Ministers’ Deputies

Decisions

CM/Del/Dec(2008)1020  27 March 2008

———————————————

1020th (DH) meeting, 4-6 March 2008

Decisions

(Formal date of adoption: 27 March 2008)

———————————————

CONTENTS

Pages

            List of those present.................................................................................................................... 5

General Questions

a.         Adoption of the Annotated Agenda and Order of Business............................................................ [1]

b.         State of ratification by member states of the European Agreement relating to persons participating in proceedings of the European Court of Human Rights, the Sixth Protocol to the General Agreement on privileges and immunities of the Council of Europe and Protocols No. 12, No. 13 and No. 14 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms..................................................... *

c.         Preparation of the next DH meeting (1028th meeting (3‑5 June 2008)).............................................. ¹

d.         Measures to improve the execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights......... ¹

e.         First annual report of the Committee of Ministers on the execution of the judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (January – December 2007)..................................................................................... ¹

f.          Execution approach appropriate to cases raising issues of child care and parental rights................ ¹

Section 1

            Final Resolutions......................................................................................................................... 7

Section 2.1

            Cases raising new problems (“precedent cases”)......................................................................... 11

Section 2.2

            Cases raising issues already examined by the Committee of Ministers (“repetitive cases”)............. 20

Section 3.a

Supervision of the payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction as well as, where due,

of default interest, in cases where the deadline for payment expired less than 6 months ago......... 35

Section 3.b

Supervision of payment of the capital sum of the just satisfaction in cases where the deadline for

payment expired more than 6 months ago................................................................................... 43

Section 4.1

            Supervision of individual measures only..................................................................................... 55

Section 4.2

            Individual measures and/or general problems.............................................................................. 62

Section 4.3

            Special problems....................................................................................................................... 96

Section 5.1

            Legislative and/or regulatory changes......................................................................................... 97

Page

Section 5.2

            Changes of courts’ case-law or of administrative practice............................................................ 98

Section 5.3

            Publication/dissemination......................................................................................................... 100

Section 5.4

            Other measures........................................................................................................................ 103

Section 6.1

            Cases in which the new information available since the last examination appears to allow the

preparation of a draft final resolution........................................................................................ 104

Section 6.2

            Cases waiting for the presentation of a draft final resolution....................................................... 109

The 1020th (DH) meeting of the Ministers’ Deputies opened on 4 March 2008 at 10 a.m. under the chairmanship of Mr Per Sjøgren, Deputy for the Minister for Foreign Affairs of Sweden and continued on 5 and 6 March 2008.

PRESENT

ALBANIA

Mr        M.        Meminaj

ANDORRA

Ms        F.         Aleix

ARMENIA

Ms        N.         H ambarzumyan

Mr        A.         Hovhannisyan

AUSTRIA

Ms        E.         Ellison-Kramer

AZERBAIJAN

Mr        J.         Musayev

BELGIUM

Mr        F.         Bontemps

BOSNIA AND HERZEGOVINA

Ms        M.        Sidran-Kamisalic

Mrs       Z.         Ibrahimovic

BULGARIA

Ms        E.         Tomova

CROATIA

Ms        V.         Batistić-Kos

CYPRUS

Mr        M.        Stavrinos

Mr        D.         Samuel

Ms        S-M.     Joannides

Lord                 Lester of Herne Hill QC

CZECH REPUBLIC

Mr        O.         Abrhám

DENMARK

Mr        J.D.      Thomsen

ESTONIA

Mrs       N.         Luts

Mr        E.         Harremoes

FINLAND

Ms        I.          Ertman

Ms        A.-C.     Krank

FRANCE

Ms        C.         Schmerber

GEORGIA

Ms        L.         Goginava

GERMANY

Ms        C.         Althauser

GREECE

Mr        D.         Karabalis

Ms        V.         Pelekou

HUNGARY

Mr        B.         Horváth

ICELAND

Ms        P.M.     Rúnarsdóttir

Ms        L.         Arnlaugsdóttir

IRELAND

Ms        M.        Connery

ITALY

Mr        F.         Crisafulli

Mr        N.         Lettieri

LATVIA

Mrs       I.          Freimane-Deksne

LIECHTENSTEIN

Mr        D.         Ospelt

LITHUANIA

Mr        J.         Rakitskis

LUXEMBOURG

-

MALTA

Mr        J.         Licari

Mr        M.        Pace

MOLDOVA

Ms        R.         Postu

MONACO

-

MONTENEGRO

Mr        I.          Ivanišević

NETHERLANDS

Mr        G.C.     de Boer

NORWAY

Ms        E.         Widsteen

POLAND

Mrs       K.         Dąbek

Mrs       K.         Kowalska

PORTUGAL

Mr        L.         Sequeira

ROMANIA

Mr        C.H.      Rogoveanu

RUSSIAN FEDERATION

Mr        A.         Alekseev

Ms        M.        Molodtsova

Mrs       V.         Milinchuk

Mr        I.          Gordyushkin

Mr        A.         Ilin

Ms        A.         Bashlykova

Ms        E.         Kartashova

SAN MARINO

Mr        G.         Bellatti Ceccoli

SERBIA

Mr        S.         Caric

Ms        V.         Rodic

Ms        T.         Rastovac Siamashvili

SLOVAK REPUBLIC

Ms        I.          Kasárová

Ms        M.        Pirošíková

Ms        M.        Bálintová

SLOVENIA

Mrs       M.        Kušer

SPAIN

Ms        M.        Vilardell Coma

Mr        P.         Desportes

SWEDEN

Mr        P.         Sjögren, Chairman

Mr        M.        Molander

SWITZERLAND

Mr        M.        Wey

“THE FORMER

YUGOSLAV REPUBLIC

OF MACEDONIA”

Ms        O.         Vasilevska

TURKEY

Mr        K.         Esener

Ms        N.         Darama

Mrs       B.         Tuğ

Mr        U.         Umar

Mr        M.        Özmen

Ms        D.         Akçay

Ms        Y.         Renda

Ms        İ.          Altintaş

Ms        A.         Emüler

Ms        D.         Akal

Mrs       G.         Plümer Kücük

Ms        S.         Karabacak

Ms        E.         Demir

UKRAINE

Ms        N.         Shakuro

Mrs       N.         Shkliar

Mrs       I.          Kushnir

UNITED KINGDOM

Ms        H.         Mulvein

*

*        *

EUROPEAN COMMISSION

-

Section 1.1

- 1 case against Armenia

6562/03 Mkrtchyan, judgment of 11/01/2007, final on 11/04/2007

- 48 cases against France

39288/98          Association Ekin, judgment of 17/07/01, final on 17/10/01

33592/96          Baumann, judgment of 22/05/01, final on 22/08/01

45840/99          Bayle, judgment of 25/09/03, final on 25/12/03

59765/00          Carabasse, judgment of 18/01/2005, final on 18/04/2005

36378/97          Bertuzzi, judgment of 13/02/03, final on 21/05/03

33951/96           Caloc, judgment of 20/07/00

51279/99          Colombani and others, judgment of 25/06/02, final on 25/09/02

34000/96          DuRoy and Malaurie, judgment of 03/10/00, final on 03/01/01

48215/99           Lutz, judgment of 26/03/02, final on 26/06/02

59335/00          Makhfi, judgment of 19/10/2004, final on 19/01/2005

11760/02          Raffi, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 13/09/2006

51442/99          Coudrier, judgment of 10/02/2004, final on 14/06/2004

55084/00          Dagot, judgment of 27/04/2004, final on 10/11/2004

55704/00          Rega, judgment of 09/12/2004, final on 09/03/2005

55763/00          Conus, judgment of 04/10/2005, final on 04/01/2006

60392/00          Abribat and autre, judgment of 25/11/03, final on 25/02/04

60495/00          Dukmedjian, judgment of 31/01/2006, final on 01/05/2006

60504/00          Fattell, judgment of 27/01/2005, final on 27/04/2005

61173/00          Lechoisne and others, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 17/09/03

65786/01          Lechelle, judgment of 08/06/2004, final on 08/09/2004

69825/01          Faivre No. 2, judgment of 16/12/03, final on 16/03/04

70034/01          Guez, judgment of 17/05/2005, final on 17/08/2005

75866/01          Colin, judgment of 05/07/2005, final on 05/10/2005

3041/02            Consorts Demir, judgment of 04/04/2006, final on 04/07/2006

4094/02            Beloeil, judgment of 02/11/2004, final on 30/03/2005

8103/02            Gardedieu, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 21/09/2007

18836/02          Le Calvez No. 2, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 26/03/2007

26160/02          Alagia and Nusbaum, judgment of 29/11/2005, final on 01/03/2006

28738/02          Le Bechennec, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006

35009/02          Maillard, judgment of 06/12/2005, final on 06/03/2006

55007/00          SCI Boumois, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 17/09/03

57115/00          Bouilly, judgment of 24/06/03, final on 24/09/03

60955/00          Seidel No. 2, judgment of 17/06/03, final on 17/09/03

72313/01          Favre, judgment of 02/03/04, final on 02/06/04

15110/02          Duhamel, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006

19249/02          Donnadieu No. 2, judgment of 07/02/2006, final on 07/05/2006

22897/02          Barillon No. 2, judgment of 09/02/2006, final on 09/05/2006

31520/02          Oberling, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006

