Ministers' Deputies

Decisions

CM/Del/Dec(2003)827 (unclassified) 27 March 2003

Volume I – APPENDICES

————————————————

827th (DH) meeting, 11 and 12 February 2003

Appendices adopted

(Formal date of adoption: 24 February 2003)

————————————————

827th meeting (DH) – 11 and 12 February 2003

CONTENTS

APPENDICES

Pages

APPENDIX 3              827th MEETING OF THE MINISTERS' DEPUTIES

                                 (Strasbourg, 11 and 12 February 2003, DH)

                                 ANNOTATED AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS (PUBLIC)................................ 4

                                 AND

                                 827th MEETING OF THE MINISTERS' DEPUTIES

                                 (Strasbourg, 11 and 12 February 2003, DH)

                                 APPENDIX TO THE ANNOTATED AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS............. 103

APPENDIX 2              834th MEETING OF THE MINISTERS' DEPUTIES

                                 (Strasbourg, 9 and 10 April 2003, DH)

                                 PRELIMINARY LIST OF ITEMS FOR CONSIDERATION (PUBLIC).......................... 143

827th meeting (DH) – 11 and 12 February 2003

APPENDIX 3

827th METING OF THE MINISTERS’ DEPUTIES

(Strasbourg, 11 and 12 February 2003 – DH)

ANNOTATED AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS

Document made public in pursuance of the decision taken at the 749th meeting (DH) (17 April 2001) – item d.

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION.. 6

GENERAL QUESTIONS.. 12

SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS.. 13

SECTION 2 - NEW CASES.. 19

SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION.. 29

SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTION (INDIVIDUAL MEASURES,
MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS) 52

SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED.. 84

SECTION 6 - CASES AWAITING FOR THE PRESENTATION OF A DRAFT RESOLUTION.. 92

c. PREPARATION OF THE NEXT DH MEETING (834th MEETING, 9-10 April 2003) 102

Additional documents

Addendum General Questions

Addendum 1 - Final Resolutions

Addendum 4 – Cases raising special questions

Addendum Preparation of the next DH meeting (834th meeting, 9-10 April 2003)

Appendix to the Draft Annotated Agenda and Order of Business of the 827th meeting

CM/Inf(2003)4

CM/Inf(2002)47-Add 2

INTRODUCTION

At the present Human Rights meeting, the Committee of Ministers, sitting at the level of the Ministers’ Deputies, will supervise the execution of some 3151 cases in accordance with Article 46, § 2, of the Convention for the protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Supervision is carried out in accordance with the Rules for the application of this Article adopted by the Deputies on 11 January 2001[1]. The Directorate General of Human Rights (Department for the execution of the judgments of the Court) and the Secretariat of the Committee of Ministers provide advice and assistance to the Deputies in the fulfilment of their functions under the Convention. Information and communications relating to the cases should be addressed to these departments.

Below follows a short comparative survey of the meeting (the information on the nature of the cases in the different sections is described after the table):

SECTION 1 – FINAL RESOLUTIONS

In the cases appearing under this heading the Deputies are invited to adopt draft resolutions putting an end to the supervision of execution carried out pursuant to Article 46§2 of the Convention (or former Articles 32[3] and 54 for cases decided before the entry into force of Protocol N° 11).

In these cases the Court (or the Committee) has either found a violation of the Convention or struck the case out of the list on the basis of undertakings made by the parties (for example in the case of friendly settlements – see Article 39 of the Convention and Rule 44 of the Rules of Court).

In all the cases, the Deputies have provisionally found, with the assistance of the Directorate General of Human Rights, that the required execution measures have been taken. The relevant information for each case has been summarised in a draft final resolution presented in Addendum 1. To facilitate examination, the cases are grouped as follows:

Sub-section 1.1. - Leading cases

In these leading cases the measures adopted aim at preventing new violations of the Convention  (legislative or regulatory measures, changes of case-law, mere publication in those states where the Convention and the Court’s judgments are given direct effect, administrative measures or other measures) and/or at redressing adequately the individual situation of the applicant (among the measures which may be relevant mention may be made of reopening of proceedings, striking out a conviction from criminal records, granting a residence permit, etc.)

Sub-section 1.2 – Cases concerning problems already solved

This sub-section comprises cases which do not raise problems as regards the applicant’s individual situation, but which concern general problems which have already been solved in the context of similar earlier cases.

Sub-section 1.3 – Cases not involving general or individual measures

Contains cases which do not raise problems of a general or individual character. In these cases the mere dissemination of the judgment to the authorities directly concerned is considered sufficient.

Sub-section 1.4 – Friendly settlements and problems of a general character

This new sub-section groups friendly settlements relating to complaints concerning general problems already under examination by the Deputies in the context of other leading cases in which violations have been established.

No discussion of cases in Section 1 is envisaged since the examination of the different execution questions has already been carried out by the Deputies in the course of earlier meetings.

SECTION 2 – NEW CASES

Under this heading, the Deputies are called upon to conduct a first examination of the execution of the new final judgments delivered by the Court (Article 44 §§ 1 and 2 of the Convention) finding violations of the Convention. The Deputies also supervise the execution of judgments striking cases out of the Court’s list (friendly settlements, non-pursuit of the application, or a solution to the dispute) and which contain specific undertakings (Article 39 of the Convention and Article 44 of the Rules of Court).

The examination of new cases is in general resumed after the expiry of the 3-month time-limit normally imparted by the Court for the payment of the just satisfaction.

 

In those cases where all execution measures have already been taken before this first examination, a draft final resolution summarising the relevant information could be submitted for adoption. Such draft resolutions appear in Addendum 2.

Discussion is envisaged mainly for cases which raise questions of individual measures or new general measures.

Dissemination of the judgments to all the authorities involved has been requested in all these cases.

SECTION 3 – JUST SATISFACTION

In these cases the Deputies are called upon to supervise the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court and, where required, of any default interest owed.

The section also presents the last cases in which the Deputies, in accordance with former Article 32§2 of the Convention, are called upon to decide on the question of just satisfaction on the basis of proposals submitted by the former European Commission of Human Rights or by the Committee of Special Advisors set up by Resolutions DH(99)681 and (2000)138 (see also decision 692/4.4 from December 1999).

                   Sub-section 3.1 – control of payment:

3.1.a: Supervisionof the payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction as well as, where due, of default interest, in cases where the deadline for payment expired less than 6 months ago.

Delegations are invited to submit written confirmation of payment to the Directorate General of Human Rights (Service for the execution of the judgments).

 

3.1.b: Supervisionof the payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction in cases where the deadline for payment expired more than 6 months ago.

3.1.c: Examination of special payment problems (for example the disappearance of the applicant, disputes regarding the exact amount paid as a result of exchange rate problems or administrative fees).

The further examination of the cases in sub-sections 3.1 a - c depends on the information received.

Sub-section 3.2 – Decisions on just satisfaction

The Deputies may be are called upon to take a decision on just satisfaction pursuant to former Article 32. The details of the cases are found either in a table presented under this sub-section, or, if the case is complex, in Addendum 3 II.

The examination of such cases will be resumed after the expiry of the 3 months time-limit set for payment.

SECTION 4 – CASES RAISING SPECIAL QUESTIONS

(individual measures, measures not yet defined or special problems) 

The cases which appear under this heading require special attention to the extent that they either raise problems regarding the individual situation of the applicant, or concern problems in respect of which the necessary execution measures have not yet been defined, or raise other special problems (for example on account of the magnitude of the problems raised or delays in the adoption of the necessary execution measures).

 

Sub-section 4.1 – Supervision of individual measures only

This sub-section groups together cases in which the Deputies will exclusively examine the measures taken or to be taken in order to put an end to the violation found and/or remedy its consequences as far as the applicant’s individual situation is concerned – where the just satisfaction awarded by the Court has not done so.

Sub-section 4.2 - Individual measures and/or general problems

This heading presents both cases involving payment problems combined with general problems and cases in which measures have not yet been defined. For supervision of individual measures, see sub-section 4.1 above; for supervision of payment, subsection 3.1.c and for general measures, section 5 below.

Sub-section 4.3 – Special problems

This title groups together complex cases raising special problems.

Supplementary information relating to the cases under this heading may, where necessary, be found in Addendum 4.

As long as individual measures are outstanding cases are examined at each Human Rights meeting, unless the Deputies decide otherwise. Examination of other issues is decided upon on a case-by-case basis.

SECTION 5 – SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED

In these cases the Deputies are called upon to supervise the progress made in adopting measures of a general character defined at the national level and to ensure that these measures are apt to prevent new violations similar to those found by the Court. Cases are grouped together according to the nature of the main reforms envisaged.

In complex cases which require the adoption of several kinds of measures, cases are placed in the sub-section which corresponds to the main measures remaining to be adopted. A case may thus, for example, pass from sub-section 5.1 to sub-section 5.4 if the legislative changes required are rapidly adopted, whereas the implementation of the practical measures required turn out to take more time.

Sub-section 5.1 – Legislative and/or regulatory changes

In the cases in this group, the Deputies are mainly waiting for changes of legislation or of government regulations aiming at preventing new similar violations. Delegations of respondent States will thus furnish information about the content of draft legislation or regulations and on the procedure for their adoption.

Sub-section 5.2 – Changes of courts’ case-law or of administrative practice

This heading presents cases in which the Deputies are waiting for evidence (in the form of copies of judgments or decisions, statistics, etc.) of a change of the domestic courts’ case-law or of administrative practice, where such a change cannot, for one reason or another, be presumed solely on the basis of the publication or dissemination of the judgment (cf. the next sub-section).

Sub-section 5.3 – Publication / dissemination

This title encompasses in particular cases in which a change of court case-law or of administrative practice may be presumed, on the basis of evidence of the direct effect accorded to the Court’s judgments in general, as a result of simply publishing or disseminating the judgment in the case at issue, where necessary in translation into the national language. It may also concern other types of cases presenting a broader interest, such as those which imply important indications regarding the scope of the rights guaranteed by the Convention. In all these cases, the Deputies are normally waiting for details regarding the publication or dissemination carried out.

The Deputies are invited to present all relevant information in writing to the Directorate General of Human Rights (Service for the execution of the judgments of the Court).

Sub-section 5.4 – Other measures

This sub-section includes cases which primarily imply other types of general measures, for example practical measures such as the construction of prison facilities, the recruitment of judges, police training, etc.

Where necessary, supplementary information with respect to the cases in this section will be presented in Addendum 5.

Examination of these cases is normally resumed within 6 months’ time.

SECTION 6 – CASES WAITING FOR THE PRESENTATION OF A DRAFT RESOLUTION 

In these cases, the draft resolutions (prepared in collaboration with the Delegation concerned in cases raising questions of individual measures or new problems of a general character) putting and end to the examination of the case are not yet available at the time of issuing the annotated agenda and order of business.

If available in time for the meeting, drafts could be distributed separately.

Examination is in principle be resumed at the next Human Rights meeting.

GENERAL QUESTIONS

a.                Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business

Action

The Deputies are invited to adopt the present annotated agenda and order of business.

b.                State of ratification by member States of the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceedings of the European Court of Human Rights, the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe and Protocols No. 12 and No. 13 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms

Action

The Deputies are invited to provide information on the state of signature and ratification of these four texts. Tables showing the current state of signature and ratification appear in Addendum General Questions.

c.                Preparation of the next meeting (834th (9-10 April 2003)) see page 102

d.                Application of default interest in the supervision of the execution of the terms of friendly settlements

                   Addendum General Questions

Action

The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of this item, in the light of the debate held at the 819th meeting.

SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS

(NO DEBATE ENVISAGED)

(Addendum 1)

Action

The Deputies are invited to adopt the resolutions putting and end to the examination of the following cases as they appear in Addendum 1.

                   SUB-SECTION 1.1 – LEADING CASES

- 1 case against Austria

H46-1           35115          Riepan, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

- 3 cases against Germany

H46-2677     23541          Garcia Alva, judgment of 13/02/01

H46-2678     24479          Lietzow, judgment of 13/02/01

H46-2679     25116          Schöps, judgment of 13/02/01

- 3 cases against Greece

H46-3           33170          Biba, judgment of 26/09/00, final on 26/12/00

H46-4           38194          Karakasis, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-5           30175          S.A. « Avis Entreprises Hôtelières Touristiques and Industrielles Rurales »

- 1 case against Ireland

H46-6           33267          Croke, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01 - Friendly settlement

                   SUB-SECTION 1.2 – CASES CONCERNING PROBLEMS ALREADY SOLVED

- 2 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-8           29545          Devlin, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-9           35685          Mills, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

                   SUB-SECTION 1.3 – CASES NOT INVOLVING GENERAL OR INDIVIDUAL MEASURES

- 1 case against Cyprus

H46-10         50516          Georgiadis, judgment of 14/05/2002, final on 14/08/2002

- 4 cases against France

H46-11         41333          Brochu, judgment of 12/06/01, final on 12/09/01

H46-12         43713          Joly, judgment of 27/03/01, final on 27/06/01

H46-13         46693          Chapus, judgment of 24/10/00, final on 24/01/01

H46-14         42406          Vallar, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

- 1 case against Greece

H46-15         39442          Société Anonyme Sotiris and Nikos Koutras Attee, judgment of 16/11/00,

                                      final on 16/02/01

- 1 case against Italy

H46-16         29569          Buscemi, judgment of 16/09/99

- 10 cases against Portugal

H46-17         37010          Conde, judgment of 23/03/00, final on 23/06/00

H46-18         47459          Fernandes João, judgment of 18/04/2002, final on 18/07/2002

H46-19         36668          Fertiladour S.A., judgment of 18/05/00, final on 18/08/00

H46-20         42918          Nascimento, judgment of 27/09/01, final on 27/12/01

H46-21         46462          Rego Chaves Fernandes, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-2830     35593          Galinho Carvalho Matos, judgment of 23/11/99, final on 23/02/00

H46-2831     46464          Vaz Da Silva Girão, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-2832     45725          Malveiro, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 12/06/02

H46-2833     45560          Guerreiro, judgment of 31/01/02, final on 30/04/02

H46-2834     42636          Bento Da Mota, judgment of 28/06/01, final on 28/09/01

- 1 case against Switzerland

H32-22         26452          D’Amico Heidi and Salvatore

                   SUB-SECTION 1.4 – FRIENDLY SETTLEMENTS AND PROBLEMS OF A GENERAL CHARACTER

- 1 case against Austria

H46-23         32097          Biegler Bau GesmbH, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 1 case against Croatia

H46-24         53227          Majstorović, judgment of 06/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 3 cases against Greece

H46-25         53051          Livanos, judgment of 16/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-26         50529          Teka Ltd, judgment of 26/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-27         49222          Tiburzi, judgment of 25/10/01 – Friendly settlement

- 29 cases against Italy

H46-28         44968          Amato Del Re, judgment of 07/05/02, Friendly settlement

H46-29         35797          Arrivabene, judgment of 07/05/02, Friendly settlement

H46-30         35795          Ferrari Barbara, judgment of 07/05/02, Friendly settlement

H46-31         42609          Fusco Fabrizio, judgment of 07/05/02, Friendly settlement

H46-32         42444          O.L.B., judgment of 13/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-33         40037          S.B., judgment of 13/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-34         40537          T., judgment of 13/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-35         44864          V.L. and others, judgment of 07/05/02, Friendly settlement

H46-36         32671          B. and F., judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-37         32541          Celona, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-38         31605          Colucci, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-39         33967          De Filippis, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-40         31480          Guglielmi II, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-41         37509          Pané P. and A., judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-42         31525          Pezza, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-43         39716          Stoppini, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-44         38656          Tiberio, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-45         30968          Barone Mario, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-46         32645          Castello, judgment of 04/10/01- Friendly settlement

H46-47         32404          Girolami Zurla, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-48         31916          Immobiliare Anba, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-49         31922          Micucci, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-50         33831          Musiani Dagnini, judgment of 04/10/01- Friendly settlement

H46-51         31929          Pini and Bini, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-52         31927          Serlenga, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-53         32650          Sit s.r.l., judgment of 04/10/01- Friendly settlement

H46-54         32648          Tentori Montalto, judgment of 04/10/01- Friendly settlement

H46-55         37007          Pittini, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-56         36010          Venturi, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-57         58964          K.K.C., judgment of 21/12/01 – Friendly settlement

- 1 case against Poland

H46-58         31387          Kliniecki, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01 – Friendly settlement

Sub-section 1.4

- 8 cases against Portugal

H46-59         48959          Azevedo Moreira, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-60         46772          Baptista Do Rosàrio, judgment of 04/04/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-61         45648          Caldeira and Gomes Faria, judgment of 14/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-62         48960          Conceição Fernandes, judgment of 20/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-63         47584          Martos Mellado Ribeiro, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-64         52772          Pereira Palmeira and Sales Palmeira, judgment of 04/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-65         46143          Sociedade Panificadora Bombarralense Lda., judgment of 14/02/02 –

                                      Friendly settlement

H46-66         48526          Viana Montenegro Carneiro, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement

SECTION 2 - NEW CASES

Action

The Deputies are invited to procede to the first examination, under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the ECHR, of the following new judgments, delivered by the European Court of Human Rights (for further information, see the text of the judgments, http://www.echr.coe.int).

The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases after expiry of the time-limit set for payment or according to the specificity of the cases.

PAYMENT OF JUST SATISFACTION

In all the new cases in which States should pay just satisfaction as ordered by the Court or as agreed in a friendly settlement, the authorities of the respondent State are invited to provide the Secretariat, in writing, with confirmations of payment.

INDIVIDUAL AND/OR GENERAL MEASURES

As regards any other execution measures which may be called for in the light of the conclusions of the Court, the authorities of the respondent State are invited, on a preliminary basis, to provide the Secretariat, in writing, with information on the measures mentioned after each case. The possible necessity to take other measures than those mentioned could nevertheless be addressed at the meeting.

Dissemination of the judgments to all the authorities involved is requested in all cases and delegations are invited to provide the written confirmation of this dissemination.

In all these cases, just satisfaction or compensation agreed under a friendly settlement has been awarded to the applicants except in the following case: Sovtransavto Holding (reserved).

Section 2

- 3 cases against Austria

H46-67         33505          H.E., judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[4]

The case concerns the excessive length of certain civil proceedings (violation of Article 6§1). The proceedings started on 28/06/1985 and ended on 24/05/1996 (almost 10 years and 11 months).

*H46-68        37093          Informationsverein Lentia, judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the fact that the applicant company was unable to obtain radio and television broadcasting licences, despite a judgment of the European Court of Human Rights in this respect three years earlier, until 1/08/1996. On that date a judgment of the Constitutional Court liberalising the creation of radio and television stations and the new Act on cable and satellite broadcasting took effect (complaint under Article 10).

Following the European Court’s judgment of 24/11/93, the Committee of Ministers adopted Final Resolution (DH(98)142) summarising the measures taken by the Austrian authorities to avoid repetition of the violation found.

*H46-69        34994          Walter, judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the applicant’s complaint concerning a breach of his right of access to a court in the context of proceedings he sought to bring under Austrian media law. The applicant, who was in prison at the material time, maintained that he had been prevented from lodging an application to enforce the exercise of his right of reply to a press article in time because of an alleged delay by the prison authorities in posting a letter (complaint under Article 6§1).

- 1 case against Belgium

H46-70         37370          Stratégies and Communications and Dumoulin, judgment of 15/07/2002,

                                      final on 15/10/2002

The case concerns the excessive length of certain criminal proceedings which began on 24/04/1996, when the searches were carried out at the company’s head office and the applicant’s home and were still pending  (after 6 years and 2 months) when the European Court rendered its judgment (violation of Article 6§1).

The case also concerns the absence of an effective remedy in this respect (violation of article 13). In this context, the European Court noted that the law of 12 March 1998 amending Article 136 of the Criminal Investigation Code entered into force on 2 October 1998. This law introduced a remedy under domestic law making it possible to complain about the length of a criminal investigation. However, the Court noted that Article 136 of the Criminal Investigation Code raised issues in domestic law which had not yet been resolved. Consequently, the Court found that Article 136 had not acquired sufficient legal certainty to constitute a remedy under the terms of Article 13 of the Convention.

Possible individual and/or general measures: accelerate the proceedings; other measure (s) to be discussed at the meeting.

- 1 case against Cyprus

H46-71         51591          Markass Car Hide Ltd, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[5]

This case concerns the excessive length of certain civil proceedings (violation of Article 6§1). Proceedings started on 05/05/1998 and finished on 11/05/2000 (2 years and 6 days).

Section 2

- 2 cases against Croatia

H46-72         62912          Benzan, judgment of 08/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the applicant’s complaints that he had suffered inhuman and degrading treatment on account of the conditions under which he was detained in the B wing of the Lepoglava State Prison which amounted to degrading treatment of the applicant (complaint under Article 3) and that that he had no remedy in this respect (complaint under Article 13). The applicant also complained of a violation of his right to respect of his correspondence in that he was prevented from contacting his lawyer (complaint under Article 8).

In June 2002 the applicant was moved to another cell in one of the renovated wings of the above-mentioned prison (see § 15 of the judgment). According to the friendly settlement concluded, the Croatian Government, in addition to payment of compensation, undertakes to renovate the B Wing of the Lepoglava State Prison before the end of September 2003.

Possible individual and/or general measures: publication and dissemination of the judgment of the European Court to prison authorities; other measure(s) to be discussed at the meeting.

H46-73         56773          Rajčević, judgment of 23/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[6]

The case concerns the excessive length of certain civil proceedings (violation of Article 6§1). The proceedings started on 18/09/1992. However, the period which falls within the Court’s jurisdiction began on 06/11/1997, once the Convention had entered into force in respect of Croatia. The proceedings were concluded on 06/02/2002 (four years and three months).

- 4 cases against France

H46-74         38748          Immeubles Groupe Kosser, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

The case concerns an infringement of the applicant company’s right to a fair trial on account of the Government Commissioner’s presence in the deliberations of the trial bench in proceedings before the Conseil d’Etat (violation of Article 6§1).

The case presents similarities to the Kress case of 07/06/2001 – see Sections 3.a and 4.2 of this document.

H46-75         54210          Papon, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 25/10/2002

The case concerns the violation of the applicant’s right of access to a court, in that the Cour de cassation found that his appeal on a point of law had lapsed, pursuant to Article 583 of the Code of Criminal Procedure which was applicable at that time, because he had not surrendered to custody nor obtained dispensation from the obligation to do so. The European Court considered that making the admissibility of an appeal to the Cour de cassation conditional on the appellant’s surrendering to custody undermined his right of access to the juge de cassation and thus his right to a fair trial (violation of Article 6§1). This case is similar to the Khalfaoui case, which is in Section 6 as a result of measures taken, in particular the abrogation of Article 583 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

Possible individual measure:  re-opening of the appeal on basis of Articles 626-1 to 626-7 of the Code of Criminal Procedure introduced by Law No.2000-516 of 15 June 2000.

Section 2

H46-76         42400          Seguin, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 06/11/2002[7]

The case concerns the excessive length of two sets of proceedings before administrative and civil courts, concerning a redundancy for economic reasons, ended by a judgment of the Court of Cassation on 21/01/1998 (12 years and 9 months).

Possible individual or general measures: publication of the judgment of the European Court.

H46-77         41358          Desmots, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[8]

The case concerns the excessive length of proceedings before the administrative courts including the Conseil d’Etat: 8 years and 6 months (violation of Article 6§1).

It presents similarities to the cases of Beaume Marty & others which are in the process of being closed following the adoption of measures (See Section 6 of this document).

Possible individual or general measures: publication of the judgment of the European Court.

- 10 cases against Italy

H46-78         57574+        Sulejmanovic and others and Sejdovic and Sulejmanovic, judgment of 08/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the applicants’ expulsion to Bosnia-Herzegovina in March 2000 (complaints under Articles 3, 8 and 13 of the Convention and under Article 4 of Protocol No. 4 to the Convention).

According to the friendly settlement reached, the Italian Government has undertaken, in addition to the payment of certain sums to the applicants and to their lawyer, to revoke the deportation orders, to permit the applicants to enter Italy with their families and to issue them with residence permits on humanitarian grounds. The Government has further undertaken to arrange for the children of school age to be allowed to attend school and for a sick child to receive the medical attention she needs.

Individual measures: information is expected on the compliance with the terms of the friendly settlement.

H46-79         36534          Osu, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002

The case concerns the fact that the applicant could not challenge his conviction in absentia in 1989, his appeal having been rejected in 1996 as time-barred. The European Court found that the failure by the Italian Court of Cassation to apply Section 1 of Law 747/69 (concerning the suspension of time-limits in summer) without reason deprived the applicant of his right to access to a court (violation of Article 6§1).

The applicant was sentenced to seven years’ imprisonment and expelled in 1997 to the United Kingdom.

Possible individual and/or general measures: to be discussed at the meeting.

Section 2

- 8 cases concerning the failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

*H46-80        34742          A.M.M., judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-81         36112          C. Srl, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-82         38043          Ciccone, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-83         33115          Fabbrini, judgment of 15/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-84        39451          Fiorentini Vizzini, judgment of 19/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-85         35001          Franceschetti, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-86        57206          Virgulti, judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-87         36734          Visca, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

These cases concern the prolonged impossibility for the applicants to obtain the assistance of the police in order to implement judicial decisions ordering their tenants’ eviction, owing to the implementation of legislation providing for the suspension or staggering of evictions (complaints under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 and Article 6§1).

These cases are similar to the case of Immobiliare Saffi, judgment of 28/07/99, under Section 4.2 of this document.

- 2 cases against Poland

H46-88         55106          Górka, judgment of 05/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the length of certain civil proceedings (complaint under Article 6§1).

H46-89         71891          Hałka and others, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002

The case concerns the excessive length of civil proceedings (7 years and 3 months) relating to a claim for compensation for persecution suffered under the communist regime (violation of Article 6§1).

This case is similar to that of Kurzac against Poland (judgment of 22/02/2001).

Under the 1991 law, only the Warsaw Regional Court was competent to examine such claims. Legislative amendments were introduced in 1995 so that all regional courts became competent to examine claims for annulment of convictions and compensation for persecution under the communist regime.  However, claims submitted before that date remain with the Warsaw Regional Court where a special division was created in order to deal with this type of claims. 

Possible individual and/or general measures: Statistics are awaited concerning the time taken to deal with similar cases before the Warsaw regional Court.

- 2 cases against Portugal

H46-90         48187          Rosa Marques and others, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 25/10/2002

This case concerns the excessive length of certain civil proceedings (violation of Article 6§1). Proceedings started on 21 August 1990 and finished on 9 November 1998 (eight years and two months).

*H46-91        54483          Lógica - Móveis de Organização, Lda, judgment of 19/12/2002 – Friendly

                                      settlement

The case concerns the excessive length of certain criminal proceedings combined with a civil action for damages (complaints under Article 6§1).

Section 2

- 1 case against Romania

H46-92         33358          Oprea and others, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002

The case concerns the Supreme Court’s annulment of a final court decision delivered at first instance establishing the validity of the applicants' titles to real estate. The Supreme Court intervened following application for nullity lodged by the Procurator General on the ground of Article 330 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which allowed him at any moment to challenge final court decisions. The European Court considered that by acting in this way, the Supreme Court had failed to acknowledge the security of legal transactions and accordingly violated the applicants’ right to a fair trial. It also took the view that the Supreme Court had infringed the applicants’ right of access to a tribunal in that it had not recognised courts’ jurisdiction over disputes concerning recovery of real estate (violations of Article 6§1). Finally the European Court found that the Supreme Court’s decision had violated the applicants’ right to respect for their possessions (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

The case present similarities to that of Brumarescu against Romania (judgments of 23/01/01 and 11/05/01) which will be examined at the 834th meeting (April 2003) for supervision of general measures.

- 2 cases against the Slovak Republic

H46-93         41263          Konček, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns first an administrative decision withdrawing the applicant’s driving licence following an accident. In this context, the applicant complained of the unfairness and the length of this procedure (complaint under Article 6§1) and the absence of an effective remedy (complaint under Article 13). Secondly, the case concerns the length of criminal proceedings subsequently brought against the applicant for having caused a road accident while drunk (complaint under Article 6§1).

H46-94         41384          Varga, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the applicant’s complaint regarding the length of certain criminal proceedings and the absence of an effective remedy in this regard (complaint under Article 6§1).

- 1 case against Spain

H46-95         45238          Perote Pellon, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 25/10/2002

The case concerns the lack of objective impartiality of a military court in that two of the judges sitting on the court which judged the applicant, the president and the rapporteur, had been involved in several investigatory procedures including the confirmation of the applicant’s indictment at appeal, the extension of his detention on remand and the rejection of his súplica appeal against this decision (violation of Article 6§1).

A chamber of the central military court, in a judgment dated 09/07/1997, sentenced the applicant to 7 years’ imprisonment for the crime of revealing secrets or information concerning national security or defence and cashiered him from the army. On 15/04/1999 he was released on parole having served three quarters of his sentence.

Possible individual and/or general measures: publication of the judgment of the European Court; other measures to be discussed at the meeting.

Section 2

- 21 cases against Turkey

H46-96         36971          Kuray, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

The case concerns the applicant’s complaint concerning his prolonged detention (11 days) in police custody in 1996 before being brought before a magistrate (complaint under Article 5 § 3).

This case presents similarities to that of Sakık and others against Turkey (judgment of 26/11/1997) which was closed by a final resolution, ResDH(2002)110, following the adoption of general measures by the Turkish authorities.

H46-97         25144+        Sadak Selim and others, judgment of 11/06/2002, final on 06/11/2002[9]

The case concerns the automatic lapse of the applicants’ parliamentary mandates following the dissolution of their political party (DEP) by the Constitutional Court’s judgment of 16/06/1994 on the grounds of comments made abroad by the former chairman of the party and a written statement issued by its central committee (violation of Article 3 of Protocol No.1). The European Court considered that the definitive dissolution of the DEP with immediate effect and the automatic lapse of the applicants’ parliamentary mandates, was a disproportionate sanction incompatible with the very essence of the right to be elected. After constitutional amendments in 1995, only the parliamentarian whose words or deeds has caused the dissolution of a political party, loses his or her mandate (see § 37 of the judgment). The impact of these constitutional amendments on the applicants’ case remains to be clarified.

Possible individual and/or general measures: publication of the judgment; other measure(s) to be discussed at the meeting.

H46-98         27209+        Kiliç Özcan, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

This case concerns the applicant’s complaints concerning a violation of his freedom of expression on account of his convictions between 1993 and 1994 by State Security Courts following the publication of certain articles and the State Security Courts’ lack of independence and impartiality (complaints under Articles 10 and 6§1).

The applicant was imprisoned and sentenced to pay fines for separatist propaganda and for defending illegal organisations under Article 16 of the Press Act No. 5680 and Articles 6 and 8 of the Anti-Terror Law No. 3713.

According to the friendly settlement, the Turkish Government undertook to pay a sum of money to the applicant and to implement all necessary reform of domestic law and practice in order to bring the Turkish Law into conformity with the requirements of the Convention in the area of freedom of expression. Furthermore, the government undertook to adopt the individual measures set out in Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106 in order rapidly and fully to erase the consequences of the applicant’s convictions. This case is comparable to the “freedom of expression” cases against Turkey under Section 4.2 of this annotated agenda and order of business.

H46-99         27602          Ekinci Ülkü, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002

The case relates to killing of the applicant's husband in February 1994 near Ankara and to the authorities' failure to conduct an adequate and effective investigation into the circumstances surrounding his death (violations of Articles 2 and 13).

Individual measures: The applicant argued that the above finding of violations imposes on the respondent State a legal obligation to carry out a genuine and effective investigation into the circumstances of her husband's murder. The Court stated that it was for Turkey to take all measures to put an end to the violations and as far as possible restore the applicant to his rights and for the Committee of Ministers, acting under Article 46, to supervise their execution (§179 of the judgment).

Section 2

General measures: In its Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98 the Committee took stock of the progress and pointed out a number of outstanding problems in the execution of some 40 judgments finding violations of the Convention by the Turkish security forces. As a result, Turkey has been invited to adopt further general measures to comply with these judgments. The Committee will be invited to resume consideration of these issues at the 834th meeting (9-10 April 2003).

H46-100       25656          Orhan Salih, judgment of 18/06/2002, final on 06/11/2002[10]

The case relates to the unacknowledged detention of the applicant's son and two brothers, in May 1994 in South-East Turkey, in the total absence of fundamental procedural safeguards (violation of Article 5) and to their disappearance and presumed death under the responsibility of the security forces (violations of Article 2 in respect of the three disappeared persons and of Article 3 in respect of the applicant). The case also concerns the destruction by the security forces of the applicant's and his relatives' homes and property (violations of Articles 8 and/or Article 1 of Protocol No. 1) and the lack of effective domestic remedies in respect of the applicant's complaints (violations of Article 2 due to serious deficiencies of the investigation into the applicant's relatives' disappearance and of Article 13, combined with Articles 2, 3, 5, and 8 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1). The Court also found that the Turkish authorities hindered the exercise of the applicant's right to individual petition under the Convention (violation of Article 34).

Individual measures: The applicant asked the Court to oblige the respondent Government to undertake a serious investigation into the fate of the disappeared relatives of the applicant and to reconstruct their houses and the village of Caglayan so as to allow the applicant and his surviving relatives to return to their homes. The Court stated that it was for Turkey to take all measures to put an end to the violations and as far as possible restore the applicant to his rights and for the Committee of Ministers, acting under Article 46, to supervise their execution (§451 of the judgment).

General measures: In its Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98 the Committee took stock of the progress and pointed out a number of outstanding problems in the execution of some 40 judgments finding violations of the Convention by the Turkish security forces. As a result, Turkey has been invited to adopt further general measures to comply with these judgments. The Committee will be invited to resume consideration of these issues at the 834th meeting (9-10 April 2003).

                   -  8 Friendly settlement cases containing undertakings of the Turkish Government

H46-101       38588          Keçeci, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-102      31137          Adalı, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-103      31154          Şen Filiyet, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-104      31153          Soğukpınar, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-105       36189          Yakar, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-106      22280          Demir Mahmut, judgment of 05/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-107       31890          Kınay M. and Kınay R., judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

*H46-108      31152          Yalçın Şaziment, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

These cases concern in particular allegations of either ill-treatment during police custody or the killing of relatives of the applicants in the course of operations conducted by security forces or destruction of their properties between October 1988 and November 1996 in Istanbul, Diyarbakır, Ankara, Mus and Bingol  (complaints under Articles 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 13, 14 and 18 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

According to the friendly settlements, the Turkish Government, in addition to payment of compensation, undertakes notably to issue appropriate instructions and adopt all the necessary measures – including the obligation to carry out effective investigations – to ensure that the right to life and the prohibition of such forms of ill-treatment are respected in the future. The Government also referred to the Committee of Ministers’ supervision of execution of other similar judgments.

Section 2

The complaints and the governmental undertakings in these cases present similarities with those made in a number of other friendly settlements relating to actions of the Turkish security forces, which will be re-examined at the 834th meeting (9-10 April 2003) for supervision of their implementation.

- 8 cases relating to delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest against Turkey

H46-109       19660          Çalkan Dudu, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-110       20140          Çelebi Mehmet n° 2, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-111       68117          Denli Nesibe, judgment of 23/07/2002, final on 23/10/2002

H46-112       20144          Kartal Adile, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-113       20152          Özen Mehmet, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-114       20151          Öztürk Ahmet, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-115       20155          Şen Aziz n° 2, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

*H46-116      26543          Çallı, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

These cases concern in particular the applicants’ complaints of breaches of their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions due to the administration’s delays in paying additional compensation awarded by domestic courts for expropriation of their property and due to the substantial difference between the default interest rate applicable at the time and the average rate of inflation in Turkey (violations of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

These cases present similarities to those of Akkuş and Aka against Turkey (judgments of 09/07/1997 and 23/09/1998) closed by Resolutions ResDH(2001)71 and ResDH(2001)70 respectively, following a legislative reform which brought the statutory rate of default interest into line with the annual rediscount rate applied by the Turkish Central Bank to short-term debts (the latter rate is fixed and permanently reviewed, taking into account particularly the country’s inflation rate).

- 1 case against Ukraine

H46-117      48553           Sovtransavto Holding, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[11]

The case concerns the failure to respect the applicant company’s right to a fair trial before an impartial and independent tribunal in respect of certain proceedings it conducted between 1997 and 2002 before the Ukrainian courts with a view to establishing the unlawfulness of domestic decisions which resulted in the depreciation of its shares in – and the ensuing loss of control over – a Ukrainian transport company (violation of Article 6§1). The main deficiencies found by the Court consist of:

- repeated attempts by the President of Ukraine to influence domestic court decisions;

- application of "protest" procedure ("application for supervision") making it possible to quash final judicial decisions without any limitations;

- the refusal by courts to examine the arguments on the merits in a public hearing and the absence of adequate motivation of judicial decisions.

The Court concluded in addition that the manner in which the impugned proceedings were conducted and concluded had also violated the applicant company's right to peaceful enjoyment of its possessions (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

Possible individual or general measures: to be discussed at the meeting.

Section 2

- 1 case against the United Kingdom

H46-118       36042          Willis, judgment of 11/06/2002, final on 11/09/2002

The case particularly concerns discrimination on grounds of sex against the applicant in that as a widower, he was denied the social security benefits for widowed parents: the Widowed Mother’s Allowance and the Widow’s Payment, as these benefits were only available to women (violation of Article 14 together with Article 8 and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

The case present similarities with the Crossland, Cornwell and Leary cases (see Resolutions ResDH(2000)81, ResDH(2002)95 and ResDH(2002)96 respectively adopted in these cases).

SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise the payment of just satisfaction in the following cases pending before the Committee of Ministers for execution supervision. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in principle at their next Human Rights meeting.

3.a               SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST SATISFACTION AS WELL AS, WHERE DUE, OF DEFAULT INTEREST, IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT EXPIRED LESS THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

At the time of issuing the present Annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the Secretariat had not received the written confirmation of payment of just satisfaction and/or default interest in the following cases (see the table below summarising the total number of cases by States). The Representatives of the States concerned are invited to give the Secretariat written confirmation of payment of the sums awarded by the Court and/or the default interests.

- 1 case against Austria

H46-119       38275          W.F., judgment of 30/05/2002, final on 30/08/2002

- 1 case against Belgium

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-120       51564          Čonka, judgment of 05/02/02, final on 05/05/02

- 33 cases against France

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-123       51279          Colombani and others, judgment of 25/06/2002, final on 25/09/2002

H46-124       48161          Motais de Narbonne, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002

H46-125       53613          Goth, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-126       32911+        Meftah, Adoud and Bosoni, judgment of 26/07/2002 - Grand Chamber

H46-127       37971          Sociétés Colas Est, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 16/07/2002

H46-128       41376          D.M., judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

H46-129       43125          Delbec Annick n° 3, judgment of 18/06/2002, final on 18/09/2002[12]

H46-130       33395          L.R., judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

H46-131       39626          Granata, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-132       38396          Karatas and Sari, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-133       33424          Nouhaud and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-134       44952+        Van der Kar and Lissaur Van West, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-136       51575          Baillard, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 04/09/2002[13]

H46-137       48215          Lutz, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-138       44081          Perhirin and 29 others, judgment of 14/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[14] [15]

H46-139       56198          Société Industrielle d’Entretien and de Service (Sies), judgment of 19/03/02,

                                      final on 19/06/02

H46-140       51179          Solana, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 04/09/2002[16]

H46-141       44797+        Etcheveste and Bidart, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-142       45172          Fentati, judgment of 22/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-143       33592          Baumann, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

H46-144       41476          Laine, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02

H46-145       40096          Versini, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 10/10/01

H46-146       41526          Pulvirenti, judgment of 28/11/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-147       44211          Lacombe, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-148       39273          Vermeersch, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

H46-149       48167          Hababou, judgment of 26/04/01 - Friendly settlement

H32-150       39966          De Cantelar, Interim Resolution DH(2000)86

H46-151       42195          Mortier, judgment of 31/07/01, final on 31/10/01

H46-152       39594          Kress, judgment of 07/06/01 – Grand Chamber[17]

H46-153       40472          Tricard, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 10/10/01

H46-154       29731          Krombach, judgment of 13/02/01, final on 13/05/01

H46-155       47631          Lemort, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/04/01

H32-156       31677          Watson John, Interim Resolution DH(2000)20

- 10 cases against Greece

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-157       37095          Pialopoulos and others, judgments of 15/02/01, final on 27/06/02 and of 15/05/01, final on 06/11/02[18] (Article 41)[19]

*H46-158      47730          Entreprises Meton and Etep, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-159       48392          Hatzitakis, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-160       48679          AEPI S.A., judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-161       46356          Smokovitis and others, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-162       49215          Angelopoulos, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-163       46806          Sakellaropoulos Yeoryios, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-164       46352          Logothetis, judgment of 12/04/01, final on 12/07/01 and judgment of 18/04/02

                                      (Article 41), final on 18/07/02

H46-165       49282          Marinakos, judgment of 04/10/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-166       47020          Kolokitha, judgment of 07/06/01 - Friendly settlement

- 2 cases against Hungary

H46-167       42373          Bódine Bencze, judgment of 01/10/2002 – Striking-out following a Friendly

                                      settlement

H46-168       43352          Kósa, judgment of 01/10/2002 – Striking-out follwong a Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

- 419 cases against Italy

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-169       36732          Pisano, judgment of 24/10/2002 – Striking-out - Grand Chamber

H46-170       33202          Beyeler, judgments of 05/01/00 (merits) and of 28/05/02 (just satisfaction)

H46-171       28724          Capitanio, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002[20]

H46-172       46079          Biffoni, judgment of 24/10/2001 - Friendly settlement

H46-173       41624          Calvagno, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-174       31928          F. and F., judgment of 24/10/2001 - Friendly settlement

H46-175       39690          Gianotti Ricardo, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-176       43986          Pugliese Rosalba, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-177       47895          Sartorelli, judgment of 24/10/2001 - Friendly settlement

H46-178       34714          Tacchino and Scorza, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- Civil courts[21]

H46-179       56084          At.M., judgment of 07/05/02, final on 07/08/02

H46-180       41740          Diebold, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-181       44413          Guerrera Angelo Giuseppe, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-182       47479          Mastromauro S.R.L., judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-183       44409          Rizzo Giuseppe, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, rectified on 09/07/02

H46-184       51664          Rodolfi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-185       30423          Salini Costruttori Spa, Interim Resolution DH(99)673

H46-186       51674          V.I., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 04/09/2002[22]

- Administrative courts[23]

H46-187       56226          Abate and Ferdinandi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-188       44341          Cannone, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-189       44347          Carapella and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-190       44350          Cecere Domenico, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-191       56222          Centis, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-192       56206          Colonnello and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-193       56208          Conte and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-194       56202          Cornia, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-195       56224          D’Amore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-196       56217          De Cesaris, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-197       44337          Delli Paoli, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-198       56205          Dente, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-199       56225          Di Pede II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-200       56221          Donato, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-201       56212          Folletti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-202       44349          Fragnito, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-203       44340          Gaudenzi, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-204       56203          Ginocchio, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-205       44334          Lattanzi and Cascia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-206       56204          Limatola, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-207       56207          Lugnan in Basile, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-208       56220          Mastropasqua, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-209       38594          Mereu and S. Maria Navarrese, judgment of 13/06/2002, final on 13/09/2002

H46-210       56211          Napolitano Giuseppe, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-211       44348          Nazzaro and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

Section 3.a

H46-212       44351          Pace and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-213       56213          Piacenti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-214       56223          Polcari, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-215       56219          Presel, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-216       56214          Ripoli I, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-217       56215          Ripoli II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-218       56201          Sardo Salvatore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-219       56218          Stabile Michele, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

- Court of Audit

H46-220       54282          Amici, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-221       54278          Leonardi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-222       54312          Manna, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-223       54319          Sportola, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

- Labour courts[24]

H46-224       51031          Aceto and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-225       51089          Armellino Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-226       52824          Belviso and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-227       52804          Bianco Pellegrino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-228       52816          Biondi and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-229       51030          Biondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-230       52835          Cerbo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-231       52801          Ciarmoli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-232       52815          Cimmino and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-233       52807          Ciullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-234       52821          Colangelo Domenico, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-235       51164          Crovella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-236       51163          D’Angelo Michele, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-237       51125          De Filippo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-238       51027          Del Vecchio Anna Rita, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-239       51155          Della Ratta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-240       52813          Di Meo and Masotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-241       52846          Di Meo Antonio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-242       51092          Di Mezza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-243       51156          Fasulo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, rectified on 12/09/2002

H46-244       51091          Ferrara Clementina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/2002

H46-245       52843          Franco and Basile, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-246       51161          Gagliardi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-247       52830          Giannotta and Iannella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-248       51094          Iacobucci and Lavorgna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-249       51170          Izzo Giovanni, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-250       52802          Lagozzino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-251       52812          Lavorgna and Iorio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-252       52822          Macolino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-253       52819          Mancino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-254       51169          Marotta Alberto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-255       51168          Martino Alfonso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-256       52827          Mastrocinque Mafalda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-257       51167          Matera Tommasina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-258       52845          Mazzarelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-259       52818          Meola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-260       52840          Mongillo Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-261       44428          Nardone Antonio, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

Section 3.a

H46-262       52832          Nero and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-263       51029          Ocone, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-264       51114          Paduano, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-265       52829          Pallotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-266       51023          Palmieri Maddalena, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised judgment of

                                      18/04/02, final on 18/07/02

H46-267       51022          Palmieri Mario Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-268       52841          Panza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-269       52837          Pascale and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-270       52842          Pascale Elda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-271       52826          Pascale Maria Annunziata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-272       51162          Pengue, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-273       52808          Perna Giuseppina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-274       52828          Petrillo and Petrucci, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-275       51025          Petrillo Gino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-276       51024          Porto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-277       52825          Pucella and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-278       51126          Raccio Emilia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-279       51109          Restuccio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-280       52820          Riccardi Vicenzina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-281       52823          Romano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-282       52844          Romano Rosa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-283       52833          Santagata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-284       51165          Santina Pelosi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-285       40151          Sciarrotta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-286       52839          Tanzillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-287       52836          Tazza and Zullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-288       52810          Tazza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-289       52809          Truocchio Edmondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-290       51166          Truocchio Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-291       51124          Tudisco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-292       52817          Urbano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-293       51026          Uzzo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-294       52811          Villari, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-295       52847          Viscuso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-296       51028          Vitelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-297       52814          Zoccolillo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-298       52800          Zuotto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

- Criminal proceedings[25]

H46-299       38576          Barattelli Carlo, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-300       41863          Boldrin Stefano, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-301       37249          Casadei Roberto, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-302       35991          Del Federico Alberto, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-303       42619          Di Vuono Bernardo, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-304       44173          Mucciacciaro Raffaele, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-305       42287          Pascazi Domenico, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-306       43915          Rocci Luigi, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-307       42291+        Tumbarello and Titone, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-308       41424          Nuvoli, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

Section 3.a

- Criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages[26]

H46-309       46970          Contardi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-310       25639          F.L., judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-311       30127          Sciortino, judgment of 18/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H46-312       39676          Rojas Morales, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-313       26772          Labita, judgment of 06/04/00, final on 06/04/00

H46-314       30882          Pellegrini Maria Grazia, judgment of 20/07/01, final on 20/10/01

H46-315       15918          Antonetto, judgment of 20/07/00, final on 20/10/00

H46-316       28168          Quadrelli, judgment of 11/01/00, final on 20/03/00

H46-317       33354          Lucà, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-318       26161          Natoli, judgment of 09/01/01[27]

H32-319       19734          F.S. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)209

H46-321       41852          Vaccaro, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-322       39221+        Scozzari and others, judgment of 13/07/00 – Grand Chamber

                                      Interim Resolutions ResDH(2001)65 and ResDH(2001)151[28]

- Civil courts[29]

H46-327       44481          A.C. VII, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-328       46515          Adriani, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-329       46964          Alpites S.P.A., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-330       47785          Angemi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-331       48412          Ar.M., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-332       46958          Ardemagni and Ripa, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-333       39900          Artuso Paolo, Interim Resolution DH(99)569

H32-334       39137          Avallone, Interim Resolution DH(99)475

H46-335       44511          Bellagamba, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-336       40977          Beltramo, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-337       44431          Beluzzi and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-338       39883          Bertozzi, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/04/00

H46-339       44442          Bevilacqua, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-340       36811          Bielectric S.R.L., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-341       44437          Bocca, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-342       39121          Bolla, Interim Resolution DH(99)480

H46-343       44457          Bonelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-344       44436          Buffalo s.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-345       46534          Burghesu, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-346       46980          C.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-347       35292          Calandrella F., P. and 2 others, Interim Resolution DH(98)405

H46-348       39881          Capodanno, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/04/00

H46-349       45071          Capurro and Tosetti, judgment of 28/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-350       46526          Carboni, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-351       45859          Caruso Giuseppina, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-352       45861          Cavallaro, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-353       36620          Ceriello, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H46-354       46537          Cerulli and Zadra, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-355       45869          Chiappetta, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-356       46959          Circo and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

Section 3.a

H46-357       44504          Citterio and Angiolillo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-358       47779          Ciuffetti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-359       46532          Conte Gaspare and others, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-360       47774          Conti Giuliana, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-361       44385          Cornaglia, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-362       46527          Corsi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-363       35616          Coscia, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H46-364       46538          Costantini Francesco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-365       44500          Cova, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-366       45880          Cultraro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-367       46536          D.C. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-368       44513          D’Ammassa and Frezza, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, revised

                                      judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03[30]

H46-369       45872          D’Annibale, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-370       40216          D’Arrigo and Garrozzo, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-371       52921          Damiano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-372       17482          D'Aquino and Petrizzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)28

H32-373       40566          De Cicco Concetta, Interim Resolution DH(98)405

H32-374       40580          De Lorenzi, Interim Resolution DH(99)588

H46-375       42520          De Simone Pasquale, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-376       39138          Di Fant I, Interim Resolution DH(99)488

H32-377       39139          Di Fant II, Interim Resolution DH(99)489

H46-378       46976          Di Motoli and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-379       46520          Dorigo Franco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-380       44480          E.G., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-381       44519          E.M. II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-382       39906          Emmebiemme S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)592

H46-383       40982          Erdokovy, judgment of 01/02/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-384       46524+        F., T. and E., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-385       46533          F.L.S., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-386       39164          F.S.p.A. II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-387       46971          F.T., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-388       26012          Facciolini, Interim Resolution DH(96)648

H46-389       46968          Falconi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-390       52972          Falzarano Carmine, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-391       47781          Farinosi and Barattelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-392       45870          Ferrazzo and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-393       45868          Filippello Giorgio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-394       38145          Focardi and Conti, Interim Resolution DH(99)287

H46-395       46965          Franceschetti and Odorico, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-396       38118          Fraschetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)288

H46-397       44397          G.B. IV, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-398       37131          G.M.N., judgment of 02/11/99, final on 02/11/99

H32-399       38503          G.P. and 25 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)388

H46-400       46543          G.S. and L.M., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-401       47786          G.V. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-402       46963          Galiè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-403       46528          Giannalia, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-404       47773          Gianni, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-405       45860          Giuseppe Nicola and Luciano Caruso, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-406       40968          I.F., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-407       44418          I.P.E.A. S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-408       39116          I.R., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-409       44447          Ianniti and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

Section 3.a

H46-410       46516          Il Messaggero S.a.s. II, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-411       46517          Il Messaggero S.a.s. III, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-412       46518          Il Messaggero S.a.s. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-413       46519          Il Messaggero S.a.s. V, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-414       47777          Ilardi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-415       44508          Immobiliare Il Messaggero del geometra Antonio Iorillo, judgment of 25/10/01,

                                      final on 25/01/02

H46-416       39894          Italiano, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-417       46530          Iulio, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-418       40924          L. S.r.l., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-419       46542          Lanino, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-420       31341          Lazzari and Scagnoli, Interim Resolution DH(97)637

H46-421       45853          Lo Cicero, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-422       40571          Lo Sardo, Interim Resolution DH(99)606

H46-423       46523          Lonardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-424       46962          Lucas International S.R.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-425       44406          M. S.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-426       46961          Maletti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-427       28725          Manzi A., B. and L., Interim Resolution DH(97)254

H46-428       44443          Marchi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-429       46957          Marcolongo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-430       44517          Mari and Mangini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-431       44422          Marzinotto, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-432       46966          Massaro, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-433       46979          Mastrantonio Francesca, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-434       44420          Mauri, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-435       46973          Morelli and Nerattini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-436       44490          Murgia, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-437       39872          Nata, Interim Resolution DH(99)617

H46-438       46522          Nolla, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-439       44494          O.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-440       44468          P.B. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-441       40570          Padalino V. and G., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-442       40952          Paderni II, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-443       21707          Panissa, D., G. and A. Vittonetto

H32-444       39155          Perilli and Gigotti Micheli, Interim Resolution DH(99)509

H46-445       45070          Persichetti and C.S.r.l., judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-446       44380          Pettirossi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-447       28936          Piccinini II, judgment of 11/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-448       39899          Pirilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)623

H46-449       45065          Pirola, judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-450       46967          Procaccianti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-451       46969          Procopio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-452       44412          Quattrone Pasquale, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-453       38498          Rando, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-454       45058          Rettura, judgment of 17/10/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-455       44465          Rigutto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-456       43098          Romano, judgment of 28/09/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-457       35328          Roselli Italo II, Interim Resolution DH(98)440

H46-458       44479          Rosetti e Ciucci and C., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-459       44527          Rossana Ferrari, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-460       44472          Rossi Valeria, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-461       44461          Sacchi Roberto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-462       38135          Sanna, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H46-463       44466          Santoro Valerio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-464       47780          Santorum, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

Section 3.a

H46-465       45854          Savino, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-466       44419          Sbrojavacca Pietrobon, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-467       36621          Scalvini, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H46-468       44491          Sonego, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-469       44470          Spada, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-470       56094          Sposito, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-471       39705          Spurio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-472       39865          Staffolani, Interim Resolution DH(99)635

H46-473       44417          Tagliabue, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-474       38102          Talenti, Interim Resolution (2001)58

H46-475       44486          Tebaldi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-476       44425          Tedesco Michele, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-477       46539          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.P.A. VII, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-478       45068          Toscano and others, judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-479       44488          Vecchi and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-480       44528          Vecchini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-481       44534          Venturini Alberto I, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-482       40586          Verini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)639

H46-483       40599          Vicari II, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-484       44395          Visentin, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-485       37166          Vitale and others, judgment of 02/11/99

H46-486       44445          W.I.E. S.n.c., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-487       44462          Zanasi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-488       37079          Zironi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

- Administrative courts[31]

H46-489       41809          A.B. V, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-490       34437          Caliendo, judgment of 14/03/00, final on 14/03/00

H46-491       41817          Caliri, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-492       41807          Centioni and others, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-493       41815          Monti Enrico, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-494       41810          Mosca, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-495       41813          Musiani, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-496       41816          Paradiso Antonio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-497       31631          Procaccini, judgment of 30/03/00, final on 30/03/00

H46-498       41814          Zeoli and 34 others, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 05/10/00

- Court of Audit

H46-502       41823          Pascali and Conte, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-506       39175          Sileo, Interim Resolution DH(99)524

- Labour courts[32]

H46-511       40363          Ascierto Ada, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-512       43063          Bello, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-513       43094          C.B., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-514       42999          Cacciacarro, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-515       43020          Ciaramella Pasquale, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-516       36615          Cappello, Interim Resolution DH(99)212

H32-517       38095          Cardillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)317

H46-518       46521          Ciccardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-519       42996          Cocca, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-520       44532          Colacrai, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-521       43088          Coppolaro, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

H46-522       43086          Cosimo Cesare, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-523       43087          Cosimo Rotondi, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-524       43083          D’Addona Simone, judgment of 22/06/00 – Friendly settlement

H46-525       43017          D’Ambrosio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-526       43059          D’Antonoli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-527       43054          Del Buono, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-528       43051          Di Biase Leonardo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-529       43062          Di Blasio Concetta, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-530       46975          Di Gabriele, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-531       43030          Di Libero, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-532       43022          Di Mella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-533       46978          F.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-534       43056          Fallarino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-535       43058          Foschini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-536       45855          Fr.C., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-537       43096          G.A. IV, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-538       43093          G.P. VI, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-539       43075          Gallo Giuseppe, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-540       37170          Giampietro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-541       38975          Gioia Angelina, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-542       43050          Gioia Filomena Giovanna, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-543       43074          Grasso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-544       42998          Iannotta, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-545       39124          Guagenti, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-546       43072          Guarino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-547       43091          Iadarola, judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-548       43101          Iannotti, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-549       43021          Iapalucci, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-550       43067          Izzo Italia, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-551       43065          Lanni, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-552       43102          Lepore T., Lepore M. and Iannotti T., judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-553       43068          Luciano, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-554       43095          M.C. X, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-555       43010          Mannello, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-556       37160          Marsicovetere, Interim Resolution DH(99)221

H46-557       43000          Maselli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-558       43018          Meoli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-559       43069          Mercone, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-560       43057          Mongillo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-561       43064          Nicolella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-562       43100          Orsini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-563       43076          P.T. II, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-564       43012          Palumbo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-565       43052          Panzanella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-566       43061          Patuto, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-567       43060          Pizzi, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-568       43023          Pozella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-569       46974          Risola, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-570       43019          Rubortone, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-571       43055          Sabatino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-572       43099          Santillo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-573       43085          Silvio Cesare, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-574       42997          Squillace, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-575       43084          Tontoli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-576       46960          Trimboli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-577       43016          Truocchio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

H46-578       43070          Vignona, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-579       43109          Zeoli Nicolina, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-580       43015          Zollo Clavio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-581       43066          Zullo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

- Criminal courts[33]

H46-582      38878         Ciacci, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-583      42351         Del Giudice, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-584      45267         F.R. and 3 others, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-585      41603         G.B.Z., L.Z. and S.Z., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 15/02/00

H46-586      41094         Giannangeli, judgment of 05/07/01, final on 05/10/01

H46-587      32646         Guerresi, judgment of 24/04/01, final on 24/04/01

H46-588      41893         Martinez, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-589      23969         Mattoccia, judgment of 25/07/00

H46-590      44943         Orlandi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-591      29898         Patanè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-592      30132         Pepe Umberto, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-593      36733         Perilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)427

H32-594      24170         Pesce Mario, Interim Resolution DH(97)468

H46-595      37118         Sergi, judgment of 11/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-596      26806         U.O. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)52

H32-597      26781         U.O. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)129

H32-598      26782         U.O. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)130

H46-599      43199         Visintin, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

- Criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages[34]

H46-600       45856          Bacigalupi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-601       45857          Comella and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-602       45858          Tesconi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-603       34462          Wessels-Bergervoet, judgment of 04/06/2002, final on 04/09/2002 and judgment of

                                      12/11/2002 (Article 41) – Friendly settlement

- 6 cases against Poland

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-604       34611          Dacewicz, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002

H46-605       33885          Kawka Eryk, judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

H46-606       24244          Migoń, judgment of 25/06/2002, final on 25/09/2002[35]

H46-607       27715+        Berliński Roman and Sławomir, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-608       48684          Uthke, judgment of 18/06/02, défintif le 18/09/02[36]

                   - Default interest to be paid

H32-609       24559          Gibas, Interim Resolution DH(97)242

Section 3.a

- 12 cases against Portugal

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-610       54073          Agostinho, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-611       48233          Almeida Do Couto, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-612       47460          Câmara Pestana, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-613       48752          Coelho, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-614       49020          F. Santos Lda., judgment of 16/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-615       50843+        Longotrans - Transportes Internacionais Lda, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-616       47833          Marques Francisco, judgment of 06/06/2002, final on 06/09/2002

H46-617       53793          Morais Sarmento, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-618       54449          Saraiva e Lei, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-619       49118          SIB - Sociedade Imobiliária Da Benedita Lda, judgment of 16/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-620       44298          Tourtier, judgment of 14/02/02, final on 14/05/02

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-621       43654          Pires, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

- 10 cases against Romania

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-622       35831          Bălănescu, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-623       34992          Basacopol, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-624       33912          Budescu and Petrescu, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002,

                                      rectified on 09/07/2002

H46-625       29053          Ciobanu, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002

H46-626       32925          Cretu, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-627       32943          Falcoianu and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-628       29968          Hodoş and others, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[37]

H46-629       29407          Vasiliu, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[38]

H46-630       32260          Surpaceanu Constantin and Traian-Victor, judgment of 21/05/2002,

                                      final on 21/08/2002

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-631       28342          Brumărescu, judgments of 28/10/99, 23/01/01 (Article 41) and 11/05/01

                                      (rectification) – Grand Chamber

- 1 case against Slovenia

H46-633       42320          Belinger, judgment of 13/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

- 17 cases against Turkey

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-635       38578          Kaplan Süleyman, judgment of 10/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-636       33234          N.Ö, judgment of 17/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-637       29296          İğdeli, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-638       34481          Filiz and Kalkan, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-639       33179          Karataş Seher, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[39]

H46-640       29590          Yağmurdereli, judgment of 04/06/2002, final on 04/09/2002[40]

H46-641       27694          A.S., judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-642       38916          Atalağ, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-643       38915          Bayram Abdullah Naci, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-644       35867          Bayram and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-649       37414          Birsel and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-652       35050          Karabıyık and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-656       33419          Özdiler Hasan Doğan, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-659       35079          Özkan and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-664       35866          Ünlü Dudu, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-665       30944          Öcal, judgment of 10/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-666       22876          Şemse Önen, judgment of 26/01/02, final on 14/05/02

- 9 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-667       43290          McShane, judgment of 28/05/2002, final on 28/08/2002[41]

H46-668       30668+        Wilson and the National Union of journalists; Palmer, Wyeth and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers; Doolan and others, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002[42]

H46-669       56547          P., C. and S., judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[43]

H46-671       65905          Rice, judgment of 01/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-672       42007          Davies, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002, rectified on 13/09/2002

H46-673       24265          Devenney, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-674       46477          Edwards Paul and Audrey, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02[44]

H46-675       25680          I., judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber[45]

H46-676       28957          Goodwin Christine, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber[46]

- 1 case against « the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”

H46-678       58185          Janeva, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

3.b              SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST

                   SATISFACTION IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT

                   EXPIRED MORE THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

Some of the cases appearing under this section concern late payment for reasons beyond the control of the Governments concerned.

