Français | Word

Ministers’ Deputies

Annotated Agenda

CM/Del/OJ(2004)891-Add (Restricted) 5 July 2004
Preparation of the next meeting

———————————————

891st (DH) Meeting, 6-7 July 2004

c. Preparation of the next DH meeting
897th meeting (DH) (28-29 September 2004)

Preliminary draft agenda

——————————————

Action

The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary draft agenda and order of business for their 897th meeting (28-29 September 2004 (DH)), as it appears below.

In accordance with the examination system established for Human Rights meetings, the Deputies are invited to take note of the following schedule for the issue of documents for the 897th DH meeting (28-29 September 2004):

a.         a list of new items for consideration at the 897th meetings will be issued in Appendix 2 to the volume of Decisions taken at the present meeting (see Appendix to this Addendum);

b.         in principle, new judgments of the Court which are final on or before 6 August 2004, will be added;

c.         Delegations wishing to furnish information concerning the items appearing on this list for the 891st meeting are invited to make such information available to the Secretariat before 13 August 2004;

d.         the draft annotated agenda - volume I (Sections 4, 5 and 6.1) will be distributed on 13 September 2004 and the addenda foreseen will be sent out shortly after;

e.         the draft annotated agenda - volume II (Sections 2, 3, and 6.2) will be distributed on 20 September 2004 ;

f.          the order of business will be distributed on 20 September  2004.

DRAFT DECISION

Item c

PREPARATION OF THE NEXT MEETING (DH)

(897th, 28-29 September 2004)

Decision

The Deputies approved the preliminary draft Agenda and Order of Business for their 897th meeting (28-29 September 2004 (DH)), as it appears at Appendix 2 to the present volume of Decisions; <see below >.

CONTENTS

STATISTICAL TABLE. 5

GENERAL QUESTIONS (Volume I) 6

SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS (Volume II) 7

SECTION 2 - NEW CASES. 12

SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION (Volume II) 18

SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTION (INDIVIDUAL MEASURES,
MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS) (Volume I) 23

SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED (Volume I) 37

SECTION 6 - CASES PRESENTED WITH A VIEW TO THE PREPARATION
OF A DRAFT FINAL RESOLUTION. 42

c. PREPARATION OF THE NEXT DH MEETING (906th MEETING, 30 November - 1 December 2004) 45

Additional documents

Addendum General Questions

Addendum 1 - Final Resolutions

Addendum 4 – Cases raising special questions

Addendum Preparation of the next DH meeting (906th meeting, 30 November - 1 December 2004)

STATISTICAL TABLE

GENERAL QUESTIONS (Volume I)

a.                Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business

Action

The Deputies are invited to adopt the present annotated agenda and order of business.

b.                State of ratification by member States of the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceedings of the European Court of Human Rights, the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe and Protocols No. 12, No. 13 and No. 14 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms

Action

The Deputies are invited to provide information on the state of signature and ratification of these texts. Tables showing the current state of signature and ratification appear in Addendum General Questions.

c.                Preparation of the next meeting (906th (30 November - 1 December 2004)) see page 45

SECTION 1 - FINAL RESOLUTIONS (Volume II)

(NO DEBATE ENVISAGED)

(Addendum 1)

Action

The Deputies are invited to adopt the resolutions putting and end to the examination of the following cases as they appear in Addendum 1.

                   SUB-SECTION 1.1 – LEADING CASES

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 1.2 – CASES CONCERNING PROBLEMS ALREADY SOLVED

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 1.3 – CASES NOT INVOLVING GENERAL OR INDIVIDUAL MEASURES

                   No new case

                   SUB-SECTION 1.4 – FRIENDLY SETTLEMENTS AND PROBLEMS OF A GENERAL CHARACTER

                   No new case

SECTION 2 - NEW CASES

This section lists the new judgments rendered by the European Court of Human Rights, (for further details, see the texts of the judgments on http://www.echr.coe.int).

Action

The Deputies are invited to take a decision to resume consideration of these cases following expiry of the date-limit set by the Court for payment of the just satisfaction or, depending of the requirements of the cases, on completion of bilateral consultations between the Secretariat and the delegations concerned.

Payment of just satisfaction

In all new cases in which states are obliged to pay a sum, whether granted by the Court or agreed to in friendly settlement, the authorities of the state concerned are invited to provide written confirmation of payment to the Secretariat.

General or individual measures

The general and/or individual measures required are currently under consideration in the context of bilateral consultations.

However, in all cases circulation of the text of the judgment to the competent authorities is required and delegations are invited to provide written confirmation of this.

The cases for which the final character of the judgment has not yet been confirmed by the Court appear on a grey background.

Section 2

- 3 cases against Austria

H46-            42703/98      Radovanovic, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

H46-            11057/02      Haase, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-            72159/01      Löffler Hans-Peter No. 2, judgment of 04/03/2004, final on 04/06/2004

- 3 cases against Belgium

H46-            47650/99      Silvester’s Horeca Service, judgment of 04/03/2004, final on 04/06/2004

                   Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-            51083/99      Bouzalmad, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            50857/99      Lenaerts, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

- 5 cases against Bulgaria

H46-            42346/98      G.B., judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            40653/98      Iorgov, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            44076/98      Angelov, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

H46-            39270/98      Belchev, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-            44062/98      Hamanov, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

- 3 cases against Croatia

H46-            12775/02      Kovačevič, judgment of 01/07/2004 - Friendly settlement

H46-            75545/01      Kresović, judgment of 24/06/2004 - Friendly settlement

H46-            70446/01      Jorgić, judgment of 24/06/2004 - Friendly settlement

- 2 cases against the Czech Republic

H46-            57567/00      Bulena, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

H46-            45107/98      Koktavá, judgment of 02/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

- 2 cases against Finland

H46-            30508/96      Pitkänen, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

H46-            48339/99      Kangasluoma, judgment of 20/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

- 9 cases against France

H46-            59584/00      Rivas, judgment of 01/04/2004, final on 01/07/2004

H46-            39001/97      Maat, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

Section 2

H46-            67114/01      Coorbanally, judgment of 01/04/2004, final on 01/07/2004

H46-            68255/01+    Crochard and 6 others, judgment of 03/02/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            65110/01      Quesne, judgment of 01/04/2004, final on 01/07/2004

H46-            45130/98      Slimane-Kaïd No. 3, judgment of 06/04/2004, final on 06/07/2004

Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative courts

H46-            51442/99      Coudrier, judgment of 10/02/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            63156/00      Mirailles, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

