Strasbourg, 30 January 1998 Restricted
Misc(98)2
618th MEETING OF THE MINISTERS' DEPUTIES
(Strasbourg, 6 (10am) February 1998 - DH)
FINAL DRAFT AGENDA
AND ORDER OF BUSINESS[1]
Friday 6 February 1998 to 10 am
1. General questions
1.1 Adoption of the Agenda and of the Order of Business
1.2 Preparation of the next DH meeting
(626th meeting, 7 April 1998)
(Notes No. 98/151 of 30.1.98)
1.3 State of ratification by member States of the European Convention on Human Rights and its Protocol No. 11; the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceeding of the European Court of Human Rights and the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe
(CM/Del/Dec/Act(97)610/1.3)
(Notes No. 98/150 of 30.1.98)
1.4 Modalities for correcting mistakes in the decisions on just satisfaction
(CM/Del/Dec/Act(97)610/1.5)
(Notes No. 98/152 of ...)
1.5 Exchange of views with the Secretary of the European Commission of Human Rights
(Notes No. 98/153 of ...)
o o o
|
SECTION A : ADOPTION OF RESOLUTIONS PUTTING AN END TO THE EXAMINATION OF CASES BY THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS (NO DEBATE ENVISAGED)[2] |
A1 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 32 OF THE ECHR
- 1 case against Austria
(¤)
H32-419 17588 Linsbod (F. and M.L.) (Notes No. 98/114)
- 1 case against Belgium
H32-96 21280 Charuel (Notes No. 98/135 of 23.1.98)
- 4 cases against France
H32-422 18526 J.-C. C. (Notes No. 98/117)
H32-423 21537 Mandonnet (Notes No. 98/100)
H32-424 19946 Haas (Notes No. 98/99)
H32-425 18974(+) Laidi, Ruellan and Laumont (Notes No. 98/105)
* * *
(¤) NB: This column sets out the application number of the case. When this number is followed bt the (+) sign, it means that there are several application numbers (only the first one is mentioned).
Item moved from Section D.I.1
- 1 case against France
H32-99 25202 Juchault
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Grouped Notes No. 98/51 of 19 January 1998
* * *
Item moved from Section E 1
- 1 case against Austria
H32-290 20197 Körner
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/102 of 19 January 1998
* * *
Item moved from Section F 1
- 1 case against France
H32-420 18143 A.G.
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/138 of 23 January 1998
* * *
A2 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 54, JUDGMENTS OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
- 1 case against Austria
*H54-36 Fischer, judgment of 26/04/1995 (Notes No. 98/113)
- 3 cases against the United Kingdom
H54-53 D., judgment of 02/05/1997 (Notes No. 98/118)
H54-54 Findlay, judgment of 25/02/1997 (Notes No. 98/115)
H54-57 Coyne, judgment of 24/09/1997 (Notes No. 98/116)
* * *
Item moved from Section E 2
- 1 case against the Netherlands
H54-46 De Haan, judgment of 26/08/1997
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/106 of 19 January 1998
* * *
|
SECTION B: NEW CASES |
B1 - NEW REPORTS OF THE COMMISSION
DECISION TO BE TAKEN UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF THE ECHR (ORDINARY PROCEDURE)[3]
- 1 case against Belgium
*H32-1 24906 Rosenberg (Notes No. 98/84)
- 3 cases against France
*H32-3 24263 Areno (Notes No. 98/30)
*H32-4 23321 Delbec Annick I (Notes No. 98/54)
*H32-5 26514 Delbec Annick II (Notes No. 98/55)
- 1 case against the Netherlands
*H32-6 22411 A.Ö. (Notes No. 98/57)
- 1 case against Spain
*H32-2 28652 Sala Pujolar and others (Notes No. 98/87)
- 1 case against Turkey
*H32-7 21106 Kafkasli (Notes No. 98/56)
B2 - NEW REPORTS OF THE COMMISSION CONCERNING LENGTH OF PROCEDURE CASES (ACCELERATED EXAMINATION)
DECISION TO BE TAKEN UNDER ARTICLE 32 OF THE ECHR.[4]
-2 cases against France
*H32-8 26561 Rebai and others (Notes No. 98/40)
*H32-9 24239 Tressel (Notes No. 98/45)
- 31 cases against Italy
*H32-10 32284 Buompastore )Grouped Notes on
*H32-11 32285 Donato )the Agenda and
*H32-12 32300 F.M., A.L. and C.A. )Order of Business
*H32-13 29040 Faieta )No. 98/47 for
*H32-14 32296 Filosa Francesco )these 31 cases
*H32-15 32279 G.V. II )
*H32-16 32283 Giraldi Francesco )
*H32-17 32294 Giraldi Germana )
*H32-18 32297 Giusti II )
*H32-19 32276 L.M. VII )
*H32-20 32302 M.V. )
*H32-21 32278 Marcello )
*H32-22 32298 Martino )
*H32-23 32280 Minnai )