Expiry date

of the time-limit set

- 11 cases against France

H32-679       26984          Picard, Interim Resolution DH(99)30                                                    31/01/1999

H32-680       25971          Proma di Franco Gianotti, Interim Resolution DH(99)566        14/05/00+02/01/2001

H32-681       31409          Riccobono, Interim Resolution DH(99)557                                           26/09/2001

H46-682       35683          Vaudelle, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 06/09/01                                06/12/2001

H46-683       44451          A.A.U., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01                                   19/12/2001

H32-684       26242          Lemoine Pierre, Interim Resolution DH(99)353                                      17/03/2002

H46-685       44069          G.B. II, judgment of 02/10/01, final on 02/01/02                                   02/04/2002

H46-686       37794          Pannullo and Forte, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02                 30/04/2002

H46-687       33023          Meier, judgment of 07/02/02 – Friendly settlement                               07/05/2002

H46-689       44070          Beljanski, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02                               07/08/2002

H46-690       39278          Langlois, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02                                07/08/2002

- 31 cases against Italy

H46-691       20855          Esposito Luigi, judgment of 25/05/00 - Friendly settlement                   25/08/2000

H46-693       31260          Lamperi Balenci, judgment of 21/02/02 - Friendly settlement                 21/05/2002

H46-694       41232          Quartucci, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                         28/06/2002

- Civil courts[47]

H46-700       44421          Galasso, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                                25/04/2002

H46-701       44501          Il Messaggero S.A.S. VI, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02         25/04/2002

H46-707       51708          I.M., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002                                11/06/2002

H46-708       51668          Lopriore, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002                         11/06/2002

H46-713       51672          Selva, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02                                    11/06/2002

H46-719       56101          Mesiti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02                                    12/08/2002

H46-721       56093          Società Croce Gialla Romana S.a.s., judgment of 12/02/02,

                                      final on 12/05/02                                                                                12/08/2002

- Administrative courts[48]

H46-726       44330          Principe and others, judgment of 19/12/00 - Friendly settlement           19/03/2001

H46-727       41806          Alesiani and 510 others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01          27/08/2001

H46-728       41805          Arivella, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01                                  27/08/2001

H46-729       41804          Ciotta, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01                                    27/08/2001

H46-730       35956          Galatà and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01                  27/08/2001

H46-731       44525          Ferrari Marcella II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                   25/04/2002

H46-732       44379          Finessi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                                  25/04/2002

H46-733       44343          Massimo Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02              25/04/2002

H46-734       44352          Massimo Giuseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02             25/04/2002

H46-735       44345          Rinaudo and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02               25/04/2002

H46-737       44342          Gattuso, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002                          06/06/2002

H46-738       44333          V.P. and F.D.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02                     12/08/2002

Section 3.b

- Labour courts[49]

H46-739       43097          Nicoli, judgment of 22/06/00 – Friendly settlement                               22/09/2000

H46-741       52924          Frattini and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02,

                                      revised judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003[50]                          12/08/2002

- Court of Audit

H46-748       54307          Meleddu, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement                          21/05/2002

H46-749       54316          Betti, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                                28/06/2002

H46-750       54293          Chiappetta Domenico, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement       28/06/2002

H46-751       54287          Ferrari Sergio, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                   28/06/2002

H46-752       54299          Libertini and Di Girolamo, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement  28/06/2002

H46-753       44359          Marrama, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                           28/06/2002

H46-754       54286          Strangi, judgment of 07/05/02 – Friendly settlement                             07/08/2002

- 6 cases against Poland

H46-755       26760          Werner, judgment of 15/11/01                                                             15/02/2002

H32-756       27506          Owczarzak, Interim Resolution DH(99)260                                            17/03/2002

H46-757       38328          Bejer, judgment of 04/10/01, final on 04/01/02[51]                                   04/04/2002

H46-758       32499          Z.R., judgment of 15/01/02 – Friendly settlement                                 15/04/2002

H46-759       25196          Iwańczuk, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02                               15/05/2002

H46-760       34052          Olstowski, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02                              15/05/2002

- 1 case against Portugal

H46-762       49018          Marques Jorge Ribeiro, judgment of 04/04/02 – Friendly settlement      04/07/2002

- 10 cases against Turkey

H54-763       15318          Loizidou, judgments of 18/12/96 (merits) and 28/07/98 (just satisfaction) –

                                      Interim Resolutions DH(99)680, DH(2000)105

                                      and ResDH(2001)80[52]                                                                         28/10/1998

H46-764       25723          Erdoğdu, judgment of 15/06/00[53]                                                        15/09/2000

H46-765       27308          Demiray, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 04/04/01                                04/07/2001

H46-766       34688          Akin, judgment of 12/04/01                                                                 12/07/2001

H46-767       19265          Atak and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01                     30/07/2001

H46-768       19279          Göçmen and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01               30/07/2001

H46-769       19285          Karabulut Cemile and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01   30/07/2001

H46-770       19303          Şen Celal and Keziban, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01           10/10/2001

H46-812       28505          Ülger, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                                28/06/2002

H46-813       29856          Özcan Mehmet, judgment of 09/04/02 – Friendly settlement                 09/07/2002

- 4 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-814       28883          McKerr, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[54]                                   04/11/01

H46-815       37715          Shanaghan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[55]                             04/11/01

H46-816       24746          Hugh Jordan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[56]                           04/11/01

H46-817       30054          Kelly and others, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[57]                      04/11/01

Table summarising the total number of cases by States

State	No confirmation of payment of the capital sum	No confirmation of payment of the capital sum although payment due since more than 6 months	Payment after expiration of the time-limit set and no confirmation of payment of the default interest due
Austria	1
Belgium			1
Cyprus	1
Finland	1
France	20	12	14
Greece	1		8
Hungary	2
Italy	141	54	279
Macedonia	1
Netherlands	1
Poland	5	6	1
Portugal	11	2	1
Roumania	9		1
Slovakia	1
Slovénia	1
Turkey	32	51	1
United Kindom	11	4

List of cases for which late information on payment of just satisfaction has been provided

up to 10 January 2003

(827th meeting, 11 and 12 February 2003, Sections 2, 3 and 4)

The information presented in the table below is the sole responsibility of the states concerned. Bearing in mind the date upon which this information was communicated to it, the Secretariat has not yet had the opportunity to check it. This will be done for the next meeting.

Liste d’affaires pour lesquelles des informations tardives sur le paiement de la satisfaction équitable ont été fournies jusqu’au 10 janvier 2003

(827e réunion, 11 et 12 février 2003, Rubriques 2, 3 et 4)

Les informations présentées dans le tableau ci-dessous relèvent de la seule responsabilité des Etats concernés. Compte tenu de la date de la transmission de ces informations, le Secrétariat n’a pas encore eu l’occasion de les vérifier. Cette vérification sera effectuée pour la prochaine réunion.

Item / Point	State / Etat	Application / Requête	Case/ Affaire	Section / Rubrique	Judgment of / Arrêt du	Final on / Définitif le
H46-67	A	33505	H.E.	2	11/07/02	06/11/02
H46-71	CY	51591	Markass Car Hire Ltd.	2	02/07/02	06/11/02
H46-95	SP	45238	Perote Pellon	2	25/07/02	25/10/02
H46-97	TR	25144	Sadak Selim and others / et autres	2	11/06/02	6/11//02
H46-121	CY	53594	Alithia Publising Company	3.a	11/07/02	11/10/02
H46-122	FIN	30013	Türkiye iş Bankasi	3.a	18/06/02	18/09/02
H46-135	F	47007	Arnal	3.a	19/03/02	19/06/02
H46-320	I	28272	Ghidotti	3.a	21/02/02	21/05/02
H46-632	SK	32106	Komanický	3.a	04/06/02	04/09/02
H46-634	TR	29289	Aydın Mehmet	3.a	16/07/02	16/07/02
H46-645	TR	37087	Bekmezci and others / et autres	3.a	27/06/02	27/06/02
H46-646	TR	20132	Bilgin Burhan	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-647	TR	20133	Bilgin Leyli	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-648	TR	20134	Bilgin Münir	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-650	TR	20136	Canlı	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-651	TR	20142	Günal Kazım	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-653	TR	30448	Önel Ahmet	3.a	23/05/02	23/08/02
H46-654	TR	30948	Önel Mehmet	3.a	23/05/02	23/08/02
H46-655	TR	30446	Önel Temur	3.a	23/05/02	23/08/02
H46-657	TR	30447	Özel Hacı Bayram	3.a	23/05/02	23/08/02
H46-658	TR	31964	Özel Hacı Osman	3.a	23/05/02	23/08/02
H46-660	TR	20153	Şen Ismet	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-661	TR	20156	Şen Kemal	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-662	TR	20154	Şen Mahmut	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-663	TR	20158	Taşdemir Mehmet (n° 2)	3.a	20/06/02	20/09/02
H46-670	UK	37471	Faulkner William (n° 2)	3.a	04/06/02	04/09/02
H46-677	UK	40302	Matthews Michael	3.a	15/07/02	15/07/02
H32-688	F	29877	Pauchet and others / et autres	3.b	28/02/98	28/02/98
H46-692	I	31143	Indelicato	3.b	18/10/01	18/01/02
H46-695	I	47247	Mercuri	3.b	11/04/02	11/04/02
H32-696	I	25249	Cazzorla & Gigante	3.b	16/02/96	16/02/96
H46-698	I	49372	De Pilla	3.b	25/10/01	25/01/02
H46-699	I	44446	Di Girolamo and others / et autres	3.b	25/10/01	25/01/02
H46-702	I	49314	Steiner & Hassid Steiner	3.b	06/12/01	06/03/02
H46-703	I	51671	Arrigoni	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-704	I	51678	Baioni & Badini	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-705	I	51667	Bertot	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-706	I	51696	Cappelletti & Dell'Agnese	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-709	I	51706	Mannari	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-710	I	51704	Rota Giacomo & Gianfranco	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-711	I	51705	Rota Roberto & Giuseppe	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-712	I	51710	Rossi Gianbattista	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-714	I	51670	Sordelli & C. S.n.c.	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-715	I	51711	Spanu	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-716	I	51673	Tiozzo Peschiero L. & L.	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-717	I	51707	Vanzetti	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-718	I	41803	Pupillo	3.b	18/12/01	18/03/02[58]
H32-724	I	15800	Perego & Romanet	3.b	12/01/94	12/01/94
H32-725	I	27189	Bevilacqua	3.b	21/07/97	21/07/97
H46-736	I	44346	Venturini Alberto II	3.b	25/10/01	25/01/02
H46-740	I	51677	Meneghini	3.b	11/12/01	11/03/02
H46-761	P	43999	Martins Serra & Andrade Cancio	3.b	06/12/01	06/03/02
H46-771	TR	19661	Çalkan Gülnahar	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-772	TR	19662	Çalkan Rabia	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-773	TR	19663	Çapar Ekrem	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-774	TR	19664	Çelebi Hamdi	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-775	TR	19665	Çalkan Seyfettin	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-776	TR	19666	Çapar Nuri	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-777	TR	19668	Dalgiç Hayrettin	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-778	TR	19669	Dalgiç Necati	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-779	TR	19670	Dişçi Dursun	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-780	TR	19671	Dişçi Hasan	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-781	TR	19672	Dişçi Osman	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-782	TR	19673	Güneysu Davut	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-783	TR	19674	Kartal Ali	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-784	TR	19675	Koç Hasan	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-785	TR	19676	Koçer Ayse	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-786	TR	19678	Öztürk Ali	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-787	TR	19679	Öztürk Gülfiye	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-788	TR	19681	Öztürk Kamil	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-789	TR	19682	Öztürk Muhsin	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-790	TR	19683	Öztürk Mustafa	3.b	05/06/01	05/09/01
H46-791	TR	19640	Akça Halim	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-792	TR	19641	Akçay Mehmet	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-793	TR	19642	Akkaya Ahmet	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-794	TR	19643	Akkaya İbrahim	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-795	TR	19644	Akkaya Mustafa	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-796	TR	19645	Balci Hüseyin	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-797	TR	19646	Balci Macit	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-798	TR	19647	Baltekin Bilge	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-799	TR	19648	Başar Halil	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-800	TR	19649	Başar Talip	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-801	TR	19650	Bilgin Ahmet	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-802	TR	19651	Bilgin Mahmut	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-803	TR	19652	Bilgin Mehmet II	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-804	TR	19653	Bilgiç Yusuf	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-805	TR	19654	Dinç Fethiye	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-806	TR	19655	Dokel Ünzile	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-807	TR	19656	Eğrikale Saadettin	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-808	TR	19657	Erol Naside II	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-809	TR	19658	Erol Recep	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-810	TR	19659	Erol Sefer	3.b	03/07/01	03/10/01
H46-811	TR	30492	Erat & Sağlam	3.b	26/03/02	26/03/02
H46-640	TR	29590	Yağmurdereli	3.a + 4.2	04/06/02	04/09/02

3.c               EXAMINATION OF SPECIAL PAYMENT PROBLEMS (FOR EXAMPLE THE DISAPPEARANCE OF THE APPLICANT, DISPUTES REGARDING THE EXACT AMOUNT PAID AS A RESULT OF EXCHANGE RATE PROBLEMS OR ADMINISTRATIVE FEES)

- 2 cases against Italy

H46-818       53708          Mas A. and 207 others, judgment of 07/06/01 – Friendly settlement

                                      Addendum General Questions

The case concerns the length of certain civil proceedings brought by haemophiliacs seeking compensation for damages suffered following blood transfusions infected with various viruses (complaints under Article 6§1). The proceedings in the present case are the same as those challenged in the cases A.B., E.F. and C.C. (Application No. 37874+, Interim Resolution DH(98)392), M.A. and 81 others (Application No. 44814+, Friendly settlement of 30/11/2000) and M.L. & 46 others (Application No. 53705, Friendly settlement of 05/04/2001).

Payment problems: The Court struck this case out of its list on the basis of a friendly settlement agreed between the parties according to which the Italian Government offered to pay to each of the 208 applicants certain sums, ranging from 5 000 000 Italian lire to 73 300 000 Italian lire (for a global sum of 9 687 800 000 Italian lire – see the detailed list available at the Registry of the Court) for non-pecuniary damages as well as, to all the applicants, the global sum of 80 000 000 Italian lire for costs and expenses. The payment took place between 5 and 9 November 2001, i.e. more than two months after the expiry of the time-limit set, namely the 7 September 2001. The payment of costs and expenses as well as of default interests due has not yet been made. A letter recalling the Committee of Ministers’ principles on payment of default interests was addressed to the Italian authorities on 30 January 2002.

Subsequently however, at the 783rd meeting (February 2002), the question of the application of default interests in the supervision of the execution of friendly settlements was raised in other cases; the Deputies instructed therefore the Secretariat to prepare a document summarising the considerations to be taken into account concerning this issue and agreed to resume its consideration at their 792nd meeting (16, 17 and 19 (3 p.m.) April 2002). Having not found an agreement, the Deputies decided to reconsider the matter at their 798th (June 2002), 803rd (July 2002), 810th (October 2002), 819th (December 2002) and 827th (February 2003) meetings (DH) in the light of written contributions that the Delegations would send to the Secretariat (see General Questions, item e. and Addendum General Questions).

H46-819       53705          M.L. and 46 others, judgment of 05/04/01 – Friendly settlement

                                      Addendum General Questions

The case concerns the length of certain civil proceedings brought by haemophiliacs seeking compensation for damages suffered following blood transfusions infected with various viruses (complaints under Article 6§1). The proceedings in the present case are the same as those challenged in the cases A.B., E.F. and C.C. (Application No. 37874+, Interim Resolution DH(98)392), M.A. and 81 others (Application No. 44814+, Friendly settlement of 30/11/2000) and Mas. A. & 207 others (Application No. 53708, Friendly settlement of 07/06/2001).

Payment problems: The Court struck this case out of its list on the basis of a friendly settlement agreed between the parties according to which the Italian Government offered to pay to each of the 47 applicants certain sums, ranging from 15 000 000 Italian lire to 75 000 000 Italian lire (for a global sum of 1 910 000 000 Italian lire – see the detailed list available at the Registry of the Court) for non-pecuniary damages as well as, to all the applicants, the global sum of 20 000 000 Italian lire for costs and expenses. Although the Government had undertaken to pay these sums before 5 July 2001, the payment of costs and expenses has not yet been made, while the other sums were in fact paid between 11 and 13 September 2001, i.e. with a delay of more than two months. The Italian authorities have argued that no default interest is due because the friendly settlement did not include any clause on the subject: the applicants’ counsel has accordingly invited the Committee of Ministers to express its views on the lawfulness of such a position. At the 775th meeting (December 2001), it was recalled that, according to the practice of the Committee of Ministers, the payment of default interest was due whenever the payment took place more than three months after the date at which the judgment became final. This also applies to friendly settlements, unless the parties have explicitly agreed different terms. A letter recalling these principles was addressed to the Italian authorities on 30 January 2002.

Section 3.c

Subsequently however, at the 783rd meeting (February 2002), the question of the application of default interests in the supervision of the execution of friendly settlements was raised in other cases; the Deputies instructed therefore the Secretariat to prepare a document summarising the considerations to be taken into account concerning this issue and agreed to resume its consideration at their 792nd meeting (16, 17 and 19 (3 p.m.) April 2002). Having not found an agreement, the Deputies decided to reconsider the matter at their 798th (June 2002), 803rd (July 2002), 810th (October 2002), 819th (December 2002) and 827th (February 2003) meetings (DH) in the light of written contributions that the Delegations would send to the Secretariat (see General Questions, item e. and Addendum General Questions).

- 37 cases against Turkey

H46-820       28635+        Aksoy Ibrahim, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01[59]

H46-821       30947          Alpay, judgment of 27/02/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-822       26093+        B.T. and others, judgment of 14/11/00 – Friendly settlement

H46-823       28340          Büyükdağ, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-824       25182+        Cankoçak, judgment of 20/02/01, final on 20/05/01

H46-825       25724          Cihan, judgment of 30/01/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-826       31963          Özel and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-827       26680          Şener, judgment of 18/07/00[60]

H46-828       27697+        Yaşar and others, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

H46-829       19310          Yilmaz Hamit, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01

H46-830       19308          Yilmaz Zekeriya, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01

H46-831       26976+        Sürek Kamil Tekin V, judgment of 16/07/2002 - Friendly settlement[61]

In these cases the applicants and/or the Secretariat have identified various problems relating to the payment of just satisfaction. These problems concern mostly more or less substantial shortfalls in payment, due among other things to currency conversion and/or delays in payment (default interest).

The Turkish authorities have undertaken to examine these problems with a view to settling the outstanding amounts due in accordance with the Court’s judgments. Information is awaited on the progress made to that effect.

H54-832       22729          Kaya Mehmet, judgment of 19/02/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H54-833       21893          Akdivar, Çiçek, Aktaş, Karabulut, judgment of 16/09/96, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H54-834       23178          Aydin, judgment of 25/09/97, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H54-835       24276          Kurt, judgment of 25/05/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H54-836       23818          Ergi, judgment of 28/07/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H54-837       22495          Yaşa, judgment of 02/09/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-838       23657          Çakici, judgment of 08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-839       23763          Tanrikulu, judgment of 08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-840       23144          Özgür Gündem, judgment of 16/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106[62]

H46-841       22535          Kaya Mahmut, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-842       22492          Kiliç, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-843       20764          Ertak Ismail, judgment of 09/05/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-844       23531          Timurtaş, judgment of 13/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

Section 3.c

H46-845       21986          Salman, judgment of 27/06/00 – Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-846       22277          Ilhan Nasir, judgment of 27/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H32-847       23179+        Yilmaz, Ovat, Şahin et Dündar, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H32-848       25658          Aslantaş Sedat, Interim Resolutions DH(99)560 and ResDH(2001)106[63]

H46-849       22947+        Akkoç Nebahat, judgment of 10/10/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-850       24396          Taş Beşir, judgment of 14/11/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-851       23819          Bilgin İhsan, judgment of 16/11/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-852       22676          Gül Mehmet, judgment of 14/12/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-853       25801          Dulaş Zubeyde, judgment of 30/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-854       22493          Berktay, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-855       24490          Şarli, judgment of 22/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-856       23954          Akdeniz and others, judgment of 31/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

In these 25 cases, the applicants, their representatives and the Secretariat have raised various problems relating to the payment of just satisfaction. These problems concern mostly more or less substantial shortfalls in payment. The total shortfall claimed by the applicants in these 25 cases amounts to more than 250 000 pounds sterling (including default interest).

During the examination of these cases in the Committee of Ministers, some concerns have been expressed about the comprehensive and persistent shortfalls in payment of just satisfaction and Turkey has been invited to remedy this problem urgently.

Following a bilateral meeting held in Strasbourg on 18/02/2002 between the Secretariat and a delegation from Ankara, the Turkish authorities’ presented in April 2002 their own calculations in each of the outstanding cases. In many cases the shortfalls acknowledged by the authorities coincide with the figures submitted by the applicants (including the default interest and restitution of a stamp duty erroneously deducted from the payments). However, in some of the cases the calculations differ notably as the payment was not effectuated as prescribed by the Court as regards the place and/or the currency of payment.

On 07/06/2002, the applicants’ representatives responded to the Governments’ calculations by maintaining and further substantiating the sums claimed.

Having examined the parties’ communications, the Secretariat has sent on 14/11/2002 a letter to the Turkish authorities inviting them to proceed to pay the 10 cases in which the shortfalls acknowledged by the authorities correspond to the sums dues. At the 819th meeting (December 2002) the Turkish authorities announced that they would pay these sums shortly. However, no confirmation of payment has so far been received.

As regards the 15 other cases, the shortfalls acknowledged by the Turkish authorities are lower than the actual shortfalls found with reference to the sums granted under the Court's judgments. The Secretariat remains in contact with the Turkish authorities to provide them with the necessary details allowing the payment in conformity with the judgments.

SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTION
(INDIVIDUAL MEASURES, MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS)

(See Addendum 4 for part or all these cases)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise the progress made in the adoption of the implementing measures in the following cases raising several problems. Supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will be issued in Addendum 4. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these items on a case-by-case basis.

                   SUB-SECTION 4.1 – SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUAL MEASURES ONLY[64]

- 1 case against France

H46-857       57753          C.K., judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

The case relates to the excessive length of compensation proceedings before administrative courts, introduced by the first applicant, her parents and her brother, the first applicant having discovered after a blood transfusion that she had been infected with the human immunodeficiency virus and with the hepatitis C virus (violation of Article 6§1). These proceedings, which began on 23 March 1998, were still pending when the European Court rendered its judgment having at that date lasted more than 3 years, 10 months.

Individual measures: accelerating the proceedings.

- 1 case against Germany

H46-858       46544          Kutzner, judgment of 26/02/2002, final on 10/07/2002

The case concerns in particular the fact that decisions of German courts withdrawing the applicants’ parental authority in respect of their two daughters constituted interference in their right to respect for their family life (violation of Article 8). On 12/02/1997, the guardianship tribunal decided provisionally to withdraw the applicants' rights to choose where the children lived and to make decisions concerning the need for medical measures. At that time, the children were six and four years old. On 27/05/1997, the tribunal entirely withdrew the applicants' parental authority over their two children.

Individual measures: the German Government has informed the Committee that they are currently considering possible individual measures. The local authority convened a meeting on 08/08/2002 inviting the administration, the guardian, the parents, legal counsellors and human rights NGOs involved in this case. Furthermore, an expert was appointed to examine whether and under what circumstances the children could be returned to their biological family without risk. The expert was to begin work in December 2002. Information awaited.

General measures: the judgment of the European Court has been published in the Europäische Grundrechte Zeitschrift (Volume 2002, pp. 244-251) and transmitted to all authorities concerned.

- 1 case against Italy

H46-883      37119          N.F., judgment of 02/08/2001, final on 12/12/2001[65]

The case notably concerns an unlawful interference with the freedom of association of the applicant, a judge, on account of a disciplinary sanction imposed on him in 1994 because of his belonging to a Masonic association. The Court considered that the sanction was not “foreseeable” or “prescribed by the law” because the provisions at its basis (namely, Article 18 of Royal Decree No. 511 of 31/05/1946 combined with a 1990 directive of the Supreme Judicial Board) were not clear enough (violation of Article 11).

A new directive, clearly establishing the incompatibility of membership of Masonic associations with the exercise of judicial functions was issued in 1993 (when the procedure against the applicant had already started). The applicant indicated his wish that the disciplinary proceedings be reviewed and drew attention to Article 37§6 of the 1946 Decree, which may allow for such a revision (see §42 of the judgment).

Individual measures: Information is expected on the follow-up given by the Supreme Judicial Board (C.S.M.) to the applicant’s request for revision of the impugned disciplinary procedure.

General measures: the Italian authorities indicated that the judgment would be published in Quaderni, the legal journal of the Supreme Judicial Board (C.S.M.)

Sub-section 4.1

- 3 cases against the United Kingdom

H54-859       19187          Saunders, judgment of 17/12/96, Interim Resolution DH(2000)27

H46-860       29522+        I.J.L., G.M.R. and A.K.P., judgment of 19/09/00

These cases concern the violation of the applicants’ right not to incriminate themselves and thus their right to a fair trial in that, at their trials, the prosecution made use of statements given earlier, under legal compulsion and in different proceedings, to Department of Trade and Industry Inspectors (violations of Article 6§1). After the Deputies had decided, on the basis of the information available at the time, to mandate the Secretariat to draft a resolution with a view to closing the examination of the first case, a complaint dated 15/04/2002 was received from the applicants to the effect that they have so far been unable to obtain redress.

Individual measures: The applicants complain in particular of certain obstacles recently encountered in the proceedings they have engaged in order to have their convictions re-examined and overturned following the European Court’s judgments. In support of their request, the applicants make a number of points, including the following:

Following the European Court’s judgments, their case was referred to the Court of Appeal for new examination by the Criminal Cases Review Commission, as the latter had found that there was a real possibility that the Court of Appeal might not uphold the convictions because of the decisions of the European Court.

However, while their case was pending before the Court of Appeal, the House of Lords held in another case concerning a situation which had not been brought before the European Court, that the right to rely on Convention rights in any legal proceedings guaranteed by the Human Rights Act did not have retroactive effect (i.e. before 02/10/2000). In a subsequent judgment, also adopted while the proceedings before the Court of Appeal in the present cases were pending, the House of Lords reached the opposite conclusion but found that, in the interest of judicial certainty, the erroneous construction in its first judgment should not be overturned.

In its decision of 21/12/2001, the Court of Appeal notably indicated that”…if we concluded that we were bound to give effect to the Strasbourg Court’s decision that the trial was unfair by examining anew the safety of the convictions, we would not uphold the convictions on the basis that they are safe in any event” (§47). However, the Court of Appeal did not find itself so bound under Article 46 of the Convention (especially §§50‑53). Neither did it uphold any other ground of appeal. Accordingly, it concluded that the convictions were safe and dismissed the appeal (§86). The applicants sought leave to appeal to the House of Lords.

On 11/02/2002, the Court of Appeal certified that the appeal raised a point of law of general public importance, namely whether the House of Lords decision not to give retroactive effect to the Human Rights Act also covers the situation where the United Kingdom is under the obligation by virtue of Article 46 of the Convention to abide by the European Court’s judgment. On 09/03/2002, the House of Lords granted leave to appeal. The applicants indicate that the case is listed for hearing on 09/10/2002.

At the 798th meeting (June 2002) the Representative of the United Kingdom objected to the applicants’ request for an adjournment, referring notably to the following considerations: the authorities have done all that was required by the Court’s judgment (payment of just satisfaction and legislative reform to prevent recurrence of the violations found). Even if reopening of proceedings is a desirable measure in certain circumstances, the Convention does not require such a measure in all circumstances, and in particular not in respect of cases such as the applicants’. No question had indeed been raised before in these cases regarding any necessity of reopening the proceedings. Moreover, a requirement to reopen or to quash the applicants’ convictions could risk opening the floodgates to reopening requests in respect of cases in which there had been, or might have been, a violation of a Convention right at trial many years ago, something that would risk undermining the “controlled introduction” of the Convention rights into domestic law achieved through the Human Rights Act. Furthermore, the adjournment request appeared primarily to be an attempt to bolster the arguments run domestically. If the appeal failed, this might, however, possibly give raise to an allegation of a fresh violation of the Convention. Such a complaint should, however, be pursued through the ordinary procedure before the European Court. In conclusion the Representative urged the Committee to agree to the closure of the cases.

Sub-section 4.1

At the 810th meeting (October 2002), the Deputies decided not to close the cases but to pursue their examination and to resume consideration of the discussion at their 819th meeting (December 2002) with a view to examining the individual measures to be taken, in the light of the outcome of the proceedings pending before the House of Lords.

At the 819th meeting (December 2002), the United Kingdom Delegation informed the Deputies that the House of Lords had not granted the re-opening of the proceedings. It was noted that if the House of Lords had reconsidered the question of the applicants’ guilt in the light of the violations of their right to a fair trial, the decision would appear acceptable. However the House of Lords’ reasoning would have to be examined before reaching a conclusion. The Deputies accordingly decided to resume consideration of the cases at the present meeting. Having examined the judgment of the House of Lords (http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200203/ldjudgmt/jd021114/lyons-1.htm, copies available to delegations on request) the Secretariat finds that the House of Lords appears to have rejected the appeal solely on the basis of the law as it stood without taking into account the violations of Article 6 of the Convention. The question of individual measures would thus remain outstanding.

The House of Lords in its judgment of 14/11/2002 notably concluded that courts were obliged to examine the safety of convictions according to the law as it stood at the time of the trial (see §16,17,18, 29, 34, 59, 82, 96, 100 of the judgment). At the time of the trial, Section 434(5) of the Companies Act 1985 admitted answers given under compulsory questioning as evidence although this was later found by the European Court in the present cases to violate Article 6 of the Convention. This provision was changed by Parliament by the 1999 Act which came into force on 14/04/2000. However, the House of Lords found that Parliament had no intention to give retroactive effect either to the Act of 1999 or to the Human Rights Act 1998 (see § 18, 63, 81, 98 of the judgment). Besides, the House recalled that it was established in the cases of R v Lambert(2001) 3 WLR 206 and R v Kansal (no.2)(2002) 2 AC 69 that a person who had been convicted at a trial which took place before the entry into force of the Human Rights Act (namely 2/10/2000) could not rely on the rights given by that Act in appeal against a conviction even if lodged after that date(see § 12, 18, 25, 61, 99 of the judgment).Finally, the House held that the domestic law of the UK did not permit the quashing of convictions by reason only of the admission of the evidence in question (see §108 of the judgment) and unanimously dismissed the appeal brought by the applicants.

The applicants have requested the Committee of Ministers to invite the United Kingdom to indicate what measures it intends to take to achieve, as far as possible, restitutio in integrum in their cases.

General measures: The legislative amendments announced in Interim Resolution DH(2000)27 have been adopted.

H46-861       36533          Atlan A. and T., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01

The case concerns the absence of a fair trial in that, in criminal proceedings against the applicants, the prosecution repeatedly denied the existence of evidence pertinent to a central issue of the defence and, without the knowledge or approval of the judge, decided that this evidence should not be disclosed to the judge or to the defence (violation of Article 6§1).

In 1991, the applicants were convicted of importing cocaine and sentenced to 18 and 13 years’ imprisonment respectively. The second applicant died in 1998.

The case presents similarities to that of Rowe and Davis against the United Kingdom (judgment of 16/02/2000), which was transferred to Section 6 following the adoption of general and individual measures (reopening of proceedings, quashing convictions) by the United Kingdom.

Individual measures: At the 775th meeting (November 2001) the Government was asked whether this case would be reviewed by the Criminal Cases Review Board as in the Rowe and Davis case. At the 819th meeting (December 2002), the United Kingdom Delegation indicated that the Board did not allow the surviving applicant to have his conviction reviewed before the competent court of appeal. The text of the Board’s decision was requested in order to assess the reasoning used and whether the merits of the case were taken into account.

                   SUB-SECTION 4.2 – INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

- 1 case against Austria

H46-862       32636          A.T., judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

The case concerns the lack of a public hearing in two sets of proceedings concerning the applicant’s compensation claims under the Media Act following the publication of statements against him in the weekly publication News (violation of Article 6§1).

General measures: The judgment of the European Court was published in ÖIMR-Newsletter 2002/No.2. At the 810th meeting (October 2002), information was requested on the measures envisaged in respect of the lack of a public hearing during the proceedings under the Media Act.

- 2 cases against Bulgaria

H46-863       50963          Al-Nashif and others, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

The case concerns the deportation of the first applicant, a stateless person, to Syria on 4 July 1999. The European Court considered that there had been a violation of the applicants’ right to family life inasmuch as the applicable legal provisions did not give sufficient guarantees against arbitrariness, the first applicant having been deported on the basis of considerations of national security exclusively within the discretionary power of the Minister of the Interior (violation of Article 8). The Court further found that the applicants had not had access to an effective remedy in this respect (violation of Article 13). The case finally concerns the fact that the first applicant had, under the applicable law, been given no opportunity to challenge the lawfulness of his detention while awaiting deportation (violation of Article 5§4).

Individual measures: By letter of 02/12/2002, the applicant's lawyer indicated that he had introduced an application to reopen the judicial proceedings before the Supreme Administrative Court with a view to lifting the ban on his entry to Bulgaria. At the 819th meeting (December 2002), the Bulgarian authorities were invited to keep the Committee informed of the outcome of these proceedings and of other possible measures taken to erase the consequences for the applicant of the violations found by the Court.

General measures: At the 819th meeting (December 2002), the attention of the Bulgarian authorities was drawn to a number of problems in the legislation and regulations which were the basis of the violations found by the European Court in the present case (see notably Articles 46 and 47 of the Aliens Law). Particular attention was drawn to the fact that Bulgarian law does not provide for judicial review of the lawfulness of aliens' detention in case of their expulsion on the grounds of national security (cf. Court's finding under Article 5§4). The Bulgarian authorities have thus been invited to bring the domestic law in line with the Convention so as effectively to prevent new violations similar to those found in the present judgment. It was suggested that the experience of other countries which had been confronted with similar problems in the past be taken into account in planning and adopting the general measures in this case (eg. Chahal against the United Kingdom, judgment of 15/11/1996, Resolution ResDH(2001)119).

H46-864       38361          Anguelova, judgment of 13/06/2002, final on 13/09/2002[66]

Sub-section 4.2

- 2 cases against Cyprus

H46-865       30873          Egmez, judgment of 21/12/00

The case mainly concerns the inhuman treatment inflicted upon the applicant by state officials during his arrest before being admitted to hospital in Larnaca (violation of Article 3) and the absence of an effective remedy in this respect (violation of Article 13). On 01/12/1995, the Attorney General filed at the Nicosia District Court a nolle prosequi in the applicant’s case, in accordance with Article 113.2 of the Constitution. The applicant was released on the same day. On 04/12/1995, the Nicosia District Court discharged the applicant.

Individual measures: The applicant’s lawyer sent a letter to the Secretariat on 19/04/2001 raising several questions about the need to adopt individual measures in this case. In May 2001 the Secretariat forwarded a copy of the letter to the Cypriot authorities. The latter confirmed that they were presently examining the measures that might need to be taken in respect of this case and indicated that the Secretariat would be kept informed in written form of any development in this field.

On 26/09/2002, the Secretariat received a letter from the applicant’s lawyer requesting among other things precise information about the measures presently under examination by the Cypriot authorities. He also requested information as to whether the Attorney-General had instituted criminal proceedings against the officers involved and, if that is not the case, what reasons had been given. Finally, he requested that a copy of his letter be made available to all the Deputies.

General measures: As in the Denizci & others case, also examined under section 4.2, the Cypriot authorities have informed the Committee of Ministers that the judgment of the European Court was disseminated to all institutions concerned (judicial and also police/security forces, Attorney General’s Office, Ombudsman, Cyprus Bar Association). The Ministry of Justice and Ministry of the Interior have requested that appropriate instructions be prepared and distributed to all state officials in order to avoid any future cases of ill-treatment. Instructions prepared by the Attorney General have also been distributed to all authorities concerned. Finally, the judgment has received extensive media coverage in Cyprus. Information about its publication has been requested.

Furthermore, sections 242-243 of the Criminal Code and related parts of the Code of Criminal Procedure have been amended taking into account the findings of the European Court. However, further legislative measures are envisaged. The Cypriot authorities have transmitted to the Secretariat, in written form, details of the above-mentioned information in Greek. An English summary was also transmitted to the Secretariat on 04/10/2002.

The Committee has asked, whether, as far as the violation of Article 13 is concerned and in the light of §§71 and 99 of the Court’s judgment, the Cypriot authorities envisage the adoption of specific measures in order to guarantee that similar violations do not recur.

On 31 October 2002, a bilateral meeting took place between the Cypriot Delegation and the Secretariat. At the meeting, the Secretariat has signalled the issues for which clarifications are needed, and has requested to have this, if possible, in time for the examination of the Egmez and Denizci cases at the 819th meeting.

At the time of preparing this document, no information had been received by the Secretariat.

H46-866       25316+        Denizci and others, judgment of 23/05/01, final on 23/08/01

The case concerns in particular the fact that the applicants (and in the case of the ninth applicant, her son) were subjected to ill-treatment considered inhuman by the European Court (violation of Article 3), that they have been victims of unlawful arrest and detention (violation of Article 5§1) and that they have been subjected to restrictions on their freedom of movement (violation of Article 2 of Protocol No. 4).

Individual measures: The Cypriot authorities have stated that the applicants were released from detention. The Committee has asked whether the investigation proceedings, which started in 1995, are still open (§23 of the judgment of the European Court).

Sub-section 4.2

General measures: The Cypriot authorities have informed the Committee of Ministers that the judgment of the European Court was disseminated to all institutions concerned (judicial and also the police force/security forces, the Attorney General’s Office, the Ombudsman, the Cyprus Bar Association). The Ministry of Justice and Ministry of the Interior have requested that appropriate instructions be prepared and distributed to all State officials in order to avoid any future cases of ill-treatment. Instructions prepared by the Attorney General have also been distributed to all authorities concerned. Finally, the judgment has received extensive media coverage in Cyprus. Exact references as to its publication and the dissemination have been requested. The Cypriot authorities have transmitted to the Secretariat, in written form, details of the above-mentioned information in Greek.

Furthermore, sections 242-243 of the Criminal Code and related parts of the code of criminal proceedings were already amended taking into account the findings of the European Court. However, further legislative measures are envisaged. An English summary was also transmitted to the Secretariat on 04/10/2002.

On 30 October 2002, a bilateral meeting took place between the Cypriot Delegation and the Secretariat. At the meeting, the Secretariat has identified the issues for which clarifications are needed, and has requested to have this, if possible, in time for the examination of the Egmez and Denizci cases at the 819th meeting.

At the time of preparing this document, no information had been received by the Secretariat.

- 5 cases against Croatia

H46-867       54727          Cerin, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02

H46-868       52634          Futterer, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-869       51585          Horvat, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-870       49706          Rajak, judgment of 28/06/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-871       48771          Delić, judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

These cases concern the excessive length of certain civil proceedings, which lasted more than 17, 11, 6 and 25 years respectively concerning the first four cases and the Court’s jurisdiction for these cases, taking into account the date of Croatia’s accession to the Convention, extends respectively to 3 years and 11 months; 3 years and 10 months; 3 years and 8 months, and 3 years and 7 months (violations of Article 6§1).

The Delić case concerns several sets of proceedings, most of which have lasted about nine years, of which a period of about 4 years and 6 months falls to be examined by the Court, except a set of proceedings which lasted almost 6 years (of which a period of 1 year, 11 months and 10 days falls to be examined by the Court) and another set which lasted almost 8 years (of which a period of 3 years, 10 months and 12 days falls to be examined by the Court).

The Horvat and the Delic cases also concern the lack of an effective remedy in domestic law, since the formal institution of proceedings upon a complaint lodged with the Constitutional Court depended on the discretion of the latter (violation of Article 13).

Individual measures: In the Rajak case the proceedings were ended by a final judgment of 25/09/2002. In the other cases, the proceedings are still pending and further information is awaited.

General measures: The judgments of the European Court have already been translated, and disseminated to domestic courts. They have also been published on the official Internet site of the Government www.vlada.hr/dokumenti.html and in legal journals.

As regards the violation of Article 13, a new Act amending the Constitutional Act on the Constitutional Court entered into force on 15/03/2002. Section 63 of the Constitutional Act, introduced by this act, provides inter alia that the Constitutional Court must examine a constitutional complaint even before all legal remedies have been exhausted, in cases where a competent court has not decided within a reasonable time a claim concerning the applicant’s rights and obligations, or a criminal charge against him. If the Constitutional Court finds the complaint well-founded it must set a time-limit for deciding the case on the merits and it shall also award compensation for the excessive length of proceedings. In the Radoš case (judgment of 07/11/2002) and in the admissibility decisions in the cases of Jeftić, Plaftak and others, Nogolica and Slaviček, (Applications Nos. 57576/00, 76687/01, 77784/01 and 20862/02 respectively), the European Court found that this new Section provided an effective remedy in respect of complaints concerning excessive length of proceedings.

Sub-section 4.2

The Croatian Government adopted the “Strategy for the Reform of the Judicial System”, a document setting the short-term and long-term objectives for overall judicial reform. The Strategy is intended to be implemented before the end of 2007.

As regards the violation of Article 6§1, a reform of the Act on Civil Procedure is under way. The relevant draft law sets out to reconstruct the system on new principles, but also aims to prevent the abuse of procedural rights and strengthen procedural discipline. The courts’ comments on this draft have been studied by the Ministry of Justice. The draft law has been sent to the Parliament for adoption. Further information on the progress of this draft is awaited.

- 1 case against Finland

H46-872       28856          Jokela, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 21/08/2002

The case concerns an infringement to the applicants’ general right to peaceful enjoyment of their possessions. A piece of land owned by the spouse and father of the applicants (since deceased) was subject to expropriation. The market value of the land for the expropriation compensation was fixed at 7,50 Finnish Marks per square meter, despite the applicants’ contestations. However, when assessing the inheritance tax to be paid by the applicants for the land at issue, its market value was fixed at 20 Finnish Marks per square meter. The Court considered that the applicants could legitimately expect a reasonably consistent approach from the relevant authorities and the courts in determining the market value of the land or, in the absence of such consistency, an adequate explanation for the different valuations. In this case, there was neither consistency nor explanation for the lack of it (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

General measures: The Finnish authorities have been invited to provide information on their thinking concerning the adequate explanation of how such differences in estimating the market value of land can arise and what measures they envisage in order to avoid them.

- 4 cases against France

H46-152       39594          Kress, judgment of 07/06/01 – Grand Chamber[67]

H46-873       38436          APBP, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

                                      Addendum 4

These cases concern infringements of the right to a fair trial on account of the Government Commissioner’s participation in the deliberations of the trial bench in proceedings before the Conseil d’Etat (violations of Article 6§1). The Government Commissioner actually takes no part in voting within the trial bench, as he has already expressed his submissions on the case orally during the hearing. He attends the deliberations and answers, if necessary, any question which might be put to him. On this point, the Court considered that the advantage for the bench of this purely technical assistance by the Government Commissioner in the deliberations “is to be weighed against the higher interest of the litigant, who must have a guarantee that the Government Commissioner cannot, through his presence to influence their outcome.” (see § 85 of the Kress judgment).

The Kress case also concerns the excessive length (10 years, 1 month, 8 days) of the proceedings before administrative courts (violation of Article 6§1).

General measures adopted: the French delegation had sent to the Secretariat a copy of the memorandum addressed to Government Commissioners by the Président de la section du contentieux of the Conseil d’Etat (see Addendum 4), in which it is in particular explained that they may continue to attend deliberations on condition that they do not take the initiative of speaking during the deliberations. The Secretariat considers that this interpretation does not take fully into account the reasoning of the Court (see §§ 81 to 85 of the Kress judgment), and does not prevent new, similar violations.

Sub-section 4.2

H46-874       36515          Fretté, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

The case concerns the unfairness of certain proceedings before the Conseil d’Etat. According to the practice in force at the time of the facts, the applicant, who was not represented, was not summonsed to the hearing; he did not have the opportunity to be informed of the submissions of the Government commissioner and therefore could not answer them. He was thus denied a fair hearing of his case in adversarial proceedings (violation of Article 6§1).

General measures: Since 01/01/2001, all parties have been notified of hearing dates. Following the memorandum presented in the Kress case (q.v., Section 4.2), information concerning concrete measures adopted by the Conseil d’Etat with regard to litigants in person are awaited.

H46-875       36436          Piron, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

The case concerns the excessive length of certain proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations regarding consolidation of parcels of land, before administrative courts. When the Court issued its judgment, these proceedings had already lasted, for the purposes of the Convention, 26 years, 5 months and were still pending (violation of Article 6§1).

The case also concerns an infringement of the applicant’s right to the peaceful enjoyment of her possessions, as she had been deprived of a part of her property in consequence of the same proceedings, without obtaining adequate compensation (i.e. for being deprived of her property and for damages resulting from the length of this privation) within a reasonable time (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

Individual measures: It has been suggested, since the first examination of the case at the 749th meeting (April 2001), that a particular attention be paid to closing the case at national level (the proceedings lasted 26 years and 5 months for the purposes of the Convention, but actually more than 35 years). At the 764th meeting (September 2001), the Representative of France stated that the case was pending before the Conseil d’Etat. The judgment of the European Court recalls that it was for national tribunals to evaluate the material damage. By a letter dated 13/06/2002, the Representative of France stated that the case was still pending before the Conseil d’Etat because the applicant was not satisfied with the sum proposed by the competent authority (Commission d’aménagement foncier).

General measures: Information has been requested, most recently at the 819th meeting, concerning the running and the workload of commissions responsible for consolidating parcels of land. This information is awaited.

- 1 case against Germany

H46-876       33900          P.S., judgment of 20/12/2001, final on 04/09/2002[68]

This case concerns the violation of the applicant’s right to a fair trial in that he was unable to question or to have questioned the principal prosecution witness. The applicant was convicted on 10 January 1994 of a sexual offence against a child and sentenced to seven months’ imprisonment suspended (violation of Article 6§3d taken in conjunction with Article 6§1).

Individual measures: The German authorities were asked whether it would be possible to mention the conclusion of the judgment of the European Court in the applicant’s criminal record.

General measures: The judgment of the European Court has been disseminated to the judicial authorities concerned; publication of the judgment still to be confirmed.

- 1 case against Greece

H46-877       47541          Vasilopoulou, judgment of 21/03/02, final on 21/06/02[69]

Sub-section 4.2

- 2 cases against Ireland

H46-880       36887          Quinn, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-881       34720          Heaney and McGuinness, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

These cases concern in particular the failure to respect the applicants’ right to remain silent and not to incriminate themselves (violation of Article 6§1) and the consequent breach of the presumption of their innocence (violation of Article 6§2). The applicants, remanded in custody on suspicion of having committed terrorist acts, were initially informed by the police that they had the right to remain silent. However, charges subsequently laid against them included that of refusing to answer questions under the terms of Article 52 of the 1939 Offences against the State Act. In the subsequent criminal proceedings, they were found not guilty of the substantive charges but convicted and sentenced (June 1991 in the Heaney & McGuinness case, and May 1997 in the Quinn case) to six months’ imprisonment for having refused to answer questions while on remand, under the terms of the above-mentioned Article 52.

Individual measures: The applicant in the Quinn case has brought proceedings, which are pending before the High Court, seeking inter alia to have his conviction quashed. As regards the Heaney & McGuinness case, the Court of Criminal Appeal has not received any communication from the applicants’ solicitors with a view to taking any procedural steps necessary to determine the appeal. Information as to the outcome of the proceedings at the domestic level in the Quinn case has been requested.

The Secretariat has requested information on any individual measure envisaged e.g. the deletion of the conviction or, at least, the annotation of the records with the conclusion of the judgment of the European Court in the applicants’ criminal records.

General measures: the Irish authorities have informed the Committee of Ministers that under the Good Friday Peace Agreement of 10 April 1998, reforms of the Offences against the State Act 1939 are envisaged. In this respect the Minister of Justice, Equality and Law Reform has established a committee to examine all aspects of the 1939 Acts and to report to the Minister with recommendations for reform. The final report of the Review Group on the 1939 Offences Against the State Act was submitted to the Minister for Justice, Equality and Law reform at the beginning of 2002. A copy of the Report was submitted to the Secretariat in August 2002. In Chapter VIII of the Report (pp 183 to 212), the problems raised under the Quinn and Heaney & McGuinness cases have been extensively examined by the committee, which has recommended, inter alia, that section 52 of the 1939 Act and section 2 of the 1972 Act (having amended the 1939 Act) the be repealed. The Committee of Ministers has asked to be kept informed of any development in this field, in particular whether following the recommendations of the review committee, the Irish authorities envisaged the introduction of amendments to the existing legislation. Finally, the judgments of the European Court are now accessible on the Irish Courts Service website (www.courts.ie) and are also available in legal libraries.