H46-            53988/00      Moufflet, judgment of 03/02/2004, final on 14/06/2004

- 2 cases against Greece

H46-            62503/00      Karahlios No. 2, judgment of 11/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            70626/01      Manios, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

- 2 cases against Hungary

H46-            75116/01      Karalyos and Huber, judgment of 06/04/2004, final on 06/07/2004

H46-            55220/00      Csanádi, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

- 9 cases against Italy

H46-            7503/02       Neroni, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

H46-            51703/99      Vadalà, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

H46-            55634/00      Cianetti, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

                   Cases relating to the failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

H46-            64098/00      Bellini Franco No. 2, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            59636/00      Calvo, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            61995/00      Montanari, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            59273/00      Picone, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            60391/00      Pollifrone, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

H46-            65120/01      Siena Antonio, judgment of 11/03/2004, final on 11/06/2004

- 1 case against Moldova

H46-            60115/00      Amihalachioaie, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-            50210/99      Doerga, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

- 12 cases against Poland

H46-            31443/96      Broniowski, judgment of 22/06/2004 - Grand Chamber

Section 2

H46-            26624/95      Worwa, judgment of 27/11/2003, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            34091/96      M.B., judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            36258/97      J.G., judgment of 06/04/2004, final on 06/07/2004

                   Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-            38811/97      Góra, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            35656/97      Hulewicz, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 30/06/2004

H46-            60225/00      Jablonská, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

H46-            38564/97      Janik, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            37770/97      Krzewicki, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            53029/99      Pachnik, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 30/06/2004

H46-            38930/01      Politikin, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            52478/99      Surman-Januszewska, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

- 2 cases against Portugal

                   Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-            58617/00      Garcia da Silva, judgment of 29/04/2004, final on 29/07/2004

H46-            59017/00      Soares Fernandes, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

- 1 case against the Russian Federation

H46-            53084/99      Kormacheva, judgment of 29/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004, rectified on 29/04/2004

- 2 cases against the Slovak Republic

H46-            56193/00+    E.O and V.P., judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            54809/00      Sabol and Sabolovà, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

- 1 case against Spain

H46-            71752/01      Quiles Gonzales, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

- 1 case against Sweden

H46-            48630/99      Romlin, judgment of 15/06/2004 - Friendly settlement

- 39 cases against Turkey

                   - Length of detention in police custody

H46-            29486/95+    Mamaç and others, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

H46-            36115/97      Sarıkaya, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

                   - Action of the Turkish security forces

H46-            28298/95      Buldan, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

H46-            25760/94      İpek, judgment of 17/02/2004, final on 17/05/2004

H46-            25354/94      Şen Nuray No.2, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 30/06/2004

H46-            32457/96      Özalp and others, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-            21689/93      Özkan Ahmet and others, judgment of 06/04/2004, final on 06/07/2004

H46-            27699/95      Tekdağ, judgment of 15/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

Section 2

H46-            37415/97      Şahmo, judgment of 22/06/2004 - Friendly settlement

                   - Delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

H46-            45630/99      Çakmak Mehmet Salih and Çakmak Abdülsamet, judgment of 29/04/2004, final on 29/07/2004

H46-            48990/99      Dönmez, judgment of 29/04/2004, final on 29/07/2004

H46-            42124/98      Kayıhan and others, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-            49657/99      Yazgan F. and M., judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

H46-            50915/99      Yazganoğlu and others, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

                   - Cases concerning the independence and impartiality of State security courts

H46-            46272/99      Güneş Haydar, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

H46-            48059/99      Özer K. and others, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

H46-            55427/00      Özcan Serdar, judgment of 08/04/2004, final on 08/07/2004

H46-            35070/97      Tezcan Uzunhasanoğlu, judgment of 20/04/2004, final on 20/07/2004

H46-            53586/99      Yavuzaslan, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

H46-            40997/98      Duran, judgment of 29/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            44054/98      Kaya İrfan, judgment of 22/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            49503/99      Doğan Halil, judgment of 29/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            54919/00      İçöz, judgment of 15/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            57939/00      Kalyoncugil and others, judgment of 29/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            57944/00      Çetinkaya and others, judgment of 18/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            56021/00      Erolan and others, judgment of 15/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            57562/00      Becerikli and Altekin, judgment of 08/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            48155/99      Çınar, judgment of 15/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            48065/99      Polat Metin and others, judgment of 15/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            48062/99      Kırcan Mustafa, judgment of 22/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            47340/99      Jalaliaghdam, judgment of 22/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            50903/99      Korkmaz, judgment of 22/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            46952/99      Özdemir Hıdır, judgment of 15/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            40528/98      Güven Ahmet and others, judgment of 22/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            42775/98      Ünkünç and Güneş, judgment of 18/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

H46-            48438/99      Özertikoğlu İsmail, judgment of 22/01/2004, final on 14/06/2004

                   - Cases concerning freedom of expression and independence and impartiality of State security courts

H46-            42435/98      Aydın Abdullah, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

H46-            26982/95      Zana Mehdi No.2, judgment of 06/04/2004, final on 06/07/2004

                   - Cases concerning freedom of expression

H46-            35071/97      Gündüz Müslüm, judgment of 04/12/2003, final on 14/06/2004

- 1 case against Ukraine

H46-            66561/01      Merit, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 30/06/2004

- 5 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-            74025/01      Hirst John No. 2, judgment of 30/03/2004, final on 30/06/2004

H46-            21413/02      Kansal, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

H46-            19365/02      Hill, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 27/07/2004

Section 2

H46-            61827/00      Glass, judgment of 09/03/2004, final on 09/06/2004

H46-            69187/01      Broadhurst, judgment of 22/06/2004 - Friendly settlement

SECTION 3 - JUST SATISFACTION (Volume II)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise the payment of just satisfaction in the following cases pending before the Committee of Ministers for execution supervision. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in principle at their next Human Rights meeting.

3.a               SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST SATISFACTION AS WELL AS, WHERE DUE, OF DEFAULT INTEREST, IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT EXPIRED LESS THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

At the time of issuing the present Annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the Secretariat had not received the written confirmation of payment of just satisfaction and/or default interest in the following cases (see the table below summarising the total number of cases by States). The Representatives of the States concerned are invited to give the Secretariat written confirmation of payment of the sums awarded by the Court and/or the default interests.

                   No new case

3.b              SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST

                   SATISFACTION IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT

                   EXPIRED MORE THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

Some of the cases appearing under this section concern late payment for reasons beyond the control of the governments concerned.