32929/02          Barillon, judgment of 24/01/2006, final on 24/04/2006

41828/02          Bitton No. 2, judgment of 04/04/2006, final on 04/07/2006

22992/02          Bitton n° 1, judgment of 19/12/2006, final on 19/03/2007

29507/95          Slimane-Kaïd No. 1, judgment of 25/01/00, final on 17/05/00

48943/99          Slimane-Kaïd No. 2, judgment of 27/11/03, final on 27/02/04

48221/99          Berger, judgment of 03/12/02, final on 21/05/03

46802/99          Mac Gee, judgment of 07/01/03, final on 07/04/03

45019/98          Pascolini, judgment of 26/06/03, final on 26/09/03

49843/99          Weil, judgment of 05/02/04, final on 05/05/04

35683/97           Vaudelle, judgment of 30/01/01, final on 06/09/01, Interim Resolution ResDH(2005)1

- 1 case against Poland

45355/99+        Shamsa, judgment of 27/11/03, final on 27/02/04

- 1 case against Romania

46626/99          Partidul Comunistilor (Nepeceristi) and Ungureanu, judgment of 03/02/2005, final on 06/07/2005

- 10 cases against the Russian Federation

4856/03            Dubinskaya, judgment of 13/07/2006, final on 13/10/2006

69889/01           Groshev, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006

23697/02           Popova, judgment of 21/12/2006, final on 21/03/2007

69315/01          Sukhorubchenko, judgment of 10/02/2005, final on 10/05/2005

72701/01           Yakovlev, judgment of 15/03/2005, final on 06/07/2005

23472/03          Grinberg, judgment of 21/07/2005, final on 21/10/2005

14881/03          Zakharov, judgment of 05/10/2006, final on 05/01/2007

60776/00          Poleshchuk, judgment of 07/10/2004, final on 07/01/2005

65659/01          Presidential Party of Mordovia, judgment of 05/10/2004, final on 05/01/2005, rectified on 31/03/2005

77785/01           Znamenskaya, judgment of 02/06/2005, final on 12/10/2005

- 1 case against the Slovak Republic

46845/99          Indra, judgment of 01/02/2005, final on 01/05/2005

- 3 cases against Switzerland

27426/95          G.B., judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

28256/95          M.B., judgment of 30/11/00, final on 01/03/01

73604/01           Monnat, judgment of 21/09/2006, final on 21/12/2006, rectified on 11/01/2007

- 2 cases against Ukraine

25921/02          Fedorenko, judgment of 01/06/2006, final on 01/09/2006

23436/03           Melnyk, judgment of 28/03/2006, final on 28/06/2006

Section 1.2

- 7 cases against the Czech Republic

73577/01          Vodárenská akciová společnost, a. s, judgment of 24/02/2004, final on 07/07/2004

73116/01           Mařík, judgment of 12/04/2005, final on 12/10/2005

5424/03            Šroub, judgment of 17/01/2006, final on 03/07/2006

73403/01          Turek, judgment of 21/06/2005, final on 21/09/2005

15333/02          Pillmann, judgment of 27/09/2005, final on 27/12/2005

64737/01          Páleník, judgment of 21/06/2005, final on 12/10/2005

12108/03           Friedrich, judgment of 26/10/2006, final on 26/01/2007

- 3 cases against Moldova

37511/02          Mihalachi, arrêt du 09/01/2007, définitif le 09/04/2007

42288/02           Ermicev, judgment of 08/08/2006, final on 08/11/2006

31535/03          Venera-Nord-Vest Borta A.G., judgment of 13/02/2007, final on 13/05/2007

- 35 cases against Turkey

11804/02          Ayaz and others, judgment of 22/06/2006, final on 22/09/2006

41136/98          Kılıçoğlu, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006

36115/97          Sarıkaya, judgment of 22/04/2004, final on 22/07/2004

35979/97          Korkmaz and others, judgment of 21/03/2006, final on 21/06/2006

36965/97          I.Ö, judgment of 28/06/2005, final on 28/09/2005

74411/01          Daş, judgment of 08/11/2005, final on 08/02/2006

13007/02+        Şahin and Sürgeç, judgment of 31/10/2006, final on 31/01/2007

21283/02          Aslan Davut, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 26/09/2007

3921/02+          Çetinkaya and Çağlayan, judgment of 23/01/2007, final on 23/04/2007

11838/02          Veske, judgment of 20/02/2007, final on 20/05/2007

56497/00          Özçelik, judgment of 20/02/2007, final on 20/05/2007

31734/96          Pütün, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006

30497/96          I.B., judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006

30498/96          H.E., judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006

35064/97          Işık Mehmet Hanefi, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006

41676/98          Yılmaz Mehmet Ertuğrul and others, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 04/08/2006

45736/99          D.A. and B.Y., judgment of 08/08/2006, final on 08/11/2006

64741/01          Bulduş, judgment of 22/12/2005, final on 22/03/2006

74347/01          Sar and others, judgment of 05/12/2006, final on 05/03/2007

77111/01          Ataoğlu, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006, rectified on 01/06/2006

77649/01          Mete Ahmet, judgment of 25/04/2006, final on 25/07/2006

6283/02            Okay, judgment of 21/12/2006, final on 21/03/2007

48069/99          Çoban, judgment of 21/02/2006, final on 21/05/2006

49574/99          Erdem Süleyman, judgment of 19/09/2006, final on 19/12/2006

56002/00+        Bazancir and others, judgment of 11/10/2005, final on 11/01/2006

74325/01          Çağırıcı, judgment of 27/06/2006, final on 27/09/2006

16608/02          Tunç Fatma, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006

4528/02            Şevk, judgment of 11/04/2006, final on 11/07/2006

77366/01          Berk Ferhat, judgment of 27/07/2006, final on 27/10/2006

7035/02            Küçük Mehmet Mübarek, judgment of 20/10/2005, final on 20/01/2006

39081/97          Bora and others, judgment of 10/01/2006, final on 10/04/2006

51479/99          Çelik and Yıldız, judgment of 10/11/2005, final on 10/02/2006

29918/96+        Tanrıkulu and others, judgment of 06/10/2005, final on 06/01/2006

37021/97          Avcı Zeynep, judgment of 06/02/03, final on 09/07/03

59246/00          Rüzgar, judgment of 04/05/2006, final on 04/08/2006

- 1 case against Ukraine

21040/02           Lyashko, judgment of 10/08/2006, final on 10/11/2006

Section 1.3

- 6 cases against France

42270/98          Frangy, judgment of 01/02/2005, final on 01/05/2005

69258/01          Quemar, judgment of 01/02/2005, final on 01/05/2005

46621/99           Mutimura, judgment of 08/06/2004, final on 08/09/2004

50632/99           Coste Pascal, judgment of 22/07/03, final on 22/10/03

49857/99           Ottomani, judgment of 15/10/02, final on 15/01/03

44070/98           Beljanski, judgment of 07/02/02, final on 07/05/02

- 1 case against Ukraine

63566/00          Pronina, judgment of 18/07/2006, final on 18/10/2006

Section 1.4

- 2 cases against France

53951/00           Ardex S.A., judgment of 06/04/04 - Friendly settlement

51294/99           Madi, judgment of 27/04/04 - Friendly settlement

Section 2

2.1        Cases raising new problems (“precedent cases”)

- 1 case against Azerbaijan

- Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments

33343/03           Tarverdiyev, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 2 cases against Bulgaria

- Case concerning the lack of effective investigation into the death of the applicants’ relatives, of Roma origin

55523/00           Angelova and Iliev, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

64209/01           Peev, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 3 cases against Croatia

503/05              Kovač, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases of length of civil proceedings

12419/04           Jakupović, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

43714/02           Skokandić, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

- 1 case against the Czech Republic

57325/00           D.H. and others, judgment of 13/11/2007 - Grand Chamber

- 1 case against Estonia

*11423/03          Pello, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 2 cases against Finland

10163/02           Johansson, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*           *           *

68050/01           Ekholm, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

- 6 cases against France

70456/01           Sayoud, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case concerning freedom of expression

1914/02 Dupuis and others, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

53640/00           Baucher, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

35787/03           Walchli, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

56802/00           Baumet, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the Government Commissioner's presence at the deliberations of the trial bench in proceedings before administrative courts

7091/04 Pieri, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 2 cases against Germany

39741/02           Nanning, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007

71440/01           Freitag, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

 

- 1 case against Greece

44858/04           Markoulaki No. 1, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 1 case against Hungary

25691/04           Bukta and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007, rectified on 25/09/2007

- 1 case against Italy

                       - Case concerning freedom of expression

30278/04           Ormanni, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 1 case against Latvia

65022/01           Zaicevs, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

- 1 case against Lithuania

*11529/04          Baškienė, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 1 case against Moldova

32268/02           Malahov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 2 cases against Norway

11106/04+         Ekeberg and others, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

*              *              *

9042/04 Riis A. and E., judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 31/08/2007

- 1 case against Portugal

- Case concerning inadequate compensation for land expropriated under the agrarian reform of 1975

31677/04           Sociedade Agrícola Herdade da Palma S.A., judgment of 10/07/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 2 cases against Romania

48254/99           Cobzaru, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

29294/02           Hirschhorn, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 6 cases against the Russian Federation

32718/02           Tuleshov and others, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

71362/01           Smirnov, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

65582/01           Radchikov, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

78145/01           Kovalev, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

52058/99          Gorodnitchev, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

35082/04           Makhmudov, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 1 case against Serbia

3150/05 Jevremović, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 3 cases against the Slovak Republic