- 17 cases against Italy

H46-882       35972          Grande Oriente d’Italia di Palazzo Giustiniani, judgment of 02/08/01,

                                      final on 12/12/01[70]

The case notably concerns a disproportionate interference with the freedom of association of the applicant, an Italian Masonic association affiliated to the Universal Freemasons, on account of the obligation for candidates to public offices in the Marches region to declare that they are not members of the Freemasons. The European Court concluded that this restriction, established by Article 5 of Marches Regional Law No. 34 of 1996, was not necessary in a democratic society nor was it justified by the character of the public office concerned by the law (violation of Article 11).

General measures: the attention of the Italian authorities was drawn to the need to modify or abrogate Article 5§2, point (e) of Marches Regional Law No. 34/1996. The question was also raised of whether similar provisions existed in other regional laws. The Italian authorities were furthermore invited to ensure the publication of the judgment of the European Court.

Sub-section 4.2

H32-884       23924          C.A.R. srl, Interim Resolution DH(98)154

The case concerns the fact that the applicant company was unable, for a three-year period between 1991 and 1994, to secure the eviction of tenants for non-payment of rent despite the fact that it had obtained a court order to that effect. The Prefect of Latium refused to provide police assistance to evict a group of Somali refugees illegally occupying buildings belonging to the applicant company. It also concerns the absence of compensation from the State for the financial damage the applicant company suffered as a result of the authorities’ inaction.

On 18/06/1998, the Deputies decided, accepting the reasoning of the Commission, that there had been a violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1: the Prefect’s refusal could be considered justified in the general interest but the violation was due to the absence of a right of compensation for the prejudice suffered in terms of both unpaid rent and damage to the property during the period of non-execution, in connection with the refugee’s occupation of the property until the administrative authorities had found them alternative accommodation.

General measures: Information has been requested with regard to the general measures envisaged in order to ensure a right to compensation in cases similar to that of C.A.R., notably in the light of the decision of the Rome Court of Appeal of 16/05/2000, rejecting the applicant’s request for reparation of the prejudice suffered. At the 819th meeting, a copy of this judgment was requested.

H32-885       22716          P.G. II, Interim Resolutions DH(97)18 and ResDH(2002)58

                                      Addendum 4

The case concerns the impossibility in Italian law to rehabilitate a person declared bankrupt before a minimum 5-year term has expired. The applicant was accordingly refused an earlier rehabilitation, in spite of the fact that he had been declared bankrupt while he was a minor and de facto had no appointed guardian or legal representative (violation of Article 8).

General measures: the need for legislative changes has been raised since 1998: it has been suggested that the law should be made more flexible to allow for exceptions, subject to judicial supervision, in cases such as this. By letter of 26/06/2000, the Italian Delegation informed the Secretariat that the period of incapacity imposed on bankrupts would probably be modified, in the context of an envisaged reform of the bankruptcy law. The attention of the Italian authorities was drawn, however, to the fact that it was not the length of the period of incapacity that was at issue in this case, but the rigidity of the system, leaving no discretion to authorise derogation in special circumstances. In addition the publication of the Commission’s report was requested, but has not yet been confirmed. By letter of 18/02/2002, the Italian authorities indicated that, in January 2002, the legislative Office of the Italian Ministry of Justice had transmitted the decision in the case P.G. II to the President of a Commission set up to draft new bankruptcy legislation, pointing out the necessity of incorporating in the draft provisions that will allow Italy to comply with its obligations resulting from the Committee of Ministers’ decision in this case. An Interim Resolution, ResDH(2002)58 (see Addendum 4) was adopted in April 2002, inviting the Italian authorities to adopt without further delay the necessary measures in order to prevent new similar violations. At that occasion, the Committee of Ministers decided to resume consideration of this issue once the new legislation was adopted or, at the latest, at its first meeting in 2003. A Bill (S/1243) aimed at amending Royal Decree No. 267/42 on the bankruptcy law was presented in March 2002 and assigned to the Senate Justice Committee, but it has not been debated yet.

Sub-section 4.2

                   - Cases against Italy concerning the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence

H54-886       15211          Diana Calogero, judgment of 15/11/96, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178

H54-887       15943          Domenichini, judgment of 15/11/96, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178

H46-888       39920          Di Giovine, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-889       25498          Messina Antonio 2, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00

H46-318       26161          Natoli, judgment of 09/01/01[71]

H46-890       31543          Rinzivillo, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178

                                      Addendum 4

These cases mainly concern violations of Article 8 of the Convention on account of the lack of clarity of Italian law on the monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence (law No. 354/75), which leaves too much leeway to the public authorities, particularly in respect of the duration of monitoring measures and the reasons justifying such measures, authorises the monitoring of correspondence with the organs of the European Convention on Human Rights and provides for no effective remedy against decisions ordering the monitoring of correspondence (violation of Article 13 in cases Diana and Domenichini).

In the Domenichini case, the Court also found a violation of Article 6§3 because one of the applicant’s letters to his lawyer had been intercepted while penal proceedings were still pending, thus impairing his defence rights.

The Messina Antonio 2 case also concerns the lack of effective remedies against the restrictions resulting from the special prison regime (Section 41bis of the Prison Administration Act n° 354/75) to which he was subject (violation of Article 13).

General measures: In December 2001, the Committee of Ministers adopted Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178, urging the Italian authorities rapidly to adopt the legislative reform required fully to ensure that Italian law complies with the Convention on the points raised by the Court; it decided to resume consideration of the issue once the process of amending law No. 354/75 had been completed or, at the latest, at its first meeting in 2003. It noted with satisfaction the provisional measures already taken, which are summarised in the above-mentioned Interim Resolution (see Addendum 4).

A Presidential Decree on penitentiary organisation entered into force on 06/09/2000, Article 38§11 of which provides that correspondence addressed to international human rights organisations should be exempt from monitoring. As regards the other problems highlighted by the Court in these judgments, a new Bill (No. 2675/C) aimed at amending the law on monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence has been presented to the Chamber of Deputies in April 2002.

Furthermore, the Domenichini judgment (the section “The law”) was translated and published in the Italian legal journal Rivista internazionale dei diritti dell’uomo (1997, vol. II, p. 119-124) and, in March and April 1999, the Italian Ministry of Justice addressed circular letters to Presidents and Public Prosecutors of Appeal Courts, drawing their attention to the requirements of Article 8 of the Convention, as established in the case-law of the European Court of Human rights about monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence, and to the prison authorities, giving them guidelines on how to comply with the above-mentioned requirements. However, it results from the Natoli judgment (§15) that letters between the applicant and his lawyers were in fact submitted to monitoring measures even after the issuing of the circulars and in spite of the fact that Article 103 of the code of the criminal procedure, as amended in 1989, prohibits such control.

As regards the effectiveness of remedies to check the lawfulness of restrictions imposed on prisoners, the Italian authorities informed the Secretariat, by letter of 04/12/2000, that the Messina Antonio 2 judgment had been translated, published in the legal magazine Documenti Giustizia and communicated to the authorities concerned, and that the Department for Penitentiary Administration would consider possible measures to prevent new violations of Article 13, similar to those found by the Court in this case (§§ 84-97 of the judgment). Information has been requested as to the result of these reflections.

Sub-section 4.2

                   - Italian cases concerning the failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

H46-891       22774          Immobiliare Saffi, judgment of 28/07/99 - Grand Chamber

H32-892       20177          Aldini, Interim Resolution DH(97)413

H46-893       22534          A.O., judgment of 30/05/00, final on 30/08/00

H46-894       22671          G.L. IV, judgment of 03/08/00, final on 03/11/00

H46-895       21463          Lunari, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 11/04/01

H46-896       24650          P.M., judgment of 11/01/01, final on 12/09/01

H46-897       15919          Palumbo Edoardo, judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

H46-898       23424          Tanganelli, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 11/04/01

These cases mainly concern the sustained impossibility for the applicants to obtain the assistance of the police in order to enforce judicial decisions ordering their tenants’ eviction, owing to the implementation of legislation providing for the suspension or staggering of evictions. The European Court concluded that a fair balance had not been struck between the protection of the applicants’ right of property and the requirements of the general interest (violations of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1). In some of these cases, the Court also concluded that, as a result of the legislation at issue, rendering eviction orders nugatory, the applicants had been deprived of their right to have their disputes decided by a court, contrary to the principle of the rule of law (violation of Article 6§1). All the applicants recovered their apartments between 1992 and 2000, i.e. between 5 and 16 years after the eviction decisions had been issued.

75 further cases similar to these, having led to the conclusion of friendly settlements, have been examined to date by the Committee of Ministers.

General measures: A new law was adopted in December 1998 (Law No. 431/98 “Regulations concerning the renting and the repossession of housing”), which sets – inter alia – the conditions, modalities and deadlines for the enforcement of eviction decisions. The Director General of human rights asked, as early as September 1999, to have information with regard to the concrete measures adopted to implement this legislation as well as some data confirming the effectiveness of the new measures.

By letter of 19/06/2001, the Italian authorities informed the Committee that the Ministry for Home Affairs was approaching the other competent departments in order to identify further and more effective measures, both on the administrative and legislative level, notably with a view to simplifying the proceedings.

At the 775th bis meeting (January 2002), the Representative of Italy indicated that some implementation problems still existed in practice, notably in some major towns, but were on their way to being solved. However, in August 2002 a new law (No. 185/02) suspended the implementation of eviction orders until 30/06/2003.

In addition, the Immobiliare Saffi judgment has been published in the legal journal Rivista internazionale dei diritti dell’uomo, No. 1/2000, P. 252-265.

- 1 case against Moldova

H46-900       45701          Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia and others, judgment of 13/12/01,

                                      final on 27/03/02[72]

                                      Addendum 4

The case concerns the failure of the Government to recognise the Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia. The Court concluded that this non-recognition constituted an interference with the applicants’ right to freedom of religion and that this interference, although pursuing a legitimate aim, was not “necessary in a democratic society” and thus not justified under the Convention (violation of Article 9). The Court also concluded that the applicants did not enjoy an effective remedy in respect of their claims at domestic level (violation of Article 13).

Individual measures: On 31/07/2002, the Government's agent indicated to the Secretariat that the competent authorities had recognised the Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia (recognition certificate No.1651 of 30/07/2002) in accordance with the Moldovan law on Religious Denominations, as amended on 12/07/2002 (see below). This recognition would appear to erase the consequences of the violation of the Convention in the present case, as regards in particular the legal personality of the Church and, consequently, its right to peaceful enjoyment of its possessions.

Sub-section 4.2

At the 806th meeting (September 2002), the Representative of Moldova stated that the Church would be able – like other religious communities – to participate in the procedures defined by a Governmental decision of 10/06/2002 (this decision appears in Addendum 4) with a view to recognition of its property. Confirmation in this respect has been requested in writing.

Subsequently, the applicants contacted the Secretariat alleging problems with regard to their property claims. They furthermore challenged the Government's decree of 26/09/2001, which states that Metropolitan Church of Moldova is a legal successor of Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia, and certain new provisions of the Criminal Code relating to illegal occupation of religious buildings.

In view of these allegations, the Moldovan delegation was requested at the 810th meeting (October 2002) to provide the Secretariat in writing with clarifications concerning the articulation of the above-mentioned texts and their practical impact on the applicant church, notably with regard to enjoyment of its property rights. At the time of issuing the present annotated agenda, the Secretariat had not yet received these clarifications.

General measures: The Moldovan authorities informed the Committee of Ministers that the original version of the judgment of the European Court and its official translation into Moldovan were published on 09/07/2002 in the Official Journal of Moldova (Monitorul Oficial, n°100).

The Moldovan authorities also indicated that the Moldovan legislation on religious denominations was amended by Law n°1220-XV which entered into force on 12/07/2002. The relevant provisions (articles 9, 14, 49 and 52) of the Law, as amended, appear in Addendum 4.

The new provisions (Article 14) provide among other things that religious denominations are free to organise themselves and can function after depositing a declaration and their statutes with the competent authority, which will register the denomination in question in the State Register of Religious Denominations within 30 days following the deposit. Such recognition can be declared void though judicial proceedings in case of violation of the conditions provided for in Article 9 (§3). The latter prohibits religious denominations from conducting activities which undermine the independence, sovereignty, integrity and security of the Republic of Moldova, as well as the Constitution and the legislation in force, or to undertake actions connected with political activities.

Article 325 of the Code of Civil Procedure has also been amended so as to allow the reopening of domestic civil proceedings following violations of the Convention found by the European Court. The Moldovan authorities moreover recalled that a similar provision (Article 369/2, 1i) has been in existence since June 2000 in the Code of Criminal Procedure (see Addendum 4).

Following the adoption of the new law, the attention of the Moldovan authorities was drawn to the fact that the requirement of proportionality embodied in the Convention did not appear to be included in articles 9§3 and 14 which set out the conditions under which the Moldovan authorities can cancel the recognition of a religion. It was furthermore noted that the new law was not absolutely clear and detailed with regard to the right of a religious community to take judicial proceedings against the authorities' decision to cancel the recognition of this religion. This lack of clarity could prejudice the effective judicial control required by Article 13 and, consequently, the effective prevention of new violations similar to those found in the present case. This analysis was shared by the independent experts who had been mandated, upon the request of the Moldovan authorities and within the framework of the Targeted Co-operation Programme to assist in the implementation of commitments, to assess the compatibility of the new Law on Religious Denominations (as amended) with Council of Europe standards, notably the ECHR.

During the consideration of this case at the 806th meeting (September 2002), the Representative of Moldova indicated that, following the aforementioned expert examination, the Minister of Justice had set up a working party to draw up an entirely new version of the law which would remedy the aforementioned problems. At the 810th meeting (October 2002), the Representative of Moldova stated that the work on the new draft law was progressing and that a copy of the draft would be submitted to the Secretariat as soon as it is finalised.

Sub-section 4.2

- 2 cases against the Russian federation

H46-902       59498          Burdov, judgment of 07/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[73]

The case concerns the non-execution in full or in part over several years by the Russian social authorities of final decisions delivered in 1997-2000 by the Shakhty City Court (Rostov region) which ordered them to pay the applicant compensation for damage to his health sustained during his participation in emergency operations at the Chernobyl nuclear plant (violations of Articles 6 and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1). The amounts owed were paid on 05/03/2001.

General measures: During the examination of the case at 810th (October, 2002) and 819th (December, 2002) meetings, the Russian authorities informed the Committee of the following measures adopted in response to the European Court's judgment:

- publication of the judgment in Rossijskaia Gazeta and its wide dissemination with a view to ensuring that the competent authorities may comply therewith;

- payment of arrears because of the non-execution, as in the Burdov case, of domestic judgments ordering the payment of allowances for the victims of Chernobyl (a total of 284,6 million rubles were paid between January and October 2002);

- execution of 5128 other domestic judgments concerning the indexation of the allowances for the victims of Chernobyl and allocation of the necessary budgetary means (378,6 million rubles for 2002 and 260 million rubles for 2003) to social security bodies to allow them to meet the obligations arising from these judgments;

- Amendment of the Laws governing the mandatory social insurance of the professional accidents and professional diseases with a view to providing for a new system of indexation of allowances paid in accordance with these laws (the indexation will be henceforth based on the inflation rate used for calculation of the federal budget);

The Russian authorities furthermore indicated that the aforementioned system of allowances' indexation would be shortly made applicable to the allowances paid to Chernobyl victims. Specific legislation to that effect was to be submitted before Parliament by mid December 2002. The final adoption of the latter legislation has not yet been confirmed.

The Russian authorities were invited to provide the Secretariat with a copy of new provisions governing the indexation of the relevant social allowances. The particular importance of this legislation was again stressed (cf. letter of the Director General of Human Rights sent on 26/09/2002 to the Representative of the Russian Federation before the Court). It was also suggested that in tackling the problem of non-execution of domestic judgments the Russian authorities take into account the solutions adopted by other Contracting states which had been previously confronted with this problem (eg. the reinforcement of civil, administrative and criminal responsibility for non-execution of judgments, providing for a possibility of forcible execution of judgment against the State through seizure of property, etc.).

Following the debate, satisfaction was expressed in the Committee on account of the speedy and positive response given by the Russian Federation to the Burdov judgment, consisting inter alia in the enforcement of over 5000 outstanding domestic court decisions similar to the one here at issue and the current adoption of other comprehensive general measures to prevent similar violations.

It was recalled that the Committee had considered from the outset that the present judgment was among those which warranted the Committee's special attention given the large number of similar complaints which could be lodged with the Court. It was therefore stressed that the rapid and efficient execution of such judgments under the Committee's supervision was of the utmost importance to prevent repetitive complaints.

Sub-section 4.2

H46-903       47095          Kalashnikov, judgment of 15/07/2002, final on 15/10/2002

The case concerns the poor conditions of the applicant's pre-trial detention between 1995 and 2000 which was found by the European Court to amount to degrading treatment, due in particular to severe prison overcrowding and an unsanitary environment; and its detrimental effect on the applicant's health and well-being, combined with the length of the period during which the applicant was detained in these conditions (violation of Article 3). The case also concerns the excessive length of this detention (1 year, 2 months falling within the Court's jurisdiction - violation of Article 5§3) and the excessive length of criminal proceedings brought against the applicant (1 year, 10 months falling within the Court's jurisdiction - violation of Article 6§1).

General measures: During the first examination of the case at the 819th meeting (December, 2002), the Russian delegation stated that a number of improvements had been and continued to be made as regards the conditions of pre-trial detention in the Russian Federation. They indicated in particular that:

- from October 2001 to October 2002 the overcrowding of pre-trial detention facilities has largely decreased, mostly through reducing the overall number of detainees (from 199 000 to 137 000) as a result of the entry into force of the new Code of Criminal Procedure on 01/07/2002;

- in 2002 some 838 new places were created in pre-trial detention facilities;

- the number of persons committed to detention on remand per month has decreased from 10 000 in 2001 to 3 700 in September-October 2002

- as a result of the above measures, the living space per detainee was increased to 3,46 m². In 26 of 89 Russian regions the number of persons held in pre-trial detention does not exceed the limits set for detention facilities;

The Russian Delegation furthermore indicated that the Ministry of Justice had published in its professional review in November 2002 those extracts from the CPT reports which concern the detention facilities placed under the responsibility of this Ministry (including pre-trial detention facilities).

As regards the excessive length of pre-trial detention and criminal proceedings, the Russian authorities indicated that the new Code of Criminal Procedure is instrumental in preventing new, similar violations as it imposes stricter time-limits on investigation and trial. Following the Kalashnikov judgment, a circular letter was sent by the Vice-Chairman of the Supreme Court to all Russian courts requiring strict compliance with the time-limits.

The European Court's judgment furthermore was published in the daily Rossijskaia Gazeta (17 and 19 October 2002) and in many other Russian legal journals.

The Deputies took note of the information provided and the Russian authorities were invited to keep the Committee informed of further measures adopted to prevent fresh violations of the Convention, in particular with regard to the conditions of pre-trial detention.

- 28 cases against Turkey

H46-904       40035          Jabari, judgment of 11/07/00, final on 11/10/00

This case concerns the deportation of the applicant to Iran, where, she maintained, she would have run the risk of being flogged or stoned to death, these being the penalties prescribed by Iranian law as punishment for adultery. Her asylum application was rejected by the Police, on the grounds that it had been submitted out of the 5-day time-limit as from her arrival in Turkey. However, she was later granted refugee status by the UNHCR. Seised by the applicant, the Administrative Court, which limited itself to the issue of the formal legality of the refusal because the application had been submitted out of time, nevertheless concluded that the decision of the police was not clearly unlawful and that its implementation would not have  resulted for the applicant in damage which would have been impossible to compensate. The European Court considered that there would have been a real risk of the applicant being subjected to treatment contrary to Article 3 if she had been returned to Iran (violation of article 3 if deportation order executed). The Court also decided that no effective remedy had been granted to the applicant: there was no assessment made by the national authorities of the risk the applicant claimed to run; the judicial control by the Council of State was too limited to constitute an effective remedy and that no possibility of suspending the implementation of the execution had existed (violation of Article 13).

Sub-section 4.2

Individual measures: Following the judgment of the European Court, the applicant was granted a Turkish residence permit. She obtained a Canadian visa, in September 2001.

General measures: The regulations on asylum seekers was modified in 1998 to increase the five-day period in which appeals against political asylum rejection may be lodged, to ten days. Moreover, the judgment of the European Court has been translated and published. Explanations concerning how Turkish Law guarantees respect of the requirements of Article 13 of the ECHR were requested. Concerning the violation of Article 13, reference has been made to the possibility of suspending the implementation of a deportation order, in particular if it is clearly unlawful (Article 125 of the Constitution of Turkey). The question of the effectiveness of this rule and its application, in the light of the requirements of Article 13 of the ECHR, has also been raised. Information is also awaited concerning the guarantees offered to ensure that in all appeals – even those submitted out of time – against a measure of removal involving a risk of treatment contrary to Article 3, an examination of the substance of the case is actually carried out.

H46-905       36590          Göç Mehmet, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber

The case concerns the breach of the applicant’s right to a fair trial, first on account of the absence of an oral hearing in the domestic proceedings concerning his compensation claim for two days’ detention, lodged in accordance with Law No. 466 (on compensation for unlawful detention and arrest), and of the non-communication of the Principal Public Prosecutor’s written opinion to the applicant during the appeal procedure before the Court of cassation (violations of Article 6§1).

General measures: By a letter of 15/01/2003, the Turkish authorities indicated that a new provision was added by Law No. 4778 to Article 316 of the Code of Criminal Procedure requiring notification of written opinions of the Principal Public Prosecutor to parties by the competent chamber of the Court of cassation. Information is awaited on the measures envisaged in respect of absence of an oral hearing during proceedings under Law No. 466. The publication of the judgment of the European Court has been requested.

                   - 21 cases of freedom of expression

                   (CM/Inf(2000)28-rev 3 and Addendum, CM/Inf(2001)7, Interim Resolution

                   ResDH(2001)106)

                   Addendum 4

H54-906       22678          Inçal, judgment of 09/06/98

H46-907       23462          Arslan, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-908       23536+        Baskaya and Okçuoğlu, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-909       23556          Ceylan, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-910       25067+        Erdoğdu and Ince, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-911       24919          Gerger, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-912       23168          Karataş, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-913       24246          Okçuoğlu, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-914       23500          Polat, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-827       26680          Şener, judgment of 18/07/00[74]

H46-915       24122          Sürek II, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-916       24762          Sürek IV, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-917       23927+        Sürek and Özdemir, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-918       22479          Öztürk, judgment of 28/09/99

H32-848       25658          Aslantaş Sedat, Interim Resolution DH(99)560[75]

H46-840       23144          Özgür Gündem, judgment of 16/03/00,[76]

H46-764       25723          Erdoğdu, judgment of 15/06/00[77]

Sub-section 4.2

H46-820       28635+        Aksoy Ibrahim, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01[78]

H46-919       28496          E.K., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-640       29590          Yağmurdereli, judgment of 04/06/2002, final on 04/09/2002[79]

H46-639       33179          Karataş Seher, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[80]

These cases all relate to unjustified interferences with the applicants’ freedom of expression, in particular because of their conviction by State Security Courts following the publication of articles and books or the preparation of messages addressed to a public audience. In the Özgür Gündem case, the Court also concluded that the search operation conducted in the applicant newspaper’s premises had not been necessary in a democratic society and that the respondent Government had failed to comply with their positive obligation to protect the applicant newspaper in the exercise of its freedom of expression (violation of Article 10)[81].

Individual measures: since June 1998 it has in particular been repeatedly stressed in the Committee that the applicants’ convictions found to be contrary to Article 10 must be erased from the applicants’ criminal records and that the applicants’ civil and political rights, to the extent that they have been restricted as a result of the convictions, must be restored. The Turkish authorities indicated that this result could be achieved by introducing in the code of criminal procedure the possibility of reopening proceedings found to be contrary to the Convention. Although this amendment was announced in September 1999 and the Committee of Ministers had constantly stressed its urgency, in March 2001 the Turkish authorities indicated that its adoption was only scheduled for 2003-2004[82]. Pending this reform, on 23 July 2001, the Committee of Ministers adopted Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106 (appended to Addendum 4), which, among other things, “urges the Turkish authorities, without further delay, to take ad hoc measures allowing the consequences of the applicants’ convictions contrary to the Convention in the above mentioned cases to be rapidly and fully erased”.

Updated information on the current situation of the applicants and on the concrete follow-up given to Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106 as well as on the possible implications of the amendment of Article 87 of the Constitution (as regards pardons and amnesties) have been requested. By letter of 27/05/2002, the Turkish authorities indicated that six applicants (Mr M.S. Okçuoğlu, Mr U. Erdoğdu, Mr S. Ince, Ms P. Şener, Mr K.T. Sürek, Mr Y. Özdemir) were no longer subject to restrictions of their rights and that eleven among the remaining applicants (Mr Ibrahim Aksoy, Mr Arslan, Mr Gerger, Mr Karataş, Mr A.Z. Okçuoğlu, Mr Polat, Mr Baskaya, Mr Aslantaş, Mr Ceylan, Mr Inçal, Mr Öztürk) could now avail themselves of the remedies normally provided for by Turkish law. On 03/08/2002, the Turkish Parliament adopted provisions allowing for the reopening of civil and criminal proceedings found to be contrary to the Convention (Act No. 4709). These provisions however did not apply to these cases, as their scope was limited to European Court judgments on applications brought after 09/08/2003. An amendment, extending reopening possibilities, within one year, to court judgments already finalised has just been adopted by the Turkish Parliament.

General measures: the question has been raised, since 1998, of the necessity to adapt Turkish law to the requirements of the Convention in order to avoid further violations similar to those found (see CM/Inf(2000)28-rev. 3 for details). As a preliminary measure, the most important judgments have been published in Turkish and some of them can be accessed through the Ministry of Justice website (http://www.adalet.gov.tr/aihm/aihmk.htm). Furthermore, at the 741st meeting (February 2001), the Representative of Turkey indicated that an information note would be sent to judges and public prosecutors in order to raise their awareness of the requirements of the Convention. A copy of this note has been requested. Additional information on a training programme aimed at raising the awareness of the judiciary of the requirements of the Convention was communicated in April 2001.

Sub-section 4.2

In March 2001, the Turkish authorities presented the National Programme containing information on the reforms planned for the “short term” and the “medium term” (respectively 2002 and 2003-2004). Subsequently, on 03/10/2001, a number of constitutional amendments, concerning inter alia the provisions on freedom of expression and information, were adopted and are directly applicable. Since then, a series of packages of laws have been adopted respectively on 06/02/2002, 26/03/2002, 03/08/2002 and 02/01/2003, amending notably Articles 159 and 312 of the Criminal Code, Articles 7 and 8 of the Anti-Terrorism Act (No. 3713), the Press Act (No. 5680), the Political Parties Act (No. 2820) and the Broadcasting Act (No. 3984). Although these amendments are aimed at generally improving the situation of freedom of expression (in some cases, maximum penalties are lowered and the scope of the provisions restricted), they do not seem to solve all the problems raised by the Court’s judgments. Additional information has accordingly been requested on a number of points, including: the way Turkish Courts apply the criterion of “incitement to violence” after the legislative reforms; the introduction of a general criterion of truth and public interest; the review of minimum penalties in crimes related to freedom of expression; the amendment or abrogation to Article 6 of the Anti-Terrorism law; the adoption of specific measures aimed at ensuring the protection of freedom of expression. Finally, at the 792nd meeting, the Turkish authorities were invited to clarify the expected impact of the reforms on freedom of expression in Turkey. By letters of 16/12/2002 and 03/01/2003, the Turkish authorities provided examples of the case-law of the Court of Cassation and Security courts, concerning the application of Articles 312 and 159 of the Criminal Code, after the entry into force of the abovementioned reforms.

                   - 5 Friendly settlements in cases against Turkey concerning freedom of expression and containing undertakings of the Turkish Government

                   (Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106

                   Addendum 4

H46-920       32985          Altan, judgment of 14/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-921       35076          Erol Ali, judgment of 20/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-922       25753          Özler, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-831       26976+        Sürek Kamil Tekin V, judgment of 16/07/2002 - Friendly settlement[83]

H46-923       27307          Bayrak Mehmet, judgment of 03/09/2002 - Friendly settlement

These cases all relate in particular to alleged unjustified interferences with the applicants’ freedom of expression, on account of their conviction by State Security Courts following public speeches or the publication of articles and books (complaints under Article 10 and 6§1).

The Court took note of the friendly settlements reached between the parties. The Turkish Government undertook to pay a sum of money to the applicants, to implement all necessary reform of domestic law and practice in order to bring the Turkish Law into conformity with the requirements of the Convention in the area of freedom of expression and to adopt the individual measures set out in Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106, adopted on 23/07/2001(appended to Addendum 4), in order rapidly and fully to erase the consequences of the applicants’ conviction. These cases are comparable to the 21 “freedom of expression” cases against Turkey under Section 4.2 of this annotated agenda and order of business.

Individual Measures: information is expected on the current situation of the applicants as well as on the measures envisaged, in conformity with the undertakings included in the friendly settlements, in order rapidly and fully to erase the consequences of the applicants’ conviction.

General Measures: see above (“freedom of expression” cases against Turkey).

Sub-section 4.2

- 11 cases against the United Kingdom

H54-924       25599          A., judgment of 23/09/98

The case concerns the failure of the state to protect the applicant from ill-treatment (1993-1994) by his step-father (violation of Article 3).

General measures: newspaper coverage has been extensive. The publication of the European Court’s judgment in a legal journal is still to be confirmed.

As regards the legislative change, which the United Kingdom authorities had undertaken to have adopted (see paragraph 24 of the judgment), the Secretariat received a copy of the Consultation Paper on the Physical Punishment of Children prepared by the United Kingdom authorities. Answers to the questions raised in this paper were ready by mid-2001. It was indicated that the answers should be the basis for further discussions on possible legislative changes to be introduced.

Subsequently, at the 775th meeting (December 2001) the United Kingdom authorities indicated that the Human Rights Act would suffice to prevent the recurrence of a breach of the kind found by the Court in this case so that no special legislative change is necessary. However, this new approach raised the question as to how parents, in the absence of a clear legislative change, would be made aware of the new standard.

At the 819th meeting (December 2002) the United Kingdom Representative responded that ministers have asked the Attorney General to continue his review of the use of the “reasonable chastisement” defence. His report of May 2002 suggested that it was indeed being used reasonably. Furthermore steps had been taken to support families through promoting positive parenting, such as an HM Treasury announcement of a 25 million-pounds (37 million Euro) three-year programme to support parents though the voluntary sector.

The National Family and Parenting Institute, which is government-funded, has launched a video and leaflet “From Breakfast to Bedtime”. This provides tips for parents on how to cope with “meltdown moments” with toddlers. Both parents and professionals have received it very well and NFPI is having to produce additional copies to meet demand. It deliberately avoids any mention of smacking since preliminary research with parents found that the positive parenting messages were much better received on their own.

Ministers are aware that the smacking rules are different in Wales and Scotland where there is a total ban on childminders using corporal punishment, and are listening carefully to what others are saying on these issues. The Government will be reviewing the National Standards this year and this will be the opportunity for making any changes.

In view of recent case-law evidencing a continuing high degree of tolerance in respect of what violence constitutes “reasonable chastisement” (discussed in particular at the Seminar organised in Strasbourg on 21‑22 November 2002) and the Government’s undertaking before the Court, several Delegations and the Secretariat expressed that, apart from the measures already announced, legislative changes would be needed in this case.

The Committee has asked to be kept informed of any new development in particular as regards legislative change.

H46-668       30668+        Wilson and the National Union of journalists; Palmer, Wyeth and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers; Doolan and others, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002[84]

The case concerns the failure of the state in its positive obligation to secure the enjoyment of the rights under Article 11, by permitting employers to use financial incentives to induce employees to surrender important union rights (violation of Article 11). The individual applicants refused to sign new, individual contracts of employment offering a wage increase in return for renouncing the right to be represented by their trade unions. As a consequence their salaries fell below those of their colleagues who had signed individual contracts.

Sub-section 4.2

General measures: in order to prevent similar violations, the United Kingdom Delegation was asked to provide information as to whether there have been any changes to the UK trade union legislation since the 1993 Act and if not, what changes are envisaged.

H46-669       56547          P., C. and S., judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[85]

The case concerns measures taken by the local authority of the United Kingdom to protect the applicants’ second child from her mother, previously convicted in the United States, on the basis of medical expertise, of having ill-treated her first child. The European Court found that the applicants had not had effective access to a Court and that the measures had been unfair in that the applicants had had no legal representation in proceedings brought by the local authority in applying for a care order (proceedings started on 02/02/1999) and an order freeing for adoption (proceedings started on 15/03/1999) (violation of Article 6§1). The European Court also found breaches in the applicants’ right to family life due to the removal of the baby from her mother at birth and to the fact that the above-mentioned proceedings prevented the applicants from being involved in decisions to protect their family interests (violations of Article 8). The applicants’ daughter was finally given to adoption on 27/03/2000.

Individual measures: in the light of the violations found in this case, the Committee has asked whether the United Kingdom authorities are envisaging the adoption of any measures.

General measures: the Committee has asked for copies of the Children Act 1989 and the Adoption Act 1976 to be sent to the Secretariat. The publication and wide dissemination of the judgment of the European Court have also been requested.

H46-674       46477          Edwards Paul and Audrey, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02[86]

The case concerns a breach of the positive obligation imposed on the national authorities to protect the life of the applicants’ son, who was killed while in custody by another detainee, considered dangerous, who shared the same cell (November 1994). The case also concerns inefficacity of the inquiry into the death of the applicants’ son as it was not possible to oblige prison staff to give evidence and because the applicants were not sufficiently associated with the investigation procedure (violations of Article 2). Finally, it concerns the lack of an effective remedy in this respect (violation of Article 13).

Individual measures: The United Kingdom Delegation has informed the Committee that Mr and Mrs Edwards have now written to the minister to accept his offer of a further investigation into a number of complaints against the Prison Service that they regard as outstanding. The investigation, which will be conducted by a Senior Investigating Officer reporting to the Director General of the Prison Service, will begin early this year and prison staff will be required to co-operate. The Committee has asked to be informed of the outcome of this investigation.

General measures: The Delegation indicated that, as far as the particular violations found in this case, the Prison Service had changed its practice and procedure in order to avoid situations of a similar type.

The Committee has asked to be kept informed of the changes introduced in the practice and procedures of the Prison Service. In respect of Article 13, it has requested clarifications on the type of remedies available.

Publication of the European Court’s judgment and dissemination to the authorities concerned has also been requested.

Sub-section 4.2

H46-675       25680          I., judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber[87]

H46-676       28957          Goodwin Christine, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber[88]

These cases concern, in particular, the state’s failure to comply with its positive obligation to ensure the right of the applicants (post-operative, male-to-female transsexuals) to respect for their private life, in particular due to the lack of legal recognition given to their gender re-assignment (violations of Article 8) as well as the impossibility for them to marry a person of the sex opposite to their re-assigned gender (violations of Article 12).

General/individual measures: the United Kingdom authorities have informed the Committee that the Inter-Departmental Working Group on Transsexual People was reconvened to consider the position of transsexual people in general and, since the European Court’s judgments in these cases, has been considering how to implement them. However, the Government was not yet in a position to indicate what measures might be taken as a result of this process. Lastly, the judgments of the European Court have been published in “Sweet & Maxwell” at (2002) 35 EHRR 447.

The Committee has asked whether, pending the adoption of any general measure, the United Kingdom authorities envisage the adoption of any individual measure in these cases.

                   - Cases concerning the security forces

H46-814       28883          McKerr, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[89]

H46-815       37715          Shanaghan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[90]

H46-816       24746          Hugh Jordan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[91]

H46-817       30054          Kelly and others, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[92]

H46-667       43290          McShane, judgment of 28/05/2002, final on 28/08/2002[93]

                                      CM/Inf(2003)4

These cases concern the death of applicants’ next-of-kin during police detention or security forces operations. In this respect, the Court mainly found the following shortcomings in the proceedings for investigating the use of lethal force by police officers/ security forces (violation of Article 2): lack of independence of the investigating police officers from the security forces/police officers involved in the events; lack of public scrutiny and information to the victims’ families concerning the reasons for decisions not to prosecute any soldier / police officer; the inquest procedure did not allow for any verdict or findings which could play an effective role in securing a prosecution in respect of any criminal offence which might have been disclosed; the soldiers / police officers who shot the deceased could not be required to attend the inquest as witnesses; the non-disclosure of witness statements prior to the witnesses’ appearance at the inquest prejudiced the ability of the applicants to participate in the inquest and contributed to long adjournments in the proceedings; the inquest proceedings did not commence promptly and were not pursued with reasonable expedition.

The McShane case also concerns the finding by the Court of a failure by the respondent state to comply with its obligations under Article 34, in that the police had – albeit unsuccessfully – brought disciplinary proceedings against the solicitor who represented the applicant in national proceedings for having disclosed certain witness statements to the applicant’s legal representatives before the European Court.

General measures: Representatives of the United Kingdom and the Secretariat have maintained various contacts in order to discuss the Government’s preliminary position in respect of the measures that need to be adopted.

Sub-section 4.2

The publication of the judgments of the European Court and dissemination to police officers / security officers and judicial authorities concerned are still to be confirmed. Copies of the judgments have been sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions and to all coroners in Northern Ireland.

On 25 September 2002, consultations took place between the Secretariat and representatives of the United Kingdom authorities regarding the measures to be taken. On 07/10/2002, following these consultations, the United Kingdom authorities submitted to the Committee of Ministers a document containing a package of measures (either already adopted or for adoption) with a view to avoiding the repetition of the violations found in these cases. A preliminary examination of this information was made at the 810th meeting (October 2002). The main document was included in Addendum 4, volume 1 of the 819th meeting and the appendix (300 pages) to the document can be obtained from the Secretariat in the original language.

The examination of this document and other relevant information was pursued at the 819th meeting (December 2002) at the close of which the Secretariat was requested to prepare a memorandum summarising the information available. Subsequently, additional information has been received, notably from the applicants’ representatives and the Northern Ireland Human Rights Commission. The memorandum, including the additional information submitted, is presented in document CM/Inf(2003)4.

                   SUB-SECTION 4.3 – SPECIAL PROBLEMS

- 2175 cases against Italy

H46-322       39221+        Scozzari and others, judgment of 13/07/00 – Grand Chamber

                                      Interim Resolutions ResDH(2001)65 and ResDH(2001)151, CM/Inf(2001)12 and CM/Inf(2002)20[94]

                                      Addendum 4

The case concerns two violations of Article 8 of the Convention related, on the one hand, to the continued placement, since 1997, of the two children of the first applicant (mother) in the “Forteto” community, after they had been taken into public care and, on the other hand, to the authorities’ failure to maintain the opportunities of the mother and her children to re-establish family bonds, through the organisation of regular contact visits. The Court notably considered the fact that certain “Forteto” leaders with serious previous convictions notably for ill-treatment and sexual abuse of handicapped people placed in the community (§§32-34) could still play an active role in bringing up the children (§§201-208); the fact that the implementation of the Youth Court’s decisions had been deflected from their intended purpose of allowing visits between the mother and the children to take place as a result of the attitude of the social services (§§178-179 & 213) and of some of the leaders of “Il Forteto” (§211), who had delayed or hindered the implementation of such decisions (§209) and exercised a mounting influence on the children aimed at distancing them from their mother (§210); the doubt about who really has effective care of the children (§211); the insufficient level of control on the social services and the “Forteto” (§§179-181 & §§212-216); the risk of long-term integration of the children into the “Forteto”, which – in the Court’s opinion - runs contrary to the objectives of a temporary placement and of the superior interest of the children (§§215-216).

Individual measures: on 12/12/2002, the Florence Court of Appeal decided that the issue of the temporary placement of the children in the “Forteto” community will be re-examined at the end of June 2003, in the light of a report to be presented by the social services before 05/06/2003 on developments of the relationship between the mother and her children. This re-examination should notably make it possible to assess whether the elements that had brought the European Court to find that the rights of the mother and of her children had been violated (see above) still exist and justify the transfer of the children elsewhere, as requested by the Public Prosecutor (see also, in Addendum 4, the two Interim Resolutions ResDH(2001)65 and ResDH (2001)151 as well as the letter addressed to the Italian authorities on 08/07/2002). Furthermore, the applicant sent to Secretariat a videotape from the monthly meeting in September 2002 in which the children indicate inter alia that, contrary to the Youth Court orders of July 2001, they are still sleeping separately, each of them sharing his bedroom with a “foster parent”. According to the children, there is no traditional “family”  within the community, as marriages are organised only with a view to having the right to obtain the placement of children in the “family”.

As regards the contacts between the mother and the children, the Youth Court found, in December 2000, that the social services were still continuing to delay and hamper the implementation of its decisions to organise such visits. Therefore, after three short visits in March-April 2001 (interrupted when Ms Scozzari moved to Belgium), on 17/07/2001 the Youth Court decided that a regular programme of visits should be set up, with the participation of an official of the social services, appointed among those having never previously intervened in the procedure. Following this decision, monthly visits have been taking place since December 2001, also thanks to the Belgian authorities’ undertaking to pay the travel expenses for Ms Scozzari and a qualified assistant. The question has been raised – both in the course of the discussions within the Committee of ministers and before the domestic courts – (see CM/Inf(2002)20) of whether such visits are organised in such a way to effectively allow a resumption of family relations, in conformity with the Youth Court’s decision and the Strasbourg Court’s judgment. By decision of 12/12/2002, the Florence Court of Appeal decided therefore that there should henceforth be three visits per month.

Sub-section 4.3

General measures: The judgment of the European Court was translated and published in the legal review Rivista Internazionale dei Diritti dell’Uomo, No. 3/2000, p. 1015-1046.

With respect to awareness-raising measures, in May 2001, the Superior Judicial Council asked for the organisation of seminars, both at national and local level, to train magistrates of Youth Courts on the requirements of the Convention, as interpreted in the Strasbourg case-law in the field of family law. This project has not been followed up yet. Further measures aimed at raising the awareness of the social services of the same issues are being considered.

As regards the existence of an effective and regular supervision mechanism of the placement of children, in October 2002, the Italian Delegation informed the Secretariat of the adoption of a new law (No. 149/01) in 2001, amending and making more precise certain provisions on adoption and placement of children, including as regards controls. According to the Italian delegation this law introduces regular control also over institutions such as the “Forteto”. A draft law (No. 2517/C) aiming at centralising jurisdiction over issues concerning minors has also been under examination by Parliament since April 2002.

As regards the effectiveness of existing controls and the alleged links existing between the authorities in charge of children’s placement and the “Forteto” community, in June 2002 the Superior Judicial Council decided that the involvement in the co-operative community « Il Forteto » of two members of the Youth Court did not raise any incompatibility issue, as long as these persons had not taken part in the decisions concerning the placement of the applicant’s children in the « Forteto ».

As regards the question raised of how it happened that people convicted of sexual abuse and ill-treatment were still managing a community entrusted with the care of children, the Italian Delegation explained that these people had been granted a stay of execution; in any event, any ban would no longer be applicable, as the convictions occurred a long time ago. The Secretariat has inquired how situations such as this can be prevented in the future (see for details CM/Inf(2001)12, CM/Del/Act(2001)741).

- 2174 cases concerning the length of judicial proceedings

                   (see also, for more detailed information, CM/Inf(98)29, CM/Inf(98)40, CM/Inf(99)37,

                   CM/Inf(2000)40, CM/Inf(2000)40-Add, CM/Inf(2001)37 and CM/Inf(2002)47

                   and Addendum and Addendum 2 ; Interim Resolutions DH(97)336, DH(99)436, DH(99)437

                   and ResDH(2000)135)[95]

                   Addendum 4, Appendix to this draft Annotated Agenda and Order of Business

In all the 2174 cases against Italy listed in the Appendix to the present document, violations of Article 6§1 were found on account of the excessive length of civil proceedings (1565 cases), execution proceedings (7 cases), labour proceedings (363 cases), administrative proceedings (117 cases), criminal proceedings (118 cases) and criminal proceedings combined with proceedings for damages (4 cases). 182 similar cases concluded by friendly settlements have been examined by the Committee of Ministers up to now (including 20 concerning civil proceedings, 126 labour proceedings, 6 administrative proceedings and 30 criminal proceedings).

General measures: Following the numerous and continuous findings of violations of the right to a trial within a reasonable time, comprehensive reforms of the Italian judicial system have been under way since the end of the eighties and notably since the Committee of Ministers found, in 1997 (cf. Interim Resolution DH(97)336), that the previously enacted measures had been ineffective. These measures however have not so far solved the problem of the excessive length of judicial proceedings in Italy.

The new general measures required and under way in the fields of civil and administrative justice were presented in Interim Resolutions DH(99)436 and DH(99)437. Subsequently, the examination was also extended to criminal justice.

A first assessment was made in October 2000 and was presented in Interim Resolution ResDH(2000)135. In this resolution, the Committee of Ministers, considering the size of the problem, decided among other things “to resume its consideration of the progress made, at least at yearly intervals, on the basis of a comprehensive report to be presented each year by the Italian authorities”.

Sub-section 4.3

The first annual report, provided by the Italian authorities (covering mainly the year 2000 and up to 2001 for criminal proceedings, issued as public document CM/Inf(2001)37), was examined by the Committee at its 764th, 775th and 803rd meetings (October 2001, February and July 2002).

The Committee concluded that the data was relatively encouraging as regards the overall reform of civil and administrative proceedings. With respect to criminal proceedings, the Committee took note of the entry into force of some important legislative reforms and other draft reforms, but regretted that the statistics available did not show any significant progress in the efficiency of criminal justice. Finally, it requested details on some other questions (see the press releases issued after the above-mentioned meetings and reproduced in CM/Inf(2002)47-Add and Addendum 2).

In December 2002, the Committee of Ministers held a preliminary examination of the second annual report provided by the Italian authorities, including statistical data on civil and criminal justice up to the end of 2001. It decided to resume consideration of the application of the measures in February 2003. Complementary information is in particular awaited about some issues detailed in a letter sent to the Italian authorities by the Director of Human Rights (see Addendum 4). New statistical data on civil and criminal justice in 2001 was sent on 19/12/02. More recent data concerning the year beginning 01/07/2001 was subsequently published in Italy on the occasion opening of the judicial year in January 2003.

This information confirms that the progress observed at the previous examination is slowing down:

-             Concerning civil jurisdictions, the backlog has been reduced by 8% before courts of first instance, but is increasing before both justices of peace (+10%) and courts of appeal (between +26,5% and +30,5%). Thus the number of pending civil cases has remained stable overall at first-instance level since 1996 (about 3 300 000 cases) and at appeal level (244 000 cases) in comparison with 2001. The evolution concerning duration is difficult to evaluate because the data available is conflicting.

-             Concerning the criminal jurisdictions, the backlog has increased by 3,8% (from 5 500 000 to more than 5 700 000 cases) and the average overall length of proceedings – from the preliminary inquiry to the appeal – has increased from 1490 to 1509 days.

-             The situation before the Court of cassation has been worsening, the average length increased from 836 to 994 days for civil proceedings and from 192 to 219 days for criminal proceedings. Its backlog has also increased by 23% for civil proceedings and 4% for criminal proceedings.

-             In view of the present results, it appears unlikely that the Sezioni stralcio could complete the 238 793 cases pending for more than 7 years on 30/06/02 (between 1/06/02 and 30/06/02, they had completed 108 970 cases) before the time-limit expected by the Committee of Ministers, i.e. November 2003.

The Committee of Ministers is awaiting information on the situation of administrative justice since 2000.

On the state of legislative reform, the report mentions some 290 new measures envisaged, including notably those relating to the reform of the criminal code and of the codes of criminal and civil procedure. In this connection, the Secretariat asked for information concerning the integration of the new measures in the overall reform project aimed at reducing the length of proceedings and also information concerning the expected impact of these measures.

Concerning judicial organisation and resources, progress appears to have been made in the computerisation of courts, although the programme is at present held up, not least for lack of funding. It will be interesting to know the progress achieved in recruiting 1000 new judges and the time-frame for their effectively taking up their duties.

Progress appears to have been made in the adoption of awareness-raising measures of the Italian judicial operators. In addition, the opinion of the Supreme Judicial Council is expected on the proposal to extend to all Italian courts the measures, concerning the internal organisation of the judicial work, successfully tested in Turin and aimed at speeding up the management of the oldest cases (“Strasbourg programme”).

Sub-section 4.3

As regards national remedies, the Italian authorities indicated that they were planning to modify the “Pinto Act”, which allows victims of excessive length of proceedings the possibility to obtain not only compensation before domestic courts, but also the acceleration of pending proceedings.

Moreover, in a judgment of June 2002 concerning the application of this law, the Italian Court of cassation concluded that the reasonable length of proceedings is not a fundamental, personal right guaranteed by the Italian Constitution.

(See also, for detailed information on the measures enacted or planned by the Italian authorities, Memorandum CM/Inf(98)29 of 28 August 1998, CM/Inf(98)40 of 27 October 1998, CM/Inf(99)37 of 6/07/1999, Memorandum CM/Inf(2000)40 and CM/Inf(2000)40-Add as well as Addendum 4 to this Annotated Agenda and order of business, the second Italian annual report CM/Inf(2002)47 and the Secretariat addendum (CM/Inf(2002)47-Add and Addendum 2).

Individual measures: the Italian authorities have been invited to provide information on the cases indicated as still pending at domestic level at the time the violation was found by the European Court of Human Rights, and to adopt appropriate measures in order to speed up these proceedings. According to the information provided, only around a third of the proceedings examined by the Committee of Ministers would still be pending before the domestic courts today, while roughly half of them were pending when the violation of the Convention was found. In addition, the pending cases having led to a conviction by the Court are now brought to the attention of the competent domestic courts and receive, where possible, accelerated treatment.

- 4 cases against Turkey

H46-2523     25781          Cyprus against Turkey, judgment of 10/05/01 – Grand Chamber

The case relates to the situation that has existed in northern Cyprus since the conduct of military operations there by Turkey in July and August 1974 and the continuing division of the territory of Cyprus. The European Court of Human Rights held that the matters complained of by Cyprus in its application entailed Turkey’s responsibility under the European Convention on Human Rights.

The Court held that there had been the following 14 violations of the Convention:

Greek-Cypriot missing persons and their relatives

-           a continuing violation of Article 2 (right to life) of the Convention concerning the failure of the authorities of the respondent State to conduct an effective investigation into the whereabouts and fate of Greek-Cypriot missing persons who disappeared in life-threatening circumstances;

-           a continuing violation of Article 5 (right to liberty and security) concerning the failure of the Turkish authorities to conduct an effective investigation into the whereabouts and fate of the Greek-Cypriot missing persons in respect of whom there was an arguable claim that they were in Turkish custody at the time of their disappearance;

-           a continuing violation of Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman or degrading treatment) in that the silence of the Turkish authorities in the face of the real concerns of the relatives attained a level of severity which could only be categorised as inhuman treatment.

Home and property of displaced persons

-           a continuing violation of Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life, home and correspondence) concerning the refusal to allow the return of any Greek-Cypriot displaced persons to their homes in northern Cyprus;

-           a continuing violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (protection of property) concerning the fact that Greek-Cypriot owners of property in northern Cyprus were being denied access to and control, use and enjoyment of their property as well as any compensation for the interference with their property rights;

-          a violation of Article 13 (right to an effective remedy) concerning the failure to provide to Greek Cypriots not residing in northern Cyprus any remedies to contest interferences with their rights under Article 8 and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.

Sub-section 4.3

Living conditions of Greek Cypriots in Karpas region of northern Cyprus

-           a violation of Article 9 (freedom of thought, conscience and religion) in respect of Greek Cypriots living in northern Cyprus, concerning the effects of restrictions on freedom of movement which limited access to places of worship and participation in other aspects of religious life;

-           a violation of Article 10 (freedom of expression) in respect of Greek Cypriots living in northern Cyprus in so far as school-books destined for use in their primary school were subject to excessive measures of censorship;

-           a continuing violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 in respect of Greek Cypriots living in northern Cyprus in that their right to the peaceful enjoyment of their possessions was not secured in case of their permanent departure from that territory and in that, in case of death, inheritance rights of relatives living in southern Cyprus were not recognized;

-           a violation of Article 2 of Protocol No. 1 (right to education) in respect of Greek Cypriots living in northern Cyprus in so far as no appropriate secondary-school facilities were available to them;

-           a violation of Article 3 in that the Greek Cypriots living in the Karpas area of northern Cyprus had been subjected to discrimination amounting to degrading treatment;

-           a violation of Article 8 concerning the right of Greek Cypriots living in northern Cyprus to respect for their private and family life and to respect for their home;

-            a violation of Article 13 by reason of the absence of remedies in respect of interferences by the authorities, as a matter of practice, with the rights of Greek Cypriots living in northern Cyprus under Articles 3, 8, 9 and 10 of the Convention and Articles 1 and 2 of Protocol No. 1.

Rights of Turkish Cypriots living in northern Cyprus

-           a violation of Article 6 (right to a fair trial) on account of the legislative practice of authorizing the trial of civilians by military courts.

The Court also decided, unanimously, that the question of the possible application of Article 41 (just satisfaction) of the Convention was not ready for decision and adjourned consideration thereof.

The Deputies examined this case for the first time at their 760th meeting (July 2001) (see the records of the 760th meeting).

During the second examination of the case at the 764th meeting (October 2001) delegations strongly supported the proposal made by the Delegation of Liechtenstein that the Committee should follow the approach already proposed by the Director General of human rights at the 760th meeting, that is identifying specific categories of violations according to the complexity of the execution measures required:

-      the question of missing persons,

-      the living conditions of Greek Cypriots in northern Cyprus,

-      the rights of Turkish Cypriots living in northern Cyprus,

-      the question of the homes and property of displaced persons.

The Liechtenstein Delegation proposed that Delegations concentrate on some of the violations presented under the heading “Living conditions of Greek Cypriots in northern Cyprus” specifically in the Karpas region, as well as the problem of the powers of the military courts presented under heading “Rights of Turkish Cypriots living in northern Cyprus”. As indicated by the Chairman in his summing-up, the procedure adopted for the examination of this case should not prevent the Deputies from pursuing in parallel an examination of the other issues raised in the Court’s Judgment.

At the 783rd meeting (February 2002), the Delegation of Turkey stated that it was in agreement with the approach suggested at the 764th meeting.

At the 792nd meeting, it was noted that a large number of Delegations consider that the question of missing persons should be examined as a matter of priority. At the same meeting the Delegation of Turkey gave a certain amount of information which has been distributed at its request, to all Delegations. The Delegation of Turkey notably indicated that the legislative practice of authorising the trial of civilians by military courts no longer took place: judges who sit on courts which try civilians are chosen from civilian judges by an independent body whose members themselves are civilians.

Sub-section 4.3

At the 798th meeting, the discussions focused in particular on the situation of missing persons and the role played by the Committee on Missing Persons in Cyprus (CMP). Whilst the Turkish Delegation underlined the importance of the CMP, the contribution of Turkey to the work of the CMP and the necessity of reactivating it, several other delegations referred to the text of the Court’s judgment. In fact, in its judgment, the Court considers “that the respondent State’s procedural obligation at issue cannot be discharged through its contribution to the investigatory work of the CMP … (and) it notes that, although the CMP’s procedures are undoubtedly useful for the humanitarian purpose for which they were established, they are not of themselves sufficient to meet the standard of an effective investigation required by Article 2 of the Convention, especially in view of the narrow scope of that body’s investigations”.

At the 810th meeting (October 2002) the Greek Delegation asked that special attention be given to the “living conditions of Greek Cypriots in northern Cyprus” at the 819th meeting.

At the 819th meeting (December 2002), the Committee decided to postpone the examination of the case to the present meeting.