Expiry date

of the time-limit set

                   No new case

3.c               EXAMINATION OF SPECIAL PAYMENT PROBLEMS (FOR EXAMPLE THE DISAPPEARANCE OF THE APPLICANT, DISPUTES REGARDING THE EXACT AMOUNT PAID AS A RESULT OF EXCHANGE RATE PROBLEMS OR ADMINISTRATIVE FEES)

                   No new case

Table summarising the total number of cases by States

State	No confirmation of payment of the capital sum (3.a capital sum)	Payment after expiration of the time-limit set and no confirmation of payment of the default interest due (3.a default interest)	No confirmation of payment of the capital sum although payment due since more than 6 months (3.b)	Special payment problems (3.c)

SECTION 4 - CASES RAISING SPECIFIC QUESTION
(INDIVIDUAL MEASURES, MEASURES NOT YET DEFINED OR SPECIAL PROBLEMS) (Volume I)

(See Addendum 4 for part or all these cases)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise the progress made in the adoption of the implementing measures in the following cases raising several problems. Supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will be issued in Addendum 4. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these items on a case-by-case basis.

                   SUB-SECTION 4.1 – SUPERVISION OF INDIVIDUAL MEASURES ONLY[2]

- 4 cases against Belgium

H46-            26103/95      Van Geyseghem, judgment of 21/01/99 – Grand Chamber

H46-            34989/97      Goedhart, judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-            36449/97+    Stroek L. and C., judgment of 20/03/01, final on 20/06/01

H46-            33400/96      Ernst and others, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

- 4 cases against Croatia

H46-            61237/00      Aćimović, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            60533/00      Kastelic, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

H46-            48778/99      Kutić, judgment of 01/03/02, final on 01/06/02

H46-            58112/00      Multiplex, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 10/10/03

- 1 case against Spain

H46-            58496/00      Prado Bugallo, judgment of 18/02/03, final on 18/05/03

- 2 cases against France

H46-            46096/99      Mocie, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03

H46-            50331/99      Julien Ferdinand, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03

- 4 cases against Italy

H46-            39676/98      Rojas Morales, judgment of 16/11/00, final on 16/02/01

H46-            39748/98      Maestri, judgment of 17/02/04 - Grand Chamber

H46-            37119/97      N.F., judgment of 02/08/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-            41879/98      Saggio, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

- 34 cases against Turkey

                   - Cases concerning freedom of expression

                   (Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106)

                   CM/Inf(2003)43

H46-             28635/95+    Aksoy Ibrahim, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01

H46-            23462/94      Arslan, judgment of 08/07/99

H32-            25658/94      Aslantaş Sedat, Interim Resolution DH(99)560 of 08/10/99

H46-            27214/95      C.S.Y., judgment of 04/03/03, final on 04/06/03

H46-            23556/94      Ceylan, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            28496/95      E.K., judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

Sub-section 4.1

H46-            25067/94+    Erdoğdu and Ince, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            24919/94      Gerger, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            27215/95+    Gökçeli Yaşar Kemal, judgment of 04/03/03, final on 04/06/03

H54-            22678/93      Inçal, judgment of 09/06/98

H46-            33179/96      Karataş Seher, judgment of 09/07/02, final on 09/10/02

H46-            23168/94      Karataş, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            43928/98      Karkin, judgment of 23/09/03, final on 23/12/03

H46-            28493/95      Küçük Yalçın, judgment of 05/12/02, final on 05/03/03

H46-            24246/94      Okçuoğlu, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            24914/94      Öztürk Ayşe, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

H46-            22479/93      Öztürk, judgment of 28/09/99

H46-            23500/94      Polat, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            23927/94+    Sürek and Özdemir, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            24122/94      Sürek No. 2, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            24762/94      Sürek No. 4, judgment of 08/07/99

H46-            29590/96      Yağmurdereli, judgment of 04/06/02, final on 04/09/02

                   - Friendly settlements in cases concerning freedom of expression and containing undertakings of the Turkish Government

                   Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106

                   CM/Inf(2003)43

H46-            32985/96      Altan, judgment of 14/05/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            27529/95      Caralan, judgment of 25/09/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37048/97      Demirtaş Nurettin, judgment of 09/10/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37721/97      Erkanlı, judgment of 13/02/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            35076/97      Erol Ali, judgment of 20/06/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            27209/95+    Kiliç Özcan, judgment of 26/11/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            25753/94      Özler, judgment of 11/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            26976/95+    Sürek Kamil Tekin No. 5, judgment of 16/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            32455/96      Zarakolu, judgment of 27/05/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37059/97      Zarakolu Ayşenur No. 1, judgment of 02/10/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37061/97      Zarakolu Ayşenur No. 2, judgment of 02/10/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37062/97      Zarakolu Ayşenur No. 3, judgment of 02/10/03 - Friendly settlement

- 3 cases against the United Kingdom

H54-            19187/91      Saunders, judgment of 17/12/96, Interim Resolution DH(2000)27

H46-            29522/95      I.J.L., G.M.R., and A.K.P., judgment of 19/09/00, final on 19/12/00, and judgment of 25/09/01 (Article 41), final on 25/12/01

H46-            48539/99      Allan, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03

                   SUB-SECTION 4.2 – INDIVIDUAL MEASURES AND/OR GENERAL PROBLEMS

- 2 cases against Austria

H46-            40284/98      Krone Verlag GmbH and CoKG No. 2, judgment of 06/11/03, final on 06/02/04

H46-            32636/96      A.T., judgment of 21/03/02, final on 21/06/02

- 3 cases against Belgium

H46-            37370/97      Strategies et Communications et Dumoulin, judgment of 15/07/02, final on 15/10/02

H46-            51564/99      Čonka, judgment of 05/02/02, final on 05/05/02

H46-            32576/96      Wynen, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03

- 5 cases against Bulgaria

H46-            41488/98      Velikova, judgment of 18/05/00, final on 04/10/00

H46-            38361/97      Anguelova, judgment of 13/06/02, final on 13/09/02

H46-            37104/97      Kitov, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-            35825/97      Al Akidi, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03 rectified on 16/10/03

H46-            35436/97      Hristov, judgment of 31/07/2003, final on 31/10/2003

- 11 cases against Croatia

                   - Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-            51585/99      Horvat, judgment of 26/07/01, final on 26/10/01

H46-            54727/00      Cerin, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02