8607/02 Cabala, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

14893/02           Haris, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

48666/99           Kučera, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 1 case against Switzerland

3688/04 Weber, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 2 cases against Turkey

52658/99           Yiğit Mehmet and Suna, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

*           *           *

58771/00           Amato, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 2 cases against the United Kingdom

*44362/04          Dickson, judgment of 04/12/2007 – Grand Chamber

*           *           *

60860/00           Tsfayo, judgment of 14/11/2006, final on 14/02/2007, rectified on 10/07/2007

2.2        Cases raising issues already examined by the Committee of Ministers (“repetitive cases”)

- 3 cases against Austria

- Cases of length of proceedings concerning the determination of criminal charges before administrative courts and of lack of an effective remedy

18015/03           Schütte, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

18294/03           Stempfer, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

8140/04 Vitzthum, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 2 cases against Belgium

                         - Cases of length of civil proceedings

27535/04           De Saedeleer, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

40628/04           Nagler and Nalimmo B.V.B.A., judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 3 cases against Bulgaria

- Cases mainly concerning the poor conditions of detention and / or the lack of an effective remedy in this respect

61507/00           Georgiev Andrei, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

57830/00           Malechkov, judgment of 28/06/2007, final on 28/09/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case of length of criminal proceedings

67189/01           Ivanov, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 1 case against Cyprus

                       - Case of length of civil proceedings

43151/04           Charalambous Aresti, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

- 1 case against the Czech Republic

- Case concerning the lack of access to Constitutional Court due to its excessively formalistic interpretation of the admissibility rules

*18806/02          Ješina, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 1 case against Finland

                         - Case of length of judicial proceedings

25072/02           Riihikallio and others, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 5 cases against Greece

                         - Case of length of civil proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy

527/05              Doggakis and others, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

- Cases of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before administrative courts

17930/05           Leonidopoulos, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

23009/05           Makris Thomas, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

77658/01           Zisis, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case of length of criminal proceedings

14846/05           Peca, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 3 cases against Hungary

                       - Cases of length of judicial proceedings

45311/05           Bakonyi, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

30077/03           Hélioplán Kft, judgment of 03/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*13647/04          Immobilia Bau Kft, judgment of 09/10/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 11 cases against Italy

- Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments ordering the demolition of buildings

77606/01           Paudicio, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

6870/03 Vitiello, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the failure to give speedy decisions on the lawfulness of the detention on remand

16508/04           Naranjo Hurtado, judgment of 03/07/2007, final on 03/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case concerning in absentia proceedings

19321/03          Pittito, judgment of 12/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning excessive length of judicial proceedings and effectiveness of the compensatory remedy (Pinto Act)

- Cases before civil courts

56293/00          G.M., judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 12/11/2007

23901/03          Gragnano, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

62265/00          Gregori, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case concerning bankruptcy proceedings (Articles 1 of Protocol No. 1 and 6§1)

10756/02          Gallucci, judgment of 12/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning bankruptcy proceedings (Articles 8 and 13)

*26041/04         Casotti, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

13611/04          Maugeri, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

*22689/04         Scorziello, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 1 case against Lithuania

                       - Case of length of criminal proceedings

418/04              Gečas, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 1 case against Luxembourg

                       - Case of length of criminal proceedings combined with civil action for damages

11282/05           Electro Distribution Luxembourgeoise (E.D.L.) S.A., judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

- 2 cases against Moldova

                        - Case concerning detention without legal basis

21984/05           Gorea, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration in abiding by final domestic judgments

27568/02           Ungureanu, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

- 12 cases against Poland

- Cases concerning the violation of the right to the peaceful enjoyment of possessions following the modifications to the local land development plan

17373/02           Rosiński, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

38672/02           Skrzyński, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the lack of access to court on account of excessive court fees

73002/01           Kijewska, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*           *           *

                        - Case concerning the unfairness of lustration proceedings

*68761/01          Bobek, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning monitoring of prisoners’ correspondence

8363/04 Kliza, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*           *           *

                        - Cases of length of detention on remand

3994/03 Kaķol, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*73102/01          Kuc, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

32849/04           Mucha, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

19177/03           Schmalz, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

21541/03           Szmajchel, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning the length of proceedings before civil and labour courts

*11184/03          Krempa-Czuchryta, judgment of 03/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

73192/01           Wawrzynowicz, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 8 cases against Romania

- Case concerning the lack of access to a court in order to claim the restitution of a nationalised building

65402/01           Radu Cornelia Eufrosina, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning the failure to restore or compensate for nationalised property sold by the state to third parties

34011/02           Hertzog and others, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007, rectified on 13/09/2007

42061/02           Ionescu Elena and Nicolae, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

24681/03           Popescu and Daşoveanu, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

4198/04 Rusu and others, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

1696/03 Săvulescu, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning failure to enforce or late enforcement by the administration of final judicial decisions ordering the restitution of land properties nationalised or lost during the communist period

1818/02 Dorneanu, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the continued impossibility to dispose of the properties and to receive rent for their use resulting from the application of the urgency provisions concerning housing payments

*3864/03           Spanoche, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 20 cases against the Russian Federation

                       - Case concerning security forces in the Chechen Republic

40464/02          Akhmadova and Sadulayeva, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning the applicants’ poor conditions of detention

52697/99          Mikadze, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

36898/03          Trepashkin, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning judicial guarantees in the context of detention on remand

36911/02          Mishketkul and others, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

64140/00          Rozhkov, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 12/11/2007

2708/02            Solovyev Vladimir, judgment of 24/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning freedom of expression

72683/01          Chemodurov, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

25968/02          Dyuldin and Kislov, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the right of association

10519/03          Barankevich, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case mainly concerning quashing of final judgments on the basis of newly discovered circumstances

67579/01           Kuznetsova, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments

21198/05          Ayrapetyan, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

19134/05          Bolyukh, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

*24842/04         Kletsova, judgment of 12/04/2007, final on 10/12/2007

3790/05            OOO PTK “Merkuriy”, judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

3519/05            Sidorenko, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

33986/02          Somchenko, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

3462/04            Vershinina, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

13296/03          Zverev, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration to enforce judgments relating to the social benefits of former Chernobyl workers

                       Resolution ResDH(2004)85

21932/03           Bakharev, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

39013/05           Svitich, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

- 1 case against Serbia

- Case of length of proceedings concerning civil rights and obligations before civil and commercial courts

28443/05           Samardžić and AD Plastika, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

- 1 case against Spain

                        - Case concerning the right of access to a court

25779/03           Salt Hiper, S.A., judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 1 case against Switzerland

- Case concerning the principle of equality of arms (failure to communicate defendant’s submissions to the applicant)

10577/04           Kessler, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 2 cases against “the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”

                       - Cases of length of civil proceedings

13270/02           Dika, judgment of 31/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*22931/03          Lazarevska, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

- 44 cases against Turkey

- Case concerning the excessive use of force in quelling a prison riot and lack of an effective investigation

36672/97           Kurnaz and others, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

                        - Cases concerning the actions of the Turkish security forces

a) Cases concerning the failure to protect the right to life and / or the lack of effective investigation into the death of the applicants’ relatives

40074/98           Yıldırım Feyzi, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

b) Cases concerning the inhuman and degrading treatment of the applicants and / or the absence of an effective remedy whereby complaint might be made and lack of procedural safeguards in police custody

56003/00           Asan and others, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

19735/02           Atıcı, judgment of 10/05/2007, final on 12/11/2007

68351/01           Diri, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

56365/00           Kurt Cafer, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning the ineffectiveness of domestic proceedings brought following ill treatment inflicted by members of the security forces

19028/02           Tamer Fazıl Ahmet and others, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

34738/04           Yeşil and Sevim, judgment of 05/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007, rectified on 14/11/2007

17721/02           Yılmaz Hürriyet, judgment of 05/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning freedom of expression

6586/05 Güzel No. 3, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case concerning freedom of expression - state of emergency

75512/01           Demirel and others, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases mainly concerning the independence and impartiality of state security courts

47115/99           Çelik Ulaş, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

64447/01           Garbul, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

37625/03           Güven Birtan and others, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

41551/98           Karatepe, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

40991/98           Koçak Kemal, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

44662/98           Öz and Yürekli, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

64570/01           Tekin Halis, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

*           *           *

                        - Case mainly concerning freedom of expression

52709/99           Ulusoy, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning the lack of compensation following annulment of title to a plot of land in the framework of the Coastal Law regime

16480/03+         Katayıfçı and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007, rectified on 13/12/2007

*29128/03          Tozkoparan and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

21850/03           Yurtöven, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning the lack of compensation for the loss of title to property under Article 38 of Law on Expropriation

69911/01           İnci (Nasiroğlu), judgment of 14/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning the failure to communicate the public prosecutor’s opinion

9709/03 Marti, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

42086/02           Yurtsever Mesut, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

*           *           *

- Case concerning mainly the unlawfulness of the applicants’ transfer to the gendarmerie premises after being placed in pre-trial detention

33412/02+         Zerey and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases concerning the length of detention on remand and of criminal proceedings

26896/02           Bayam, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007, rectified on 28/01/2008

*7940/05           Çarkçı, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 10/12/2007

48545/99           Çelik Mehmet Şah, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

18378/02           Hanbayat, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

47043/99           Yavuz Mehmet, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Case concerning the length of detention in custody