H54-763       15318          Loizidou, judgments of 18/12/96 (merits) and 28/07/98 (just satisfaction) – Interim Resolutions DH(99)680, DH(2000)105 and ResDH(2001)80[96]

                                      Addendum 4

At the present stage of the examination of the case the Deputies have decided to concentrate on the question of payment of the just satisfaction awarded in the last-mentioned judgment on account of the violation of the applicant’s right to the peaceful enjoyment of certain properties located in the Northern part of Cyprus (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1). The Court specified that payment was to take place within 3 months, i.e. before 28/10/1998.

Just satisfaction: As Turkey did not pay the just satisfaction awarded, the Chairman of the Committee of Ministers, the Icelandic Minister of Foreign Affairs, on 22/06/1999 wrote to his Turkish counterpart expressing the Committee’s concern regarding the failure to execute the judgment.

Payment still not taking place, the Committee adopted, on 06/10/1999, Interim Resolution DH(99)680, strongly urging Turkey to review its position and to pay the just satisfaction awarded. As payment still remained outstanding, the Chairman of the Committee, the Irish Minister of Foreign Affairs, wrote a new letter on 04/04/2000 to his Turkish counterpart reiterating the Committee’s expectation that Turkey ensure payment in the near future. The reply of the Turkish Ministers of Foreign Affairs indicated that Turkey did not consider itself to have either the competence or the jurisdiction to execute the Court’s judgment.

On 12/07/2000, the Deputies, in response, adopted a new Interim Resolution DH(2000)105, declaring that the refusal of Turkey to execute the judgment of the Court demonstrates a manifest disregard for its international obligations, both as a High Contracting Party to the Convention and as a member State of the Council of Europe and insisted strongly, in view of the gravity of the matter, that Turkey comply fully and without any further delay with the European Court of Human Rights’ judgment of 28/07/1998.

At the 749th meeting (April 2001) the Turkish Delegation presented a payment proposal subjected, however, to conditions deemed unacceptable by the other Delegations.

Payment not taking place the Committee adopted on 26/06/2001 a new Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)80 in which it recalled its previous Interim Resolutions and stated:

“Very deeply deploring the fact that, to date, Turkey has still not complied with its obligations under this judgment;

Stressing that every member State of the Council of Europe must accept the principles of the rule of law and of the enjoyment by all persons within its jurisdiction of human rights and fundamental freedoms;

Stressing that acceptance of the Convention, including the compulsory jurisdiction of the Court and the binding nature of its judgments, has become a requirement for membership of the organisation;

Sub-section 4.3

Stressing that the Convention is a system for the collective enforcement of the rights protected therein,

Declares the Committee’s resolve to ensure, with all means available to the organization, Turkey’s compliance with its obligations under this judgment,

Calls upon the authorities of the member States to take such action as they deem appropriate to this end.”

When the Deputies examined the matter at their 783rd meeting (February 2002), the Turkish Delegation reiterated the proposal made at the 749th meeting. Recalling that the conditions attaching to this proposal were unacceptable, several delegations presented proposals in order to make possible progress on the payment question.

The Deputies at the 792nd meeting (April 2002), different proposals regarding payment of the sums awarded were discussed. The proposals examined were mainly based on the idea of a payment to the Council of Europe, which organisation should forward the sums, including default interest, to the applicant. The Delegations of Greece and Cyprus objected to such a payment method as it would not correspond to the Court’s judgment, which ordered payment to the applicant. Several Delegations asked Turkey to provide further clarifications as to the exact content of its own payment proposal.

The Chairman also presented to the Deputies a letter from the applicant in which she expressed her frustration and anguish about Turkey’s unwillingness to comply with the judgment and asked to be authorised to address the Committee in person at a forthcoming meeting. A short discussion followed indicating that the Deputies were not inclined to grant the request. A negative reply has subsequently been sent by the Chair to the applicant.

For procedural reasons, the merits of the case could not be examined at the 796th meeting (May 2002) and the examination was postponed to the 798th DH meeting (June 2002). The Chairman indicated that he would in the meantime continue his consultations with interested Delegations. At the 798th (June 2002) and 803rd (July 2002), 810th (October 2002) and 819th (December 2002) meetings no new information regarding the payment was available.

The texts of the Interim Resolutions adopted in this case appear in Addendum 4.

H46-2524     26308          Institut de Prêtres français and others, judgment of 14/12/00 – Friendly settlement

                                      Addendum 4

The case concerns a Turkish judicial decision of 1993 annulling the applicant Institute’s property entitlement to a plot of land on the grounds that, by letting part of this land to a private company, the applicant Institute was no longer eligible for special treatment as a non-profit body (complaints under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 and Article 9). The parties concluded a friendly settlement according to which the Government undertook the following obligations:

- The Treasury and the Directorate General of Foundations recognise the right to usufruct to the benefit of the priests representing the applicant Institute. This right to usufruct shall comprise the full use and enjoyment of the land and the buildings thereon and the right to rent the land for profit-making purposes in order to meet its needs;

- The two above-mentioned state authorities agree to undertake the formalities necessary to register their respective declarations in the land register with a view to renewing the life tenancy in favour of the priests who will replace the current usufructuary;

- The Directorate General of Foundations waives its claim to USD 41,670 owed by the applicant Institute in rent collected over the five years since its property title was annulled.

In October 2001, the applicant Institute indicated to the Secretariat that the Government had still not complied with the terms of the friendly settlement. The applicant thus requested that the appropriate action be taken without further delay by the authorities and that in particular:

- the Government should give instruction for registering in the land register the right to usufruct to the benefit of the current representative of the Church, Father Alain Fontaine;

- the Government should ensure that the General Directorate of Foundations immediately ceases the collection of the rents and recognises the applicant’s right to usufruct;

- the Treasury should withdraw its claim for compensation for illegal occupation of the plot.

Sub-section 4.3

The necessity of an urgent solution to these issues has been stressed in the Committee of Ministers at each of its DH meetings since October 2001 and the Turkish authorities have been invited to take the necessary measures without further delay. In 2002, the Turkish Delegation indicated on numerous occasions that the above-mentioned problems were going to be solved, notably through a Decree by the Prime Minister and that the competent national authorities were engaged in negotiations with the applicant Institute in order to establish the division of rent between the State and the applicants. However, no conclusive result has been achieved.

In view of these persistent problems, it was decided at the 810th meeting (October 2002) that the Chairman-in-office of the Committee of Ministers write a letter to her Turkish counterpart with a view to conveying to him the Committee’s concern at the non-execution of the friendly settlement concluded in this case and to requesting a rapid solution to the problem. This letter was sent on 06/11/2002. By letter of 29/11/2002, the Minister of Foreign Affairs conveyed the Committee's concerns to the Prime Minister asking him to instruct the competent authorities urgently to implement the friendly settlement (see Addendum 4).

During the examination of the case at the 819th meeting (December, 2002), the adoption of an Interim Resolution was suggested if no concrete and visible progress were achieved by February 2003. At the time of issuing the present annotated Agenda, i.e. more than 2 years after the Court's judgment, no new information regarding its execution was available.

H46-2525     29900+        Sadak, Zana, Dicle and Doğan, judgment of 17/07/01

                                      Addendum 4

The case concerns the violation of the right to a fair trial in proceedings before the Ankara State Security Court, which sentenced the four applicants, members of the Turkish Grand National Assembly, to 15 years’ imprisonment in December 1994.

The violations found are the following:

- lack of independence and impartiality of the tribunal due to the presence of a military judge on the bench of the State Security Court (violation of Article 6§1 - see §40 of the judgment);

- lack of timely information about the legal redefinition of the accusation brought against the applicants and lack of sufficient time and facilities to prepare the applicants’ defence (violation of Article 6§3 a and b taken together with Article 6§1 - see §§57-59 of the judgment);

- impossibility to examine or to have examined the witnesses who testified against the applicants (violation of Article 6§3d taken together with Article 6§1 - see §§67-68 of the judgment).

Having found these violations, the Court did not consider it necessary to decide separately the applicants’ complaints under Articles 10, 11 and 14.

Individual measures:

Background: In view of the extent of the violations of the right to a fair trial and of their consequences for the applicants, the Turkish authorities were requested, at the 764th meeting (October 2001), to consider urgently specific individual measures to erase these consequences. (cf. Committee of Ministers’ Recommendation R(2000)2 and its Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106 on the individual measures in cases concerning freedom of expression in Turkey).

The Turkish authorities initially informed the Committee (at the 775th meeting, December 2001) that possibilities for re-opening domestic proceedings following the European Court’s judgments would be shortly introduced through legislation. However, at the 783rd meeting (February 2002), the Turkish Delegation indicated that preparation of the draft law in question had been adjourned but that the Turkish authorities were continuing to seek ways to adopt the necessary individual measures in the present case. Many delegations expressed their disappointment at the fact that the new legislation, which was of such urgency for the execution of the present judgment, had been adjourned and deplored the fact that no specific measure had yet been taken in respect of the applicants. Some delegations furthermore stressed that the execution of the judgment was being attentively observed by the Parliamentary Assembly (cf. AS(2002)CR2) and outside the Council of Europe, notably by the European Union.

Sub-section 4.3

Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)59: At the 794th meeting (30 April 2002), as no progress in the execution of the judgment was reported on this point, the Committee of Ministers adopted Interim Resolution in which it

- Strongly urges the Turkish authorities, without further delay, to respond to the Committee’s repeated demands that the said authorities urgently remedy the applicants’ situation and take the necessary measures in order to reopen the proceedings impugned by the Court in this case, or other ad hoc measures erasing the consequences for the applicants of the violations found;

-Decides, in view of the urgency of the situation, to resume its control of the adoption of these individual measures, if necessary at each of its meetings.

At the 798th (June 2002) and 803rd (July 2002) meetings, the Turkish delegation stated that the authorities were still considering the introduction of a possibility for reopening of proceedings through legislation.

At the 807th meting (September 2002), the Representative of Turkey presented the reforms adopted by the Parliament on 03/08/2002 and the Deputies specifically considered the amendments to the Codes of Criminal and Civil Procedure, which concern the reopening of domestic proceedings. Disappointment was expressed at the fact that that the four applicants in the present case – who continue to serve their 15-year prison sentences and to suffer the consequences of the violations found – will not be able to benefit from the newly adopted provisions (the latter were applicable only to new cases lodged with the European Court after their entry into force, i.e. after 03/08/2003). The necessity for urgent action to grant the applicants the appropriate redress has been accordingly strongly reiterated.

As no concrete action in this respect had been reported at the 810th meeting (October 2002), the Secretariat was mandated to prepare a new draft Interim Resolution.

Adoption of new legislation: At the 819th meeting (December, 2002) the Turkish authorities announced that the draft provisions which would allow the reopening of proceedings in the present case had been included in the complementary reform package presented to the Prime Minister. The question of adoption of a new Interim Resolution was thus not pursued by the Committee. Instead, it welcomed the new information and "expressed confidence that Turkey would ensure that the new legislation is adopted rapidly, and immediately applied to the applicants’ case in the light of the gravity of their situation".

On 23/01/2003, the Grand National Assembly adopted the provisions allowing the re-opening of domestic proceedings in all cases which have already been decided by the European Court and in all new cases which would henceforth be brought before the European Court (see Addendum 4). The provisions however exclude re-opening for all cases which are presently pending before the Court and have not yet been decided. The Law still has to be approved by the President.

On 27/01/2003, the Turkish Prime-Minister Abdullah Gül confirmed before the Parliamentary Assembly that, in accordance with this law, a new trial could now be granted to the four applicants. Information on the re-opening of the case before domestic courts is awaited.

Follow-up by the Parliamentary Assembly: From the outset, the Parliamentary Assembly has been closely scrutinising the follow-up to the present judgment. At its 4th part session (23/09/2002) the Assembly held a debate and adopted Resolution 1297(2002) and Recommendation 1576(2002) on the implementation of the Court's judgments by Turkey. In these texts the Assembly, in particular, strongly supported demands to remedy the applicants' situation and urged the Committee of Ministers to use all means at its disposal to ensure compliance with the judgment without further delay.

General measures:

Information has been requested with regard to the measures the Turkish authorities envisage with a view to preventing new violations of the right to a fair trial in the proceedings before the security courts. The Turkish authorities have informed the Committee that some reforms had already been adopted and certain others were under way.

As regards the specific problem relating to the lack of independence and impartiality of the State Security courts, general measures have already been adopted within the constitutional reform which replaced the military judge on State Security Courts by a civil judge (see the Çiraklar against Turkey case, judgment of 28/10/1998, Resolution DH(99)555). As regards the right to a fair trial in general, this right received constitutional protection as a result of an amendment to Article 36 of the Constitution on 17/10/2001.

SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED

(See Addendum 5 for part or all these cases)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise progress in the adoption of general measures aiming at preventing further similar violations to those found by the Court in the following cases. If necessary, supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will appear in Addendum 5. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in 6 months at the latest.

                   SUB-SECTION 5.1 – LEGISLATIVE AND/OR REGULATORY CHANGES

- 4 cases against Belgium

H46-2526     34989          Goedhart, judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-2527     36449+        Stroek L. and C., judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-2529     26103          Van Geyseghem, judgment of 21/01/99 – Grand Chamber

These three cases concern infringements of the applicants’ right to defend themselves through legal assistance of their own choosing at different stages of criminal proceedings (1st instance, appeal and “opposition”(appeal on specific grounds of non-representation)) the Courts seised having refused, because of the applicants’ failure to appear, to hear their lawyers or to take into account the pleadings filed by them on the merits (violations of Article 6§1 combined with Article 6§3c)).

The cases of Stroek and Godhaert also concern an infringement of the right of access to a tribunal because of the decisions of the Cour de cassation declaring the applicants’ appeal on points of law inadmissible because they had not complied with warrants for their arrest (violation of Article 6§1).

Possible individual measures: The authorities granted a pardon to Mr Stroek and Mr Goedhart which erased the consequences of their conviction, i.e. declared void the international arrest warrant taken out against them. Following the 798th meeting (June 2002) the Belgian authorities sent the Secretariat a draft law, which had been adopted by the Belgian House of Representatives on 16/05/02, inserting a new Article 442bis in the Code of Criminal Investigation. Information is awaited on this subject.

During the examination of these cases, the Representative of Belgium also indicated that a Bill on reopening of proceedings following a judgement of the European Court of Human Rights was being studied.

General measures: the European Court’s judgment has been widely disseminated with a circular and the Cour de cassation quickly changed its case-law. A Bill modifying the Code of Criminal Procedure was transmitted for opinion to the Conseil d’Etat on 14/09/2001. Information is awaited on this subject.

H54-2528     25357          Aerts, judgment of 30/07/98

The case concerns the lawfulness and the conditions of the applicant’s detention in the psychiatric wing of an ordinary prison for seven months pending his transfer to a social protection centre, the applicant’s right of access to a tribunal with the power to determine the lawfulness of that detention and his right to legal aid (violations of Article 5§1e) and Article 6§1).

General measures: the Belgian authorities indicated that ad hoc measures had been taken in order to increase the number of places available in social protection centres, thus reducing delays in transferring prisoners to about 2 months. Moreover, the judgment was published in several legal journals. Further information has been requested concerning measures envisaged to prevent new violations as regards the granting of legal aid and access to the Cour de cassation. In this connection, at the 732nd meeting (December 2000), the Representative of Belgium indicated that a draft law was being prepared and would be transmitted to the Secretariat. At the 775th and 798th meetings (December 2001 and June 2002), the Representative of Belgium stated that the draft law was being examined by the State Council. The attention of the Belgian authorities has been drawn to the recent case-law of the European Court, providing further indications on the requirements of the Convention as regards the granting of legal aid in cassation proceedings (cf. judgments Del Sol and Essaadi against France of 26/02/2002)

- 1 case against Latvia

H46-899       46726          Podkolzina, judgment of 09/04/02, final on 09/07/02

The case relates to a violation of the right of the applicant, a Latvian national belonging to a Russian-speaking minority, to present her candidature at the elections to the Parliament in October 1998, in that she was struck off the electoral lists on the ground of insufficient knowledge of the Latvian language. The European Court took the view that, in subjecting the applicant to an additional language test with a fundamentally different procedure from normal, the administrative and judicial authorities had effectively imposed upon her a procedure which did not comply with the conditions of fairness and legal certainty. It also considered that the Riga Regional Court had deliberately decided not to put right the violation committed, as it had chosen to regard the results of the second test, held according to a procedure presenting no basic guarantees of fairness, as irrefutable (violation of Article 3 of Protocol No. 1).

Sub-section 5.1

General measures: At the 810th meeting, the Representative of Latvia stated inter alia that following the European Court's judgment, the Laws on parliamentary and municipal elections were amended on 09/05/2002. As a result, the provisions requiring higher proficiency in Latvian language for all persons running for parliamentary election were deleted. The judgment of the European Court was furthermore published in the Official Gazette of 21/05/2002. The Latvian authorities' attention was drawn in particular to § 37 of the judgment which highlights the refusal by the Riga Regional Court to review the lawfulness of decisions taken by administrative authorities. The Latvian authorities were thus invited to consider measures to prevent similar problems in the future. In this context, examples demonstrating the direct effect of the European Court's judgments in domestic court case-law have been requested.

- 20 cases against Poland

H46-901       29692+        R.D., judgment of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02

The case relates to a refusal by the Wrocław Court of Appeal to grant the applicant free legal assistance for cassation proceedings which prevented him from having his case brought to and defended in the Court of cassation (violation of Article 6§1 taken together with Article 6§3c).

General measures: At the 798th meeting (June 2002), the Representative of Poland stated that the Ministry of Justice was drawing up new legislation which would allow individuals easier access to the legal aid. He added that the judgment of the European Court had been translated and sent to the Ministry of Justice for publication and dissemination to domestic courts. The Polish authorities were invited to provide the text of current legislation governing legal aid and a copy of the new draft provisions once they are finalised. They were also requested to provide new examples of domestic case-law showing that the latter effectively takes into account the European Court's judgments.

H46-2530     27785          Włoch, judgment of 19/10/00, final on 22/01/01

H46-606       24244          Migoń, judgment of 25/06/2002, final on 25/09/2002[97]

These cases concern the unfairness of judicial proceedings brought between 1993 and 1995 by the applicants, persons detained on remand at that time, in order to regain their freedom. This was due to the facts that the applicants' lawyers could not participate at all the judicial hearings and that they could not have access to the case-files at certain stages of the proceedings (violations of Article 5§4).

General measures: At the 749th meeting (April 2001), the Representative of Poland indicated that, subsequent to the impugned facts, the relevant provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure had been modified so as to prevent new similar violations of the Convention and that the Ministry of Justice was preparing a circular to courts with a view to drawing their attention to the Włoch judgment and to the rules currently in force. He stated that copies of this circular and of the new legal provisions would be sent to the Secretariat. The Polish Delegation confirmed this information at the 798th (June 2002) and 819th (September 2002) meetings. However, none of the above-mentioned texts have so far been received at the Secretariat.

Sub-section 5.1

                   - Cases of length of civil proceedings[98]

H54-2531     27916          Podbielski, judgment of 30/10/98

H54-2532     28616          Styranowski, judgment of 30/10/98

H46-757       38328          Bejer, judgment of 04/10/01, final on 04/01/02[99]

H46-2533     27918          C., judgment of 03/05/01

H46-2534     48001          Goc, judgment of 16/04/02, final on 16/07/02

H46-2535     29695          Gronuś, judgment of 28/05/02, final on 28/08/02

H46-2536     29691          Jedamski, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-2537     43779          Mączyński, judgment of 15/01/02, final on 15/04/02

H46-2538     35843          Malinowska, judgment of 14/12/00, final on 14/03/01

H46-2539     36250          Parciński, judgment of 18/03/01, final on 18/03/02

H46-2540     29455          Pogorzelec, judgment of 17/07/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-2541     25693+        Sobczyk, judgment of 26/10/00, final on 26/01/01

H46-2542     40835          Szaparo, judgment of 23/05/02, final on 23/08/02

H46-608       48684          Uthke, judgment of 18/06/02, défintif le 18/09/02[100]

H46-2543     32734          Wasilewski, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 06/09/01

H46-2544     33082          Wojnowicz, judgment of 21/09/00, final on 22/01/01

H46-2545     34158          Zawadzki, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 27/03/02

                   SUB-SECTION 5.2 – CHANGES OF COURTS’ CASE-LAW OR OF ADMINISTRATIVE PRACTICE

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 5.3 – PUBLICATION / DISSEMINATION

- 2 cases against France

H46-2546     46044          Lallement, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

The case concerns the fact that the applicant was deprived of his property as a result of an expropriation carried out in the public interest. The European Court took the view first that, given the specific nature of the applicant’s situation (in particular the scattered nature of his land and his agricultural specialisation) the compensation awarded was not proportionate to the value of the property expropriated since it did not specifically cover the loss of the applicant’s “working tool” and secondly that the relevant articles of the Code on expropriation proposed no effective remedy to the situation called into question (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

Just satisfaction: The European Court decided that Article 41 concerning pecuniary damage in respect of the loss of the applicants’ source of income is not ready for decision.

General measures: Written confirmation that the judgment of the European Court has been published is awaited.

H46-2547     36677          SA Dangeville, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 16/07/2002

The case concerns an infringement of the applicant company’s right to the peaceful enjoyment of its possessions. The company brought an action requesting the refund of the VAT which it had paid in respect of the financial year 1978 relying a European Community Directive which entered into force on 01/01/78 which exonerated various business activities, including those carried out by the applicant company, from payment of the tax. This claim was dismissed not least on the ground that a directive could not be relied upon by an individual litigant against a provision of national law. The applicant lodged a second application, which was dismissed by a further judgment of the Conseil d’Etat, holding that the applicant could not seek to obtain, by way of an action for damages, satisfaction which had been refused in the tax proceedings in a decision which had become res judicata. The European Court of Human Rights noted that in both its applications the applicant was a creditor of the state on account of the VAT wrongly paid for 1978 and that in any event it had at least a legitimate expectation of being able to obtain a refund. The European Court found that the interference with the applicant company’s possessions did not satisfy the requirements of the general interest and that this interference was disproportionate because of its inability to enforce its debt against the State and the lack of domestic proceedings providing a sufficient remedy to protect its right to respect for enjoyment of its possessions, upset the fair balance between the demands of the general interest of the community and the requirements of the protection of the individual’s fundamental rights (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1).

General measures: The written confirmation of the judgment’s publication is awaited.

- 1 case against Greece

H46-157       37095          Pialopoulos and others, judgment on 15/02/01, final on 27/06/02 and on 15/05/01, final on 06/11/2002[101] (Article 41)[102]

The case concerns an unjustified restriction of the applicants’ right to use their property, due to a series of building prohibitions imposed by the administrative authorities and attempted expropriations decided upon by these authorities without prior compensation (violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1). The case also concerns the fact that the administration failed to comply with a judgment of a court of appeal declaring revoked ipso jure one of the expropriations on the grounds that the compensation was not paid within the time-limit provided for by law (violation of Article 6§1).

In this last-mentioned respect, the case presents similarities in particular to the Hornsby case (judgment of 19/03/1997) closure of which is proposed following a number of general measures adopted by the Greek authorities.

Sub-section 5.3

Individual measures: At the 760th meeting (July 2001), the Greek authorities were asked to inform the Committee of Ministers about the measures envisaged for the official annulment of the impugned expropriation (§ 69 of the judgment of the European Court), as well as about the settlement of the present situation of the applicants’ property. Following the 803rd meeting, a copy of the revocation of the expropriation dated 7 July 2002, was transmitted to the Secretariat by the authorities.

General measures: The wide dissemination of the judgment of the European Court to the competent administrative authorities would be useful.

- 1 case against Italy

H46-2548     43269          Leoni, judgment of 26/10/00, final on 04/04/01[103]

The case concerns the dismissal of an appeal on a point of law lodged by the applicant before the Italian Court of Cassation, to obtain compensation for damage resulting from the allegedly unfounded rejection of his application to be registered by the surveyors’ professional body. The European Court of Human Rights found that the dismissal of this application for being out of time - while the applicant had in fact respected the deadline – had infringed his right to of access to a tribunal (violation of Article 6§1).

General measures: At the 757th meeting (June 2001) the Italian authorities were invited to ensure dissemination of the judgment of the European Court to the Rome Court of Appeal and the Court of Cassation.

- 1 case against Lithuania

H46-2549     48297          Butkevičius, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

The case concerns the unlawfulness of the detention on remand of the applicant, a member of Parliament and Minister of Defence at the time, in the absence of judicial orders (violation of article 5§1 for the periods from 30/11/1997 to 08/12/997 and from 31/12/1997 to 08/01/1998). It also concerns the fact that the applicant had no opportunity to contest the lawfulness of his detention on remand (violation of article 5§4) and the breach of the presumption of innocence in respect of the applicant by the statements of the President of the Parliament which prejudged the assessment of the facts by the judicial authorities (violation of Article 6§2).

General measures: Given the violation of the presumption of innocence found in this case, it was requested, at the 810th meeting (September 2002), that the judgment of the European Court be published and disseminated to Parliament and to the public prosecutor's office with an express reference to the Court's conclusions on the ground of Article 6§2.

With regard to the violations of Article 5, this case presents similarities to the case of Ječius against Lithuania (judgment of 31/07/2000), in which Lithuania has already adopted inter alia legislative amendments to prevent new, similar violations (a draft final Resolution is being prepared).

SUB-SECTION 5.4 – OTHER MEASURES

No new case

SECTION 6 - CASES AWAITING FOR THE PRESENTATION OF A DRAFT RESOLUTION

Action

At the time of issuing the present annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the Secretariat was preparing, in consultation with the Permanent Representations concerned, draft resolutions aiming at closing the examination of these cases. The Deputies are invited to postpone consideration of these cases to their next meeting.

Section 6

- 23 cases against Austtia

H46-2550     36075          Siegl, judgment of 20/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2551     29271          Dichand and others, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H46-2552     34315          Krone Verlag Gmbh and Co. Kg., judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H46-2553     28525          Unabhängige Initiative Informationsvielfalt, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H46-2554     37075          Luksch, judgment of 13/12/01, final on 13/03/02

H46-2555     27783          T., judgment of 14/11/00

H46-2556     31266          G.H., judgment of 03/10/00, final on 03/01/01

H46-2557     26297          G.S., judgment of 21/12/99

H46-2558     35019          Ludescher, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-2559     33915          Walder, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 17/09/01

H32-2560     17291          Hortolomei

H46-2561     37950          Franz Fischer, judgment of 29/05/01, final on 29/08/01

H46-2562     26958          Jerusalem, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H54-2563     15153          Vereinigung Demokratischer Soldaten Österreichs and Berthold Gubi,

                                      judgment of 19/12/94

H32-2564     26113          Wirtschafts-Trend Zeitschriften Verlagsgesellchaft m.b.H.

H46-2565     25878          Michael Edward Cooke, judgment of 08/02/00

H46-2566     30428          Beer Gertrude, judgment of 06/02/01

H46-2567     33382          Fischer Joseph, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02

H46-2568     28501          Pobornikoff, judgment of 03/10/00

H46-2569     33501          Telfner, judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-2570     32381          Baischer, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-2571     29477          Eisenstecken, judgment of 03/10/00

H46-2572     34320          Freiheitliche Landesgruppe Burgenland, judgment of 18/07/2002 – Friendly

                                      settlement

- 2 cases against Bulgaria

H32-2573     30381          Mironov - Interim Resolution DH(99)352

H46-2574     32438          Stefanov, judgment of 03/05/01, final on 03/08/01 - Friendly settlement

- 2 cases against Cyprus

H46-2575     29515          Larkos, judgment of 18/02/99

H46-2576     47293          Selim, judgment of 16/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 3 cases against the Czech Republic

H46-2577     33644          Cesky, judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00

H46-2578     31315          Punzelt, judgment of 25/04/00, final on 25/07/00

H46-2579     35848          Barfuss, judgment of 31/07/00, final on 31/10/00

- 2 cases against Denmark

H46-2580     48470          Jensen, judgment of 14/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-2581     56811          Amrollahi, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002

- 1 case against Finland

H46-2582     25651          L., judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

Section 6

- 94 cases against France

H46-2583     38945          Francisco, judgment of 13/11/01, final on 13/02/02

H46-2584     42189          H.L., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-2585     55672          Beaume Marty, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-2586     46280          Benzi, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-2587     49622          Goubert and Labbe, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-2588     50996          Grand, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-2589     44485          Moullet, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-2590     41946+        Ribes J.M. and M.A., judgment of 07/05/2002, final on 07/08/2002

H46-2591     51818          Société Comabat, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-2592     32872          Peltier, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 21/08/2002

H46-2593     34791          Khalfaoui, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-2594     31070          Van Pelt, judgment of 23/05/00, final on 23/08/00

H46-2595     29507          Slimane-Kaïd II, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 17/05/00[104]

H46-2596     31819+        Annoni Di Gussola, Desbordes and Omer, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

H32-2597     27659          Ferville

H32-2598     28845          Venot

H46-2599     34553          Dulaurans, judgment of 21/03/00

H32-2600     33656          Lemoine Daniel

H32-2601     17572          A.C.

H54-2602     25201          Guerin, judgment of 29/07/98

H54-2603     24767          Omar, judgment of 29/07/98

H54-2604     14032          Poitrimol, judgment of 23/11/93

H46-2605     25444          Pelissier and Sassi, judgment of 25/03/99

H46-2606     27362          Voisine, judgment of 08/02/00

H32-2607     27413          Cazes

H46-2608     25803          Selmouni, judgment of 28/07/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-2609     34406          Mazurek, judgment of 01/02/00, final on 01/05/00

H46-2610     25088          Chassagnou and others, judgment of 29/04/99

H54-2611     25017          Mehemi, judgment of 06/09/97

H32-2612     27019          Slimane-Kaïd I

H54-2613     23618          Lambert Michel, judgment of 24/08/98

H32-2614     24263          Areno

H46-2615     37786          Debboub Husseini Ali, judgment of 09/11/99, final on 09/02/00

H32-2616     23438          Elbialy

H32-2617     22578          G.N. II

H46-2618     39779+        Gombert and Gochgarian, judgment of 13/02/201, final on 13/05/01

H54-2619     28213          I.A., judgment of 23/09/98

H32-2620     18847          J-P.DV

H32-2621     15091          L.D.

H32-2622     21911          Lanza

H32-2623     17831          Morganti

H54-2624     21802          Muller, judgment of 17/03/97

H46-2625     38781          P.B., judgment of 01/08/00, final on 01/11/00

H46-2626     34947          Richet, judgment of 13/02/01, final on 13/05/01

H32-2627     24245          Touihri

H46-2628     42211          Zannouti, judgment of 31/07/01, final on 31/10/01

H46-2629     38687          Djaid, judgment of 29/09/99, final on 29/12/99

H46-2630     49342          Dunan, judgment of 30/10/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2631     49350          Ivars, judgment of 30/10/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2632     39066          Donnadieu, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-2633     33933          Guisset, judgment of 26/09/00, final on 26/09/00

H32-2634     31603          Hermant

Section 6

H46-2635     35589          Kanoun, judgment of 03/10/00, final on 03/01/01

H46-2636     41943          L.L., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-2637     47575          Marks and Ordinateur Express, judgment of 21/02/02, final on 21/05/02

H32-2638     26496          Société Fruehauf France

H46-2639     36932          Caillot, judgment of 04/06/99, final on 04/09/99

H46-2640     38249          Arvois, judgment of 23/11/99, final on 23/02/00

H46-2641     28660          Ballestra, judgment of 12/12/00, final on 12/03/01

H46-2642     33207          Blaisot C. and M., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2643     42401          Camps, judgment of 24/10/00, final on 09/04/01

H46-2644     54757          Chaufour, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-2645     41449          Durrand I, judgment of 13/11/01, final on 13/02/02

H46-2646     42038          Durrand II, judgment of 13/11/01, final on 13/02/02

H46-2647     30979          Frydlender, judgment of 27/06/00

H46-2648     48205+        Gentilhomme, Schaff-Benhadji and Zerouki, judgment of 14/05/2002, final on 14/08/2002

H46-2649     44066          Grass, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-2650     41001          Joseph-Gilbert Garcia, judgment of 26/09/00, final on 26/12/00

H46-2651     37387          Lambourdiere, judgment of 02/08/00, final on 02/11/00

H46-2652     39996          Ouendeno, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 10/07/2002[105]

H32-2653     32510          Peter

H46-2654     33989          Thery, judgment of 01/02/00, final on 01/05/00

H46-2655     38042          Zanatta, A. and J.-B., judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H46-2656     53118          Boiseau, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2657     31842          Darmagnac Pierre V

H46-2658     40493          Jacquie and Ledun, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H46-2659     44617          Leray and others, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-2660     42588          Linard, judgment of 25/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2661     43288          Mahieu, judgment of 19/06/01

H32-2662     25309          Maljean

H46-2663     45573          Moyer, judgment of 25/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2664     37565          Sapl, judgment of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02

H46-2665     46708          Zaheg, judgment of 9/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H54-2666     36313          Henra, judgment of 29/04/98

H54-2667     36317          Leterme, judgment of 29/04/98

H54-2668     32217          Pailot, judgment of 22/04/98

H54-2669     33441          Richard, judgment of 22/04/98

H32-2670     27518          A.S.

H46-2671     47194          Leboeuf, judgment of 26/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-2672     38398          Leclercq, judgment of 28/11/00, final on 28/02/01

H46-2673     44791          Marcel, judgment of 09/04/02 – Friendly settlement

H32-2674     35259          Nagler

H46-2675     37257          Lucas, judgment of 28/11/00, final on 28/02/01

H46-2676     32033          Thurin, judgment of 28/11/00, final on 28/02/01

Section 6

- 37 cases against Greece

H46-2           38703          Agoudimos and Cefallonian Sky Shipping Co., judgment of 28/06/01,

                                      final on 28/09/01

H46-878       55611          Xenopoulos, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 04/09/2002[106]

H46-879       47891          Spentzouris, judgment of 07/05/2002, final on 07/08/2002

H46-2680     42079          E.H., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H32-2681     32397          Sinnesael, Interim Resolution DH(99)130

H54-2682     21522          Georgiadis Anastasios, judgment of 29/05/97

H46-2683     53478          Sajtos, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H32-2684     34373          Goutsos, Interim Resolution DH(99)558

H46-2685     47734          Adamogiannis, judgment of 14/03/2002, final on 14/06/2002

H46-2686     38178          Serif, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H54-2687     18748          Manoussakis and others, judgment of 25/09/96

H46-2688     40434          Kosmopolis S. A., judgment of 29/03/01, final on 29/06/01

H46-2689     30342          Academy Trading Ltd and others, judgment of 04/04/00

H54-2690     28523          Portington, judgment of 23/09/98

H46-2691     38971          Protopapa and Marangou, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H46-2692     40437          Tsingour, judgment of 06/07/00, final on 06/10/00

H46-2693     41459          Fatourou, judgment of 03/08/00, final on 03/11/00

H54-2694     20323          Pafitis and others, judgment of 26/02/98

H46-2695     38459          Varipati, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/01/00

H32-2696     34569          Société anonyme Dimitrios Koutsoumbos, société technique,

                                      commerciale and touristique

H32-2697     32857          Stamoulakatos Nicholas I

H46-2698     37439          Agga, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H54-2699     19773          Philis 2, judgment of 27/06/97

H54-2700     18357          Hornsby, judgment of 19/03/97

H46-2701     37098          Antonakopoulos, Vortsela and Antonakopoulou, judgment of 14/12/99,

                                      final on 21/03/00

H46-2702     31107          Iatridis, judgments of 25/03/99 and 19/10/00 (Article 41) – Grand Chamber

H46-2703     41209          Georgiadis Dimitrios, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H46-2704     28802          Tsavachidis, judgment of 21/01/99

H54-2705     19233+        Tsirlis and Kouloumpas, judgment of 29/05/97

H46-2706     43597          Dionyssios Petrotos, judgment of 29/02/00 – Friendly settlement

H46-2707     34369          Thlimmenos, judgment of 06/04/00

H46-2708     38704          Savvidou, judgment of 01/08/00, final on 01/11/00

H46-2709     41867          Messochoritis, judgment of 12/04/01, final on 12/07/01

H32-2710     24453          Tarighi Wageh Dashti

H46-2711     46380          LSI Information Technologies, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H54-2712     24348          Grigoriades, judgment of 25/11/97

H54-2713     23372+        Larissis and others, judgment of 24/02/98

- 2 cases against Hungary

H46-2714     32396          Magyar, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 11/04/01

H46-2715     38937          Erdős, judgment of 09/04/2002, final on 09/07/2002

- 112 cases against Italy

H46-323       33966          Bastreghi, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-324       32363          Bertini, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-325       37242          Caramanti, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-326       31259          Rizzi, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-697       44375          Rocchi Roberto, judgment of 29/03/01 - Friendly settlement

Section 6

H46-747       44362          Di Deco, judgment of 12/04/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-499       41829          Campomizzi, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-500       41833          Cardillo, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-501       41821          Delicata, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-503       41831          Pio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-504       41819          Quinci, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-505       41830          Raglione, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-507       41820          Sinagoga, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-508       41837          Trotta, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-509       41841          Vay, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-510       41818          Vero, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-742       44365          Calvani, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-743       44370          D’Innella, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-744       44367          G.G. IV, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-745       44369          Pe.C., judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-746       44368          Sapia, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-2716     35243          N. and D.A., judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2717     37248          Vietti, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2718     37019          A.M., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-2719     31227          Ambruosi, judgment of 19/10/00, final on 19/01/01

H54-2720     14025          Zubani, judgments of 07/08/96 and 16/06/99

H32-2721     16609          Intrieri

H32-2722     27253          Biasetti

H46-2723     44955          Mancini Vittorio and Luigi, judgment of 02/08/01, final on 12/12/01

H32-2724     25650          Santandrea

H46-2725     41221          Troiani Marcello, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 10/07/2002

H46-2726     40979          Conte Riccardo II, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2727     40954          D’Alessandro, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2728     44814+        M.A. and 81 others, judgment of 30/11/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2729     40978          Mantini, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2730     40956          Marchetti, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2731     44344          Marcotrigiano, judgment of 19/12/00

H46-2732     41812          Piccirillo Aldo, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2733     43077          A.S. II, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2734     43092          Ascierto Pietro, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2735     43048          Bernardo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2736     43005          Bianchi Michele, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2737     38973          Borrillo, judgment of 22/06/00 – Friendly settlement

H46-2738     40975          Bucci, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2739     43082          C.S., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2740     43081          C.T., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2741     43073          Camerlengo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2742     43007          Capasso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2743     43008          Catillo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2744     43107          Circelli Maria Carmela, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2745     42989          Costantini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2746     40960          Dattilo, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2747     43014          D’Errico, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2748     43044          De Cicco Giuseppe, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2749     43003          De Fiore, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2750     43013          De Nunzio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2751     42992          Del Grosso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2752     43047          Del Vecchio Edvige, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2753     43009          Di Biase Maria, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2754     42991          Falzarano, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2755     43045          Forgione, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2756     43049          Fusco Adelia, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

Section 6

H46-2757     43104          Galietti, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2758     43002          Giorgio Nicola, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2759     43103          Lombardi Gianfranco and 7 others, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2760     43105          Intorcia, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2761     43006          La Vista, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2762     43080          M.A.P., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2763     42990          Manganiello, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2764     40722          Marotta, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2765     42988          Marucci, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2766     42994          Mascolo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2767     43046          Masella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2768     43001          Masuccio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2769     42995          Mirra, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2770     43071          Narciso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2771     43079          P.C. IV, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2772     43089          Pellegrino Rossi, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2773     43090          Perugini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2774     43106          Rossi Lina, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2775     43108          Selvaggio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2776     43004          Verzino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2777     43078          Z., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2778     54288          Andreozzi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2779     54297          Aniceto, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2780     54309          Carretta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2781     54313          Castiello, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2782     54292          Cerasomma, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2783     54291          Caproni, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2784     54290+        D'Agostino Francesco, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2785     44401          Fermi and others, judgment of 06/11/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2786     54280          Giordano, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2787     54302          Incollingo, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2788     54301          Jaculli, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2789     54294          Fiore Mario, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2790     54296          Manera, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2791     54306          Masia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2792     54308          Mignanelli, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2793     54318          Picano, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2794     54279          Prete, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2795     54314          Quacquarelli, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2796     54284          Radicchi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2797     54298          Sabetta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2798     54311          Soave, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2799     54303          Spatrisano, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2800     54305          Tamburrini, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2801     54285          Tatangelo, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2802     54315          Tortolani, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2803     54295          Trovato, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2804     54317          Zullo Rocco, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-2805     38415          C.M.F., judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2806     39797          Guazzone, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Friendly settlement (rectified on 01/08/2002)

- 1 case against Latvia

H46-2807     50108          Kulakova, judgment of 18/10/01 – Friendly settlement

Section 6

- 7 cases against Lithuania

H46-2808     37975          Graužinis, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01

H46-2809     36743          Grauslys, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01

H46-2810     34578          Jėčius, judgment of 31/07/00

H46-2811     47679          Stašaitis, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-2812     42095          Daktaras, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 18/01/01

H46-2813     44558          Valašinas, judgment of 24/07/01, final on 24/10/01

H46-2814     44800          Puzinas, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02

- 3 cases against Luxembourg

H46-7          41761          Scheele, judgment of 17/05/01, final on 17/08/01

H46-2815     21156          G.J., judgment of 26/10/00

H46-2816     45165          Matthies-Lenzen, judgment of 05/02/02 – Friendly settlement

- 7 cases against the Netherlands

H32-2817     14084          R.V. and others - Interim Resolution DH(2000)25

H46-2818     28369          Camp and Bourimi, judgment of 03/10/00

H46-2819     29192          Ciliz, judgment of 11/07/00

H46-2820     31725          Köksal, judgment of 20/03/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2821     33258          Holder, judgment of 05/06/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2822     36499          Samy, judgment of 18/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2823     34549          Meulendijks, judgment of 14/05/2002, final on 14/08/2002

- 6 cases against Poland

H46-2824     28358          Baranowski, judgment of 28/03/00

H46-2825     31382          Kurzac, judgment of 22/02/01, final on 22/05/01

H46-2826     38670          Dewicka, judgment of 04/04/00, final on 04/07/00

H46-2827     51669          Pałys, judgment of 11/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2828     25874          Kawka, judgment of 09/01/01

H46-2829     33310          H.D., judgment of 20/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 4 cases against Portugal

H46-2835     37698          Lopes Gomes da Silva, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00

H46-2836     37528          Martins and Garcia Alves, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H54-2837     15777          Matos and Silva and 2 others, judgment of 16/09/96

H46-2838     33290          Salgueiro Da Silva Mouta, judgment of 21/12/99, final on 21/03/00

- 1 case against Romania

H32-2839     32922          C.C.M.C.

- 7 cases against the Slovak Republic

H46-2840     34753          Jóri, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-2841     40345          Stančiak, judgment of 12/04/01, final on 12/07/01

H46-2842     29032          Feldek, judgment of 12/07/01, final on 12/10/01

H46-2843     32686          Marônek, judgment of 19/04/01, final on 19/07/01

H46-2844     46843          Remšíková, judgment of 17/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2845     24530          Vodeničarov, judgment of 21/12/00

H46-2846     38794          J.K., judgment of 23/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

Section 6

- 2 cases against Slovenia

H46-2847     29462          Rehbock, judgment of 28/11/00

H46-2848     28400          Majarič, judgment of 08/02/00

- 4 cases against Sweden

H46-2849     26978          Beck, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2850     28222          Muonio Saami Village, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2851     32531          Jakola, judgment of 06/03/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2852     30526          De Laczay Ervin and Olga, judgment of 24/09/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 12 cases against Switzerland

H46-2853     27154          D.N., judgment of 29/03/01 - Grand Chamber

H46-2854     33958          Wettstein, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-2855     27798          Amann, judgment of 16/02/00 - Grand Chamber

H54-2856     23224          Kopp, judgment of 25/03/98

H46-2857     54273          Boultif, judgment of 02/08/01, final on 02/11/01

H46-2858     24699          VGT Verein Gegen Tierfabriken, judgment of 28/06/01, final on 28/09/01

H46-2859     37292          F.R., judgment of 28/06/01, final on 28/09/01

H46-2860     33499          Ziegler, judgment of 21/02/02, final on 21/05/02

H46-2861     27426          G.B., judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

H46-2862     28256          M.B., judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

H32-2863     27613          P.B.

H54-2864     19800          R.M.D., judgment of 26/09/97 - Interim Resolution DH(99)678

- 59 cases against Turkey

H46-2865     33322          Özdiler and Bakan, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-2866     29495          Erdemli, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/10/01

H46-2867     29295+        Ecer and Zeyrek, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-2868     31850          Günay and others, judgment of 27/09/01, final on 27/12/01

H46-2869     34686          Sürek Kamil Tekin, judgment of 14/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2870     29851          Zana, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01

H46-2871     32983          Çavuşoğlu, judgment of 06/03/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2872     24947          Ekinci Lalihan, judgment of 05/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2873     31849          İşçi, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2874     24669          Karataş and Boğa, judgment of 17/10/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-2875     24937          Koç Fırat, judgment of 05/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2876     24933          Kürküt, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2877     31733          Tuncay and Ozlem Kaya, judgment of 08/11/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2878     28011          Yeşiltepe, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2879     35980          Z.E., judgment of 07/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2880     29862          Bağci and Murğ, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2881     31882          Çakmak, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2882     32450          Çaloğlu, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2883     31896          Değerli, judgment of 22/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2884     29866+        Demir C., Demir M. and Gül, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2885     29883+        Fidan, Çağro and Özarslaner, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2886     31787          Göktaş and others, judgment of 25/09/01

H46-2887     31249          Gündüz and others, judgment of 14/11/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2888     24932          Kaplan, judgment of 26/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-2889     28013+        Karatepi and Kirt, judgment of 17/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2890     34499          Kortak, judgment of 31/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2891     31895          Morsümbül, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

Section 6

H46-2892     30495          Mutlu and Yildiz, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2893     28014+        Okuyucu, Kara and Bilmen, judgment of 17/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2894     30453          Özata and others, judgment of 22/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2895     29425          Özçelik and others, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2896     36760          Şanlı and Erol, judgment of 22/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-2897     37191          Yildirim and others, judgment of 25/09/01

H46-2898     34684          Yolcu, judgment of 05/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-2899     19264          Aktaş and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H32-2900     22907          Atatür A. and M., and Pamir

H46-2901     19266          Baltekin, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2902     19267          Bilgin Mehmet and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2903     19268          Bilgin Saniye and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2904     19269          Bozkurt and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2905     19272          Çalkan and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2906     19273          Çapar, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2907     19274          Çelebi Hamdi, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2908     19275          Çelebi Yusuf, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2909     19276          Çiplak and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2910     19277          Daniş, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2911     19278          Erol, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2912     19280          Gökgöz, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2913     19281          Gökmen and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2914     38931          İ.S., judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-2915     19270          Ilhan Buzcu and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2916     19283          Işik Ayşe and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2917     19284          Işik Yilmaz and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2918     19286          Karabulut Sefer, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2919     19271          Nuriye Buzcu, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2920     19287          Özen, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2921     19288          Öztekin, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-2922     31312          Eğinlioğlu, judgment of 20/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-2923     29921          Büker, judgment of 24/10/00, final on 24/01/01

- 15 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-2924     48521          Armstrong, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002

H46-2925     24724          T., judgment of 16/12/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-2926     24888          V., judgment of 16/12/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-2927     45276          Hilal, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01

H54-2928     24839          Bowman, judgment of 19/02/98

H32-2929     27237          Govell

H32-2930     26109          Santa Cruz Ruiz

H54-2931     24838          Steel, Lush, Needham, Polden and Cole, judgment of 23/09/98

H46-2932     35394          Khan, judgment of 12/05/00, final on 05/10/00

H46-2933     28901          Rowe and Davis, judgment of 16/02/00

H46-2934     35718          Condron, judgment of 02/05/00, final on 02/08/00

H46-2935     33274          Foxley, judgment of 20/06/00, final on 20/09/00

H46-2936     39360          S.B.C., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01

H54-2937     20605          Halford, judgment of 25/06/97 - Interim Resolution DH(1999)725

H46-2938     36670          Duyonov and others, judgment of 02/10/01 – Friendly settlement

c. PREPARATION OF THE NEXT DH MEETING
(834th MEETING, 9-10 April 2003)

(See Addendum Preparation of the next meeting)

Action

The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary lists of items to be examined at the next DH meeting, which appears in Addendum Preparation of the next meeting to the present annotated agenda and order of business.

827th meeting (DH) – 11 and 12 February 2003

APPENDIX 3

827th METING OF THE MINISTERS’ DEPUTIES

(Strasbourg, 11 and 12 February 2003 – DH)

APPENDIX TO THE ANNOTATED AGENDA AND ORDER OF BUSINESS

Global list of Italian cases of length of proceedings (Section 4.3)[107]

                   - 1565 cases before the civil courts

H32-925       26017          A. and B.T., Interim Resolution DH(96)479

H32-926       40581          A. and M.B., Interim Resolution DH(99)564

H32-927       35284          A. L.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)565

H32-928       31643          A., G., C. and M.B., Interim Resolution DH(97)611

H32-929       36653          A., M., R. and R.Z., Interim Resolution DH(99)133

H32-930       27194          A.A. and L.M., Interim Resolution DH(97)22

H32-931       24166          A.A. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)471

H32-932       26021          A.A. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)478

H32-933       29135          A.A. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)365

H32-934       35296          A.A. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)391

H32-935       26829          A.A.Q. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)615

H32-936       26846          A.B. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)616

H32-937       37874+        A.B., E.F. and C.C., Interim Resolution DH(98)392

H32-938       30097          A.C. and C.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)444

H32-939       26036          A.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)480

H32-940       23588          A.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)559

H32-941       27985          A.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)159

H32-942       38148          A.C. VI, Interim Resolution DH(99)272

H46-327       44481          A.C. VII, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-943       26418          A.F. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)521

H32-944       35334          A.F. V, Interim Resolution DH(98)393

H32-945       18067          A.G. I

H32-946       36627          A.G. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)134

H32-947       39129          A.G. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)474

H32-948       26413          A.I. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)522

H32-949       35304          A.I. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)394

H32-950       31640          A.M. A., Interim Resolution DH(97)612

H32-951       29668          A.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)424

H32-952       31352          A.M. L., Interim Resolution DH(97)613

H32-953       26424          A.M. R., Interim Resolution DH(96)523

H32-954       38488          A.P. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)370

H46-955       35265          A.P. II, judgment of 28/07/99

H32-956       16480          A.R.