H46-            58115/00      Čuljak and others, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            48771/99      Delić, judgment of 27/06/02, final on 27/09/02

H46-            52634/99      Futterer, judgment of 20/12/01, final on 20/03/02

H46-            66485/01      Napijalo, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 13/02/04

H46-            45435/99      Radoš and 4 others, judgment of 07/11/02, final on 07/02/03

H46-            49706/99      Rajak, judgment of 28/06/01, final on 12/12/01

H46-            56773/00      Rajčević, judgment of 23/07/02, final on 06/11/02

H46-            63412/00      Sahini, judgment of 19/06/03, final on 19/09/03

H46-            47863/99      Šoć, judgment of 09/05/03, final on 09/08/03

- 1 case against Cyprus

H46-            44730/98      Serghides and Christoforou, judgment of 05/11/02, final on 05/02/03

- 4 cases against the Czech Republic

H46-            41486/98      Bořánková, judgment of 07/01/03, final on 21/05/03

H46-            53341/99      Hartman J. and J., judgment of 10/07/03, final on 03/12/03[3]

Sub-section 4.2

H46-            48568/99      Schmidtová, judgment of 22/07/03, final on 03/12/03

H46-            29010/95      Credit and Industrial Bank, judgment of 21/10/03

- 1 case against Spain

H46-            59072/00      González Doria Durán de Quiroga, judgment of 28/10/03, final on 28/01/04

- 1 case against Finland

H46-            32559/96      The Fortum Corporation, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

- 6 cases against France

H46-            36378/97      Bertuzzi, judgment of 13/02/03, final on 21/05/03

H46-            49636/99      Chevrol, judgment of 13/02/03, final on 13/05/03

H46-            55875/00      Signe, judgment of 14/10/2003, final on 14/01/2004

H46-            67263/01      Mouisel, judgment of 14/11/02, final on 21/05/03

H46-            40472/98      Tricard, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 10/10/01

H46-            36436/97      Piron, judgment of 14/11/00, final on 14/02/01

- 10 cases against Greece

H46-            46355/99      Tsirikakis, judgment of 17/01/02, final on 10/07/02 and du 23/01/03, final on 09/07/03 (Article 41)

H46-            48392/99      Hatzitakis, judgment of 11/04/02, final on 11/07/02

H46-            41666/98      Kyrtatos, judgment of 22/05/03, final on 22/08/03

H46-            50824/99      Azas, judgment of 19/09/02, final on 21/05/03

H46-            55794/00      Efstathiou and Michaïlidis and Cie Motel Amerika, judgment of 10/07/03,

                                      final on 10/10/03

H46-            58642/00      Interoliva Abee, judgment of 0/07/03, final on 10/10/03

H46-            58634/00      Konstantopoulos AE and others, judgment of 10/07/03, final on10/10/03

H46-            46372/99      Papastavrou, judgment of 10/04/03, final on 10/07/03

H46-            59506/00      Papageorgiou Georgios, judgment of 09/05/03, final on 09/08/03

H46-            61582/00      Biozokat A.E., judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

- 9 cases against Hungary

H46-            60037          Németh, judgment of 13/01/04, final on 09/02/04

Sub-section 4.2

                   Cases of length of civil proceedings

H46-            47355/99      Kerékgyártó, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 24/03/04

H46-            43657/98      Lévai and Nagy, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 24/09/03

H46-            55539/00      Militaru, judgment of 12/11/03, final on 12/02/04

H46-            52724/99+    Nyírő and Takács, judgment of 21/10/2003, final on 11/11/2003

H46-            59094/00      Sesztakov, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04

H46-            53844/00      Sikó, judgment of 04/11/03, final on 04/02/04

H46-            42961/98      Simkó, judgment of 08/04/03, final on 08/07/03

H46-            36186/97      Tímár, judgment of 25/02/03, final on 09/07/03

- 2 cases against Iceland

H46-            39731/98      Sigurđsson, judgment of 10/04/03, final on 10/07/03

H46-            44671/98      Arnarsson SigurÞór, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

- 91 cases against Italy

H46-            31127/96      E.P. No.3, judgment of 06/11/99, revised on 03/05/2001 (Article 41)

H46-            25498/94      Messina Antonio II, judgment of 28/09/00, final on 28/12/00

                                      Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)178

H46-            56298/00      Bottaro, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            32190/96      Luordo, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            44521/98      Peroni, judgment of 06/11/03, final on 06/02/04

H46-            52985/99      S.C., V.P., F.C., M.C. and E.C., judgment of 06/11/03, final on 06/02/04

                   - Cases relating to the failure to enforce judicial eviction orders against tenants

H46-            22774/93      Immobiliare Saffi, judgment of 28/07/99

H46-            66441/01      A.G. No. 4, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            22534/93      A.O., judgment of 30/05/00, final on 30/08/00

H46-            20177/92      Aldini, Interim Resolution DH(97)413 of 17/09/97

H46-            35550/97      Auditore, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            66920/01      Battistoni, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            65413/01      Bonamassa, judgment of 02/10/03, final on 02/01/04

H46-            62849/00      Brienza, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04

H46-            35428/97      C.T. No. 2, judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03

H46-            63947/00      Calosi, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04

H46-            45006/98      Capurso, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-            48842/99      Carbone Anna, judgment of 22/05/03, final on 22/08/03

H46-            35777/97      Carloni and Bruni, judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03

H46-            34819/97      Cau, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            56717/00      Cavicchi and Ruggeri, judgment of 30/10/03, final on 30/01/04

H46-            34412/97      Ciccariello Franca, judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03

H46-            36268/97      Clucher No. 2, judgment of 17/04/03, final on 24/09/03

H46-            45356/99      Conti Lorenza, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 03/12/03

H46-            63938/00      Cucinotta Rosario and Giovanni, judgment of 30/10/03, final on 30/01/04

H46-            32589/96      D.V. No. 2, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            61667/00      D’Aloe and others, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 13/02/04

H46-            33113/96      D’Ottavi, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            37117/97      De Benedittis, judgment of 17/04/03, final on 17/07/03

H46-            59634/00      De Gennaro, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            41427/98      Del Beato, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

Sub-section 4.2

H46-            36254/97      Del Sole, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            30883/96      Esposito Paola, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            63523/00      Federici C. and L., judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            39735/98      Fegatelli, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-            63408/00      Ferroni Rossi, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            60464/00      Fezia and others, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            33909/96      Fiorani, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            34454/97      Fleres, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            32577/96      Folli Carè, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            43580/98      G.G. No. 6, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 09/07/03