*H32-25 32295 Pansa )
*H32-26 32288 Sapuppo )
*H32-27 32286 Scipioni, Mancini C. M., B. and D. )
*H32-28 32289 Société Générale de Sucreries )
H32-29 31637 Troncato )
*H32-471 32287 G.R. and P.M )
*H32-30 32292 E.Z. )
*H32-31 32291 Lilli )
*H32-32 32301 Mostacciuolo )
*H32-33 32277 Patrizi Mario )Grouped Notes on
*H32-35 23356 A.R. II )the Agenda and
*H32-34 32293 Prologo )Order of Business
H32-36 22873 Arconte )No. 98/47 for
*H32-37 28166 Forte II )these 31 cases
*H32-38 28666 G.N. IV )
*H32-39 28167 Moni )
*H32-40 26806 U.O. I )
- 1 case against the Netherlands
*H32-41 23229 H.H. (Notes No. 98/46)
BC: NEW CASES: DECISIONS ON THE MERITS WITH SIMULTANEOUS ADOPTION OF A DECISION ON JUST SATISFACTION[5]
(Article 32 of the ECHR)
- 1 case against France
*H32-472 27518 A.S. (Notes No. 98/79)
- 1 case against Italy
H32-24 31348 Napoli (Notes No. 98/58)
B3 - NEW JUDGMENTS OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS -
APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 54 OF THE ECHR.[6]
- 3 cases against Austria
*H54-1 Szücs, judgment of 24/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/31)
*H54-2 Telesystem Tirol Kabeltelevision, judgment of 09/06/1997 (Notes No. 98/32)
*H54-3 Werner, judgment of 24/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/33)
- 1 case against Germany
*H54-4 K-F., judgment of 27/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/34)
- 1 case against Finland
*H54-60 Raninen, judgment of 16/12/1997 (Notes No. 98/89)
- 3 cases against Greece
*H54-5 Grigoriades, judgment of 25/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/35)
*H54-6 Stamoulakatos Nicholas, judgment of 26/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/91)
*H54-59 Canea Catholic Church, judgment of 16/12/1997 (Notes No. 98/88)
- 1 case against Switzerland
*H54-61 Camenzind, judgment of 16/12/1997 (Notes No. 98/90)
- 4 cases against Turkey
*H54-7 Mentes, Turhalli M. and S., Uvat, judgment of 28/11/1997
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/36 of 19 January 1998
*H54-8 Sakik and others, judgment of 26/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/37)
*H54-9 Zana, judgment of 25/11/1997 (Notes No. 98/92)
*H54-58 Sur, judgment of 03/10/1997 (Notes No. 98/29)
|
SECTION C: DECISIONS ON JUST SATISFACTION[7] |
C1 - GROUPED NOTES ON THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS No. 98/82 of 19 January 1998 and Corrigendum of 30 January 1998:
- 2 cases against Austria
*H32-42 20223 Schottenberger
*H32-43 20864 Feingold
- 9 cases against France
*H32-46 20282 G.B.
*H32-444 22578 G.N. II
*H32-445 25024 J-J. C.
*H32-446 26915 Loyen
*H32-44 23411 Montion
*H32-45 26222 Mugler-Bentoumi
*H32-447 23264 P.S. II
*H32-448 23339 Société AZUL Résidence and R. Espanol
*H32-449 26496 Société Fruehauf France
- 1 case against Greece
*H32-47 26642 Zakowski
- 53 cases against Italy
*H32-450 31643 A., G., C. and M.B.
*H32-48 31352 A.M. L.
*H32-451 31640 A.M. A.
*H32-452 31635 Anfosso
*H32-49 29720 Arlistico
*H32-50 31347 Bordogna
*H32-453 31358 Borselli
*H32-51 21075 Bottiglieri
*H32-52 30582 C.M.R. L.C.
*H32-454 31641 C.R.A.D.C.C. S.r.l.
*H32-53 31334 Cairo
*H32-455 27959 Capezzali
*H32-54 31339 Carcassi II
*H32-55 31333 Ciliberti
*H32-56 31336 Cimenti
*H32-57 31346 Cims
*H32-58 31355 G. and I.B.
*H32-456 31645 G.F. II
*H32-59 30585 G.L.
*H32-60 31351 G.M.
*H32-61 31357 G.P. and F.C.
*H32-62 30091 Garufi
*H32-457 31646 Gasperoni
*H32-63 30590 Ghirardi
*H32-64 31354 L.L., C.S. and S.M.
*H32-65 31329 L.R. B.
*H32-458 31341 Lazzari and Scagnoli
*H32-66 31327 Lilloni
*H32-459 31647 M.L. D.R.
*H32-67 31353 M.M. II
*H32-68 31350 Manotti
*H32-69 31328 Mazziotti
*H32-70 28056 Pasquino
*H32-71 31337 Peresson
*H32-72 30592 Pezzilli
*H32-460 31642 Pierfederici
*H32-73 31345 Rocchi
*H32-74 31340 Sambati
*H32-75 30591 Sasso
*H32-76 27195 Spadoni
*H32-461 30586 Stacchiotti
*H32-77 30589 Tessadri
*H32-78 31342 V.L.
*H32-462 30216 V.N.
*H32-79 29171 Abbate
*H32-463 31622 G.O. II
*H32-464 31625 Santoro
*H32-80 29131 Cherubini
*H32-81 31343 Cimadoro
*H32-82 29123 Mascia
*H32-465 31638 Sciarra
*H32-83 24908 Fortini
*H32-466 25124+ Nativi and others
- 2 cases against the Netherlands
*H32-467 25706 Roestenburg
*H32-468 22046 H.J.B.