7144/02+           Tuş and others, judgment of 19/07/2007, final on 19/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases of length of judicial proceedings and lack of an effective remedy

a) Cases before civil courts

76091/01           Doğan Naime and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

6749/03 Yıldız and others, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

b) Case before commercial courts

74495/01           Kat İnşaat Ticaret Kollektif Şirketi, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

c) Case before Cadastre courts

64236/01           Talipoğlu Mehmet Ali, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007, rectified on 07/01/2008

d) Case before criminal courts

74522/01           Esen Ali, judgment of 24/07/2007, final on 24/10/2007

e) Case before administrative courts

26576/02           Genç Hasan, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

f) Execution proceedings

27150/02           Ak, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning delays by the administration in paying additional compensation for expropriation and the applicable rate of default interest

23901/02+        Akdaş and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007, rectified on 27/09/2007

73068/01+        Bağcı and others, judgment of 17/07/2007, final on 17/10/2007

34026/02          Evcil, judgment of 31/07/2007, final on 31/10/2007

74433/01          Kansiz, arrêt du 22/05/2007, définitif le 12/11/2007

117/02              Kizir and others, judgment of 26/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

- 16 cases against Ukraine

2570/04 Kucheruk, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*           *           *

- Cases concerning the failure or substantial delay by the administration or state companies in abiding by final domestic judgments

39265/02           Fateyev, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

28562/02           Lozynskyy and others, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

18219/02           Lysenko, judgment of 07/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

74096/01           Shamray, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

34339/03           Sikorska, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

36678/03           Sova, judgment of 21/06/2007, final on 12/11/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases of length of criminal proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy

31585/02           Benyaminson, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

25444/03           Kalinichenko, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

26277/02           Nosalskiy, judgment of 12/07/2007, final on 12/10/2007

31580/03           Safyannikova, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

*           *           *

                       - Cases of length of civil proceedings and of lack of an effective remedy

39946/03           Inkovtsova, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

22600/02           Kucherenko, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

12347/02           Lastovka, judgment of 06/09/2007, final on 06/12/2007

*31780/02          Panteleeva, judgment of 05/07/2007, final on 10/12/2007

39970/02           Shanko, judgment of 26/07/2007, final on 26/10/2007

- 2 cases against the United Kingdom

- Friendly settlements concerning discrimination between widows and widowers on grounds of gender regarding social security benefits

45773/99           Cairney, judgment of 20/11/2007 - Friendly settlement

63388/00           Dobb, judgment of 20/11/2007 - Friendly settlement

SECTION 3.A    :   SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST SATISFACTION IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT EXPIRED LESS THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

Decision unless specified otherwise: The Deputies decided to resume consideration of the following cases at their 1028th meeting (3-5 June 2008) (DH) for supervision of payment of the just satisfaction or, at the latest, within six months providing that proof of the payment of the just satisfaction has been received before the deadline for transmission of new information for the preparation of the meeting.

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ARM	3.A	36549/03	HARUTYUNYAN c. Armenia
AUT	3.A	2293/03	WIESER c. Austria
AUT	3.A	5266/03	NIKOWITZ ET VERLAGSGRUPPE NEWS GESMBH c. Austria
AZE	3.A	34445/04	MAMMADOV (JALALOGLU) c. Azerbaijan
BEL	3.A	44899/98	BRICHET et BOUZET c. Belgium
BGR	3.A	42908/98	KIRILOVA ET AUTRES c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	47797/99	KEHAYA ET AUTRES c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	54323/00	HASAN c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	57045/00	ZHECHEV c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	57847/00	NAVUSHTANOV c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	65028/01	BASHIR et Autres c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	68079/01	NIKOLA NIKOLOV c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	68490/01	STANKOV c. Bulgaria
BGR	3.A	77147/01	KUYUMDZHIYAN c. Bulgaria
CZE	3.A	50073/99	CHADIMOVA c. République tchèque
CZE	3.A	25326/03	PATERA c. République tchèque
CZE	3.A	23499/06	HAVELKA ET AUTRES c. République tchèque
FIN	3.A	40412/98	V. c. Finland
FIN	3.A	43160/98	TOIVE LEHTINEN c. Finland
FIN	3.A	45830/99	JUHA NUUTINEN c. Finland
FIN	3.A	46602/99	A.H. c. Finland
FIN	3.A	70216/01	LAAKSONEN c. Finland
FIN	3.A	14151/02	W c. Finland
FIN	3.A	22508/02	F et M c. Finland
FIN	3.A	10736/03	VAANANEN c. Finland
FRA	3.A	11950/02	TEDESCO v. France
FRA	3.A	12106/03	SCM SCANNER DE L'OUEST LYONNAIS et autres v. France
FRA	3.A	23101/03	AIOUAZ v. France
FRA	3.A	31501/03	AUBERT ET 8 AUTRES v. France
FRA	3.A	23241/04	ARMA v. France
FRA	3.A	25389/05	GEBREMEDHIN v. France [GABERAMADHIEN]
GEO	3.A	71156/01	97 membres de la congrégation des témoins de Jehovah de Gldani et 4 autres c. Géorgie
GEO	3.A	12979/04	GORELISHVILI c. Géorgie
GRC	3.A	16163/02	NASTOU v. Greece (n° 2)
GRC	3.A	2898/03	N.T. GIANNOUSIS ET KLIAFAS BROTHERS S.A. v. Greece
GRC	3.A	8863/03	GOUSIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	17060/03	ZELILOF v. Greece

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
GRC	3.A	25771/03	ALSAYED ALLAHAM v. Greece
GRC	3.A	27850/03	KARAGIANNOPOULOS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	35115/03	VADEN v. Greece
GRC	3.A	39725/03	ANASTASIADIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	9747/04	GOROU v. Greece (n° 4)
GRC	3.A	14249/04	SAKKOPOULOS (n° 2) v. Greece
GRC	3.A	17721/04	PERLALA v. Greece
GRC	3.A	21449/04	CELNIKU v. Greece
GRC	3.A	28770/04	TSEKOURIDOU v. Greece
GRC	3.A	32155/04	NOEL BAKER v. Greece
GRC	3.A	38752/04	GEORGOULIS et autres v. Greece
GRC	3.A	199/05	JOHN v. Greece
GRC	3.A	624/05	PSARAKIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	1131/05	LIONARAKIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	2189/05	PAPASTERIADES v. Greece
GRC	3.A	6571/05	PANTALEON v. Greece
GRC	3.A	7629/05	ROIDAKIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	9029/05	KAMPANELLIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	10953/05	CHRYSOCHOOU v. Greece
GRC	3.A	14189/05	KARANAKIS v. Greece
GRC	3.A	18700/05	PAPADOGEORGOS v. Greece
HUN	3.A	6690/02	PEPSZOLG Kft (`v.a.`) c. Hongrie
HUN	3.A	26137/04	BARTA c. Hongrie
HUN	3.A	28323/04	GOTTHARD-GAZ KFT c. Hongrie
HUN	3.A	38329/04	SZEBELLEDI c. Hongrie
HUN	3.A	12941/05	KREISZ c. Hongrie
ISL	3.A	31930/04	EGGERTSDOTTIR c. Islande
ITA	3.A	41040/98	ACCIARDI & CAMPAGNA v. Italy
ITA	3.A	43662/98	SCORDINO v. Italy (n° 3)
ITA	3.A	43663/98	MASON et autres v. Italy
ITA	3.A	56300/00	FASCINI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	56301/00	CAMPANA v. Italy
ITA	3.A	62154/00	PRATI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	62155/00	PROVIDE S.R.L. v. Italy
ITA	3.A	62157/00	LOCATELLI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	62158/00	BERTOSSI et MARTINELLI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	64111/00	DOMINICI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	64888/01	CIVITILLO v. Italy
ITA	3.A	64889/01	PARRELLA v. Italy
ITA	3.A	66418/01	CERUTI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	66419/01	MARTINELLI et DOTTI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	10347/02	DI IESO v. Italy
ITA	3.A	20236/02	CAPONE v. Italy
ITA	3.A	26740/02	GRANDE ORIENTE D`ITALIA DI PALAZZO GIUSTINIANI v. Italy (n° 2)
ITA	3.A	6683/03	FALZARANO v. Italy
ITA	3.A	25701/03	KOLLCAKU v. Italy