H46-            22671/93      G.L. No. 4, judgment of 03/08/00, final on 03/11/00

H46-            59635/00      Gamberini Mongenet, judgment of 06/11/03, final on 06/02/04

H46-            59454/00      Gatti and others, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            53233/99      Ghelardini and Brunori, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            28272/95      Ghidotti, judgment of 21/02/02, final on 21/05/02

H46-            31663/96      Giagnoni and Finotello, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            32006/96      Gnecchi and Barigazzi, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            32374/96      Guidi I. and F., judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            32766/96      Immobiliare Sole Srl, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            34442/97      Indelicato Antonio, judgment of 06/11/03, final on 06/02/04

H46-            64151/00      Kraszewski, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            32392/96      L. and P. No. 1, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            41610/98      L.M. No. 7, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-            62020/00      La Paglia, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            63336/00      Lari, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            21463/93      Lunari, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 11/04/01

H46-            32391/96      M.C. No. 11, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            31923/96      M.P., judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            42343/98      Malescia, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-            60388/00      Marigliano, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            35088/97      Marini E., C., A.M., R. and S., judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03

H46-            31129/96      Merico, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            58408/00      Miscioscia, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

H46-            58191/00      Mottola, judgment of 22/05/03, final on 22/08/03

H46-            35024/97      Nigiotti and Mori, judgment of 17/04/03, final on 17/07/03

H46-            24650/94      P.M. No. 1, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 5/09/01

H46-            15919/89      Palumbo, judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

H46-            37008/97      Pannocchia, judgment of 17/04/03, final on 17/07/03

H46-            59367/00      Pozzi, judgment of 04/12/03, final on 04/03/04

H46-            59539/00      Pulcini, judgment of 17/04/03, final on 17/07/03

H46-            67412/01      Ragone, judgment of 02/10/03, final on 02/01/04

H46-            32385/96      Ricci Onorato, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            50293/99      Robba, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            55725/00      Rosati, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            30530/96      Rossi Luciano, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            59538/00      Sabatini and Di Giovanni, judgment of 02/10/03, final on 02/01/04

H46-            32644/96      Sanella, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            59537/00      Savio Delfino, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04

H46-            56924/00      Scalera, judgment of 13/11/03, final on 13/02/04

H46-            33227/96      Scurci Chimenti, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

H46-            47703/99      Serni, judgment of 09/10/03, final on 09/01/04

H46-            31223/96      T.C.U., judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            23424/94      Tanganelli, judgment of 11/01/01, final on 11/04/01

H46-            47758/99      Tassinari, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04

H46-            62000/00      Tempesti Chiesi and Chiesi, judgment of 31/07/03, final on 31/10/03

Sub-section 4.2

H46-            33252/96      Tona, judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            33692/96      Traino, judgment of 17/07/03, final on 17/10/03

H46-            30972/96      V.T., judgment of 15/11/02, final on 15/02/03

H46-            48730/99      Voglino, judgment of 22/05/03, final on 22/08/03

H46-            35006/97      Zazzeri, judgment of 19/12/02, final on 19/03/03

- 1 case against Lithuania

H46-            41510/98      Jasiūnienė, judgment of 06/03/03, final on 06/06/03

- 1 case against Moldova

H46-            45701          Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia and others, judgment of 13/12/01, final on 27/03/02

- 1 case against Malta

H46-            55263/00      Kadem, judgment of 09/01/03, final on 09/04/03

- 1 case against the Netherlands

H46-            39657/98      Steur, judgment of 28/10/03, final on 28/01/04

- 3 cases against Poland

H46-            33870/96      Fuchs, judgment of 11/02/03, judgment of 11/05/03

H46-            30218/96      Nowicka, judgment of 03/12/02, final on 03/03/03

H46-            25196/94      Iwánczuk, judgment of 15/11/01, final on 15/02/02

- .. cases against Portugal

                   - Cases concerning excessive length of judicial proceedings

a. Cases before civil courts

H46-            53997/00      Dias Da Silva and Gomes Ribeiro Martins, judgment of 27/03/03, final on 27/06/03

H46-            53534/99      Esteves, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

H46-            53937/00      Ferreira Alves, Limited, judgment of 27/02/03, final on 27/05/03

H46-            49671/99      Ferreira da Nave, judgment of 07/11/02, final on 07/02/03

H46-            49279/99      Koncept-Conselho em Comunicação e Sensibilização de Públicos, Lda, judgment of 31/10/02, final on 31/01/03

H46-            52412/99      Marques Nunes, judgment of 20/02/03, final on 20/05/03

H46-            54566/00      Moreira and Ferreirinha, Lda and others, judgment of 26/06/03, final on 26/09/03

H46-            34422/97      Oliveira Modesto and others, judgment of 08/06/00, final on 08/09/00

b. Cases before criminal courts

H46-            48956/99      Gil Leal Pereira, judgment of 31/10/02, final on 31/01/03

H46-            50775/99      Sousa Marinho and Marinho Meireles Pinto, judgment of 03/04/03, final on 03/07/03

Sub-section 4.2

c. Case before family courts

H46-            51806/99      Figueiredo Simoes, judgment of 30/01/03, final on 30/04/03

d. Cases before labour courts

H46-            53795/00      Farinha Martins, judgment of 10/07/03, final on 10/10/03

- 3 cases against Romania

H46-            28114/95      Dalban, judgment of 28/09/99 - Grand Chamber

H46-            42930/98      Crişan, judgment of 27/05/03, final on 27/08/03

H46-            28341/95      Rotaru, judgment of 04/05/00 - Grand Chamber

- 2 cases against the Russian Federation

H46-            59498/00      Burdov, judgment of 07/05/02, final on 04/09/02

H46-            58263/00      Timofeyev, judgment of 23/10/03, final on 23/01/04

- 1 case against San Marino

H46-            69700/01      Tierce Vanessa, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 03/12/03

- 1 case against the Slovak Republic

H46-            41784/98      A.B., judgment of 04/03/03, final on 04/06/03

- 92 cases against Turkey

H46-            36590/97      Göç Mehmet, judgment of 11/07/02 – Grand Chamber

H46-            27692/95+    Karakoç and others, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

                                      (Interim Resolution ResDH(2001)106)

                                      CM/Inf(2003)43

                   Cases concerning actions of the Turkish security forces

H46-            22947/93+    Akkoç Nebahat, judgment of 10/10/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H54-            21987/93      Aksoy, judgment of 18/12/96, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-            32574/96      Algür, judgment of 22/10/02, final on 22/01/03