- 1 case against Portugal
*H32-84 27621 Morais Sarmento
- 1 case against Turkey
*H32-469 22677 Çetin
- 1 case against the United Kingdom
*H32-470 25523 Murdoch
C2 - INDIVIDUAL NOTES ON THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
- 1 case against Austria
*H32-85 16906 Lagler I (Notes No. 98/93)
- 1 case against Belgium
*H32-474 22913 N.P. (Notes No. 98/136 of 23.1.98)
- 2 cases against France
H32-86 17831 Morganti (Notes No. 98/97)
*H32-87 26726 Sass (Notes No. 98/41)
- 2 cases against Italy
*H32-88 26825 Silvan S.p.a. (Notes No. 98/94)
*H32-475 25293 V.P. II (Notes No. 98/140 of 23.1.98)
- 2 cases against Portugal
*H32-89 27291 Ribeiro Morgado (Notes No. 98/80)
*H32-90 26095 Rocha de Gouveia II (Notes No. 98/83)
- 2 cases against Turkey
*H32-91 23762 S.N.C. Molin In_aat (Notes No. 98/81)
*H32-92 19092 Yagiz (Notes No. 98/95)
|
SECTION D: CASES TO BE POSTPONED TO THE NEXT MEETING: SUPERVISION OF PAYMENT OF JUST SATISFACTION INCLUDING IF APPLICABLE DEFAULT INTEREST (NO DEBATE ENVISAGED)[8] |
D.I - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 32 OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
Grouped Notes on the Agenda and Order of Business No. 98/51
D.I.1 Supervision of payment of just satisfaction
- 3 cases against Austria
H32-93 16942 Lagler II
H32-94 18624 Lagler III
H32-95 20178 Hengl
- 14 cases against France
H32-97 27850 Damery-Vetter-Weil
H32-98 27081 Giorsetti
H32-100 22730 Segaud
H32-101 21978 Bainier and others
H32-102 19053 Hayot and Sté Caraïbe de Développement
H32-103 22331 Lestienne
H32-104 24546 Negroni
H32-105 23107 Duclos III
H32-106 18657 G., A., G. and C.J.
H32-107 23313 Erbs
H32-108 27415 Hachemi and others
H32-109 21549 Duclos II
H32-110 24736 Hayat
H32-111 25164 Morlet
- 117 cases against Italy
H32-112 27985 A.C. V
H32-113 23588 A.C. III
H32-114 29668 A.M. IV
H32-115 29158 Albertosi
H32-116 27982 Amighetti and Jolly Moto S.N.C.
H32-117 29155 Andreoletti
H32-118 30094 Ausilio
H32-270 28729 Avellani
H32-119 29129 B.A. S.
H32-120 29652 Bianchi II
H32-121 26845 Bizzotto
H32-122 29150 Bonforte
H32-123 30108 Botta II
H32-124 27979 Botti
H32-125 29139 Broccia
H32-126 29153 Carcassi
H32-127 29161 Cavadini
H32-128 29138 Ceglia
H32-129 29647 Celi
H32-130 29648 Cirino
H32-131 29669 Condoluci
H32-132 27164 Covi and Anzelini
H32-133 29127 Dall'Acqua
H32-134 27968 Dambra
H32-135 29163 Danesi
H32-136 23603 De Camillis
H32-139 24853 Di Blasio A. and L.
H32-137 29143 Di Ciccio
H32-138 25242 Di Gregorio
H32-140 29665 Donfrancesco M. and A.
H32-141 29159 Dotti
H32-142 27456 Ferraro Salvatore
H32-143 30100 Fiorentino
H32-144 29653 Foresta
H32-145 29124 Frediani
H32-146 19496 G.B. II
H32-147 29660 G.G. II
H32-148 27183 G.M. V
H32-149 29658 G.S. V
H32-150 29670 G.V. I
H32-151 29141 Giraldi I
H32-152 30092 Granatelli
H32-153 27986 Gualtieri
H32-154 29157 I.S. II
H32-155 29126 Iaconetta
H32-156 26853 Immobiliare San Teodoro s.r.l.
H32-157 29128 Li Donni
H32-158 29167 Litardi
H32-159 27865 Lunari
H32-160 27965 Maggi and Arcangeloni
H32-161 29154 Manzinali
H32-162 29656 Martelli and Straccia
H32-163 29146 Mezzatesta
H32-164 30087 Muso
H32-165 29661 Nardone Angelo
H32-166 29667 Nardone Antonio
H32-167 29646 O. S.a.s.
H32-168 29169 Patrizii
H32-169 29664 Pepiciello
H32-170 29137 Pettinelli
H32-171 29162 Piazzalunga
H32-172 13545 Provinzano
H32-173 30090 R.M.
H32-174 27983 Rizzo M. R. and G. and De Martino
H32-175 27977 Ruggeri
H32-176 30104 Salvatore I
H32-177 30105 Salvatore II
H32-178 30106 Salvatore III
H32-179 30110 Salvatore IV
H32-180 30111 Salvatore V
H32-181 30112 Salvatore VI
H32-182 29651 Spinosi
H32-183 27177 Tripodo M, C. and G. and Leonardo
H32-184 29168 V. L.S.
H32-185 29130 V.M. II
H32-186 30103 V.R.
H32-187 30101 Vaccari
H32-188 27980 Valsecchi
H32-189 19835 Villani I
H32-190 29144 Vitali I
H32-191 29164 Vivian
H32-192 29170 Cerruto
H32-193 29125 Chierici B. and E.
H32-278 27996(+) D'Amico and Altobelli
H32-279 27994(+) Manzini and Benet
H32-194 17814 Mori Puddu
H32-280 27999(+) Recinelli and Corona
H32-195 29672 Scopelliti II
H32-282 27484(+) Serino and others
H32-196 25450 Spera Michele
H32-197 29301 Vitali II
H32-198 29302 Vitali III
H32-199 30114 G.A. III
H32-200 29172 Santacatterina
H32-201 28001 Sbrolla
H32-286 27482 Tobia
H32-202 27462 Bagli and Musumeci
H32-203 29166 Maiale
H32-204 29649 Mastronunzio
H32-205 30098 Mecozzi
H32-206 27191 O.F.T.