H32-957       24022          A.S., A.T. and M.S., Interim Resolution DH(95)262

H32-958       25999          A.T. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)481

H32-959       27165          A.T. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)23

H32-960       24023          A.V., Interim Resolution DH(95)263

H46-961       40947          Abbate Giuseppe, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-962       28730          Abrami, Interim Resolution DH(97)246

H32-963       26842          Adamo Antonia, Interim Resolution DH(96)617

H46-964       40944          Adamo Nino Andrea, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-328       46515          Adriani, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-965       39882          Adrignola A., G., and P., Interim Resolution DH(99)566

H32-966       34854          Agnello, Interim Resolution DH(98)395

H46-967       40963          Aiello, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-968       44392          Albergamo, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 10/07/2002[108]

H46-969       49316          Albertosi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-970       29158          Albertosi, Interim Resolution DH(97)298

H32-971       38519          Albini, Interim Resolution DH(99)371

H32-972       40617          Alborghetti and Brivio S., E., M.C., and R., Interim Resolution DH(99)567

H46-973       45078          Aldo Tripodi, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-974       24033          Alessandrini, Interim Resolution DH(95)264

H46-975       49371          Alfonsetti, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-976       44383          Alicino, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-977       34838          Allegranzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)329

H46-978       51651          Allegri, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-979       19752          Aloe

H46-329       46964          Alpites S.P.A., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-980       45084          Altamura, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-981       34234          Altieri and Cifani, Interim Resolution DH(98)225

H32-982       27459          Aluffi, Interim Resolution DH(97)169

H46-983       49353          Am. M. and S.I., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-984       37132          Amato, Interim Resolution DH(99)234

H32-985       27495          Ambiveri and Arnoldi, Interim Resolution DH(97)91

H32-986       26039          American Eagle S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)482

H32-987       27982          Amighetti and Jolly Moto S.N.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)156

H46-988       52979          An.M., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-989       29155          Andreoletti, Interim Resolution DH(97)299

H32-990       31635          Anfosso, Interim Resolution DH(97)614

H32-991       34841          Angeli, Interim Resolution DH(98)330

H32-992       24162          Angelone and Celeste, Interim Resolution DH(96)472

H46-330       47785          Angemi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-993       40604          Annibale, Interim Resolution DH(99)568

H32-994       28592          Annunziata, Interim Resolution DH(99)51

H32-995       26444          Antognelli, Interim Resolution DH(96)524

H46-996       46993          Antonini C. and A., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-997       26836          Antonini V. and I., Interim Resolution DH(96)618

H32-998       24796          Antoniotti, Interim Resolution DH(96)38

H32-999       27452          Aprile, Interim Resolution DH(97)51

H46-1000     45881          AR.GE.A S.n.c. en liquidation, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-331       48412          Ar.M., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1001     24163          Archimede, Interim Resolution DH(96)224

H46-332       46958          Ardemagni and Ripa, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1002     44628          Aresu, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1003     46987          Arienzo, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1004     29720          Arlistico, Interim Resolution DH(97)547

H46-1005     38098          Arnò, judgment of 09/11/99

H46-703       51671          Arrigoni, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1006     20046          Arruzzolo

H32-1007     38138          Artefice, Interim Resolution DH(99)273

H32-1008     30099          Artuso Maria Nicoletta, Interim Resolution DH(97)445

H32-333       39900          Artuso Paolo

H32-1009     28383          Ass. Consumatori San Gregorio, Interim Resolution DH(98)161

H46-179       56084          At.M., judgment of 07/05/02, final on 07/08/02

H46-1010     44456          Atzori, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1011     38520          Ausiello Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(99)372

H32-1012     30094          Ausilio, Interim Resolution DH(97)446

H32-334       39137          Avallone

H32-1013     28729          Avellani, Interim Resolution DH(97)247

H32-1014     25287          Azzarà, Interim Resolution DH(96)483

H32-1015     29129          B.A. S., Interim Resolution DH(97)300

H32-1016     26849          B.M., Interim Resolution DH(96)619

H32-1017     35940          B.Z., Interim Resolution DH(99)52

H32-1018     39119          Baffoni, Interim Resolution DH(99)476

H32-1019     28727          Baglietto, Interim Resolution DH(97)248

H32-1020     40587          Bagnarelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)570

H46-1021     44433          Bagnetti and Bellini, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-704       51678          Baioni and Badini, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1022     26410          Bakovic, Interim Resolution DH(96)525

H32-1023     37135          Balderi, Interim Resolution DH(99)135

H46-1024     49362          Baldi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1025     47001          Baldini, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1026     34852          Balzani, Interim Resolution DH(98)331

H32-1027     27964          Baracchini, Interim Resolution DH(97)142

H32-1028     38101          Baranelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)274

H32-1029     35294          Barbagiovanni Gasparo, Interim Resolution DH(98)396

H32-1030     39117          Barbarino I, Interim Resolution DH(99)477

H32-1031     39142          Barbarino II, Interim Resolution DH(99)478

H46-1032     38109          Bargagli, judgment of 09/11/99

H46-1033     49377          Barnaba, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1034     52987          Barone Antonio and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1035     49369          Baroni and Michinelli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1036     34268          Barraco, Interim Resolution DH(98)226

H32-1037     38507          Bartolini I, Interim Resolution DH(99)373

H32-1038     39895          Bartolini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)571

H46-1039     44458          Bartolini III, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1040     29662          Bartolucci, Interim Resolution DH(97)526

H32-1041     35342          Basile Bernardo Domenico, Interim Resolution DH(98)397

H32-1042     34863          Basile and Perazza, Interim Resolution DH(98)317

H32-1043     26011          Basile Rocco Antonio and Nicolò, Interim Resolution DH(96)484

H46-1044     40928          Battistelli, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1045     34260          Baudone, Interim Resolution DH(98)227

H32-1046     35921          Bazzea, Interim Resolution DH(99)53

H46-1047     49315          Bazzoni, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1048     39128          Bedin, Interim Resolution DH(99)479

H46-335       44511          Bellagamba, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1049     27969          Belletti, Interim Resolution DH(97)146

H32-1050     27476          Bellio, Interim Resolution DH(97)170

H46-336       40977          Beltramo, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-337       44431          Beluzzi and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1051     51661          Beluzzi and Mangili, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1052     52974          Beneventano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1053     30593          Berardini Angelo I, Interim Resolution DH(97)527

H32-1054     35286          Berardini Angelo II, Interim Resolution DH(99)54

H32-1055     26826          Bergonzini, Interim Resolution DH(96)620

H46-1056     44435          Berlani, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1057     34869          Bernardi, Interim Resolution DH(98)398

H32-1058     34261          Bernardoni, Interim Resolution DH(98)399

H46-1059     46995          Berto, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-705       51667          Bertot, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-338       39883          Bertozzi, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/04/00

H32-1060     38493          Bertuccelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)374

H46-1061     44388          Besati, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1062     51695          Bettella, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-339       44442          Bevilacqua, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1063     29652          Bianchi Armando, Interim Resolution DH(97)425

H32-1064     26817          Bianchi Ines, Interim Resolution DH(96)621

H32-1065     26027          Biasci, Interim Resolution DH(97)52

H46-340       36811          Bielectric S.R.L., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1066     33802          Bimbi, Interim Resolution DH(98)162

H46-1067     40937          Binelis and Nanni, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1068     49358          Bini, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1069     34266          Bisaro, Interim Resolution DH(98)228

H32-1070     26845          Bizzotto, Interim Resolution DH(97)92

H46-341       44437          Bocca, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1071     38482          Boccabella and Torlone, Interim Resolution DH(99)375

H32-1072     22944          Boccardi and Comune, Interim Resolution DH(96)225

H32-1073     35308          Bogliolo Giacomo I, Interim Resolution DH(98)400

H32-1074     35309          Bogliolo Giacomo II, Interim Resolution DH(98)401

H32-1075     35311          Bogliolo Giacomo III, Interim Resolution DH(98)402

H32-1076     27181          Bogliolo Mario, Interim Resolution DH(97)93

H32-1077     37175          Bolignari, Interim Resolution DH(99)136

H32-342       39121          Bolla

H46-1078     49313          Bonacci and others, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1079     25257          Bonaccorso, Interim Resolution DH(96)163

H32-1080     34247          Bonanno, Interim Resolution DH(98)229

H46-343       44457          Bonelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1081     38133          Bonetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)275

H32-1082     19838          Bonfanti I

H32-1083     19839          Bonfanti II

H32-1084     19840          Bonfanti III

H32-1085     19841          Bonfanti IV

H32-1086     19842          Bonfanti V

H32-1087     19843          Bonfanti VI

H32-1088     19837          Bonfanti VII, Interim Resolution DH(96)226

H32-1089     29150          Bonforte, Interim Resolution DH(97)301

H32-1090     26840          Bongianni R. and F. M., Interim Resolution DH(96)622

H32-1091     38516          Bongiovanni, Interim Resolution DH(99)376

H46-1092     45059          Bono, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-1093     39902          Bonomi A. and S., Interim Resolution DH(99)572

H32-1094     38114          Bonvicini, Interim Resolution DH(99)276

H32-1095     31347          Bordogna, Interim Resolution DH(97)615

H32-1096     33782          Borracci, Interim Resolution DH(98)163

H32-1097     37148          Borromeo, Interim Resolution DH(99)137

H32-1098     31358          Borselli, Interim Resolution DH(97)616

H32-1099     24816          Boscaro, Interim Resolution DH(96)40

H46-1100     36608          Bosio and Moretti, judgment of 06/09/99

H32-1101     30108          Botta II, Interim Resolution DH(97)447

H32-1102     27979          Botti, Interim Resolution DH(97)154

H32-1103     21075          Bottiglieri

H32-1104     29650          Bramante, Interim Resolution DH(97)426

H32-1105     40620          Bricalli, Interim Resolution DH(99)573

H46-1106     51660          Brivio, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1107     29139          Broccia, Interim Resolution DH(97)302

H32-1108     27952          Bruno Emanuele, Interim Resolution DH(97)175

H46-1109     52914          Bruno Paolo, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-344       44436          Buffalo s.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1110     33790          Buldini Kotecha, Interim Resolution DH(98)164

H32-1111     32284          Buompastore, Interim Resolution DH(98)22

H32-1112     34872          Buonfino, Interim Resolution DH(98)332

H46-1113     48419          Buonocore, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-345       46534          Burghesu, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1114     39879          Burigat, Interim Resolution DH(99)574

H46-1115     51682          Butta, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1116     34857          C. C., Interim Resolution DH(98)403

H32-1117     27988          C. D.C. (Di Cara), Interim Resolution DH(97)178

H32-1118     33131          C. D.L., Interim Resolution DH(98)101

H32-1119     39898          C., G., and N.A., and T.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)575

H46-1120     49302          C.A.I.F., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1121     38146          C.B. and F.E.V., Interim Resolution DH(99)277

H32-1122     38099          C.B.S., Interim Resolution DH(99)278

H32-1123     35912          C.C. and 5 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)55

H32-1124     31330          C.I.P.D.I. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)617

H46-346       46980          C.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1125     34243          C.L.P.C., Interim Resolution DH(98)230

H32-1126     30587          C.M. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)528

H32-1127     35944          C.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)56

H32-1128     30582          C.M.R. L.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)529

H32-1129     31641          C.R.A.D.C.C. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)618

H32-1130     35340          Cacace, Interim Resolution DH(98)404

H32-1131     37151          Caccamo, Interim Resolution DH(99)138

H32-1132     39875          Caccialupi Olivieri Parteguelfa and Ciarrocchi, Interim Resolution DH(99)576

H32-1133     26443          Cacciola, Interim Resolution DH(96)647

H32-1134     31334          Cairo, Interim Resolution DH(97)619

H32-1135     34829          Calandra, Interim Resolution DH(98)318

H32-347       35292          Calandrella F., P. and 2 others

H32-1136     38129          Calanna, Interim Resolution DH(99)279

H32-1137     19830          Calaudi

H46-1138     46541          Calbini, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1139     40588          Calderone R., A.M., A.M., and E., Interim Resolution DH(99)577

H32-1140     35941          Caldora, Interim Resolution DH(99)57

H32-1141     35305          Calipso Montana s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(98)406

H32-1142     27473          Calistri, Interim Resolution DH(97)180

H32-1143     26430          Callegari, Interim Resolution DH(96)527

H46-1144     36624          Calor Sud, judgment of 26/10/99

H46-1145     56092          Calvagni and Formiconi, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1146     51649          Camici, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1147     23203          Camodeca, Interim Resolution DH(96)227

H46-1148     48423          Campana, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1149     27472          Campoli, Interim Resolution DH(97)53

H32-1150     37140          Canali, Interim Resolution DH(99)139

H46-1151     51680          Canapicchi, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1152     34855          Canocchi, Interim Resolution DH(98)319

H46-1153     40959          Cantacessi, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1154     47004          Cantu, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1155     27959          Capezzali, Interim Resolution DH(97)139

H46-1156     41802          Capoccia Agnese, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-348       39881          Capodanno, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/04/00

H32-1157     38137          Caporaso Adamo, Interim Resolution DH(99)280

H46-1158     40951          Cappellaro, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-706       51696          Cappelletti and Dell’Agnese, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1159     39161          Capriotti, Interim Resolution DH(99)481

H32-1160     30583          Capulli, Interim Resolution DH(97)530

H46-1161     45074          Caputo, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1162     44382          Caracciolo, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1163     33152          Carbonaro, Interim Resolution DH(98)102

H32-1164     25265          Carbone Alessandro, Interim Resolution DH(96)211

H32-1165     38523          Carbone Benito, Interim Resolution DH(99)377

H46-1166     51702          Carbone, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-350       46526          Carboni, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1167     39165          Carcani and Monterosso, Interim Resolution DH(99)482

H32-1168     29153          Carcassi I, Interim Resolution DH(97)303

H32-1169     31339          Carcassi II, Interim Resolution DH(97)620

H32-1170     25230          Cariola E. and M.R., Interim Resolution DH(96)228

H32-1171     27179          Carlino, Interim Resolution DH(97)24

H32-1172     35297          Carloni Natale, Interim Resolution DH(98)407

H32-1173     27978          Carloni Paolo, Interim Resolution DH(97)153

H32-1174     37147          Carnevali, Interim Resolution DH(99)140

H32-1175     39159          Carozza, Interim Resolution DH(99)483

H46-1176     44516          Carrone, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1177     35301          Carrubba, Interim Resolution DH(98)408

H46-1178     44399          Cartoleria Poddighe S.N.C., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-351       45859          Caruso Giuseppina, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1179     26035          Caruso Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(96)486

H32-1180     26406          Caruso, Giardiello and Caruso, Interim Resolution DH(96)528

H32-1181     27182          Casanica, Interim Resolution DH(97)167

H32-1182     27470          Casavola, Interim Resolution DH(97)54

H32-1183     31335          Casilli, Interim Resolution DH(97)621

H32-1184     35332          Casini, Interim Resolution DH(98)409

H32-1185     37313          Cassa Edile della Provincia di Ascoli Piceno, Interim Resolution DH(99)578

H32-1186     37137          Cassandra Luigi II, Interim Resolution DH(99)207

H46-1187     40961          Cassetta, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1188     51679          Cassin, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1189     40962          Castelli Elia, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1190     35333          Castelli Massimiliano, Interim Resolution DH(98)410

H32-1191     34233          Castellucci Galtrucco, Interim Resolution DH(98)237

H46-1192     44448          Castrogiovanni, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1193     34843          Casula, Interim Resolution DH(98)411

H46-1194     46510          Catalano, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-1195     45075          Catania and Zuppelli, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 06/04/01

H32-1196     29161          Cavadini, Interim Resolution DH(97)304

H46-352       45861          Cavallaro, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1197     26860          Cavallin, Interim Resolution DH(96)623

H32-1198     38487          Cavallini and Gualersi, Interim Resolution DH(99)378

H32-1199     25215          Caviglia, Interim Resolution DH(96)164

H46-1200     52915          Cazzato, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-696       25249          Cazzorla and Gigante

H32-1201     34272          Cecchi, Interim Resolution DH(98)231

H46-1202     40936          Cecere (Maria Rosaria), judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1203     27479          Cecere Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(97)55

H32-1204     29138          Ceglia, Interim Resolution DH(97)305

H32-1205     37154          Celebre, Interim Resolution DH(99)141

H32-1206     29136          Celi Lelio, Interim Resolution DH(97)306

H32-1207     29647          Celi Leonida, Interim Resolution DH(97)427

H46-1208     44429          Centi I, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1209     44432          Centi II, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1210     39150          Centi, Interim Resolution DH(99)484

H46-1211     44377          Centineo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1212     27196          Centore, Interim Resolution DH(97)25

H32-1213     20554          Ceravolo

H46-353       36620          Ceriello, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H32-1214     34830          Cerqueti, Interim Resolution DH(98)333

H46-354       46537          Cerulli and Zadra, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1215     38504          Ceruti, Interim Resolution DH(99)379

H46-1216     48418          Cesaro, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H54-1217     22461+        Ceteroni, judgment of 15/11/96

H32-1218     35938          Chiapetto Vincenzo II, Interim Resolution DH(99)142

H46-355       45869          Chiappetta, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1219     13569          Chiarelli

H32-1220     40582          Chinnici I, Interim Resolution DH(99)579

H46-1221     49374          Chinnici II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1222     26023          CI.ME.B. S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)487

H46-1223     46989          Ciabocco, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-1224     52970          Ciancetta and Mancini, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1225     27469          Cianci G. and A., Interim Resolution DH(97)56

H32-1226     35928          Cibin, Interim Resolution DH(99)58

H32-1227     22527          Cicely and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)27

H32-1228     35303          Cicerone E., S., S. and D., Interim Resolution DH(98)453

H32-1229     29654          Cicino, Interim Resolution DH(97)467

H32-1230     39168          Cilea, Interim Resolution DH(99)485

H32-1231     31333          Ciliberti, Interim Resolution DH(97)622

H32-1232     31336          Cimenti, Interim Resolution DH(97)624

H32-1233     26862          Cimini, Interim Resolution DH(96)624

H32-1234     35914          Cimino Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(99)59

H32-1235     33792          Cims Iole, Interim Resolution DH(98)165

H32-1236     31346          Cims Marco, Interim Resolution DH(97)625

H32-1237     35902          Cipolletti, Interim Resolution DH(99)60

H46-356       46959          Circo and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1238     36603          Cirillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)143

H32-1239     29648          Cirino, Interim Resolution DH(97)428

H46-1240     40955          Cittadini and Ruffini, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-357       44504          Citterio and Angiolillo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1241     46999          Ciuffetelli, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1242     27474          Ciuffetelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)94

H46-358       47779          Ciuffetti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1243     25341          Civelek, Interim Resolution DH(99)580

H32-1244     37187          Clucher, Interim Resolution DH(99)144

H46-1245     43434          Cobianchi I, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-1246     45852          Cobianchi II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1247     31344          Coccia, Interim Resolution DH(97)626

H32-1248     37167          Coduto Fernando I, Interim Resolution DH(99)145

H32-1249     37181          Coduto Fernando II, Interim Resolution DH(99)146

H32-1250     38509          Cogo, Interim Resolution DH(99)380

H32-1251     40590          Colangelo, Interim Resolution DH(99)581

H46-1252     56095          Colasanti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1253     35925          Colautti, Interim Resolution DH(99)61

H32-1254     26024          Comentale, Interim Resolution DH(96)488

H32-1255     20010          Condoluci and Napoli

H32-1256     29669          Condoluci, Interim Resolution DH(97)429

H46-1257     44460          Condominio Citta di Prato, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1258     34842          Condominio Rosa Dei Venti, Interim Resolution DH(98)334

H32-1259     12168          Condominio via Flaminia. 141

H46-1260     49375          Consalvo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-359       46532          Conte Gaspare and others, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-1261     32765          Conte Nunzio II, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-1262     34239          Conte Riccardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)232

H32-1263     40589          Conti Elia, Interim Resolution DH(99)582

H46-360       47774          Conti Giuliana, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1264     39160          Copropriété X., Interim Resolution DH(99)486

H32-1265     38128          Coralluzzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)281

H46-1266     48416          Corcelli, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-361       44385          Cornaglia, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-362       46527          Corsi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1267     39140          Corso and Facchetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)525

H32-1268     27201          Cortellessa, Interim Resolution DH(97)26

H46-363       35616          Coscia, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H32-1269     27199          Cosma Bonifacio, Interim Resolution DH(97)27

H46-1270     45884          Cossu, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-364       46538          Costantini Francesco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-365       44500          Cova, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1271     27164          Covi and Anzelini, Interim Resolution DH(97)28

H32-1272     19827          Crea

H46-1273     56085          Cristina, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1274     49309          Crotti, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1275     24027          Crovato, Interim Resolution DH(95)275

H32-1276     20332          Crupi and others

H32-1277     40583          Cucinotta Orazio, Interim Resolution DH(99)583

H32-1278     38105          Cucinotta Tullio, Interim Resolution DH(99)282

H46-366       45880          Cultraro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1279     28384          Cunsolo, Interim Resolution DH(98)166

H32-1280     34827          Curatola, Interim Resolution DH(98)335

H32-1281     26855          Curatolo and Marucchelli, Interim Resolution DH(96)625

H32-1282     38524          Curia, Interim Resolution DH(99)381

H32-1283     25240          Curio, Interim Resolution DH(96)473

H32-1284     25226          D. and P.D.R. and L.M., Interim Resolution DH(96)167

H32-1285     34859          D. S., Interim Resolution DH(98)337

H32-1286     40576          D., F., and F.M. and M.V., Interim Resolution DH(99)584

H32-1287     27178          D.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)57

H46-367       46536          D.C. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-1288     46507          D.G., judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-1289     44533          D.I., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1290     26026          D.M. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)489

H32-1291     26448          D.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)529

H32-1292     16300          D.S. and O.P., Interim Resolution DH(96)112

H46-1293     52925          D’Alfonso, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-368       44513          D’Ammassa and Frezza, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, revised

                                      judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03[109]

H46-369       45872          D’Annibale, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-370       40216          D’Arrigo and Garrozzo, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-1294     27200          D'Agata, Interim Resolution DH(97)29

H32-1295     20207          D'Agostino and Pugliese

H32-1296     38485          Dalla Pozza I, Interim Resolution DH(99)382

H32-1297     40597          Dalla Pozza II, Interim Resolution DH(99)585

H32-1298     29127          Dall'Acqua, Interim Resolution DH(97)307

H32-1299     27968          Dambra, Interim Resolution DH(97)145

H46-371       52921          Damiano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1300     49307          D'Amore, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1301     40603          Dan, Interim Resolution DH(99)586

H32-1302     29163          Danesi, Interim Resolution DH(97)308

H32-1303     36651          Danieli, Interim Resolution DH(99)235

H46-1304     45890          D'Antoni, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1305     51662          D'Apice, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-372       17482          D'Aquino and Petrizzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)28

H46-1306     49318          D'Arrigo, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1307     39147          Datti A. and F., and Bezzi, Interim Resolution DH(99)487

H32-1308     38139          De Agazio Fortunato III, Interim Resolution DH(99)283

H32-1309     37157          De Agazio Giancarlo, Interim Resolution DH(99)147

H32-1310     30102          De Camillis Emidio, Interim Resolution DH(98)168

H32-1311     23603          De Camillis Giovanni, Interim Resolution DH(97)95

H32-373       40566          De Cicco Concetta

H32-1312     33797          De Cicco Nicola, Interim Resolution DH(98)167

H32-1313     37134          De Cristofaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)148

H46-1314     51683          De Guz, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1315     40974          De Lisi, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00

H32-374       40580          De Lorenzi

H32-1316     26843          De Luca Gianni, Interim Resolution DH(96)661

H32-1317     22741          De Luca Vincenzo, Interim Resolution DH(96)34

H32-1318     24805          De Mita, Interim Resolution DH(96)45

H32-1319     26010          De Mori, Interim Resolution DH(96)491

H32-1320     36625          De Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(99)149

H46-698       49372          De Pilla, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1321     52920          De Rosa Francesco, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1322     19559          De Santis Armando

H46-1323     49366          De Santis Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on, 25/01/02

H46-1324     49367          De Santis Guiseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1325     52923          De Santis III, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1326     44455          De Simine, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1327     35287          De Simon and Incontrera, Interim Resolution DH(98)412

H32-1328     35300          De Simone and 6 others, Interim Resolution DH(98)454

H46-375       42520          De Simone Pasquale, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1329     35949          De Simone, Interim Resolution DH(99)62

H32-1330     40567          Decaro G., A., M., and F., Interim Resolution DH(99)589

H46-1331     52968          Del Bono and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1332     36640          Del Mistro, Interim Resolution DH(99)150

H32-1333     24644          Del Prete, Interim Resolution DH(96)229

H32-1334     35933          Del Sole, Interim Resolution DH(99)63

H32-1335     37183          Del Vecchio Michele, Interim Resolution DH(99)201

H32-1336     26015          Delfino, Interim Resolution DH(96)490

H46-1337     56106          Dell’Aquila, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1338     32299          Della Corte, Interim Resolution DH(98)169

H46-1339     44408+        Delmonte and Badano, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1340     38469          Deschamps, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-1341     40965          Di Annunzio, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H32-1342     27974          Di Bella and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)150

H32-1343     24853          Di Blasio A. and L., Interim Resolution DH(97)96

H32-1344     38497          Di Caro, Interim Resolution DH(99)590

H32-1345     29143          Di Ciccio, Interim Resolution DH(97)470

H32-1346     37314          Di Cicco, Di Giammatteo and Fantini, Interim Resolution DH(99)644

H32-1347     34251          Di Domenico, Interim Resolution DH(98)234

H32-1348     29666          Di Donfrancesco, Interim Resolution DH(97)430

H32-1349     34851          Di Fabio I, Interim Resolution DH(98)338

H46-1350     49355          Di Fabio II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-376       39138          Di Fant I

H32-377       39139          Di Fant II

H32-1351     35910          Di Florio, Interim Resolution DH(99)64

H46-1352     44495          Di Francesco, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1353     39130          Di Gianfilippo, Interim Resolution DH(99)490

H32-1354     36629          Di Giovanni II, Interim Resolution DH(99)151

H46-699       44446          Di Girolamo and 6 others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1355     36645          Di Girolamo, Interim Resolution DH(99)152

H32-1356     25242          Di Gregorio, Interim Resolution DH(97)97

H46-1357     34256          Di Mauro, judgment of 28/07/99

H46-378       46976          Di Motoli and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1358     52978          Di Niso, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1359     35285          Di Prisco and Cappon, Interim Resolution DH(98)455

H46-1360     40970          Di Rosa, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1361     35923+        Di Salvo and Formica, Interim Resolution DH(99)65

H46-1362     45898          Di Teodoro and others, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1363     33153          Di Trapani and Crescimanno, Interim Resolution DH(98)123

H46-180       41740          Diebold, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H32-1364     26411          Diglio, Interim Resolution DH(96)530

H32-1365     34840          Dionisi, Interim Resolution DH(98)339

H32-1366     33160          Domenico and Giusa, Interim Resolution DH(98)103

H32-1367     34848          Donati, Interim Resolution DH(98)340

H32-1368     32285          Donato, Interim Resolution DH(98)23

H32-1369     29665          Donfrancesco M. and A., Interim Resolution DH(97)431

H46-1370     40925          D'Onofrio Francesco, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-379       46520          Dorigo Franco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1371     34870          D'Orsi, Interim Resolution DH(98)336

H32-1372     29159          Dotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)370

H32-1373     38513          Dulcamara and Del Vecchio, Interim Resolution DH(99)383

H32-1374     40579          E.A., Interim Resolution DH(99)591

H32-1375     38107          E.B., E.B. and M.B., Interim Resolution DH(99)284

H32-1376     27186          E.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)30

H32-1377     38484          E.D.C., Interim Resolution DH(99)384

H32-1378     19824          E.D.G., Interim Resolution DH(97)58

H32-1379     24817          E.F. and M.C.P., Interim Resolution DH(96)46

H46-380       44480          E.G., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1380     48422          E.I., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1381     24801          E.M. and A.P., Interim Resolution DH(96)47

H46-381       44519          E.M. II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1382     23600          E.M., R.V. and A.S.S.

H32-1383     23623          E.P. I

H32-1384     26043          E.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)492

H46-1385     40953          Ediltes S.n.c., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1386     24036          Elettrodiffusion S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)35

H32-1387     27477          Elia, Interim Resolution DH(97)59

H32-382       39906          Emmebiemme S.r.l.

H46-1388     40976          Ercolino and Ambrosino, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1389     40926          F. I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1390     40971          F. II, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1391     30577          F., A.M., M.G. and P.P. S., Interim Resolution DH(97)531

H46-384       46524+        F., T. and E., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1392     27457          F.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)98

H32-1393     27458          F.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)99

H46-1394     44523          F.C. and F.G., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1395     35337          F.C. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)413

H46-1396     51653          F.CA., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1397     26409          F.D.A. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)531

H32-1398     37143          F.D.L., Interim Resolution DH(99)153

H32-1399     38505          F.D.S., Interim Resolution DH(99)385

H32-1400     39869          F.D'A III, Interim Resolution DH(99)593

H32-1401     39870          F.D'A IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)594

H32-1402     39874          F.E., Interim Resolution DH(99)595

H32-1403     26029          F.L., Interim Resolution DH(96)493

H46-385       46533          F.L.S., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1404     26421          F.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)532

H32-1405     26422          F.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)533

H32-1406     38134          F.P.R., Interim Resolution DH(99)431

H32-1407     30597          F.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)532

H46-1408     44471          F.S. II, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-386       39164          F.S.p.A. II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-387       46971          F.T., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1409     34249          F.V., Interim Resolution DH(98)235

H32-1410     38499          Fabbiano, Interim Resolution DH(99)386

H32-388       26012          Facciolini

H32-1411     38136          Facciolini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)285

H32-1412     29040          Faieta, Interim Resolution DH(98)25

H46-389       46968          Falconi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1413     38474          Faldetta, Interim Resolution DH(99)387

H32-1414     36635          Falleni A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(99)154

H46-390       52972          Falzarano Carmine, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1415     25264          Famas S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)171

H32-1416     35319          Fanni Bruno, Interim Resolution DH(98)414

H32-1417     36638          Fanni Susanna, Interim Resolution DH(99)155

H46-391       47781          Farinosi and Barattelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1418     39157          Fattore A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(99)491

H32-1419     40596          Fazioli, Interim Resolution DH(99)596

H32-1420     20042          Fedele

H46-1421     45892          Feffin, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1422     35935          Feliciano, Interim Resolution DH(99)66

H32-1423     27957          Feminella, Interim Resolution DH(97)137

H32-1424     39126          Feneziani, Interim Resolution DH(99)492

H46-1425     51675          Ferfolja, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1426     52916          Ferrara Vincenza, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1427     44405          Ferraresi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1428     25216          Ferrari Stefano, Interim Resolution DH(96)172

H32-1429     27456          Ferraro Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(97)60

H32-1430     39156          Ferrazzini, Interim Resolution DH(99)493

H46-392       45870          Ferrazzo and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1431     27197          Ferretti Amleto, Interim Resolution DH(97)31

H32-1432     26835          Ferretti Guido, Interim Resolution DH(96)626

H32-1433     39880          Ferron, Interim Resolution DH(99)597

H32-1434     33803          Ficara Carmela, Interim Resolution DH(98)170

H46-1435     45062          Ficara Domenico, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H46-393       45868          Filippello Giorgio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1436     38475          Filippello, Interim Resolution DH(99)598

H32-1437     34868          Filocamo and Dominijanni, Interim Resolution DH(98)341

H32-1438     32296          Filosa II, Interim Resolution DH(98)26

H46-1439     49317          Filosa, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1440     27464          Finvilden S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)61

H32-1441     30100          Fiorentino, Interim Resolution DH(97)448

H46-1442     44393          Fiorenza, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1443     36611          Fioretto and De Luca, Interim Resolution DH(99)156

H32-1444     26832          Firme zia Lilla, Interim Resolution DH(96)627

H32-1445     38121          Florio and Butera, Interim Resolution DH(99)286

H32-394       38145          Focardi and Conti

H32-1446     24050          Foggetti and Quaini, Interim Resolution DH(95)280

H46-1447     44424          Follo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1448     36616          Fondificio A.C.F., Interim Resolution DH(99)157

H32-1449     39166          Fontana and Sartorio, Interim Resolution DH(99)495

H32-1450     29653          Foresta, Interim Resolution DH(97)432

H32-1451     27448+        Formica, Interim Resolution DH(97)62

H32-1452     26830          Formichetti, Interim Resolution DH(97)100

H32-1453     22975          Fornara and others

H32-1454     26420          Forni, Albanese, Centro Orafo Mantovano, Interim Resolution DH(96)534

H46-1455     45079          Fortunati, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1456     46996          Fracchia, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-395       46965          Franceschetti and Odorico, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1457     26022          Franceschi, Interim Resolution DH(96)494

H46-1458     46529          Franchina, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-1459     49373          Franco, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-396       38118          Fraschetti

H32-1460     29124          Frediani, Interim Resolution DH(97)309

H32-1461     27192          Furnari A., G., G. and F., Interim Resolution DH(97)32

H32-1462     26415          Fusco G., F. and P., Interim Resolution DH(96)556

H32-1463     36655          G. D'A., Interim Resolution DH(99)159

H32-1464     16014          G. and A.P.

H46-1465     44510          G. and C.C., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H32-1466     31355          G. and I.B., Interim Resolution DH(97)628

H46-1467     46997          G. Giappichelli Editore S.r.l., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1468     31356          G. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)627

H32-1469     33161          G., R. and V. V., Interim Resolution DH(98)104

H32-1470     35945          G.A. and 7 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)67

H32-1471     19496          G.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)110

H46-397       44397          G.B. IV, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1472     33134+        G.B., A.C. and L.V., Interim Resolution DH(98)105

H32-1473     33136          G.B.C., Interim Resolution DH(98)106

H32-1474     32290          G.C. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)342

H46-1475     44441          G.C. VII, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1476     36605          G.C.VI, Interim Resolution DH(99)158

H32-1477     34236          G.D. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)236

H46-1478     44522          G.F. and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1479     31645          G.F. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)629

H32-1480     27960          G.F.I, Interim Resolution DH(97)140

H32-1481     30598          G.G. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)533

H32-1482     29660          G.G.II, Interim Resolution DH(97)433

H32-1483     26016          G.I., Interim Resolution DH(96)495

H32-1484     24315          G.L. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)173

H32-1485     30585          G.L. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)534

H46-1486     51666          G.L., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1487     40614          G.L.S., Interim Resolution DH(99)599

H32-1488     25247          G.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)174

H32-1489     27183          G.M. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)33

H32-1490     31351          G.M. VI, Interim Resolution DH(97)630

H32-1491     35330          G.M. VII, Interim Resolution DH(98)415

H46-398       37131          G.M.N., judgment of 02/11/99, final on 02/11/99

H32-1492     25266          G.M.N., Interim Resolution DH(96)175

H32-399       38503          G.P. and 25 others

H32-1493     31357          G.P. and F.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)631

H32-1494     33794          G.P. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)171

H32-1495     38123          G.P.F. and M.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)289

H32-1496     27954          G.P.M., Interim Resolution DH(97)135

H32-1497     32287          G.R. and P.M., Interim Resolution DH(98)41

H32-1498     23300          G.R. and S.D., Interim Resolution DH(97)535

H32-1499     23480          G.R. II

H46-400       46543          G.S. and L.M., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1500     26447          G.S. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)535

H32-1501     27180          G.S. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)34

H32-1502     29658          G.S. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)434

H32-1503     32281          G.S. VI, Interim Resolution DH(98)172

H32-1504     35312          G.S. VII, Interim Resolution DH(99)600

H32-1505     29670          G.V. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)435

H32-1506     32279          G.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)27

H32-1507     35341          G.V. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)416

H32-1508     38506          G.V. IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)389

H46-401       47786          G.V. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-700       44421          Galasso, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1509     35315          Galazzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)417

H46-1510     39871          Galgani and De Matteis I, judgment of 28/09/00

H46-1511     44497          Galgani and de Matteis II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-402       46963          Galiè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1512     26848          Galletti, Interim Resolution DH(96)628

H46-1513     46990          Gallo Carmelo, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1514     37163          Gambardella, Interim Resolution DH(99)160

H32-1515     33800          Gambini and Macchia, Interim Resolution DH(98)173

H32-1516     26828          Garavaglia, Interim Resolution DH(97)63

H32-1517     27956+        Garberi P. E. and M., Interim Resolution DH(97)632

H32-1518     30091          Garufi, Interim Resolution DH(97)420

H46-1519     51648          Gaspari, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1520     25225          Gasparoli, Interim Resolution DH(96)176

H32-1521     31646          Gasperoni, Interim Resolution DH(97)633

H32-1522     33140          Gatta, Interim Resolution DH(98)107

H32-1523     34242          Gatti, Interim Resolution DH(98)418

H46-1524     49304          Gatto, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1525     45873          Gaudino, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1526     36636          Gavoncini Lenci A. and A. and Scanu, Interim Resolution DH(99)161

H46-1527     52984          Ge.Im.A.S.a.s., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1528     36614          Gennari, Interim Resolution DH(99)162

H46-1529     56099          Genovesi, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1530     23422          Gentile Italo, Interim Resolution DH(96)536

H32-1531     19870          Gerace

H32-1532     40602          Geva S.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(99)601

H32-1533     36623          Ghedina, Interim Resolution DH(99)163

H46-1534     38116          Ghilino, judgment of 02/11/99

H32-1535     30590          Ghirardi, Interim Resolution DH(97)536

H32-1536     26019          Ghiron, Interim Resolution DH(96)496

H32-1537     35266          Giacomon, Interim Resolution DH(99)68

H32-1538     28733          Giambrone, Interim Resolution DH(97)249

H32-1539     35908          Giampietri, Interim Resolution DH(99)69

H46-1540     40942          Gianetti and De Lisi, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-403       46528          Giannalia, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-404       47773          Gianni, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1541     25245          Giardinieri, Interim Resolution DH(96)177

H46-1542     45888          Giarratana, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1543     45109          Gibertini, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-1544     33789          Gigante E. and N., Interim Resolution DH(98)192

H32-1545     35916          Gilio Benito, Interim Resolution DH(99)70

H46-1546     53361          Giomi, judgment of 05/10/00, final on 05/01/01

H32-1547     24322          Giorgi Alberti, Interim Resolution DH(95)417

H46-1548     40930          Giorgio, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1549     22572          Giovanelli and Vicentini

H46-1550     46531          Giovannangeli, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1551     21340          Giovannetti

H32-1552     18924          Giovannetti Graziani

H32-1553     32283          Giraldi Francesco, Interim Resolution DH(98)28

H32-1554     32294          Giraldi Germana, Interim Resolution DH(98)29

H32-1555     29141          Giraldi I, Interim Resolution DH(97)310

H46-405       45860          Giuseppe Nicola and Luciano Caruso, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-1556     27475          Giusti I, Interim Resolution DH(97)64

H32-1557     32297          Giusti II, Interim Resolution DH(98)30

H32-1558     26838          Giusto, Interim Resolution DH(96)629

H46-1559     40941          Glebe Visconti, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1560     24542          Godet, Interim Resolution DH(96)230

H32-1561     33791          Golia Angelo, Interim Resolution DH(98)174

H32-1562     23431          Gracci, Interim Resolution DH(96)231

H32-1563     38486          Graizzaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)390

H32-1564     30092          Granatelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)449

H32-1565     21671          Granatiero Rosa and Raffaella

H32-1566     27963          Grande and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)181

H46-1567     45110          Grappio, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1568     44430          Grassi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1569     45886          Gratteri, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1570     27467          Gravagno Francesca, Interim Resolution DH(97)65

H46-1571     44512          Greco, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1572     39151          Greppi, Interim Resolution DH(99)496

H32-1573     26408          Grignano, Interim Resolution DH(96)649

H32-1574     35907          Grilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)71

H46-1575     49308          Grimaldi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1576     26020          Grio, Interim Resolution DH(96)497

H32-1577     38511          Gris, Interim Resolution DH(99)391

H46-1578     49303          Grisi, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1579     27986          Gualtieri, Interim Resolution DH(97)160

H46-1580     49321          Guarnieri, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1581     24782          Gubitosi, Interim Resolution DH(96)51

H46-1582     52975          Gucci, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02, revised judgment of 01/10/2002,

                                      final on 01/01/2003[110]

H46-181       44413          Guerrera Angelo Giuseppe, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-1583     44403          Guerrera I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1584     44423          Guerrera II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1585     33144          Guetti G, G. and G., Interim Resolution DH(98)108

H46-1586     45896          Guidi, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1587     31639          Gurciullo and Cappello, Interim Resolution DH(97)634

H46-1588     44502          Gusso and Grasso, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1589     30109          Hay, Interim Resolution DH(97)450

H32-1590     22974          I. S. and M.A.T. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)178

H32-1591     29157          I. S. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)311

H32-1592     34839          I. S. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)343

H46-1593     40957          I., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-406       40968          I.F., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-707       51708          I.M., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-1594     52957          I.P.A. S.r.l., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-407       44418          I.P.E.A. S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-408       39116          I.R., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H32-1595     36606          I.S. and M.A.T. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)165

H32-1596     35336          I.S. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)419

H32-1597     37158          I.S. V, Interim Resolution DH(99)164

H32-1598     29126          Iaconetta, Interim Resolution DH(97)312

H46-1599     44530          Iacovelli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1600     40973          Iadanza, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-1601     45885          Iannelli, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1602     49359          Iannetti, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1603     30580          Ianni Domenico I, Interim Resolution DH(97)537

H32-1604     35295          Ianni Domenico II, Interim Resolution DH(98)420

H46-1605     46986          Ianni III, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-409       44447          Ianniti and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1606     44514          Iezzi and Cerritelli, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1607     45876          Il Messaggero S.a.s. I, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-410       46516          Il Messaggero S.a.s. II, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-411       46517          Il Messaggero S.a.s. III, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-412       46518          Il Messaggero S.a.s. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-413       46519          Il Messaggero S.a.s. V, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-701       44501          Il Messaggero S.A.S. VI, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1608     39154          Il quadrifoglio" calzature-pelletteria di Maria Enrica Colombo S.a.s.,

                                      Interim Resolution DH(99)497

H46-414       47777          Ilardi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-415       44508          Immobiliare Il Messaggero del geometra Antonio Iorillo, judgment of 25/10/01,

                                      final on 25/01/02

H32-1609     34270          Immobiliare Li.ma. s.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(98)238

H32-1610     26853          Immobiliare San Teodoro s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)631

H32-1611     34861          Imparato Francesco, Interim Resolution DH(98)344

H32-1612     29156          Inches, Interim Resolution DH(97)313

H32-1613     28728          Inteco S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)250

H32-1614     33786          Iorillo Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(98)175

H46-1615     45875          Iorillo Debora, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-1616     56088          IT.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-1617     44396          Ital Union Servizi S.a.s. n° 1, judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[111]

H46-1618     44913          Ital Union Servizi S.a.s. n° 2, judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[112]

H46-1619     44914          Ital Union Servizi S.a.s. n° 3, judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[113]

H46-416       39894          Italiano, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-417       46530          Iulio, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1620     35291          L. P., Ga. C. and Gi. C., Interim Resolution DH(98)421

H46-418       40924          L. S.r.l., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1621     44515          L., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1622     56087          L.B., judgment of 12/02/2002, final on 04/09/2002[114]

H32-1623     26018          L.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)498

H32-1624     26040          L.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)650

H32-1625     24024          L.D.C., Interim Resolution DH(95)284

H32-1626     35922          L.D.T., Interim Resolution DH(99)72

H32-1627     27973          L.F. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)149

H32-1628     30088          L.F. V, Interim Resolution DH(97)451

H32-1629     36646          L.G. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)166

H32-1630     40575          L.G. IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)602

H46-1631     39487          L.G.S. S.p.a. II, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-1632     40980          L.G.S. S.p.a., judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H32-1633     31354          L.L., C.S. and S.M., Interim Resolution DH(97)635

H32-1634     24825          L.M. V, Interim Resolution DH(96)474

H32-1635     32276          L.M. VI, Interim Resolution DH(98)31

H32-1636     36633          L.M.L., Interim Resolution DH(99)167

H32-1637     30576          L.P. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)538

H32-1638     36631          L.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)168

H32-1639     31329          L.R. B., Interim Resolution DH(97)636

H32-1640     27958          L.S. and T.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)138

H46-1641     52986          L.S., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/022

H32-1642     26423          L.U., Interim Resolution DH(96)537

H32-1643     18664          La Ferrara and others

H32-1644     34853          La Gorga, Interim Resolution DH(98)422

H32-1645     33788          La Mantia, Interim Resolution DH(98)176

H32-1646     34845          La Monica, Interim Resolution DH(98)345

H32-1647     13570          La Porta

H32-1648     39152          La Rosa, Interim Resolution DH(99)498

H32-1649     38100          La Torre, Interim Resolution DH(99)290

H32-1650     28731          Labate A., G., S. and B., Interim Resolution DH(97)251

H46-1651     44520          Lagana, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1652     33158          Laino, judgment of 18/02/99

H46-419       46542          Lanino, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1653     19832          Lanzo

H32-1654     35919          Larotonda I, Interim Resolution DH(99)73

H32-1655     35920          Larotonda II, Interim Resolution DH(99)392

H32-1656     39866          Lasagna and Milandri I, Interim Resolution DH(99)603

H32-1657     39867          Lasagna and Milandri II, Interim Resolution DH(99)604

H32-1658     25237          Latella, Interim Resolution DH(96)232

H32-1659     26038          Laterza, Interim Resolution DH(96)499

H32-420       31341          Lazzari and Scagnoli

H32-1660     39144          Lazzari M. and C. and F., Interim Resolution DH(99)499

H32-1661     26844          Lazzarini, Interim Resolution DH(96)632

H32-1662     28726          Lealini, Interim Resolution DH(97)252

H32-1663     23604          Legge Massimo and Liberato, Interim Resolution DH(97)101

H32-1664     28721          Lelli G., L. and L., Interim Resolution DH(97)555

H32-1665     39158          Lenza, Di Stefano and Mancini, Interim Resolution DH(99)500

H32-1666     37171          Leo, Interim Resolution DH(99)169

H32-1667     39897          Leone Prefabbricati S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)605

H32-1668     27188          Lepore Armando I, Interim Resolution DH(97)35

H32-1669     27993          Lepore Armando II, Interim Resolution DH(97)161

H32-1670     29128          Li Donni, Interim Resolution DH(97)314

H46-1671     44394          Liberatore, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1672     35331          Liberi, Interim Resolution DH(98)423

H46-1673     40950          Liddo and Batteta, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1674     49376          Lilla Santilli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1675     31327          Lilloni, Interim Resolution DH(97)638

H32-1676     34835          Limardi, Interim Resolution DH(98)346

H32-1677     35930          Lipari, Interim Resolution DH(99)74

H46-1678     45055          Lippera Zaniboni, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-1679     38122          Lispi, Interim Resolution DH(99)291

H32-1680     29167          Litardi, Interim Resolution DH(97)315

H32-1681     34860          Liut, Interim Resolution DH(98)347

H46-421       45853          Lo Cicero, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-422       40571          Lo Sardo

H32-1682     35915          Lodi and Delmonte, Interim Resolution DH(99)75

H32-1683     25239          Lombardi Satriani I, Interim Resolution DH(96)180

H32-1684     26008          Lombardi Satriani II, Interim Resolution DH(96)500

H32-1685     34831          Lombardi Satriani III, Interim Resolution DH(98)320

H32-1686     35273          Lombardi Satriani IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)424

H46-1687     52958          Lombardo Francesco, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-423       46523          Lonardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-708       51668          Lopriore, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1688     38132          Losardo, Interim Resolution DH(99)292

H32-1689     33842          Lucarini Maria Clementina II, Interim Resolution DH(99)393

H46-424       46962          Lucas International S.R.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1690     52919          Luciani, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1691     27865          Lunari, Interim Resolution DH(97)253

H32-1692     39122          Lupi Giovanni II, Interim Resolution DH(99)501

H32-1693     25244          Luzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)181

H32-1694     38126          M. and G.P., Interim Resolution DH(99)502

H32-1695     33133          M. G., Interim Resolution DH(98)110

H46-1696     40940          M. I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1697     40931          M. II, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-425       44406          M. S.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1698     33154          M., G.F. and A.T., Interim Resolution DH(98)109

H32-1699     27953          M.A.D.F., Interim Resolution DH(97)134

H46-1700     45893          M.A.I.E. S.n.c., judgment of 07/11/00, final on 06/04/01

H32-1701     26000          M.C. C., Interim Resolution DH(96)651

H32-1702     24797          M.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)53

H32-1703     39135          M.C. IX, Interim Resolution DH(99)503

H32-1704     26833          M.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(96)662

H32-1705     34263          M.C. VI, Interim Resolution DH(98)239

H32-1706     37141          M.C. VII, Interim Resolution DH(99)170

H46-1707     38478          M.C. VIII, judgment of 09/11/99

H32-1708     18253          M.C., A.C., A.N.C., G.S. and E.S.

H32-1709     25228          M.D.M., Interim Resolution DH(96)182

H32-1710     34873          M.F. C., Interim Resolution DH(98)348

H32-1711     38525          M.G. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)394

H46-1712     49305          M.I. and E.I., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1713     31647          M.L. D.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)639

H32-1714     25231          M.L. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)183

H32-1715     31353          M.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)640

H46-1716     46985          M.Q., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1717     35943          M.R. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)100

H32-1718     38496          M.R.G. and E.F., Interim Resolution DH(99)395

H32-1719     26006          M.R.V., Interim Resolution DH(96)501

H32-1720     35934          M.S. and F.B., Interim Resolution DH(99)76

H32-1721     40578          M.S.A., Interim Resolution DH(99)607

H32-1722     27168          M.T. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)36

H32-1723     34252          M.T.P., Interim Resolution DH(98)240

H32-1724     32302          M.V., Interim Resolution DH(98)32

H32-1725     37133          M.V.F. and M.O.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)171

H32-1726     27169          M.Z., Interim Resolution DH(97)77

H32-1727     26028          Ma. C., Interim Resolution DH(96)652

H32-1728     25214          MA.RI.OR. S.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(96)184

H32-1729     37159          Maccà Amelia I, Interim Resolution DH(99)172

H32-1730     38110          Maccà Amelia II, Interim Resolution DH(99)293

H46-1731     44464          Maccari Ada, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1732     39877          Macelloni, Interim Resolution DH(99)608

H32-1733     29663          Maffeo and Papa, Interim Resolution DH(97)548

H32-1734     27965          Maggi and Arcangeloni, Interim Resolution DH(97)143

H32-1735     39896          Maggioni and Rota, Interim Resolution DH(99)609

H32-1736     25263          Maggiore, Interim Resolution DH(96)185

H32-1737     35903          Magnano and Anselmo, Interim Resolution DH(99)77

H32-1738     35932          Magnante Trecco, Interim Resolution DH(99)78

H32-1739     34280          Magnaterra, Interim Resolution DH(98)241

H32-1740     27184          Magni, Interim Resolution DH(97)37

H32-1741     26007          Magno Di Gaspare, Interim Resolution DH(96)502

H32-1742     26859          Magri, Interim Resolution DH(96)633

H32-1743     34275+        Maiorano G, C., and M. and Serafini, Interim Resolution DH(98)242

H32-1744     24822          Majani S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)113

H32-1745     25221          Maldini and Garulli G. B. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)233

H46-426       46961          Maletti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1746     21076          Malvaso Maria Concetta and Carmela

H32-1747     20012          Malvaso Rocco

H32-1748     24332          Manca Antonio Gavina, Interim Resolution DH(95)425

H32-1749     31636          Manca Marisa, Interim Resolution DH(97)641

H46-1750     40938          Manca Renata and Maria, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1751     46994          Mancinelli, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1752     34248          Mandelli, Interim Resolution DH(98)243

H32-1753     38104          Manieri, Interim Resolution DH(99)294

H46-709       51706          Mannari, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-1754     34241          Manni Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(98)244

H32-1755     29132          Manni, Interim Resolution DH(97)371

H32-1756     31350          Manotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)642

H32-1757     35314          Mansueto, Interim Resolution DH(98)425

H46-1758     44498          Mantini II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-427       28725          Manzi A., B. and L.

H32-1759     29154          Manzinali, Interim Resolution DH(97)316

H46-1760     49370          Marcantoni, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1761     28734          Marcellino, Interim Resolution DH(97)256

H32-1762     32278          Marcello, Interim Resolution DH(98)33

H32-1763     33142          Marchese Carlo, Interim Resolution DH(98)111

H32-1764     26403          Marchetti Alessandro I, Interim Resolution DH(96)653

H32-1765     25882          Marchetti Alessandro II, Interim Resolution DH(97)102

H46-428       44443          Marchi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-429       46957          Marcolongo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1766     37156          Marè, Interim Resolution DH(99)208

H46-430       44517          Mari and Mangini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1767     45063          Mari I, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H46-1768     49365          Mari II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1769     38481          Marinelli and C.S.n.c. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)610

H32-1770     38514          Marinelli and C.S.n.c. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)611

H32-1771     38515          Marinelli and C.S.n.c. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)612

H32-1772     35335          Marinelli Guiseppe, Interim Resolution DH(98)426

H46-1773     49364          Marinelli Lucia, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1774     33781          Marino Liliana, Interim Resolution DH(98)177

H32-1775     26005          Marino Ruggiero, Interim Resolution DH(96)503

H32-1776     37139          Marletta, Interim Resolution DH(99)173

H32-1777     25250          Marolda, Interim Resolution DH(96)186

H32-1778     29656          Martelli and Straccia, Interim Resolution DH(97)436

H46-1779     47784          Martinetti and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1780     32298          Martino, Interim Resolution DH(98)34

H46-431       44422          Marzinotto, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1781     44496          Masala, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1782     40972          Masi, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1783     37185          Massa, Interim Resolution DH(99)174

H46-432       46966          Massaro, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-433       46979          Mastrantonio Francesca, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1784     34849          Mastrocinque Giovanni, Interim Resolution DH(98)321

H46-182       47479          Mastromauro S.R.L., judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H32-1785     27453          Matarrese and Di Masi, Interim Resolution DH(97)66

H32-1786     39141          Matera, Interim Resolution DH(99)504

H46-1787     52973          Mattaliano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/0

H32-1788     35931          Matteoni O. F. A. and R., Interim Resolution DH(99)79

H46-434       44420          Mauri, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-1789     44391          Mauti, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1790     27187          Mazzà Giuseppe and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)38

H32-1791     26044          Mazzacuva, Interim Resolution DH(96)504

H32-1792     34828          Mazzella, Interim Resolution DH(98)322

H32-1793     33779          Mazzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)178

H32-1794     31328          Mazziotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)643

H46-1795     51655          Mazzoleni and others, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1796     29142          Mazzoli and 8 others, Interim Resolution DH(97)317

H32-1797     26417          Mazzone, Interim Resolution DH(96)538

H32-1798     26254          Medzihradszky, Interim Resolution DH(98)112

H32-1799     24798          Meistro and Santin, Interim Resolution DH(96)475

H46-1800     44438          Mel Sud S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1801     35917          Melchionna, Interim Resolution DH(99)80

H32-1802     26857          Meloni S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)634

H32-1803     24789          Meluso Angelo I, Interim Resolution DH(96)66

H32-1804     26416          Meluso Angelo II, Interim Resolution DH(96)539

H32-1805     38471          Meluso Angelo III, Interim Resolution DH(99)396

H32-1806     38472          Meluso Angelo IV, Interim Resolution DH(99)397

H32-1807     35288          Mengano and Morini, Interim Resolution DH(98)427

H32-1808     34269          Mercandino, Interim Resolution DH(98)245

H32-1809     30578          Merlanti, Interim Resolution DH(97)539

H32-1810     26419          Merra, Interim Resolution DH(96)540

H46-719       56101          Mesiti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1811     37168          Messina Giuseppe I, Interim Resolution DH(99)175

H32-1812     40574          Messina Giuseppe II, Interim Resolution DH(99)613

H32-1813     29146          Mezzatesta, Interim Resolution DH(97)318

H46-1814     49311          Mezzena, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1815     51654          Mezzetta, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1816     33796          Micanzi, Interim Resolution DH(98)179

H32-1817     38130          Michieli and Gentilini, Interim Resolution DH(99)295

H32-1818     34847          Milani, Interim Resolution DH(98)428

H32-1819     33798          Milano, Interim Resolution DH(98)180

H32-1820     35906          Milazzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)81

H46-1821     48403          Minici, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-1822     32280          Minnai, Interim Resolution DH(98)35

H32-1823     33163          Minniti and Lucianò, Interim Resolution DH(98)113

H32-1824     25218          Minotti, Interim Resolution DH(96)187

H46-1825     45098          Miola, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-1826     46540          MMB S.N.C. and Beloli, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1827     36612          Mobilio, Interim Resolution DH(99)176

H32-1828     36609          Molari, Interim Resolution DH(99)177

H46-1829     48417          Mole, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1830     51652          Molek, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1831     51650          Molinaris, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1832     34250          Monaco Maria, Interim Resolution DH(98)246

H32-1833     35909          Monorchio, Interim Resolution DH(99)82

H32-1834     39885          Montanari, Interim Resolution DH(99)614

H32-1835     32282          Monti, Interim Resolution DH(98)247

H32-1836     38492          Monticelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)398

H46-1837     49354          Morelli and Levantesi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-435       46973          Morelli and Nerattini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1838     39120          Morelli F. and G., Interim Resolution DH(99)505

H46-1839     45066          Morena, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H46-1840     48413          Morese II, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-1841     40932          Morese, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1842     45067          Moretti, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-1843     26428          Moroni, Interim Resolution DH(96)542

H32-1844     37138          Morra, Interim Resolution DH(99)178

H32-1845     34267          Morticella, Interim Resolution DH(98)248

H32-1846     39143          Moscarelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)506

H46-1847     52926          Mostacciuolo, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1848     36641          Mostosi, Interim Resolution DH(99)179

H32-1849     36656          Motta Umberto S.R.L., Interim Resolution DH(99)180

H32-1850     35293          Mucciola and Bottino, Interim Resolution DH(98)429

H32-1851     37153          Mugnaini Brandani, Interim Resolution DH(99)236

H46-436       44490          Murgia, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1852     46514          Murru I, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-1853     45091          Murru II, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-1854     45095          Murru III, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-1855     44386          Murru IV, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1856     56089          Murru V, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1857     34846          Musci, Interim Resolution DH(98)323

H32-1858     26002          Muso Aurelio I, Interim Resolution DH(96)505

H32-1859     30087          Muso Rosina, Interim Resolution DH(97)452

H46-1860     44507          Musti and Iarossi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1861     39868          N.M. and A.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)615

H32-1862     35329          N.Z., Interim Resolution DH(98)430

H32-1863     20043          Napoli and Mammoliti

H32-1864     27970          Nardelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)147

H32-1865     29661          Nardone Angelo I, Interim Resolution DH(97)438

H32-1866     37173          Nardone Angelo II, Interim Resolution DH(99)181

H32-1867     29667          Nardone Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(97)437

H46-1868     40949          Nardone Ennio and Antonella, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1869     27972          Naselli, Interim Resolution DH(97)148

H32-1870     39878          Nasto, Interim Resolution DH(99)616

H32-437       39872          Nata

H32-1871     38147          Nati II, Interim Resolution DH(99)296

H32-1872     33780          Nati, Interim Resolution DH(98)181

H32-1873     34277          Nazzaro, Interim Resolution DH(98)249

H32-1874     38500          Nembrini Gonzaga, Interim Resolution DH(99)399

H46-438       46522          Nolla, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-1875     38124          Novello, Interim Resolution DH(99)297

H46-1876     45072          Novotny, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-1877     29646          O. S.a.s., Interim Resolution DH(97)439

H32-1878     38108          O.B. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)298

H46-1879     44506          O.B. II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1880     29657          O.C., Interim Resolution DH(97)440

H46-1881     51698          O.M., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1882     26837          O.O., Interim Resolution DH(96)635

H46-439       44494          O.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-1883     49320          Onori, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1884     38473          Orelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)400

H32-1885     27463          Orlando and Fiorentino, Interim Resolution DH(97)67

H32-1886     35905          Orlando, Interim Resolution DH(99)101

H32-1887     36622          Orlandoni and Lapis, Interim Resolution DH(99)182

H32-1888     25232          Ottelli, Interim Resolution DH(96)476

H32-1889     26861          Ozimo and Lamanna, Interim Resolution DH(96)636

H46-1890     51692          P. and M.O., judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1891     34858          P. T. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)349

H32-1892     39864          P., M.R. and C.E., Interim Resolution DH(99)618

H32-1893     37144          P.A. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)209

H32-1894     37145          P.A. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)183

H32-1895     37146          P.A. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)184

H32-1896     26441          P.B. IV, Interim Resolution DH(96)543

H46-440       44468          P.B. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1897     27161          P.C. and F.Z., Interim Resolution DH(97)40

H32-1898     27976          P.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)151

H32-1899     39162          P.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)507