H46-            22279/93      Altay, judgment of 22/05/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            25657/94      Avşar, judgment of 10/07/01, final on 27/03/00

H54-            23178/94      Aydin, judgment of 25/09/97, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-            25659/94      Bilgin İrfan, judgment of 17/07/01, final on 17/10/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            28340/95      Büyükdağ, judgment of 21/12/00, final on 21/03/01

H46-            23657/94      Çakici, judgment of 08/07/99, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H32-            22677/93      Çetin, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

Sub-section 4.2

H46-            25704/94      Çiçek, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 05/09/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            20869/92      Dikme, judgment of 11/07/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            25801/94      Dulaş Zubeyde, judgment of 30/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            27602/95      Ekinci Ülkü, judgment of 16/07/02, final on 16/10/02

H46-            20764/92      Ertak Ismail, judgment of 09/05/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            29484/95      Esen, judgment of 22/07/03, final on 22/10/03

H54-            21593/93      Güleç, judgment of 27/07/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-            22277/93      Ilhan Nasir, judgment of 27/06/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            22492/93      Kiliç, judgment of 28/03/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H54-            23186/94      Menteş, Turhallı M. and S, and Uvat, judgment of 28/11/97, Interim Resolution DH(99)434

H46-            21594/93      Oğur, judgment of 20/05/99 - Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H46-            31889/96      Orak Abdurrahman, judgment of 14/02/02, final on 14/05/02

H46-            31866/96      Satık and others, judgment of 10/10/00, final on 10/01/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H54-            23184/94      Selçuk and Asker, judgment of 24/04/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-            26129/95      Tanlı, judgment of 10/04/01, final on 10/07/01, rectified on 28/04/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H54-            22496/93      Tekin, judgment of 09/06/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-            32357/96      Veznedaroğlu Sevtap, judgment of 11/04/00, final on 18/10/00, Interim Resolution ResDH(2002)98

H54-            22495/93      Yaşa, judgment of 02/09/98, Interim Resolutions DH(99)434 and ResDH(2002)98

H46-            29485/95      Yaz, judgment of 22/07/03, final on 22/10/03

                   - Friendly settlements cases and 1 striking-out concerning action of the security forces containing undertakings of the Turkish Government

                   CM/Inf(2004)12

H46-            24940/94      Acar, judgment of 18/12/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31137/96      Adalı, judgment of 12/12/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            32598/96      Akbay, judgment of 04/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37453/97      Akman, judgment of 26/06/01, final on 25/10/01 - Striking out

H46-            24935/94      Avcı, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28293/95      Aydın K., C. Aydin and S. Aydin and others, judgment of 10/07/01- Friendly settlement

H46-            29289/95      Aydın Mehmet, judgment of 16/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29875/96      Başak and others, judgment of 16/10/03 – Friendly settlement

H46-            24946/94      Boğ, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24938/94      Boğa, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24934/94      Değer, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            22280/93      Demir Mahmut, judgment of 05/12/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24990/94      Demir, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31845/96      Dilek Kemal, judgment of 17/06/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24939/94      Doğan, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            30492/96      Erat and Sağlam, judgment of 26/03/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            31246/96      Ercan, judgment of 25/09/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            26337/95      Erdoğan Mahmut, judgment of 20/06/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            42428/98      Eren and others, judgment of 02/10/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24945/94      Güngü Kemal, judgment of 18/12/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29864/96      H.K. and others, judgment of 14/01/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            30953/96      I.I., I.S., K.E., and A.O., judgment of 06/11/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24849/94+    Kalın, Gezer and Ötebay, judgment of 28/10/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38578/97      Kaplan Süleyman, judgment of 10/10/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37446/97      Kara and others, judgment of 25/11/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38588/97      Keçeci, judgment of 26/11/02 - Friendly settlement

Sub-section 4.2

H46-            42591/98      Kılıç Özgür, judgment of 22/07/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31890/96      Kınay M. and Kınay R., judgment of 26/11/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24944/94      Kızılgedik, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28516/95      Macir, judgment of 22/04/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            33234/96      N.Ö, judgment of 17/10/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31865/96      O.O. and S.M., judgment of 29/04/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            39978/98      Oğraş and others, judgment of 28/10/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31136/96      Önder Yalçın, judgment of 25/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24936/94      Orak Adnan, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            27735/95      Oral and others, judgment of 28/03/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31883/96      Özbey, judgment of 31/01/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29856/96      Özcan Mehmet, judgment of 09/04/02 – Friendly settlement

H46-            37088/97      Özkur and Göksungur, judgment of 04/03/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24942/94      Parlak, Aktürk and Tay, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            29359/95      Saki, judgment of 30/10/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            41926/98      Sarı Ramazan, judgment of 31/07/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31154/96      Şen Filiyet, judgment of 12/12/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            24991/94      Şenses, judgment of 10/07/01 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31153/96      Soğukpınar, judgment of 12/12/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28632/95      Sünnetçi, judgment of 22/07/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            38382/97      Toktaş, judgment of 29/07/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31731/96      Tosun Hanım, judgment of 06/11/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            36189/97      Yakar, judgment of 26/11/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            31152/96      Yalçın Şaziment, judgment of 12/12/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            37049/97      Yaman Mehmet, judgment of 22/05/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            22281/93      Yaşa Sıddık, judgment of 27/06/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            32979/96      Yıldız Özgür, judgment of 16/07/02 - Friendly settlement

H46-            28308/95      Yıldız Zeki, judgment of 22/04/03 - Friendly settlement

H46-            27532/95      Z.Y., judgment of 09/04/02 - Friendly settlement

                    - Cases concerning dissolution of political parties

H46-            25141/94      Dicle for the Democratic Party (DEP), judgment of 10/12/02, final on 21/05/03

H46-            23885/94      Freedom and Democracy Party (ÖZDEP), judgment of 08/12/99 - Grand Chamber

H54-            19392/92      United Communist party of Turkey and others, judgment of 30/01/98

H54-            21237/93      Socialist Party and others, judgment of 25/05/98, Interim Resolution DH(99)245

H46-            22723/93+    Yazar, Karataş, Aksoy and the People’s Labour party (HEP), judgment of 09/04/02

H46-            26482/95      Socialist party of Turkey (STP) and others, judgment of 12/11/03, final on 12/02/04