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ITA	3.A	27654/03	GIANVITO v. Italy
ITA	3.A	35941/03	GIANNI et autres v. Italy
ITA	3.A	22697/04	MORSELLI v. Italy
ITA	3.A	26570/04	DELLA VECCHIA v. Italy
LVA	3.A	58822/00	CHEVANOVA  c. Lettonie
LVA	3.A	59643/00	KAFTAILOVA c. Lettonie
LVA	3.A	16657/03	A/S DIENA ET OZOLINS c. Lettonie
MDA	3.A	1115/02	MAZEPA v. Moldova
MDA	3.A	20289/02	GUTU v. Moldova
MDA	3.A	39745/02	COOPERATIVA AGRICOLA SLOBOZIA-HANESEI v. Moldova
MDA	3.A	6888/03	PRUNEANU v. Moldova
MDA	3.A	15084/03	BIMER S.A. v. Moldova
MDA	3.A	8721/05	ISTRATII v. Moldova
MDA	3.A	14437/05	MODARCA v. Moldova
MKD	3.A	66907/01	DOCEVSKI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	69908/01	JASAR v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	17995/02	STOIMENOV v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	27866/02	ZIBERI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	33046/02	MITREVSKI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	34215/02	STOJANOV v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	44221/02	MIHAJLOSKI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	6924/03	GRABERSKA v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	14349/03	SALI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.A	21510/03	GROZDANOSKI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
NLD	3.A	52391/99	RAMSAHAI ET AUTRES c. Pays-Bas
NLD	3.A	14683/03	SYLLA c. Pays-Bas
POL	3.A	46702/99	DZWONKOWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.A	56026/00	WENDE ET KUKOWKA v. Poland
POL	3.A	59519/00	STAROSZCZYK v. Poland
POL	3.A	59526/00	KASZCZYNIEC v. Poland
POL	3.A	77420/01	KRYSZKIEWICZ v. Poland
POL	3.A	77765/01	LASKOWSKA v. Poland
POL	3.A	1363/02	WILUSZ v. Poland
POL	3.A	4657/02	POLAKOWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.A	8174/02	AMURCHANIAN v. Poland
POL	3.A	11638/02	PAWLIK v. Poland
POL	3.A	13146/02	RAFINSKA v. Poland
POL	3.A	14348/02	GARYCKI v. Poland
POL	3.A	21508/02	W.S. v. Poland
POL	3.A	29437/02	LEWANDOWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.A	44319/02	ZMALINSKI  v. Poland
POL	3.A	5410/03	TYSIAC v. Poland
POL	3.A	25490/03	SWIECICKI v. Poland
POL	3.A	28949/03	SANOCKI v. Poland
POL	3.A	35615/03	KRZYCH et GURBIERZ v. Poland
POL	3.A	38184/03	MATYJEK v. Poland

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
POL	3.A	5608/04	RUBACHA v. Poland
POL	3.A	14382/04	TONDERYS v. Poland
POL	3.A	28836/04	ABRAMCZYK v. Poland
POL	3.A	8932/05	SIALKOWSKA v. Poland
POL	3.A	43120/05	ANDRULEWICZ v. Poland
PRT	3.A	11182/03	COLACO MESTRE c. Portugal
PRT	3.A	25053/05	FERREIRA ALVES c. Portugal (N° 3)
ROM	3.A	49234/99	POPESCU v. Romania (n° 1)
ROM	3.A	53897/00	DANILA v. Romania
ROM	3.A	57884/00	KALANYOS et autres v. Romania
ROM	3.A	57885/00	GERGELY v. Romania
ROM	3.A	63252/00	PADURARU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	67703/01	HAULER v. Romania
ROM	3.A	73969/01	PETRESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	75297/01	BRAZDA ET MALITA v. Romania
ROM	3.A	77193/01	DRAGOTONIU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	77217/01	CLEJA et MIHALCEA v. Romania
ROM	3.A	2239/02	DOBRE v. Romania
ROM	3.A	2726/02	NERUMBERG v. Romania
ROM	3.A	5048/02	MACOVEI et autres v. Romania
ROM	3.A	9405/02	PAUN v. Romania
ROM	3.A	10793/02	DURA v. Romania
ROM	3.A	11116/02	IONESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	16891/02	FUNKE v. Romania
ROM	3.A	18037/02	GAVRILEANU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	18419/02	TODICESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	21740/02	BOCK et PALADE v. Romania
ROM	3.A	22626/02	SCHREPLER v. Romania
ROM	3.A	24959/02	ERBICEANU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	27086/02	POPESCU ET TOADER v. Romania
ROM	3.A	31442/02	RADULESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	35951/02	GABRIEL v. Romania
ROM	3.A	41857/02	FLORESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.A	6098/03	DURDAN v. Romania
ROM	3.A	32494/03	ASLAN v. Romania
ROM	3.A	19215/04	GHEORGHE v. Romania
ROM	3.A	26449/04	STROIA v. Romania
ROM	3.A	9292/05	ENCIU ET LEGA v. Romania
RUS	3.A	62866/00	BOYCHENKO AND GERSHKOVICH v. Russia
RUS	3.A	72967/01	BELEVITSKIY v. Russia
RUS	3.A	74237/01	BAYSAYEVA v. Russia
RUS	3.A	106/02	BENEDIKTOV v. Russia
RUS	3.A	18147/02	CHURCH OF SCIENTOLOGY MOSCOW v. Russia
RUS	3.A	30138/02	NURMAGOMEDOV v. Russia
RUS	3.A	43282/02	NAYDENKOV v. Russia

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
RUS	3.A	2191/03	PRIDATCHENKO ET AUTRES v. Russia
RUS	3.A	2993/03	AKALINSKIY v. Russia
RUS	3.A	2999/03	DOVGUCHITS v. Russia
RUS	3.A	20098/03	KHVOROSTINA ET AUTRES v. Russia
RUS	3.A	28639/03	SAVENKO v. Russia
RUS	3.A	38719/03	GLUSHAKOVA v. Russia
RUS	3.A	38720/03	Aleksandr POPOV v. Russia
RUS	3.A	5945/04	FURMAN v. Russia
RUS	3.A	7111/05	PYLNOV v. Russia
RUS	3.A	8582/05	ZHELTKOV v. Russia
RUS	3.A	6558/06	SAIDOV v. Russia
RUS	3.A	18762/06	TELYATYEVA v. Russia
SVK	3.A	7510/04	KONTROVA c. Slovaquie
SVN	3.A	66824/01	LESAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.A	75617/01	SVARC & KAVNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.A	77522/01	SEDMAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.A	26867/02	GRZINCIC v. Slovenia
SWE	3.A	75252/01	EVALDSSON ET AUTRES v. Sweden
TUR	3.A	32581/96	KOCAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	37410/97	UZUN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	37451/97	N.A. ET AUTRES v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	39429/98	BAYRAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	39464/98	OLMEZ v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	49240/99	GUNDOGDU v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	50091/99	SOYSAL v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	50147/99	YEDIKULE SURP PIRGIC ERMENI HASTANESI VAKFI v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	50948/99	MUSLUOGLU et autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	54902/00	GULSEN et autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	63758/00	ANIK et Autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	70830/01	ERN MAKINA SANAYI VE TICARET A.S. v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	74069/01	CICEK ET OZTEMEL v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	74321/01	KOSTI et autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	75603/01	ILDAN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	75606/01	MICOOGULLARI v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	8610/02	BILGIN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	15394/02	ILICAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	23914/02	YALMAN ET TURKMEN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	25321/02	ULGER v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	28152/02	DEMIRHAN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	31487/02	OZDEN (2) v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	33434/02	BELGE v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	33663/02	MOREL v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	37685/02	USTUN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	38128/02	TANGUN ET AUTRES v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	38323/02	MEHMET COLAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	6247/03	KAYMAZ v. Turkey

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
TUR	3.A	9613/03	VURANKAYA v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	10054/03	EMIR v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	10365/03	DEMIREL v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	12101/03	KURT et autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	18207/03	KOC v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	29840/03	HASAN ERKAN v. Turkey
TUR	3.A	34797/03	ULUSOY ET AUTRES v. Turkey
UKR	3.A	803/02	INTERSPLAV v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	1110/02	KOVAL v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	11370/02	VASILYEV v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	17787/02	GIRYA ET AUTRES v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	25476/02	POGREBNA v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	25543/02	STRATEYCHUK v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	31105/02	SHINKARENKO v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	33983/02	ARTEMENKO v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	4078/03	CHUKHAS v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	6725/03	LIZANETS v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	9616/03	SVISTUN v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	9755/03	DOLGIKH v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	10569/03	BARSKIY v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	11084/03	KOZLOV v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	25681/03	PANCHENKO v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	28746/03	VYROVYY v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	22986/04	MIKHAYLOV v. Ukraine
UKR	3.A	32558/04	MAVRODIY v. Ukraine

SECTION 3.Aint : SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF DEFAULT INTEREST DUE

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
BGR	3.Aint	56891/00	BORISOVA c. Bulgaria
ESP	3.Aint	66990/01	SOTO SANCHEZ c. Spain
FIN	3.Aint	10615/03	MOLANDER c. Finland
FRA	3.Aint	29731/96	KROMBACH v. France
FRA	3.Aint	37786/97	DEBBOUB alias Husseini Ali v. France
FRA	3.Aint	37794/97	PANNULLO ET FORTE v. France
FRA	3.Aint	43640/98	MARIANI v. France
FRA	3.Aint	44081/98	PERHIRIN et autres v. France
FRA	3.Aint	49451/99	BLONDET v. France
FRA	3.Aint	50278/99	AOULMI v. France
FRA	3.Aint	52206/99	MOKRANI v. France
FRA	3.Aint	56198/00	SIES v. France
FRA	3.Aint	57752/00	MATHERON v. France
FRA	3.Aint	58148/00	PLON (SOCIETE) v. France
FRA	3.Aint	60796/00	CABOURDIN v. France