H32-1900     38140          P.D.B, Interim Resolution DH(99)299

H46-1901     47000          P.I., judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1902     14140          P.P. I

H32-1903     27460          P.P.II, Interim Resolution DH(97)68

H32-1904     25258          P.U. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)188

H32-1905     25259          P.U. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)189

H32-1906     25260          P.U. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)190

H32-1907     40568          Padalino R., C., and M.R., Interim Resolution DH(99)619

H46-441       40570          Padalino V. and G., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-1908     35994          Paderni I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 29/06/00

H32-1909     24334          Pala, Interim Resolution DH(95)428

H32-1910     36637          Paladini, Interim Resolution DH(99)185

H32-1911     28723          Pallotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)255

H32-1912     38127          Palmisano, Interim Resolution DH(99)312

H46-1913     49310          Palumbo, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1914     40565          Panarari and Turani, Interim Resolution DH(99)620

H32-1915     30579          Panella Bruno I, Interim Resolution DH(97)540

H32-1916     31349          Panella Bruno II, Interim Resolution DH(97)644

H32-443       21707          Panissa, D., G. and A. Vittonetto

H32-1917     35302          Panozzo, Interim Resolution DH(98)431

H32-1918     32295          Pansa, Interim Resolution DH(98)36

H46-1919     46991          Paolelli I, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-1920     44463          Paolelli II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1921     26033          Paolillo and Morini, Interim Resolution DH(96)506

H32-1922     40573          Paradiso Giorgio, Interim Resolution DH(99)621

H32-1923     24331          Parisi, Interim Resolution DH(95)429

H32-1924     25219          Parodi, Interim Resolution DH(96)191

H32-1925     40585          Pasinetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)622

H32-1926     34274          Pasquali Zanotti, Interim Resolution DH(98)258

H46-1927     45101          Pasquetti, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-1928     28056          Pasquino, Interim Resolution DH(97)645

H32-1929     27160          Passarella, Interim Resolution DH(97)41

H32-1930     38096          Passerini I, Interim Resolution DH(99)300

H32-1931     38097          Passerini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)301

H32-1932     39125          Pasta, Interim Resolution DH(99)508

H46-1933     51657          Pastrello, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1934     30095          Patelli and Pesenti, Interim Resolution DH(97)666

H32-1935     29169          Patrizi I, Interim Resolution DH(97)326

H32-1936     34833          Patteri, Interim Resolution DH(98)432

H46-1937     49396          Peda, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-1938     51700          Pelagagge, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-1939     56098          Pelagatti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1940     35338          Pellegrini Odilia, Interim Resolution DH(98)433

H32-1941     38489          Pepe, Interim Resolution DH(99)401

H32-1942     29664          Pepiciello, Interim Resolution DH(97)441

H32-1943     31337          Peresson, Interim Resolution DH(97)646

H46-1944     51699          Perico, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-444       39155          Perilli and Gigotti Micheli

H32-1945     24047          Perini, Interim Resolution DH(95)293

H46-1946     45894          Pernici and D'Ercole, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-1947     25267          Perrone, Interim Resolution DH(96)192

H32-1948     29160          Pesaresi and 8 others, Interim Resolution DH(97)319

H32-1949     33147          Pesarin, Interim Resolution DH(98)114

H46-1950     40923          Petix, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-1951     25246          Petromilli, Interim Resolution DH(96)193

H32-1952     29137          Pettinelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)320

H46-446       44380          Pettirossi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-1953     25248          Pezzati, Interim Resolution DH(96)194

H32-1954     30592          Pezzilli, Interim Resolution DH(97)541

H32-1955     34278          Pezzini, Interim Resolution DH(98)250

H32-1956     31644          Pia, Interim Resolution DH(97)647

H32-1957     29162          Piazzalunga II, Interim Resolution DH(97)321

H46-1958     51697          Piccinin, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1959     26031          Piccinini I, Interim Resolution DH(96)654

H32-1960     33167          Piccininno, Interim Resolution DH(98)182

H46-1961     45878          Piccirillo Angela, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1962     47003          Piccoli, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-1963     29655          Piccolo, Interim Resolution DH(97)442

H32-1964     35942          Picconi and Puggioni, Interim Resolution DH(98)434

H32-1965     31642          Pierfederici, Interim Resolution DH(97)648

H32-1966     29140          Pierucci, Interim Resolution DH(98)115

H32-1967     34862          Pioli, Interim Resolution DH(98)350

H32-448       39899          Pirilli

H32-1968     35283          Piscopo and 5 others, Interim Resolution DH(98)435

H46-1969     45874          Pittoni, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-1970     51665          Plebani, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-1971     26445          Poddighe and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)544

H32-1972     35901          Poli, Interim Resolution DH(99)83

H46-1973     52976          Policriti and Gioffré, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1974     34834          Polidoro, Interim Resolution DH(98)351

H32-1975     35317          Poligamma s.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(98)436

H32-1976     24794          Polperio and 7others I, Interim Resolution DH(96)71

H32-1977     24795          Polperio and 7 others II, Interim Resolution DH(96)72

H46-1978     44499          Pomante Pappalepore, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1979     37164          Poppi, Interim Resolution DH(99)237

H46-1980     44454          Porcelli, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-1981     30584          Porfilio, Interim Resolution DH(97)542

H46-1982     40967          Privitera, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-450       46967          Procaccianti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-451       46969          Procopio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-1983     27955          Proietti Valeri, Interim Resolution DH(97)136

H32-1984     37593          Provide S.r.l. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)624

H32-1985     40621          Provide s.r.l. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)625

H46-1986     49312          Provide S.R.L., judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-1987     13545          Provinzano

H32-1988     20235          Pucchielli

H32-1989     20208          Pucci

H32-1990     35911          Pucci and Veschi, Interim Resolution DH(99)84

H32-1991     27447          Puglia, Interim Resolution DH(97)69

H32-1992     25254          Pugliani and Cianca, Interim Resolution DH(96)195

H46-718       41803          Pupillo, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00; revised judgment

                                      of the just satisfaction of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02

H32-1993     39893          Quattrone Francesco, Interim Resolution DH(99)626

H46-452       44412          Quattrone Pasquale, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-1994     40927          R. I, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-1995     40964          R. II, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-1996     26440          R.D., Interim Resolution DH(96)545

H46-1997     52971          R.L., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-1998     33156          R.L.P., Interim Resolution DH(98)183

H32-1999     30090          R.M. IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)453

H46-2000     44526          R.P. and others, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2001     24807          R.P. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)73

H32-2002     36626          R.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)210

H32-2003     34245          R.R., Interim Resolution DH(98)251

H32-2004     36602          R.S.p.A., Interim Resolution DH(99)186

H32-2005     26425          R.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)546

H46-2006     44381          Raffa, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2007     26046          Raffi Giuliano I, Interim Resolution DH(96)507

H32-2008     26841          Raffi Giuliano II, Interim Resolution DH(96)637

H46-720       52962          Raffio, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2009     44524          Ragas, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02, revised judgment of 17/12/02

                                      (Article 41), final on 17/03/03[115]

H32-2010     35939          Ragnolini, Interim Resolution DH(99)85

H32-2011     27171          Ragusi, Bordandini, Pattuelli and Vidimian, Interim Resolution DH(97)42

H46-453       38498          Rando, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H32-2012     27162          Ranucci, Interim Resolution DH(97)103

H46-2013     52913          Rapisarda, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2014     19222          Rapotez

H32-2015     38495          Ravanelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)510

H46-2016     46984          Ravignani, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2017     35289          Redaelli Tecna S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(98)437

H32-2018     26014          Reinaudo, Interim Resolution DH(96)509

H32-2019     26847          Reni, Interim Resolution DH(96)638

H32-2020     36652          Reniero, Interim Resolution DH(99)238

H32-2021     26001          Ricchiuto, Interim Resolution DH(96)510

H32-2022     38483          Ricci Maria Annina, Interim Resolution DH(99)402

H32-2023     35327          Ricci Riccardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)438

H46-2024     46988          Ricci Silvia, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2025     26030          Riccioni, Interim Resolution DH(96)511

H32-2026     36617          Rico Giovanni I, Interim Resolution DH(99)187

H32-2027     36618          Rico Giovanni II, Interim Resolution DH(99)188

H32-2028     17049          Righetti

H46-455       44465          Rigutto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2029     25256          Ristoro G., A. and A., Interim Resolution DH(96)196

H46-2030     49357          Rizio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2031     26404          Rizza, Interim Resolution DH(96)547

H46-183       44409          Rizzo Giuseppe, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, rectified on 09/07/02

H32-2032     27983          Rizzo M. R. and G. and De Martino, Interim Resolution DH(97)157

H32-2033     38477          Rizzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)403

H32-2034     39892          Roberto R., M-L., C., and F., and Tudisco, Interim Resolution DH(99)627

H46-2035     51659          Roccatagliata, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2036     31345          Rocchi Almerico, Interim Resolution DH(97)649

H46-184       51664          Rodolfi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-2037     45887          Roma, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2038     26437          Romagnoli, Interim Resolution DH(96)548

H32-2039     33510          Romaniello G. and A., Interim Resolution DH(98)266

H32-2040     30089          Romaniello, Interim Resolution DH(97)454

H46-2041     52969          Romano Almanio Antonio, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2042     38106          Romei, Interim Resolution DH(99)302

H32-2043     40572          Rondinone, Interim Resolution DH(99)628

H46-2044     44531          Rongoni, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-2045     40948          Ronzulli, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2046     49361          Rosa Antonio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2047     36643          Rosa Elisabetta, Interim Resolution DH(99)189

H32-2048     34874          Roselli Italo I, Interim Resolution DH(98)439

H32-457       35328          Roselli Italo II

H46-2049     38480          Roselli Italo III, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-458       44479          Rosetti e Ciucci and C., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-459       44527          Rossana Ferrari, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2050     40598          Rossi Eufrasia, Interim Resolution DH(99)629

H32-2051     27971          Rossi Franca, Interim Resolution DH(97)171

H46-712       51710          Rossi Gianbattista, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-2052     52988          Rossi Maria Giovanna, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2053     34238          Rossi Romano, Interim Resolution DH(98)252

H46-460       44472          Rossi Valeria, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-710       51704          Rota Giacomo and Gianfranco, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-711       51705          Rota Roberto and Giuseppe, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2054     25236          Rotella and Zuccalà, Interim Resolution DH(96)197

H46-2055     46513          Rotiroti, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-2056     27977          Ruggeri, Interim Resolution DH(97)152

H32-2057     27478          Rullo Tassone, Interim Resolution DH(97)70

H32-2058     33143          S. C. IV, Interim Resolution DH(98)116

H32-2059     27962          S. D.P., Interim Resolution DH(97)141

H46-2060     40934          S., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2061     40184          S.A.GE.MA S.n.c. II, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-2062     24042          S.B., Interim Resolution DH(95)298

H32-2063     26042          S.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)78

H32-2064     26405          S.C. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)549

H32-2065     26407          S.D., Interim Resolution DH(96)550

H32-2066     39118          S.G., Interim Resolution DH(99)526

H32-2067     39148          S.I.E.L.P.A. S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)511

H32-2068     34864          S.I.P.I. S.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(98)324

H32-2069     38508          S.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)404

H32-2070     26414          S.P. and S.V., Interim Resolution DH(96)551

H46-2071     45061          S.S., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2072     24324          Sabia, Interim Resolution DH(95)441

H46-461       44461          Sacchi Roberto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2073     25107          Sacchi, Interim Resolution DH(96)115

H32-2074     37169          Salamanca, Interim Resolution DH(99)190

H32-185       30423          Salini Costruttori Spa, Interim Resolution DH(99)673

H32-2075     38111          Salomone, Interim Resolution DH(99)303

H32-2076     36642          Saltari, Interim Resolution DH(99)240

H32-2077     30104          Salvatore I, Interim Resolution DH(97)455

H32-2078     30105          Salvatore II, Interim Resolution DH(97)456

H32-2079     30106          Salvatore III, Interim Resolution DH(97)457

H32-2080     30110          Salvatore IV, Interim Resolution DH(97)458

H32-2081     30111          Salvatore V, Interim Resolution DH(97)459

H32-2082     30112          Salvatore VI, Interim Resolution DH(97)460

H46-2083     40943          Salvatori and Gardin, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-2084     49360          Salvi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H46-2085     44404          Salzano, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 04/04/01

H32-2086     31340          Sambati, Interim Resolution DH(97)650

H32-2087     27174          Samir, Interim Resolution DH(97)43

H46-462       38135          Sanna, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H32-2088     35929          Santarcangelo, Interim Resolution DH(99)86

H32-2089     30588          Santella, Interim Resolution DH(97)543

H46-2090     45895          Santini, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2091     26034          Santonocito and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)512

H46-463       44466          Santoro Valerio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-464       47780          Santorum, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2092     32288          Sapuppo, Interim Resolution DH(98)37

H32-2093     35326          Sardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)441

H32-2094     40569          Sarti, Interim Resolution DH(99)630

H46-2095     45069          Sartori, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-2096     30591          Sasso, Interim Resolution DH(97)544

H32-2097     38490          Saullo, Interim Resolution DH(99)405

H46-2098     49368          Savanna and La Selva, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2099     33166          Savini and Malaspina, Interim Resolution DH(98)117

H46-465       45854          Savino, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2100     52977          Savona II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2101     38479          Savona, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-466       44419          Sbrojavacca Pietrobon, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2102     34237          Scagliola, Interim Resolution DH(98)253

H32-2103     24021          Scala, Interim Resolution DH(95)299

H46-467       36621          Scalvini, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H46-2104     44489          Scannella Giuseppe, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2105     33793          Scannella, Interim Resolution DH(98)184

H32-2106     35904          Scappaticci A.F. and A., and Ruzza, Interim Resolution DH(99)87

H46-2107     40929          Scarano, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2108     30096          Scerra, Interim Resolution DH(97)461

H32-2109     24780          Schiavone, Interim Resolution DH(96)76

H46-2110     40623          Sciarrotta and Guarino, judgment of 05/04/00

H46-2111     52918          Scinto, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2112     32286          Scipioni, Mancini C.M., B. and D., Interim Resolution DH(98)38

H32-2113     24814          Scognamiglio II, Interim Resolution DH(96)116

H32-2114     38470          Scoppio, Interim Resolution DH(99)406

H32-2115     14578          Scotti II

H32-2116     26834          Scuderi Graziella, Interim Resolution DH(96)639

H46-2117     52983          Seccia, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-713       51672          Selva, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-2118     44467          Seminara, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2119     38119          Serino Luigi, Interim Resolution DH(99)304

H46-2120     49306          Servillo and D'Ambrosio, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-2121     44402          Servodidio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-2122     52959          Sessa, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2123     33151          Sestito, Sestito and Zaccone, Interim Resolution DH(98)118

H32-2124     37155          Severino, Interim Resolution DH(99)191

H32-2125     33787          Sferlazza, Interim Resolution DH(98)185

H32-2126     33148          Sgrò, Interim Resolution DH(98)119

H32-2127     27984          Sgroi, Interim Resolution DH(97)158

H46-2128     40945          Siega and 7 others, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2129     40577          Siena I, Interim Resolution DH(99)631

H46-2130     48415          Siena II, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2131     26432          Siface, Interim Resolution DH(96)552

H32-2132     26825          Silvan S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(96)640

H46-2133     44400          Silvestri, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-2134     27176          Simonetti (N.S.), Interim Resolution DH(97)39

H32-2135     30581          Simoni, Interim Resolution DH(97)545

H32-2136     26854          Simotti A, O. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)641

H32-2137     26402          Siniscalchi and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)553

H46-2138     44493          Siper S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2139     36604          Sirol Soc. Coop. a.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)192

H46-2140     52989          Sirufo, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2141     25243          SO.CO.AB.S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(97)291

H46-721       56093          Società Croce Gialla Romana S.a.s., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2142     35271          Società Sant'Andrea S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(98)442

H32-2143     32289          Société Générale de Sucreries, Interim Resolution DH(98)39

H32-2144     34240          Somigli, Interim Resolution DH(98)254

H46-468       44491          Sonego, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2145     33146          Sonego, Interim Resolution DH(98)120

H32-2146     39901          Sonzogno, Interim Resolution DH(99)632

H32-2147     34832          Sorace Carmelo, Interim Resolution DH(98)443

H32-2148     26004          Sorace Giuseppe I, Interim Resolution DH(96)513

H32-2149     38494          Sorace Giuseppe II, Interim Resolution DH(99)407

H32-2150     27468          Sorbo, Interim Resolution DH(97)168

H46-714       51670          Sordelli and C. S.n.c., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2151     25235          Sorrenti Alessandro II, Interim Resolution DH(96)198

H46-469       44470          Spada, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2152     35299          Spadon, Interim Resolution DH(98)444

H32-2153     27195          Spadoni Giacomo, Interim Resolution DH(97)44

H32-2154     38125          Spadoni Maurizio, Interim Resolution DH(99)305

H32-2155     39132          Spampani, Interim Resolution DH(99)512

H46-715       51711          Spanu, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H46-2156     46512          Sparano, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-2157     34232          Sparti, Interim Resolution DH(98)267

H46-2158     44487          Spera II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2159     26839          Spiccia, Interim Resolution DH(96)642

H32-2160     36613          Spinato, Interim Resolution DH(99)193

H46-2161     56105          Spinelli, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2162     29651          Spinosi, Interim Resolution DH(97)443

H32-2163     40618          Spitale, Interim Resolution DH(99)633

H32-2164     39873          Sportelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)634

H46-470       56094          Sposito, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-471       39705          Spurio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-2165     37142          Squeo, Interim Resolution DH(99)194

H46-2166     44503          Squillante Gennaro, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2167     39136          Squillante Pasquale, Interim Resolution DH(99)513

H46-2168     52990          Stabile, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2169     30586          Stacchiotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)651

H32-472       39865          Staffolani

H32-2170     35282          Statile, Interim Resolution DH(98)445

H46-2171     44518          Stefanini, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-702       49314          Steiner and Hassid Steiner, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002

H32-2172     25229          Sterchele C. and C., Interim Resolution DH(96)199

H46-2173     47002          Storti, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2174     21507          Stringini, Interim Resolution DH(97)104

H32-2175     25252          Strongoli I, Interim Resolution DH(96)200

H32-2176     25253          Strongoli II, Interim Resolution DH(96)201

H46-2177     45056          Studio Tecnico AMU S.A.S., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2178     27173          Sud Ovest S.A.S., Interim Resolution DH(97)45

H32-2179     24039          T. s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(95)302

H32-2180     37165          T.A.M., Interim Resolution DH(99)88

H32-2181     24040          T.M. and M.G.C., Interim Resolution DH(95)303

H32-2182     38521          T.M.A.2 S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)408

H32-2183     35937          T.P. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)89

H32-2184     24803          T.S.I. s.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(96)77

H32-2185     23566          T.-S.I., Interim Resolution DH(97)297

H32-2186     35298          Taddei, Interim Resolution DH(99)90

H46-473       44417          Tagliabue, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2187     33661          Tagliavini, Interim Resolution DH(98)446

H32-2188     36610          Talarico, Interim Resolution DH(99)239

H32-474       38102          Talenti

H46-2189     51656          Targi and Bianchi, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H46-2190     40933          Tarsia, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2191     33165          Tartaglia I, Interim Resolution DH(98)121

H46-2192     48402          Tartaglia II, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-475       44486          Tebaldi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2193     13692          Tedesco I

H32-2194     13693          Tedesco II

H32-2195     40593          Tedesco Mario Felice, Interim Resolution DH(99)636

H46-476       44425          Tedesco Michele, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-2196     46508          Teofili, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-2197     35913          Tesolin S. and F., Interim Resolution DH(99)91

H32-2198     30589          Tessadri, Interim Resolution DH(97)546

H46-716       51673          Tiozzo Peschiero L. and L., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2199     26436          Todesco Aldo, Interim Resolution DH(96)554

H32-2200     38468          Tommaselli C., A., M. V. and G., Interim Resolution DH(99)409

H46-2201     45862          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. I, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2202     45863          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2203     45864          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. III, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2204     45865          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. IV, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2205     45866          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. V, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-2206     45867          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. VI, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-477       46539          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.P.A. VII, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-2207     56100          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.p.a. VIII, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2208     39123          Torregiani, Interim Resolution DH(99)514

H54-2209     26433          Torri, judgment of 01/07/97

H32-2210     39903          Torzo, Interim Resolution DH(99)637

H32-2211     39167          Tosone, Interim Resolution DH(99)515

H46-2212     45104          Trapani Francesco II, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H32-2213     34265          Trapani, Interim Resolution DH(98)255

H46-2214     44439          Traspadini, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2215     34856          Tripodi Giacinto, Interim Resolution DH(98)352

H46-2216     40946          Tripodi Giuseppe, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00, revised judgment of

                                      23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2217     27177          Tripodo M, C. and G. and Leonardo, Interim Resolution DH(97)46

H32-2218     34230          Trippa, Interim Resolution DH(98)256

H32-2219     38491          Triuzzi, Interim Resolution DH(99)410

H32-2220     34844          Trivellini, Interim Resolution DH(98)353

H32-2221     27961          Troccolo and Carrassi L. and C., Interim Resolution DH(97)172

H46-2222     44478          Troiani I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2223     31637          Troncato, Interim Resolution DH(98)40

H32-2224     38510          Tulli, Interim Resolution DH(99)411

H46-2225     45879          Turchini, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H32-2226     36632          Turetta, Interim Resolution DH(99)195

H32-2227     35267          Tuso, Interim Resolution DH(98)447

H32-2228     26013          Uricchio, Interim Resolution DH(96)514

H32-2229     27198          V. and R.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)47

H32-2230     29168          V. L.S., Interim Resolution DH(97)322

H32-2231     36628          V.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)196

H32-2232     36634          V.D.P., Interim Resolution DH(99)197

H46-186       51674          V.I., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 04/09/2002[116]

H32-2233     31342          V.L., Interim Resolution DH(97)652

H32-2234     25234          V.M. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)202

H32-2235     29130          V.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)323

H32-2236     30216          V.N., Interim Resolution DH(97)653

H32-2237     33155          V.P. and F.P., Interim Resolution DH(98)122

H32-2238     26401          V.R. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)655

H32-2239     30103          V.R. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)462

H46-2240     52967          Vaccarella, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2241     30101          Vaccari, Interim Resolution DH(97)463

H46-2242     46977          Vaccarisi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2243     23147          Vaggelli-Lupi, Interim Resolution DH(96)245

H46-2244     44459          Vairano, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-2245     49356          Valenti, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2246     24793          Valentini, Interim Resolution DH(96)79

H46-2247     44398          Valentino, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2248     38467          Valeri and Valeri and Rosa, Interim Resolution DH(99)412

H32-2249     37180          Valerio, Interim Resolution DH(99)198

H32-2250     34836          Valesani, Interim Resolution DH(98)354

H32-2251     27980          Valsecchi, Interim Resolution DH(97)155

H46-2252     44384          Valvo and Branca, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2253     27455          Vannucchi, Interim Resolution DH(97)71

H46-717       51707          Vanzetti, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-2254     40584          Vardaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)638

H32-2255     25251          Varvaro, Interim Resolution DH(96)477

H32-2256     36607          Vasto, Interim Resolution DH(99)241

H32-2257     37172          Vattano, Interim Resolution DH(99)199

H46-2258     56086          Vazzana, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-479       44488          Vecchi and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-480       44528          Vecchini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2259     34253          Vedovato, Interim Resolution DH(98)257

H46-722       52960          Ventrone, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2260     56096          Venturin, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-481       44534          Venturini Alberto I, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-2261     44535          Venturini III, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2262     33801          Verdelli, Interim Resolution DH(98)186

H32-2263     27166          Verini I, Interim Resolution DH(97)105

H32-482       40586          Verini II

H46-2264     46982          Verini III, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2265     46983          Verini IV, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2266     46992          Verini V, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2267     16087          Vernillo

H32-2268     35948          Verza, Interim Resolution DH(99)92

H32-2269     25222          Vesentini, Interim Resolution DH(96)203

H46-2270     52965          Vetrone, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-2271     18011          Vicari G., R., and V.

H32-2272     36654          Vicari I, Interim Resolution DH(99)200

H46-483       40599          Vicari II, judgment of 15/02/00

H32-2273     19835          Villani I

H46-2274     51663          Villanova, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2275     35306          Vincenti Salvatore, Interim Resolution DH(98)448

H46-2276     40935          Vinci, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H32-2277     38501          Viola, Interim Resolution DH(99)413

H46-484       44395          Visentin, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-485       37166          Vitale and others, judgment of 02/11/99

H32-2278     29144          Vitali I, Interim Resolution DH(97)324

H32-2279     34875          Vitone, Interim Resolution DH(98)235

H32-2280     29164          Vivian, Interim Resolution DH(97)325

H46-2281     45064          Von Berger Icilio and Luciano, judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2282     26850          Von Berger Icilio I, Interim Resolution DH(96)644

H32-2283     26851          Von Berger Icilio II, Interim Resolution DH(96)645

H32-2284     26852          Von Berger Icilio III, Interim Resolution DH(96)646

H32-2285     35926          Von Berger Luciano I, Interim Resolution DH(99)93

H32-2286     35927          Von Berger Luciano II, Interim Resolution DH(99)94

H32-2287     27471          W.B., Interim Resolution DH(97)72

H46-486       44445          W.I.E. S.n.c., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-2288     45060          X200 S.R.L., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2289     39127          Zagato, Interim Resolution DH(99)516

H46-487       44462          Zanasi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2290     23587          Zanelli

H32-2291     40606          Zanon and Lazzaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)640

H32-2292     27185          Zappavigna and Andriano, Interim Resolution DH(97)48

H32-2293     27966          Zarzana, Interim Resolution DH(97)144

H32-2294     34257          Zavatta I, Interim Resolution DH(98)259

H32-2295     34259          Zavatta II, Interim Resolution DH(98)355

H32-2296     27175          Zilaghe and Dettori, Interim Resolution DH(97)49

H46-488       37079          Zironi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-2297     27451          Zoccali, Interim Resolution DH(97)73

H32-2298     39133          Zoccola, Interim Resolution DH(99)517

H46-723       52963          Zotti and Ferrara I, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2299     52964          Zotti and Ferrara II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2300     52966          Zotti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2301     45087          Zurzolo, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

                   - 7 cases concerning execution proceedings

H46-2302     40958          A.V. and A.B., judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H32-2303     34273          De Luca Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(98)233

H54-2304     15797          Di Pede, judgment of 26/09/96

H32-2305     35290          Finocchiaro, Interim Resolution DH(99)494

H46-2306     40969          Muso Aurelio II, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-2307     40981          Muso Aurelio III, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/07/00

H54-2308     24295          Zappia, judgment of 26/09/96

                   - 117 cases before the administrative courts

H46-489       41809          A.B. V, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-187       56226          Abate and Ferdinandi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2309     29171          Abbate Giovanni, Interim Resolution DH(97)367

H54-2310     25587          Abenavoli, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-727       41806          Alesiani and 510 others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2311     26863          Almanno, Interim Resolution DH(96)611

H46-728       41805          Arivella, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2312     25579          B.Q., Interim Resolution DH(96)213

H32-2313     26864          Bacci Roberto Maria, Interim Resolution DH(96)612

H32-2314     25585          Bagnoli and Mazzone G., A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)214

H32-2315     34878          Barcellona, Interim Resolution DH(99)202

H32-2316     35343          Bertozzi, Vorrasi, Ciarmoli and Forgione, Interim Resolution DH(99)642

H32-725       27189          Bevilacqua

H46-490       34437          Caliendo, judgment of 14/03/00, final on 14/03/00

H46-491       41817          Caliri, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-188       44341          Cannone, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-189       44347          Carapella and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H32-2317     19977          Carriero, Interim Resolution DH(96)26

H32-2318     31628          Catania, Interim Resolution DH(99)414

H32-2319     25576          Cavaliero s.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(96)215

H32-2320     34882          Cecamore, Interim Resolution DH(99)203

H46-2321     44332          Cecchini, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-190       44350          Cecere Domenico, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-191       56222          Centis, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2322     29170          Cerruto, Interim Resolution DH(97)368

H32-2323     29125          Chierici B. and E., Interim Resolution DH(97)331

H46-729       41804          Ciotta, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/011

H46-192       56206          Colonnello and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-2324     41811          Comitini, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-193       56208          Conte and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-194       56202          Cornia, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2325     27494          Corona Vincenzo, Interim Resolution DH(97)020

H32-2326     25577          Cosma, Interim Resolution DH(96)216

H32-2327     25588          D.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)217

H46-195       56224          D’Amore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2328     27996+        D'Amico and Altobelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)130

H46-196       56217          De Cesaris, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H54-2329     25574          De Santa, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-2330     20359          Della Sala Raffaele, Interim Resolution DH(96)614

H46-197       44337          Delli Paoli, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-198       56205          Dente, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2331     14147+        Di Bonaventura

H46-199       56225          Di Pede II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-200       56221          Donato, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-731       44525          Ferrari Marcella II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-732       44379          Finessi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-201       56212          Folletti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-202       44349          Fragnito, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H32-2332     30600          G. D.P., Interim Resolution DH(97)525

H32-2333     25584          G.L.C., Interim Resolution DH(96)218

H32-2334     31622          G.O. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)654

H46-730       35956          Galatà and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-737       44342          Gattuso, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002

H46-203       44340          Gaudenzi, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-204       56203          Ginocchio, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2335     25580          Giorgini, Interim Resolution DH(96)219

H54-2336     25586          Lapalorcia, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-2337     25581          Latini, Interim Resolution DH(96)220

H46-205       44334          Lattanzi and Cascia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-206       56204          Limatola, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-207       56207          Lugnan in Basile, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2338     15080          Magnaghi, Interim Resolution DH(96)379

H32-2339     27994+        Manzini and Benet, Interim Resolution DH(97)129

H46-733       44343          Massimo Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-734       44352          Massimo Giuseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-208       56220          Mastropasqua, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2340     38149          Mazzone G. and E. (I), Interim Resolution DH(99)306

H32-2341     38150          Mazzone G. and E. (II), Interim Resolution DH(99)307

H46-2342     33804          Mennitto, judgment of 05/10/00

H32-2343     25589          Mentastro, Interim Resolution DH(96)221

H46-209       38594          Mereu and S. Maria Navarrese, judgment of 13/06/2002, final on 13/09/2002

H46-2344     44338          Miele, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-493       41815          Monti Enrico, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-2345     17814          Mori Puddu, Interim Resolution DH(97)177

H46-494       41810          Mosca, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-2346     38526          Murgo M, O, and S. and Giannone, Interim Resolution DH(99)415

H32-2347     30322          Nani, Interim Resolution DH(98)193

H46-210       56211          Napolitano Giuseppe, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-211       44348          Nazzaro and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H54-2348     25839          Nicodemo, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-2349     44335          O., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-2350     18908          P.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)111

H46-212       44351          Pace and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H32-2351     35950+        Paglietti and 126 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)99

H46-496       41816          Paradiso Antonio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-724       15800+        Perego and Romanet

H46-213       56213          Piacenti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-214       56223          Polcari, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2352     34880          Polto Miranda, Interim Resolution DH(99)204

H46-215       56219          Presel, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-497       31631          Procaccini, judgment of 30/03/00, final on 30/03/00

H32-2353     27999+        Recinelli and Corona, Interim Resolution DH(97)132

H32-2354     27493          Recinelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)21

H32-2355     27997          Ridolfi, Interim Resolution DH(97)131

H46-735       44345          Rinaudo and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-216       56214          Ripoli I, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-217       56215          Ripoli II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2356     26865+        Rubbo and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)613

H32-2357     34881          Ruocco, Interim Resolution DH(99)643

H32-2358     25582          Sansoni, Interim Resolution DH(96)222

H32-2359     31625          Santoro Claudio, Interim Resolution DH(97)655

H46-218       56201          Sardo Salvatore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2360     29672          Scopelliti II, Interim Resolution DH(97)469

H32-2361     27484+        Serino and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)133

H32-2362     25450          Spera Michele, Interim Resolution DH(97)372

H46-219       56218          Stabile Michele, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-2363     34283          Stampacchia, Interim Resolution DH(98)272

H32-2364     25583          Stracuzzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)241

H32-2365     25578          Turrina and Scattolini, Interim Resolution DH(96)223

H32-2366     31620          U. P., Interim Resolution DH(97)656

H32-2367     38152          Ullo, Interim Resolution DH(99)308

H46-738       44333          V.P. and F.D.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-736       44346          Venturini Alberto II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2368     29301          Vitali II, Interim Resolution DH(97)332

H32-2369     29302          Vitali III, Interim Resolution DH(97)333

H32-2370     39170          Zappalà, Interim Resolution DH(99)523

H46-498       41814          Zeoli and 34 others, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 05/10/00

                   - 363 cases before the labour courts

H46-2371     44390          A.V. II, judgment of 06/11/01, final on 06/02/02

H32-2372     27991+        Accuosto and Saviello, Interim Resolution DH(97)166

H46-224       51031          Aceto and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2373     38141          Altieri, Interim Resolution DH(99)313

H46-2374     48421          Altomonte, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2375     36648          Ambrosino Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(99)211

H32-2376     33145          Antonini Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(98)124

H32-2377     28771          Apicella, Interim Resolution DH(97)290

H46-2378     32375          Aprile De Puoti, judgment of 09/11/99

H46-225       51089          Armellino Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2379     51093          Armellino Lucia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2380     44469          Ascolinio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-2381     27462          Bagli and Musumeci, Interim Resolution DH(97)79

H32-2382     39891          Balbi, Interim Resolution DH(99)645

H32-2383     40605          Barone Maria, Interim Resolution DH(99)646

H32-2384     34271          Belloni, Interim Resolution DH(98)260

H46-226       52824          Belviso and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2385     38115          Ben Charfeddine, Interim Resolution DH(99)314

H32-2386     28769          Benedetto, Interim Resolution DH(97)257

H46-2387     56091          Bernardini, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2388     56103          Bevilacqua Giovanni, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-227       52804          Bianco Pellegrino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-228       52816          Biondi and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-229       51030          Biondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2389     35918          Buffa, Interim Resolution DH(99)95

H32-2390     29645          C.A., Interim Resolution DH(97)418

H46-2391     45883          C.a.r.l. en Liquidation II, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H46-2392     45882          C.a.r.l.en Liquidation I, judgment of 16/01/01, final on 16/04/01

H32-2393     26439          Cagnetta, Interim Resolution DH(96)559

H32-2394     28747          Cairella, Interim Resolution DH(97)258

H46-2395     51150          Calabrese, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2396     48408          Calo, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2397     40595          Camerino, Interim Resolution DH(99)648

H32-2398     39169          Capoluongo Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(99)649

H32-2399     40619          Capoluongo M.R.V., Interim Resolution DH(99)650

H32-2400     28745          Caporaso Carmela, Interim Resolution DH(97)259

H32-2401     38142          Capozzi Di Stefano, Interim Resolution DH(99)316

H32-516       36615          Cappello, Interim Resolution DH(99)212

H32-2402     38120          Cappelloni, Interim Resolution DH(99)315

H46-2403     49319          Capri, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H32-517       38095          Cardillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)317

H46-2404     51134          Cardo Cristina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2406     51146          Cardo Elisa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2407     48414          Carlucci, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-2408     51127          Carolla, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised judgment of 28/11/2002,

                                      final on 28/02/2003[117]

H32-2409     40612          Caruso Angelina, Interim Resolution DH(99)652

H32-2410     35339          Cascone and Marrazzo, Interim Resolution DH(98)449

H32-2411     37136          Cassandra Luigi I, Interim Resolution DH(99)213

H32-2412     40600          Celentano, Interim Resolution DH(99)653

H46-230       52835          Cerbo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2413     29131          Cherubini, Interim Resolution DH(97)369

H46-2414     56102          Ciampaglia, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-231       52801          Ciarmoli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-518       46521          Ciccardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-2415     31343          Cimadoro, Interim Resolution DH(97)623

H46-232       52815          Cimmino and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2416     51112          Circelli Maria Antonia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2417     28741          Circelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)260

H46-233       52807          Ciullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2418     28739          Cocchiaro, Interim Resolution DH(97)261

H46-520       44532          Colacrai, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-234       52821          Colangelo Domenico, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2419     51116          Colella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2420     26827          Conti Filippo, Interim Resolution DH(96)663

H32-2421     39888          Coppola, Interim Resolution DH(99)651

H32-2422     38502          Corrarello I, Interim Resolution DH(99)416

H32-2423     39149          Corrarello II, Interim Resolution DH(99)518

H32-2424     39146          Correnti, Interim Resolution DH(99)519

H46-2425     51147          Crisci, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-235       51164          Crovella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2427     56104          Cullari, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-2428     51154          Cuozzo Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2429     51149          Cuozzo Giovanna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2430     28766+        Cusano and La Salvia, Interim Resolution DH(97)262

H32-2431     37186          Cutillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)214

H46-236       51163          D’Angelo Michele, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2939     33141          De Candia, Interim Resolution DH(98)125

H46-237       51125          De Filippo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2405     51098          De la Rosa Giovanna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2940     28763          De Luca Maria, Interim Resolution DH(97)264

H46-2426     51141          De Rosa Maria, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2941     34254          De Sando, Interim Resolution DH(98)261

H46-3110     51137          Del Grosso Nicola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2942     28767          Del Pozzo, Interim Resolution DH(97)265

H46-3111     51160          Del Re, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-238       51027          Del Vecchio Anna Rita, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-239       51155          Della Ratta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2943     28736          Delle Donne, Interim Resolution DH(97)266

H46-3112     51129          Di Dio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-530       46975          Di Gabriele, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2944     38112          Di Gilio, Voto, Peduto and Notari, Interim Resolution DH(99)318

H46-3113     51131          Di Maria, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-241       52846          Di Meo Antonio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-240       52813          Di Meo and Masotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3114     51099          Di Meo Franca, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-242       51092          Di Mezza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2945     43011          Di Niro, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H32-2946     23243          Di Paola, Interim Resolution DH(96)242

H46-3115     51157          Di Resta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2947     40616          Di Santo, Interim Resolution DH(99)654

H46-2948     44414          Di Sisto, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-3116     51143          Donato Pepe, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2949     28743          D'Onofrio Gelsomina, Interim Resolution DH(97)263

H32-2950     39153          Dottorini, Interim Resolution DH(99)520

H46-2951     48404          Dragonetti, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2952     32292          E.Z., Interim Resolution DH(98)42

H46-2953     48420          Efisio Pisano, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2954     37184          Esposito Loredana, Interim Resolution DH(99)215

H46-3117     51119          Esposito Lucia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-533       46978          F.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2955     35269          F.V. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)450

H32-2956     33157          Falbo, Interim Resolution DH(98)126

H32-2957     27990          Falco, Interim Resolution DH(97)165

H46-3118     51145          Falluto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3119     51121          Falzarano Pasquale, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-243       51156          Fasulo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, rectified on 12/09/2002

H46-244       51091          Ferrara Clementina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/2002

H46-3120     51128          Ferrara Serafina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2958     25220          Ferrari Giampiero, Interim Resolution DH(96)212

H46-2959     33440          Ferrari Marcella I, judgment of 28/07/99

H46-3121     51144          Fiorenza Carmine, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3122     51142          Formato, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2960     40613          Formichella, Interim Resolution DH(99)655

H46-2961     45897          Forte, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-536       45855          Fr.C., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-245       52843          Franco and Basile, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2962     36619          Franklin, Interim Resolution DH(99)216

H46-741       52924          Frattini and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02, revised judgment

                                      of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003[118]

H32-2963     33150          G. D. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)451

H32-2964     24826          G.B. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)59

H32-2965     39163          G.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)521

H32-2966     24779          G.B.S., Interim Resolution DH(96)60

H32-2967     30093          G.D.Z., Interim Resolution DH(97)552

H32-2968     28744          Gagliarde, Interim Resolution DH(97)267

H46-246       51161          Gagliardi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2969     51103          Gattone and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised judgment of

                                      03/10/02, final on 03/01/03[119]

H46-3123     51135          Gaudino Palma, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2970     37176+        Gazzo, Rossini, Poli, Dal Forno and Ferro, Interim Resolution DH(99)217

H46-3124     47186          Gentile Agostino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-540       37170          Giampietro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-2971     28749          Giannini, Interim Resolution DH(97)268

H46-247       52830          Giannotta and Iannella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2972     39905          Gilio Antonia, Interim Resolution DH(99)656

H46-3125     51148          Gisondi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-2973     48407          Giuseppina Romano, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02

H32-2974     34850          Grassi, Interim Resolution DH(98)356

H46-3126     51159          Grasso Alfonsina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2975     26807          Grosso, Interim Resolution DH(96)243

H46-545       39124          Guagenti, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-248       51094          Iacobucci and Lavorgna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2976     38144          Iammarino, Interim Resolution DH(99)319

H46-3127     51153          Iannotta Antonietta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2977     24806          Iaria, Interim Resolution DH(96)61

H46-3128     51102          Iesce and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2978     39890          Iescone, Interim Resolution DH(99)657

H32-2979     39145          Incarbone, Interim Resolution DH(99)522

H32-2980     27981          Iudica, Interim Resolution DH(97)162

H46-3129     51120          Izzo Antonio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2981     39889          Izzo Domenico, Interim Resolution DH(99)658

H46-249       51170          Izzo Giovanni, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2982     24694          L.C. I, Interim Resolution DH(96)517

H32-2983     26442          La Bella, Interim Resolution DH(96)560

H46-3130     51021          La Torella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-250       52802          Lagozzino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2984     28737          Lamberti, Interim Resolution DH(97)269

H32-2985     36639          Lapolla, Interim Resolution DH(99)218

H46-251       52812          Lavorgna and Iorio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2986     38103          Lentini, Interim Resolution DH(99)320

H32-2987     38512          Leonessa, Interim Resolution DH(99)417

H32-2988     37182          Leonetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)219

H32-2989     40592          Liberato, Interim Resolution DH(99)659

H32-2990     32291          Lilli, Interim Resolution DH(98)43

H46-3131     51140          Lombardi Emma, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3132     51100          Lombardi Gaetana, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2991     26009          Lombardo Sestilio, Interim Resolution DH(96)518

H32-2992     28762+        Longo, D'Occhio and Bruno, Interim Resolution DH(97)270

H46-2993     48405          Lucio Mario Catillo, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-2994     27446          M. D.C. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)81

H46-252       52822          Macolino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2995     29166          Maiale, Interim Resolution DH(97)330

H46-253       52819          Mancino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-2996     36644          Maniglio, Interim Resolution DH(99)220

H32-2997     35936          Marasco, Interim Resolution DH(99)321

H32-2998     35947          Marchese Giuseppina, Interim Resolution DH(99)96

H32-2999     27202+        Marino Ettore and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)82

H46-254       51169          Marotta Alberto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3133     51138          Marotta Arturo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-556       37160          Marsicovetere, Interim Resolution DH(99)221

H32-3000     38117          Marsili, Interim Resolution DH(99)322

H46-255       51168          Martino Alfonso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3001     29123          Mascia, Interim Resolution DH(97)553

H32-3002     28750          Massimo, Interim Resolution DH(97)271

H32-3003     40608          Mastrantone, Interim Resolution DH(99)660

H46-256       52827          Mastrocinque Mafalda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3004     29649          Mastronunzio, Interim Resolution DH(97)419

H46-257       51167          Matera Tommasina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3005     42993          Mattiello, judgment of 27/07/00, final on 27/10/00

H46-3134     51101          Maturo and Vegliante, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3006     28758          Maturo, Interim Resolution DH(97)272

H46-3007     49322          Mazzacchera, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

H46-258       52845          Mazzarelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3008     28760          Mazzilli, Interim Resolution DH(97)273

H46-3135     51130          Mazzone and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3136     51158          Meccariello, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3009     30098          Mecozzi, Interim Resolution DH(97)421

H46-3137     51118          Melillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-740       51677          Meneghini, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002

H32-3010     28752          Mennillo, Interim Resolution DH(97)274

H46-259       52818          Meola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3011     40594          Mideo, Interim Resolution DH(99)661

H32-3012     33164          Minieri, Interim Resolution DH(98)357

H46-3138     51133          Moffa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-260       52840          Mongillo Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3013     39887          Montano, Interim Resolution DH(99)662

H32-3014     38518          Morzillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)418

H32-3015     30596          Mostacciulo, Interim Resolution DH(97)549

H32-3016     32301          Mostacciuolo, Interim Resolution DH(98)44

H32-3017     26003          Napoli Elio, Interim Resolution DH(96)664

H32-3018     31348          Napoli, Interim Resolution DH(98)55

H46-3019     44415          Napolitano, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-261       44428          Nardone Antonio, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-3020     51123          Natalina de Rosa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3139     51136          Nazzaro, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-262       52832          Nero and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3021     21438          Nicoletti, Interim Resolution DH(96)111

H32-3022     27191          O.F.T., Interim Resolution DH(97)83

H46-263       51029          Ocone, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3023     39886          Olgato, Interim Resolution DH(99)663

H32-3024     38522          Orsillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)419

H46-3025     40966          P., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H32-3026     27193          P.V.G., Interim Resolution DH(97)84

H46-3140     51105          Pacifico, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-264       51114          Paduano, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3027     28756          Pagnano, Interim Resolution DH(97)275

H46-265       52829          Pallotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3028     28732          Palma, Interim Resolution DH(97)276

H46-266       51023          Palmieri Maddalena, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised judgment

                                      of 18/04/02, final on 18/07/02

H46-267       51022          Palmieri Mario Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-268       52841          Panza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3029     29152          Paolini, Interim Resolution DH(97)327

H32-3030     36650          Papa Saletta, Interim Resolution DH(99)222

H32-3031     36630          Pappalardo, Interim Resolution DH(99)223

H32-3032     38143          Paradiso Marilena, Interim Resolution DH(99)323

H32-3033     40611          Parente, Interim Resolution DH(99)664

H46-270       52842          Pascale Elda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-269       52837          Pascale and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-271       52826          Pascale Maria Annunziata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3034     28740          Pasquariello, Interim Resolution DH(97)277

H46-3035     44444          Pastore, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-3036     32277          Patrizi II, Interim Resolution DH(98)045

H46-3141     51111          Patuto Salvatore, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3142     51113          Pelosi Concetta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-272       51162          Pengue, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-273       52808          Perna Giuseppina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3037     26856          Persia, Interim Resolution DH(96)665

H32-3038     40610          Pesce Agnese, Interim Resolution DH(99)665

H32-3039     37174          Pesce Giuseppa, Interim Resolution DH(99)224

H46-274       52828          Petrillo and Petrucci, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-275       51025          Petrillo Gino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3040     36649          Petrillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)225

H32-3041     34262          Petrone, Interim Resolution DH(98)262

H46-3042     44529          Pezzuto, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-3043     35946          Piazza, Interim Resolution DH(99)097

H46-3044     46509          Picconi, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H32-3045     34837          Piconi, Interim Resolution DH(98)326

H32-3046     28761          Piesco, Interim Resolution DH(97)278

H46-3143     51139          Pilla Addolorata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3047     28759          Pilla Michele, Interim Resolution DH(97)279

H46-276       51024          Porto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3048     34279          Pristerà, Interim Resolution DH(98)263

H32-3049     40622          Proietti Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(99)666

H32-3050     32293          Prologo, Interim Resolution DH(98)46

H46-277       52825          Pucella and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3051     17292          R.d.R.

H32-3052     26045          R.M. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)519

H32-3053     26429          R.S. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)562

H46-278       51126          Raccio Emilia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3054     28722          Radicioni, Interim Resolution DH(97)280

H32-3055     40615          Ranaldo Pellegrino, Interim Resolution DH(99)667

H32-3056     33149          Regino, Interim Resolution DH(98)187

H46-3057     48409          Reino, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-279       51109          Restuccio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3144     51095          Riccardi Lucia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-280       52820          Riccardi Vicenzina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3145     51096          Riccio and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3146     51108          Rinaldi Giovanni, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3058     28753          Rinaldi Giuseppe, Interim Resolution DH(97)281

H46-569       46974          Risola, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-281       52823          Romano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-282       52844          Romano Rosa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3059     38113          Rotondi II, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H46-3147     51151          Ruggiero, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3060     17336          Rulli

H32-3061     37162          S.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(99)226

H32-3062     34246          Sabio, Interim Resolution DH(98)264

H32-3063     40609          Saccone, Interim Resolution DH(99)668

H46-283       52833          Santagata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-284       51165          Santina Pelosi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3064     28751          Sanzari, Interim Resolution DH(97)282

H32-3065     38131          Sarli, Interim Resolution DH(99)324

H32-3066     28754          Sauchella, Interim Resolution DH(97)283

H32-3067     29165          Savoia II, Interim Resolution DH(97)328

H46-3068     51090          Scaccianemici, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised judgment of

                                      03/10/02, final on 03/01/03[120]

H32-3069     30107          Scagnoli, Interim Resolution DH(97)550

H46-3070     44389          Scarfone, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-3071     52982          Sciacchitano and Lo Sciuto, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-3072     31638          Sciarra, Interim Resolution DH(97)657

H46-285       40151          Sciarrotta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H32-3073     24784          Scognamiglio I, Interim Resolution DH(96)117

H32-3074     34255          Sellan, Interim Resolution DH(98)265

H32-3075     28746          Serena and De Filippo, Interim Resolution DH(97)284

H46-3076     52917          Serino Antonella, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-3077     28738          Simeone, Interim Resolution DH(97)285

H46-3078     52831          Simone and Pontillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised judgment of

                                      03/10/02, final on 03/01/03[121]

H32-3079     27454          Società Italiana Cauzioni S.p.a., Interim Resolution DH(97)85

H32-3080     30595          Soriano, Interim Resolution DH(97)551

H46-3148     51115          Spagnoletti, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3081     40607          Sperandeo, Interim Resolution DH(99)669

H32-3082     34865+        Spiezio and Di Furia, Interim Resolution DH(98)358

H46-3083     48406          Stefanucci, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H32-3084     33162          Stile, Interim Resolution DH(98)127

H46-286       52839          Tanzillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3085     51122          Tarantino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3086     40591          Tascione, Interim Resolution DH(99)670

H46-287       52836          Tazza and Zullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-288       52810          Tazza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3087     28748          Tedesco Luigi, Interim Resolution DH(97)286

H32-3088     33799          Tesauro, Interim Resolution DH(98)188

H32-3089     39876          Tola, Interim Resolution DH(99)671

H46-3090     52922          Tommaso, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-3091     48410          Tozzi, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-3149     51152          Tretola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-576       46960          Trimboli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-289       52809          Truocchio Edmondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-290       51166          Truocchio Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-291       51124          Tudisco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3092     45108          Tullio D'Angelo, judgment of 12/10/00, final on 12/01/01

H46-3150     51097          Uccellini and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-292       52817          Urbano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-293       51026          Uzzo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3093     27466          V.B. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)086

H32-3094     34871          Venzo, Interim Resolution DH(98)359

H32-3095     39907          Verde, Interim Resolution DH(99)672

H32-3096     33785          Vespucci, Interim Resolution DH(98)189

H32-3097     28755          Vigliotti, Interim Resolution DH(97)287

H46-294       52811          Villari, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H46-3098     44416          Viola, judgments of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02 and du 07/11/02, final on 07/02/03[122]

H32-3099     28757          Viscio, Interim Resolution DH(97)288

H32-3100     33783          Visco and Montuoro I, Interim Resolution DH(98)190

H32-3101     33784          Visco and Montuoro II, Interim Resolution DH(98)191

H46-295       52847          Viscuso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3102     27167          Vitale Rosa, Interim Resolution DH(97)87

H46-296       51028          Vitelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3103     27989          Volpe, Interim Resolution DH(97)164

H32-3104     17765          Zaffarana, Interim Resolution DH(96)244

H32-3105     36647          Zampetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)227

H46-3151     51132          Zeolla, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3106     38517          Zito, Interim Resolution DH(99)420

H46-297       52814          Zoccolillo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

H32-3107     28735          Zollo, Interim Resolution DH(97)289

H32-3108     27987          Zuccardi Merli, Interim Resolution DH(97)163

H32-3109     29134          Zullino, Interim Resolution DH(97)329

H46-298       52800          Zuotto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02

                   - 118 cases before the criminal courts

H32-2432    21807+       A. and A.F. and A.R., Interim Resolution DH(97)176

H32-2433    27141         A.A.Q. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)128

H32-2434    21068         A.M. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)366

H32-2435    23356         A.R. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)47

H32-2436    21873         Achilli, Interim Resolution DH(98)91

H46-2437    35207         Aggiato, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2438    33454         Albé, Interim Resolution DH(99)421

H32-2439    22873         Arconte I, Interim Resolution DH(98)48

H32-2440    31230         Arconte II, Interim Resolution DH(99)102

H46-2441    44970         Arganese, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2442    20854         Arichetta, Interim Resolution DH(97)108

H32-2443    24920         Ballestra, Interim Resolution DH(98)268

H46-299      38576         Barattelli Carlo, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H32-2444    27584         Bertelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)325

H46-300      41863         Boldrin Stefano, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H32-2445    24909         Bonomo, Interim Resolution DH(99)228

H32-2446    25541         Bortolussi, Interim Resolution DH(97)554

H32-2447    27540         Brincat Joseph II, Interim Resolution DH(99)103

H46-2448    44976         C.P., judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2449    39997         Cancellieri, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2450    16752+       Capoccia Vittorio

H46-2451    42600         Carbone Biagio, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-301      37249         Casadei Roberto, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-582      38878         Ciacci, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2452    27240         Cilione, Interim Resolution DH(99)326

H32-2453    33950         Cola, Interim Resolution DH(99)422

H32-2454    24854         Coser Lauro, Interim Resolution DH(97)292

H46-2455    39714         Davinelli, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2456    33969         De Blasiis, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 06/04/00

H32-2457    23968         De Santis Roberto, Interim Resolution DH(98)269

H46-302      35991         Del Federico Alberto, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-583      42351         Del Giudice, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-2458    41513         Di Donato and 3 others, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-303      42619         Di Vuono Bernardo, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H32-2459    29077         E.M. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)229

H32-2460    16549         Emmanuele V. and G.

H46-2461    40457         F.C., judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2462    35000         F.F., Interim Resolution DH(99)423

H46-584      45267         F.R. and 3 others, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H32-2463    31009         Fabrizi, Interim Resolution DH(99)327

H46-2464    37263         Falcone Nicolò, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-2465    34203         Ferrarin, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 06/09/01

H32-2466    28166         Forte II, Interim Resolution DH(98)49

H32-2467    28591         Frisaldi, Interim Resolution DH(98)270

H32-2468    17043         G. and A.G. and M.C.