                                      CM/Inf(98)48

- 14 cases against the United Kingdom

H46-            28212/95      Benjamin and Wilson, judgment of 26/09/02, final on 26/12/02

- Cases concerning the lack of proper review of the lawfulness of the applicants’ continued detention

H46-            46295/99      Stafford, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber

H46-            75362/01      Von Bulow, judgment of 07/10/03, final on 07/01/04

H46-            67385/01      Wynne No. 2, judgment of 16/10/03, final on 16/01/04

H46-            38784/97      Morris, judgment of 26/02/02, final on 26/05/02

Sub-section 4.2

H46-            57067/00      Grieves, judgment of 16/12/03 - Grand Chamber

H46-            30668/96      Wilson and the National Union of Journalists, Palmer, Wyeth and the National Union of Rail, Maritime and Transport workers, Doolan and others, judgment of 02/07/02, final on 02/10/02

H46-            50390/99      McGlinchey and others, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

H46-            35605/97      Kingsley, judgment of 28/05/02 - Grand Chamber

                   - Cases of length of judicial proceedings

H46-            44808/98      Mitchell and Holloway, judgment of 17/12/02, final on 21/05/03

H46-969       42116/98      Somjee, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

H46-970       50034/99      Obasa, judgment of 16/01/03, final on 16/04/03

H46-            39482/98      Dowsett, judgment of 24/06/03, final on 24/09/03

H46-            46477/99      Edwards Paul and Audrey, judgment of 14/03/02, final on 14/06/02

- 5 cases against Ukraine

H46-            39042/97      Kuznetsov, judgment of 29/04/03

H46-            38812/97      Poltoratskiy, judgment of 29/04/03

H46-            40679/98      Dankevich, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

H46-            39483/98      Nazarenko, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

H46-            41707/98      Khokhlich, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

                   SUB-SECTION 4.3 – SPECIAL PROBLEMS

- 75 cases against Italy

Cases concerning the length of proceedings before administrative courts

H46-            41809/98      A.B. No.5, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            29171/95      Abbate Giovani, Interim Resolution DH(97)367

H54-            25587/94      Abenavoli, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-            26863/95      Almanno, Interim Resolution DH(96)611

H32-            25579/94      B.Q., Interim Resolution DH(96)213

H32-            26864/95      Bacci Roberto Maria, Interim Resolution DH(96)612

H32-            25585/94      Bagnoli and Mazzone G., A. and M., Interim Resolution DH(96)214

H32-            34878/97      Barcellona, Interim Resolution DH(99)202

H32-            35343/97      Bertozzi, Vorrasi, Ciarmoli and Forgione, Interim Resolution DH(99)642

H32-            27189/95      Bevilacqua, Interim Resolution DH(97)524

H46-            34437/97      Caliendo, judgment of 14/03/00, final on 14/03/00

H46-            41817/98      Caliri, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            19977/92      Carriero, Interim Resolution DH(96)26

H32-            31628/96      Catania, Interim Resolution DH(99)414

H32-            25576/94      Cavaliero s.n.c., Interim Resolution DH(96)215

H32-            34882/97      Cecamore, Interim Resolution DH(99)203

H46-            44332/98      Cecchini, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H32-            29170/95      Cerruto, Interim Resolution DH(97)368

H32-            29125/95      Chierici B. and E., Interim Resolution DH(97)331

H46-            41811/98      Comitini, judgment of 27/02/01, final on 27/05/01

H32-            27494/95      Corona Vincenzo, Interim Resolution DH(97)020

H32-            25577/94      Cosma, Interim Resolution DH(96)216

H32-            25588/94      D.M. No.2, Interim Resolution DH(96)217

H32-            27996/95+    D'Amico and Altobelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)130

H54-            25574/94      De Santa, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-            20359/92      Della Sala Raffaele, Interim Resolution DH(96)614

H32-            14147/88+    Di Bonaventura

H32-            30600/96      G. D.P., Interim Resolution DH(97)525

H32-            25584/94      G.L.C., Interim Resolution DH(96)218

H32-            31622/96      G.O. No. 2, Interim Resolution DH(97)654

H32-            25580/94      Giorgini, Interim Resolution DH(96)219

H54-            25586/94      Lapalorcia, judgment of 02/09/97

H32-            25581/94      Latini, Interim Resolution DH(96)220

H32-            15080/89      Magnaghi, Interim Resolution DH(96)379

H32-            27994/95+    Manzini and Benet, Interim Resolution DH(97)129

H32-            38149/97      Mazzone G. and E. No.1, Interim Resolution DH(99)306

H32-            38150/97      Mazzone G. and E. No.2, Interim Resolution DH(99)307

H46-            33804/96      Mennitto, judgment of 05/10/00

H32-            25589/94      Mentastro, Interim Resolution DH(96)221

H46-            38594/97      Mereu and S. Maria Navarrese, judgment of 13/06/02, final on 13/09/02

H46-            44338/98      Miele, judgment of 21/11/00, final on 21/02/01

H46-            41815/98      Monti Enrico, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            17814/91      Mori Puddu, Interim Resolution DH(97)177

H46-            41810/98      Mosca, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            38526/97      Murgo M, O, and S. and Giannone, Interim Resolution DH(99)415

H32-            30322/96      Nani, Interim Resolution DH(98)193

H54-            25839/94      Nicodemo, judgment of 02/09/97

H46-            44335/98      O., judgment of 17/10/00, final on 17/01/01

H32-            18908/91      P.P. No. 3, Interim Resolution DH(97)111

Sub-section 4.3

H32-            35950/97+    Paglietti and 126 others, Interim Resolution DH(99)99

H46-            41816/98      Paradiso Antonio, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 08/05/00

H32-            15800/89+    Perego and Romanet

H32-            34880/97      Polto Miranda, Interim Resolution DH(99)204

H46-            31631/96      Procaccini, judgment of 30/03/00, final on 30/03/00

H32-            27493/95      Recinelli, Interim Resolution DH(97)21

H32-            27999/95+    Recinelli and Corona, Interim Resolution DH(97)132

H32-            27997/95      Ridolfi, Interim Resolution DH(97)131

H32-            26865/95+    Rubbo and others, Interim Resolution DH(96)613

H32-            34881/97      Ruocco, Interim Resolution DH(99)643

H32-            25582/94      Sansoni, Interim Resolution DH(96)222

H32-            31625/96      Santoro Claudio, Interim Resolution DH(97)655

H32-            29672/96      Scopelliti II, Interim Resolution DH(97)469

H32-            27484/95+    Serino and others, Interim Resolution DH(97)133

H32-            25450/94      Spera Michele, Interim Resolution DH(97)372

H32-            34283/96      Stampacchia, Interim Resolution DH(98)272

H32-            25583/94      Stracuzzi, Interim Resolution DH(96)241

H32-            25578/94      Turrina and Scattolini, Interim Resolution DH(96)223