H32-207 29152 Paolini
H32-208 17336 Rulli
H32-209 29165 Savoia II
H32-287 28746 Serena and De Filippo
H32-288 27989 Volpe
H32-289 28735 Zollo
H32-210 27987 Zuccardi Merli
H32-211 29134 Zullino
H32-212 20854 Arichetta
H32-213 20290+ De Mitri G. and A.
H32-214 22905 Figoli
H32-215 27963 Grande and others
H32-216 20730 Mazzelli
H32-217 22369+ N.B. and G.A.
H32-218 20358 Savoia I
H32-219 23566 T.-S.I.
- 1 case against Portugal
H32-220 24383 Aires III
- 1 case against the United Kingdom
H32-222 20448 A.T.
D.I.2 - Supervision of payment of default interest
- 1 case against Belgium
H32-223 19171 Escobar Londono and others
- 6 cases against France
H32-224 21244 G.H.
H32-225 19616 Lambert
H32-226 16378 Boule Michel I
H32-227 22641 J.-L. N.
H32-228 17572 A.C.
H32-229 23142 Ruin
- 5 cases against Greece
H32-230 18545 Nurioglu
H32-231 23964 Stylianaki
H32-232 19937 Stamatiades
H32-427 20728(+) P.I., P.S., Fotopoulos and Moschopoulou
H32-269 24470 Mamalis
- 36 cases against Italy
H32-233 16480 A.R.
H32-234 19752 Aloe
H32-235 19830 Calaudi
H32-236 25230 Cariola E. and M.R.
H32-237 20010 Condoluci and Napoli
H32-238 12168 Condominio via F. 141
H32-239 20332 Crupi and others
H32-240 17482 D'Aquino and Petrizzi
H32-241 24817 E.F. and M.C.P.
H32-242 23600 E.M., R.V. and A.S.S.
H32-243 26043 E.P. II
H32-244 20042 Fedele
H32-245 24315 G.L.
*H32-443 27180 G.S. IV
H32-246 18924 Giovannetti Graziani
H32-247 18664 La Ferrara and others
H32-248 24822 Majani S.p.a.
H32-249 24332 Manca
H32-250 26857 Meloni S.p.a.
H32-251 24331 Parisi
H32-252 26445 Poddighe and others
H32-253 25256 Ristoro G., A. and A.
H32-254 26401 V.R.
H32-255 16087 Vernillo
*H32-442 27169 M.Z.
H32-256 26863 Almanno
H32-257 25585 Bagnoli and Mazzone G., A. and M.
H32-258 20359 Della Sala Raffaele
H32-259 26865(+) Rubbo and others
H32-260 17043 G. and A.G. and M.C.
H32-261 24324 Sabia
H32-262 27202(+) Marino Ettore and others
H32-263 21438 Nicoletti
H32-264 18138 Giner
H32-265 20543 Lupo
H32-266 18755 P.B. III
D.II - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 54 OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
Grouped Notes on the Agenda and Order of Business No. 98/52
D.II.1 Supervision of payment of just satisfaction
- 1 case against Austria
H54-10 Radio ABC, judgment of 20/10/1997
- 2 cases against Greece
H54-11 Garyfallou A.E.B.E., judgment of 24/09/1997
H54-12 Paskhalidis and others, judgment of 19/03/1997
- 4 cases against Italy
H54-13 Abenavoli, judgment of 02/09/1997
H54-14 De Santa, judgment of 02/09/1997
H54-15 Lapalorcia, judgment of 02/09/1997
H54-16 Nicodemo, judgment of 02/09/1997
- 1 case against the United Kingdom
H54-17 Johnson, judgment of 24/10/1997
D.II.2. Supervision of payment of default interest
- 7 cases against France
H54-18 Amuur and others, judgment of 25/06/1996
H54-19 Duclos, judgment of 17/12/1996
H54-20 Remli, judgment of 23/04/1996
H54-21 Foucher, judgment of 18/03/1997
H54-22 Muller, judgment of 17/03/1997
H54-23 Mantovanelli, judgment of 18/03/1997
H54-24 Vacher, judgment of 17/12/1996
- 1 case against Greece
H54-25 Philis n° 2, judgment of 27/06/1997
- 1 case against Italy
H54-26 Torri, judgment of 01/07/1997
|
SECTION DR: CASES IN WHICH JUST SATISFACTION HAS REMAINED UNPAID FOR MORE THAN SIX MONTHS AFTER EXPIRY OF THE 3 MONTHS' TIME-LIMIT[9] |
DR1 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 32
Grouped Notes on the Agenda and Order of Business No. 98/48
- 2 cases against Greece
H32-267 23436 Sakellaropoulos
H32-268 24890 Makriyannis
- 11 cases against Italy
H32-271 25249 Cazzorla and Gigante
H32-272 20554 Ceravolo
H32-273 26012 Facciolini
H32-274 26838 Giusto
H32-275 26859 Magri
H32-276 27173 Sud Ovest S.A.S.
