas RABL

AUSTRIA / AUTRICHE

        Mrs / Mme Nawel RAFIK-ELMRINI

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mr / M. Gheorghe RAILEANU

REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVA / REPUBLIQUE DE MOLDOVA

        Mr / M. Andris RAVINS

LATVIA / LETTONIE

        Mrs / Mme Miranda RIRA

ALBANIA / ALBANIE

        Mr / M. Carlo RIVA VERCELLOTTI

ITALY / ITALIE

        Mr / M. Harijs ROKPELNIS

LATVIA / LETTONIE

        Ms / Mlle Tamara ROMASHOVA

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mrs / Mme Nuti ROSU

ROMANIA / ROUMANIE

        Mrs / Mme Bryony RUDKIN

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mrs / Mme Monique RYO

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mr / M. Maros SAGAN

SLOVAK REPUBLIC / RÉPUBLIQUE SLOVAQUE

        Mr / M. Robert SAUNDERS

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mr / M. Dragoslav SCEKIC

MONTENEGRO / MONTENEGRO

        Mr / M. David SIMMONDS

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mr / M. Petar SMOLOVIC

MONTENEGRO / MONTENEGRO

        Mrs / Mme Irja Terttu SOKKA

FINLAND / FINLANDE

        Mr / M. Jonni Helge SOLSVIK

NORWAY / NORVÈGE

        Mr / M. Igor SOROKIN

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mrs / Mme Alexandra-Marina SOTIRIADOU

GREECE / GRÈCE

        Mrs / Mme Valentina SYROVA

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE

        Mr / M. Tamraz TAGHIYEV

AZERBAIJAN / AZERBAÏDJAN

        Mrs / Mme Amelie TARSCHYS INGRE

SWEDEN / SUÈDE

        Mr / M. Jean-Louis TESTUD

FRANCE / FRANCE

        Mrs / Mme Ruth THURNER

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mrs / Mme Barbara TOCE

ITALY / ITALIE

        Mr / M. Fabio TRAVAGLINI

ITALY / ITALIE

        Mrs / Mme Jelena TRIFUNOVIC

SERBIA / SERBIE

        Mrs / Mme Sevdia UGREKHELIDZE

GEORGIA / GÉORGIE

        Mrs / Mme Agnese UGUES

ITALY / ITALIE

        Ms / Mlle Brigitte VAN DEN BERG

NETHERLANDS / PAYS-BAS

        Mr / M. Rafet VERGILI

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mr / M. Bernd VOEHRINGER

GERMANY / ALLEMAGNE

        Mr / M. Ivan VUKADIN

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA / BOSNIE-HERZÉGOVINE

        Mr / M. John WARMISHAM

UNITED KINGDOM / ROYAUME-UNI

        Mr / M. Jakob WIENEN

NETHERLANDS / PAYS-BAS

        Mr / M. Emin YERITSYAN

ARMENIA / ARMÉNIE

        Mrs / Mme Ezgi YETKINER

TURKEY / TURQUIE

        Mr / M. Dimitar ZDRAVKOV replacing Arben MIMENOV

BULGARIA / BULGARIE

        Mr / M. Yury ZHURIN

RUSSIAN FEDERATION / FÉDÉRATION DE RUSSIE