H46-585      41603         G.B.Z., L.Z. and S.Z., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 15/02/00

H32-2469    28664         G.C. V, Interim Resolution DH(98)456

H32-2470    28666         G.N. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)50

H32-2471    22120         G.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)465

H32-2472    33605         G.P. V, Interim Resolution DH(99)424

H32-2473    35554         G.S. VIII, Interim Resolution DH(99)425

H46-2474    37752         Gelli, judgment of 19/10/99, final on 01/02/00

H32-2475    28594         Ghignoni, Interim Resolution DH(99)104

H46-586      41094         Giannangeli, judgment of 05/07/01, final on 05/10/01

H32-2476    18138         Giner, Interim Resolution DH(95)444

H32-2477    36057         Giunchiglia, Interim Resolution DH(99)426

H46-2478    41275         Guarino Carmela, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-587      32646         Guerresi, judgment of 24/04/01, final on 24/04/01

H46-2479    40458         Ialongo, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2480    40662         Iarrobino and De Nisco, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2481    45260         Icolaro, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2482    28963         Isnardi II, Interim Resolution DH(97)659

H32-2483    23570         L.C. and P.A., Interim Resolution DH(97)464

H32-2484    22870         L.G. I, Interim Resolution DH(97)294

H32-2485    33377         L.Z., Interim Resolution DH(99)328

H46-2486    35742         Ledonne I, judgment of 12/05/99, final on 12/08/99

H46-2487    38414         Ledonne II, judgment of 12/05/99, final on 12/08/99

H32-2488    20543         Lupo, Interim Resolution DH(96)107

H32-2489    29508         M.B. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)329

H32-2490    22901         M.C. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)466

H32-2491    24904         Maggiani, Interim Resolution DH(97)660

H46-2492    41206         Mangascia, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-2493    37702         Marchetti Alessandro III, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-588      41893         Martinez, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-2494    43635         Matera Domenico, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-589      23969         Mattoccia, judgment of 25/07/00

H46-2495    43350         Maurano, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2496    23306         Milioni Guerriero and Mansueti, Interim Resolution DH(97)661

H32-2497    30605         Mongiardo, Interim Resolution DH(98)457

H32-2498    28167         Moni Mario, Interim Resolution DH(98)51

H32-2499    32045         Morelli, Interim Resolution DH(99)105

H32-2500    28903         Motalli, Interim Resolution DH(97)280

H46-2501    47681         Motta Luciana, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-304      44173         Mucciacciaro Raffaele, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H32-2502    25124+       Nativi, Loriga+, Interim Resolution DH(97)662

H46-308      41424         Nuvoli, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-590      44943         Orlandi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2503    18755         P.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(96)109

H46-2504    45269         P.G.F., judgment of 05/07/01, final on 05/10/01

H46-2505    37507         Palmigiano Natale, judgment of 11/01/00, final on 11/04/00

H46-305      42287         Pascazi Domenico, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-591      29898         Patanè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-592      30132         Pepe Umberto, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-593      36733         Perilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)427

H32-594      24170         Pesce Mario, Interim Resolution DH(97)468

H32-2506    23310         Poidimani, Interim Resolution DH(97)173

H32-2507    35007         Profeta, Interim Resolution DH(99)428

H32-2508    29881         Puccio, Interim Resolution DH(98)458

H46-306      43915         Rocci Luigi, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H32-2509    29530         Rossi Antonio, Interim Resolution DH(98)459

H46-2510    40693         Rotellini and Barnabei, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2511    45480         S.G., S.M. and P.C., judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-2512    36719         Saccomanno, judgment of 12/05/99, final on 12/08/99

H32-2513    21567         Salerno, Interim Resolution DH(97)174

H46-2514    43536         Schiappacasse, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H32-2515    32728         Spissu, Interim Resolution DH(99)330

H46-2516    34081         Starace, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-2517    33749         Suraci A. and A., Interim Resolution DH(99)331

H46-2518    45264         Tommaso Palumbo, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/07/01

H46-307      42291+       Tumbarello and Titone, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H32-596      26806         U.O. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)52

H32-597      26781         U.O. II,Interim Resolution DH(98)129

H32-598      26782         U.O. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)130

H32-2519    33691         V.B. III, Interim Resolution DH(99)332

H32-2520    28839         Viezzer, Interim Resolution DH(98)271

H46-599      43199         Visintin, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-2521    29510         Vocca, Interim Resolution DH(98)460

H32-2522    31461         Zaia, Interim Resolution DH(2000)21

                   - 4 cases criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages

H46-600       45856          Bacigalupi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-601       45857          Comella and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-309       46970          Contardi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-602       45858          Tesconi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

827th meeting (DH) – 11 and 12 February 2003

APPENDIX 2

827th  MEETING (DH) 11 and 12 February 2003

834th meeting DH (9-10 April 2003)
Preliminary list of items for consideration

——————————————

The draft annotated Agenda and Order of Business will be issued on 28 March 2003.
The classification of the cases in sections is at this stage purely on an indicative basis.

CONTENTS

INTRODUCTION.. 145

GENERAL QUESTIONS.. 151

SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS.. 152

SECTION 2 - NEW CASES.. 157

SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION.. 162

SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTION (INDIVIDUAL MEASURES,
MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS) 183

SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED.. 195

SECTION 6 - CASES AWAITING FOR THE PRESENTATION OF A DRAFT RESOLUTION.. 201

c. PREPARATION OF THE NEXT DH MEETING (841st MEETING, 3-4 June 2003) 213

Additional documents

Addendum General Questions

Addendum 1 - Final Resolutions

Addendum 4 – Cases raising special questions

Addendum Preparation of the next DH meeting (841st meeting, 3-4 June 2003)

INTRODUCTION

At the present Human Rights meeting, the Committee of Ministers, sitting at the level of the Ministers’ Deputies, will supervise the execution of some .. cases in accordance with Article 46, § 2, of the Convention for the protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Supervision is carried out in accordance with the Rules for the application of this Article adopted by the Deputies on 11 January 2001[123]. The Directorate General of Human Rights (Department for the execution of the judgments of the Court) and the Secretariat of the Committee of Ministers provide advice and assistance to the Deputies in the fulfilment of their functions under the Convention. Information and communications relating to the cases should be addressed to these departments.

Below follows a short comparative survey of the meeting (the information on the nature of the cases in the different sections is described after the table):

SECTION 1 – FINAL RESOLUTIONS

In the cases appearing under this heading the Deputies are invited to adopt draft resolutions putting an end to the supervision of execution carried out pursuant to Article 46§2 of the Convention (or former Articles 32[125] and 54 for cases decided before the entry into force of Protocol N° 11).

In these cases the Court (or the Committee) has either found a violation of the Convention or struck the case out of the list on the basis of undertakings made by the parties (for example in the case of friendly settlements – see Article 39 of the Convention and Rule 44 of the Rules of Court).

In all the cases, the Deputies have provisionally found, with the assistance of the Directorate General of Human Rights, that the required execution measures have been taken. The relevant information for each case has been summarised in a draft final resolution presented in Addendum 1. To facilitate examination, the cases are grouped as follows:

Sub-section 1.1. - Leading cases

In these leading cases the measures adopted aim at preventing new violations of the Convention  (legislative or regulatory measures, changes of case-law, mere publication in those states where the Convention and the Court’s judgments are given direct effect, administrative measures or other measures) and/or at redressing adequately the individual situation of the applicant (among the measures which may be relevant mention may be made of reopening of proceedings, striking out a conviction from criminal records, granting a residence permit, etc.)

Sub-section 1.2 – Cases concerning problems already solved

 This sub-section comprises cases which do not raise problems as regards the applicant’s individual situation, but which concern general problems which have already been solved in the context of similar earlier cases.

Sub-section 1.3 – Cases not involving general or individual measures

Contains cases which do not raise problems of a general or individual character. In these cases the mere dissemination of the judgment to the authorities directly concerned is considered sufficient.

Sub-section 1.4 – Friendly settlement and problems of a general character

This new sub-section groups friendly settlements relating to complaints concerning general problems already under examination by the Deputies in the context of other leading cases in which violations have been established.

No discussion of cases in Section 1 is envisaged since the examination of the different execution questions has already been carried out by the Deputies in the course of earlier meetings.

SECTION 2 – NEW CASES

Under this heading, the Deputies are called upon to conduct a first examination of the execution of the new final judgments delivered by the Court (Article 44 §§ 1 and 2 of the Convention) finding violations of the Convention. The Deputies also supervise the execution of judgments striking cases out of the Court’s list (friendly settlements, non-pursuit of the application, or a solution to the dispute) and which contain specific undertakings (Article 39 of the Convention and Article 44 of the Rules of Court).

The examination of new cases is in general resumed after the expiry of the 3-month time-limit normally imparted by the Court for the payment of the just satisfaction.

 

In those cases where all execution measures have already been taken before this first examination, a draft final resolution summarising the relevant information could be submitted for adoption. Such draft resolutions appear in Addendum 2.

Discussion is envisaged mainly for cases which raise questions of individual measures or new general measures.

Dissemination of the judgments to all the authorities involved has been requested in all these cases.

SECTION 3 – JUST SATISFACTION

In these cases the Deputies are called upon to supervise the payment of the just satisfaction awarded by the Court and, where required, of any default interest owed.

 

The section also presents the last cases in which the Deputies, in accordance with former Article 32§2 of the Convention, are called upon to decide on the question of just satisfaction on the basis of proposals submitted by the former European Commission of Human Rights or by the Committee of Special Advisors set up by Resolutions DH(99)681 and (2000)138 (see also decision 692/4.4 from December 1999).

                   Sub-section 3.1 – control of payment:

3.1.a: Supervisionof the payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction as well as, where due, of default interest, in cases where the deadline for payment expired less than 6 months ago.

No discussion is envisaged of cases appearing in sub-section 3.1.a. Delegations are invited to submit written confirmation of payment to the Directorate General of Human Rights (Service for the execution of the judgments).

 

3.1.b: Supervisionof the payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction in cases where the deadline for payment expired more than 6 months ago.

3.1.c: Examination of special payment problems (for example the disappearance of the applicant, disputes regarding the exact amount paid as a result of exchange rate problems or administrative fees).

The further examination of the cases in sub-sections 3.1 a - c depends on the information received.

Sub-section 3.2 – Decisions on just satisfaction

The Deputies may be are called upon to take a decision on just satisfaction pursuant to former Article 32. The details of the cases are found either in a table presented under this sub-section, or, if the case is complex, in Addendum 3 II.

The examination of such cases will be resumed after the expiry of the 3 months time-limit set for payment.

SECTION 4 – CASES RAISING SPECIAL QUESTIONS

(individual measures, measures not yet defined or special problems) 

The cases which appear under this heading require special attention to the extent that they either raise problems regarding the individual situation of the applicant, or concern problems in respect of which the necessary execution measures have not yet been defined, or raise other special problems (for example on account of the magnitude of the problems raised or delays in the adoption of the necessary execution measures).

 

Sub-section 4.1 – Supervision of individual measures only

This sub-section groups together cases in which the Deputies will exclusively examine the measures taken or to be taken in order to put an end to the violation found and/or remedy its consequences as far as the applicant’s individual situation is concerned – where the just satisfaction awarded by the Court has not done so.

Sub-section 4.2 - Individual measures and/or general problems

This heading presents both cases involving payment problems combined with general problems and cases in which measures have not yet been defined. For supervision of individual measures, see sub-section 4.1 above; for supervision of payment, subsection 3.1.c and for general measures, section 5 below.

 

Sub-section 4.3 – Special problems

This title groups together complex cases raising special problems.

Supplementary information relating to the cases under this heading may, where necessary, be found in Addendum 4.

As long as individual measures are outstanding cases are examined at each Human Rights meeting, unless the Deputies decide otherwise. Examination of other issues is decided upon on a case-by-case basis.

SECTION 5 – SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED

In these cases the Deputies are called upon to supervise the progress made in adopting measures of a general character defined at the national level and to ensure that these measures are apt to prevent new violations similar to those found by the Court. Cases are grouped together according to the nature of the main reforms envisaged.

In complex cases which require the adoption of several kinds of measures, cases are placed in the sub-section which corresponds to the main measures remaining to be adopted. A case may thus, for example, pass from sub-section 5.1 to sub-section 5.4 if the legislative changes required are rapidly adopted, whereas the implementation of the practical measures required turn out to take more time.

Sub-section 5.1 – Legislative and/or regulatory changes

In the cases in this group, the Deputies are mainly waiting for changes of legislation or of government regulations aiming at preventing new similar violations. Delegations of respondent States will thus furnish information about the content of draft legislation or regulations and on the procedure for their adoption.

Sub-section 5.2 – Changes of courts’ case-law or of administrative practice

This heading presents cases in which the Deputies are waiting for evidence (in the form of copies of judgments or decisions, statistics, etc.) of a change of the domestic courts’ case-law or of administrative practice, where such a change cannot, for one reason or another, be presumed solely on the basis of the publication or dissemination of the judgment (cf. the next sub-section).

 

Sub-section 5.3 – Publication / dissemination

This title encompasses in particular cases in which a change of court case-law or of administrative practice may be presumed, on the basis of evidence of the direct effect accorded to the Court’s judgments in general, as a result of simply publishing or disseminating the judgment in the case at issue, where necessary in translation into the national language. It may also concern other types of cases presenting a broader interest, such as those which imply important indications regarding the scope of the rights guaranteed by the Convention. In all these cases, the Deputies are normally waiting for details regarding the publication or dissemination carried out.

No discussion is envisaged under sub-section 5.3 and the Deputies are invited to present all relevant information in writing to the Directorate General of Human Rights (Service for the execution of the judgments of the Court).

Sub-section 5.4 – Other measures

This sub-section includes cases which primarily imply other types of general measures, for example practical measures such as the construction of prison facilities, the recruitment of judges, police training, etc.

Where necessary, supplementary information with respect to the cases in this section will be presented in Addendum 5.

Examination of these cases is normally resumed within 6 months’ time.

SECTION 6 – CASES WAITING FOR THE PRESENTATION OF A DRAFT RESOLUTION 

In these cases, the draft resolutions (prepared in collaboration with the Delegation concerned in cases raising questions of individual measures or new problems of a general character) putting and end to the examination of the case are not yet available at the time of issuing the annotated agenda and order of business.

If available in time for the meeting, drafts could be distributed separately.

No discussion of these cases is envisaged: examination is in principle be resumed at the next Human Rights meeting.

GENERAL QUESTIONS

a.                Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business

Action

The Deputies are invited to adopt the present annotated agenda and order of business.

b.                State of ratification by member States of the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceedings of the European Court of Human Rights, the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe and Protocols No. 12 and No. 13 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms

Action

The Deputies are invited to provide information on the state of signature and ratification of these four texts. Tables showing the current state of signature and ratification appear in Addendum General Questions.

c.                Preparation of the next meeting (841st (3-4 June 2003)) see page 213

SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS

(NO DEBATE ENVISAGED)

(Addendum 1)

Action

The Deputies are invited to adopt the resolutions putting and end to the examination of the following cases as they appear in Addendum 1.

                   SUB-SECTION 1.1 – LEADING CASES

- 14 cases against France

H32-            24263          Areno

H32-            23438          Elbialy

H32-            22578          G.N. II

H46-            39779+        Gombert and Gochgarian, judgment of 13/02/201, final on 13/05/01

H54-            28213          I.A., judgment of 23/09/98

H32-            18847          J-P.DV

H32-            15091          L.D.

H32-            21911          Lanza

H32-            17831          Morganti

H54-            21802          Muller, judgment of 17/03/97

H46-            38781          P.B., judgment of 01/08/00, final on 01/11/00

H46-            34947          Richet, judgment of 13/02/01, final on 13/05/01

H32-            24245          Touihri

H46-            42211          Zannouti, judgment of 31/07/01, final on 31/10/01

                   SUB-SECTION 1.2 – CASES CONCERNING PROBLEMS ALREADY SOLVED

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 1.3 – CASES NOT INVOLVING GENERAL OR INDIVIDUAL MEASURES

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 1.4 – FRIENDLY SETTLEMENTS AND PROBLEMS OF A GENERAL CHARACTER

                   No new case

SECTION 2 - NEW CASES

Action

The Deputies are invited to hold a first examination, under Article 46, paragraph 2, of the ECHR, of the following new judgments, delivered by the European Court of Human Rights (for further information, see the text of the judgments, http://www.echr.coe.int) on the assumption that judgments which are not yet final will not be referred to the Grand Chamber.

The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases after expiry of the time-limit set for payment or according to the specific character of the cases.

PAYMENT OF JUST SATISFACTION

In all the new cases in which States should pay just satisfaction as ordered by the Court or as agreed in a friendly settlement, the authorities of the respondent State are invited to provide the Secretariat, in writing, with confirmations of payment.

INDIVIDUAL AND/OR GENERAL MEASURES

As regards any other execution measures which may be called for in the light of the conclusions of the Court, the authorities of the respondent State are invited, on a preliminary basis, to provide the Secretariat, in writing, with information on the measures mentioned after each case. The possible necessity to take other measures than those mentioned could nevertheless be addressed at the meeting.

Dissemination of the judgments to all the authorities involved is requested in all cases and delegations are invited to provide the written confirmation of this dissemination.

In all these cases, just satisfaction or sums agreed under a friendly settlement has been awarded to the applicants except in the following case: ...

The Secretariat has indicated the cases for which, in principle, no debate seems to be necessary, by the mention “No debate envisaged”.

The cases for which the final character of the judgment has not yet been confirmed by the Court appear on a grey background.

Section 2

- 3 cases against Austria

H46-            35437          Demir, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

H46-            38549          Vostic, judgment of 17/10/2002, final on 17/01/2003

H46-            37295          Yildiz M., G. and Y., judgment of 31/10/2002, final on 31/01/2003

- 11 cases against Belgium

H46-            32576          Wynen, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

                   Cases concerning length of civil proceedings

H46-            50615          Boca, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49797          De Plaen, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49522          Dooms and others, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            50566          Kenes, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49546          Lefebvre, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49794          Oval S.P.R.L., judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49332          Oren and Shoshan, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            50172          Randaxhe, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49495          S.A. Sitram, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            49497          Teret, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003 – Striking-out

- 1 case against Croatia

H46-            45435          Radoš and 4 others, judgment of 07/11/2002, final on 07/02/2003

- 1 case against Cyprus

H46-            44730          Serghides and Christoforou, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

- 4 cases against the Czech Republic

H46-            36541          Bucheň, judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003

H46-            36548          Pincová and Pinc, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

H46-            47273          Běleš and others, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

H46-            46129          Zvolský and Zvolská, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

- 1 case against Estonia

H46-            37571          Veeber, No. 1, judgment of 07/11/2002, final on 07/02/2003

- 1 case against Finland

H46-            35999          Pietiläinen, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 27/01/2003[126]

- 3 cases against France

H46-            43191          Laidin, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

H46-            49544          Butel, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

H46-            49857          Ottomani, judgment of 15/10/2002, final on 15/01/2003

Section 2

- 2 cases against Germany

H46-            37928          Stambuk, judgment of 17/10/2002, final on 17/01/2003

H46-            45448          Becker, judgment of 16/09/2002, final on 26/12/2002

- 2 cases against Greece

H46-            50776+        Agga n° 2, judgment of 17/10/2002, final on 17/01/2003

H46-            62530          Vitaliotou, judgment of 30/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

- 20 cases against Italy

H46-            34896          Craxi Benedetto II, judgment of 05/12/2002, final on 05/03/2003

- Cases concerning the failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

H46-            34819          Cau, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            30879          Ciliberti Raffaele, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            32589          D.V. II, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            32577          Folli Carè, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            32006          Gnecchi and Barigazzi, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            32392          L. and P., judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            32542          L.B. III, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            31548          Maltoni, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            31129          Merico, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            30530          Rossi Luciano, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            31223          T.C.U., judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            33252          Tona, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            33204          Tosi, judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            30972          V.T., judgment of 15/11/2002, final on 15/02/2003

H46-            35997          Candela, judgment of 30/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37888          Cecchi Ida, judgment of 09/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

H46-            34435          Di Tullio, judgment of 09/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

                   - Cases concerning length of criminal proceedings

H46-            43621          F.M., judgment of 28/11/2002, final on 28/02/2003

H46-            45789          Pugliese Massimo, judgment of 28/11/2002, final on 28/02/2003

- 1 case against Latvia

H46-            58442          Lavents, judgment of 28/11/2002, final on 28/02/2003

- 7 cases against Poland

H46-            30218          Nowicka, judgment of 03/12/2002, final on 03/03/2003

H46-            26761          Płoski, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

H46-            29537+        Radaj, judgment of 28/11/2002, final on 28/02/2003

H46-            37443          Lisiak, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

                   Cases concerning length of civil proceedings[127]

H46-            40330          Piechota, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

H46-            37645          Sawicka, judgment of 01/10/2002, final on 01/01/2003

H46-            65660          W.Z., judgment of 24/10/2002, final on 24/01/2003

Section 2

- 4 cases against Portugal

H46-            38830          Czekalla, judgment of 10/10/2002, final on 10/01/2003

H46-            48956          Gil Leal Pereira, judgment of 31/10/2002, final on 31/01/2003

                   Cases concerning length of civil proceedings

H46-            49671          Ferreira da Nave, judgment of 07/11/2002, final on 07/02/2003

H46-            49279          Koncept-Conselho em Comunicação e Sensibilização de Públicos, Lda, judgment of 31/10/2002, final on 31/01/2003

- 7 cases against Romania

H46-            33627          Baragan, judgment of 01/10/2002, rectified on 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

H46-            32926          Canciovici and others, judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003

H46-            29769          Curutiu A. and M., judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            32936          Dragnescu, judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003

H46-            32977          Gavrus, judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003

H46-            30698          Mateescu and others, judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            32268          Nagy, judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003

- 3 cases against the Slovak Republic

                   Cases concerning length of civil proceedings

H46-            47804          Havala, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

H46-            39752          Matouškova, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

H46-            41783          Polovka, judgment of 21/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

- 2 cases against Sweden

H46-            38629          Lundevall, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

H46-            38978          Salomonsson, judgment of 12/11/2002, final on 12/02/2003

- 1 case against Switzerland

H46-            41202          Müller, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

- 13 cases against Turkey

H46-            42739          Özel Yaşar, judgment of 07/11/2002, final on 07/02/2003

H46-            25756          Dalkılıç, judgment of 05/12/2002, final on 05/03/2003

H46-            31877          Gündoğan Halil, judgment of 10/10/2002, final on 10/01/2003

H46-            24737+        Satık, Camlı, Satık and Maraşlı, judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            32574          Algür, judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            25141          Dicle pour le Parti de la Démocratie (DEP), judgment of 10/12/2002, final on 10/03/2003

H46-            29864          H.K. and others, judgment of 14/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28002          Tamer, judgment of 09/01/2003 - Friendly settlement

                                      - Freedom of expression cases

H46-            28493          Küçük, judgment of 05/12/2002, final on 05/03/2003

H46-            24914          Öztürk Ayşe, judgment of 15/10/2002, final on 15/01/2003

H46-            27692+        Karakoç and others, judgment of 15/10/2002, final on 15/01/2003

Section 2

- Cases relating to delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

H46-            20139          Çelebi Mehmet No. 2, judgment of 10/10/2002, final on 10/01/2003

H46-            20143          İnce Fehmiye, judgment of 10/10/2002, final on 10/01/2003

- 14 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-            33218          E. and others, judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 10/01/2003[128]

H46-            53236          Waite, judgment of 10/12/2002, final on 10/03/2003

H46-            28212          Benjamin and Wilson, judgment of 26/09/2002, final on 26/12/002

H46-            44652          Beckles, judgment of 10/10/2002, final on 10/01/2003

H46-            32771          Cuscani, judgment of 24/09/2002, final on 24/12/2002

H46-            48539          Allan, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003

H46-            39393          M.G., judgment of 24/09/2002, final on 24/12/2002

H46-            47114          Taylor-Sabori, judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            38719          D.P. and J.C., judgment of 10/10/2002, final on 10/01/2003

H46-            48535+        Beck, Copp and Bazelay, judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            43208+        Perkins and R., judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            42116          Somjee, judgment of 15/10/2002, final on 15/01/2003

H46-            39197          Foley, judgment of 22/10/2002, final on 22/01/2003

H46-            49771          Jordan Stephen No. 3, judgment of 10/12/2002, final on 10/03/2003

SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise the payment of just satisfaction in the following cases pending before the Committee of Ministers for execution supervision. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in principle at their next Human Rights meeting.

3.a               SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST SATISFACTION AS WELL AS, WHERE DUE, OF DEFAULT INTEREST, IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT EXPIRED LESS THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

At the time of issuing the present Annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the Secretariat had not received the written confirmation of payment of just satisfaction and/or default interest in the following cases (see the table below summarising the total number of cases by States). The Representatives of the States concerned are invited to give the Secretariat written confirmation of payment of the sums awarded by the Court and/or the default interests (no debate envisaged during the meeting).

- 3 cases against Austria

H46-            37093          Informationsverein Lentia II, judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            34994          Walter, judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38275          W.F., judgment of 30/05/2002, final on 30/08/2002

- 2 cases against Belgium

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            37370          Stratégies and Communications and Dumoulin, judgment of 15/07/2002, final on 15/10/2002[129]

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            51564          Čonka, judgment of 05/02/02, final on 05/05/02[130]

- 2 cases against Croatia

H46-            62912          Benzan, judgment of 08/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            56773          Rajčević, judgment of 23/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[131]

- 36 cases against France

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            38748          Immeubles Groupe Kosser, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002[132]

H46-            54210          Papon, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 25/10/2002[133]

H46-            42400          Seguin, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 06/11/2002[134]

H46-            51279          Colombani and others, judgment of 25/06/2002, final on 25/09/2002

H46-            48161          Motais de Narbonne, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002

H46-            32911+        Meftah, Adoud and Bosoni, judgment of 26/07/2002 - Grand Chamber

H46-            37971          Sociétés Colas Est, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 16/07/2002

H46-            41376          D.M., judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

H46-            43125          Delbec Annick No. 3, judgment of 18/06/2002, final on 18/09/2002[135]

H46-            33395          L.R., judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

Section 3.a

H46-            38396          Karatas and Sari, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-            33424          Nouhaud and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            51575          Baillard, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 04/09/2002[136]

H46-            41358          Desmots, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[137]

H46-            51179          Solana, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 04/09/2002[138]

H46-            45172          Fentati, judgment of 22/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            33592          Baumann, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

H46-            41476          Laine, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02

H46-            40096          Versini, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 10/10/01

H46-            41526          Pulvirenti, judgment of 28/11/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44211          Lacombe, judgment of 07/11/00, final on 07/02/01

H46-            39273          Vermeersch, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

H46-            48167          Hababou, judgment of 26/04/01 - Friendly settlement

H32-            39966          De Cantelar, Interim Resolution DH(2000)86

H46-            42195          Mortier, judgment of 31/07/01, final on 31/10/01

H46-            39594          Kress, judgment of 07/06/01 – Grand Chamber[139]

H46-            40472          Tricard, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 10/10/01

H46-            29731          Krombach, judgment of 13/02/01, final on 13/05/01

H46-            47631          Lemort, judgment of 26/04/01, final on 26/04/01

H32-            31677          Watson John, Interim Resolution DH(2000)20

H46-            44070          Beljanski, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-            44069          G.B. II, judgment of 02/10/01, final on 02/01/02

H46-            53613          Goth, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-            33023          Meier, judgment of 07/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            35683          Vaudelle, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-            37794          Pannullo and Forte, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

- 10 cases against Greece

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            37095          Pialopoulos and others, judgments of 15/02/01, final on 27/06/02 and of 15/05/01, final on 06/11/02[140] (Article 41)

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            47730          Entreprises Meton and Etep, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-            48392          Hatzitakis, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-            48679          AEPI S.A., judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-            46356          Smokovitis and others, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-            49215          Angelopoulos, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-            46806          Sakellaropoulos Yeoryios, judgment of 11/04/2002, final on 11/07/2002

H46-            46352          Logothetis, judgment of 12/04/01, final on 12/07/01 and judgment of 18/04/02 (Article 41), final on 18/07/02

H46-            49282          Marinakos, judgment of 04/10/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            47020          Kolokitha, judgment of 07/06/01 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

- 2 cases against Hungary

H46-            42373          Bódine Bencze, judgment of 01/10/2002 – Striking-out following a friendly settlement

H46-            43352          Kósa, judgment of 01/10/2002 – Striking-out following a friendly settlement

- 1 case against Ireland

H46-            39474          D.G., judgment of 16/05/02, final on 16/08/02[141]

- 328 cases against Italy

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            57574+        Sulejmanovic and others and Sejdovic and Sulejmanovic, judgment of 08/11/2002 - Friendly settlement[142]

H46-            36534          Osu, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002

H46-            36732          Pisano, judgment of 24/10/2002 - Striking-out - Grand Chamber

- Cases concerning the failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

H46-            28724          Capitanio, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002

H46-            34742          A.M.M., judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46079          Biffoni, judgment of 24/10/2001 - Friendly settlement

H46-            36112          C. Srl, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            41624          Calvagno, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38043          Ciccone, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31928          F. and F., judgment of 24/10/2001 - Friendly settlement

H46-            33115          Fabbrini, judgment of 15/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            39451          Fiorentini Vizzini, judgment of 19/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            35001          Franceschetti, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            39690          Gianotti Ricardo, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43986          Pugliese Rosalba, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            47895          Sartorelli, judgment of 24/10/2001 - Friendly settlement

H46-            34714          Tacchino and Scorza, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            57206          Virgulti, judgment of 28/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            36734          Visca, judgment of 07/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

- Civil courts

H46-            56084          At.M., judgment of 07/05/02, final on 07/08/02

H46-            44409          Rizzo Giuseppe, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, rectified on 09/07/02

H32-            30423          Salini Costruttori Spa, Interim Resolution DH(99)673

- Administrative courts[143]

H46-            44341          Cannone, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44347          Carapella and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44350          Cecere Domenico, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44337          Delli Paoli, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44349          Fragnito, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44340          Gaudenzi, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            38594          Mereu and S. Maria Navarrese, judgment of 13/06/2002, final on 13/09/2002

H46-            44348          Nazzaro and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44351          Pace and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

Section 3.a

- Labour courts

H46-            51156          Fasulo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, rectified on 12/09/2002

H46-            51023          Palmieri Maddalena, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02, revised jugement of 18/04/02, final on 18/07/02

- Criminal proceedings

H46-            38576          Barattelli Carlo, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            41863          Boldrin Stefano, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            37249          Casadei Roberto, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            35991          Del Federico Alberto, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            42619          Di Vuono Bernardo, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            44173          Mucciacciaro Raffaele, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            42287          Pascazi Domenico, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            43915          Rocci Luigi, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            42291+        Tumbarello and Titone, judgment of 04/07/2002, final on 04/10/2002

H46-            41424          Nuvoli, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            25639          F.L., judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-            39676          Rojas Morales, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            26772          Labita, judgment of 06/04/00, final on 06/04/00

H46-            30882          Pellegrini Maria Grazia, judgment of 20/07/01, final on 20/10/01

H46-            15918          Antonetto, judgment of 20/07/00, final on 20/10/00

H46-            28168          Quadrelli, judgment of 11/01/00, final on 20/03/00

H46-            33354          Lucà, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            26161          Natoli, judgment of 09/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178

H32-            19734          F.S. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)209

H46-            41852          Vaccaro, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            39221+        Scozzari and others, judgment of 13/07/00 – Grand Chamber

                                      Interim Resolutions ResDH(2001)65 and ResDH(2001)151

H46-            31143          Indelicato, judgment of 18/10/01, final on 18/01/02[144]

- Civil courts

H46-            44481          A.C. VII, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46515          Adriani, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46964          Alpites S.P.A., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            47785          Angemi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            48412          Ar.M., judgment of 23/10/01, final on 23/01/02

H46-            46958          Ardemagni and Ripa, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            39900          Artuso Paolo, Interim Resolution DH(99)569

H32-            39137          Avallone, Interim Resolution DH(99)475

H46-            44511          Bellagamba, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            40977          Beltramo, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            44431          Beluzzi and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            39883          Bertozzi, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/04/00

H46-            44442          Bevilacqua, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            36811          Bielectric S.R.L., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            44437          Bocca, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-            39121          Bolla, Interim Resolution DH(99)480

H46-            44457          Bonelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44436          Buffalo s.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

Section 3.a

H46-            46534          Burghesu, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            46980          C.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            35292          Calandrella F., P. and 2 others, Interim Resolution DH(98)405

H46-            39881          Capodanno, judgment of 05/04/00, final on 05/04/00

H46-            45071          Capurro and Tosetti, judgment of 28/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46526          Carboni, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            45859          Caruso Giuseppina, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            45861          Cavallaro, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            36620          Ceriello, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H46-            46537          Cerulli and Zadra, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            45869          Chiappetta, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            46959          Circo and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44504          Citterio and Angiolillo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            47779          Ciuffetti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46532          Conte Gaspare and others, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            40979          Conte Riccardo II, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            47774          Conti Giuliana, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            44385          Cornaglia, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46527          Corsi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            35616          Coscia, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H46-            46538          Costantini Francesco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            44500          Cova, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            45880          Cultraro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46536          D.C. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            40954          D’Alessandro, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44513          D’Ammassa and Frezza, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02, revised on 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03[145]

H46-            45872          D’Annibale, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-            17482          D'Aquino and Petrizzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)28

H46-            40216          D’Arrigo and Garrozzo, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            52921          Damiano, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-            40566          De Cicco Concetta, Interim Resolution DH(98)405

H32-            40580          De Lorenzi, Interim Resolution DH(99)588

H46-            49372          De Pilla, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            42520          De Simone Pasquale, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            39138          Di Fant I, Interim Resolution DH(99)488

H32-            39139          Di Fant II, Interim Resolution DH(99)489

H46-            44446          Di Girolamo and 6 others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            46976          Di Motoli and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46520          Dorigo Franco, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            44480          E.G., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            44519          E.M. II, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H32-            39906          Emmebiemme S.r.l., Interim Resolution DH(99)592

H46-            40982          Erdokovy, judgment of 01/02/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46524+        F., T. and E., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            46533          F.L.S., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            39164          F.S.p.A. II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            46971          F.T., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            26012          Facciolini, Interim Resolution DH(96)648

H46-            46968          Falconi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            52972          Falzarano Carmine, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-            47781          Farinosi and Barattelli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

Section 3.a

H46-            45870          Ferrazzo and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            45868          Filippello Giorgio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-            38145          Focardi and Conti, Interim Resolution DH(99)287

H46-            46965          Franceschetti and Odorico, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            38118          Fraschetti, Interim Resolution DH(99)288

H46-            44397          G.B. IV, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            37131          G.M.N., judgment of 02/11/99, final on 02/11/99

H32-            38503          G.P. and 25 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)388

H46-            46543          G.S. and L.M., judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            47786          G.V. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46963          Galiè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46528          Giannalia, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            47773          Gianni, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            45860          Giuseppe Nicola and Luciano Caruso, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            40968          I.F., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            44418          I.P.E.A. S.R.L., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            39116          I.R., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-            44447          Ianniti and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46516          Il Messaggero S.a.s. II, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            46517          Il Messaggero S.a.s. III, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            46518          Il Messaggero S.a.s. IV, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            46519          Il Messaggero S.a.s. V, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            47777          Ilardi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            44508          Immobiliare Il Messaggero del geometra Antonio Iorillo, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            46530          Iulio, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            40924          L. S.r.l., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-            46542          Lanino, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H32-            31341          Lazzari and Scagnoli, Interim Resolution DH(97)637

H46-            45853          Lo Cicero, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-            40571          Lo Sardo, Interim Resolution DH(99)606

H46-            46523          Lonardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            46962          Lucas International S.R.L., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44406          M. S.r.l., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46961          Maletti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            40978          Mantini, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            28725          Manzi A., B. and L., Interim Resolution DH(97)254

H46-            40956          Marchetti, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44443          Marchi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46957          Marcolongo, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44517          Mari and Mangini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44422          Marzinotto, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46966          Massaro, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46979          Mastrantonio Francesca, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44420          Mauri, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46973          Morelli and Nerattini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44490          Murgia, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            39872          Nata, Interim Resolution DH(99)617

H46-            46522          Nolla, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            44494          O.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44468          P.B. V, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            40570          Padalino V. and G., judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-            40952          Paderni II, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

H32-            21707          Panissa, D., G. and A. Vittonetto

H32-            39155          Perilli and Gigotti Micheli, Interim Resolution DH(99)509

H46-            45070          Persichetti and C.S.r.l., judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44380          Pettirossi, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            28936          Piccinini II, judgment of 11/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            39899          Pirilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)623

H46-            45065          Pirola, judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46967          Procaccianti, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            46969          Procopio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44412          Quattrone Pasquale, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            45058          Rettura, judgment of 17/10/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44465          Rigutto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            43098          Romano, judgment of 28/09/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            35328          Roselli Italo II, Interim Resolution DH(98)440

H46-            44479          Rosetti e Ciucci and C., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            44527          Rossana Ferrari, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44472          Rossi Valeria, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44461          Sacchi Roberto, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            38135          Sanna, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 11/04/00

H46-            44466          Santoro Valerio, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            47780          Santorum, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            45854          Savino, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 04/04/01

H46-            44419          Sbrojavacca Pietrobon, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            36621          Scalvini, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/10/99

H46-            44491          Sonego, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44470          Spada, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            56094          Sposito, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-            39705          Spurio II, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H32-            39865          Staffolani, Interim Resolution DH(99)635

H46-            44417          Tagliabue, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-            38102          Talenti, Interim Resolution (2001)58

H46-            44486          Tebaldi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44425          Tedesco Michele, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            46539          Tor Di Valle Costruzioni S.P.A. VII, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            45068          Toscano and others, judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44488          Vecchi and others, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44528          Vecchini, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            44534          Venturini Alberto I, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H32-            40586          Verini II, Interim Resolution DH(99)639

H46-            40599          Vicari II, judgment of 15/02/00

H46-            44395          Visentin, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            37166          Vitale and others, judgment of 02/11/99

H46-            44445          W.I.E. S.n.c., judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            44462          Zanasi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            37079          Zironi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

- Administrative courts [146]

H46-            41809          A.B. V, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            34437          Caliendo, judgment of 14/03/00, final on 14/03/00

H46-            41817          Caliri, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            41807          Centioni and others, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            41815          Monti Enrico, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

Section 3.a

H46-            41810          Mosca, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            41813          Musiani, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            41816          Paradiso Antonio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            41812          Piccirillo Aldo, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31631          Procaccini, judgment of 30/03/00, final on 30/03/00

H46-            41814          Zeoli and 34 others, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 05/10/00

- Court of Audit

H46-            41823          Pascali and Conte, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            39175          Sileo, Interim Resolution DH(99)524

- Labour courts

H46-            40363          Ascierto Ada, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43063          Bello, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            40975          Bucci, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43094          C.B., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42999          Cacciacarro, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43020          Ciaramella Pasquale, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            36615          Cappello, Interim Resolution DH(99)212

H32-            38095          Cardillo, Interim Resolution DH(99)317

H46-            46521          Ciccardi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            42996          Cocca, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44532          Colacrai, judgment of 23/10/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-            43088          Coppolaro, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43086          Cosimo Cesare, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43087          Cosimo Rotondi, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43083          D’Addona Simone, judgment of 22/06/00 – Friendly settlement

H46-            43017          D’Ambrosio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43059          D’Antonoli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            40960          Dattilo, judgment of 05/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43054          Del Buono, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43051          Di Biase Leonardo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43062          Di Blasio Concetta, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46975          Di Gabriele, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            43030          Di Libero, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43022          Di Mella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46978          F.P., judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            45855          Fr.C., judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            43056          Fallarino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43058          Foschini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43096          G.A. IV, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43093          G.P. VI, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43075          Gallo Giuseppe, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37170          Giampietro, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            38975          Gioia Angelina, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43050          Gioia Filomena Giovanna, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43074          Grasso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            39124          Guagenti, judgment of 15/02/00, final on 15/02/00

H46-            43072          Guarino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43091          Iadarola, judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42998          Iannotta, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43101          Iannotti, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43021          Iapalucci, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43067          Izzo Italia, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

H46-            43065          Lanni, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43102          Lepore T., Lepore M. and Iannotti T., judgment of 27/07/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43068          Luciano, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43095          M.C. X, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43010          Mannello, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            37160          Marsicovetere, Interim Resolution DH(99)221

H46-            43000          Maselli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43018          Meoli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43069          Mercone, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43057          Mongillo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43064          Nicolella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43100          Orsini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43076          P.T. II, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43012          Palumbo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43052          Panzanella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43061          Patuto, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43060          Pizzi, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43023          Pozella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46974          Risola, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            43019          Rubortone, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43055          Sabatino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43099          Santillo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43085          Silvio Cesare, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42997          Squillace, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43084          Tontoli, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            46960          Trimboli, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            43016          Truocchio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43070          Vignona, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43109          Zeoli Nicolina, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43015          Zollo Clavio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43066          Zullo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

- Criminal courts

H46-            38878          Ciacci, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            42351          Del Giudice, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 06/09/01

H46-            45267          F.R. and 3 others, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-            41603          G.B.Z., L.Z. and S.Z., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 15/02/00

H46-            41094          Giannangeli, judgment of 05/07/01, final on 05/10/01

H46-            32646          Guerresi, judgment of 24/04/01, final on 24/04/01

H46-            41893          Martinez, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-            23969          Mattoccia, judgment of 25/07/00

H46-            44943          Orlandi, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            29898          Patanè, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

H46-            30132          Pepe Umberto, judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H32-            36733          Perilli, Interim Resolution DH(99)427

H32-            24170          Pesce Mario, Interim Resolution DH(97)468

H46-            37118          Sergi, judgment of 11/04/00 - Friendly settlement

H32-            26806          U.O. I, Interim Resolution DH(98)52

H32-            26781          U.O. II, Interim Resolution DH(98)129

H32-            26782          U.O. III, Interim Resolution DH(98)130

H46-            43199          Visintin, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01

Section 3.a

- Criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages

H46-            45856          Bacigalupi, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            45857          Comella and others, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            45858          Tesconi, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-            34462          Wessels-Bergervoet, judgment of 04/06/2002, final on 04/09/2002 and judgment of 12/11/2002 (Article 41) – Friendly settlement

- 8 cases against Poland

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            34611          Dacewicz, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002

H46-            33885          Kawka Eryk, judgment of 27/06/2002, final on 27/09/2002

H46-            24244          Migoń, judgment of 25/06/2002, final on 25/09/2002

H46-            27715+        Berliński Roman and Sławomir, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            48684          Uthke, judgment of 18/06/02, défintif le 18/09/02[147]

H46-            55106          Górka, judgment of 05/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            71891          Hałka and others, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002[148]

                   - Default interest to be paid

H32-            24559          Gibas, Interim Resolution DH(97)242[149]

- 9 cases against Portugal

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            54073          Agostinho, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            47460          Câmara Pestana, judgment of 16/05/2002, final on 16/08/2002

H46-            54483          Lógica - Móveis de Organização, Lda, judgment of 19/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            50843+        Longotrans - Transportes Internacionais Lda, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            47833          Marques Francisco, judgment of 06/06/2002, final on 06/09/2002

H46-            53793          Morais Sarmento, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            48187          Rosa Marques and others, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 25/10/2002

H46-            54449          Saraiva e Lei, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            43654          Pires, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

Section 3.a

- 11 cases against Romania

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            33358          Oprea and others, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[150]

H46-            35831          Bălănescu, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[151]

H46-            34992          Basacopol, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[152]

H46-            33912          Budescu and Petrescu, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002, rectified on 09/07/2002[153]

H46-            29053          Ciobanu, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[154]

H46-            32925          Cretu, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[155]

H46-            32943          Falcoianu and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[156]

H46-            29968          Hodoş and others, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[157] [158]

H46-            29407          Vasiliu, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[159] [160]

H46-            32260          Surpaceanu Constantin and Traian-Victor, judgment of 21/05/2002,

                                      final on 21/08/2002[161]

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            28342          Brumărescu, judgments of 28/10/99, 23/01/01 (Article 41) and 11/05/01

                                      (rectification) – Grand Chamber[162]

- 2 cases against the Slovak Republic

H46-            41263          Konček, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            41384          Varga, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 28 cases against Turkey

                   - Just satisfaction to be paid

H46-            38578          Kaplan Süleyman, judgment of 10/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            33234          N.Ö, judgment of 17/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29296          İğdeli, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            34481          Filiz and Kalkan, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            33179          Karataş Seher, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            30944          Öcal, judgment of 10/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            36971          Kuray, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            27209+        Kiliç Özcan, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

Section 3.a

H46-            27602          Ekinci Ülkü, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[163]

H46-            25656          Orhan Salih, judgment of 18/06/2002, final on 06/11/2002[164] [165]

- Friendly settlement cases containing undertakings by the Turkish Government [166]

H46-            31137          Adalı, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            22280          Demir Mahmut, judgment of 05/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38588          Keçeci, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31890          Kınay M. and Kınay R., judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31154          Şen Filiyet, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31153          Soğukpınar, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            36189          Yakar, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31152          Yalçın Şaziment, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

- Cases relating to delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

H46-            37087          Bekmezci and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            26543          Çallı, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            19660          Çalkan Dudu, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-            20140          Çelebi Mehmet n° 2, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-            68117          Denli Nesibe, judgment of 23/07/2002, final on 23/10/2002

H46-            20144          Kartal Adile, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-            20152          Özen Mehmet, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-            20151          Öztürk Ahmet, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

H46-            20155          Şen Aziz n° 2, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 28/06/2002

                   - Default interest to be paid

H46-            22876          Şemse Önen, judgment of 26/01/02, final on 14/05/02[167]

- 9 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-            36042          Willis, judgment of 11/06/2002, final on 11/09/2002

H46-            43290          McShane, judgment of 28/05/2002, final on 28/08/2002[168]

H46-            30668+        Wilson and the National Union of journalists; Palmer, Wyeth and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport Workers; Doolan and others, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002

H46-            56547          P., C. and S., judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[169]

H46-            65905          Rice, judgment of 01/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42007          Davies, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002, rectified on 13/09/2002

H46-            46477          Edwards Paul and Audrey, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02[170]

H46-            25680          I., judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber

H46-            28957          Goodwin Christine, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Grand Chamber

- 1 case against the « former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia »

H46-            58185          Janeva, judgment of 03/10/2002 - Friendly settlement

3.b              SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST

                   SATISFACTION IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT

                   EXPIRED MORE THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

Some of the cases appearing under this section concern late payment for reasons beyond the control of the governments concerned.

Expiry date

of the time-limit set

- 12 cases against France

H32-            26984          Picard, Interim Resolution DH(99)30                                                      31/01/1999

H46-            37786          Debboub Husseini Ali, judgment of 09/11/99, final on 09/02/00                  09/05/00

H32-            25971          Proma di Franco Gianotti, Interim Resolution DH(99)566          14/05/00+02/01/2001

H32-            31409          Riccobono, Interim Resolution DH(99)557                                              26/09/2001

H46-            44451          A.A.U., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01                                     19/12/2001

H32-            26242          Lemoine Pierre, Interim Resolution DH(99)353                                        17/03/2002

H46-            39278          Langlois, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02                                   07/08/2002

H46-            39626          Granata, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02                                    19/09/2002

H46-            44952+        Van der Kar and Lissaur Van West, judgment of 19/03/02,

                                      final on 19/06/02                                                                                   19/09/2002

H46-            56198          Société Industrielle d’Entretien et de Service (Sies),

                                      judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02                                                 19/09/2002

H46-            44797+        Etcheveste and Bidart, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002       21/09/2002

H46-            48215          Lutz, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002                                  26/09/2002

- 139 cases against Italy

H46-            31260          Lamperi Balenci, judgment of 21/02/02 - Friendly settlement                   21/05/2002

H46-            41232          Quartucci, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                            28/06/2002

H46-            20855          Esposito Luigi, judgment of 25/05/00 - Friendly settlement                     25/08/2000

H46-            33202          Beyeler, judgments of 05/01/00 (merits) and of 28/05/02 (Article 41)        28/08/2002

- Civil courts

H46-            44421          Galasso, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                                   25/04/2002

H46-            44501          Il Messaggero S.A.S. VI, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02           25/04/2002

H46-            51708          I.M., judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002                                   11/06/2002

H46-            51668          Lopriore, judgment of 11/12/2001, final on 11/03/2002                            11/06/2002

H46-            51672          Selva, judgment of 11/12/01, final on 11/03/02                                       11/06/2002

H46-            41803          Pupillo, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00;

                                      revised judgment on just satisfaction of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02        18/06/2002

H46-            56101          Mesiti, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02                                      12/08/2002

H46-            56093          Società Croce Gialla Romana S.a.s., judgment of 12/02/02,

                                      final on 12/05/02                                                                                   12/08/2002

H46-            51664          Rodolfi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                    19/08/2002

H46-            41740          Diebold, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                   28/09/2002

H46-            44413          Guerrera Angelo Giuseppe, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02        28/08/2002

H46-            47479          Mastromauro S.R.L., judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                 28/09/2002

- Administrative courts[171]

H46-            44330          Principe and others, judgment of 19/12/00 - Friendly settlement              19/03/2001

H46-            41806          Alesiani and 510 others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01             27/08/2001

Section 3.b

H46-            41805          Arivella, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01                                    27/08/2001

H46-            41804          Ciotta, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01                                      27/08/2001

H46-            35956          Galatà and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01                     27/08/2001

H46-            44525          Ferrari Marcella II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                      25/04/2002

H46-            44379          Finessi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                                     25/04/2002

H46-            44343          Massimo Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                 25/04/2002

H46-            44352          Massimo Giuseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                25/04/2002

H46-            44345          Rinaudo and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02                  25/04/2002

H46-            44342          Gattuso, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002                            06/06/2002

H46-            44333          V.P. and F.D.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02                       12/08/2002

H46-            56226          Abate and Ferdinandi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02               19/08/2002

H46-            56222          Centis, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                      19/08/2002

H46-            56206          Colonnello and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02               19/08/2002

H46-            56208          Conte and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                      19/08/2002

H46-            56202          Cornia, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                      19/08/2002

H46-            56224          D’Amore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                  19/08/2002

H46-            56217          De Cesaris, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                               19/08/2002

H46-            56205          Dente, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                      19/08/2002

H46-            56225          Di Pede II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                 19/08/2002

H46-            56221          Donato, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                    19/08/2002

H46-            56212          Folletti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                     19/08/2002

H46-            56203          Ginocchio, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                19/08/2002

H46-            56204          Limatola, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                   19/08/2002

H46-            56207          Lugnan in Basile, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                       19/08/2002

H46-            56220          Mastropasqua, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                          19/08/2002

H46-            56211          Napolitano Giuseppe, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                19/08/2002

H46-            56213          Piacenti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                   19/08/2002

H46-            56223          Polcari, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                     19/08/2002

H46-            56219          Presel, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                      19/08/2002

H46-            56214          Ripoli I, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                     19/08/2002

H46-            56215          Ripoli II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                                    19/08/2002

H46-            56201          Sardo Salvatore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                       19/08/2002

H46-            56218          Stabile Michele, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02                         19/08/2002

H46-            44334          Lattanzi and Cascia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                  28/09/2002

- Labour courts

H46-            43097          Nicoli, judgment of 22/06/00 – Friendly settlement                                  22/09/2000

H46-            52924          Frattini and others, judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02,

                                      revised judgment of 26/11/2002, final on 26/02/2003[172]                           12/08/2002

H46-            51031          Aceto and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                      28/08/2002

H46-            51089          Armellino Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                 28/08/2002

H46-            52824          Belviso and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                   28/08/2002

H46-            52804          Bianco Pellegrino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                     28/08/2002

H46-            52816          Biondi and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                     28/08/2002

H46-            51030          Biondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                    28/08/2002

H46-            52835          Cerbo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                     28/08/2002

H46-            52801          Ciarmoli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                   28/08/2002

H46-            52815          Cimmino and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                 28/08/2002

H46-            52807          Ciullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                       28/08/2002

H46-            52821          Colangelo Domenico, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                28/08/2002

H46-            51164          Crovella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                   28/08/2002

Section 3.b

H46-            51163          D’Angelo Michele, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                     28/08/2002

H46-            51125          De Filippo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                28/08/2002

H46-            51027          Del Vecchio Anna Rita, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02              28/08/2002

H46-            51155          Della Ratta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                               28/08/2002

H46-            52813          Di Meo and Masotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                 28/08/2002

H46-            52846          Di Meo Antonio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                        28/08/2002

H46-            51092          Di Mezza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                  28/08/2002

H46-            51091          Ferrara Clementina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/2002                28/08/2002

H46-            52843          Franco and Basile, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                    28/08/2002

H46-            51161          Gagliardi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                  28/08/2002

H46-            52830          Giannotta and Iannella, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02              28/08/2002

H46-            51094          Iacobucci and Lavorgna, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02            28/08/2002

H46-            51170          Izzo Giovanni, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                           28/08/2002

H46-            52802          Lagozzino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                28/08/2002

H46-            52812          Lavorgna and Iorio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                   28/08/2002

H46-            52822          Macolino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                  28/08/2002

H46-            52819          Mancino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                   28/08/2002

H46-            51169          Marotta Alberto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                        28/08/2002

H46-            51168          Martino Alfonso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                       28/08/2002

H46-            52827          Mastrocinque Mafalda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02              28/08/2002

H46-            51167          Matera Tommasina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                   28/08/2002

H46-            52845          Mazzarelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                 28/08/2002

H46-            52818          Meola, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                      28/08/2002

H46-            52840          Mongillo Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                         28/08/2002

H46-            44428          Nardone Antonio, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                      28/08/2002

H46-            52832          Nero and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                       28/08/2002

H46-            51029          Ocone, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                     28/08/2002

H46-            51114          Paduano, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                  28/08/2002

H46-            52829          Pallotta, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                    28/08/2002

H46-            51022          Palmieri Mario Francesco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02          28/08/2002

H46-            52841          Panza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                      28/08/2002

H46-            52837          Pascale and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                   28/08/2002

H46-            52842          Pascale Elda, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                            28/08/2002

H46-            52826          Pascale Maria Annunziata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02         28/08/2002

H46-            51162          Pengue, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                    28/08/2002

H46-            52808          Perna Giuseppina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                     28/08/2002

H46-            52828          Petrillo and Petrucci, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                 28/08/2002

H46-            51025          Petrillo Gino, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                             28/08/2002

H46-            51024          Porto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                       28/08/2002

H46-            52825          Pucella and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                    28/08/2002

H46-            51126          Raccio Emilia, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                           28/08/2002

H46-            51109          Restuccio, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                28/08/2002

H46-            52820          Riccardi Vicenzina, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                    28/08/2002

H46-            52823          Romano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                  28/08/2002

H46-            52844          Romano Rosa, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                          28/08/2002

H46-            52833          Santagata, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                28/08/2002

H46-            51165          Santina Pelosi, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                          28/08/2002

H46-            40151          Sciarrotta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                 28/08/2002

H46-            52839          Tanzillo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                    28/08/2002

H46-            52836          Tazza and Zullo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                        28/08/2002

H46-            52810          Tazza, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                       28/08/2002

H46-            52809          Truocchio Edmondo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                 28/08/2002

H46-            51166          Truocchio Mario, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                       28/08/2002

Section 3.b

H46-            51124          Tudisco, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                   28/08/2002

H46-            52817          Urbano and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                    28/08/2002

H46-            51026          Uzzo, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                        28/08/2002

H46-            52811          Villari, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                       28/08/2002

H46-            52847          Viscuso, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                   28/08/2002

H46-            51028          Vitelli, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                       28/08/2002

H46-            52814          Zoccolillo and others, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                28/08/2002

H46-            52800          Zuotto, judgment of 28/02/02, final on 28/05/02                                     28/08/2002

- Court of Audit

H46-            54307          Meleddu, judgment of 21/02/02 – Friendly settlement                             21/05/2002

H46-            54316          Betti, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                                   28/06/2002

H46-            54293          Chiappetta Domenico, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement          28/06/2002

H46-            54287          Ferrari Sergio, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                      28/06/2002

H46-            54299          Libertini and Di Girolamo, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement     28/06/2002

H46-            44359          Marrama, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                             28/06/2002

H46-            54286          Strangi, judgment of 07/05/02 – Friendly settlement                               07/08/2002

H46-            54282          Amici, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                       28/09/2002

H46-            54278          Leonardi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                  28/09/2002

H46-            54312          Manna, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                     28/09/2002

H46-            54319          Sportola, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                  28/09/2002

- Criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages

H46-            46970          Contardi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02                                   28/09/2002

- 4 cases against Poland

H32-            27506          Owczarzak, Interim Resolution DH(99)260                                              17/03/2002

H46-            38328          Bejer, judgment of 04/10/01, final on 04/01/02[173]                                     04/04/2002

H46-            32499          Z.R., judgment of 15/01/02 – Friendly settlement                                    15/04/2002

H46-            34052          Olstowski, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02                                 15/05/2002

- 6 cases against Portugal

H46-762       49018          Marques Jorge Ribeiro, judgment of 04/04/02 – Friendly settlement        04/07/2002

H46-            44298          Tourtier, judgment of 14/02/02, final on 14/05/02                                    14/08/2002

H46-            49020          F. Santos Lda., judgment of 16/05/02 - Friendly settlement                     16/08/2002

H46-            49118          SIB - Sociedade Imobiliária Da Benedita Lda, judgment of 16/05/02

                                      - Friendly settlement                                                                             16/08/2002

H46-            48233          Almeida Do Couto, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement               30/08/2002

H46-            48752          Coelho, judgment of 30/05/02 - Friendly settlement                                30/08/2002

- 1 case against Slovenia

H46-            42320          Belinger, judgment of 13/06/2002 - Friendly settlement                           13/09/2002

- 19 cases against Turkey

H46-            25723          Erdoğdu, judgment of 15/06/00                                                             15/09/2000

H46-            28635+        Aksoy Ibrahim, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01                          10/04/2001

H46-            27308          Demiray, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 04/04/01[174]                                04/07/2001

H46-            34688          Akin, judgment of 12/04/01                                                                   12/07/2001

Section 3.b

H46-            19265          Atak and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01                        30/07/2001

H46-            19279          Göçmen and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01                  30/07/2001

H46-            19285          Karabulut Cemile and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01     30/07/2001

H46-            19303          Şen Celal and Keziban, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01              10/10/2001

H46-            28505          Ülger, judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                                  28/06/2002

H46-            27694          A.S., judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement                                   28/06/2002

H46-            29856          Özcan Mehmet, judgment of 09/04/02 – Friendly settlement                    09/07/2002

H46-            38916          Atalağ, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement                              27/09/2002

H46-            38915          Bayram Abdullah Naci, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement      27/09/2002

H46-            35867          Bayram and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement           27/09/2002

H46-            37414          Birsel and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement              27/09/2002

H46-            35050          Karabıyık and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement         27/09/2002

H46-            33419          Özdiler Hasan Doğan, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement        27/09/2002

H46-            35079          Özkan and others, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement             27/09/2002

H46-            35866          Ünlü Dudu, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement                        27/09/2002

- 5 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-            28883          McKerr, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[175]                                  04/11/2001

H46-            37715          Shanaghan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[176]                            04/11/2001

H46-            24746          Hugh Jordan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[177]                         04/11/2001

H46-            30054          Kelly and others, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[178]                    04/11/2001

H46-            24265          Devenney, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02                                19/09/2002

Table summarising the total number of cases by States

State	No confirmation of payment of the capital sum	No confirmation of payment of the capital sum although payment due since more than 6 months	Payment after expiration of the time-limit set and no confirmation of payment of the default interest due

3.c               EXAMINATION OF SPECIAL PAYMENT PROBLEMS (FOR EXAMPLE THE DISAPPEARANCE OF THE APPLICANT, DISPUTES REGARDING THE EXACT AMOUNT PAID AS A RESULT OF EXCHANGE RATE PROBLEMS OR ADMINISTRATIVE FEES)

- 2 cases against Italy

H46-            53708          Mas A. and 207 others, judgment of 07/06/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            53705          M.L. and 46 others, judgment of 05/04/01 – Friendly settlement

- 36 cases against Turkey

H46-            30947          Alpay, judgment of 27/02/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            26093+        B.T. and others, judgment of 14/11/00 – Friendly settlement[179]

H46-            28340          Büyükdağ, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-            25182+        Cankoçak, judgment of 20/02/01, final on 20/05/01

H46-            25724          Cihan, judgment of 30/01/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            31963          Özel and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            26680          Şener, judgment of 18/07/00

H46-            27697+        Yaşar and others, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

H46-            19310          Yilmaz Hamit, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01

H46-            19308          Yilmaz Zekeriya, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01

H46-            26976+        Sürek Kamil Tekin V, judgment of 16/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H54-            22729          Kaya Mehmet, judgment of 19/02/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[180]

H54-            21893          Akdivar, Çiçek, Aktaş, Karabulut, judgment of 16/09/96, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[181]

H54-            23178          Aydin, judgment of 25/09/97, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and

                                      ResDH(2002)98[182]

H54-            24276          Kurt, judgment of 25/05/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[183]

H54-            23818          Ergi, judgment of 28/07/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[184]

H54-            22495          Yaşa, judgment of 02/09/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and

                                      ResDH(2002)98[185]

H46-            23657          Çakici, judgment of 08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[186]

H46-            23763          Tanrikulu, judgment of 08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[187]

H46-            23144          Özgür Gündem, judgment of 16/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106

H46-            22535          Kaya Mahmut, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[188]

H46-            22492          Kiliç, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[189]

H46-            20764          Ertak Ismail, judgment of 09/05/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[190]

H46-            23531          Timurtaş, judgment of 13/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[191]

H46-            21986          Salman, judgment of 27/06/00 – Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[192]

H46-            22277          Ilhan Nasir, judgment of 27/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[193]

Section 3.c

H32-            23179+        Yilmaz, Ovat, Şahin and Dündar, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[194]

H32-            25658          Aslantaş Sedat, Interim Resolutions DH(99)560 and ResDH(2001)106

H46-            22947+        Akkoç Nebahat, judgment of 10/10/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[195]

H46-            24396          Taş Beşir, judgment of 14/11/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[196]

H46-            23819          Bilgin İhsan, judgment of 16/11/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[197]

H46-            22676          Gül Mehmet, judgment of 14/12/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[198]

H46-            25801          Dulaş Zubeyde, judgment of 30/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[199]

H46-            22493          Berktay, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[200]

H46-            24490          Şarli, judgment of 22/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[201]

H46-            23954          Akdeniz and others, judgment of 31/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[202]

SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTION
(INDIVIDUAL MEASURES, MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS)

(See Addendum 4 for part or all these cases)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise the progress made in the adoption of the implementing measures in the following cases raising several problems. Supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will be issued in Addendum 4. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these items on a case-by-case basis.