H32-277 27494 Corona Vincenzo
H32-281 27493 Recinelli
H32-283 15800(+) Perego and Romanet
H32-284 27172 Colombo
H32-285 27481 Criveller
DR2 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 54 OF THE EUROPEAN CONVENTION ON HUMAN RIGHTS
- 2 cases against Greece
H54-27 Katikaridis and others, judgment of 15/11/1996 (Notes No. 98/50)
H54-28 Tsomtsos and others, judgment of 15/11/1996 (Notes No. 98/49)
|
SECTION E: SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES REQUIRED BY THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS' DECISION UNDER ARTICLE 32 OR BY JUDGMENT OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS[10] |
E1 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 32 OF THE ECHR
- 1 case against Belgium
H32-291 17123 Van Wijck (Notes No. 98/103)
- 1 case against France
H32-292 14635 Union des Athées (Notes No. 98/128)
- 126 cases against Italy
H32-293 24024 L.D.C. )Grouped Notes on
H32-294 26021 A.A. II )the Agenda and
H32-295 24022 A.S., A.T. and M.S. )Order of Business
H32-296 27165 A.T. V )No. 98/101 for
H32-297 24023 A.V. )these 126 cases
H32-298 24033 Alessandrini )
H32-299 24796 Antoniotti )
H32-300 24163 Archimede )
H32-301 22944 Boccardi and Comune )
H32-302 25257 Bonaccorso )
H32-303 19838 Bonfanti I )
H32-304 19839 Bonfanti II )
H32-305 19840 Bonfanti III )Grouped Notes on
H32-306 19841 Bonfanti IV )the Agenda and
H32-307 19842 Bonfanti V )Order of Business
H32-308 19843 Bonfanti VI )No. 98/101 for
H32-309 19837 Bonfanti VII )these 126 cases
H32-310 24816 Boscaro )
H32-311 25215 Caviglia )
H32-312 29136 Celi Lelio )
H32-313 27469 Cianci G. and A. )
H32-314 22527 Cicely and others )
H32-315 24027 Crovato )
H32-316 25226 D. and P.D.R. and L.M. )
H32-317 26448 D.M. IV )
H32-318 16300 D.S. and O.P. )
H32-319 22741 De Luca Vincenzo )
H32-320 24805 De Mita )
H32-321 19559 De Santis )
H32-322 24644 Del Prete )
H32-323 24801 E.M. and A.P. )
H32-324 24036 Elettrodiffusion S.p.a. )
H32-325 27457 F.B. II )
H32-326 25264 Famas S.r.l. )
H32-327 25216 Ferrari Stefano )
H32-328 27197 Ferretti Amleto )
H32-329 24050 Foggetti and Quaini )
H32-330 16014 G. and A.P. )
H32-331 25247 G.M. IV )
H32-332 25266 G.M.N. )
H32-333 26447 G.S. III )
H32-334 25225 Gasparoli )
H32-335 23422 Gentile )
H32-336 25245 Giardinieri )
H32-337 24322 Giorgi Alberti )
H32-338 24542 Godet )
H32-339 23431 Gracci )
H32-340 21671 Granatiero Rosa and Raffaella )
H32-341 26408 Grignano )
H32-342 24782 Gubitosi )
H32-343 22974 I.S. and M.A.T. )
H32-344 26423 L.U. )
H32-345 19832 Lanzo )
H32-346 25237 Latella )
H32-347 25239 Lombardi Satriani Luigi )Grouped Notes on
H32-348 25244 Luzi )the Agenda and
H32-349 24797 M.C. III )Order of Business
H32-350 25228 M.D.M. )No. 98/101 for
H32-351 25231 M.L. II )these 126 cases
H32-352 25214 MA.RI.OR. S.a.s. )
H32-353 25263 Maggiore )
H32-354 29132 Manni )
H32-355 25250 Marolda )
H32-356 26417 Mazzone )
H32-357 24789 Meluso Angelo I )
H32-358 25218 Minotti )
H32-359 26837 O.O. )
H32-360 14140* P.P. I )
H32-361 24334 Pala )
H32-362 25219 Parodi )
H32-363 24047 Perini )
H32-364 25267 Perrone )
H32-365 25246 Petromilli )
H32-366 25248 Pezzati )
H32-367 20235 Pucchielli )
H32-368 25254 Pugliani and Cianca )
H32-369 24807 R.P. )
H32-370 19222 Rapotez )
H32-371 17049 Righetti )
H32-372 25236 Rotella and Zuccalà )
H32-373 24042 S.B. )
H32-374 26414 S.P. and S.V. )
H32-375 25107 Sacchi )
H32-376 27174 Samir )
H32-377 24780 Schiavone )
H32-378 14578 Scotti )
H32-379 27984 Sgroi )
H32-380 25235 Sorrenti Alessandro II )
H32-381 25252 Strongoli I )
H32-382 25253 Strongoli II )
H32-383 24039 T. s.r.l. )
H32-384 24040 T.M. and M.G.C. )
H32-385 24803 T.S.I. s.r.l. )
H32-386 13692 Tedesco I )
H32-387 13693 Tedesco II )
H32-388 25234 V.M. )
H32-389 24793 Valentini )
H32-390 25222 Vesentini )Grouped Notes on
H32-391 18011 Vicari )the Agenda and
H32-392 23587 Zanelli )Order of Business
H32-403 23203 Camodeca )No. 98/101 for
H32-399 15080 Magnaghi )these 126 cases
H32-393 26864 Bacci Roberto Maria )
H32-394 25576 Cavaliero s.n.c. )
H32-395 25588 D.M. II )
H32-396 14147+ Di Bonaventura )
H32-397 25580 Giorgini )
H32-398 25581 Latini )
H32-400 25589 Mentastro )
H32-401 25582 Sansoni )
H32-402 25578 Turrina and Scattolini )
H32-404 25265 Carbone )
H32-405 26415 Fusco G., F. and P. )
H32-406 26042 S.C. II )
H32-407 23147 Vaggelli-Lupi )
H32-408 26439 Cagnetta )
H32-409 23243 Di Paola )
H32-410 25220 Ferrari Giampiero )
H32-411 24826 G.B. I )