H32-            31620/96      U. P., Interim Resolution DH(97)656

H32-            38152/97      Ullo, Interim Resolution DH(99)308

H46-            44346/98      Venturini Alberto No.2, judgment of 25/10/01, final on 25/01/02

H46-            44535/98      Venturini Alberto No.3, judgment of 25/10/2001, final on 25/01/2002

H32-            29301/95      Vitali No.2, Interim Resolution DH(97)332

H32-            29302/95      Vitali No.3, Interim Resolution DH(97)333

H32-            39170/98      Zappalà, Interim Resolution DH(99)523

H46-            41814/98      Zeoli and 34 others, judgment of 08/02/00, final on 05/10/00

- 1 case against Turkey

H46-3411     25781          Cyprus against Turkey, judgment of 10/05/01 – Grand Chamber

                                      CM/Inf(2004)4-rev2, CM/Inf(2004)4/1-rev 2 and CM/Inf(2004)4/3-rev 2

SECTION 5 - SUPERVISION OF GENERAL MEASURES ALREADY ANNOUNCED (Volume I)

(See Addendum 5 for part or all these cases)

Action

The Deputies are invited to supervise progress in the adoption of general measures aiming at preventing further similar violations to those found by the Court in the following cases. If necessary, supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will appear in Addendum 5. The Deputies are invited to resume consideration of these cases in 6 months at the latest.

                   SUB-SECTION 5.1 – LEGISLATIVE AND/OR REGULATORY CHANGES

- 1 case against Cyprus

H46-            25316/94      Denizci and others, judgment of 23/05/01, final on 23/08/01

- 17 cases against Romania

                   Cases concerning the annulment of final court decisions relating to property ownership

H46-            29411/95      Anghelescu, judgment of 09/04/02, final on 09/07/02

H46-            33353/96      Boc, judgment of 17/12/02, final on 17/03/03

H46-            32926/96      Canciovici and others, judgment of 26/11/02, final on 24/09/03

H46-            36017/97      Dickmann, judgment of 22/07/03, final on 22/10/03

H46-            32936/96      Drăgnescu, judgment of 26/11/02, final on 26/02/03

H46-            38445/97      Erdei and Wolf, judgment of 15/07/03, final on 15/10/03

H46-            32977/96      Găvruş, judgment of 26/11/02, final on 26/02/03

H46-            32915/96      Ghitescu, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

H46-            31736/96      Grigore, judgment of 11/02/03, final on 11/05/03

H46-            33176/96      Moşteanu and others, judgment of 26/11/02, rectified on 04/02/03, final on 26/02/03

H46-            32268/96      Nagy, judgment of 26/11/02, final on 26/02/03

H46-            36039/97      Oprescu, judgment of 14/01/03, final on 14/04/03

H46-            31172/96      Popa and others, judgment of 29/04/03, final on 29/07/03

H46-            33631/96      Savulescu, judgment of 17/12/02, final on 17/03/03

H46-            32260/96      Surpaceanu Constantin and Traian-Victor, judgment of 21/05/02, final on 21/08/02

H46-            32269/96      Tărbăşanu, judgment of 11/02/03, final on 11/05/03

H46-            29407/95      Vasiliu, judgment of 21/05/02, final on 04/09/02

- 7 cases against the United Kingdom

H54-            22520/93      Johnson Stanley, judgment of 24/10/97

H46-            24833/94      Matthews, judgment of 18/02/99- Grand Chamber, Interim Resolution DH(2001)79

H46-            30308/96      Faulkner Ian, judgment of 30/11/99 - Friendly settlement

H46-            26494/95      J.T., judgment of 30/03/00 - Friendly settlement

H46-            25680/94      I., judgment of 11/07/02 - Grand Chamber

H46-            28957/95      Goodwin Christine, judgment of 11/07/02 - Grand Chamber

H46-            35765/97      A.D.T., judgment of 31/07/00, final on 31/10/00

                   SUB-SECTION 5.2 – CHANGES OF COURTS’ CASE-LAW OR OF ADMINISTRATIVE PRACTICE

- 1 case against France

H46-            33592/96      Baumann, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

- 1 case against Poland

H46-            26761/95      Płoski, judgment of 12/11/02, final on 12/02/03

- 1 case against the Slovak Republic

H46-            32106/96      Komanický, judgment of 04/06/02, final on 04/09/02

                   SUB-SECTION 5.3 – PUBLICATION / DISSEMINATION

- 2 cases against France

H46-            43722/98      Wiot, judgment of 07/01/03, final on 07/04/03

H46-            49580/99      Santoni, judgment of 29/07/2003, final on 29/10/2003, revised on 01/06/2004, final at 01/09/2004

SUB-SECTION 5.4 – OTHER MEASURES

No new case

SECTION 6 - CASES PRESENTED WITH A VIEW TO THE PREPARATION OF A DRAFT FINAL RESOLUTION

(See Addendum 6 for part or all these cases)

Action

At the time of issuing the present annotated Agenda and Order of Business, the information available on the measures taken in these cases seemed to allow the preparation of draft resolutions putting an end to their examination by the Committee of Ministers (if necessary, supplementary information on some or all the cases listed below will appear in an Addendum 6). As regards the cases appearing under sub-section 6.1, the Deputies are invited to examine the new information available with a view to evaluating whether a draft final resolution can be prepared. As regards cases listed under sub-section 6.2, the Deputies are invited to note that the elaboration of a draft final resolution, in cooperation with the delegation of the respondent State, is under way. In both cases, the Deputies are invited to postpone consideration of these cases to their next meeting.

Sub-section 6.1

Cases in which the new information available since the last examination appears to allow the preparation of a draft final resolution (Volume I)

                   No new case

Sub-section 6.2

Cases waiting for the presentation of a draft final resolution

(Volume II)

                   No new case

c. PREPARATION OF THE NEXT DH MEETING
(906th MEETING, 30 November - 1 December 2004)

(See Addendum Preparation of the next meeting)

Action

The Deputies are invited to approve the preliminary lists of items to be examined at the next DH meeting, which appears in Addendum Preparation of the next meeting to the present annotated agenda.