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
FRA	3.Aint	61517/00	F. W. v. France
FRA	3.Aint	62034/00	VIGROUX v. France
FRA	3.Aint	62236/00	GUILLOURY v. France
FRA	3.Aint	66018/01	VEZON v. France
FRA	3.Aint	67847/01	LECARPENTIER et autre v. France
FRA	3.Aint	68864/01	MERGER et CROS v. France
FRA	3.Aint	71377/01	WATT v. France
FRA	3.Aint	72377/01	SARL DU PARC D'ACTIVITES DE BLOTZHEIM v. France
FRA	3.Aint	73804/01	STORCK v. France
FRA	3.Aint	16616/02	VARELAS v. France
FRA	3.Aint	22945/02	BEAUCAIRE v. France
FRA	3.Aint	40403/02	PESSINO v. France
FRA	3.Aint	38208/03	SERIS v. France
GEO	3.Aint	28537/02	SARL "IZA" et MAKRAKHIDZE c. Géorgie
GEO	3.Aint	2507/03	SARL AMAT-G et MEBAGISHVILI c. Géorgie
GRC	3.Aint	17305/02	ZACHARAKIS v. Greece
GRC	3.Aint	36998/02	EFSTATHIOU et autres v. Greece
GRC	3.Aint	11720/03	INEXCO v. Greece
GRC	3.Aint	13320/03	DAMILAKOS v. Greece
GRC	3.Aint	20898/03	CHATZIBYRROS et autres v. Greece
ITA	3.Aint	17482/90	D'AQUINO v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	24170/94	PESCE v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	25337/94	CRAXI v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	36732/97	PISANO v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	37710/97	ELIA SRL v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	44409/98	RIZZO v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	44446/98	DI GIROLAMO & Autres v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	44505/98	SHIPCARE S.R.L. v. Italy
ITA	3.Aint	55984/00	GOFFI v. Italy
MDA	3.Aint	53487/99	MERIAKRI v. Moldova
MKD	3.Aint	58185/00	JANEVA v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
PRT	3.Aint	48233/99	ALMEIDA DO COUTO c. Portugal
PRT	3.Aint	64330/01	ANTUNES ROCHA c. Portugal
ROM	3.Aint	32925/96	CRETU v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	34647/97	RUIANU v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	34992/97	BASACOPOL v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	35831/97	BALANESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	54062/00	ANDRONE v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	63945/00	WEISSMAN et autres v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	77195/01	ABALUTA v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	7234/03	POP v. Romania
ROM	3.Aint	18013/03	IOACHIMESCU et ION v. Romania
RUS	3.Aint	53157/99	LEDYAYEVA v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	19457/02	ROMANENKO et ROMANENKO v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	24620/02	BELYAYEV v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	36045/02	SHNEYDERMAN v. Russia

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
RUS	3.Aint	374/03	VOLOKITIN v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	14139/03	BOLAT v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	14656/03	PONOMARENKO v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	20887/03	KOT v. Russia
RUS	3.Aint	14502/04	NELYUBIN v. Russia
SVK	3.Aint	54822/00	MICOVCIN c. Slovaquie
TUR	3.Aint	22876/93	Semsa ONEN v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	24351/94	AKTAS v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	25142/94	SADAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	27528/95	KIZILYAPRAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	29422/95	TEPE v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	32572/96	AYDIN v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	34506/97	TURKOGLU v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	34592/97	AGDAS v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	38883/97	H.B. et autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	46649/99	GULER et autres v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	47165/99	OZKAN v. Turkey
TUR	3.Aint	60847/00	SACIK v. Turkey
UKR	3.Aint	41220/98	ALIEV v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	47148/99	NOVOSELETSKIY v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	63158/00	TIMOTIYEVICH v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	67647/01	BAKAY et Autres v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	68897/01	MOLCHAN v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	5788/02	BITKIVSKA v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	14183/02	ANTONENKOV ET AUTRES v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	14397/02	VARANITSA v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	19158/02	SIDENKO v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	35091/02	MYKHAYLENKY v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	26996/03	RYBAK v. Ukraine
UKR	3.Aint	27370/03	GORDEYEVY v. Ukraine

SECTION 3.B    :   SUPERVISION OF THE PAYMENT OF THE CAPITAL SUM OF THE JUST SATISFACTION IN CASES WHERE THE DEADLINE FOR PAYMENT EXPIRED MORE THAN 6 MONTHS AGO

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ALB	3.B	7352/03	BESHIRI and others v. Albanie
AND	3.B	69498/01	PLA ET PUNCERNAU v. Andorre
AUT	3.B	45983/99	KAPLAN v. Austria
AUT	3.B	13071/03	STANDARD VERLAGS GMBH v. Austria
BEL	3.B	46046/99	MARIEN v. Belgium
BEL	3.B	46825/99	CLAES v. Belgium
BEL	3.B	19443/02	VANDAELE and VAN ACKER c. Belgium
BEL	3.B	37330/02	DEFALQUE v. Belgium
BEL	3.B	18211/03	LENARDON v. Belgium
BGR	3.B	45964/99	KAROV v. Bulgaria
BGR	3.B	51796/99	SPASOV v. Bulgaria
BGR	3.B	53820/00	BONEVA v. Bulgaria
BGR	3.B	58925/00	TOTCHEV v. Bulgaria
ESP	3.B	55524/00	STONE COURT SHIPPING COMPANY, S.A. c. Spain
FIN	3.B	36288/97	FRYCKMAN v. Finland
FIN	3.B	63235/00	VILHO ESKELINEN and others v. Finland
FRA	3.B	38396/97	KARATAS and SARI v. France
FRA	3.B	38410/97	FONTAINE v. France
FRA	3.B	39001/97	MAAT v. France
FRA	3.B	42272/98	POTIER v. France
FRA	3.B	44568/98	R.L. and M.-J.D. v. France
FRA	3.B	45338/99	AUTHOUART v. France
FRA	3.B	49580/99	SANTONI v. France
FRA	3.B	49699/99	SIFFRE v. France
FRA	3.B	50609/99	LATRY v. France
FRA	3.B	51360/99	MARSCHNER v. France
FRA	3.B	52621/99	SCHWARKMANN v. France
FRA	3.B	53892/00	LILLY FRANCE v. France
FRA	3.B	54968/00	PATUREL v. France
FRA	3.B	57470/00	OUATTARA v. France
FRA	3.B	57516/00	SOCIETE DE GESTION DU PORT DE CAMPOLORO v. France
FRA	3.B	59423/00	SARL ABORCAS v. France
FRA	3.B	59450/00	RAMIREZ SANCHEZ v. France
FRA	3.B	59584/00	RIVAS v. France
FRA	3.B	59842/00	VETTER v. France
FRA	3.B	61104/00	QUILLEVERE v. France
FRA	3.B	61328/00	DE SOUSA v. France

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
FRA	3.B	62118/00	BRENIERE v. France
FRA	3.B	62740/00	MATHEUS v. France
FRA	3.B	63879/00	BEN NACEUR v. France
FRA	3.B	65399/01	CLINIQUE DES ACACIAS v. France
FRA	3.B	65935/01	M.B. v. France
FRA	3.B	67114/01	COORBANALLY v. France
FRA	3.B	67881/01	GRUAIS and BOUSQUET v. France
FRA	3.B	68673/01	MATHIEU v. France
FRA	3.B	69507/01	FERNANDEZ-RODRIGUEZ v. France
FRA	3.B	69678/01	COSSEC v. France
FRA	3.B	70160/01	AON CONSEIL ET COURTAGE SA and other v. France
FRA	3.B	70387/01	SYNDICAT NATIONAL DES PROFESSIONNELS DES PROCEDURES COLLECTIVES v. France
FRA	3.B	71244/01	BOZON v. France
FRA	3.B	73316/01	SILIADIN v. France
FRA	3.B	73893/01	BESSEAU v. France
FRA	3.B	73947/01	ZERVUDACKI v. France
FRA	3.B	74587/01	LACAS v. France
FRA	3.B	75699/01	VATURI v. France
FRA	3.B	75833/01	SCHEMKAMPER v. France
FRA	3.B	76093/01	BARBIER v. France
FRA	3.B	76450/01	HOSTEIN v. France
FRA	3.B	77098/01	DESRUES v. France
FRA	3.B	77240/01	CED VIANDES and other v. France
FRA	3.B	77655/01	RELAIS DU MIN SARL v. France
FRA	3.B	3774/02	VESQUE v. France
FRA	3.B	4069/02	GENITEAU v. France (No. 2)
fra	3.B	8112/02	DE LUCA v. France
FRA	3.B	16022/02	ROUX v. France
FRA	3.B	17902/02	ZENTAR v. France
FRA	3.B	19617/02	SASSI v. France
FRA	3.B	21324/02	PLASSE-BAUER v. France
FRA	3.B	27928/02	BROCA v. France
FRA	3.B	28625/02	ARAGUAS v. France
FRA	3.B	38287/02	VAN GLABEKE v. France
FRA	3.B	38718/02	POULAIN DE SAINT PERE v. France
FRA	3.B	39269/02	MALQUARTI v. France
FRA	3.B	40391/02	SOCIETE AU SERVICE DU DEVELOPPEMENT v. France
FRA	3.B	44404/02	COUR v. France
FRA	3.B	97/03	MENVIELLE v. France (No. 2)
FRA	3.B	1513/03	DRAON v. France
FRA	3.B	6253/03	VINCENT v. France
FRA	3.B	20127/03	ARNOLIN and others  v. France
FRA	3.B	23054/03	S.U. v. France
FRA	3.B	39922/03	TAIS v. France
FRA	3.B	2078/04