H32-412 24779 G.B.S. )
H32-413 26807 Grosso )
H32-414 24806 Iaria )
H32-415 26003 Napoli Elio )
H32-416 17292 R.d.R. )
H32-417 26045 R.M. III )
H32-418 17765 Zaffarana )
- 1 case against Portugal
*H32-441 21599 J.M.C.S. (Notes No. 98/125)
E2 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 54 OF THE ECHR
- 1 case against Austria
H54-37 Informationsverein Lentia, judgment of 24/11/1993 (Notes No. 98/137 of 23.1.98)
- 1 case against Belgium
*H54-29 Van Orshoven, judgment of 25/06/1997 (Notes No. 98/108)
- 4 cases against Italy
H54-30 Ceteroni, judgment of 15/11/1996 (Notes No. 98/42)
H54-31 Di Pede, judgment of 26/09/1996 (Notes No. 98/124)
H54-32 Calogero Diana, judgment of 15/11/1996 (Notes No. 98/43)
H54-33 Domenichini, judgment of 15/11/1996 (Notes No. 98/44)
- 1 case against Ireland
H54-34 Keegan, judgment of 26/05/1994 (Notes No. 98/141 of 23.1.98)
- 2 cases against the United Kingdom
H54-35 Saunders, judgment of 17/12/1996 (Notes No. 98/112)
H54-56 Robins G. and M., judgment of 23/09/1997 (Notes No. 98/126)
|
SECTION F[11] |
F1 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 32 OF THE ECHR
- 1 case against France
H32-421 19033 Hakkar (Notes No. 98/53)
- 1 case against Greece
H32-426 29118 Skodras (Notes No. 98/131)
- 1 case against Hungary
H32-428 21967 Sárközy
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/119 of 19 January 1998
- 13 cases against Italy
H32-429 27495 Ambiveri and Arnoldi )Grouped Notes on
H32-430 27479 Cecere Pasquale )the Agenda and
H32-431 27974 Di Bella and others )Order of Business
H32-432 22572 Giovanelli and Vicentini )No. 98/132 for
H32-433 28725 Manzi A., B. and L. )the first 11 cases
H32-434 29142 Mazzoli and 8 others )
H32-473 27463 Orlando and Fiorentino )
H32-435 29160 Pesaresi and 8 others )
H32-436 27171 Ragusi, Bordandini, Pattuelli )
and Vindimian )
H32-437 27176 Simonetti (N.S.) )
H32-438 26854 Simotti A., O. and M. )
H32-439 26009 Lombardo Sestilio (Notes No. 98/120)
H32-440 20043 Napoli and Mammoliti
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/129 of 19 January 1998
- 1 case against Turkey
H32-221 15530+ Mitap and Müftüoglu (Notes No. 98/109)
F2 - APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 54 OF THE ECHR
- 1 case against Belgium
H54-38 S.A. Pressos Compania Naviera and others, judgments of 20/11/1995 and 03/07/1997 (Notes No. 98/144 of 23.1.98)
- 2 cases against France
H54-40 Hentrich, judments of 22/09/94, 03/07/1995 and 03/07/1997 (Notes No. 98/96)
H54-41 Mehemi, judgment of 26/09/1997 (Notes No. 98/111)
- 3 cases against Greece
H54-42 Papageorgiou, judgment of 22/10/1997 (Notes No. 98/121)
H54-43 Papamichalopoulos and others, judgments of 24/06/1993 and 31/10/1995 (Notes No. 98/104)
H54-44 Valsamis, judgment of 18/12/1996 (Notes No. 98/123)
- 1 case against the Netherlands
H54-45 Van Mechelen and others, judgments of 23/04/1997 and 30/10/1997 (Notes No. 98/110)
- 1 case against Portugal
H54-47 Matos and Silva and 2 others, judgment of 16/09/1996 (Notes No. 98/127)
- 1 case against Switzerland
H54-39 R.M.D., judgment of 26/09/1997 (Notes No. 98/98)
- 5 cases against Turkey
H54-48 Akdivar, Çiçek, Aktas, Karabulut, judgment of 16/09/1996 (Notes No. 98/122)
H54-49 Aksoy, judgment of 18/12/1996 (Notes No. 98/130)
H54-50 Aydin, judgment of 25/09/1997
Addendum of 30 January 1998
to Notes No. 98/139 of 23 January 1998
H54-51 Loizidou, judgments of 23/03/1995 and 18/12/1996 (Notes No. 98/145 of 23.1.98)
H54-52 Mitap and Müftüoglu, judgment of 25/03/1996 (Notes No. 98/142 of 23.1.98)
- 1 case against the United Kingdom
H54-55 Gaskin, judgment of 07/07/1989 (Notes No. 98/143 of 23.1.98)
APPENDIX
DECISION MODEL A
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION TO BE ADOPTED COLLECTIVELY
FOR ALL THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SECTION A
IN THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
Decision
The Deputies adopted Resolutions DH (9.) .. to DH (9.) .. concerning the items set out below as they appear in Appendices .. to .. to the present volume of Decisions:
... .................
... .................
DECISION MODEL B1
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION TO BE ADOPTED SEPARATELY
FOR THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SUB-SECTION B1
IN THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
(New reports by the Commission - Ordinary procedure)
Item ...
...
... AGAINST ...
(Application No ...)