                   SUB-SECTION 4.1 – SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUAL MEASURES ONLY[203]

- 1 case against Belgium

H46-            37370          Stratégies and Communications and Dumoulin, judgment of 15/07/2002, final on 15/10/2002[204]

- 1 case against Bulgaria

H46-            50963          Al-Nashif and others, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

- 3 cases against France

H46-            47160          Ezzouhdi., judgment of 13/02/01, final on 13/05/01

H46-            57753          C.K., judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-            54210          Papon, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 25/10/2002[205]

- 1 case against Germany

H46-            46544          Kutzner, judgment of 26/02/2002, final on 10/07/2002

- 3 cases against Italy

H54-             12151          F.C.B., judgment of 28/08/91, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)30 and Resolution DH(93)6

H46-            37119          N.F., judgment of 02/08/2001, final on 12/12/2001[206]

H46-            57574+        Sulejmanovic and others and Sejdovic and Sulejmanovic, judgment of 08/11/2002 - Friendly settlement[207]

- 1 case against Portugal

H46-            43999          Martins Serra and Andrade Cancio, judgment of 06/12/01, final on 06/03/02

- 1 case against Turkey

H46-            29900+        Sadak, Zana, Dicle and Doğan, judgment of 17/07/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)59

- 3 cases against the United Kingdom

H54-            19187          Saunders, judgment of 17/12/96, Interim Resolution DH(2000)27

H46-            29522+        I.J.L., G.M.R. and A.K.P., judgment of 19/09/00

H46-            36533          Atlan A. and T., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01

                   SUB-SECTION 4.2 – INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

- 4 cases against Austria

H46-             38536          Schreder, judgment of 13/12/01, final on 13/03/02

H46-             50110          Maurer, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02

H46-             35673          Schweighofer and others, judgment of 09/10/01, final on 09/01/02

H46-             24430          Lanz, judgment of 31/01/02, final on 31/04/02

- 1 case against Belgium

H46-             51564          Čonka, judgment of 05/02/02, final on 05/05/02[208]

- 4 cases against Bulgaria

H46-             33977          Ilijkov, judgment of 26/07/01

H46-             29221          Stankov and the United Macedonian Organisation Ilinden, judgment of 02/10/01, final on 02/01/02

H46-             41488          Velikova, judgment of 18/05/00, final on 04/10/00

H46-            38361          Anguelova, judgment of 13/06/2002, final on 13/09/2002

- 1 case against Croatia

H46-             48778          Kutić, judgment of 01/03/02, final on 01/06/02

- 2 cases against Cyprus

H46-            30873          Egmez, judgment of 21/12/00

H46-            25316+        Denizci and others, judgment of 23/05/01, final on 23/08/01

- 6 cases against France

H46-             24846          Zielinski and Pradal and Gonzalez and others, judgment of 28/10/99 - Grand Chamber

H32-             33656          Lemoine Daniel

H46-            39594          Kress, judgment of 07/06/01 – Grand Chamber[209]

H46-            38436          APBP, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-            38748          Immeubles Groupe Kosser, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002[210]

H46-            36515          Fretté, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

- 7 cases against Greece

H46-             47760          Koskinas, judgment of 20/06/02, final on 20/09/02

H46-             46355          Tsirikakis, judgments of 17/01/02, final on 10/07/02[211] and of 23/01/03 (Article 41), final up to 23/04/03[212]

H46-             40907          Dougoz, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01

H46-             28524          Peers, judgment of 19/04/01

H46-             38460          Platakou, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 06/09/01[213]

Sub-Section 4.1

H46-             25701          former King of Greece, Princess Irene and Princess Ekaterini, judgments of 23/11/00 and of 28/11/02 (Article 41) - Grand Chamber

H46-            47541          Vasilopoulou, judgment of 21/03/02, final on 21/06/02

- 3 cases against Ireland

H46-            36887          Quinn, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-            34720          Heaney and McGuinness, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-            39474          D.G., judgment of 16/05/02, final on 16/08/02[214]

- 4 cases against Italy

H46-             41879          Saggio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-             33286          Dorigo Paolo, Interim Resolutions DH(99)258 and ResDH(2002)30

H46-             30127          Sciortino, judgment of 18/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H46-            31143          Indelicato, judgment of 18/10/01, final on 18/01/02[215]

- 1 case against Moldova

H46-            45701          Metropolitan Chruch of Bessarabia and others, judgment of 13/12/01, final on 27/03/02[216]

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-             37328          A.B., judgment of 29/01/02, final on 29/04/02

- 1 case against Poland

H46-            26760          Werner, judgment of 15/11/01

- 1 case against Portugal

H46-             44872          Magalhaes Pereira, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

- 15 cases against Romania

H46-            31679          Ignaccolo-Zenide, judgment of 25/01/00

H46-            28114          Dalban, judgment of 28/09/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-            28871          Constantinescu, judgment of 27/06/00

H46-            28342          Brumărescu, judgments of 28/10/99, 23/01/01 (Article 41) and 11/05/01

                                      (rectification) – Grand Chamber[217]

H46-            29411          Anghelescu, judgment of 09/04/02, final on 09/07/02

H46-            35831          Bălănescu, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[218]

Sub-Section 4.2

H46-            34992          Basacopol, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[219]

H46-            33912          Budescu and Petrescu, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002, rectified on 09/07/2002[220]

H46-            29053          Ciobanu, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[221]

H46-            32925          Cretu, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[222]

H46-            32943          Falcoianu and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002[223]

H46-            29968          Hodoş and others, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[224] [225]

H46-            33358          Oprea and others, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[226]

H46-            32260          Surpaceanu Constantin and Traian-Victor, judgment of 21/05/2002,

                                      final on 21/08/2002[227]

H46-            29407          Vasiliu, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 04/09/2002[228] [229]

- 1 case against the Russian Federation

H46-            47095          Kalashnikov, judgment of 15/07/2002, final on 15/10/2002

- 2 cases against San Marino

H46-             24954          Tierce and others, judgment of 25/07/00

H46-             35396          Stefanelli, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

- 2 cases against the Slovak Republic

H46-             40058          Gajdúšek, judgment of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02

H46-             48672          Nemec and others, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02

- 4 cases against Switzerland

H46-             26899          H.B., judgment of 05/04/01, final on 05/07/01

H46-             31827          J.B., judgment of 03/05/01, final on 03/08/01

H54-             20919          E.L., R.L. and O.-L., judgment of 29/08/97, Interim Resolution DH(99)111

H54-             19958          A.P., M.P. and T.P., judgment of 29/08/97, Interim Resolution DH(99)110

- 109 cases against Turkey

H46-            34382          Danemark, judgment of 05/04/00- Friendly settlement

H46-            40035          Jabari, judgment of 11/07/00, final on 11/10/00

H46-            25144+        Sadak Selim and others, judgment of 11/06/2002, final on 06/11/2002[230]

                    - Cases concerning length of criminal proceedings

H46-             31880          Adıyaman, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             32964          Akçam, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             33362          Akyazı, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

Sub-Section 4.2

H46-             29280          Başpınar, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             29913          Binbir, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             26480          Bürkev, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             29912          Çilengir, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             32981          Dede and others, judgment of 07/05/02, final on 07/08/02

H46-             29699          Dinleten, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             31891          Genç, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             39428          İnan, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             28291          Kanbur, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             32990          Karademir, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             32987          Keskin, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             29360          Ketenoğlu Gülşen and Ketenoğlu Halil Yasin, judgment of 25/09/01, final on 25/12/01

H46-             29700          Metinoğlu, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             29701          Özcan Süleyman, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             31960          Pekdaş, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             31961          Şahin Metin, judgment of 25/09/01, final on 25/12/01

H46-             29702          Sarıtaç, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             29911          Uygur, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-             31834          Yağız Hasan, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/01/02

H46-             29703          Zülal, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

                    - Action of the security forces

H46-             23954          Akdeniz and others, judgment of 31/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[231]

H54-             21893          Akdivar, Çiçek, Aktaş, Karabulut, judgment of 16/09/96, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[232]

H46-             22947+        Akkoç Nebahat, judgment of 10/10/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[233]

H54-             21987          Aksoy, judgment of 18/12/96, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-             22279          Altay, judgment of 22/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-             25657          Avşar, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 27/03/2000[234]

H54-             23178          Aydin, judgment of 25/09/97, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[235]

H46-             26093+        B.T. and others, judgment of 14/11/00 – Friendly settlement[236]

H46-             22493          Berktay, judgment of 01/03/01, final on 01/06/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[237]

H46-             23819          Bilgin İhsan, judgment of 16/11/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[238]

H46-             25659          Bilgin İrfan, judgment of 17/07/01, final on 17/10/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-             23657          Çakici, judgment of08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[239]

H32-             22677          Çetin, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-             25704          Çiçek, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 05/09/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[240]

H46-             27308          Demiray, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 04/04/01[241]

Sub-Section 4.2

H46-             20869          Dikme, judgment of 11/07/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-             25801          Dulaş Zubeyde, judgment of 30/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[242]

H46-             27602          Ekinci Ülkü, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[243]

H54-             23818          Ergi, judgment of28/07/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[244]

H46-             20764          Ertak Ismail, judgment of 09/05/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[245]

H46-             22676          Gül Mehmet, judgment of 14/12/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[246]

H54-             21593          Güleç, judgment of 27/07/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-             22277          Ilhan Nasir, judgment of 27/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[247]

H46-             22535          Kaya Mahmut, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[248]

H54-            22729          Kaya Mehmet, judgment of 19/02/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[249]

H46-             22492          Kiliç, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[250]

H54-             24276          Kurt, judgment of 25/05/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[251]

H54-             23186          Menteş, Turhallı M. and S, and Uvat, judgment of 28/11/97, Interim Resolution DH(99)434

H46-             21594          Oğur, judgment of 20/05/99 - Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-             31889          Orak Abdurrahman, judgment of 14/02/02, final on 14/05/02

H46-             25656          Orhan Salih, judgment of 18/06/2002, final on 06/11/2002[252] [253]

H46-             21986          Salman, judgment of 27/06/00 – Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[254]

H46-             24490          Şarli, judgment of 22/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[255]

H46-             31866          Satık and others, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H54-             23184          Selçuk and Asker, judgment of 24/04/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-             22876          Şemse Önen, judgment of 26/01/02, final on 14/05/02[256]

H46-             26129          Tanlı, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01, rectified on 28/04/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-             23763          Tanrikulu, judgment of08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[257]

H46-             24396          Taş Beşir, judgment of 14/11/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[258]

H54-             22496          Tekin, judgment of 09/06/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-             23531          Timurtaş, judgment of 13/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98[259]

H46-             32357          Veznedaroğlu Sevtap, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 18/10/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98 [260]

Sub-Section 4.2

H54-             22495          Yaşa, judgment of02/09/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[261]

H32-             23179+        Yilmaz, Ovat, Şahin and Dündar, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98[262]

                    - Cases concerning dissolution of political parties

H46-             23885          Freedom and Democracy Party (ÖZDEP), judgment of 08/12/99 - Grand Chamber

H54-             19392          United Communist Party of Turkey and others, judgment of 30/01/98

H54-             21237          Socialist Party and others, judgment of 25/05/98, Interim Resolution DH(99)245

H46-             22723          Yazar, Karataş, Aksoy and People’s Labour Party (HEP), judgment of 09/04/02

                   - Friendly settlement cases containing undertakings by the Turkish Government

H46-             24940          Acar, judgment of 18/12/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             31137          Adalı, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement[263]

H46-             32598          Akbay, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             37453          Akman, judgment of 26/06/01, final on 25/10/2001[264] - Striking-out

H46-             24935          Avcı, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             28293          Aydın K., C. Aydin and S. Aydin and others, judgment of 10/07/01- Friendly settlement

H46-             29289          Aydın Mehmet, judgment of 16/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24946          Boğ, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24938          Boğa, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24934          Değer, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             22280          Demir Mahmut, judgment of 05/12/2002 - Friendly settlement[265]

H46-             24990          Demir, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24939          Doğan, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             30492          Erat and Sağlam, judgment of 26/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-             31246          Ercan, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             26337          Erdoğan Mahmut, judgment of 20/06/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24945          Güngü Kemal, judgment of 18/12/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             30953          I.I., I.S., K.E., and A.O., judgment of 06/11/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             38588          Keçeci, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement[266]

H46-             31890          Kınay M. and Kınay R., judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement[267]

H46-             24944          Kızılgedik, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             31136          Önder Yalçın, judgment of 25/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24936          Orak Adnan, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             27735          Oral and others, judgment of 28/03/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-             31883          Özbey, judgment of 31/01/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-             24942          Parlak, Aktürk and Tay, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             29359          Saki, judgment of 30/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-             31154          Şen Filiyet, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement[268]

H46-             24991          Şenses, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

Sub-Section 4.2

H46-             31153          Soğukpınar, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement[269]

H46-             36189          Yakar, judgment of 26/11/2002 - Friendly settlement[270]

H46-             31152          Yalçın Şaziment, judgment of 12/12/2002 - Friendly settlement[271]

H46-             22281          Yaşa Sıddık, judgment of 27/06/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-             32979          Yıldız Özgür, judgment of 16/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-             27532          Z.Y., judgment of 09/04/02 - Friendly settlement

- 1 case against Ukraine

H46-            48553          Sovtransavto Holding, judgment of 25/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[272]

- 21 cases against the United Kingdom

H32-             23496          Quinn, Interim Resolutions DH(98)214 and ResDH(2002)85

H32-             22384          Murray Kevin, Interim Resolutions DH (98)156 and ResDH(2002)85

H46-             28135          Magee, judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)85

H54-             18731          Murray John, judgment of 08/02/96, Interim Resolutions DH(2000)26, ResDH(2002)85

H46-             36408          Averill, judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)85

H46-             46295          Stafford, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber

H46-             37555          O'Hara, judgment of 16/10/01, final on 16/01/02

H46-             38784          Morris, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H46-             27229          Keenan, judgment of 03/04/01

H46-             35605          Kingsley, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber

H46-             39846          Brennan, judgment of 16/10/01, final on 16/01/02

H46-             35765          A.D.T., judgment of 31/07/00, final on 31/10/00

H46-             44787          P.G. and J.H., judgment of 25/09/01, final on 25/12/01

H46-             56547          P., C. and S., judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002[273]

H46-             46477          Edwards Paul and Audrey, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02[274]

H54-             25599          A., judgment of 23/09/98

                    Action of the security forces (CM/Inf(2003)4)

H46-            43290          McShane, judgment of 28/05/2002, final on 28/08/2002[275]

H46-            28883          McKerr, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[276]

H46-            37715          Shanaghan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[277]

H46-            24746          Hugh Jordan, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[278]

H46-            30054          Kelly and others, judgment of 04/05/01, final on 04/08/01[279]

                   SUB-SECTION 4.3 – SPECIAL PROBLEMS

- 117 cases against Italy

                   117 cases concerning length of proceedings before administrative courts [280]

H46-            41809          A.B. V, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            56226          Abate and Ferdinandi, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            29171          Abbate Giovanni, Interim Resolution DH(97)367

H54-            25587          Abenavoli, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-            41806          Alesiani and 510 others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-            26863          Almanno, Interim Resolution DH(96)611

H46-            41805          Arivella, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-            25579          B.Q., Interim Resolution DH(96)213

H32-            26864          Bacci Roberto Maria, Interim Resolution DH(96)612

H32-            25585          Bagnoli and Mazzone G., A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)214

H32-            34878          Barcellona, Interim Resolution DH(99)202

H32-            35343          Bertozzi, Vorrasi, Ciarmoli and Forgione, Interim Resolution DH(99)642

H32-            27189          Bevilacqua, Interim Resolution DH(97)524

H46-            34437          Caliendo, judgment of 14/03/00, final on 14/03/00

H46-            41817          Caliri, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            44341          Cannone, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            44347          Carapella and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H32-            19977          Carriero, Interim Resolution DH(96)26

H32-            31628          Catania, Interim Resolution DH(99)414

H32-            25576          Cavaliero s.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(96)215

H32-            34882          Cecamore, Interim Resolution DH(99)203

H46-            44332          Cecchini, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            44350          Cecere Domenico, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            56222          Centis, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            29170          Cerruto, Interim Resolution DH(97)368

H32-            29125          Chierici B. and E., Interim Resolution DH(97)331

H46-            41804          Ciotta, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            56206          Colonnello and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            41811          Comitini, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            56208          Conte and others, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            56202          Cornia, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            27494          Corona Vincenzo, Interim Resolution DH(97)020

H32-            25577          Cosma, Interim Resolution DH(96)216

H32-            25588          D.M. II, Interim Resolution DH(96)217

H46-            56224          D’Amore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            27996+        D'Amico and Altobelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)130

H46-            56217          De Cesaris, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H54-            25574          De Santa, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-            20359          Della Sala Raffaele, Interim Resolution DH(96)614

H46-            44337          Delli Paoli, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            56205          Dente, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            14147+        Di Bonaventura

H46-            56225          Di Pede II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            56221          Donato, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            44525          Ferrari Marcella II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            44379          Finessi, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            56212          Folletti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            44349          Fragnito, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

Sub-Section 4.3

H32-            30600          G. D.P., Interim Resolution DH(97)525

H32-            25584          G.L.C., Interim Resolution DH(96)218

H32-            31622          G.O. II, Interim Resolution DH(97)654

H46-            35956          Galatà and others, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            44342          Gattuso, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 06/03/2002

H46-            44340          Gaudenzi, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H46-            56203          Ginocchio, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            25580          Giorgini, Interim Resolution DH(96)219

H54-            25586          Lapalorcia, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-            25581          Latini, Interim Resolution DH(96)220

H46-            44334          Lattanzi and Cascia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            56204          Limatola, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            56207          Lugnan in Basile, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            15080          Magnaghi, Interim Resolution DH(96)379

H32-            27994+        Manzini and Benet, Interim Resolution DH(97)129

H46-            44343          Massimo Giuseppe I, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            44352          Massimo Giuseppe II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            56220          Mastropasqua, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            38149          Mazzone G. and E. I, Interim Resolution DH(99)306

H32-            38150          Mazzone G. and E. II, Interim Resolution DH(99)307

H46-            33804          Mennitto, judgment of 05/10/00

H32-            25589          Mentastro, Interim Resolution DH(96)221

H46-            38594          Mereu and S. Maria Navarrese, judgment of 13/06/2002, final on 13/09/2002

H46-            44338          Miele, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            41815          Monti Enrico, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            17814          Mori Puddu, Interim Resolution DH(97)177

H46-            41810          Mosca, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            38526          Murgo M, O, and S. and Giannone, Interim Resolution DH(99)415

H32-            30322          Nani, Interim Resolution DH(98)193

H46-            56211          Napolitano Giuseppe, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            44348          Nazzaro and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H54-            25839          Nicodemo, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-            44335          O., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-            18908          P.P. III, Interim Resolution DH(97)111

H46-            44351          Pace and others, judgment of 09/07/2002, final on 09/10/2002

H32-            35950+        Paglietti and 126 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)99

H46-            41816          Paradiso Antonio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            15800+        Perego and Romanet

H46-            56213          Piacenti, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            56223          Polcari, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            34880          Polto Miranda, Interim Resolution DH(99)204

H46-            56219          Presel, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            31631          Procaccini, judgment of 30/03/00, final on 30/03/00

H32-            27999+        Recinelli and Corona, Interim Resolution DH(97)132

H32-            27493          Recinelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)21

H32-            27997          Ridolfi, Interim Resolution DH(97)131

H46-            44345          Rinaudo and others, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            56214          Ripoli I, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            56215          Ripoli II, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            26865+        Rubbo and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)613

H32-            34881          Ruocco, Interim Resolution DH(99)643

H32-            25582          Sansoni, Interim Resolution DH(96)222

H32-            31625          Santoro Claudio, Interim Resolution DH(97)655

H46-            56201          Sardo Salvatore, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

Sub-Section 4.3

H32-            29672          Scopelliti II, Interim Resolution DH(97)469

H32-            27484+        Serino and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)133

H32-            25450          Spera Michele, Interim Resolution DH(97)372

H46-            56218          Stabile Michele, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H32-            34283          Stampacchia, Interim Resolution DH(98)272

H32-            25583          Stracuzzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)241

H32-            25578          Turrina and Scattolini, Interim Resolution DH(96)223

H32-            31620          U. P., Interim Resolution DH(97)656

H32-            38152          Ullo, Interim Resolution DH(99)308

H46-            44333          V.P. and F.D.R., judgment of 12/02/02, final on 12/05/02

H46-            44346          Venturini Alberto II, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H32-            29301          Vitali II, Interim Resolution DH(97)332

H32-            29302          Vitali III, Interim Resolution DH(97)333

H32-            39170          Zappalà, Interim Resolution DH(99)523

H46-            41814          Zeoli and 34 others, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 05/10/00

- 2 cases against Turkey

H46-            25781          Cyprus against Turkey, judgment of 10/05/01 – Grand Chamber

H46-            26308          Institut de Prêtres français and others, judgment of 14/12/00 – Friendly settlement

SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED

(See Addendum 5 for part or all these cases)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise progress in the adoption of general measures aiming at preventing further similar violations to those found by the Court in the following cases. If necessary, supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will appear in Addendum 5. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in 6 months at the latest.

                   SUB-SECTION 5.1 – LEGISLATIVE AND/OR REGULATORY CHANGES

- 1 case against Austria

H46-             49455          Gollner, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02

- 1 case against Liechtenstein

H46-             28396          Wille, judgment of 28/10/99 - Grand Chamber

- 3 cases against Malta

H46-             25642          Aquilina, judgment of 29/04/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-             25644          T.W., judgment of 29/04/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-             35892          Sabeur Ben Ali, judgment of 29/06/00, final on 29/09/00

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-             25989          Van Vlimmeren and Van Ilverenbeek, judgment of 26/09/00

- 22 cases against Poland

                   - Cases concerning length of civil proceedings

H54-            27916          Podbielski, judgment of 30/10/98

H54-            28616          Styranowski, judgment of 30/10/98

H46-            38328          Bejer, judgment of 04/10/01, final on 04/01/02[281]

H46-            27918          C., judgment of 03/05/01

H32-            24559          Gibas, Interim Resolution DH(97)242[282]

H46-            48001          Goc, judgment of 16/04/02, final on 16/07/02

H46-            29695          Gronuś, judgment of 28/05/02, final on 28/08/02

H46-            71891          Hałka and others, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 02/10/2002[283]

H46-            29691          Jedamski, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-            43779          Mączyński, judgment of 15/01/02, final on 15/04/02

H46-            35843          Malinowska, judgment of 14/12/00, final on 14/03/01

H46-            36250          Parciński, judgment of 18/03/01, final on 18/03/02

H46-            40330          Piechota, judgment of 05/11/2002, final on 05/02/2003 [284]

H46-            29455          Pogorzelec, judgment of 17/07/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-            37645          Sawicka, judgment of 01/10/2002, final on 01/01/2003[285]

H46-            25693+        Sobczyk, judgment of 26/10/00, final on 26/01/01

H46-            40835          Szaparo, judgment of 23/05/02, final on 23/08/02

H46-            48684          Uthke, judgment of 18/06/02, final on 18/09/02[286]

H46-            65660          W.Z., judgment of 24/10/2002, final on 24/01/2003[287]

H46-            32734          Wasilewski, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 06/09/01

H46-            33082          Wojnowicz, judgment of 21/09/00, final on 22/01/01

H46-            34158          Zawadzki, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 27/03/02

Sub-section 5.1

- 3 cases against Romania

H54-             27053          Vasilescu, judgment of 22/05/98, Interim Resolution DH(99)676

H54-             27273          Petra, judgment of 23/09/98

H46-             28341          Rotaru, judgment of 04/05/00 - Grand Chamber

- 2 cases against the-United Kingdom

H54-             22520          Johnson Stanley, judgment of 24/10/97

H46-             30308          Faulkner Ian, judgment of 30/11/99 - Friendly settlement

                   SUB-SECTION 5.2 – CHANGES OF COURTS’ CASE-LAW OR OF ADMINISTRATIVE PRACTICE

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 5.3 – PUBLICATION / DISSEMINATION

                   (NO DEBATE ENVISAGED)

- 1 case against Germany

H46-            34045          Hoffmann, judgment of 11/10/01, final on 11/01/02

- 2 cases against Finland

H46-            31611          Nikula, judgment of 21/03/02, final on 21/06/02

H46-            49684          Hirvisaari, judgment of 27/09/01, final on 27/12/01

- 1 case against Greece

H46-            43622          Malama, judgments of 01/03/01, final on 5/09/2001[288] and of 18/04/02 (Article 41), final on 18/07/02

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-            31465          Sen, judgment of 21/12/01, final on 21/03/02

SUB-SECTION 5.4 – OTHER MEASURES

No new case

SECTION 6 - CASES AWAITING FOR THE PRESENTATION OF A DRAFT RESOLUTION

Action

At the time of issuing the present annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the Secretariat was preparing, in consultation with the Permanent Representations concerned, draft resolutions aiming at closing the examination of these cases. The Deputies are invited to postpone consideration of these cases to their next meeting.

Section 6

- 24 cases against Austria

H46-            29271          Dichand and others, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H46-            26958          Jerusalem, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H46-            34315          Krone Verlag Gmbh and Co. Kg., judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H46-            34320          Freiheitliche Landesgruppe Burgenland, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28525          Unabhängige Initiative Informationsvielfalt, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

H54-            15153          Vereinigung Demokratischer Soldaten Österreichs and Berthold Gubi, judgment of 19/12/94

H32-            26113          Wirtschafts-Trend Zeitschriften Verlagsgesellchaft m.b.H.

H46-            36075          Siegl, judgment of 20/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            33505          H.E., judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[289]

H46-            37075          Luksch, judgment of 13/12/01, final on 13/03/02

H46-            27783          T., judgment of 14/11/00

H46-            31266          G.H., judgment of 03/10/00, final on 03/01/01

H46-            26297          G.S., judgment of 21/12/99

H46-            35019          Ludescher, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-            33915          Walder, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 17/09/01

H32-            17291          Hortolomei

H46-            37950          Franz Fischer, judgment of 29/05/01, final on 29/08/01

H46-            25878          Michael Edward Cooke, judgment of 08/02/00

H46-            30428          Beer Gertrude, judgment of 06/02/01

H46-            33382          Fischer Joseph, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 17/04/02

H46-            28501          Pobornikoff, judgment of 03/10/00

H46-            33501          Telfner, judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-            32381          Baischer, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-            29477          Eisenstecken, judgment of 03/10/00

- 1 case against Belgium

H54-            17849          S.A. Pressos Compania Naviera and others, judgment of 20/11/95

- 2 cases against Bulgaria

H32-            30381          Mironov - Interim Resolution DH(99)352

H46-            32438          Stefanov, judgment of 03/05/01, final on 03/08/01 - Friendly settlement

- 4 cases against Cyprus

H46-            53594          Alithia Publishing Company, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002

H46-            51591          Markass Car Hide Ltd, judgment of 02/07/2002, final on 06/11/2002[290]

H46-            29515          Larkos, judgment of 18/02/99

H46-            47293          Selim, judgment of 16/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 3 cases against the Czech Republic

H46-            33644          Cesky, judgment of 06/06/00, final on 06/09/00

H46-            31315          Punzelt, judgment of 25/04/00, final on 25/07/00

H46-            35848          Barfuss, judgment of 31/07/00, final on 31/10/00

Section 6

- 2 cases against Denmark

H46-            48470          Jensen, judgment of 14/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            56811          Amrollahi, judgment of 11/07/2002, final on 11/10/2002

- 3 cases against Finland

H46-            28856          Jokela, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 21/08/2002

H46-            25651          L., judgment of 27/04/00, final on 27/07/00

H46-            30013          Türkiye iş Bankasi, judgment of 18/06/2002, final on 18/09/2002

- 80 cases against France

H46-            25803          Selmouni, judgment of 28/07/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-            34406          Mazurek, judgment of 01/02/00, final on 01/05/00

H46-            25088          Chassagnou and others, judgment of 29/04/99

H54-            25017          Mehemi, judgment of 06/09/97

H32-            27019          Slimane-Kaïd I

H54-            23618          Lambert Michel, judgment of 24/08/98

H32-            27413          Cazes

H46-            25444          Pelissier and Sassi, judgment of 25/03/99

H46-            32872          Peltier, judgment of 21/05/2002, final on 21/08/2002

H46-            31819+        Annoni Di Gussola, Desbordes and Omer, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

H46-            34553          Dulaurans, judgment of 21/03/00

H32-            27659          Ferville

H32-            28845          Venot

H46-            29507          Slimane-Kaïd II, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 17/05/00[291]

H46-            27362          Voisine, judgment of 08/02/00

H46-            33933          Guisset, judgment of 26/09/00, final on 26/09/00

H54-            14032          Poitrimol, judgment of 23/11/93

H32-            17572          A.C.

H54-            25201          Guerin, judgment of 29/07/98

H46-            34791          Khalfaoui, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H54-            24767          Omar, judgment of 29/07/98

H46-            31070          Van Pelt, judgment of 23/05/00, final on 23/08/00

- Length of civil proceedings

H46-            53118          Boiseau, judgment of 19/02/02, final on 19/05/02

H46-            39066          Donnadieu, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-            31603          Hermant

H46-            35589          Kanoun, judgment of 03/10/00, final on 03/01/01

H46-            41943          L.L., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-            47575          Marks and Ordinateur Express, judgment of 21/02/02, final on 21/05/02

H32-            29877          Pauchet and others - Interim Resolution DH(98)100

H32-            26496          Société Fruehauf France

- Length of proceedings before administrative courts

H54-            36313          Henra, judgment of 29/04/98

H54-            36317          Leterme, judgment of 29/04/98

H54-            32217          Pailot, judgment of 22/04/98

H54-            33441          Richard, judgment of 22/04/98

H46-            47007          Arnal, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-            55672          Beaume Marty, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

Section 6

H46-            46280          Benzi, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H32-            31842          Darmagnac Pierre V

H46-            38945          Francisco, judgment of 13/11/01, final on 13/02/02

H46-            49622          Goubert and Labbe, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-            50996          Grand, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-            42189          H.L., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

H46-            40493          Jacquie and Ledun, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H46-            44617          Leray and others, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-            42588          Linard, judgment of 25/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43288          Mahieu, judgment of 19/06/01

H32-            25309          Maljean

H46-            44485          Moullet, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-            45573          Moyer, judgment of 25/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            41946+        Ribes J.M. and M.A., judgment of 07/05/2002, final on 07/08/2002

H46-            37565          Sapl, judgment of 18/12/01, final on 18/03/02

H46-            51818          Société Comabat, judgment of 26/03/2002, final on 26/06/2002

H46-            46708          Zaheg, judgment of 9/02/02, final on 19/05/02

- Length of proceedings before the Conseil d’Etat

H46-            38249          Arvois, judgment of 23/11/99, final on 23/02/00

H46-            28660          Ballestra, judgment of 12/12/00, final on 12/03/01

H46-            33207          Blaisot C. and M., judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H46-            36932          Caillot, judgment of 04/06/99, final on 04/09/99

H46-            42401          Camps, judgment of 24/10/00, final on 09/04/01

H46-            54757          Chaufour, judgment of 19/03/02, final on 19/06/02

H46-            41449          Durrand I, judgment of 13/11/01, final on 13/02/02

H46-            42038          Durrand II, judgment of 13/11/01, final on 13/02/02

H46-            30979          Frydlender, judgment of 27/06/00

H46-            48205+        Gentilhomme, Schaff-Benhadji and Zerouki, judgment of 14/05/2002, final on 14/08/2002

H46-            44066          Grass, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            41001          Joseph-Gilbert Garcia, judgment of 26/09/00, final on 26/12/00

H46-            37387          Lambourdiere, judgment of 02/08/00, final on 02/11/00

H46-            39996          Ouendeno, judgment of 16/04/2002, final on 10/07/2002[292]

H32-            32510          Peter

H46-            33989          Thery, judgment of 01/02/00, final on 01/05/00

H46-            38042          Zanatta, A. and J.-B., judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

- Length of proceedings before labour courts

H32-            27518          A.S.

H46-            47194          Leboeuf, judgment of 26/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            38398          Leclercq, judgment of 28/11/00, final on 28/02/01

H46-            44791          Marcel, judgment of 09/04/02 – Friendly settlement

H32-            35259          Nagler

- Length of criminal proceedings

H46-            38687          Djaid, judgment of 29/09/99, final on 29/12/99

H46-            49342          Dunan, judgment of 30/10/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            49350          Ivars, judgment of 30/10/01 – Friendly settlement

- Length of criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages

H46-            37257          Lucas, judgment of 28/11/00, final on 28/02/01

H46-            32033          Thurin, judgment of 28/11/00, final on 28/02/01

Section 6

- 37 cases against Greece

H54-            19233+        Tsirlis and Kouloumpas, judgment of 29/05/97

H54-            24348          Grigoriades, judgment of 25/11/97

H54-            23372+        Larissis and others, judgment of 24/02/98

H54-            18748          Manoussakis and others, judgment of 25/09/96

H46-            38178          Serif, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-            34369          Thlimmenos, judgment of 06/04/00

H46-            38703          Agoudimos and Cefallonian Sky Shipping Co., judgment of 28/06/01, final on 28/09/01

H46-            37098          Antonakopoulos, Vortsela and Antonakopoulou, judgment of 14/12/99, final on 21/03/00

H46-            43597          Dionyssios Petrotos, judgment of 29/02/00 – Friendly settlement

H54-            21522          Georgiadis Anastasios, judgment of 29/05/97

H46-            41209          Georgiadis Dimitrios, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H32-            34373          Goutsos, Interim Resolution DH(99)558

H54-            18357          Hornsby, judgment of 19/03/97

H46-            31107          Iatridis, judgments of 25/03/99 and 19/10/00 (Article 41) – Grand Chamber

H46-            53478          Sajtos, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-            38704          Savvidou, judgment of 01/08/00, final on 01/11/00

H32-            32397          Sinnesael, Interim Resolution DH(99)130

H46-            28802          Tsavachidis, judgment of 21/01/99

- Length of civil proceedings

H46-            30342          Academy Trading Ltd and others, judgment of 04/04/00

H46-            40434          Kosmopolis S. A., judgment of 29/03/01, final on 29/06/01

H46-            46380          LSI Information Technologies, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

- Length of proceedings before administrative courts

H46-            42079          E.H., judgment of 25/10/01, final on 27/03/02

H46-            41459          Fatourou, judgment of 03/08/00, final on 03/11/00

H46-            41867          Messochoritis, judgment of 12/04/01, final on 12/07/01

H54-            20323          Pafitis and others, judgment of 26/02/98

H46-            38971          Protopapa and Marangou, judgment of 28/03/00, final on 28/06/00

H32-            34569          Société anonyme Dimitrios Koutsoumbos, société technique, commerciale et touristique

H46-            47891          Spentzouris, judgment of 07/05/2002, final on 07/08/2002

H46-            40437          Tsingour, judgment of 06/07/00, final on 06/10/00

H46-            38459          Varipati, judgment of 26/10/99, final on 26/01/00

H46-            55611          Xenopoulos, judgment of 28/03/2002, final on 04/09/2002[293]

- Court of Audit

H46-            47734          Adamogiannis, judgment of 14/03/2002, final on 14/06/2002

- Length of criminal proceedings

H46-            37439          Agga, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 25/04/00

H54-            19773          Philis 2, judgment of 27/06/97

H54-            28523          Portington, judgment of 23/09/98

H32-            32857          Stamoulakatos Nicholas I

H32-            24453          Tarighi Wageh Dashti

Section 6

- 2 cases against Hungary

H46-            32396          Magyar, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 11/04/01

H46-            38937          Erdős, judgment of 09/04/2002, final on 09/07/2002

- 106 cases against Italy

H46-            41221          Troiani Marcello II, judgment of 06/12/2001, final on 10/07/2002

H32-            27253          Biasetti

H46-            44955          Mancini Vittorio and Luigi, judgment of 02/08/01, final on 12/12/01

H32-            25650          Santandrea

H46-            37019          A.M., judgment of 14/12/99, final on 14/03/00

H46-            47247          Mercuri, judgment of 11/04/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31227          Ambruosi, judgment of 19/10/00, final on 19/01/01

H32-            16609          Intrieri

H54-            14025          Zubani, judgments of 07/08/96 and 16/06/99

- Labour courts

H46-            43077          A.S. II, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43092          Ascierto Pietro, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43048          Bernardo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43005          Bianchi Michele, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38973          Borrillo, judgment of 22/06/00 – Friendly settlement

H46-            43082          C.S., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43081          C.T., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43073          Camerlengo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43007          Capasso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43008          Catillo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43107          Circelli Maria Carmela, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42989          Costantini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43014          D’Errico, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43044          De Cicco Giuseppe, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43003          De Fiore, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43013          De Nunzio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42992          Del Grosso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43047          Del Vecchio Edvige, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43009          Di Biase Maria, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42991          Falzarano, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43045          Forgione, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43049          Fusco Adelia, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43104          Galietti, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43002          Giorgio Nicola, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43103          Lombardi Gianfranco and 7 others, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43105          Intorcia, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43006          La Vista, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43080          M.A.P., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42990          Manganiello, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            40722          Marotta, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42988          Marucci, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42994          Mascolo, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43046          Masella, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43001          Masuccio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42995          Mirra, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43071          Narciso, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

Section 6

H46-            43079          P.C. IV, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43089          Pellegrino Rossi, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43090          Perugini, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43106          Rossi Lina, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43108          Selvaggio, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43004          Verzino, judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            43078          Z., judgment of 22/06/00 - Friendly settlement

- Civil courts

H46-            44375          Rocchi Roberto, judgment of 29/03/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            44814+        M.A. and 81 others, judgment of 30/11/00 - Friendly settlement

- Administrative courts

H46-            44344          Marcotrigiano, judgment of 19/12/00 - Friendly settlement

- Court of Audit

H46-            54288          Andreozzi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54297          Aniceto, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            44365          Calvani, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            41829          Campomizzi, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            54291          Caproni, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            41833          Cardillo, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-            54309          Carretta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54313          Castiello, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54292          Cerasomma, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54290+        D'Agostino Francesco, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            41821          Delicata, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            44370          D’Innella, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            54294          Fiore Mario, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            44367          G.G. IV, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            54280          Giordano, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54302          Incollingo, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54301          Jaculli, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54296          Manera, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54306          Masia, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54308          Mignanelli, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            44369          Pe.C., judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            54318          Picano, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            41831          Pio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            54279          Prete, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54314          Quacquarelli, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            41819          Quinci, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            54284          Radicchi, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            41830          Raglione, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            54298          Sabetta, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            44368          Sapia, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            41820          Sinagoga, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-            54311          Soave, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54303          Spatrisano, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54305          Tamburrini, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54285          Tatangelo, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            54315          Tortolani, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            41837          Trotta, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H46-            54295          Trovato, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

Section 6

H46-            41841          Vay, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-            41818          Vero, judgment of 28/04/00, final on 28/07/00

H46-            54317          Zullo Rocco, judgment of 28/03/02, final on 28/06/02

H46-            44362          Di Deco, judgment of 12/04/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            44401          Fermi and others, judgment of 06/11/01 – Friendly settlement

- Failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

H46-            33966          Bastreghi, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            32363          Bertini, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            38415          C.M.F., judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37242          Caramanti, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            39797          Guazzone, judgment of 11/07/2002 - Friendly settlement (rectified on 01/08/2002)

H46-            35243          N. and D.A., judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31259          Rizzi, judgment of 03/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            37248          Vietti, judgment of 18/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 1 case against Latvia

H46-            50108          Kulakova, judgment of 18/10/01 – Friendly settlement

- 7 cases against Lithuania

H46-            37975          Graužinis, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01

H46-            36743          Grauslys, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01

H46-            34578          Jėčius, judgment of 31/07/00

H46-            47679          Stašaitis, judgment of 21/03/2002, final on 21/06/2002

H46-            42095          Daktaras, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 18/01/01

H46-            44558          Valašinas, judgment of 24/07/01, final on 24/10/01

H46-            44800          Puzinas, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02

- 3 cases against Luxembourg

H46-            41761          Scheele, judgment of 17/05/01, final on 17/08/01

H46-            21156          G.J., judgment of 26/10/00

H46-            45165          Matthies-Lenzen, judgment of 05/02/02 – Friendly settlement

- 7 cases against the Netherlands

H32-            14084          R.V. and others - Interim Resolution DH(2000)25

H46-            28369          Camp and Bourimi, judgment of 03/10/00

H46-            29192          Ciliz, judgment of 11/07/00

H46-            31725          Köksal, judgment of 20/03/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            33258          Holder, judgment of 05/06/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            36499          Samy, judgment of 18/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

H46-            34549          Meulendijks, judgment of 14/05/2002, final on 14/08/2002

- 6 cases against Poland

H46-            28358          Baranowski, judgment of 28/03/00

H46-            31382          Kurzac, judgment of 22/02/01, final on 22/05/01

H46-            38670          Dewicka, judgment of 04/04/00, final on 04/07/00

H46-            51669          Pałys, judgment of 11/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            25874          Kawka, judgment of 09/01/01

H46-            33310          H.D., judgment of 20/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

Section 6

- 4 cases against Portugal

H46-            37698          Lopes Gomes da Silva, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00

H46-            37528          Martins and Garcia Alves, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H54-            15777          Matos and Silva and 2 others, judgment of 16/09/96

H46-            33290          Salgueiro Da Silva Mouta, judgment of 21/12/99, final on 21/03/00

- 1 case against Romania

H32-            32922          C.C.M.C., Interim Resolution DH(99)333

- 7 cases against the Slovak Republic

H46-            34753          Jóri, judgment of 09/11/00, final on 09/02/01

H46-            40345          Stančiak, judgment of 12/04/01, final on 12/07/01

H46-            29032          Feldek, judgment of 12/07/01, final on 12/10/01

H46-            32686          Marônek, judgment of 19/04/01, final on 19/07/01

H46-            46843          Remšíková, judgment of 17/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24530          Vodeničarov, judgment of 21/12/00

H46-            38794          J.K., judgment of 23/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 2 cases against Slovenia

H46-            29462          Rehbock, judgment of 28/11/00

H46-            28400          Majarič, judgment of 08/02/00

- 4 cases against Sweden

H46-            26978          Beck, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28222          Muonio Saami Village, judgment of 09/01/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            32531          Jakola, judgment of 06/03/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            30526          De Laczay Ervin and Olga, judgment of 24/09/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 12 cases against Switzerland

H46-            27154          D.N., judgment of 29/03/01 - Grand Chamber

H46-            33958          Wettstein, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-            27798          Amann, judgment of 16/02/00 - Grand Chamber

H54-            23224          Kopp, judgment of 25/03/98

H46-            54273          Boultif, judgment of 02/08/01, final on 02/11/01

H46-            24699          VGT Verein Gegen Tierfabriken, judgment of 28/06/01, final on 28/09/01

H46-            37292          F.R., judgment of 28/06/01, final on 28/09/01

H46-            33499          Ziegler, judgment of 21/02/02, final on 21/05/02

H46-            27426          G.B., judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

H46-            28256          M.B., judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

H32-            27613          P.B., Interim Resolution ResDH(2000)83

H54-            19800          R.M.D., judgment of 26/09/97 - Interim Resolution DH(99)678

- 113 cases against Turkey

H46-            29921          Büker, judgment of 24/10/00, final on 24/01/01

H46-            31312          Eğinlioğlu, judgment of 20/12/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            29851          Zana, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01

H46-            29295+        Ecer and Zeyrek, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

Section 6

H46-            34686          Sürek Kamil Tekin, judgment of 14/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29495          Erdemli, judgment of 30/10/01, final on 30/10/01

H46-            35980          Z.E., judgment of 07/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31882          Çakmak, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            24947          Ekinci Lalihan, judgment of 05/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31849          İşçi, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24937          Koç Fırat, judgment of 05/06/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24933          Kürküt, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            31733          Tuncay and Ozlem Kaya, judgment of 08/11/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28011          Yeşiltepe, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            32983          Çavuşoğlu, judgment of 06/03/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31249          Gündüz and others, judgment of 14/11/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            24932          Kaplan, judgment of 26/02/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            24669          Karataş and Boğa, judgment of 17/10/00 - Friendly settlement

- Length of detention on remand

H46-            29862          Bağci and Murğ, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            32450          Çaloğlu, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            31896          Değerli, judgment of 22/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29866+        Demir C., Demir M. and Gül, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            29883+        Fidan, Çağro and Özarslaner, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            31787          Göktaş and others, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31850          Günay and others, judgment of 27/09/01, final on 27/12/01

H46-            28013+        Karatepe and Kırt, judgment of 17/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            34499          Kortak, judgment of 31/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31895          Morsümbül, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            30495          Mutlu and Yildiz, judgment of 10/07/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            28014+        Okuyucu, Kara and Bilmen, judgment of 17/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            30453          Özata and others, judgment of 22/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29425          Özçelik and others, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            36760          Şanlı and Erol, judgment of 22/05/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37191          Yildirim and others, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            34684          Yolcu, judgment of 05/02/02 – Friendly settlement

- Delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

H46-            19640          Akça Halim, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19641          Akçay Mehmet, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19642          Akkaya Ahmet, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19643          Akkaya İbrahim, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19644          Akkaya Mustafa, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19264          Aktaş and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H32-            22907          Atatür A. and M., and Pamir

H46-            19645          Balci Hüseyin, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19646          Balci Macit, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19647          Baltekin Bilge, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19266          Baltekin, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19648          Başar Halil, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19649          Başar Talip, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19653          Bilgiç Yusuf, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19650          Bilgin Ahmet, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            20132          Bilgin Burhan, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            20133          Bilgin Leyli, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            19651          Bilgin Mahmut, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19267          Bilgin Mehmet and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

Section 6

H46-            19652          Bilgin Mehmet II, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            20134          Bilgin Münir, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            19268          Bilgin Saniye and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19269          Bozkurt and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19272          Çalkan and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19661          Çalkan Gülnahar, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19662          Çalkan Rabia, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19665          Çalkan Seyfettin, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            20136          Canlı, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            19663          Çapar Ekrem, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19666          Çapar Nuri, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19273          Çapar, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19664          Çelebi Hamdi, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19274          Çelebi Hamdi, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19275          Çelebi Yusuf, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19276          Çiplak and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19668          Dalgiç Hayrettin, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19669          Dalgiç Necati, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19277          Daniş, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19654          Dinç Fethiye, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19670          Dişçi Dursun, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19671          Dişçi Hasan, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19672          Dişçi Osman, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19655          Dokel Ünzile, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19656          Eğrikale Saadettin, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19657          Erol Naside II, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19658          Erol Recep, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19659          Erol Sefer, judgment of 03/07/01, final on 03/10/01

H46-            19278          Erol, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19280          Gökgöz, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19281          Gökmen and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            20142          Günal Kazım, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            19673          Güneysu Davut, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19270          Ilhan Buzcu and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19283          Işik Ayşe and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19284          Işik Yilmaz and others, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19286          Karabulut Sefer, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19674          Kartal Ali, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19675          Koç Hasan, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19676          Koçer Ayse, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19271          Nuriye Buzcu, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            30448          Önel Ahmet, judgment of 23/05/2002, final on 23/08/2002

H46-            30948          Önel Mehmet, judgment of 23/05/2002, final on 23/08/2002

H46-            30446          Önel Temur, judgment of 23/05/2002, final on 23/08/2002

H46-            30447          Özel Hacı Bayram, judgment of 23/05/2002, final on 23/08/2002

H46-            31964          Özel Hacı Osman, judgment of 23/05/2002, final on 23/08/2002

H46-            19287          Özen, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19288          Öztekin, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 30/04/01

H46-            19678          Öztürk Ali, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19679          Öztürk Gülfiye, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19681          Öztürk Kamil, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19682          Öztürk Muhsin, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            19683          Öztürk Mustafa, judgment of 05/06/01, final on 05/09/01

H46-            20153          Şen Ismet, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

Section 6

H46-            20156          Şen Kemal, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            20154          Şen Mahmut, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            20158          Taşdemir Mehmet n° 2, judgment of 20/06/2002, final on 20/09/2002

H46-            38931          İ.S., judgment of 28/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            33322          Özdiler and Bakan, judgment of 27/06/2002 - Friendly settlement

- 16 cases against the-United Kingdom

H46-            48521          Armstrong, judgment of 16/07/2002, final on 16/10/2002

H46-            24724          T., judgment of 16/12/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-            24888          V., judgment of 16/12/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-            45276          Hilal, judgment of 06/03/01, final on 06/06/01

H54-            24839          Bowman, judgment of 19/02/98

H32-            27237          Govell

H32-            26109          Santa Cruz Ruiz

H54-            24838          Steel, Lush, Needham, Polden and Cole, judgment of 23/09/98

H46-            35394          Khan, judgment of 12/05/00, final on 05/10/00

H46-            28901          Rowe and Davis, judgment of 16/02/00

H46-            35718          Condron, judgment of 02/05/00, final on 02/08/00

H46-            33274          Foxley, judgment of 20/06/00, final on 20/09/00

H46-            39360          S.B.C., judgment of 19/06/01, final on 19/09/01

H54-            20605          Halford, judgment of 25/06/97 - Interim Resolution DH(1999)725

H46-            36670          Duyonov and others, judgment of 02/10/01 – Friendly settlement

H46-            40302          Matthews Michael, judgment of 15/07/2002 - Friendly settlement

c. PREPARATION OF THE NEXT DH MEETING
(841st MEETING, 3-4 June 2003)

(See Addendum Preparation of the next meeting)

Action

The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary lists of items to be examined at the next DH meeting, which appears in Addendum Preparation of the next meeting to the present annotated agenda and order of business.