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
FRA	3.B	5356/04	MAZELIE v. France
FRA	3.B	3211/05	VUILLEMIN v. France
GEO	3.B	68622/01	DANELIA v. Georgia
GEO	3.B	71678/01	GOURGUENIDZE v. Georgia
GEO	3.B	36378/02	SHAMAYEV and 12 others  v. Georgia and Russia
GRC	3.B	77574/01	ZOUBOULIDIS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	22879/02	AJA INTERNATIONAL TRADE B.V. v. Greece
GRC	3.B	389/03	ANDRIOTIS AND ANDRIOTI v. Greece
GRC	3.B	27695/03	SERIFIS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	11801/04	TSALKITZIS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	28743/04	SILLAIDIS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	28749/04	DIAKOUMAKOS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	28760/04	AGGELAKOU-SVARNA v. Greece
GRC	3.B	28819/04	ELMALIOTIS AND KONSTANTINIDIS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	35533/04	MAMIDAKIS v. Greece
GRC	3.B	2736/05	VASILEV v. Greece
ITA	3.B	27265/95	TERAZZI S.R.L. v. Italy
ITA	3.B	30423/96	SALINI COSTRUTTORI Spa v. Italy
ITA	3.B	35956/97	GALATA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	36681/97	SANTORO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	36813/97	SCORDINO v. Italy (No. 1)
ITA	3.B	36815/97	SCORDINO v. Italy (No. 2)
ITA	3.B	38746/97	BUFFALO SRL EN LIQUIDATION v. Italy
ITA	3.B	41804/98	CIOTTA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	41805/98	ARIVELLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	41806/98	ALESIANI and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44330/98	PRINCIPE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44333/98	V.P. AND F.D.R. v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44334/98	LATTANZI and CASCIA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44337/98	DELLI PAOLI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44340/98	GAUDENZI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44341/98	CANNONE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44342/98	GATTUSO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44343/98	MASSIMO v. Italy (No. 1)
ITA	3.B	44345/98	RINAUDO and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44347/98	CARAPELLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44348/98	NAZZARO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44349/98	FRAGNITO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44350/98	CECERE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44351/98	PACE and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44352/98	MASSIMO v. Italy (No. 2)
ITA	3.B	44379/98	FINESSI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	44525/98	FERRARI v. Italy (No. 2)
ITA	3.B	50774/99	SCIACCA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	52980/99	STORNAIUOLO and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56201/00	SARDO v. Italy

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ITA	3.B	56202/00	CORNIA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56203/00	GINOCCHIO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56204/00	LIMATOLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56205/00	DENTE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56206/00	COLONNELLO and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56207/00	LUGNAN IN BASILE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56208/00	CONTE and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56211/00	Giuseppe NAPOLITANO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56212/00	FOLLETTI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56213/00	PIACENTI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56214/00	RIPOLI v. Italy (n° 1)
ITA	3.B	56215/00	RIPOLI v. Italy (n° 2)
ITA	3.B	56217/00	DE CESARIS v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56218/00	STABILE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56219/00	PRESEL v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56220/00	MASTROPASQUA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56221/00	DONATO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56222/00	CENTIS v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56223/00	POLCARI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56224/00	D'AMORE ALBA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56225/00	DI PEDE v. Italy (No. 2)
ITA	3.B	56226/00	ABATE and FERDINANDI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	56581/00	SEJDOVIC v. Italy
ITA	3.B	59909/00	GIACOMELLI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	62094/00	MAJADALLAH v. Italy
ITA	3.B	62361/00	RICCARDI PIZZATI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	64088/00	PILLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	64699/01	MUSCI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	64705/01	MOSTACCIUOLO Giuseppe v. Italy (I)
ITA	3.B	64886/01	COCCHIARELLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	64890/01	APICELLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	64897/01	ZULLO Ernestina v. Italy
ITA	3.B	65075/01	PROCACCINI Giuseppina and Orestina v. Italy
ITA	3.B	65102/01	MOSTACCIUOLO GIUSEPPE v. Italy (No. 2)
ITA	3.B	67785/01	QUATTRONE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	68610/01	GAUTIERI and others v. Italy
ITA	3.B	70148/01	FODALE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	70585/01	CECERE ENRICO v. Italy**
ITA	3.B	73575/01	DI PIETRO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	77156/01	MILAZZO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	77986/01	FORTE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	1595/02	DE BLASI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	3638/02	TAIANI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	3641/02	TAIANI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	3643/02	FRANCESCA Carmine v. Italy

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ITA	3.B	3647/02	FRANCESCA Cosimo v. Italy
ITA	3.B	3649/02	CHIUMIENTO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	3653/02	LA FRAZIA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	3656/02	MARRONE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	7774/02	MINICOZZI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	10399/02	MORETTI Francesco v. Italy
ITA	3.B	10427/02	RODA and BONFATTI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	10644/02	COLLARILE v. Italy
ITA	3.B	15535/02	CHIZZOTTI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	17175/02	CALICCHIO and URRIOLABEITIA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	20662/02	PERNICI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	21120/02	PANTUSO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	21757/02	CAMPELLO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	23053/02	IELO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	25513/02	BOVA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	27394/02	ZICCARDI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	29871/02	VERTUCCI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	33447/02	MARTELLACCI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	42053/02	MATTEONI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	42644/02	PICARO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	6597/03	CIARAMELLA v. Italy
ITA	3.B	30961/03	SANNINO v. Italy
ITA	3.B	5941/04	HU v. Italy
ITA	3.B	10180/04	PATRONO, CASCINI and STEFANELLI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	24691/04	ALI v. Italy
ITA	3.B	14405/05	ZUNIC v. Italy
MDA	3.B	40663/98	ASITO v. Moldova
MDA	3.B	74154/01	BRAGA c. Moldavie
MDA	3.B	36492/02	BUJNITA v. Moldova
MDA	3.B	14914/03	MOISEI v. Moldova
MDA	3.B	30303/03	NISTAS GMBH v. Moldova
MKD	3.B	26124/02	MZT LEARNICA A.D. v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.B	44208/02	ARSOV v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MKD	3.B	22928/03	MARKOSKI v. “The former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia”
MLT	3.B	17209/02	ZARB ADAMI v. Malta
MLT	3.B	26111/02	MIZZI v. Malta
MLT	3.B	34539/02	DEBONO v. Malta
MLT	3.B	35829/03	CENTRAL MEDITERRANEAN DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED v. Malta
MLT	3.B	16631/04	ZARB v. Malta
NLD	3.B	8196/02	SALAH v. the Netherlands
POL	3.B	34049/96	ZWIERZYNSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	44115/98	WEDLER v. Poland
POL	3.B	51744/99	KWIECIEN v. Poland
POL	3.B	52589/99	SKIBINSCY v. Poland
POL	3.B	55339/00	ROZANSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	59738/00	JAGIELLO v. Poland

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
POL	3.B	64974/01	AKERBLOM v. Poland
POL	3.B	65888/01	JERUZAL v. Poland
POL	3.B	67016/01	DUDA v. Poland
POL	3.B	69128/01	ZYGMUNT v. Poland
POL	3.B	76299/01	WROBLEWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	1524/02	MAJCHRZAK v. Poland
POL	3.B	1564/02	KEDRA v. Poland
POL	3.B	5413/02	AUGUSTYNIAK v. Poland
POL	3.B	5650/02	PIATKOWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	6334/02	DOLASINSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	6880/02	STASIOW v. Poland
POL	3.B	6925/02	SZYMONSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	7313/02	ZIELONKA v. Poland
POL	3.B	8612/02	NOWAK v. Poland
POL	3.B	10384/02	CZERWINSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	11219/02	TROJANCZYK v. Poland
POL	3.B	14580/02	WIERCIGROCH v. Poland
POL	3.B	20838/02	CHYB v. Poland
POL	3.B	22346/02	WROBLEWSKA v. Poland
POL	3.B	25301/02	ZASLONA v. Poland
POL	3.B	26918/02	TRZCIALKOWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	43702/02	GRABINSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	3489/03	CEGLOWSKI v. Poland
POL	3.B	3675/03	STENKA v. Poland
POL	3.B	18036/03	CICHLA v. Poland
POL	3.B	19607/03	SITO v. Poland
POL	3.B	26876/03	TRZNADEL v. Poland
POL	3.B	29386/03	STANKIEWICZ v. Poland
POL	3.B	2782/04	HASS v. Poland
POL	3.B	19583/05	RYCKIE v. Poland
PRT	3.B	21240/02	COMPANHIA AGRICOLA DE PENHA GARCIA, S.A. v. Portugal
ROM	3.B	30324/96	SMOLEANU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	31549/96	POPOVICI AND DUMITRESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	31678/96	GHEORGHIU Theodor and Dinu Ioan v. Romania
ROM	3.B	32927/96	SEGAL v. Romania
ROM	3.B	32943/96	FALCOIANU AND OTHERS v. Romania
ROM	3.B	33358/96	OPREA AND OTHERS v. Romania
ROM	3.B	33912/96	PETRESCU and BUDESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	34642/97	BUZATU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	35671/97	LINDNER and HAMMERMAYER v. Romania
ROM	3.B	36782/97	IONESCU AND MIHAILA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	38608/97	IONESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	40670/98	TODORESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	41138/98	MOLDOVAN and others v. Romania
ROM	3.B	46596/99	ZAMFIRESCU v. Romania