Decision to be taken under Article 32
of the European Convention on Human Rights
Decisions
The Deputies
1. having taken a vote, under Article 32, paragraph 1, of the European Convention on Human Rights, on whether there had been a violation of Article ..., paragraph ..., of the Convention, decided, by ... votes for the violation to ... against, with ... abstentions, that there had been a violation of that provision in this case;
2. requested the Commission, in application of Rule 9, paragraph 2, of the Rules for the application of Article 32 of the Convention, to complete the proposals it had already made under Article 31, paragraph 3, of the Convention concerning just satisfaction for the applicant, by indicating the exact amount which it considers should be paid to him;
3. authorised, on the terms indicated in paragraph 3.b of the Appendix to the above mentioned Rules, the communication to the applicant of the Report of the Commission in the case of ...;
4. agreed to resume consideration of this item as soon as the question of the just satisfaction is ready for a decision.
DECISION MODEL B2
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION TO BE ADOPTED SEPARATELY
FOR THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SUB-SECTION B2
IN THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
(New reports by the Commission - Accelerated examination)[12]
Item ...
...
... AGAINST ...
(Application No ...)
Decision to be taken under Article 32
of the European Convention on Human Rights
Decisions
The Deputies
1. having taken a vote, under Article 32, paragraph 1, of the European Convention on Human Rights, on whether there had been a violation of Article ..., paragraph ..., of the Convention, decided, by ... votes for the violation to ... against, with ... abstentions, that there had been a violation of that provision in this case;
2. agreed to resume consideration of this item as soon as the question of the just satisfaction is ready for decision.
DECISION MODEL BC
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION MODEL BC
CASE OF .. AGAINST ..
(Application No. ../)
Item H32-..
a. Concerning the merits of the case
Decisions
The Deputies
1. having taken a vote, under Article 32, paragraph 1, of the European Convention on human rights, on whether there had been a violation of Article .., paragraph .., of the Convention, decided, by ... votes for the violation to ... against, with ... abstentions, that there had been a violation of that provision in this case.
2. adopted the Interim Resolution DH (97) ... as it appears in Appendix ... to the present volume of Decisions;
b. Concerning the just satisfaction
Decisions
The Deputies
1. held, in accordance with Article 32, paragraph 2, of the Convention, that the Government of .. was to pay, within three months, to .., born on .. , the sum of .. lire for non-material damage and the sum of .. for costs and expenses, namely the total sum of .. and dismissed the remainder of the claim for just satisfaction;
2. invited the Government of .. to inform the Committee of Ministers of the measures taken in consequence of decision 1 above, having regard to its obligation under Article 32, paragraph 4, of the Convention to abide by it;
3. agreed that if the just satisfaction indicated under decision 1 above has not been paid at the expiry of the time-limit, the Government of .. shall pay the applicant interest on any unpaid sum, calculated on the basis of each full elapsed month of delay at the statutory rate applicable on the date of this decision, it being understood that the interest will accrue from the expiry of the time limit until full payment is placed at the disposal of the applicant;
4. decided to resume consideration of this item at the latest at the next meeting following expiry of the time limit set under decision 1 above;
5. authorised the Secretariat to inform the applicant of the decisions taken by the Committee of Ministers in the present case.
DECISION MODEL B3
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISIONS TO BE ADOPTED SEPARATELY
FOR EACH ONE OF THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SUB-SECTION B3
OF THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
(New Judgments by the Court)
Item ...
...
JUDGMENT OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
IN THE CASE OF ..... AGAINST .....
(Judgment of .. ..... 19..)
Application of Article 54
of the European Convention on Human Rights
Decision
The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their ...th meeting (DH) (1st meeting after the 3-month deadline set for the payment of the just satisfaction).
DRAFT DECISION MODEL C (GROUPED NOTES)
PROJET DE DECISION MODELE C (OBSERVATIONS GROUPEES)
CASE OF .. AGAINST ...
AFFAIRE .. CONTRE ..
(Application/Requête No. ..)
Item/Point H32-..
Decisions/décisions
The Deputies/les Délégués
1. held, in accordance with Article 32, paragraph 2, of the Convention, that the respondent State should pay, within three months, the following sums to the applicant (s)/
disent, conformément à l'article 32, paragraphe 2, de la Convention, que le Gouvernement défendeur doit verser au (x) requérant (es), dans les trois mois, les sommes suivantes:
|
Appli- cation/Re- quête |
Applicant/ Requérant date of birth/ date de naissance (Case/Affaire) |
Cur./ Dev. |
Total just satisfaction/ Satisfaction équitable totale |
Comments/ Commen- taires |
Details / détail |
||||
|
Non pecuniary damage*/ Dommage moral* |
Pecuniary damage/ Dommage matériel |
Costs and expenses /Frais et dépens |
|||||||
2. agreed that if the just satisfaction indicated under decision 1. above has not been paid at the expiry of the time-limit, the respondent Government shall pay the applicant interest on any unpaid sum, calculated on the basis of each full elapsed month of delay at the statutory rate applicable on the date of this decision, it being understood that the interest will accrue from the expiry of the time-limit until full payment is placed at the disposal of the applicant (s)/
disent qu'au cas où la satisfaction équitable indiquée dans la décision 1. ci‑dessus n'aura pas été payée à l'expiration du délai fixé, le Gouvernement défendeur devra verser au requérant (s) des intérêts sur toute somme impayée, calculés sur la base de chaque mois de retard révolu au taux légal applicable à la date de la présente décision, étant entendu que les intérêts courront à partir de l'expiration du délai jusqu'au jour de la mise à disposition du paiement complet;
3. decided to resume consideration of this case at the latest at the next meeting following expiry of the time-limit set under decision 1. above/
décident de reprendre l'examen de cette affaire au plus tard lors de leur prochaine réunion suivant l'expiration du délai fixé sous la décision 1. ci-dessus;
4. authorised the Secretariat to inform the applicant of the decisions taken by the Committee of Ministers in the present case/
autorisent le Secrétariat à informer le requérant des décisions prises par le Comité des Ministres dans la présente affaire.
DECISION MODEL C (INDIVIDUAL NOTES)
Item ...
Decisions
The Deputies
1. held, in accordance with Article 32, paragraph 2, of the Convention, that the Government of ... was to pay to Mr/Mrs/Miss (name and forename in full) ..., within three months, the sum of ... for non-material damage/for material damage/for costs and expenses, ie. the total sum of ...;
2. invited the Government of ... to inform the Committee of Ministers of the measures taken in consequence of decision 1 above, having regard to its obligation under Article 32, paragraph 4, of the Convention to abide by it;
3. agreed that if the just satisfaction indicated under decision 1. above has not been paid at the expiry of the time-limit, the Government of ... shall pay the applicant interest on any unpaid sum calculated on the basis of each full elapsed month of delay at the statutory rate applicable on the date of this decision, it being understood that the interest will accrue from the expiry of the time-limit until full payment is placed at the disposal of the applicant;
4. decided to resume consideration of this item at the latest at the next meeting following expiry of the time-limit set under decision 1 above;
5. authorised the Secretariat to inform the applicant of the decisions taken by the Committee of Ministers in the present case.
DECISION MODEL D
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION TO BE ADOPTED COLLECTIVELY
FOR ALL THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SECTION D
IN THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
Decision
The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of the items appearing on the following list at their ...th meeting (DH) (dates of the following meeting):
... ....................
... ....................
MODEL DECISION DI.2
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
Decision
The Deputies, having found that a delay had arisen in the payment of just satisfaction, which details appear below, agreed to resume consideration of this item at their ..th meeting (DH) (..) with a view to monitoring the payment of default interest.
... .... .... .........
DECISION MODEL DR
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION TO BE ADOPTED INDIVIDUALLY
FOR EACH OF THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SECTION DR
IN THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
Decisions
The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of this item at their ... meeting (DH) (dates of the following meeting).
DECISION MODEL E
...th meeting (DH) - ... 199.
DRAFT DECISION TO BE ADOPTED COLLECTIVELY
FOR ALL THE ITEMS APPEARING UNDER SECTION E
IN THE AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS
Decisions
The Deputies agreed to resume consideration of the items appearing on the following list at one of their forthcoming meetings, not later than six months hence:
... ....................
... ....................
[1] The present final draft Agenda and Order of Business takes into account changes that have taken place, to the Secretariat' knowledge, since the provisional draft Agenda and Order of Business on 19 January 1998.
* Those items marked with an asterisk were added after approval of the Draft Agenda (Appendix 2 to the volume of Decisions of the 610th meeting) in accordance with the Rules adopted by the Committee of Ministers for the application of Articles 32 and 54 of the European Convention on Human Rights and with the European Convention on Human Rights.
[2]It is proposed that all the Resolutions concerning the cases which appear in this section be adopted without debate by collective decision model A as appended, both for sub-section A1 (Article 32 of the ECHR) and for sub-section A2 (Article 54 of the ECHR).
[3] In the cases appearing under sub-section B1, the Committee of Ministers is called upon to decide whether there has been a violation or violations of the Convention and, if need be, to adopt the draft interim resolution appended to the Notes on the Agenda. It is proposed, for each of these cases, to adopt decision model B1 as appended, it being understood, however, that for grouped Notes on the Agenda, there will be a single decision per group.
[4] Among cases appearing under sub-section B2 the Committee of Ministers is called upon to decide whether there has been a violation or violations of the Convention and to adopt, if need be, the draft interim resolution appended to the Notes on the Agenda. Is is therefore proposed to adopt for each of these cases the relevant model decision as it appears attached, it being understood that for grouped Notes on the Agenda, there will be a single decision per group.
[5] As these cases require the adoption of a specific decision combining elements from the model decision B2 and C, it is proposed to deal with them into a separate section, named BC. A new model decision for this section is appended to the present draft Agenda and Order of Business.
[6] In the cases appearing in this sub-section, the Committee of Ministers is called upon to consider new judgments delivered by the European Court of Human Rights. It is proposed to adopt the decision model B3 as appended, for each of the items in this section.
[7] It is proposed to adopt the model decision C as appended for each of the items in this section.
[8] It is proposed for all the cases appearing in this section to adopt the draft collective model decision D, except for the cases appearing in sub-section DI.2 (Article 32, supervision of payment of default interest) for which the draft collective model decision DI.2 should be adopted. This section being examined in principle without any debate, it is recommended that all the information concerning the payment of just satisfaction be sent in writing to the Secretariat after the meeting.
[9] This section contains all cases for which payment of just satisfaction should have taken place at least six months ago. Each item must be considered individually and be the object of a separate decision according to the relevant model decision as appended.
[10] It is proposed to adopt a collective decision model E as it appears in the appendix, both for cases under sub-section E1 (Article 32 of the ECHR) and for cases under sub-section E2 (Article 54 of the ECHR). Each item is nevertheless considered individually.
[11] In this section are presented all the cases of which a separate examination has been requested by a Delegation and cases that, for one reason or another, cannot be included in any of the other sections. Obviously, there is no model decision for the cases appearing in this section.
[12] In these cases, the Commission will submit ex officio the complementary proposals on just satisfaction without waiting for the Committee of Ministers to make a request, in accordance with the Decision taken by the Deputies at their 484th meeting (November 1992).