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ROM	3.B	46639/99	BAN v. Romania
ROM	3.B	49781/99	FLORICA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	56326/00	CARSTEA and GRECU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	57001/00	STRAIN and others v. Romania
ROM	3.B	58318/00	GEORGI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	58612/00	SEBASTIAN TAUB v. Romania
ROM	3.B	59892/00	MASZNI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	60957/00	VELCEA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	62276/00	NICHIFOR v. Romania (No. 1)
ROM	3.B	62710/00	LUNGOCI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	68479/01	RADOVICI and STANESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	70639/01	BARBU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	70890/01	DANULESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	71649/01	PETRE v. Romania
ROM	3.B	73970/01	SACALEANU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	75101/01	GRECU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	75129/01	ROSCA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	75261/01	BARCANESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	77048/01	TOVARU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	77364/01	ILISESCU and CHIFOREC v. Romania
ROM	3.B	78037/01	CARACAS v. Romania
ROM	3.B	78047/01	DRAGNE and others v. Romania
ROM	3.B	746/02	TACEA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	1295/02	NICOLAU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	1434/02	LUPAS and others v. Romania (No. 1)
ROM	3.B	1597/02	PATRICHI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	2252/02	DAVIDESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	2608/02	IONESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	5050/02	PANTEA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	5060/02	MIHAESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	6350/02	VLADUT v. Romania
ROM	3.B	7114/02	ACATRINEI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	7893/02	GHIBUSI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	12050/02	BARTOS v. Romania
ROM	3.B	19567/02	MATICA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	21118/02	KONNERTH v. Romania
ROM	3.B	21397/02	POPESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	23354/02	UNGUREANU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	25603/02	SUCIU ARAMA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	29683/02	ROTARU et CRISTIAN v. Romania
ROM	3.B	37284/02	LAFARGUE v. Romania
ROM	3.B	38113/02	MATACHE and others v. Romania
ROM	3.B	41124/02	FILIP v. Romania
ROM	3.B	42588/02	CARJAN v. Romania
ROM	3.B	42872/02	CORNIF v. Romania
ROM	3.B	5691/03	TOGANEL and GRADINARU v. Romania

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
ROM	3.B	6248/03	POPEA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	8402/03	PIETRO and others v. Romania
ROM	3.B	13028/03	SIMION v. Romania
ROM	3.B	13075/03	PENESCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	21351/03	STINGACIU and TUDOR v. Romania
ROM	3.B	28104/03	RAICU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	38467/03	RABINOVICI v. Romania
ROM	3.B	2122/04	TARBUC v. Romania
ROM	3.B	4738/04	PAIS v. Romania
ROM	3.B	7198/04	IOSUB CARAS v. Romania
ROM	3.B	9862/04	NEGOITA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	10337/04	LUPSA v. Romania
ROM	3.B	23576/04	VIDRASCU v. Romania
ROM	3.B	33970/05	KAYA v. Romania
RUS	3.B	59334/00	CHITAYEV and CHITAYEV v. Russia
RUS	3.B	69480/01	LULUYEV and others v. Russia
RUS	3.B	69481/01	BAZORKINA v. Russia
RUS	3.B	3852/02	UGLANOVA v. Russia
RUS	3.B	10415/02	CHERNYSHOV AND 11 OTHERS v. Russia
RUS	3.B	15969/02	Vladimir NIKITIN v. Russia
RUS	3.B	26410/02	KAZARTSEV v. Russia
RUS	3.B	29372/02	KARMAN v. Russia
RUS	3.B	33132/02	METELITSA v. Russia
RUS	3.B	36219/02	SHELOMKOV v. Russia
RUS	3.B	10833/03	SHITIKOV v. Russia
SMR	3.B	40786/98	BENEFICIO CAPPELLA PAOLINI v. San Marino
SVN	3.B	49016/99	NOVAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	49019/99	EUCONE D.O.O. v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	54503/00	PLANTARIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	57566/00	CUNDRIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	66458/01	KLINAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	66819/01	PETAN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75366/01	FETIS D.O.O. v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75402/01	BAUER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75567/01	OBERWALDER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75618/01	NOVAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75628/01	HRUSTELJ v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75653/01	CVETREZNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75687/01	ROJC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75688/01	ZOLGER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75695/01	HAFNER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75697/01	ROJNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75701/01	VIDEMSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75705/01	KRAMER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75742/01	KOVACIC v. Slovenia

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
SVN	3.B	75745/01	MAMIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75773/01	MAJHEN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75784/01	PREKORSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75787/01	KRZNAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75790/01	IBRAHIMI v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75798/01	KLANECEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75809/01	BASTIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75810/01	SLEMENSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75813/01	GORSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75815/01	MEH v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	75817/01	HUSEINOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76199/01	PUZ v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76212/01	DREU v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76378/01	GOLENJA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76430/01	CMOK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76434/01	ZNIDAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76439/01	PECNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76515/01	PODKRIZNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	76524/01	KUKAVICA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77512/01	VIDOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77541/01	KRASOVEC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77542/01	KUMER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77545/01	MULEJ - ZUPANEC AND OTHERS v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77769/01	KOS v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77779/01	SLUGA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77796/01	CEKUTA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77818/01	FERLIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77819/01	GORENJAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	77821/01	PLANKO v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	1423/02	OZEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	1438/02	DEZELAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	1461/02	MARINOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	2792/02	ZORC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	4225/02	OLENIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	4267/02	JENKO v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	4507/02	GORICAN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	5059/02	GABER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	5162/02	DROZG v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	6799/02	MURATOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	6841/02	VIRJENT v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	7210/02	ROBER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	7877/02	BELOSEVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	7883/02	JURKOSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	9277/02	GRADIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	9301/02	ZEMLJIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	9303/02	VARACHA v. Slovenia

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
SVN	3.B	10288/02	REPAS v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	10296/02	HRIBERSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	16263/02	RAMSAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	16281/02	ZLENDER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	17321/02	LORBEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	17330/02	KOTNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	17337/02	PAZON v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	17360/02	MRKONJIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	18831/02	KRACUN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	19894/02	KOTNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	20254/02	ROZMAN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	20300/02	KUKOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	20543/02	PAVLOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	20610/02	JURKOSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	21464/02	SOLESA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	21675/02	NOSE v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	22235/02	WITMAJER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	22266/02	POZIN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	23571/02	BLATESIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	24784/02	STRADOVNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	24896/02	ZAKONJSEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	24897/02	RUPNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	24901/02	BEDI v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	25053/02	SKRABLIN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	25055/02	PFEIFFER v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	25195/02	KORDA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	25616/02	VRECKO v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	26881/02	AVDIC  v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	27694/02	KRAJNC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	27701/02	ZIDOV v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	27946/02	ANTOLIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	28922/02	KUNSTIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	31489/02	JAZBEC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	32958/02	GAISCHEG v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	32964/02	DAKOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33024/02	CAKS v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33488/02	LAKOTA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33538/02	SOLINC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33541/02	HRIBAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33553/02	LESJAK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33561/02	OVNICEK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	33595/02	HERIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	35063/02	ZGONJANIN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	35489/02	MARIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	36054/02	HRIBERSEK v. Slovenia

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
SVN	3.B	36550/02	VISNJAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	37057/02	GASHI v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	37289/02	DRAGOVAN v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	37296/02	RADANOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	38310/02	DRAGANOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	38333/02	GRUSOVNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	38341/02	JESIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	38523/02	DIVKOVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	38528/02	RODIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	38933/02	SIMEK HUDOMALJ v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	39137/02	FONDA v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	39160/02	STROPNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	39178/02	BENEDEJCIC and TRATNIK v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	40125/02	MANDIR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	40128/02	KOCEVAR v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	41511/02	RADIVOJEVIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	42274/02	BIZJAK JAGODIC v. Slovenia
SVN	3.B	14852/03	GLUHAR v. Slovenia
SWE	3.B	62332/00	SEGERSTED-WIBERG and others v. Sweden
SWE	3.B	36689/02	LILJA v. Sweden
TUR	3.B	23145/93	ELCI and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	25723/94	ERDOGDU v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	26546/95	ACAR v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	35982/97	AGRAG and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	37087/97	BEKMEZCI and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	40153/98	CETIN v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	41054/98	TERECE and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	42560/98	KULTER v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	44766/98	KANIOGLU v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	46347/99	XENIDES-ARESTIS v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	46771/99	OCKAN and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	46827/99	MAMATKULOV v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	47278/99	Mahmut YILMAZ and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	48264/99	VEHBI UNAL v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	48884/99	YAZICI v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	51176/99	ANYIG and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	52067/99	OKKALI v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	52083/99	MACIN v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	55913/00	Hidir DURMAZ  v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	57344/00	YAGIZ and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	61446/00	POLAT v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	62633/00	YENER v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	70289/01	YAYLA v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	70845/01	KILIC v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	71908/01	GUZEL (ZEYBEK) v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	72317/01	TOPKAYA v. Turkey

State	Meeting Section	Application Number	English Case Title
TUR	3.B	73739/01	KARAMAN ET BEYAZIT  v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	74318/01	RESUL SADAK and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	74341/01	KARAHANOGLU v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	77191/01	AVCI (CABAT) and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	225/02	COMAK v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	7142/02	KURKCU and others v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	8006/02	MUTLU v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	9292/02	ONEL v. Turkey
TUR	3.B	27633/02	Memetali GUNDUZ v. Turkey
UKR	3.B	11931/02	MAS v. Ukraine
UKR	3.B	26131/02	GRISHECHKIN and others v. Ukraine
UKR	3.B	32478/02	SHEVCHENKO v. Ukraine
UKR	3.B	10722/03	LAPINSKAYA v. Ukraine
UKR	3.B	16571/03	TIKHONCHUK v. Ukraine
UKR	3.B	32166/04	SARAFANOV and others v. Ukraine